5 ms·
Gartner's grift is about to unravel
- robertlagrant 1y ago> The basic business model of Gartner is: > make up term as The Future > put a lot of marketing firepower behind it > make people pay to list on the magic quadrants This is partially correct. My understanding is Gartner will also allow people to pay them to create the segment that exactly matches their product.
- xnx 1y ago"OpenAI top Leader in AI companies with a CEO named 'Sam'"
- esafak 1y agoCoining new categories gives startups the validation they need to justify their differentiation, which is how they get launched. If the company coins its own category, prospective buyers will never find the product in the first place since they will not have not heard of the category. So companies like Gartner are serving a valuable function in the startup economy. It's the formalization of what Karpathy did when he coined the term "vibe coding", christening a new category.
- api 1y agoCan we crowd source bullshit neologisms instead? GenA does it just fine skibidi Ohio.
- the_mitsuhiko 1y agoI have no idea how people end up on the magic quadrant but I had a good chuckle recently when I saw Vercel advertise that they are Visionaries in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ and when you look at the infographic [1] you become a visionary by just executing worse than the leaders. [1]: https://vercel.com/gartner-mq-visionary https://vercel.com/gartner-mq-visionary
- kstrauser 1y agoThat's astounding. I could see bragging if you're almost as able to execute but with a better future plan: "look at us, the up-and-comers!" But less ability to execute and a smaller roadmap? I think I'd be keeping my mouth shut.
- lazide 1y agoThe problem with sales and marketing is they kinda can’t keep their mouth shut. It’s a problem.
- fakedang 1y agoI mean, look at the quadrants - they all can be spun positively. - we have been named an "Industry Challenger" - Gartner calls us an industry-focused "Niche Product" - "Visionaries" - "Leaders" Like another comment stated, you get placed in different brackets based on how much you pay them to list your product. Niche guys didn't pay enough while the leaders are your usual suspects.
- notfromhere 1y agothe magic quadrant is essentially a stack ranking of 'how much money are you paying us vs how much money we think we can get out of you'. that's how you end up in scenarios where some shit IBM product is leading the chart against its objectively superior competitors.
- DebtDeflation 1y agoA few months ago I saw one of Gartner's AI Magic Quadrants (there are several) and it had IBM, Oracle, and a few companies I'd never heard of in the Leaders quadrant and OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google in the bottom left. Obviously companies like OpenAI and Google have absolutely no need to pay Gartner for anything. But how is this actually considered credible research by people in non-tech companies? You'd have to be living in a cave to not know who is really leading in AI.
- 1y ago
- rendaw 1y agoTop leadership at the company I'm at is trying to push AI down dev's throats in order to list in the magic quadrant.
- datax2 1y agoWell written. Coming out of college years ago Gartner was a whole section of review during my business courses. Working with Data for years now I have become hyper sensitive to this keyword grift; Big data, Data lake, Datalakehouse, realtime-analytics, no-code, data model, data schema...etc. People lean so hard on certain words as if they mean they are doing something different or unique. You work in one product in your company, then you bring someone who has experience in another product and they remark "But product X cannot do XYZGrift" but it can, people hang on these keywords as though they are platform actions or enablement that exist only there. Rambling, but to get to the point, AI in general will strip this SEO/Marketing/Boomer catch phrasing, and build the common language which I appreciate greatly. I can go to ChatGPT or Claude and ask it I want to Foo this Bar with these filters, doesn't matter if its SQL, Python, Unix, Alteryx, Tableau... whatever, it digest the request without the fluff and responds commonly. To stack on this info hunting or product research with AI is also typically less full of fluff for me. I don't have to deal with a sales engineer saying how wonderful their ML product is when I know its garbage immediately, I can just move on and assess the rest of the product. The only value I can still see in Gartner is their customer survey information, but I am sure someone or somehow AI will scrape the forum post for all these products and weight the products community feedback about its product.
- SirFatty 1y ago"Boomer catch phrasing" really?
- taude 1y agoIt's really funny how the younger people are creating derogatory terms about older people. It's also applied to people who actually aren't baby boomers, too. And they're repeating this, because the title of the article had it in the sub-title [1], and I found it off-puting. But hey, I'm just a sensitive old person. Maybe need to expand their DEI trainig. [1] "swyx recognizes $IT as a visionary short in the DX Tips Magic Quadrant of Boomer Relics That No Longer Make Sense"
- antonvs 1y ago
- llm_nerd 1y ago"Boomer C-Suites who fancy themselves Enterprise Tech executives and are happy to throw humans at any problem were happy buying off the Gartner catalog and then hitting the golf course. Today, millennial CEOs and CTOs get their analysis and news sources from X, /r/LocalLlama, the All In Podcast, Semianalysis Substacks, any number of YouTubes and Podcasts." This reads like parody. I see another post in here talking about "Boomer catch phrasing" (in a word salad comment) which is simply hilarious. While this millennial thought guru seems to think their age defines them, I think the rest of us realize that there are gullible rubes in every age group. There are fresh new recruits citing the gartner magic quadrant or whatever nonsense makes their world feel more orderly. I mean, LinkedIn is absolutely full of hilarious nonsense from people at every age trying to show that they Ordered The World because of some list or source they subscribe to.
- notfromhere 1y agoEh. They're not wrong. A lot of folks still pay Gartner money to be on their lists, but it's more of a feeling that you have to, and not because it actually leads to any results. Having worked in both corporate and startup worlds, I've rarely seen anyone under 40 reference a Gartner report as credible or actually use that as a source of information. Everyone knows it's pay-to-play, not particularly credible, and as the younger generations age into these very senior roles, I have no doubt that Gartner will lose a lot of relevance. Given that trust in "mainstream media" has pretty much collapsed everywhere, I don't really doubt that this will inevitably hit the obvious corporate gatekeepers as well. Enterprise/b2b is just 10-20 years behind on trends experienced elsewhere.
- llm_nerd 1y ago"People used to rely on this thing. As replacements come along and a bit of the magic was revealed to be a hoax, people rely less on that thing so it became less valuable." Amazing, super simple to understand and without any need for hilariously shallow bigotry! I haven't heard anyone in business -- like you, having worked in F100, corporate, startups, and so on -- reference a Gartner report seriously in well over a decade. From any age group. Whether "boomer" or super savvy YouTube-watching (lol) "millenial". I mean, I know they exist as this company still has revenue, but it seems like classic inertia where people are just going through the motions of historic norms as something is phased out, precisely why the market is looking poorly on the company. Seriously, trying to tie the evolution of industry to some sort of tired, laughable ageist nonsense is just boorish. Be better. When someone older yips about how younguns today are all cooked and they play Roblox all day, it looks like ageist shrieking from someone with little nuance and a very binary view of the world. It is no different when laughable pieces like this appear.
- phillipcarter 1y agoYeah, nah. The enterprise software market is nowhere near close to being upended by AI, and Gartner has their tendrils deeply wrapped inside of it. Small companies like Netlify which are barely in use by this market are not a canary in the coal mine.
- crinkly 1y agoYeah that. The company I work for has an annual revenue of about 6x the valuation of Netlify. We're busy sucking Gartner off at every possible corner and learning it's a mistake over and over again. Everyone we know is as well. Some of the startup industry has no idea how enterprise is at all. There aren't even any trendy CEO/CTO here. It's all suits. Not all things are sexy.
- samdixon 1y agoWhat do they use it for?
- phillipcarter 1y agoPurchasing decisions. If Gartner doesn’t claim you’re a Leader, then a massive chunk of your addressable market is not unlockable for you. This may be fine for now, but eventually when your investors demand accelerated revenue curves (and you’re not an AI coding tool), then you’ll be talking to Gartner and praying they place you high. Full stop. Separately, they offer consulting with their analysts. A lot of these consultants are quite knowledgeable. They also are usually there to help a leader make a purchasing decision.
- henrikschroder 1y ago> and praying they place you high. If you remove an 'r', there's the other way you can get placed high.
- stego-tech 1y agoI will never trust Gartner for recommendations on anything. Either your product solve a problem we presently have or we don’t need it. It’s really just the suits relying on it as a crutch in lieu of actually hiring competent Engineers and Architects and then listening to them. As those folks cycle out with their millions in cash to retire somewhere, I’m hoping us younger folks won’t tolerate such consultant drivel.
- kerblang 1y agoThe web is already compostable
- steveBK123 1y agoMy experience with Gartner has been seeing in-over-their-head CTOs in lagging firms take their recommendations a bit too seriously. Earnestly printing out the latest white paper and distributing it to their directs. Hiring "head of X" for whatever new X Gartner has invented. Thinking they are getting a peak at industry best practices when in reality the industry leaders are not sharing anything with Gartner, so its blind leading blind. This leads to a lot of self delusion that actually being a lagger is an advantage because we'll simply buy XYZ that Gartner suggested and leapfrog over the leaders who are mired in their legacy tech. No thought whatsoever to the people, processes and institutional knowledge that got the leaders to where they are. Nor any questioning as to whether there are actual off the shelf solutions for things your better competitors built in house with many man years of effort. So the sooner the better ..
- dcchuck 1y agoGartner stock price: On the day this was published (2025-02-07) it closed at $529.29. Yesterday it closed at $238.37. Source - https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/IT/history/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/IT/history/ Victory lap submission?
- swyx 1y ago(im the author) i didnt submit this haha. thanks @mooreds for always having my back.
- personjerry 1y agoIs it too late to short?
- twoodfin 1y agoThis article implies that Gartner’s revenue stream comes primarily from vendors. Does anyone know if that’s true? Gartner calls that whole arm of the business “insights” and doesn’t break it down further in their SEC filings. I’d be surprised if that’s the case.
- pinewurst 1y agoWhat’s really funny is that Gartner are probably the most reputable of the enterprise analysts. I had to cultivate these for years and could tell stories…
- tallytarik 1y agoG2, Sourceforge (yes, that one), and Gartner’s Capterra/GetApp/SoftwareAdvice all have the same business plan: charge vendors $x,xxx+ per month to outrank other vendors in their made up categories. Of course, you can technically list for free. But look! For the low low price of $x,xxx per month, now you can show one of 40 tailor-made award icons on your site! Or, unlock the privilege of showing “user reviews” from our site on your site! (of course if you had managed to get reviews independently, you’re not allowed to use the widget without paying) Don’t have reviews? Ah, I forgot to mention. The $x,xxx plan also comes with “review generation” — we’ll pay users to write reviews for you! Oh, and on an unrelated note, the $x,xxx plan just also happens to unlock dofollow links across each of those 40 made up categories, which all rank highly in google. And the $xx,xxx plan means that - user ratings aside - you can end up at the top of those categories. It’s hard to describe it other than the author says: a grift. Seeing those logos on other companies sites are now a huge turn off to me personally, and I haven’t yet capitulated for my own SaaS, but I suspect this isn’t the feeling of the execs they seek to target. Or maybe it is, and it’s just the price of doing business.
- abirch 1y agoI think this is the at same model that the NYTimes book reviews back had in the 1990s. Pay us money and we'll say nice things. It'll be interesting to see how AI Agents approach things. My prediction is that more of our media is going to be controlled by our AI Agent's Algorithm instead of Google, Twitter, and Facebook's algorithm or some distant editors who decided what went on the front page of the newspaper.
- ilamont 1y agoIgnoring the magic quadrant baloney and market growth predictions, Gartner and other analyst firms conduct some useful research based on large industry surveys on how companies and large organizations regard emerging technologies, or how they are planning to pilot or deploy new technology. This is especially true of in-house series conducted on a quarterly or annual basis, less so for vendor-funded research. The data may pour cold water on whatever Big Trend is supposedly rising to the fore, or call out important caveats that vendors would rather not address.
- jjtheblunt 1y agodo you think, in so doing, they discover anything not obvious to an audience like HN which posts and shares insights themselves?
- sriram_malhar 1y agoWhat they discover is what the CEOs would _like_ to happen for their business. Everyone is seeking an edge, and CEOs would like nothing better than hitching their wagon to the next buzzword. Gartner generates a buzzword, trials it with CEOs who make it an actual industry buzz. Most HN readers don't have visibility into what a gaggle of CEOs is going to be tempted to do.
- jaybrendansmith 1y agoAgree. If you get past the baloney, the typical Gartner analyst is speaking with 50-100 CTOs per month. This is incredibly useful, as it provides a great general understanding of what companies are implementing, what is working, what is failing, what is no longer important, what is important. This allows them to become true mavens on their specific vertical or sub-vertical, sharing best practice. So this is definitely valuable, depending on how cutting-edge you happen to be.
- x0x0 1y agoand the author totally misunderstands this. ctos / execs generally are not offering their candid thoughts on how company X's products work to youtube. ec.
- nimbius 1y agolarge institutions dont buy into gartner because its accurate or even reasonably current. Gartner is part of a risk management strategy for shareholders. its a brand and reputation that you can shove in front of any problem you might encounter to insulate your companies reputation. X, Podcasts, and Substacks offer up-to-the-second analysis of the latest trends and such, but at no point will they offer the type of indemnity that Gartner does. They are a technical resource, not a business leadership one.
- overfeed 1y ago> to insulate your companies reputation ...and more importantly, allows you to keep your job should your choice not work out. Gartner, like consultants, get paid for so management can pass the buck and not be held accountable for their decisions.
- pembrook 1y agoGartner isn't going anywhere. How do I know? Because they aren't actually selling software advice; they're laundering personal-responsibility for corporate decision makers. That's the real business of most brand-name B2B "advice." Very few people are dumb enough to believe the 22yr-old new grad from Ohio that created the powerpoint you're buying is an expert in Software (or management in the case of McKinsey/BCG/Bain, or law in the case of overpriced white shoe law firms, or accounting in the case of the big 4, etc). But John Executive with the big house and 3 kids doesn't care what the actual advice is, or if your software will save the company millions. He just wants to keep his job. Being able to point to a "trusted brand" like Gartner as the escape hatch for why you made a large decision with downside risk is priceless. That's the real grift. "...so that software implementation didn't turn out well for us? Wow..who could have known? I followed what the trusted experts at Gartner said!"
- jongjong 1y agoYes this is an astute perspective. I would say a lot of consulting firms are basically little more than narrative devices in the bigger story of 'the economy'. The children of elites need an avenue to fulfill their parents' expectations and propagate the legitimacy of the social order. Consulting firms provide that.
- manmal 1y agoIf ass covering is easy like that, what’s actually the argument for insane leadership comps?
- pembrook 1y agoThere is no argument for it if the company is a legacy juggernaut with basically zero new product development (which is most of the Fortune 500). Leadership comp is a total grift and has ballooned in recent decades (in the US exclusively) since the 1980s due to the shift to stock-based comp. Fun story, a lot of analysts didn’t even count stock based comp as part of the cost structure of a company until oddly recently.
- Vegenoid 1y ago
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoHow are the architects and directors at my company’s IT department going to make decisions without Gartner? They don’t believe the people who have hands-on experience with the products. Who else can they go to for advice?
- mxuribe 1y agoBoy, am i glad i ran into you! I'd like to introduce myself: I am lead analyst for a new org named Rentrag! We do the opposite of Gartner, so you can trust us, And our analysis! :-) /s
- weitendorf 1y agoI think this assumes Gartner just coincidentally offer the right kind of branding and messaging to drive $100M+ technology spending decisions at the present time. I have a feeling the people running such a successful marketing machine are smart enough to know that over time, decision makers' tastes and preferences will shift as younger generations age into their target audience. Maybe they won't be able to pull it off but I suspect they're well aware that millenials will be listening to something different from their conjoined triangles of success. Lately I've been trying to reprogram myself to be more self-critical when I run into successful products that don't speak to my own personal tastes - it's really easy to just say "other people are stupid" but I don't think it's usually the full answer. Gartner is kind of like the technology Consumer Reports for F500 executives - it's not really any different from you looking at the rating breakdown for a vacuum cleaner or kitchen appliance back when Consumer Reports was the go-to source for product reviews. Baby boomer executives are not stupid just because they couldn't tell you exactly how relational databases and Linux work. And it's gonna be a while until insanely busy and established 65 year olds start making significant purchasing decisions based on anime avatar tweets, so Gartner's audience definitely shouldn't be underestimated.
- kleiba 1y agoI can neither parse the headline nor the subheading?!
- jrexilius 1y agoyeah, had no idea what that word jumble was meant to convey..
- moadel_111 1y agoFor me they always seemed as if a Wall Street Analyst is reviewing hardware
- hermitcrab 1y agoIt is just a slighly classier (and more expensive) version of this: https://successfulsoftware.net/2025/07/11/pay-to-play-the-ugly-truth-behind-top-5-rankings/ https://successfulsoftware.net/2025/07/11/pay-to-play-the-ug...
- tootie 1y agoFailure to make accurate predictions about the tech market is hardly evidence of grift. It's just really hard to do well. In areas that I'm most familiar with Gartner broadly comports with my own experience. It definitely favors entrenched players probably because they have so many case studies but honestly that heavily influences procurement teams too. There's always a strong thread of "let's buy what our competitors bought last year" and Gartner can reinforce that. As much as anything it's cover for a decision making process that's very difficult for a lot of orgs. That's valuable even if it's not very scientific.
- zahlman 1y agoI've never heard of Gartner, or Netlify, or Composable, or.... I guess I should be glad for that... ?
- antonvs 1y ago> I’ve never heard of Gartner Which branch of the quantum multiverse are you in? I want to go there.
- zahlman 1y agoI'd like to explain, but I literally don't understand what branches I'd have to be in in order to have heard of them.
- antonvs 1y agoIf you've worked at any large corporation in the US there's a good chance you would have seen a Gartner Magic Quadrant in a slide deck at some point, at the very least. People use them as a way to justify their choices, because they're slide-deck friendly - just paste the chart and say "look, X is a leader on the Magic Quadrant, therefore we should buy X!" The Magic Quadrant started out as a gimmick to kind of popularize Gartner's consulting services, but ended up becoming what they were most known for, to the point they now have to include disclaimers saying "uh guys? we do other stuff too, y'know?"
- zahlman 1y agoIt sounds like I'd not only have to have worked at a "large corporation in the US" (I live in Canada), but have had a role that would have required sitting at meetings where business purchasing decisions are made. There are a lot of programmers out there not meeting that description.
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]