11 ms·
How AI conquered the US economy: A visual FAQ
- croes 1y agoI see hardware and AI companies‘ revenues rise. Shouldn’t the customers‘ revenue also rise if AI fulfills its productivity promises? Seems like the only ones getting rich in this gold rush are the shovel sellers. Business as usual.
- mewpmewp2 1y agoIf it's automation it could also reduce costs of the customers. But that is a very complex question. It could be that there isn't enough competition in AI and so the customers are getting only marginal gains while AI company gets the most. It could also be that for customers the revenue / profits will be delayed as implementation will take time, and it could be upfront investment.
- thecupisblue 1y agoThe biggest problem is the inability of corporate middle management to actually leverage GenAI.
- sofixa 1y ago> Shouldn’t the customers‘ revenue also rise if AI fulfills its productivity promises Not necessarily, see the Jevons paradox.
- metalliqaz 1y agoApplying the Jevons paradox to this scenario should still result in revenues going up, assuming the employee labor being optimized adds value to the company. (they would add more)
- croes 1y agoJevron is about higher resource consumption and costs but the output and therefore the revenue should rise too. Maybe not the profit but at least the revenue.
- amunozo 1y agoThis is going to end badly, I am afraid.
- m_ke 1y agoCould all pop today if GPT5 doesn’t benchmark hack hard on some new made up task.
- mewpmewp2 1y agoI don't expect GPT-5 to be anything special, it seems OpenAI hasn't been able to keep its lead, but even current level of LLMs to me justifies the market valuations. Of course I might eat my words saying that OpenAI is behind, but we'll see.
- stackbutterflow 1y agoPredicting the future is always hard. But the only thing I've seen in my life that most resembles what is happening with AI, the hype, its usefulness beyond the hype, vapid projects, solid projects, etc, is the rise of the internet. Based on this I would say we're in the 1999-2000 era. If it's true what does it mean for the future?
- baxtr 1y ago"It is difficult to make predictions, especially about the future" - Yogi Berra (?) But let’s assume we can for a moment. If we’re living in a 1999 moment, then we might be on a Gartner Hype Cycle like curve. And I assume we’re on the first peak. Which means that the "trough of disillusionment" will follow. This is a phase in Hype Cycle, following the initial peak of inflated expectations, where interest in a technology wanes as it fails to deliver on early promises.
- baggachipz 1y agoClassic repeat of the Gartner Hype Cycle. This bubble pop will dwarf the dot-bomb era. There's also no guarantee that the "slope of enlightenment" phase will amount to much beyond coding assistants. GenAI in its current form will never be reliable enough to do so-called "Agentic" tasks in everyday lives. This bubble also seems to combine the worst of the two huge previous bubbles; the hype of the dot-com bubble plus the housing bubble in the way of massive data center buildout using massive debt and security bundling.
- brookst 1y agoThe Internet in its 1999 form was never going to be fast enough or secure enough to support commerce, banking, or business operations.
- falcor84 1y agoExactly, it took an evolution, but there was no discontinuity. At some point, things evolved enough for people like Tim O'Reilly to say that we know have "Web 2.0", but it was all just small steps by people like those of us here on this thread, gradually making things better and more reliable.
- hnhg 1y agoI found this the most interesting part of the whole essay - "the ten largest companies in the S&P 500 have so dominated net income growth in the last six years that it’s becoming more useful to think about an S&P 10 vs an S&P 490" - which then took me here: https://insight-public.sgmarkets.com/quant-motion-pictures/outside-of-the-top-10-stocks-sp500-forward-profits-haven-t-grown-in-three-years https://insight-public.sgmarkets.com/quant-motion-pictures/o... Can anyone shed light on what is going on between these two groups. I wasn't convinced by the rest of the argument in the article, and I would like something that didn't just rely on "AI" as an explanation.
- rogerkirkness 1y agoWinner takes most is now true at the global economy level.
- moi2388 1y agoThey are 40% of the S&P 500, so it makes sense that they are primary drivers of its growth. They are also all tech companies, which had a really amazing run during Covid. They also resemble companies with growth potential, whereas other companies such as P&G or Walmart might’ve saturated their market already
- andsoitis 1y ago> They are also all tech companies, which had a really amazing run during Covid. Only 8 out of the 10 are. Berkshire and JP Morgan are not. It is also arguable whether Tesla is a tech company or whether it is a car company.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 1y agoBerkshire holds ~$60B+ of Apple and is also exposed to AI through its power-utility arm, Berkshire Hathaway Energy.
- andsoitis 1y ago
- snitzr 1y agoBillion-dollar Clippy.
- emptyfile 1y ago[dead]
- PessimalDecimal 1y agoTrillions, right?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- freetonik 1y agoInteresting that the profits of those bottom 490 companies of S&P 500 do not rise with the help of AI technology, which is supposedly sold to them at a reduced rate as AI vendors are bleeding money.
- roncesvalles 1y agoOther than NVIDIA, the profits of the S&P 10 haven't risen either. It's just that the market is pricing them very optimistically. IMO this is an extremely scary situation in the stock market. The AI bubble burst is going to be more painful than the Dotcom bubble burst. Note that an "AI bubble burst" doesn't necessitate a belief that AI is "useless" -- the Internet wasn't useless and the Dotcom burst still happened. The market can crash when it froths up too early even though the optimistic hypotheses driving the froth actually do come true eventually.
- Workaccount2 1y agoWe are still in the "land grab" phase where companies are offering generous AI plans to capture users. Once users get hooked on AI and it becomes an indispensable companion for doing whatever, these companies will start charging the true cost of using these models. It would not be surprising if the $20 plans of today are actually just introductory rate $70 plans.
- esafak 1y agoI'd be surprised because (free) open source are continually closing the gap, exerting downward pressure on the price.
- Workaccount2 1y agoI don't think it will be much of an issue for large providers, anymore than open source software has ever been a concern for Microsoft. The AI market is the entirety of the population, not just the small sliver who knows what "VRAM" means and is willing to spend thousands on hardware.
- andsoitis 1y ago> Artificial intelligence has a few simple ingredients: computer chips, racks of servers in data centers, huge amounts of electricity, and networking and cooling systems that keep everything running without overheating. What about the software? What about the data? What about the models?
- Steve16384 1y ago> What about the data? What, you want them to pay for all the copyrighted data they consume and regurgitate? They can't afford that!
- dsign 1y agoI don't think AI is having much impact on the bits of the economy that have to do with labor and consumption. Folk who are getting displaced by AI are, for now, probably being re-hired to fix AI mess-ups later. But if, or when AI gets a little better, then we will start to see a much more pronounced impact. The thing competent AIs will do is to super-charge the rate at which profits don't go to labor nor to social security, and this time they will have a legit reason: "you really didn't use any humans to pave the roads that my autonomous trucks use. Why should I pay for medical expenses for the humans, and generally for the well-being of their pesky flesh? You want to shutdown our digital CEO? You first need to break through our lines of (digital) lawyers and ChatGPT-dependent bought politicians."
- tehjoker 1y agoWell, if you don't use humans, then you're using machine labor that will drive prices down to at-cost in a competitive environment and strip profits in the end. Profits come from underpaying labor.
- OtherShrezzing 1y ago>Without AI, US economic growth would be meager. The assumption here is that, without AI, none of that capital would have been deployed anywhere. That intuitively doesn't sound realistic. The article follows on with: >In the last two years, about 60 percent of the stock market’s growth has come from AI-related companies, such as Microsoft, Nvidia, and Meta. Which is a statement that's been broadly true since 2020, long before ChatGPT started the current boom. We had the Magnificent Seven, and before that the FAANG group. The US stock market has been tightly concentrated around a few small groups for a decades now. >You see it in the business data. According to Stripe, firms that self-describe as “AI companies” are dominating revenue growth on the platform, and they’re far surpassing the growth rate of any other group. The current Venn Diagram of "startups" and "AI companies" is two mostly concentric circles. Again, you could have written the following statement at any time in the last four decades: > According to [datasource], firms that self-describe as “startups” are dominating revenue growth on the platform, and they’re far surpassing the growth rate of any other group.
- biophysboy 1y agoIts also not fair to compare AI firms with others using growth because AI is a novel technology. Why would there be explosive growth in rideshare apps when its a mature niche with established incumbents?
- dragontamer 1y agoI think the explosive growth that people want is in manufacturing. Ex: US screws, bolts, rivets, dies, pcbs, assembly and such. The dollars are being diverted elsewhere. Intel a chip maker who can directly serve the AI boom, has failed to deploy its 2nm or 1.8nm fabs and instead written them off. The next generation fabs are failing. So even as AI gets a lot of dollars it doesn't seem to be going to the correct places.
- biophysboy 1y agoThey're not going to get it. The political economy of East Asia is simply better suited for advanced manufacturing. The US wants the manufacturing of East Asia without its politics. Sometimes for good reason - being an export economy has its downsides!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- vannevar 1y ago>Nobody can say for sure whether the AI boom is evidence of the next Industrial Revolution or the next big bubble. Like the Internet boom, it's both. The rosy predictions of the dotcom era eventually came true. But they did not come true fast enough to avoid the dotcom bust. And so it will be with AI.
- GoatInGrey 1y agoMy suspicion is that there's a there there, but it doesn't align with the predictions. This is supported by the tension between AI doom articles and the leading models experiencing diminishing performance gains while remaining error-prone. This is to speak nothing of the apparent LLM convergence limit of a ketamine-addled junior developer. Which is a boundary the models seem destined to approach indefinitely without ever breaching. The "bust" in this scenario would hit the valuations (P/E ratio) of both the labs and their enterprise customers, and AI businesses dependant on exponential cost/performance growth curves with the models. The correction would shake the dummies (poorly capitalized or scoped businesses) out of the tree, leaving only the viable business and pricing models still standing. That's my personal prediction as of writing.
- owebmaster 1y agoAlthough that is true, the big players just have enough money to go through it this time.
- bravetraveler 1y agoThey mention rate of adoption, compared to the internet. Consider the barriers to entry. Before we all got sick of receiving AOL CDs, the prospect of 'going online' was incredibly expensive and sometimes laborious. More people subscribe to/play with a $20/m service than own/admin state-of-the-art machines?! Say it ain't so /s
- thewebguyd 1y ago> More people subscribe to/play with a $20/m service than own/admin state-of-the-art machines?! Say it ain't so /s The problem is, $20/m isn't going to be profitable without better hardware, or more optimized models. Even the $200/month plan isn't making money for OpenAI. These companies are still in the "sell at a loss to capture marketshare" stage. We don't even know if being an "AI Company" is viable in the first place - just developing models and selling access. Models will become a commodity, and if hardware costs ever come down, open models will win. What happens when OpenAI, Anthropic, etc. can't be profitable without charging a price that consumers won't/can't afford to pay?
- bravetraveler 1y agoPop :) For some, at least. Barons tend to leave remnants
- hackable_sand 1y agoWhat about food and housing? Why can't America invest in food and housing instead?
- margalabargala 1y agoAmerica has spent a century investing in food. We invested in food so hard we now have to pay farmers not to grow things, because otherwise the price crash would cause problems. Food in America is very cheap.
- hackable_sand 1y agoIt's reassuring to be reminded that every child in America must justify their existence or starve to death.
- margalabargala 1y agoOkay, that's too far. That's not true at all. Children in America do not starve to death. There is no famine, economically manmade or otherwise. This is America. We will happily allow and encourage your child to go into arbitrary amounts of debt from a young age to be fed at school.
- antifa 1y agoThere is definitely a type of famine going on in the US right now, 40 million are struggling with food insecurity. There is also a crises of healthy food being unaffordable, so people are essentially eating 2x their daily calories while getting 0.5x their daily nutrients. Then there are multiple political decisions that have already been made this year that will result in various forms of crop loss (migrants scared to show up at work) and disease outbreak (RFKJr's raw milk). The results of which are likely to impact food prices. The people who are hit hardest by this will already have been hit the hardest by greedflation in rent.
- margalabargala 1y ago
- biophysboy 1y ago>“The top 100 AI companies on Stripe achieved annualized revenues of $1 million in a median period of just 11.5 months—four months ahead of the fastest-growing SaaS companies.” This chart is extremely sparse and very confusing. Why not just plot a random sample of firms from both industries? I'd be curious to see the shape of the annualized revenue distribution after a fixed time duration for SaaS and AI firms. Then I could judge whether its fair to filter by the top 100. Maybe AI has a rapid decay rate at low annualized revenue values but a slower decay rate at higher values, when compared to SaaS. Considering that AI has higher marginal costs and thus a larger price of entry, this seems plausible to me. If this is the case, this chart is cherry picking.
- doyouevensunbro 1y ago> because the oligarchs demanded it There, summed it up for you.
- voidhorse 1y agoNot sure why you were down voted. It's true and it actually answers the question in the article title, which the article doesn't even explore, let alone answer.
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoRelated: AI is propping up the US economy https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44802916 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44802916
- GoatInGrey 1y agoI'm noticing how that article is myopically discussing equity valuations rather than actual economic output and worker productivity.
- krunck 1y agoPlease stop using stacked bar charts where individual lines(plus a Total) line would help the poor reader comprehend the data better.
- GolfPopper 1y agoRemember, the appropriate way to parse use of "the economy" in popular press is to read it as "rich peoples' yatch money".
- csours 1y ago> Nobody can say for sure whether the AI boom is evidence of the next Industrial Revolution or the next big bubble. All we know is that it’s happening. In hindsight, it will be clear, and future generations (if any exist) will ask: "Why didn't you understand what was happening at the time" My answer: Noise. Just because you can find someone who wrote down the answer at the time, doesn't mean that they really understood the answer, at least not to the extent that we will understand with hindsight. Future history is contingent.
- jimmydoe 1y agoThis matches the tech job market: if you are not in top corp or labs, your hard work is most likely subsidizing the $ 1.5M paycheck for OpenAI employees.
- maerF0x0 1y ago> “They’re generating unprecedented amounts of free cash flow,” Cembalest told me. “They make oodles and oodles of money, which is why they can afford to be pouring hundreds of billions of dollars of capital spending each year into AI-related R&D and infrastructure.” IMO this should be a trigger for investors that they have not been receiving their profits, and instead the profits are being dumped into CEOs next big bets that will fuel their stockbased compensation gains. Also to blame is the government's culpability here for creating both tax incentives and a lack of laws that say profits must be returned as dividends (they can always be DRIP'd back into the company as new shares if desired, it's absurd to say its better for investors, when the alternative actually gives more choice).
- jameslk 1y agoI found this analysis insightful: https://x.com/dampedspring/status/1953070287093731685 https://x.com/dampedspring/status/1953070287093731685 > However, this pace is likely unsustainable going forward. The sharp acceleration in capex is likely behind us, and the recent growth rate may not be maintained. Any sustained weakness in final demand will almost certainly affect future investment, as AI demand ultimately depends on business revenues and profits, which are tied to nominal GDP. Realized and forecasted capex remain elevated, while free cash flow and cash and cash equivalents are declining for hyperscalers.
- ThinkBeat 1y agoThe fact that there is massive spending in AI in the tech sector, isn't that just a -possible- sign of a other bust coming down the road? We have seen it before, again and again.
- johnnienaked 1y agoAll I see is B-U-B-B-L-E
- knowaveragejoe 1y ago> METR also conducted an in-depth study that asked experienced developers to code with a popular AI assistant. After they finished their tasks, the developers claimed that using the AI had made them 20 percent more productive. But independent evaluators in the study actually concluded that using AI did the opposite: it increased task completion time by about 20 percent. This somewhat reflects my experience... I can totally see the back-and-forth dance taking longer in some cases. But I also think there is more than efficiency being unlocked here. Sure, a developer might have cranked out a rough MVP in less time, but with this they're also often continuously updating a README, tests and other infrastructure as they go. One could argue about whether that's its own footgun - relying on tests that don't really test what they should, and let critical bugs through later.
- throwmeaway222 1y agoAI bills are in the thousands of dollars per day for some small AI startups, and in the 10-100k range per day for large companies. So as many people have speculated that OpenAI has no moat - are wrong.
- jjtheblunt 1y agoWhat is the moat you are implying? (affordability?)
- antonvs 1y agoA moat is protection from competition. What you’ve described is not a moat.
- scotty79 1y agoMeasuring such things in dollars rubs me the wrong way. Is using inflation adjusted dollar common or do people just compare nominal values?
- Animats 1y agoSee "Spending on AI data centers is so massive that it’s taken a bigger chunk of GDP growth than shopping—and it could crash the American economy"[1] The US is having a giant AI boom and a recession in the rest of the economy. Historically, the classic example of this is railway mania of the mid 19th century.[2] That started in 1830, with the Liverpool and Manchester Railway.[3] This was when the industrial revolution got out of beta. There were earlier railroads, but with dual tracks, stations, signals, tickets, schedules, and reasonably good steam engines, the Liverpool and Manchester worked like a real service. It was profitable. Then lots of others started building and over-building railroads, with varying degrees of success. See Panic of 1847. It was really too early for good railroads. Volume production of steel didn't exist. Early railroads were built with wood and iron, not very well. Around 1880-1900, everything was rebuilt in steel, and got bigger, better, and safer. Consider the early Internet. We had TCP/IP working across the US in the early 1980s, but it wasn't a big deal commercially for another 10-15 years, it wasn't everywhere until the early 2000s, and it wasn't out of bubble mode until 2010 or so. [1] https://fortune.com/2025/08/06/data-center-artificial-intelligence-bubble-consumer-spending-economy/ https://fortune.com/2025/08/06/data-center-artificial-intell... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_Mania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_Mania [3] https://youtu.be/pDEnsraYx3k?t=505 https://youtu.be/pDEnsraYx3k?t=505
- jcgrillo 1y agoThe really scary thing is all the value in the AI boom is predicated on the belief that the technology is "early" and that it will improve over time. We're seeing the opposite. Instead, all the competing models are basically converging on the same benchmark performance numbers, as we saw yesterday with the gpt-5 debacle. This suggests that performance is actually topping out, which makes intuitive sense if advancements in LLMs are proportional to their training data. They've already used up all the data. So it very well could be what we see right now is basically as good as it gets, or at least approximately so. The market is not ready for that.
- Animats 1y ago> We're seeing the opposite. Instead, all the competing models are basically converging on the same benchmark performance numbers... That question is really important. Comments on that? Maybe LLMs are asymptotically approaching some fundamental limit for that technology. What goes on inside an LLM hasn't changed much in years. More data and more compute is thrown at that little kernel that makes it all go. Additional gimmicks are added around the core algorithm. But there's not much progress down at the bottom. There's no reaching into the net and extracting a reliable "don't know". Is there an upper limit to what that architecture can do? AGI may not be reachable by this route. Maybe someone will find a way around that limit. The field has way too much money, too much visibility, and too many people. The technology works, although it has limits.
- cess11 1y agoOn the face of it, it looks positively habsburgian.
- sdsd 1y agoOne argument I often hear in my corner of the internet is that AI is one of the only remaining sectors of unregulated, meritocratic activity. The smart people have been pushed out of the real economy, so we're congregating here. EXIT blog talks about this a lot. Eg in this article, "Sanctuary Cities are Special Economic Zones - Just Not For You": https://blog.exitgroup.us/p/sanctuary-cities-are-special-economic https://blog.exitgroup.us/p/sanctuary-cities-are-special-eco... Anyone else knows fun writing like this, please recommend it to me
- sheepybloke 1y agoThe take away from the teacher graphs were very different than my take aways. The author was bullish because ~55% used AI to help prep lessons. However, looking at the graph, I would be very bearish about the adoption of AI. Most of the graphs show that a vast majority of teachers aren't using AI. This leads me to see a huge discrepancy between real world usage and the amount of money that's being invested.
- BrenBarn 1y agoAI didn't conquer the US economy. What conquered the US economy is a small number of large companies. If Apple started rolling out an iTurd app, and Google started offering gTurd, and Amazon started shipping free turds to everyone's doorstep, and so on, then we would be talking about how turds have conquered the US economy. The economy has become divorced from any pretense of meeting actual consumer needs. The suppliers are creating their own demand.