11 ms·
Solar-plus-storage technology is improving quickly
- JackSlateur 1y agoNothing interesting about the cleanest energy (which is, as everybody knows, nuclear) ? That's desapointing. I'm glad that some countries have built and are still betting on the half-century years-old tech: fast neutrons reactors, those outputs are equivalent to our regular light-water reactors and which generates no waste (to be precise, most of that waste have a ~30yo half-life, not a big deal)
- staticcaucasian 1y agoVolts covers nuclear fairly often. Check the transcript history if you're genuinely interested. It's not a compelling story; solar and wind are _really_ cheap now, and our modeling and software is getting way better at accommodating them. Nuclear just isn't economical at all in comparison.
- jillesvangurp 1y agoNot that cheap though. Cheap nuclear seems to be a bit of a fantasy.
- JackSlateur 1y agoYeah In the meantime, here in France, we've had the lowest power supply cost for decades I am glad politics have fixed that, so that we can be miserable like everyone else
- jillesvangurp 1y agoAnd high taxes. Which pay for the nuclear plants. That are currently aging and need tens of billions more investment to keep running.
- JackSlateur 1y agoCould you share more informations on both affirmations ?
- jillesvangurp 1y agohttps://www.perplexity.ai/search/explain-how-france-pays-for-it-ZbW7QpPgTkyRIvklDp3IKA https://www.perplexity.ai/search/explain-how-france-pays-for... Here you go. Fairly detailed overview of how most of the cost is not factored into the monthly bills consumers pay. It basically involves a lot of state backed debt, subsidies, etc. Also note the massive investment in a waste storage facility.
- JackSlateur 1y agoI think this answers everything, indeed :)
- bityard 1y agoI have done a fair amount of noodling around with the numbers and have come to the conclusion that within a decade, maybe two, we'll start to see rural homes disconnecting from the grid in significant numbers. Or for new homes, not connecting to the grid in the first place. Around here, the cost of getting a new house on the grid is $50,000 - $100,000. This is often more than the cost of the land itself. That will buy a serious amount of panels and storage, AND you won't have to send a $100 - $200 check to the utility every month. (They will need replacing in a few decades, of course, but being energy-independent can still work out.) I live in Michigan which is one of the worst states for solar. Full sun only half the time and fairly brutal winters, depending on the year. Yet I know people who get almost all of their electricity from solar. They treat the grid as a big backup generator. Some are just getting into it now and others have been doing it for years as a hobby. Of course there's more to it than just switching power sources. You need to think about insulating your home better, alternative sources of heat, timing when you run certain appliances, running some stuff directly off DC to reduce conversion losses, etc. But it's eminently doable. Which means it's a complete no-brainer for the southwestern states with plenty of sun and very little demand for winter heat. My main concern at this point is that solar and batteries are cheap NOW, will they be in the future? It's hard to say. But my guess is that we might be at peak "cheapness" for solar, for a bunch of reasons. The federal subsidy is going away. Right now, solar panels and batteries come from almost exclusively from China, whose government has subsidized their low cost to prevent foreign competition. Even if they decide to keep producing them cheaply (they may not, their economy is not doing any better than ours lately), the new tariffs are designed explicitly to make them NOT cheap in order to favor US manufacturers (the few such that there are, one of which is Tesla) and indirectly, oil companies. In urban/suburban environments, solar can make sense to offset SOME electricity usage in order to lower the light bill, but that's about as far as you can get for most homes. What little land is available is shaded by trees or large buildings. Roof panels work, but are a huge pain for panel and roof maintenance, and the roof should face south, and only so many can fit on the roof, etc. A rack of lithium batteries bolted to the outside of a house looks like a liability to insurance companies and may lower resale value. I still think the best strategy for urban environments is to force utilities (via regulation) to build out more solar farms to move the risks out of the neighborhoods, let the utilities handle all the maintenance and pain points, and take advantage of the economies of scale.
- jmpman 1y agoI want a solar powered greenhouse in AZ, where the solar panels are used solely to run an AC unit, keeping temps down during the day - without using inverters or batteries. With some large water barrels in the greenhouse, it should maintain temps down during the night. Is this practical? The solar panels don’t necessarily need to be on the greenhouse itself, as I have plenty of land. Trying to do this as cheap as possible. Any ideas?
- bryanlarsen 1y agohttps://signaturesolar.com/eg4-hybrid-solar-mini-split-kit-energy-star-certified-air-conditioner-heat-pump-ac-dc-12000-btu-seer2-22-1800-watts-of-solar-pv-kit-e0011 https://signaturesolar.com/eg4-hybrid-solar-mini-split-kit-e...
- jmpman 1y agoThanks for the link. Is it difficult to find just DC powered Air Conditioning units? What’s different? Any concerns about intermittent running? Clouds or partial shading of panels from leaves? Should such a device include a super capacitor capable of running it for a few minutes to ensure there aren’t brownouts which will cause problems for the compressor?
- dzhiurgis 1y agoWe are at the point where batteries are so cheap they are going to leapfrog household solar - at $100 / kWh (half that in china or 1/3rd in actual cell costs) it doesn't make sense to pay thousands for someone to install solar when you can plug and play relatively simple battery and arbitrage using virtual power plant. Even V2G isn't so appealing anymore - actual bidirectional chargers cost 5-10k for some bizarre reason. You can commission equivalent of your cars battery for that, without too much of electrical work.
- deepnotderp 1y agoThis is a lot of words to say “solar + battery lcoe is $70/MWH and gas is $40/MWH, but most places outside the U.S. don’t have access to tons of cheap gas so it’s more expensive there” And no, they are wrong, gas is still currently cheaper ($40 is less than $70)
- rstuart4133 1y ago> This is a lot of words to say “solar + battery lcoe is $70/MWH and gas is $40/MWH, No, that isn't what the article says. I'll quote it for you: I think it was around $70 for new gas. It was a weighted US average — from memory, but I might be wrong on that. I suspect your $40/MWH isn't LCOE, it's the marginal cost of producing an extra MWH from an existing plant. A second problem they don't mention for gas is the demand is so high, the wait time for a new turbine is around 4 years. Batteries on the other hand can be bought with very short lead times.
- bjourne 1y agoLazard agrees with you: https://www.lazard.com/media/uounhon4/lazards-lcoeplus-june-2025.pdf https://www.lazard.com/media/uounhon4/lazards-lcoeplus-june-... Marginal costs of $108 for gas peaking and $31 for combined cycle. $48-$107 actual LCOE ($77.5 average).
- triknomeister 1y agoIn other places outside US, cost of gas electricity is not 40/MWh. In Germany for example, the cost of natural gas power plants is 110 to 170 Euros/MWh. For solar in Germany, it is 37 Euro/MWh to 80 Euros/MWh not including storage.
- rapsey 1y agoYeah ok but without storage you are comparing apples to oranges. Even with storage it is barely comparable. Since even with batteries you can't provide power 24/7.
- 1y ago
- Aurornis 1y agoSolar and batteries are still more expensive than gas (as the article admits) but prices are continuing to decrease. Sadly, the US is hitting a hiccup as the current administration is going out of their way to make solar installs harder and more expensive. Putting tariffs on solar equipment imports is an insane self-defeat. We should be importing as much cheap solar and battery gear as we can get our hands on. Give it a couple years of price progress and political turnover and I think we’re going to be in a great position.
- jillesvangurp 1y ago> Solar and batteries are still more expensive than gas (as the article admits) but prices are continuing to decrease. Exactly, gas is heavily subsidized and government supported in the US. And even with that support it only barely scrapes ahead. Courtesy of current and future tax payers coughing up the interest payments on the trillions of dollars in debt. That's not going to last indefinitely. The key point here is that the difference is a bit artificial. In the rest of the world where installing solar is something like a third of the cost (no tariffs, less installation bureaucracy, less crippling rules and legislation, etc.) and where batteries can be imported closer to cost price from China, the picture is very different. If it's importing LNG vs. cheap solar panels + batteries, the latter is already very attractive in many places. Even at higher latitudes than the 49th parallel below which most of the US is. And it's on track to get a lot better. Production for sodium ion batteries is starting to come online in China. It will be a while before those make it to the US due to the politics. But some are now projecting cost as low as 10$/kwh for those mid term. 1 mwh battery would cost about 10K$ at those prices. And they have quite long lives (thousands of charge cycles). You can run a house on one of those for well over a month in the US. Much longer in places where houses are better insulated and more efficient. It will be a few years before we can get these obviously. But it's a nice mental model for what a reasonably affordable battery will be able to do soon.
- bjourne 1y ago> And it's on track to get a lot better. Production for sodium ion batteries is starting to come online in China. It will be a while before those make it to the US due to the politics. But some are now projecting cost as low as 10$/kwh for those mid term. Is that a typo? Just a year ago ago batteries were expected to drop to $80/kWh around 2026-2027... $10/kWh in the near future is absolutely insane.
- lvl155 1y agoOT, how much more (or less) efficient is solar out in space? I am guessing radiant energy is much higher.
- scarecrowbob 1y agoLocation and use are big factors, I am sure. I am writing from an off-grid shack in rural CO where I have installed a fairly nice panel, storage, and inverter system (4kw panels, 15kwh batteries, 6kw inverter). I'm about $10k into that project (though I did all the labor, and didn't count that), but the easement and company equipment would have been $25k-$35k... much more effecient from a money perspective to go with solar out here in the sticks. I am sure that in places like space, where there are no gas stations (or much solid matter at all), solar is going to be an easier deal than petrochemicals.
- orthecreedence 1y agoVery cool! What's winter like for you and this setup?
- scarecrowbob 1y agoLast winter (my first) was cold, but I still hadn't built the little solar setup and was living in a 9x9 shack with a diesel heater. By the end of the winter I had renovated a 24x24 room into my music studio, which is mostly heated with firewood that I collect as part of my wildfire mitigation or (kind of expensive) an externally vented propane all heater. By the end of the winter it was much easier to stay warm. Hopefully I'll have a septic, cistern, and tiny house setup by the time it geet cold again. The solar equipment was super easy to install and I think it will be cheaper than grid power in the 10-year time frame.
- ceejayoz 1y agoIf you can get there cheaply (you can't right now), getting rid of heat becomes an issue rapidly. ISS has large banks of radiators to shed heat.
- 1y ago
- BoxFour 1y agoIf I were a VC or PE firm, this is exactly where I’d be putting a lot of money in the next year or two. Right now there’s a lot of fear given the stance of the current administration, which makes it pretty ripe for smart money willing to play the long game (as Buffett famously noted). The technology keeps improving, clean energy is increasingly shaping up to be a new arms race with China, and politics these days tend to swing back and forth wildly. By 2028+, it’s very plausible we’ll see things 180 and there'll be plenty of government attention given to clean energy. Even the current administration could change their tune if it's positioned as "beating China" (or even for no reason at all, because who knows with them). Spending a couple years to prop it up and become a well-established player by then could be a huge advantage.
- fromwilliam 1y agoDo you mean investments in solar panel manufacturing, or something else? From what I understand solar panels are somewhat commoditized, and China has massive subsidies for their manufacturers. I wouldn't want to get in that game. If you mean battery R&D + manufacture, I think that could be promising
- ipdashc 1y agoI wonder how much is being invested into reducing the costs of inverters and MPPTs and such. ("Balance of system" seems to be the term?) I'm looking into a DIY install, and it's looking like the microinverters are going to basically be just as expensive as the panels themselves. A quick Google seems to imply this is similar for utility-scale installs: the BoS costs are less than, but still comparable to the costs of the actual panels. On one hand I get it; panels are very simple, robust devices, while inverters need to interface with the grid and usually have network connectivity and so on. On the other hand, there's a lot less material in an inverter, and they're still relatively simple electronics? Which we're pretty good at mass producing cheaply. You'd think there's a lot of room there to get the cost down.
- dv_dt 1y agoOn solar panel investments, at the time TSMC got into the chip game, I think most people might have said something very similar to a TSMC. Chips are commodotized, and the existing entrants are highly capitalized, and why TSMC do you think you can outdo the likes of 1987 Intel TI, Motorola, NEC et al. Perkskovites to name one tech, will probably be a generational shift in solar panel technologies, the US would be stupid to miss it if they want to be a future world energy player outside the slow inevitable decline of fossil fuels. For who has the stomach to fund it, there is available maybe another order of magnitude in cost performance in solar, and say two or three orders of magnitude of cost performance available in batteries?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ilaksh 1y agoSeems like renewable fuels of some type could make it much more realistic to move away from fossil fuels. Even hydrogen could work if people really wanted to make it work. But surely there is a way to make ammonia, ethanol, biodiesel, or something viable for long term renewable energy storage.
- ggreer 1y agoThat's the business model of Terraform Industries[1]. They're betting on solar getting cheap enough to make synthesis of hydrocarbons economically competitive. It looks like they're selling synthesized natural gas for $35/MCF, which is 2.5x the national average. As panels get cheaper and they optimize their processes, it seems likely that they'll be able to make natural gas for cheaper than uhh... natural natural gas. 1. https://terraformindustries.com/ https://terraformindustries.com/
- tln 1y agoI'm rooting for them but $35/MCF is more like 10x current market price. "Henry Hub Natural Gas Spot Price is at a current level of 3.21, down from 3.22 the previous market day and up from 2.17 one year ago." That's in $/MMBTU, divide by 1.038 to get $/MCF.
- ggreer 1y agoThat's the price at a hub before distribution & transport. For comparison, the cost in Hawaii is $23/MCF. Terraform's plan is to make synthesis plants closer to where the natural gas would be used, reducing distribution & transport costs.
- trunnell 1y agoThey mention California. https://www.caiso.com/todays-outlook/supply https://www.caiso.com/todays-outlook/supply is a dashboard showing electricity demand and supply, real-time and historical. Yesterday evening's peak demand was between 7-8pm at 30.7 gigawatts. Supply breakdown around 8pm: Batteries: 8.4 GW Natural gas: 6.0 GW Renewables: 5.4 GW Large hydro: 4.4 GW Imports: 4.1 GW Nuclear: 2.3 GW This is a remarkable development. All of the peak demand supplied from batteries used to be supplied by natural gas just a couple years ago.
- Nicholas_C 1y agoThat is much higher than I would have expected. Good news. What are they using to charge the batteries though? I wonder if it's offpeak renewables or mostly natural gas?
- gpm 1y agoIf you scroll to the "Supply trend" graph you can see when the batteries were charging and how electricity was being generated at that time. It's the renewables during the day while the sun is shining.
- mjamesaustin 1y agoDaytime solar, in the summer especially. Power demand yesterday was negative from 11:30 to 3:30, for instance, meaning batteries can charge for free to absorb excess solar generation during those hours.
- UltraSane 1y agoThat is impressive but California electricity is pretty expensive compared to most of the rest of the US.
- asdefghyk 1y agoRE "...All of the peak demand supplied from batteries...." This is a very good start. My question is how do the batteries go , if there is 1 - N days of cloudy weather? Can the batteries supply the peak for more than one day? Is there ( or where would they go ) transmission lines to bring in the needed peak supply from other storage (battery / pumped hydro ) areas? Another step would be to include days of peak electricity demand, which in my country occurs in cold weather ( heaters) and very hot weather ( air conditioner's ) OR is there demand limits like in Spain demand limit for some houses is around 3KW (YUKS)
- rapsey 1y agoA crucial factor is also availability. You can basically buy square kilometers of solar today, but if you want a gas turbine for your plant, you are on a +5yr waiting list.
- locallost 1y agoSound to me like it's a feature not a bug.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- martini333 1y agoThat's just about how far I thought
- pandemic_region 1y ago> who find that solar-plus-storage costs have declined so much that it can now provide baseload-level power in sunny cities for less than the cost of new nuclear or even new gas. What about cities that only get enough sun from about April to late September? If your battery is doing almost nothing during the other half of the year, it becomes way less cost effective. Still good, but takes twice as long to be really profitable.
- ben_w 1y agoUntil you're really close to the arctic circle, it's really cheap to just buy e.g 4x the amount of PV and then keep charging in winter anyway. Beyond a certain point, it makes more sense to use transmission lines connecting you to somewhere sunnier. The western American grid connects bits of Canada to bits of Mexico.
- locallost 1y agoHonest question, maybe I am being stupid here, but why do people insist on counting solar+storage costs per MWh, when LCOE already takes into account that the sun does not shine at night. So when you pay for electricity from solar and the price is 40 per MWh, the fact you will not get anything at night is already baked into the price. If you could get solar at night, the price would be half of what it is now. So it should be either solar or storage costs because you only pay for one of those, and the price in case you use each for half the time is basically the average of the two. Yet I keep seeing people argue against solar by simply stacking those two costs on top of each other.
- dzhiurgis 1y agoBanks who'll be dropping billions on this don't care about your logic.
- perihelions 1y agoThere's something that struck me about the recent controversy with the Memphis datacenter. The one rolling out 2 gigawatts of on-site natural gas to power itself. It's this: that the CEO-who-can't-be-named, happens to own one of the largest lithium battery makers in the US; and makes utility-scale grid storage batteries; and also, for completeness, owns a solar photovoltaic plant. If anyone would be using solar+storage for economics, it would that datacenter in sunny, southern USA—but that CEO would rather buy gas than his own product. It's not a one-off datapoint: none of the other upcoming massive AI datacenters, that I've read about, are built for solar power. Amazon's in rural Illinois (2.2 gigawatts), was also on HN, also going with natural gas. I'll believe in this when the ruthlessly optimizing FAANG's believe in it, with their own money. Clearly they do not.
- megaman821 1y agoThe xAI datacenters do use batteries though. The batteries have advantages for providing a clean power supply and not tripping the grid when large workloads start or finish. According to the article, 2 GW would require 8-10 Solar GW and 35-40 GWh of batteries to achieve high 90's availability. I would guess finding enough land close by might be a challenge.
- justlikereddit 1y agoYou're not supposed to look at the Real world. Just imagine if we install 300GW of solar panels in a dark warehouse and connect it to 3000 GWh of battery capacity, then we can magically dance around with fairies in our CO2 free Utopia? Don't believe it? What are you a nazi bigot?
- seec 1y agoYou got downvoted, I upvoted because I share the sentiment very strongly. I keep getting downvoted for much less sarcastic comments that are actually providing actual information on reality. In this case, I find it baffling that they see nothing wrong in needing 22km2 just for a solar panel installation, before even talking about the cost of batteries. Like there is no way that this has no environmental impact and plenty of unsuspected side effects. And that's before talking about the fact that it would be an installation for just one usage, in very good conditions. Solar is getting installed because it makes a lot of money for already rich people, there is not really any other good explanation but they'll ask the public to fund the "bad" CO2 producing installation necessary to make the whole thing viable...
- siliconc0w 1y agoSolar is a lot easier and faster to deploy - no turbine needed, just convert photons to electrons. The US has sadly decided to shoot itself in the foot by electing an Administration bankrolled by the fossil fuel industry so they're doing everything they can to stymie solar.
- Guid_NewGuid 1y agoA funny thing that I notice on this site, as a foreign, is apparently everywhere in the US that isn't the place in whichever article is under discussion has weather such as to be effectively uninhabitable. I realise there is extreme weather in the US but every discussion on renewables, cars, trains, cycling, construction standards or whatever else has comments along the lines of "good for Utah (or wherever) but this couldn't possibly work in the 95% of the US that is constantly inundated by biblical plagues". Sure the performance of whatever technology might be suboptimal but I struggle to believe vast swathes of the US experience weather so extreme as to be uninhabitable. If I'm wrong y'all really need to leave that country for your own safety.
- Loughla 1y agoNo one said uninhabitable except you. OP said that in terms of weather, California is almost ideal for renewables and self-driving cars. California is very, very, very sunny and mild. Many places in the United States are not that for a good portion of the year. That was the point. Not that it's uninhabitable, but that these results may not translate to other areas.
- Guid_NewGuid 1y agoYou're correct that uninhabitable was my exaggeration and the OP's reasonable point was that some parts of the US would see less impressive outcomes. But from a brief Google California isn't even in the 10 most southerly states in the US. While I have broader problems with the political direction of travel of this site in general my main concern is trying to shake Americans out of this fatalism where nothing ever works, nothing is possible and the country has to be left to decay. You guys landed on the moon for goodness sake, where's that America gone?
- SoftTalker 1y ago> where's that America gone It basically died when we became divided into two camps, neither of which can support any proposal if the other side supports it too. People are more concerned with feeling they've won an argument than actually achieving anything.
- snapetom 1y agoI looked at solar and battery set up for an off-grid RV system about 3 years ago and revisited again just a few weeks ago. There's been some impressive strides in terms of wattage produced and battery AH. It's still a long, long way from where it needs to be to live fully off solar, though. Want solar powered AC and a fridge? One or the other. You can't have both. It still needs help from the consumption end and energy production end. For example, mini-split AC systems these past few years have at least made solar-powered ACs in RVs possible.
- madaxe_again 1y agoSure you can. You can get a 5kva inverter/charger from victron for about €800, and pylontech lifepo4 batteries will set you back about €200/kWh with 5kwh units. Panels are now so cheap as to be negligible in price. 15kWh of storage, which is plenty to run AC, a fridge, and plenty else overnight, would be €3000. Call it €1200 for 7kw of panels and mounting gear, which you could just about cram on your roof assuming a full sized RV, and you’re looking at €5000 all in. I live totally off grid, and admittedly have 30kW of panels and 75kWh of storage, but we also charge the car, cook, heat, cool, and all the rest off of it. Battery prices have dropped precipitously over the last five years - our original OPzS lead bank is a joke compared to the lithiums I can now just chuck in on pretty much a whim.
- snapetom 1y ago> full sized RV, 7kw of panels? Nothing under a full-sized RV (45') can touch that. Those are the tour-bus style RVs. The problem is that at that length, they're impractical for boondocking because that often involves some pretty rough terrain. You'll be limited to RV parts and those have power hookup anyways. Boondocking is far easier/less dangerous with your Class B/Cs which are well under 30' in length. You have far less room for panels at that length.
- madaxe_again 1y agoWith a shorter rig you could use slide-out armatures - double or triple your area when you’re parked up, plus get a nice awning to chill out under. Victron stuff if you’re talking about the electronics is all marine rated and commonly used in vehicles. This sort of thing: https://censohardware.com/slide-rails-for-solar-panels/ https://censohardware.com/slide-rails-for-solar-panels/
- errantmind 1y agoThis article fails to mention that a lot of current commercial scale battery co-locations' purpose is to capitalize on rare but highly profitable periods where demand spikes and spot prices go up by, sometimes, multiple orders of magnitude. The idea is to store the power until these events. A lot of money is made from these.
- profsummergig 1y agoWhere are they getting all the lithium from, anyone know? I thought we would have a major shortage by now.
- philipkglass 1y agoThe top lithium mining country is currently Australia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_lithium_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_lithium_p... Here's a USGS report on global lithium from 1996: https://d9-wret.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/production/mineral-pubs/lithium/lithimcs96.pdf https://d9-wret.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/... And the same report from 2025: https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2025/mcs2025-lithium.pdf https://pubs.usgs.gov/periodicals/mcs2025/mcs2025-lithium.pd... Over those 29 years world production shot up from 6,300 tons in 1995 to 240,000 tons in 2024. At the same time reserves grew from 2.2 million tons to 30 million tons. How can reserves go up even as we're mining lithium faster? It's because reserves are defined by a combination of economics and technology. The Earth's crust contains 20 ppm of lithium now and in 1996 (or a million years ago, for that matter). The geology doesn't change but the effort put into identifying potential sources of lithium and means of extracting and purifying lithium does change. Geologically speaking, the Earth has a lot of lithium. World lithium reserves have been increasing faster than they have been depleted, because the industrial demand that causes reserve depletion also spurs additional research to identify potential lithium sources and extraction processes.
- profsummergig 1y agoCapitalism doing its (positive) thing. Awesome to hear, thank you!
- standardUser 1y agoMostly Australian mines. There's no projected shortage that I have ever heard of. There's plenty of Lithium in them there hills.
- profsummergig 1y ago
- pchristensen 1y agoIf you're interested in this, I recommend reading Casey Handmer's blog. Here is one of several pieces about cost curves and learning rate for solar and batteries: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2024/11/09/solar-and-batteries-for-generic-use-cases/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2024/11/09/solar-and-batt...
- woodpanel 1y agoInteresting to see that solar panels seem to keep their Moor‘s Law intact. This is indeed a fundamental lever to lift solar over the threshold to make it viable for many. However in terms energy security: Are these efficient panels (and future ones) produced at all outside of China?
- palata 1y agoIsn't one problem with solar+storage that the battery cannot store the energy accumulated in the summer until the winter? I mean, there are countries with seasons (at least for a few more years, until we're done screwing up the climate).
- nicoburns 1y agoGenerating enough power even in winter is feasible in most countries. The very northerly ones may need other solutions (but luckily tend to be sparsely populated and thus need less power).
- throw-qqqqq 1y agoSolar and wind are good complements. Solar is strong at day in the summer, and wind is strong at night in the winter. Most Northern european countries would need 2-10 days of storage with 2-5x required capacity of solar+wind installed. Noone wants to store a full season’s energy. Tony Seba talks a lot about this stuff if you’re interested.
- palata 1y ago> Noone wants to store a full season’s energy. Dams do that...
- bityard 1y agoNot THAT Dave Jones, unfortunately.
- cbeach 1y agoThe cost of solar panels and batteries has tumbled over the last decade, but it would still take an enormous amount of battery storage to cover weeks/months of cloud, which is common in many parts of the world. To describe solar+batteries as "baseload" is like calling the Martingale Strategy an infinite money machine. It works brilliantly until it doesn't.
- ben_w 1y ago"Really cloudy" still has a lot of sun; e.g. dunkelflaute is often defined as when both solar and wind are simultaneously below 20% peak output, which just means "let's have five of this absurdly cheap thing".
- tetha 1y agoOff-topic, but why is these no scrollbar on the transcript in firefox? I smacked my keyboard and now I've lost my position and it's going to be a pain to find it again. Besides that, I was going to note: Yes, solar isn't necessarily great in northern Germany and further north. But us and the Scots and the Brits have one super-power up our sleeve: Shitty weather made of rain, wind and misery. Meaning, we put up wind turbines up here. We got like 33% of our power from these turbines over 2024 and apparently, expansion of wind capacity in 2025 is happening very quickly. It's somewhat amusing, because the amount of wind power and planned offshore wind capacities are currently forcing rather large infrastructure projects to move all of this power south. My parents are living right next to where Nordtrasse A-Nord is going past. That is a _huge_ construction site.
- darknavi 1y ago> Off-topic, but why is these no scrollbar on the transcript in firefox? I smacked my keyboard and now I've lost my position and it's going to be a pain to find it again. I see a scrollbar in Firefox on Windows but it's quite small due to the article length + comments at the bottom. Maybe 5% of the height of the whole scroll bar.
- jakedata 1y agoMeanwhile in the WSJ opinion section there is a hit-piece warning of power shortages because of wind and solar subsidies. We should be subsidizing gas turbines, if only the market would listen! "The Real Risk to the Electric Grid" https://archive.ph/avp9N https://archive.ph/avp9N Ooga-Booga!!!
- scythe 1y agoSolar and batteries have made a lot of strides. At the technology level, it looks great. The problem is that energy is a concerted industry that requires all of the parts to work together. That requires institutions that are ready and willing to play ball. Otherwise you look like Brazil, which until this year had a really impressive trend of solar adoption which just... suddenly... stopped: https://www.absolar.org.br/mercado/infografico/ https://www.absolar.org.br/mercado/infografico/ You can see it clearly in the graph: solar adoption grows rapidly every year until 2024, going from under 5% to over 20% of Brazil's electricity matrix in a decade, and then we get to 2025. Solar farm expansions drop almost to zero, and rooftop adoption significantly slows. Why did this happen? Well, the grid wasn't ready: https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/brazils-grid-caps-power-wind-solar-threatening-renewable-projects-2024-08-22/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/brazils-grid-caps-po... It's not like nobody could have seen this coming. The trend is smoothly exponential every year until 2025. They just didn't care. There simply was not enough pressure or attention from the government or the public to prevent a grid crunch. These problems are not unavoidable. They are mostly political failures. In general, electricity markets do not exist without state support. China does not have this problem. In the West, our politicians seem to be too fond of the legacy energy industry and too timid about building infrastructure to address the issue, not to mention the popular tendency to think that the government should — or even can — just "get out of the way", or the ever-present NIMBY lawsuits. It's not only Brazil, either; the UK has the same problem with wind: https://archy.deberker.com/the-uk-is-wasting-a-lot-of-wind-power/ https://archy.deberker.com/the-uk-is-wasting-a-lot-of-wind-p... ...which has been outstanding since 2023. There is not even enough grid capacity planned to address the problem, to say nothing of how little they've actually built. I believe there is currently a political controversy about the appearance of pylons.
- dalyons 1y agobatteries should help with this. They can be cited in points with existing grid connections, and used to lower overall demands on the grid by smoothing out production & demand spikes.
- rstuart4133 1y ago> Well, the grid wasn't ready: You are being sold a pup. The grid was fine. Places like South Australia (a state) have 70% renewables without big changes to the grid. I don't know what the real reason was, but it's more likely to do renewables undercutting the price the existing coal plants could sell electricity during the day, to the point the were no longer profitable. So to keep them profitable they curtailed the much cheaper solar and wind, rather than the coal fired generation. Maybe those plants are state owned, or perhaps they have good political connections, or perhaps they own the generation, distribution and retail networks making them very difficult for a politician to take on. The approach taken in other countries is to let the market sort it out, with a guiding hand. If coal plants can only generate at night because they are out-competed during the day by solar, then let them raise their prices at night and when the sun don't shine. That will cause price spikes. Don't like the political problems price spikes cause? Force the retailers to sell at a base price fixed for must they advertise in advance. The retailers won't do that because they are owned by the generators - it's time to split the two functions and create an electricity market. Intermittent renewables and slow ramping coal companies are causing spikes? Create a market for storage, and ensure the retails have no choice but to purchase enough storage guarantee the continuous supply they promised to the customers. Or you can just sit on your hands, let the existing coal generators continue doing what they have always done, and justify it by saying "the grid" can't handle change. Reuters will happily repeat that excuse for you, without asking too many questions. Politically, that works too. But only in the short term. In the longer term, particularly as those coal fired plants reach end of life, you are up for a really painful time because the gradual change you could have had had now has to happen all at once.