10 ms·
Ask HN: Is it time to fork HN into AI/LLM and "Everything else/other?"
I would very much like to enjoy HN the way I did years ago, as a place where I'd discover things that I never otherwise would have come across.
The increasing AI/LLM domination of the site has made it much less appealing to me.
- thomascountz 1y agoWe had it the way we had, Because of the way it was. And, because of the way it is, We have it the way we have. And so it is.
- slig 1y agoVibe code a browser extension that uses a cheap LLM to filter out content that you don't want to see.
- esperent 1y agoOr just spend 60 seconds writing a ublock filter with the ten most common phrases you don't want>
- toomuchtodo 1y agoFeature request: HN could support a tag or label for categorizing a post. This would allow for filtering trivially, and creating views based on participant interest.
- bookofjoe 1y agoI second that emotion.
- PaulHoule 1y agoWouldn't be hard to train an LLM to do it!
- toomuchtodo 1y agoIndeed! Previous: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44261825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44261825 I suppose an extension is the answer, classifying and customizing the user’s view accordingly with a pluggable LLM config.
- azath92 1y agoweve just explored a HN site-reskin as a quick way to validate this, and I now use it for my browsing every day. Its a pretty transparent "profile" that gets applied by an llm to rank your HN frontpage, but would be trivial to shift that to a filter. An extension could be a powerful way to apply it without having to leave HN, but I wonder if that (and our website prototype) is a short term solution. I can imaging having an extension per news/content site, or an "alt site" for each that takes into account your preferences, but it feels clunky. OTOH having a generic llm in browser that does this for all sites feels quite far off, so maybe the narrow solutions where you really care about it are the way to go?
- curious_cat_163 1y agoMaybe you'll want to try Techne: https://techne.app https://techne.app.
- Hasnep 1y agoI don't know if you're allowed to promote alternatives to HN, but Lobste.rs has tags which you can follow or completely block. Plus I've found the quality of the discussion is higher than HN, at the cost of much lower quantity.
- mdaniel 1y ago> at the cost of much lower quantity. Which they could solve by having a less dumb invite system. They can very easily confirm I am not a bot nor a spammer based on any number of objective metrics I can provide to them. But instead the answer is "idle in IRC, hope for the best" and thus they end up with the audience who is willing to jump through those hoops
- Hasnep 1y agoIf you're looking for an invite my email is on my hn profile, email me and I'll invite you
- jowea 1y agoThat is a perennial proposal as far as I remember.
- al_borland 1y agoKeyword filters on the user side would avoid adding extra steps to submitting and moderation. Categories are an extra complication.
- esafak 1y agoSomeone has probably developed a personalized browser for HN.
- toomuchtodo 1y agohttps://github.com/plibither8/refined-hacker-news https://github.com/plibither8/refined-hacker-news is perhaps relevant. If someone wants to add LLM pluggable support (API endpoint target) and it’ll work on Firefox, I’m willing to kick in some fiat. “HN Copilot.”
- aleksituk 1y agoNot a browser but a reskin website: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44454305 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44454305
- PaulHoule 1y agoThis post is turning up at least every other day. The last few times my reply was "AI is 4/30 or 5/30 of the front page, it's not such a big deal", but today it is 9/30. I am wondering what the ratio is for VC and angel dealflow in the valley right now. Hanging out on the "new" page and upvoting quality non-AI articles is an effective method of resistance.
- delusional 1y ago> The last few times my reply was "AI is 4/30 or 5/30 of the front page, it's not such a big deal", but today it is 9/30. A bigger impact for me has been the number of mentions of AI in the comments. It's not just that a large part of the front page is dominated by LLM hype posts, it's that every single post has a least one guy near the top somehow bringing AI into the discussion. I don't even care if it's "AI will fix this" or "haha, AI sucks at this too". I just don't want to hear anything about AI ever again.
- probably_wrong 1y agoI noted that too, to the point where I'm suspecting that "that guy" (obviously not just one user) is being paid to do so. I've started downvoting them, the same way I always downvote "I fed this to an LLM and here's what it spat out".
- delusional 1y agoI have had that same thought when I see them as one of the first comments on a post. I can't do anything with that suspicion, how would I prove it, but it's definitely there.
- jader201 1y ago> I just don't want to hear anything about AI ever again. Genuinely curious: Why? Don’t get me wrong, I upvoted this post, and would love to see AI separated out, or at least tagged (like a root comment suggests) so that I can filter them out if I want. But I can’t say I’d never want to hear anything about AI ever again (though I’m headed in that direction). What field are you in, and what are your interests, such that you’d want to visit HN without ever seeing mentions of AI?
- alganet 1y agoPrevention of bots and other kinds of automation takes precedence over any thematic changes. If that is done first, we might not need to separate subjects. HN lacks even the most basic aspects of human verification.
- rasengan 1y agoUnfortunately, this is simply a by product of the fact that this is both news and the state of the world. Like most it too will come to pass (as it is further adopted in the mainstream and becomes commonplace).
- optimlayer 1y agocurious, couldn't AL/llm related content also have interesting new information? im not referring to ai generated sloppy articles. more so the deep tech behind it. personally im super interested in machine learning and love it when i come across such links here.
- dylan604 1y agoFrom time to time, you find something AI/LLM related that is interesting. Like the people trying to save money by speeding up their audio before submitting for transcription. Not only did it save money, but improved accuracy. It's those kinds of finds that are interesting in the hacker sense. Increasing the number of tokens at a certain point has a negative affect. Okay, someone is taking that hacker ethos to see what happens when the knobs are twisted. Showing me yet another image manipulation tool or new chat bot? Yawn. Next.
- gosub100 1y agoNo, I have zero interest in LLM and ignoring the posts has worked fine for me. The political posts are causing more damage IMO. There is also a "hide" button if you keep seeing a lingering high activity post.
- dylan604 1y agoBut finding out that LLMs are used to push the political posts in such obvious ways yet people are still falling for it is a somewhat interesting topic. Regardless whether that just pushes your bias towards LLMs == bad or tweaks you to spin up your own LLM to combat by searching/detecting/posting the slop. Burying your head in the sand and ignoring all of it is not good either.
- zahlman 1y ago> LLMs are used to push the political posts in such obvious ways Most of "the political posts" seem to happen because someone shares a news article and everyone else uses it as an excuse to discuss the general topic (or at least something that gets general agreement as being the topic). I'm not really clear on how LLMs get involved there.
- gosub100 1y agoI would absolutely click on an article about the detection of AI and how to get rid of fake accounts. Or how AI is being used to scam people. But I couldn't care less about turdF1nger.6i and it's 3.4b paramters.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- danbruc 1y agoNo, will go away just like all the crypto stuff - remember that time? - went away.
- speedgoose 1y agoVery few problems were solved by crypto, so it naturally disappeared. On the contrary, LLMs based AIs create a lot of new problems.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bestouff 1y agoBut but the Rust stuff is still there ! (To my pleasure I must confess)
- bombcar 1y agoA new crypto LLM AI on the blockchain-l - in Rust!
- ryandrake 1y agoYou joke--but an article exactly like that has probably been posted here.
- waffletower 1y agoCould we have a fork where people talk about Rust somewhere else ;)
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- conception 1y agoUnlike crypto though LLMs are actually useful.
- tornikeo 1y agoNo, it is not time to fork HN into AI/LLM and "Everything else/other". I enjoy the website as-is, and simply use search when I want to get to the topics that interest me.
- bnchrch 1y agoNo for three reasons. One, lets be honest, hn wont do it, part of their secret sauce is that they don't change, and they know that. Two, fragmenting the community would just reduce engagement and risk making both feel like a ghost town. Three, LLMs are (one of) the forefronts of our industry. State of the art is advancing fast. It has properties that no one knows the best practises for. And it has implications that are wide ranging. To try and bury this because it has a lot of new developments goes against why most of us are on this site. I believe in the meritocracy of the upvote button.
- 59nadir 1y ago> Two, fragmenting the community would just reduce engagement and risk making both feel like a ghost town. I would rather hang out on a HN more similar in attitude and user count as when I joined than have it be "lively" with the user base it has now. I would agree with #3 if it were the case that the technical side of LLMs were discussed more, and there was a focus on trying to run and understand them yourself; these are topics that I think make more sense for hackers to care about. The front page stories about LLMs are usually business news about LLMs, blog post about using (someone else's) LLM, the occasional blog post that says LLMs suck either for technical, social, or other purposes. Obviously I'm missing a few categories here, but my point is that there is basically zero hacker spirit in the LLM posts. Since when is it part of the hacker ethos to plug into a SV machine that you pay $200/month for the privilege to use to do stuff? That's ridiculous... It's hard to not feel like this is part of a bigger transformation of the culture and then absorbing that culture on HN. Hackers make things, and they are unlikely to settle for poorly made things, but routinely the chorus on HN is that you should never reinvent the wheel, etc., even though you could make a better wheel for your purposes than the wheel you've found online. Not to mention this hilarious "I hate writing code" sentiment that seems to have grown over time. In my opinion neither of these sentiments belong in any group claiming to be hackers. But the user base of HN is not hackers, hence why they feel comfortable spouting these opinions, plugging into $200/month services that write code for them (badly and slowly, I've used Anthropic's Max plan with Claude Code), not understanding and/or taking apart the technology they use, etc.
- thrill 1y agoMaybe we could fork it into technical discussions and complaints about technical discussions.
- leonheld 1y agoMy experience with HackerNews would be significantly improved if I could exclude the LLM-related stuff... it's overwhelming.
- unclad5968 1y agoI havent been on here forever, but I vaguely remember other trends took over for certain periods. I could be misremembering, but crypto drove a lot of interaction for a while. I'm indifferent towards LLMs, probably because I'm not a developer in my day job, and I don't mind seeing LLM posts. It is annoying that every single LLM thread devolves into the same tired arguments between LLM zealots and detractors.
- freedomben 1y ago> I would very much like to enjoy HN the way I did years ago, as a place where I'd discover things that I never otherwise would have come across. I've had the exact same feeling a lot over the past couple years or so, and especially the last 6 months. I used to hit the front page and find 5 to 10 stories I was interested in. Exhausting those to read the second or third page wasn't common. Now I find maybe one story I want, and I routinely will scan through 4 or 5 pages (down to 120 to 160) and only find a handful (4 or 5) that I want to read. I've long found myself wishing for mini-HNs on different broad topics that interest me. Sadly this was the whole point/idea behind reddit. For example, besides the actual and venerable and loved real HN, I'd love an HN for: 1. Politics: Where disagreements are encouraged and any claims are challenged, but only with factual arguments/counterarguments, and any emotional arguments are moderated (basically how we encourage HN comments to be). There have been some reddit communities over the years doing this, but IME they frequently devolve into echo chambers. It almost always comes down to bad moderators. 2. General News: Where stuff that is of broad interest (and not really tech-related) can be posted and commented on in thoughtful ways. Particularly local news would be fun 3. <placeholder>: Had an idea and forgot it as I was making the list. Will edit and insert when I remember! I've kind of accepted that my dream just can't work (at least, looking at Reddit as the great experimentation of that). People on the internet are just (generally speaking) incapable of consistently humanizing the user(s) on the other end, and proceed to treat others very poorly. Pride and inability to be wrong strongly exacerbate that tendency.
- waffletower 1y agoI have a similar process, but usually scan down to 60 (as I did today). I found eight stories including this one and have tabbed them to read. I don't like rust-y koolaid myself, but would never complain that it is here, nor would I complain about seeing the word 'typescript' as it is really far from my interests. To my interest -- excellent AI related white papers, AI agent paradigms and code, model announcements etc. are regularly posted here. Of the eight I picked today, half are AI related. 4 out of 60 isn't bad if I was trying to be an artificial intelligence ostrich.
- zahlman 1y ago> There have been some reddit communities over the years doing this, but IME they frequently devolve into echo chambers. It almost always comes down to bad moderators. In my experience: Most of them are basically designed to be echo chambers from the start — opposition is only admitted in to the extent that it allows easy targets to knock down. Most people just aren't that good at explaining why they believe what they believe, let along making a convincing argument for it; so all you need to do is set up an environment where one side's position is the default. There have been a few attempts at explicitly avoiding that problem. They do eventually collapse. But I don't think it's due to bad moderation. It's more that certain factions simply refuse to engage civilly and unemotionally with each other. They will see statements as inherently provocative that the other side genuinely consider matter-of-fact. I was a moderator for a place like that once. It was remarkable to me how, on the "hot topics" that were polarizing and led to a lot of bans and suspensions, on one side people who were suspended would argue and whine and complain basically as long as we'd listen to them, maybe even the entire duration of the suspension, and they would never get it into their head what our standards were for respectful discourse; and they would even suggest that having such standards was inherently oppressive; and when they got back they would immediately go back to their old ways. And on the other side, people would basically say "LOL, see you on <suspension end date>" and disappear, and come back as promised, and behave themselves for a while. And while there were a very few people who simply couldn't kick the habit of using slurs or other disparaging terms to refer to identifiable groups of people, there were far more — almost all on the opposite side — who simply couldn't kick the habit of openly insulting the people they were directly responding to. Or at insinuating negative character traits and hidden motivations not in evidence, or other such "dark hinting" as we call it. Or even just of using obnoxious, brutal sarcasm all the time when we expected people to speak plainly.
- waldopat 1y agoHonestly, I’ve always appreciated how much of 2007 Hacker News is still intact. It remains one of the few places on the internet where discovery still happens organically without trending algorithms or clickbait optimization. It's just manual submissions, one by one. There’s only one other community I’ve encountered like it, run by a small liberal arts college. From a signals perspective, HN is incredibly valuable. You get to watch in real time what’s capturing the minds of technically inclined readers. Sure, that means lots of lurkers and a few dominant topics (right now: AI). But that’s also kind of the point. HN works as a reflection of where the collective attention is, whether we like it or not. Anyways...just two cents.
- Lerc 1y agoI have seen this question asked on subreddits, Not about AI, but for other topics that some people dislike. They always seem to take the form of "Should we divide this group into A and B, A stays here and B goes over there and that way everybody is happy" Invariably the person who proposes this wants to remain in group A and will not be a participant in group B. To me this seems like the subtext is "Those people are not welcome here, they are not like us. It's not like we have anything against them, we just don't want them ramming it down our throats" Anyone is free to make a website with whatever content they want, they can invite people to it and grow your own community. Directing a community to divide to remove an element you dislike is an attempt to appropriate the established community.
- bluefirebrand 1y ago> To me this seems like the subtext is "Those people are not welcome here, they are not like us. It's not like we have anything against them, we just don't want them ramming it down our throats" It could just as easily be "I don't feel like there is a place here for me anymore and I wish I had another place to go"
- Lerc 1y agoIn my experience that is not what people mean. People with that sentiment ask about what alternative places exist, some of them make their own places. My post above mentioned something I notice on Reddit. I hardly ever visit Reddit these days. It doesn't really feel like the place for me now. I am not posting this comment on Reddit.
- bluefirebrand 1y ago> People with that sentiment ask about what alternative places exist, some of them make their own places I don't think that's overall very true Most of those people are just lonely and isolated, and that's a big part of why we are living in what people are calling a "loneliness epidemic" It's easier than ever to make a new niche area. It's more difficult than ever to get your niche area discovered by others, because you are drowned out by the noise It feels quite hopeless for many people in my experience
- HPsquared 1y agoMaybe someone could make an AI service to separate them out.
- simonw 1y agoI built you this: https://tools.simonwillison.net/hacker-news-filtered https://tools.simonwillison.net/hacker-news-filtered It shows you the Hacker News page with ai and llm stories filtered out. You can change the exclusion terms and save your changes in localStorage. o3 knocked it out for me in a couple of minutes: https://chatgpt.com/share/68766f42-1ec8-8006-8187-406ef452e0d3 https://chatgpt.com/share/68766f42-1ec8-8006-8187-406ef452e0... Initial prompt was: Build a web tool that displays the Hacker News homepage (fetched from the Algolia API) but filters out specific search terms, default to "llm, ai" in a box at the top but the user can change that list, it is stored in localstorage. Don't use React. Then four follow-ups: Rename to "Hacker News, filtered" and add a clear label that shows that the terms will be excluded Turn the username into a link to https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=xxx - include the comment count, which is in the num_comments key The text "392 comments" should be the link, do not have a separate thread link Add a tooltip to "1 day ago" that shows the full value from created_at
- rottc0dd 1y agoTop story: Kiro: new agentic IDE
- samtheprogram 1y agoJust add “agent” to the search box. It’s saved in local storage.
- simonw 1y agoI just added "agent" to the default exclusion list.
- luke-stanley 1y agoStill seeing `Kiro: A new agentic IDE` BTW.
- simonw 1y agoIf the filters UI at the top shows "llm, ai" instead of "llm, ai, agent" then you probably have that previous search saved in localStorage.
- matt_heimer 1y agoAI/LLM has become of core part of IT. If you don't want AI then it seems like you want a retro-computing news aggregator or just HN minus personal annoyances. I get it, sometimes I want the simpler days but as long as the AI/LLM posts are not dumbed down mainstream content I'm interested it them and most visitors probably are also. I wouldn't have discovered most of the articles from other places. The posts match the site's on-topic criteria, from https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
- zahlman 1y ago> as long as the AI/LLM posts are not dumbed down mainstream content The problem is, most of it really is (as it boils down to "I am / $COMPANY is using an LLM to do something; here's how you can do it too, and / or some pundit's opinion of the implications for the industry"). And the stuff that wouldn't be (like how they work, or statistics and benchmarks), often requires relatively specific domain knowledge to really appreciate.
- pxc 1y agoI've gradually come around to reading and engaging more with AI-related topics, but I'd still appreciate this. The balance of the content is way off.
- jmyeet 1y agoNo. There's always a flavor of the month. Go back 3-5 years and every third post was crypto or NFT related. AI/LLM too will pass. I've never really understood this desire of people to effectively hide content that doesn't interest them. Just... ignore it. Like there are enough people on HN who really care about academia and research. I don't. But that's fine. Let them be. But here's the interesting part: so many on HN rail against the newsfeed concept . You will hear a significant number of HNers say they just want everything in chronological order. Well, except for the subjects that don't interest them. If HN submissions were tagged and a recommendation algorithm decided what to show you, you'd get exactly what you want: fewer AI/LLM posts if that doesn't interest you. But somehow newsfeeds are still bad?
- lacksconfidence 1y agoThe desire is relateively simply explained. Some people used to find HN interesting, but the modern set of things being upvoted isn't matching their interests anymore. They already ignore the content they don't like, the problem is the content they do like isn't there anymore. The assumption, I expect, is that if there was less LLM content the site would have more of the "older style" content they used to enjoy. I don't necessarily think that will happen, but that's my interpretation of the sentiment.
- zahlman 1y agoExactly. It's not supposed to be zero-sum — posting volume isn't limited, or at least I assume we're nowhere near what the servers can technically handle — but attention span is limited. Seeing a front page full of things you aren't interested in makes it harder to find the things you are interested in, and feels discouraging if you want to post one of those things (an unfortunate feedback loop).
- notepad0x90 1y agoyou're seeing more that content because it is relevant. HN should show relevant topics in tech. the AI/LLM domination of tech as a whole is what you're seeing on HN. There is lobste.rs which might be what you're looking for.
- SubiculumCode 1y agoI mean, just don't click on an AI story.
- jasonthorsness 1y agoIf you think HN AI/LLM content is bad, try LinkedIn or X! HN is probably the best source of informed, critical takes on AI/LLM content and that is super valuable to me. I don't think it should fork; I want the same audience to keep doing its work and having the debates :P.
- 6510 1y agoInstall firefox then install violentmonkey then install https://salamisushi.go-here.nl https://salamisushi.go-here.nl browse around as usual and it will collect all discoverable feeds. then export the feeds as opml then install a robust RSS aggregator then load the opml into the aggregator then sort the news items by pubDate then remove the obnoxious subscriptions this is the way
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- paulddraper 1y agoThat’s like saying HN but without the web stuff. AI is the largest technology advancement of the last 2 decades…it’s going to show up.
- bombcar 1y agoContainerization (either the docker stuff or the literal 40 foot steel boxes) was a huge revolution in their respective industries. There was a ton of work and howling and news about them for years, decades. Now they’re so boring and standard that they’re just table stakes. Nobody cares about them enough to get into long discussions about them. The same in a best case will happen with LLMs - the things they can do will become boring and assumed, and people will eventually stop trying to make them do things they can’t.
- qmmmur 1y agoIt is reducing my desire to read this site. I don't have anything against the subject matter necessarily, and sometimes it can be interesting, but in large parts it is attracting very low quality discussions and content about vibe coding X product.
- op00to 1y ago[flagged]
- conductr 1y agoI feel it's to generic in application to be interesting to a broad audience like HN. Some things I like because I have interest in the problem space and am interested in how they applied AI to it. But most things I'm not even interested in the problem space and so could care less how they applied AI to it.
- dang 1y agoCan you link to some specific examples of low-quality discussions? As with any Major Ongoing Topic on HN (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20major%20ongoing%20topic&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...), the goal is to reserve frontpage space for the higher-quality stories and try to downweight the follow-ups and low-quality ones. We can't do this perfectly, of course, but we try.
- merelysounds 1y agoNot sure if this would be practical - AI seems to be part of the startup ecosystem now. I guess people still use HN to discover things that they never otherwise would have come across, just that it now also includes AI, for better or worse.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mikewarot 1y agoIn an ideal world, you'd be able to tag a post (or a comment) with arbitrary tags, with an optional real number to turn it into a vector. This would make it possible to rank your suspected level of AI generatedness of a comment, for example, without having to disturb other things. The UI for said system, on the other hand, is something I can't even imagine.
- tolerance 1y agoMaybe try lurking into "Past". Think about it. You can go into whichever pre-AI booming period you desire. Today I think I'm gonna check out what was hot in May 2009. https://news.ycombinator.com/front?day=2009-05-14 https://news.ycombinator.com/front?day=2009-05-14 "Obama proposes no capital gains tax on qualified small business stock" Sounds steamy. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=608202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=608202 See you there!
- jonas21 1y agoNobody is stopping you from creating your own HN clone with whatever rules and guidelines you want. I'd say go for it, and good luck! I'll stay here though.
- viraptor 1y agoYou don't even have to create it. https://lobste.rs https://lobste.rs exists and is opensource https://github.com/lobsters/lobsters https://github.com/lobsters/lobsters It even has tags built-in.
- gnopgnip 1y agoIn the last ycombinator batch, how many companies do not use AI in the core of their business?
- kylehotchkiss 1y agoIt's a hype cycle that will eventually die down. People here are usually pretty excited for new hype cycles they think they can make equity windfalls from. It's looking less likely that individuals will be making windfalls even as of this week with the new style of top-talent-acquihire acquisitions that seem to be increasing in number, so there's hope that HN goes back to generally technical :)
- lazide 1y agoDifficulty - AI makes it a lot easier to generate mountains of hype articles and drown out other content, self-reinforcing the hype. Different than prior hype cycles. Frankly, this one seems to be dying out more from everyone just flat out refusing to pay attention to online stuff or things on their phone long enough to starve the beast. If that is even possible.
- ksec 1y agoPeople who are a little late to the site may not know there was a time on HN where Erlang has even more frontage submission than the best of AI / LLM. Ruby Rails, Postgres, SQLite, Rust, etc. They all have their moments and I dont think LLM right now is as overwhelming as any other hyped moments. Certainly not Erlang.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 1y agoMicroservices had a micro moment not much longer than xml.
- amarcheschi 1y agoIf it follows the name, it's gonna be terrible since we're dealing with large language models
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- antonymoose 1y agoIt all depends if you care about the tech side of HN or the startup side of HN. I love the tech articles above all else and could easily do without the general trend fluff. With that said, I don’t find the AI posts nearly as bad as the Blockchain era.
- devmor 1y agoAs annoyed as I am with the constant deluge of uninteresting AI/LLM articles, I would much rather see a split between tech and startup news. I think that's a lasting and useful distinction.
- Karrot_Kream 1y agoIsn't topical subcommunities just Reddit?
- gojomo 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Void https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Void
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- vmsp 1y agoNo. This is a trend. HN is a tech and startups website so it will show trends. At one point it was VR, eventually it was Web 3.0. Right now it's LLMs but this too will pass and something else will come along.
- azath92 1y agoWe just built https://www.hackernews.coffee/ https://www.hackernews.coffee/ to rerank your frontpage based on a quick survey of your preference, all local storage based. In general we're thinking about how you can have a transparent profile that stands in place of an opaque algo, or in this case a dominance of a community by something you're not so into. It allows you to still engage with HN, but through the lense of a profile you have control over. Ironically it is built with AI, but its pretty straightforward no magic stuff. Keen to hear if it is useful, or could be, we're really early stages exploring where to go with it.
- Narishma 1y agoI feel like 10 answers is too few to generate a good profile. I tried it and it marked a lot of stories as 'skip' that were pretty interesting to me, presumably because they didn't fit into the 3 or 4 categories it determined I was interested in. That said, it was useful to filter out AI stuff, so that's good I guess.
- azath92 1y agoTotally agree! when we first made it public we saw almost half of folks churned without finishing the survey when we had it set at 30. That number is down to 15% churn, but at the tradeoff of coarseness of profile. Theres some work to make _both_ the onboarding for totally fresh users essentially frictionless, while also allowing adding more nuance. Our todo is having a "rank some more" thats easy, or some "while browsing" to build that profile up over time.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- throwpoaster 1y agoThe first fork should be one for socialists and one for capitalists… but the latter, Bookface, already exists.
- GuB-42 1y agoYou mean, blockchain and everything else? Oh, sorry, wrong hype cycle. Currently, for me on the front page, there is 10/30 AI/LLM related. It means you have 20/30 that is not about AI/LLM. 1 of them is blockchain btw. Typical HN, 1/3 hype, 1/3 less hype tech, 1/3 other. AI is the current hype.
- jasonmarks_ 1y agoYeah, definitely an adverse amount of guerilla advertising. How many veiled pro insert some code assistant posts can one r&d budget write?
- vouaobrasil 1y agoThe fact is, the vast majority of people on HN have drunk the AI kool-aid and have no desire to be critical of it or avoid it.
- gojomo 1y ago~simonw's demo of a quickie customized HN front-end is great. But ultimately, your browser should have a local, open-source, user-loyal LLM that's able to accept human-language descriptions of how you'd like your view of some or all sites to change, and just like old Greasemonkey scripts or special-purpose extensions, it'd just do it, in the DOM. Then instead of needing to raise this issue via an "Ask HN", you'd just tell your browser: "when I visit HN, hide all the AI/LLM posts".
- azath92 1y agoIts pretty easy to do the user-loyal bit, with a bit of prompting to give an llm your preferences/profile. Not ideologically loyal, but i mean acting in accordance with your interests. The tricky part is having that act across all sites in a light and seamless way. Ive been working on a HN reskin, and it only is fast/transparent/cheap enough because HN has an api (no scraping needed), and the titles are descriptive enough that you can filter based on them, as simonws demo does. But its still HN specific. I dont know if llms are fast enough at the moment to do this on the fly for arbitrary sites, but steps in that direction are interesting!
- gojomo 1y agoI'd expect a noticeable delay with current local LLMs - especially visiting a site for the 1st time. But then they could potentially memoize their heuristics for certain designs, including recognzing when some "deeper thought" newly required by server-side redesigns. But of course local GPU processing power, & optimizations for LLM-like tools, all adancing rapidly. And these local agents could potentially even outsource tough decisions to heavierweight remote services. Essentially, they'd maintain/reauthor your "custom extension", themselves using other models, as necessary. And forward-thinking sites might try to make that process easier, with special APIs/docs/recipe-interchanges for all users' agents to share their progress on popular needs.
- azath92 1y agoYeah, we found even the delay of non-local LLMs to be prohibitive. We started using claude for "smartest" recs and profile generation from preferences and it was so slow, on the order of a minute or so for a first visit and still 20-30s on repeat visits after storing a "profile" (essentially your notion of memoized heuristics) in local storage to come back to. We ended up finding that a middle ground between that and ~simonw's no-AI but fast, was to use flash for fast semantic understanding of preferences and recs, but degraded quality compared with a friontier model. > And forward-thinking sites might try to make that process easier, with special APIs/docs/recipe-interchanges for all users' agents to share their progress on popular needs. HN is that! our exploration was made 1000% easier because they have an API which is "good enough" for most information.
- rhodey 1y agoI dont think its the right idea long-term If it went thru that this changed I would not be opposed tho I would read both
- sgc 1y agoublock origin filter example, removes post, post actions/stats, and spacer: news.ycombinator.com##tr.submission:has(:has-text(/LLM|agentic/)) + tr + tr news.ycombinator.com##tr.submission:has(:has-text(/LLM|agentic/)) + tr news.ycombinator.com##tr.submission:has(*:has-text(/LLM|agentic/))
- frm88 1y agoThank you for this - works like a charmandno need for a github project like the one proposed above.
- scoofy 1y agoI say this about Reddit all the time. If you’re on Reddit (or HN) to just consume, then you’re doing it wrong. Threads that are “my feed isn’t what I want” are exhausting. Sure, cool, but unless someone is breaking some rule, you’re looking for an algorithm to feed you content, which is all well and good, but it’s a different type of site. Reddit (and HN) are designed exactly so that you can share something interesting you found.
- 65 1y agoOne liner you can use in a GreaseMonkey/TamperMonkey script: [...document.querySelectorAll('.titleline > a')].filter(link => link.innerText.split(' ').find(word => ['llm', 'ai'].includes(word.toLowerCase()))).forEach(el => {const sub = el.closest('.submission'); sub.nextElementSibling.remove(); sub.remove() }) I wrote this in 2 minutes so I'm sure someone is going to reply with something better.
- celeritascelery 1y agoThis is one thing lobste.rs does really well. Every submission needs a tag and you can exclude tags that you are not interested in.
- throwanem 1y ago'Domination' in what sense? I could see a couple ways you might mean this, and as qe are HNers of similar "tenure" but as far as I recall more or less otherwise strangers to one another, I could see some interest perhaps in comparing our views of what's changed and how. (Hence being vague here to try to avoid putting too strong a stamp on initial conditions...)
- HumblyTossed 1y agoNo. HN is like this. It skews heavy towards startups and right now if you have one of those and you aren't putting AI in your investor propaganda, you're not going to get many investors. Besides, it's already starting to slow as people realize AI isn't as great as the influencers want you to believe.
- dawnerd 1y agoI haven’t noticed any slowing, if anything it’s accelerating as people try vibe coding and realize they can build an mvp and get some suckers to sponsor on GitHub. Just look how many end up with donate links. I suspect a large portion of people releasing open source vibe coded projects don’t care about the project but see it as a low effort way to make a few bucks.
- 3acctforcom 1y agoFuck no. AI/LLM is a tool like any other and we need to keep on top of it. If anything it needs less politics, I have other sites for that bs.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- fancyfredbot 1y ago> I would very much like to enjoy HN the way I did years ago, as a place where I'd discover things that I never otherwise would have come across. So what does this mean exactly? Nothing LLM/AI related on hacker news is new to you, or you would easily have come across it without HN? Really? Where exactly are you finding your AI/LLM news?
- gessha 1y agoA cynical take is if Joe learned a bit about LLMs, they could build an extension that filters AI stuff into a separate tab or something along the lines of what simonw coded up. This too shall pass, Joe.
- aleksituk 1y agoHN is just a reflection of the community using it. And there's always some area that's hot and trending, common challenge on any platform with a popularity-based curation. -> But still better than a highly-personalised algo that you don't get to control?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- zipy124 1y agoThis is why https://lobste.rs/ https://lobste.rs/ and reddit have tags/subreddits in a nutshell. They get too big and people want seperation.
- rickcarlino 1y agoIf you like intelligent, tech-focused discussion as seen on HN but have less of an appetite for other aspects of the HN community, you might find you really like lobste.rs
- zahlman 1y agoI'm seeing quite a few plugs for lobste.rs ITT. My recollection of my impression from many years ago is that they had different politics from HN (I did read it every now and then, even if I only actually joined months ago) of the time, but that many posters were still very much engaged in ideological battle, and furthermore flagging and downvoting was used more to suppress one side of the argument than it was to keep the site tech-focused.
- rickcarlino 1y agoI can’t speak to that aspect specifically, but I have flip-flopped in the last five years or so. I don’t go there anymore hardly and conversely I find myself using HN a lot more. My decline in usage coincided with some policy changes they made years ago. I still think there are people who will really enjoy lobste.rs over HN. It’s not for everyone (and as of late, not for me).
- egorfine 1y agoAs much as I love LLMs and crypto, I'm really tired of subpar LLM/AI news populating the vast majority of the feed. But I have no idea how to separate topics on HN. Is it even possible to do so while keeping the community intact.
- jxjnskkzxxhx 1y agoWeird that people are floating the idea of kicking out of a tech forum the most important tech development of the last 10 years. Not sure what that means about the community, but must mean something.
- zahlman 1y agoThe problem is the quality, not the topic. Understanding serious papers about AI development requires fairly specialist knowledge; there are plenty of people around (like myself) who have been programming for decades and can write really nice code in a bunch of different programming languages, but have very little if any mental model of "transformers" or whatever. So in practice, "AI" content ends up revolving around people bandying about opinions about whether or not we're all doomed, or whether or not we're all on the edge of a utopia, or how much productivity programmers (and which ones) have lost or gained, or what kinds of tasks the LLMs are or are not currently or still good at, or whether anyone still cares about the fact that the term "AI" is supposed to mean something broader than LLMs + tool use. The emergence of the "vibe coding" concept has made things worse because people will just share their blog posts about personal experiences with trying to write code that way, or flood the Show HN section with things that are basically just "I personally found this specific thing to be 'the boring stuff' that's actually relevant to me, so now I'm automating it" with a few dozen lines of AI-generated code that perhaps invokes some API to ask another AI to do something useful.
- jxjnskkzxxhx 1y agoInteresting take. To me it feels like golden age of hackers in the 60s-80s (which was before my time but I heard stories about) where everybody is doing their own home grown research to the best of their abilities and sharing insights of varying quality. But somehow these days if it's not all polished, HN "hackers" aren't interested.
- zahlman 1y ago> But somehow these days if it's not all polished, HN "hackers" aren't interested. The fun part is that these days, typically the READMEs (especially) and licensing and documentation and maybe even the packaging setup are "polished"; the actual code (and perhaps the tests), not so much. It's quite backwards from what you expect from humans writing new code based on personal intrinsic motivation.
- op00to 1y agoNo. Ignore the threads you do not like. Conversely start your own message board if you desire and have your own rules.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoIf that happens, I would like the "non AI" side to also not allow AI-generated content. (But how would that be enforced? I don't know.) More generally: You could think about creating "sub HNs" for AI, politics, functional programming, startups, and several other categories. You could think about having something in your settings which specified which sub-HNs would put stories on your front page, with the default being "all".
- elpocko 1y agoI'm interested in news about current and emergent technologies. I wouldn't mind if those who are not interested made their own site and left the curious people alone. Please do.
- wslh 1y agoYou can perform a poor guy filter via <https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=last24h&page=0&prefix=false&query=-llm%20-openai%20-gemini%20-ai%20-mcp&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=last24h&page=0&prefix=fals...>
- ei23 1y agovibecode yourself a filter ;-)
- archagon 1y agoMore generally, I wish the site had tagging support. It would help solve a number of other problems, too.
- TYPE_FASTER 1y agoHN is the way I keep up with what’s going on. AI is very much the topic of the moment. I’m fine with it the way it is.
- jmull 1y agoFrom my perspective HN has always had certain themes I find overly repetitive and boring. I just whack “hide” on those and never think of them again.
- Narishma 1y agoWhen a quarter or more of the front page is stories about those themes, you'll be doing a lot of whacking.
- unixhero 1y agoNo it isn't.
- andrewmcwatters 1y agoIt’s not just Hacker News. It’s everywhere else too. I want some sort of web extension that allows me to just block list items from various social media websites when the topic at hand is in my blocklist.
- op00to 1y agoPerhaps you can fork and enhance https://github.com/panicsteve/cloud-to-butt https://github.com/panicsteve/cloud-to-butt
- tyleo 1y agoI for one am happy with this site’s own little fads. Who knows, either AI stays with us and I’ll be glad to have got my helping here via osmosis. Or it goes away and I can reflect on this fun little quirk our community once had.
- michaelteter 1y agoNope. While the blockchain craze was less meaningful and slightly less annoying, it died down. This will too (even though there's more actual value hiding in corners). There are certainly periods where one concept is "viral" and appears quite often; that's normal.
- nomel 1y agoIt seems that, for this to be true, AI (not just LLM) will have to plateau, very soon. Considering the Nobel prize for chemistry, last year, was about AI (not LLM) [1], I think there are still an incredible number of non-LLM applications of AI out there still. [1] https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/2024/press-release/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/2024/press-relea...
- postatic 1y agoYou can easily clone HN using other forum tools (discourse, discord, HN+) and start your own? Or HN provides APIs that are quite powerful.
- atleastoptimal 1y agoThis happened with X/Twitter. What it resulted in was a sycophantic hug-box on Bluesky and amplified social-darwinist amoral techno-capitalism on the former site. I believe splitting the rare congregations of diversely oriented smart people leads to worse outcomes for everyone, as better ideas/conversations emerge from opposing sides rubbing up against each other. Bifurcating HN would probably lead to a hype-driven, noisy AI side and a myopic, increasingly anachronistic non-AI side.
- tim333 1y agoAs someone who quite likes AI, couldn't the AI dislikers just ignore the ~15% of stories that are about AI? Or does their mere presence offend?
- atleastoptimal 1y agoThe mere presence does seem to a offend. HN has what seems to be on average a more negative appraisal of AI than the industry average (based on where new software jobs/funding are going), but some of the comments I read seem to imply that this page is swamped by endless AI hype posts devoid of substance. My first instinct reading these comments is "are we on the same website?", but I realize their perspective is possibly skewed by a strong visceral dislike of AI as an affront to many fundamental things they like about software and tech. It's become a tribal conflict, based on the ethos of "whose side are you on" rather than a sober appraisal of the facts, benefits, and legitimate hazards.
- jeanlucas 1y agono
- sexy_seedbox 1y agoI concur, we need to start our "No Homers Club"
- tom_m 1y agoJust wait a bit
- hilux 1y agoOn my new page, AI/LLM is a very small fraction of the total. Instead, I see everything from "Why the Upper Middle Class Isn’t Special Anymore" to "Boeing fuel switches safe, regulator says after Air India crash" to "Building a Simple Router with OpenBSD" to "The Scourge of ‘Spot-Fixing’ Is Coming for American Sports" to "How Elon Musk’s X is fueling the MAGA-Trump split."
- nailer 1y agoNo. We’ve had this when Linux dominated, when cloud was new and AWS was releasing a new product every six months, when node.js and Rails and Django were everywhere, when Go and Rust and Elixir debuted, when crypto first happened, and AIs are just another step. Eventually LLMs will just be another part of the mix.
- martin82 1y agoI only read the 10 highest posts per day (subscribed via a RRS feed called Hacker News Daily) and never thought that it is dominated by AI. Skill issue?
- davidguetta 1y agoLiterally gatekeeping
- zild3d 1y agoSounds like it'd be pretty easy to vibe-code the site you want
- account42 1y agoI agree but this problem is far from limited to HN. Something about AI gets some people to force it into every discussion in a way that crypto never managed to do.
- ringeryless 1y agoyes. i agree
- LoveMortuus 1y agoI wouldn't worry too much about it. It's just that AI/LLM is in fashion at the moment, but it'll pass as all trends pass. Before it was crypto and "Rewritten in Rust". Trends come and they go. If you're finding that it's affecting your mental health, it might be better to just take a break, there's a high likelihood that HN will still be here when you return. ^^
- johannboehme 1y agoNo, but i really would like a chrome extension to block out all the people complaining about AI on every site.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- priyaranjan 1y agoIsn’t this already solved at https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=blockchain&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... ? If we were to look for only blockchain stories, doing an explicit feature is one way. Searching through by free text is other. And we could just bookmark the link.