12 ms·
The Academic Pipeline Stall: Why Industry Must Stand for Academia
- busssard 1y agocrazy that this kind of OP-ED pices even have to be written...
- abirch 1y agoIt's definitely sad. I'm all for the government investing in large ROI type projects and the majority of scientific research is in that category. It's doubly sad when the government is breaking up companies similar to what it did with Bell Labs.
- analog31 1y ago>>>>> Before we go any further, let me be clear: this isn’t about sides or ideologies. Support for education and research should be as fundamental as clean air or safe roads. It is part of the shared infrastructure that holds society together. When that foundation cracks, the consequences ripple far beyond the lab. Let me be clear: This is precisely about sides and ideologies.
- JadeNB 1y ago> Let me be clear: This is precisely about sides and ideologies. How so? It is, I suppose, pushing an ideology that everyone should support education, research, clean air, and safe roads, but any belief in some sort of universal good must rely on an ideology, if only circularly on the ideology that there is such a thing as a universal good.
- esafak 1y agoIn the broad sense of ideology as "a system of ideas and ideals, especially one which forms the basis of economic or political theory and policy" (New Oxford American Dictionary)
- shankfalserinse 1y agoBecause there are people who believe we don't need new things. What is research to them?
- jvanderbot 1y agoIt can be taken to be about sides/ideology when the cause of cancellation of certain high profile university's funding is over ideological / political disputes. TFA seems to say "This is important and we shouldn't cut general funding", but also goes on to call on industry, in particular large tech company CEOs to push back against ideologically driven funding cuts. That toes the line of calling for political responses.
- cle 1y ago"Everyone should support education" is an empty platitude, it doesn't help answer questions like "how much funding?" and "who gets funding and who doesn't?". That's where the sides arise. The author (and Nature) pretends like those aren't real problems and that scientists should get unconditional support. That's never been the case.
- the_af 1y ago> How so? There are currently existing ideologies in power in some countries (e.g. in Argentina, not everything is about the US!) that stand for de-funding health, education and basic science and research, and anything that is not of immediate use for businesses. It's a self-defeating ideology (because business do benefit from basic research in the long term), but it does exist today.
- georgeecollins 1y agoI think there are credible arguments about investing less in education and research. At a really basic level, imagine if you are a retired couple in a small town. You pay a lot of taxes that goes to support a school you don't have any kids at and a university you didn't go to. That's something like the state of the world for a lot of voters in parts of the United States-- aging / dying rural towns and exurbs. When the greater good is the extreme wealth of coastal cities (and I think it is!) you can see there lots of places that really don't want to pay for it. Another good argument against our subsidy of education (although maybe not against research) is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_Against_Education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_Against_Education I don't really agree, and I am surprised there are people here who would argue against funding research.
- LarsDu88 1y agoIf this is what many people perceive, it does not actually align with what is going on in the United States today. What's actually happening is that most of the wealth and tax revenue is generated by the coastal metropolitan areas of the US, which basically subsidize the rural inland regions of the country. Things like Medicare which those same rural folks vote against. This is because the amount of wealth generated by science and technology vastly outweighs what is being generated by rural areas of the country. Now we cut off the pipeline and investment into those wealth generating areas so that long term, the nation will head into decline...
- ashoeafoot 1y agoThe costal vampire empires rob those towns of youth and future
- LarsDu88 1y agoThe youth leave because there is no future in those rural and former manufacturing areas of the country. The solution by the current administration is to weaken the dollar, but this is basically robbing everyone... when the dollar goes down by 15%, its the same as torching 15% of everyone's money -- same as inflation. The correct solution is to tax the disproportionately wealthy oligarchs of those coastal vampire companies... the tech monopolies which implicitly levy taxes on all online transactions (Google's 30% cut on android apps, Google's 70% cut on all advertising, Steam's 30% cut on all PC games, Amazon's cut on all online shopping transactions), then reinvest that money into rural industries to make manufacturing competitive. Instead the solution has been to levy a tax on all consumers over all trade, which tends to make local manufacturing less competitive over the long run.
- UltraSane 1y agoNo. It is about spiteful ignorance vs science and rationality.
- tokai 1y ago>as clean air or safe roads Its really on the nose when these two examples has been anything but fundamental. There are many people out there that don't believe these things are worth working towards. In lieu of a thorough argument I'll post this old clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2xcQIoh3FQQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2xcQIoh3FQQ
- MisterBastahrd 1y agoAnd I'm fine with it. We've got trillions of dollars worth of companies that do very little but leech off of the rest of us and utilize the vast wealth they've accumulated to degrade our society in order to perpetuate their own existence.
- bilbo0s 1y agoI'm not going to argue against the veracity of what you're saying, but I would caution against cutting off our nose to spite our face. I think what we're seeing is that there is obviously a need to rein in some of those corporate excesses you're alluding to, and try to protect the research core that we need to move the nation, and humanity in general, forward.
- bee_rider 1y agoIt is basically true but also devastating to admit that “pro-education” is an ideology. “We should fulfill some basic requirements for a functional society,” and other hardcore extremist positions…
- bilbo0s 1y agoBut pro-education is an ideology. It always was.
- snapplebobapple 1y agoIts an ideology beyond a base level that is justified by reasonable cost benefit analysis. For example i am very much against the buzz sawing currently going on but i also see the mass overproduction of phds and replication crisis quality research going on in sections of academia and am very much for drastically cutting thise fields. I would want a bunch of analysis done and then very careful scaling back over several years not what is happening
- bee_rider 1y agoI’m pretty sure everybody in academia is already aware of those problems (they are personally annoyed by them on a day-to-day basis). But the serious path to fixing them is not the buzz saw. Like nobody enjoys giving up more than half of their grants to the school admin. But cutting it down 15% max all of a sudden is not a change that is going to stick around.
- dogleash 1y ago> everybody in academia is already aware of those problems (they are personally annoyed by them on a day-to-day basis). But the serious path to fixing them is not the buzz saw What is the serious path to fixing them? I don't think academics are moving the needle with their current strat of a bit of handwringing followed by conceding to the system anyway.
- zzzeek 1y agonuclear destruction of civilization vs. not, it's all just sides and ideology. maybe humanity doesn't deserve to exist and we should be pushing for nuclear annihilation. There's two sides and both should be discussed and honored with equal value to society!
- amiga386 1y agoLet me be clear: it shouldn't be about sides or ideologies, but recently in some places it has been blatantly about ideologies, promoted by one side while they were in power, and this has enraged the base of the other side, who have brought their side into power, and they approve of their side applying maximum ideological fuckery, possibly dooming us all.
- bbor 1y ago> promoted by one side while they were in power Presumably this is in reference to the years 1993-1995, 2009-2011, and 2021-2023...? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divided_government_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divided_government_in_the_Unit... > recently in some places it has been blatantly about ideologies I agree if we use the word "ideology" in an absolute, philosophical sense, but I think this it's missing the authors point entirely. To illustrate with a more familiar term: basically every part of social life is technically political, but when people say 'this isn't about politics', they're trying to communicate that it doesn't relate to the actively-debated divisions of the day among elected officials. US prosperity is something that no side will own up to opposing, and yet here we are, dismantling our soft power in the academic sphere and beyond at a breakneck pace.
- semiinfinitely 1y agoWould academia likewise stand for industry?
- duxup 1y agoAcademia provides the benefits listed in the article. The relationship is pretty clear.
- aleph_minus_one 1y ago> Would academia likewise stand for industry? Yes, but academia doesn't have the money to be of help for the industry.
- kjkjadksj 1y agoAlready does. Many PIs use their lab and facilities to spin out patents and startups. In either case it is where industry finds the trained talent they rely on to make money.
- avsm 1y agoApplications to graduate school typically surge during times of economic downturns when industry is on its back foot. So...yes? https://www.theguardian.com/education/2009/feb/17/rise-applications-postgraduate-degrees https://www.theguardian.com/education/2009/feb/17/rise-appli... (16 years ago) and more recently https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-04-12/grad-school-interest-surges-as-young-people-fear-recession-bleak-job-market https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-04-12/grad-scho...
- cs_throwaway 1y agoWe in computer science departments are very happy to send our students to industry, whether or not they bother finishing their degree. The article lists a bunch of old-timers, like Page and Brin. Right now, everyone is talking about the "$100M offers" from Meta, for people who completed (or dropped out) of their computer science PhDs. What does "not standing for industry" mean to you?
- MeetingsBrowser 1y agoWhat does this mean? The article points out that industry benefits from academic funding. Are you implying that a) academia does not benefit from industry or b) if industry’s survival were threatened academia would not care? Academia benefits hugely from industry and would/does stand to protect those benefits.
- charcircuit 1y agoAcademia is not the only place to learn. >The tech giants whose founders and engineers were trained in these institutions, whose core technologies were incubated in these research environments There is a reason many of those founders dropped out than continue. It turns out that what you learn is useless and inefficient compared to picking up the knowledge externally. Practical experience is a much better teacher than the people at universities. Every day at class I would keep a tally of how many lies and incorrect statements and explainations would get made every day. Also notice how those core technologies are not listed because it would weaken there point. It's natural for universities to argue for why they are still relevant in the 21st century. They don't want to be disrupted.
- gdulli 1y agoI would love to see a list of those lies. I may have picked them up at university too and could be naively believing them myself.
- cs_throwaway 1y ago> Every day at class I would keep a tally of how many lies and incorrect statements and explainations would get made every day. In your computer science classes? What/where were you studying?
- charcircuit 1y agoYes, and the rate was higher the more practical the content was. So for example explainations about git would have a lot and explainations about automata would have few.
- georgeburdell 1y ago>Before we go any further, let me be clear: this isn’t about sides or ideologies. Support for education and research should be as fundamental as clean air or safe roads. It is part of the shared infrastructure that holds society together. When that foundation cracks, the consequences ripple far beyond the lab. Acknowledging that I was supported by an NSF graduate research fellowship, so I benefitted from the thing I malign, but NSF, academia, and the whole federal government pissed off a good chunk of the country with DEI initiatives, codified by affirmative action, extra grant requirements, and ideological purity statements. Some anti-science folks tapped into this anger and now we’re here, reading this Op-Ed. I do fear this is the end of America’s post-WW2 STEM hegemony, but at the same time, it feels a little good
- ceejayoz 1y agoAuthoritarian regimes tend to build power precisely that way - making it "feel a little good". They're hurting the people you don't like... at first. It's the whole point of that "first they came for the Jews/commies/unions" poem. The "feels pretty bad" bit comes much later.
- searine 1y agoWhat possibly could feel good about entering a new dark age?
- bilbo0s 1y agoTo be fair, it likely will not be a dark age. The reality is that our companies will still be able to hire scientists from foreign universities. There's still Tsinghua. The Germans rolled deep at a Harvard get together I was at and nearly all of them were from TUM or Mannheim. And the brightest was actually out of Ludwig Maximillian. So humanity's capacity to push the boundaries of science forward is safe with or without us. Now, do we want to be a part of the leading edge of that? My answer would be an enthusiastic yes! But it's perfectly right for other people to feel differently.
- ceejayoz 1y ago
- rahimnathwani 1y agoOP would be easier to take seriously if it made even a token attempt to paint a balanced picture. It says "This is what system designers recognize as a pipeline stall." without acknowledging that research universities have billions of dollars in buffers. It talks about talent pipeline without acknowledging that, for most students, colleges are mostly a gatekeeper (signaling device) and that, if the university system did not exist, the talents would still exist and mostly be developed to the same extent. It talks about the transfer from basic research to industry, without talking about how industry has benefited universities. It talks about the students who have gone on to do great things, without acknowledging that those students were pretty much forced by society to pay 5 or 6 figures to a top university, so that they could show an employer they are worth interviewing. It doesn't talk about how top universities were found (by USSC) to have discriminated against applicants on the basis of race. There's credible evidence that (i) they're still doing this, and (ii) they've also done it during hiring and promotions. IANAL, but AIUI it's illegal for the US government to fund institutions that discriminate based on race.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 1y ago> research universities have billions of dollars in buffers. Where is this myth coming from?
- advisedwang 1y agoHarvard has a $53 billion endowment. The right wing talking points assume that this is the same for every university. And that it's not earmarked. And that universities should destroy their long term stability so that billionaires can get a tax break (well, destroying universities future is a plus for them).
- overfeed 1y agoEndowments aren't meant to be spent on operational expenses.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- locacorten 1y agoIn the city where I live, the contrast is striking: the local state college boasts dorms and facilities that are remarkably luxurious—architecturally grand, stylish, and visibly well-funded. Meanwhile, the local NVIDIA office operates out of a building that looks decidedly unremarkable, even shabby by comparison. One is supported in part by public funds; the other is a profit-driven enterprise. I absolutely believe in the value of academia and agree we should support it. But this administration has made it clear that reform is expected. I’m not convinced that message is being fully heard. Until we see meaningful changes—such as a leaner administrative structure and a shift away from spending on vanity infrastructure—I’ll pass.
- tech_ken 1y agoIt’s more complicated than you’re implying. University capital expenditures are rational decisions when they’re competing for a national pool of students backed by cheap debt. Parents care about the student success initiatives, students care about the multibillion dollar rec center. Given the way the current higher ed market is structured, the bloated administration and vanity dorms are thus actually revenue positive. They attract top students, especially from out of state, and with them a fat stream of tuition revenue. Just cutting their funding from the top, without looking at the other half of their revenue generation, is missing the point entirely.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- MeetingsBrowser 1y agoI’m not an expert in academic financing, but how much money from NSF research grants went towards building nice dorms? I went to an inexpensive state college and the infrastructure was horrible. I would guess that things like dorms are largely paid for from tuition. How much is tuition at the state college in your city?
- elashri 1y agoNSF grants can’t be used to build dorms, it’s actually in their official guidance. The rules (from the Uniform Guidance, 2 CFR 200) explicity say that federal research money can’t go toward capital projects like housing. The only "facilities" costs they allow are indirect ones like basic maintenance or utilities for existing research building not new construction. So dorms are totally off limits.
- shayway 1y agoIt seems like no more than a year ago the prevailing narrative was problems with higher education and science: how predatory and insidious the student loan industry is, and how it traps people in a cycle of debt with special treatment from the government to not let them escape; the replication crisis revealing just how deeply flawed the incentives in science are, and how safeguards like peer review have failed to stop the slide. And yet now that there's money at stake - not the money of those drowning in student loans, but those who benefit from the system - people come out of the woodwork to wax lyrical about the majesty of academia, championing its defense at all costs. Curious.
- tech_ken 1y agoMany things are both flawed and worth of preservation.
- shayway 1y agoScience as a principle is beautiful and valuable, and is entirely worthy of preservation. The industry surrounding it, less so. They are not inseparable. The latter has proven a poor steward of the former, and it's the latter that's under threat right now. It's not a question of 'yes science' or 'no science', but whether the current version of it is truly a fitting use of the space it occupies.
- tech_ken 1y agoI think they are way less separable than you do. Moreover, I would say that while the current stewardship has notable flaws they are far, far fewer and less grave than previous iterations. No iteration is worthy of the space it holds, but progress comes through honest introspection exactly like what has followed the replication crisis you described. Simply bulk-axing research grants that fail to properly kowtow to the current president’s political ideology is a much cruder tool, and one which seems unfit to really address the concerns you described in your original post.
- ceejayoz 1y agoAs the apocryphal Churchill quote goes, "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others." The same may be true for science.
- N7lo4nl34akaoSN 1y ago.
- bee_rider 1y agoYour post is greyed out currently, which is a shame. I think you’ve sarcastically described a tech company here, like as a joke, right? The post is a good joke, I’m surprised people missed it.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- eviks 1y ago> Before we go any further, let me be clear: this isn’t about sides or ideologies. Support for education and research should be as fundamental as clean air or safe roads. That's pretty naive. The latter is not immune to ideology, and even if it were, you can't have an ideology-free way of setting both the total amount and the split between sciences/topics within. The vision at the top of the ivory tower shouldn't be this clouded.
- tech_ken 1y agoOkay but when people in the academy do bring up the difficulty of settling on objective, ideology-free truths people get even touchier (like try bringing up critical theory to someone who supports these NSF cuts and see how far you get). I think you have to accept certain things being settled when you’re performing public rhetoric.
- pyuser583 1y agoIm split minded about this. On the one hand, academia has been taking sides for a long time. On the other, there are elements that should be non-controversial. I wish academia were more rigorous about not taking sides. I feel like they’ve been injecting their own ideology unnecessarily for a while. Am I supposed to ignore that? The best approach is some kind of grand bargain, and carefully considered compromise. I have experience in academia. I’ve heard how they talk. They see their mission as transforming society. There are exceptions, but even the exceptions are under pressure to conform. It’s hard to address two problems at once. And I feel there are two legitimate problems: an overly ideological academy, and the need for both support and independence. Solving one problem is hard enough. Solving both is impossible. So we will probably go back and forth for a while. My default is to look at foreign countries. But I don’t see anywhere else that’s solved these problems.
- 0xWTF 1y agoWhenever I hear a critique of the US academy I'm reminded of Rodney Dangerfield and Sam Kinison's bit in Back to School: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WeeL-U7cbpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WeeL-U7cbpE Correct me if I'm wrong, but I've read (I believe on this very forum though I can't find the link, but also see 1, 2, and 3) that the European universities are often closely aligned with local industries. A challenge here in the US: outside Silicon Valley, what are the manufacturing industries in the US cities with universities? What are the major industries in Kansas City? Are those companies funding research at UMKC? What are the major industries in Dallas? Are those companies funding research at Southwestern? Ronny Chieng actually breaks down the larger problem quite nicely: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/i1Hi_hacvN4 https://www.youtube.com/shorts/i1Hi_hacvN4 So now we do in fact have an incredible university system supported in part by a mess of underskilled labor in fly-over states that dropped out of college after saddling themselves with significant educational debt. Wildly, the one industry that is a major economic driver in most cities is healthcare, which is a pretty dead-end industry in terms of economic output, that is, outside of certain world-reknowned institutions like the Mayo Clinic, healthcare doesn't really generate a significant exportable commodity. (1) https://education.ec.europa.eu/education-levels/higher-education/innovation-in-education/university-business-cooperation https://education.ec.europa.eu/education-levels/higher-educa... (2) https://www.jstor.org/stable/24118541 https://www.jstor.org/stable/24118541 (3) https://sciencebusiness.net/news/universities/deepening-collaboration-between-academia-and-industry https://sciencebusiness.net/news/universities/deepening-coll...
- 6510 1y agoPretty funny plan, outsource all the manual labor, shut down rnd and then get rid of academia.
- disambiguation 1y agoThis feels like a spectator sport to me - elite classes fighting amongst themselves while ordinary people are caught in the crossfire. Sure, I do feel bad for the well meaning professors, scientists, and researchers (some of whom are personal friends) that are losing their grant funding - techies of all people should be sympathetic to a sudden disruption in funding. But if the elites are asking us to take sides, they need to make a stronger case that they're really on _our side_ - that requires more than appealing to mutual self-interest. Academia must reconcile a litany of shortcomings and broken promises. For the promise of education, we see a large and growing contingent of debt holders outweighing the number of available employment opportunities. Tuition is at an ATH, yet more and more students are walking away with worse outcomes. A grim forecast for the younger generation. For the promise of research, we've seen a shift from truth-seeking to grant-seeking, a punitive culture of ideological conformity, and a pipeline to brain-drain the rest of the world, favoring foreign talent over local. Hardly the unbiased bastion of free-thought we've been taught is the foundation of good science. As for ideology, I'm not sure the intelligentsia has ever been neutral, if that's even possible, or if neutrality itself isn't another ideology. As far as I can tell, this is just the pendulum swinging back. Academia is experiencing the consequences of its failure to live up to its promises to society and hold itself accountable for the negative externalities of its own agenda.
- epistasis 1y agoThis is a very odd way to put this, as a battle between elites. Scientific research is a general benefit to the entire US economy, one of its greatest strengths that makes the US economy so much better than anywhere else in the world. How does framing this as a competition between elites even affect the common person? Shouldn't I care about what helps the US the most? I don't give a damn about elites or taking sides or being on a side of that battle. I want what's best for the US. > Academia is experiencing the consequences of its failure to live up to its promises to society and hold itself accountable for the negative externalities of its own agenda. I'm sorry but could you explain any of this? There's a lot of assumptions in here that I can not even begin to unpack, and any possible meaning I can assign to your statements here are easily disproven with even a minimum of research, so I don't want to misunderstand you.
- kerblang 1y ago> an assault on science and scientists anywhere is an assault on science and scientists everywhere No, actually, it isn't, and that kind of hysterical catastrophizing hurts our case. I'll readily agree that science funding is good, necessary, and even a matter of national security, but you need rhetorical limits. Really, it's that kind of howling and shrieking that led to the whole mess and turns public opinion the other way. Talk like a scientist. And yes I'm sure I'll get downvoted to heck on behalf of hysterical catastrophizing anyhow.