11 ms·
BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal
- addaon 1y agoIt’s a good choice for testing out new technologies, because they’ll save a bunch of service costs… after all, warranty void if Seal is broken.
- bgnn 1y agoThe focus of the comments seem to ve personal car use case but this actually has a much bigger implications for commercial use cases like robo-taxis (waymo style), trucks, busses, tracktors or even heavy construction machines.
- cyp0633 1y agoUpdate: this news was denied by BYD
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- the_arun 1y ago> According to local reports, BYD’s solid-state EV batteries set a record by gaining 1,500 km (932 miles) range in just 12 minutes of charging. If so, can this be beneficial to use cases outside auto industry? Eg. Power walls. If so, I am more excited for that. I am tired of electricity bills.
- dzhiurgis 1y agoResidential battery costs less than an iPhone…
- majorchord 1y agoThe tech used to get such fast charging isn't revolutionary, it's just extremely (dangerous) high voltage DC charging that only exists in any capacity in China. Also, what happens when an EV taxi runs out of battery power in China? They actually have stations setup all over that you simply drive into and it replaces the entire battery pack... in minutes.
- lazide 1y agoFor the audience - up to 1500V, 600A. Or just shy of a Megawatt. Yowzers.
- daveguy 1y agoReally no more dangerous than a 480v, 300A level 3 charger in the US. Both have enough to kill. It's not like you'd be less dead if a level 3 charger malfunctioned. They both require redundant monitoring hardware and female plugs on the hot end.
- rob_c 1y agoMy favourite is the standard of water cooled high current high voltage cables for charging EVs... Imo that's stepping beyond the risk profile of filling a tank with a known high explosive that can evaporate and suffocate and catch fire in the sun ... But risk profiles are inherently personal
- awongh 1y agoMost relevant part: > BYD’s solid-state EV batteries set a record by gaining 1,500 km (932 miles) range in just 12 minutes of charging. > The test charged the battery to just 80%, meaning total EV range could reach upwards of 1,875 km (1,165 miles). Keep in mind, that is CLTC range. On the EPA scale, it would be closer to 1,300 km (808 miles) Is this true? How quickly will other companies be making these types of batteries? Is there some reason why solid state batteries seem to be being deployed in cars sooner than in phones?
- dzhiurgis 1y agoVolumetric vs gravimetric density. Cars have heaps of space but smallish weight budget. Phones are opposite.
- MostlyStable 1y agoFor the last part, my guess is that the advantages are much more valuable in an EV than they are in a phone (where batteries are mostly fine. While longer life and faster charging are always nice to have:they are just that: nice to have), so if you are A) production limited and B) they are still more expensive (the article states they expect them to be price-comparable by the end of the decade), then they probably aren't worth it in a phone (yet). When price comes down and production comes up (assuming those things happen), then I would expect them to start appearing in phones as well.
- Dylan16807 1y agoThat logic seems crazy to me. Extra hundreds of miles are also just nice to have, and with the same material that goes into a 500kg car pack you could make 10000 double life phone batteries and sell them for $100 each. There's more per-cell overhead in the phone batteries but is it worth a million dollar drop in revenue?
- MostlyStable 1y agoConsumers seem to disagree with you on the first part. I personally think that current battery tech is fine for EVs (I have an EV with a 260 mile range, and only a 77kW max charge rate, and I think it's fine even for 10+ hour road trips), but a segment of the consumer space wants more than that. I personally thought that the more interesting part of the article was where they claimed to be able to add 800 miles of range in 12 minutes. At those kinds of charge rates, my ideal EV would probably have a 300ish mile range that I could charge from 10-80 in <10 minutes (although I believe that part of the way they get those charge rates is with large battery packs, so a smaller pack would probably not charge as fast). Additionally, while the specs for EV sedans are currently fine, batteries are only barely good enough for larger, less efficient vehicles. Maybe the killer app here isn't a sedan that goes 1000 miles, but a truck or SUV that can go 500. The point is, whatever your and my opinions on the adequacy of current EV charging, the market seems to value improved battery specs more highly in the EV space than it does in the phone space (or maybe it doesn't and BYD is making a mistake by keeping their batteries for their cars instead of selling them to phone manufacturers).
- xhkkffbf 1y ago1200 miles of range? I only need 100-200 regularly and maybe a bit more on special occasions. Can I spend 1/6 as much and get 1/6 the battery?
- dzhiurgis 1y agoSolid state batteries will enable astonishing hypercars (think 10,000 hp for less than a porsche) but will also make small and cheap lightweight EVs feasible (ie 1000kg) due to mass de-compounding effect.
- wing-_-nuts 1y agobyd has a seagull model that's basically exactly that for $10k. Don't see why they wouldn't bring it to the US absent tarrifs.
- ranger_danger 1y agoBecause it would destroy the auto industry overnight.
- johnea 1y agoYou say that like its a bad thing...
- dyauspitr 1y agoIt is. I want American auto manufacturing to continue to be a thing. With this administration most industries will see 4 years of technological and competitive regression though so it’s probably a losing battle.
- johnea 1y agoPlease see this reply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44339924 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44339924
- 1y ago
- majorchord 1y ago> BYD’s solid-state batteries have an energy density of 400 Wh/kg, or nearly twice that of current lithium-ion batteries. I thought the big issue with solid-state (besides dendrites) was a lower energy density than Li-ion? What happened?
- rob_c 1y agoIt's a next generation Lithium battery, I've seen lithium chemistry power storage quoted as high as 600 in some prototypes so I'm guessing they cracked something in the lithium chemistry. Given it's still lithium based I'd still think twice before chucking a bucket of water on one that's fizzing :p As for how this battery is better I'm not an expert, but good to read if true.
- maxerickson 1y agoBetter density is one of the reasons solid state battery research has been pursued. Maybe you are comparing the density of research batteries that weren't worth commercializing to highly developed lithium ion batteries?
- _ea1k 1y agoMaybe you have confused it with iron phosphate, which is also fairly popular in lower cost EVs? That one has a lot of advantages, but does have relatively poor energy density.
- recursivedoubts 1y agowould be very interested to know if people know what the cold-weather behavior of these batteries are: i'm in montana and battery life, especially in winter, can be a life-or-death issue and that (+ range/recharge time) is a reason a lot of folks here look at ev's skeptically, would love to hear they handle cold better
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoI understand that Teslas sell [sold?] well, in Norway.
- v0976 1y agoThey used to, but Musk's hand signal and association with Trump had a serious impact on subsequent Norwegian sales.
- breve 1y agoTesla sales are suffering from the brand damage Musk has done: https://eu-evs.com/marketShare/ALL/Groups/Line/All-time-by-Quarters https://eu-evs.com/marketShare/ALL/Groups/Line/All-time-by-Q... Swasticars don't sell well. Musk needs to leave the company to give Tesla a chance to recover.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoFrom what I understand, if he did leave, the value of the stock would plummet, so it sounds like a Faustian bargain.
- breve 1y agoTesla's board of directors certainly aren't firing Musk. They don't care. They got theirs: https://archive.md/XtUhS https://archive.md/XtUhS
- bryanlarsen 1y ago> and battery life, especially in winter, can be a life-or-death issue How so? A full battery can run your seat heaters for about a month. That's a lot better than the hours of heat you'd get out of a full tank of gasoline. Not to mention that you'll never get carbon monoxide poisoning from a gasoline engine with a tailpipe blocked with snow.
- wing-_-nuts 1y agoI seriously hope the next US administration stops bending over backwards to protect the big 3. If we want to address climate change, we're gonna low cost greentech and china is currently the king of that in evs, batteries and solar. If we're really so concerned about 'supply chain' issues we could build up a strategic reserve of batteries and solar panels. If china wants to continue subsidizing their industry below costs of manufacture I see no reason why we shouldn't exploit their generosity to meet our climate goals as quickly as possible. One of the 'good news' stories re: the recent datacenter buildout is that grid storage is now being more widely deployed, and that compliments the roll out of renewable energy.
- throw0101c 1y ago> […] I see no reason why we shouldn't exploit their generosity to meet our climate goals as quickly as possible. Because your own industrial base atrophies is one reason: > Democratic countries’ economies are mainly set up as free market economies with redistribution, because this is what maximizes living standards in peacetime. In a free market economy, if a foreign country wants to sell you cheap cars, you let them do it, and you allocate your own productive resources to something more profitable instead. If China is willing to sell you brand-new electric vehicles for $10,000, why should you turn them down? Just make B2B SaaS and advertising platforms and chat apps, sell them for a high profit margin, and drive a Chinese car. > Except then a war comes, and suddenly you find that B2B SaaS and advertising platforms and chat apps aren’t very useful for defending your freedoms. Oops! The right time to worry about manufacturing would have been years before the war, except you weren’t able to anticipate and prepare for the future. Manufacturing doesn’t just support war — in a very real way, it’s a war in and of itself. * https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/manufacturing-is-a-war-now https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/manufacturing-is-a-war-now That's (partly) what did-in Japan and Germany in during WW2: they couldn't produce enough to actually run a war. Even the just the UK was out-producing Germany in many measures (e.g., aircraft). The Big 3 completely retooled for war in very short order. If things go hot again you want factory capacity available for retooling to be possible. A society just has to be willing to pay for that capacity instead of deciding that they want the cheapest widget made somewhere else. Given the use of drones in Russia-Ukraine, what is the drone-making capacity of the US versus some other countries?
- tiahura 1y agoWeren’t Chinese battery manufacturers supposed to be shipping some sort of Lithium battery breakthrough this year?
- johnea 1y agoThe resistance to electrification in the US is one of the country's biggest self inflicted wounds. In the long run, I really don't think we can tariff our way around technical innovation. 900 miles of range in 12 mins of charging... Charge for 20 mins and have enough range for 2 full days of travel driving! And this is only when driving long distances. Anyone with a driveway can eassily charge overnight for typical daily driving. The whole package: many types of energy source providing electricity, never having to go to a gas station for typical daily driving, path to complete elimination of petro combustion byproducts, massive simplification of the overall vehicle mechanism, significant performance enhancements, etc. All technical evaluation come out in favor of EVs...
- tokioyoyo 1y agoIt’s hard to win technical innovation when you’re this behind. The best you can do is to kick the can down the road, instead of short term suffering of your citizens. The thing is, the average American is also very sensitive to any kind of change to their daily life. And taking advice from anyone how “it is better for you” is against the whole individual thought idea. So, good luck.
- smeeger 1y agoill believe it when i see it
- walrus01 1y agoNotably 400Wh/kg will be very useful for medium size UAV. Battery packs made out of the best 18650 or 21700 are around 255Wh/kg right now.
- Dah00n 1y agoDoD better get in a big order then ;)