7 ms·
What were the MS-DOS programs that the moricons.dll icons were intended for?
- theandrewbailey 2y agoAnother delightful The New Old Thing post, ever living up to the name.
- rbanffy 2y agoI used many of those icons...
- codevark 2y ago[dead]
- xunil2ycom 2y agoHaving worked at WordPerfect during the days of Windows 3.0/3.1, I'm surprised they accommodated WP with icons.
- chiph 2y agoMy WP days were under DOS (I still remember the cardboard cheat-sheet you got with it that fit around the function keys). But I remember this DLL and wondering where they got the icons. Did they contact the vendors via official channels, or did someone at Microsoft just call up a buddy and ask them what they thought would look good?
- 90s_dev 2y agoWhen I was a kid, my dad upgraded our home computer from DOS 5 or 6 to Windows 3.11 for Workgroups. It was the first GUI that I ever used, and it was amazing comparitively. Every app was mysterious and innovative and wonderful. I tried Borland C++ and it was absolutely confusing, but I was probably just too young. Even QBasic was deeply confusing for a long time, but eventually I finally made a simple, terribly written and horribly broken Bomberman clone. Those looking to experience something similar to that feeling should buy pico8.
- sksrbWgbfK 2y ago> Even QBasic was deeply confusing for a long time For one whole year, I thought that Qbasic and Turbo Pascal were text editors that could also run games. I didn't understood that I had access to real compilers and that I could actually change the programs. Sometimes kids are stupid... As for your Pico8 suggestion, you can always get the open-source equivalent https://tic80.com/ https://tic80.com/ if you don't have the money.
- 90s_dev 2y agoTic80 is great but Pico8 is better if you can afford it. And yeah, for a while I avoided strings in QBasic because I didn't have any clue how thread or yarn or whatever had anything to do with writing programs.
- Sharlin 2y agoI remember being confused why the Pascal/Delphi fractional numbers were called Single, Double, and Real. Like what did those words have to do with being able to use the decimal point?
- EvanAnderson 2y agoSharing fun kid computer misconceptions: I used a version of BASIC on my father's accounting computer that had an error message which included the word "ILLEGAL" (I forget what it was, exactly). I always assumed it had something to do with tax laws and the computer warning you not to break them.
- 3036e4 2y agoIn what ways? I paid for both, but I only use TIC-80 since I prefer open source and it has a FreeBSD port. I am also not sure if PICO8 supports alternative languages like Fennel or Janet as well as TIC-80 does?
- 90s_dev 2y agoThere's just something more polished, aesthetic and functional about the choice of limitations pico8 offers, whereas tic80 encourages decision paralysis.
- 90s_dev 2y agoWord Perfect!!! I'm almost positive that was the editor they taught me in the early 1990s in grammar school! (We called it grammar school back then, for it was the 1800s.) And yet I had never seen or used it since. This brings back so many memories. I was sitting next to a girl named Dana, the only Dana I ever met.
- teddyh 2y agoMaybe her parents liked Ghostbusters?
- jonhohle 2y agoWhile it’s hard to imagine someone using Word Perfect in grammar school born during or after 1984, I hold out hope that her middle initial was “Z”. That said, I believe I learned spreadsheets in high school using Lotus for DOS in 1996, but can’t imagine kids 3 years later still doing the same.
- xp84 2y agoI'm around that age. In poorer areas we just had whatever cast-off computers. Circa 1995, my grammar school featured: - A Franklin ACE (Apple ][ Clone) with an amber screen and two floppy drives - An Atari ST with a daisywheel printer (Letter quality!) The newest additions to the school were: - A Compaq 386 with an amber screen - this is where we had WordPerfect - A Tandy 1000, 8086 with DOS and a color monitor. Not sure if it could do VGA, definitely CGA was a thing. We ran Where in The World Is Carmen Sandiego and a paint program on that. Because it was in my classroom, this was really the first computer I learned exhaustively. I read its MS-DOS manual cover to cover and enjoyed writing batch files, building launcher menus, etc.
- onionisafruit 2y agoIt was huge back then, but it tanked in the transition to Windows. I kept using the DOS version for years after that because I had muscle memory for WordPerfect’s shortcuts and liked the reveal codes feature. Also I’ve met two Danas that I can remember. Both were lovely people.
- Theodores 2y agoIt was kind of Microsoft to include icons for so many products that rivalled their own. It was also a good way to get the MS-DOS user onboard with Windows, even though it was not needed for these MS-DOS applications. Most of these MS-DOS applications installed into well known folders. Was there any tool that came with Windows to find these applications and put them in program manager groups, or was this something that one had to do for oneself?
- dontdoxxme 2y agoThe post alludes to it, the previous post has details[1], setup did it, based on the data in APPS.INF (a massive file shipped with Windows, although you could add your own data[2]). [1]: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20250505-00/?p=111143 https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20250505-00/?p=11... [2]: http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/microsoft/resource_kits/0030-54303_Windows_for_Workgroups_3.11_Resource_Kit_Addendum_1993.pdf http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/microsoft/resource_kits/0030-54... page 183
- mark_undoio 2y agoAh, lovely blast from the past! I remember finding this DLL and being delighted that I could now put pretty icons on more things. Also remember taking ages to figure out that it meant "more icons" rather than just a silly made up word.
- bombcar 2y agoMoricons' Magical Watchdog!
- myself248 2y agoMoraff's World was right there, it wasn't hard to think it was related.
- mseepgood 2y agoThey were composed by Ennio Moricons.
- kstrauser 2y agoI can hear this comment.
- mark_undoio 1y agoThis made me very happy
- deaddodo 2y ago> Also remember taking ages to figure out that it meant "more icons" rather than just a silly made up word. The good ole' days of having to figure out a meaningful name in 8 chars.
- 3036e4 2y agoThat is almost my favorite part of DOS retro computing. Every file to name is a little puzzle.
- MisterTea 2y agoHoly crap, Crosstalk XVI. Almost forgot about that one. Edit: Forgot to mention it's a terminal emulator that supported a few file transfer protocols like kermit and xmodem. My father used it to send programs to his CNC machines. I remember getting it working in Windows 3.1 but he did not like or care for Windows as all of the software he ran was DOS: Design CAD 3D, Q&A for word processing and database, and a custom payroll program his friend wrote. His favorite game was gorilla.bas.
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]
- alfiedotwtf 2y agoI'm not sure about everyone else, but even though I haven't used Windows in about 23 years, every time Raymond Chen has a post on Hacker News it's always a pleasure to read.
- williamcotton 2y agoHow many of us saw the title and the microsoft.com label and immediately knew it was Raymond Chen? He's definitely a treasure!
- themadturk 2y agoCount me in!
- donatj 2y agoOh man that brings back memories of Windows 3.1 and makes me feel oh so old.
- discreteevent 2y agoMicrosoft C 7. I started programming with this for a few months before Visual C++ came out. It had a DOS IDE that was a bit like QBasic but it's hard to remember the behavior exactly.
- omnibrain 2y agoThose fill me with so much nostalgia. I think I read in a magazine about moricons.dll, this lead me to opening every dll and exe on our computer to look for icons.
- treve 2y agoSame here! It was like finding hidden treasure. On a computer without internet and not getting new software often I just wanted to look in every nook and cranny for something interesting.
- larodi 2y agoit is super sad, that these times lasted so little. it is perhaps also because we grew with them, but still. would've been nice if these were with us enough so that we can actually remember which was which .) i mean - they bring some vaporware nostalgia, but actually not all these icons mean at all a thing to me. i dont think they ever meant that much altogether to anyone.
- mmastrac 2y agoRemember the good old days of editing PIF (Program Information Files) files [⁂]? Ah yeah. Googling a bit, it looks like a lot of this lore has just been lost. I don't know if there are modern explanations of PIF files kicking around. ⁂ I realize this is an ATM machine phrasing, but we called them PIF files in the day.
- deaddodo 2y agoThere's still plenty of information on the file format kicking around: https://www.fileformat.info/format/pif/corion.htm https://www.fileformat.info/format/pif/corion.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20220214185118/http://www.smsoft.ru/en/pifdoc.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20220214185118/http://www.smsoft... As well as a basic explanation of the file's purpose: http://justsolve.archiveteam.org/wiki/Program_information_file http://justsolve.archiveteam.org/wiki/Program_information_fi...
- hk1337 2y ago> PIF it's also an onomatopoeia for opening up a can of biscuits
- GranPC 2y agoBack in the day, sending the string ".pif" to any MSN Messenger group chat was enough to immediately disable it for everyone. Fun way of dealing with spam :)
- fredoralive 2y ago
- jandrese 2y agoLooking at the icons now I feel the ones where Microsoft put the icon on top of a row of horizontal lines are hard to read at a glance. The lines make the icon visually busy. Probably not so bad when you are on a 640x480 display and those icons are relatively large, but on a modern display they're a bit hard to make out.
- sintezcs 2y agoI’m really amazed by the fact how expressive and solid such low-res icons can be. Creating them is a true art
- jannes 2y agoTry this CSS if you want to zoom in without the icons turning into a blurry mess: img { image-rendering: pixelated; }
- mmh0000 2y agoNow, this is the kind of obscure hacking I'm on HN for! Also, I wish I had known about that little trick ... years ... ago.
- layer8 2y agoThere should be an `image-rendering: crt;`.
- kragen 2y agoThis is the kind of thing you should implement in a JS library, or by preprocessing the image before you upload it to the web site, not add to the browser platform spec.
- layer8 2y agoI was half-joking, and primarily meant to point out that the pixelated versions aren’t how those icons looked like to users back in the day either. But also, for faithful CRT rendering you want to take the actual screen pixels into account, possibly even the subpixel layout, very much like for text rendering. Therefore there’s something to be said for that to be a browser-level feature.
- aabajian 2y agoMax nostalgia. When I was ~12 years old I had an 386 PC we got for $5 from the thrift store across from the dump (a bargain for sure even at that time). I had to self-teach myself about DOS, BASIC, Win 3.1, etc. I somehow broke the Win 3.1 installation and all I could find was Win 3.0 on floppy disc. I got the thing reinstalled, but found that the sound drivers didn't work, random programs wouldn't open, and it kept crashing. I learned years later that there are a huge number of changes between 3.1 and 3.0. The biggest being support for more memory and multimedia extensions. The latter was the first time I learned what a dynamic link library (DLL) was and that took me down the rabbit hole of C++.
- chuckadams 2y agoI just can't get me enough of Raymond Chen and his wonderful walks down the dustier paths of memory lane. Feels like a more innocent time where I didn't feel like I was imminently going to be turned into paperclips.
- avidiax 2y agoYeah, the sense at that time was that you master the machine. Now, increasingly, the machines will master you if you aren't careful. Of course, the machines haven't really done anything to us. They've just been locked down and remotely controlled to deliver ads and misinformation.
- deadbabe 2y agoThe greatest trick machines ever pulled was making us believe they haven’t done anything to us.
- JadeNB 2y ago> The greatest trick machines ever pulled was making us believe they haven’t done anything to us. While "guns don't kill people, people kill people" is a cliché, I think there's still considerable meaning behind it, and I'd say the same holds in the "machines don't do anything to people" sense. Sure, a lot of decision-making and faceless authority is outsourced to machines, but it's still people who are doing that outsourcing, and if those people stopped deciding to put so much weight on the output of (intentionally and unintentionally) black-boxed algorithms then that power of the machines would vanish instantly.
- EvanAnderson 2y ago> ...you master the machine. Now, increasingly, the machines will master you... Today I bump into limitations of machines that were put there by manufacturers who are trying to assert ownership of the device after the purchase. In the "before times" limitations were either a fact of the hardware (i.e. you only have so much RAM, storage, CPU cycles, etc) or of your own ability (you don't know how to crack the protection, defeat the anti-debug tricks, etc). Today you're waging a nearly unwinnable battle against architectures of control baked-in to the hardware at a level below a level that the average end user has any hope of usurping. The machine isn't trying to master me. The people who made the machine are. I wish people in the tech industry wouldn't be party to taking away computing freedom. It pays well, though, and they can console themselves with "It's not a computer, it's a phone"-type delusions (at least until the day "the man" comes for their PCs).
- bitwize 2y agoN.B. Access for DOS was not a database. It was a communications program with preconfigured settings for popular services like CompuServe and Dow Jones. It wasn't generic like Crosstalk (also featured); to my knowledge it couldn't do anything that it didn't have a configuration for. Clearly aimed at the "on the go" business person who wanted to check stock prices or something without worrying about baud rates or stop bits.
- recursive 2y agoI didn't know these were intended for anything. I thought they were provided to users as a swiss-army knife of reasonably expressive icons for use however they saw fit. At least that's how I used them.
- jelder 2y agoWhy can I hear these icons? Seriously, all of the window .wav files just got loaded from my long term memory, along with the sound of Windows launching from a magnetic HDD.
- Calwestjobs 2y agoOh yeah, sound of rats inside of water pipe. OR floppy sound - startup button, boop beep trrrrrrrr bomp.
- ryandrake 2y agoOne thing the article did not answer is “why?” I think I am missing something but why did Microsoft feel they needed to ship icons for other software vendors’ applications? Wouldn’t Lotus and Quicken want to ship their own icons with their software?
- shdon 2y agoThese were existing MS-DOS programmes that had already shipped. They wouldn't have shipped with a Windows icon as they were made before that Windows version existed (or at least shipped) and weren't even intended to run on that platform. Once Windows had shipped, and software vendors started making software for it, they will of course have included their own icons. The "why" is simply Microsoft wanting to make Windows play nice with users' existing software, and thus enhancing the user experience.
- ok123456 2y agoPart of the Windows 3.1 installer would search your hard drive for existing applications and add them to the Program Manager. Many of these were DOS applications that had no embedded icon resources. To keep them from all being default applications, they used this little DLL database of icons.
- indymike 2y agoMicrosoft wanted to make their new GUI shell for dos look good. There were no apps with icons so they put the most popular and some good stand ins so their new GUI file manager/launcher worked well.
- Narishma 2y agoThe 'why' was answered in the first article of this series. https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20250505-00/?p=111143 https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20250505-00/?p=11...
- layer8 2y agoThe article links to earlier blog posts that explain the “why”.
- wormius 2y agoThey did Turbo Pascal dirty with those icons... I get that Borland C++ also was blue/yellow for the DOS versions (looks like they stopped the DOS version of it in 1993 with version 4). And I assume these were from the early days of Windows so it was a DOS product at that point, but... Man. Poor TP, getting the shaft. I loved TP, in 93 it was the language we learned for programming in high school. My first compiler was Borland C++ 4.5 bought used from ebay LOL.
- ulrikrasmussen 2y agoI remember clicking many of these as a kid on my friends dads computer and being disappointed because it wasn't the game I thought it was. I particularly remember the FoxPro icon.
- pavlov 2y agoRoman numerals in software versioning should make a comeback. The Cicero-approved desktop of MS-DOS programs from this moricons.dll set would include these: Applause II 1.5 Framework III Crosstalk-XVI 3.71 PC Paintbrush IV Plus And of course you’d want dBase III+ and Deluxe Paint II Enhanced.
- PTOB 2y agoI support this. "Windows XI" looks so much more professional and enigmatic.
- pavlov 2y agoThis website best experienced with Chrome CXXXVII+ on Windows XI Enhanced.
- jasomill 2y agoBuild ↂↂↁↀⅭ.ↀↁⅬⅩⅠ
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AStonesThrow 2y agoYou may laugh, but when I heard that Microsoft was working on code-name "Cairo" I turned that around phonetically in my head until I realized they were indeed referring to "Windows Chi-Rho". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chi_Rho https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chi_Rho https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_XP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_XP
- int_19h 2y agoThey should go all the way to Windows MMXXV etc.
- joemi 2y agoNo thanks. Then it just causes confusion when some people use the roman numerals and other people convert them to arabic numerals. Especially for cases like Applause and Crosstalk mentioned above.
- barbs 2y agoI always thought the fancy DOS icon meant the program was broken - it looked sort of like a sinking ship to me.
- calrain 2y agoI used these all the time when rolling out Windows 3.1 and 3.11 for thousands of computers back in the early 90's. You would just pick any icon that seemed relevant, with a focus on not choosing the same icon for two different applications. Computer GUI's were so new then that people didn't really care if the icon was 100% correct or not. Sometimes for big applications I would draw up an icon and then use it, but mainly try to stay on moricons.dll or any dll's that came with the application that might contain icons.
- qingcharles 2y agoThis. You just needed something and we were starved for icons with the default install, so I would just dig around to find an icon that half-way matched what the application (never "app" then) was.
- torben-friis 2y agoI find it funny that I use adaptive icons on android (the ones that switch color according to the OS color scheme) and I override non adaptive app icons the exact same way. Local public transport app? Choose something resembling a bus, train or similar. Banking app? Pile of money or bill or whatever. Just as long as two apps don’t end up with the same icon it’s all fine. What is old is new I guess.
- Dwedit 2y agoI wonder how many people out there actually created an icon for Kid Pix and used the icon from Moricons.dll? I was one of those people.
- sweeter 2y agoDid they store the icons as byte arrays?
- filchermcurr 2y agoMan, things had character back then. Everything is so flat and boring now. More importantly, though, Raymond Chen is an absolute treasure. I love these posts.
- dustractor 2y agoHarvard Graphics! That's where it all started for me.