8 ms·
How the US built 5k ships in WWII
- bilekas 2y ago[flagged]
- bigyabai 2y agoThis the same Navy that can't keep an F/A-18 tethered to the deck?
- vmh1928 2y agoThe first one went over during evasive maneuvers while it was being moved by a tractor. So it wasn't tied down and the people on the ship can't schedule plane movements around missile and drone attacks. That the ship had to take evasive maneuvers tells us a missile or drone got close enough to be a danger, not a good situation. The second plane went over when its hook missed the wire while landing. It happens. Also there was a plane shot down by a guided missile cruiser. Luckily in all cases the crew (including the guys moving the plane,) survived. The Navy in that part of the world has been operating at a war tempo for quite a while. It's extremely dangerous at all times.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoCitations in my comment below [1] that the Navy is operating ~14k sailors short of what is needed to operate safely, per the GAO. Assuming structural demographics and ongoing forward looking labor shortages, we can predict with significant confidence that the situation will only degrade further, as young labor has superior options for both operations and shipbuilding [2] [3]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43921352 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43921352 ("As of late last year, the Navy was lacking nearly 14,000 enlisted sailors to keep its aircraft carriers, surface ships and attack submarines properly manned, according to the GAO. The watchdog also found that aircraft carriers, cruisers and amphibious assault ships did not have enough enlisted sailors assigned to them to meet requirements for safe operations as laid out by the Navy Manpower Analysis Center.") [2] The High-School Juniors With $70,000-a-Year Job Offers - https://www.wsj.com/lifestyle/careers/skilled-trades-high-school-recruitment-fd9f8257 https://www.wsj.com/lifestyle/careers/skilled-trades-high-sc... - May 7, 2025 [3] Amid shortage, Navy recruiting program struggles to keep half first-year shipbuilders: Official - https://breakingdefense.com/2025/03/amid-shortage-navy-recruiting-program-struggles-to-keep-half-first-year-shipbuilders-official/ https://breakingdefense.com/2025/03/amid-shortage-navy-recru... - March 26, 2025 ("Difficulties in competing with the service industry wages in particular is a common complaint among shipbuilding executives. “It used to be that there was a big gap between manufacturing wages and other wages in any other industry,” Ingalls’ Shipbuilding President Kari Wilkinson told Breaking Defense in August. “Now you’ve got service industry wages — you can go down and be an attendant at Buc-ees for the same as an entry wage at a shipyard.”)
- Ecgberht 2y agoMissing all 4 wires does happen now and then but it very very rarely results in the plane ending up in the water. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolter_(aeronautics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolter_(aeronautics)
- bilekas 2y agoThere are examples I'm sure of them messing up, but anyone who's tried to mess with them.. Doesn't end well. I'm an EU appreciator.
- bilekas 2y ago> This the same Navy that can't keep an F/A-18 tethered to the deck? They'll mess up and still find a way to make it your problem :)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jaqalopes 2y agoA friend and I were at the WW2 museum in New Orleans a couple years ago and he said something that really stuck with me. Amazed at an exhibit on wartime manufacturing, he turned to me and said, "This is so unbelievable to me. To think what we accomplished when everyone in the country was pulling in the same direction. There's no way that could happen anymore." I hardly want to glorify warfare, but he has a point. As a young person in our chaotic and ambiguous present day looking back into the haze of the past, there really is something incredibly romantic about the era of war mobilization. Ordinary people had a purpose simply assigned to them, and if nothing else I think it's still the case that people in all eras crave purpose.
- cadamsdotcom 2y agoYep, purpose. Societies today have immense latent potential. So many people are doing bullshit jobs that tick things over, sitting there wishing to be put to use for some intrinsically motivating purpose. An existential threat - war - is a well known way to bring that out. But war is too destructive for modern tastes. We've seen developing countries get great results by government directing private industry in stronger ways than we're used to in the West. For example China's regularly published national development priorities for the next 5 years. If you hew to these you'll be helped in various ways. Singapore's and South Korea's rises to global powers were helped along by government getting everyone to row in the same direction - among other things, I'm greatly simplifying. But to focus on this one idea, I hope you can agree that providing purpose through top-down leadership is a great way to harness societies' latent potential and mobilize in a given direction.. Rudderless, laissez-faire governance got the US a surprisingly long way. But we are seeing the resultant directionlessness leave leaders unable to agree on whether to tear up what's been built, leave it in place, or go some completely random direction. It's not the ships that were built, it's what they represented. That was what got them built.
- southernplaces7 2y agoThe latent authoritarianism in in opinions like yours makes it easier to understand why authoritarians keep rising to the top of different societies, so they can destroy lives, squander wealth and crush individual peoples' own perfectly productive capacities for finding their own cooperative purposes in life.
- kristianp 2y agoOther things built quickly: https://patrickcollison.com/fast https://patrickcollison.com/fast I'm surprised this isn't on the list.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoCharles Paxton's Crystal Palace from the 1851 Great Exhibition belongs on the list too. Designed in 1 month, opened less than 10 months later, including a redesign to accommodate some trees instead of cutting them down. 3 times the size of St Paul's cathedral. Taken down and reassembled into a different building after the fair. Using entirely new technology including modular prefab cast-iron-and-glass-pane construction, interchangeable fasteners, and flush toilets.
- bkjelden 2y agoOne of the shipyards discussed in the article, Marinship, is on Patrick's list.
- hyruo 2y agoRadical goals, obedient workers, a peaceful environment on the continental, and the necessary industrialization capabilities all worked together to make this seemingly great thing happen.
- jonstewart 2y agoHigh unemployment going into it, too.
- pmontra 2y agoThat's not important. In times of war the government can draft people and send them wherever it needs. What might be more difficult to scale up is steel production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_steel_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_steel_pro... Chips too, but old style boats without computers still float and maybe are even easier to build.
- jonstewart 2y agoIt -is- important, for economic reasons. When you go to war with a tight labor market, you make the economy worse. George HW Bush learned this lesson the hard way.
- pmontra 2y agoDid he draft people and sent them to fight, like in WW2 or the Vietnam war? I believe he didn't but I never lived in the USA so I might be wrong. At one extreme a government can draft all the population into the military and send most of them to factories and farms. When the war is over, restart the civilian economy. A big mess for sure. At the other extreme, the war is fought with contractors and volunteers and military factories have to compete with the civilian economy for workers, by raising salaries. This is what is happening in Russia AFAIK. They seem to be badly understaffed but even there the government must be careful if people become too unsatisfied. So ultimately it's not economic reasons, is about winning the next election or staying alive.
- jamestimmins 2y agoIf you're interested in the US war build up in general, Freedom's Forge is an excellent read.
- jonstewart 2y agoWhen I first read, years ago, about how many aircraft carriers the US Navy had during WW2, I was gobsmacked. But then I read how most of them were escort carriers, slow converted merchant ships with just a few planes. The US military currently has a lot of exquisite platforms; what it [mostly] lacks today is mass from cheaper systems. It’d be good if we built more submarines, faster…
- vmh1928 2y agoWe are dependent on a relatively small number of complex weapons systems. In a high intensity conflict with a peer like China, say, we could expect to loose a significant number of our big ticket items within a few days. It's a big mistake that we don't have a swarm of cheap systems mentality but I suppose that doesn't benefit the MIC so it's a no go. We'll pay for it some day.
- arrobbiato 2y agoThis is the problem that the Pentagon’s Replicator Initiative is trying to solve.[1] However, the initiative (while well funded) only began less than two years ago. As MacArthur once said, every failure in war comes down to two words: “Too late.” We shall see. [1] https://www.diu.mil/replicator https://www.diu.mil/replicator
- jonstewart 2y agoIt’s more nuanced, though. The choices made for the types of exquisite vs mass must be correct, and the mix of features of each system. With the WW2 aircraft carriers, a high number of the escort carriers were lost—they were slow and easily sunk. So it’s not clear they were a good allocation of resources. Light carriers—smaller and less well-armored than fleet carriers, but about as fast—did considerably better. The GLSDB in Ukraine looked like it would turn the tide on paper—relatively cheap precision warheads with a huge stock of ammo which could outrange artillery and hit supply lines. But they’ve been a nonentity because of Russia’s electronic warfare capabilities. It’s similar with drones—Ukraine’s FPV drones stopped being effective due to EW, but then they switched to fiber optic cable and that’s made an enormous difference. Aircraft carriers today are sitting ducks. The more we make, the more we’d lose.
- markus_zhang 2y agoBack then the US was the No. manufacturimg power, probably equals Britain and Germany combined and more.
- maxglute 2y agoSome #s. 39-45: - US, pop 130m, 40m Gross Tons. ~0.05m GT/m 2023: - JP, 125m, 10m GT, ~0.08m GT/m (kind of in decline) - SKR, 51m, 18m GT, ~0.35m GT/m (increasing in value) - PRC, 1400m, 33 GT, ~0.02m GT/m (increasing++ in GT and value) If modern US was serious as efficient as JP or SKR, it can do 30-120m GT per year. Meanwhile PRC casually building about entire 6 year US WW2 ship building program per year (2024 puts it close to 37m GT). But it's not out of question for US to be competitive in a few generations. But also kind of lulz that SKR peacetime ship building is like 7x more efficient than US during WW2.
- chii 2y ago> But it's not out of question for US to be competitive in a few generations. i think it is - as in, if the need ever arises in a war, the loss would be far sooner than the time required for "competitiveness". That is, of course, this new war is going to play out the same as the last one. But as with all history, it only rhymes.
- maxglute 2y agoYes, IMO why DoD wanks about replicator and drone hellscape, when PRC doing the same thing. Everyone is trying to sink each others entire surface fleet... but those with industrial base (even if degraded) can reconstitute faster, i.e. PRC navy is "only" 3m GTs... about 1 month of current production, 2 months for all of USN @4.5m GT (yes 9 women can't make a baby in 1 month), but just to give scale of how "small" modern navies, including USN, are relative to modern shipbuilding. I also doubt US built ships will ever be globally commercially competitive vs east asian builders (or whoever comes next), but the point is modern ship building has gotten efficient, and it's feasible for US to reshore enough ship building for domestic needs. I think for American's sake, it's illustrative to stop nostalgical pine for US WW2 ship building prowess, because it's really meagre compared to modern ship building scale. Also be aware that if US WW2 shipping buildig dial was set to 10, PRC set the dial to not just 11, but 50. The consolation is it's very feasible for US to move dial from current 2 back to 10, perhaps even 20. And for US strategic interests (and ego) that's probably enough.
- treebeard901 2y agoThe U.S. seems to think it can out manufacture a country like China, or another peer competitor, during a potential war. This does not seem to be the case anymore... That level of American wartime manufacturing just is not possible anymore. Maybe robotics and AI can be combined to close the gap... Its just that all competitors will be able to do that too. Then consider that much of the U.S. aligned shipbuilding happens in places like South Korea. There is no guarantee the U.S. will be able to purchase ships from South Korea during a war in Asia. Then again, surface ships are quickly becoming obsolete with drones and hypersonic missiles. If the U.S. wants to get ahead, they need to build submarine drone carriers as quickly as possible.
- Alex_001 2y agoKinda agree with what you said. With the efficiency of china and the people working like soldiers, they can easily build an army of weapon in no time. But still in hope that we see less war in future.
- Incipient 2y agoI think the overwhelming Chinese population is a big factor that would prevent anyone out-manufacturing them. I don't really have immense faith in the US leaders any more (as an outsider), but surely none of them genuinely believe the US can out-manufacture China?
- Alex_001 2y agoOverpopulation in China has contributed to high job competition, leaving many people unemployed or underemployed. As a result, many are now willing to work long hours for lower wages just to make ends meet. Culturally, China places a strong emphasis on community and collective effort, valuing group success over individual recognition. This mindset, combined with a deep focus on efficiency, has been a key driver behind China’s success in manufacturing. Let's see if there's anyone else that can give us more insight from the view of US.
- 2y ago
- renewiltord 2y agoFortunately, these days with environmental law and historical protection the horrors of these shipyards will never again return. Give thanks. Our children won't have to suffer its results.
- Animats 2y agoThe interesting claim in the article is that US ship production was less efficient in terms of man-hours as quantity went up. That's unexpected.
- lurk2 2y agoCould be economies of scale reaching a point of diminishing returns.
- bruckie 2y agoIt seems plausible that as you add more people to the project, the people added later have fewer skills or less interest compared to the ones who are more engaged ones who joined earlier.
- creshal 2y agoEarly war designs also had dangerous flaws that had to be corrected, which slowed down construction of subsequent ships, but made them less likely to spontaneously break apart. Between that and muss less skilled, much less experienced labour producing ships in newly constructed shipyards with teething issues that were also in less ideal locations... something had to give, and taking a bit longer was the least bad option.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoYou have to think not having access to healthy 18+ year old men was an impact to the super physical jobs as well.
- creshal 2y agoThe US "solved" that particular problem by keeping its army much smaller than it could've been, precisely to free up more healthy 18 year olds for factory jobs. Between the British Empire, the various Chinese governments and Soviet Union, the Allies had plenty of manpower, but all that was meaningless without US munitions, US equipment, US food, and US ships to get them where they were needed.
- ilaksh 2y agoThe context is that WWIII is basically a foregone conclusion? If there is a hot war between the US and China, that proves that humans aren't fit to control the planet. The only way this makes sense for people is if they are racists deep down and think that humans should compete like ant colonies. Warfare is a total failure of management and society. The human zoos of the future are not going to allow warfare or build up to it. We have instantaneous global communication and translation.
- yesco 2y agoYou have it backwards, weakness encourages conflict, we get WWIII when there is a belief that the gains will outweigh the losses. Our modern peace is not from enlightenment but because war became too destructive. Peace should never be assumed.
- TomMasz 2y agoI remember as a kid seeing the ghost fleet of Liberty Ships in the Hudson River near NYC. They gradually disappeared, with the last of them sold off in the early 70s. You could even buy parts like hatch covers from the ships in antique stores for a while until the supply dried up. It didn't mean much to me but certainly did for my parents' generation.