8 ms·
Why I stopped angel investing after 15 years, and what I'm doing instead
- barbazoo 2y agoMight as well use the money to support your local shelter, less overhead and it actually does something good for a change.
- fsckboy 2y agoi understand your true and noble motivation, but the law of incentives is an iron law, and it tells us your subsidy will incentivize the burgeoning industry that demands more shelters
- barbazoo 2y agoThey often enable people their way to recovery. Individuals are better off because of them. Do you have a source for your claim that more shelters cause more use of shelters which is what I think you’re saying right?
- procaryote 2y agoI worry about the things an investor-run shelter would try to make their investment profitable
- barry-cotter 2y agoGiving money to your local homeless shelter encourages homeless people to move near you (see San Francisco). Making a lot of risky investments in businesses encourages people to start new businesses. One of these has positive second order effects on economic growth.
- gammarator 2y agoThe vast majority of homeless people in the Bay Area are from the Bay Area. https://www.spur.org/publications/urbanist-article/2017-10-23/homelessness-bay-area https://www.spur.org/publications/urbanist-article/2017-10-2... There is lots of homelessness because housing is expensive. https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/everything-you-think-you-know-about https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/everything-you-think-you-know-...
- investa 2y agoNeither helps homelessness. Building more affordable homes is the solution. Which also has 2nd order effects.
- barbazoo 2y agoPeople that need help are going to where the help is, shocking /s
- tananaev 2y agoI think there's just too much money chasing too few good businesses. Early days of tech boom with lots of opportunities is over. Any promising startups nowadays get crazy valuation very quickly, so stop making financial sense to invest in.
- georgeburdell 2y agoIf it’s a bad time to invest, would it be a good time to be on the other side of the table?
- xpe 2y agoHow would you test this claim relative to alternative hypotheses such as: 1. Investors choosing poorly 2. Investors not managing relationships well after they invest. Maybe we can open up the discussion to involve the other design decisions that go into how funders structure deals and involvement.
- w10-1 2y agoTwo vaguely confirming data sources: - Other investment assets have seen higher inflation rates in the US in the last decade - Buffet et al are holding cash, ostensibly for lack of qualified opportunities But it would be interesting to compare with China, Europe, LatAm...
- propter_hoc 2y agoWith much love for my angel investors, angel investing is absolutely a mug's game. If the company doesn't get off the ground (vast majority of investments) you lose all your money. If the company does get off the ground, you are the lowest on the pref stack, and you have no ability to follow on to protect your position. You're not a contributing employee or meaningful future source of capital so your piece of the pie is just dead weight on the cap table. This means every single subsequent investor (and the founders, if they care more about money than their relationship with you) has an incentive to cram you down. So net net the chances of success from passive angel investing are only slightly better than playing the lottery. Best approach would be to make very few investments, where you're able to build a special relationship with the founder, and ideally get a board seat to defend your stake. === Edit - to be clear, I don't think startups should be giving board seats to angel investors. It does happen in exceptional cases where the angel is uniquely valuable to the company, and those are the cases where the angel can defend themselves. But they are rare, which is why it's mainly a bad game to play.
- bilsbie 2y agoIs it not reasonable to ask for a seat in every investment?
- codezero 2y agoVery few of the startups I’ve worked for have given board seats before Series B.
- BlandDuck 2y agoToo many investors, too few seats
- bix6 2y agoA board seat? Absolutely not, you’re a minor investor. A pro rata opportunity? Maybe but why wrangle 50 angels when you can have 2 firms cover it?
- 2y ago
- kcatskcolbdi 2y ago"I stopped angel investing because I was losing too much money"
- danielmarkbruce 2y ago100% this. Every type of investing should be stopped and is a waste of time and money if you are losing. Talk to the few people who angel invested in google and facebook. They'll tell a different story. From their private jet.
- htrp 2y agohow many ppl were angels in fb/googl/tsla?
- danielmarkbruce 2y agoHardly any. Finding and investing in brand new businesses trying to quickly grow to hundreds of millions in revenue on reasonable terms in a highly competitive world is insanely difficult...Why would it not be? It cannot be any other way.
- varelse 2y ago[dead]
- YesBox 2y ago>Angel investors also face the longest time horizon for liquidity of any investor. Private equity aims for 3-5 year returns, and VCs typically run 7-10 year fund cycles, but angels usually wait 10+ years for exits. This means angels aren’t just taking company-specific risk, but also the risk of facing more macroeconomic cycles. >Think about all that's happened since 2009 when I started: multiple presidential administrations, a global pandemic, zero interest rates, and now high inflation and higher interest rates. My investments have had to withstand all of these shifts, and many didn't make it through. Really interesting stuff (for me, as an outsider). Can anyone comment if VCs are looking for shorter fund cycles or are the macro economic shifts what's capping it at 10 years? I once read one reason why startups take so long to IPO is so private investments can benefit longer from the growth
- bix6 2y agoMy LPs want liquidity now, always. 2021 was hot and it’s been relatively quiet since. Mega funds are keeping companies private longer. Capital is tied up which hurts emerging managers trying to raise. My LPs want returns in 6 years which only works if everything goes perfectly which almost never happens; that’s how long $100M+ rev takes if you triple yearly. IPO requires more rev than before, everything’s larger.
- LunaSea 2y agoWould smaller ventures not be an option? Say investing 500k$ and selling for 10M roughly 5 or 6 years later? I would imagine that building these smaller companies looking for smaller exists would be easier and more predictable.
- bix6 2y agoThat’s not necessarily venture returns so LPs might not be interested. Selling secondaries is also a pain as you generally have to pay fees and sell at a discount.
- bcantrill 2y agoIt would be helpful to run out the math on the $500K investment: what's the post-money on that investment when it was made? How much capital did this mythical sold-for-$10M in 5-or-6 years company raise? (Or did it survive for a half decade on a total investment of $500K?) What was the headcount and the revenue and the burn? (And to whom does it sell for $10M?) Assuming that it wasn't a wipeout, you'll quickly find that the math doesn't... math: if you have somehow conjured a successful outcome in your mind, what you likely have is not a venture-scale business.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bix6 2y agoSAFEs have also caused so many issues. They’re often poorly priced and can lead to legal issues or frustrations.
- pge 2y agoI feel like this is not talked about enough. SAFEs are not the trouble-free investment vehicle that many people seem to think they are.
- bcantrill 2y agoAbsolutely. The reality is that SAFEs are often used to price a company, even though the pricing conundrum is exactly what they are trying to solve! If you want the reveal on SAFEs, raise them uncapped (with a discount, of course!) and watch how many people tell you that they can't possibly do that. (Not everyone, though -- deeply appreciate those investors who are willing to invest on uncapped discounted SAFEs!)
- bix6 2y agoWhat’s your rationale for uncapped SAFEs? I don’t think they are a good deal for investors.
- shawabawa3 2y agoHer follow-up with stats on her investments: https://substack.com/@halletecco/note/c-113855500 https://substack.com/@halletecco/note/c-113855500 tl;dr: returned $0.31 on every dollar invested, albeit with a bunch of ongoing investments that may still pay off (but are unlikely to get her even on the investments let alone a profit)
- bix6 2y agoOuch. Wish we could see the companies list, or at least sectors.
- ryanmerket 2y agoA few here: https://www.crunchbase.com/person/halle-tecco https://www.crunchbase.com/person/halle-tecco
- thom 2y agoDo US angels get tax breaks on these investments? The floor in the UK is basically £0.70 on the pound.
- yieldcrv 2y agoyes, if you buy shares in the primary market (directly from the issuing company) there are tax free capital gains, up to a point. which can be gamed to be infinite. its called QSBS
- ryanmerket 2y agothe blog post could have been a lot shorter: "I quit angel investing because I'm not very good at it."
- itbeho 2y agoPer her linkedin: She's currently an adjunct professor at Columbia teaching a class on "Investing in Digital Health Startups". https://www.linkedin.com/in/halletecco/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/halletecco/
- turnsout 2y agoIn a tale as old as time, the mega-rich get richer. It used to be that early stage VCs and angels could see tremendous upside for taking an early risk. It’s utterly unsurprising that giant VCs have found a way to cram them down once the startup is successful and realize all the upside. Between this and giant PE coming downmarket, we should all just bootstrap and say “f off” to outside capital. With AI coding models, you don’t need that money to build anyway.
- kilroy123 2y agoI agree. Bootstrapping is best if possible.
- fsckboy 2y ago>In a tale as old as time, the mega-rich get richer no, they don't. what is mega-rich keeps price inflating, but who is mega-rich are always new names. if you are young, afauk Brin and Page have always been mega-rich, but just a little older and you remember when nobody knew who they were, nor had anybody heard of Zuck, or Musk, etc. and Jobs was a washed up has-been
- pgustafs 2y agoit's called "angel" investing because it's only one step removed from charity
- ryanmerket 2y agomy charity donations are capped with the IRS. But my cap gains (and losses) live forever.
- astrange 2y agoAlmost everyone's charity donations are worth zero with the IRS since everyone takes the standard deduction now.
- helixfelix 2y agoYour comment made me realize what a bubble of privilege I live in. I raised my eyebrow at "everyone takes" standard deduction. How is that possible with home prices and interest rates? Even a modest 300-400k house at 5-6% interest, property taxes, local sales tax deductions and minimum charity would exceed the standard deduction. Where I live good luck finding anything more than a condo for less than a million. Turns out 90% take standard deduction. This is another way to track the extreme "wealth" gap emerging. Only the wealthy itemize.
- ip26 2y agoIt’s more of a reality when home prices are over a million, or in a state with high property taxes. Be married, live in a state with low property taxes, buy a house for 700k… and you’re taking the standard.
- alabastervlog 2y agoWe have a house more expensive than that, an interest rate around the top of that range, live in a state with somewhat high property taxes, and had at least $4k in health care spending on top of insurance premiums (no big problems, that's just what a handful of minor kid-related issues in a year costs in the US) and still wouldn't have done better itemizing. We took the standard for 2024. We're ~92nd percentile for household income.
- yieldcrv 2y ago[flagged]
- rvz 2y agoAngel investor in the ZIRP era, quitting after a 10+ year bull market and never experiencing a market correction or downturn since 2008. Maybe this one was just unlucky, lost money on the way and moved on.
- aabaker99 2y ago> Four others that raised money but with painful recapitalizations that effectively wiped out early shareholders Does someone have a recommendation on reading that goes deeper on this point? What enables later investors to do this? What can early investors do to protect their investment?
- Centigonal 2y agoThere are a few different ways this can happen. It has to do with seniority of liquidation preferences -- basically, if you recap or you exit for less than your highest valuation, who gets paid first? This blog post is a pretty great summary of what can happen: https://heidiroizen.tumblr.com/post/118473647305/how-to-build-a-unicorn-from-scratch-and-walk https://heidiroizen.tumblr.com/post/118473647305/how-to-buil...
- robocat 2y agoRead the other article in the series that has more depth on this: https://www.halletecco.com/blog/angel-investing-part-iii#:~:text=In%20addition%20to%20dilution https://www.halletecco.com/blog/angel-investing-part-iii#:~:...
- skeeter2020 2y ago>> One company needs you to help close a key hire >> Another is raising a bridge round and wants your input on the deck >> A third is struggling with a co-founder conflict and needs advice >> An investor calls asking you to vouch for a portfolio company they’re considering backing This is the investor's perspective, but note all of these things consume a HUGE amount of time & energy from the founder(s) as well, and do nothing towards advancing your product or company. Good reminder how distracting outside funding can be - and this is AFTER you've gotten at least an angel round!
- _7acn 2y agoIn my opinion, all companies that have some kind of "investor" always end up the same way: eventually, a paid sociopath is installed as CEO whose only goal is profit maximization. If the CEO were someone who valued noble ideals or principles above profit, the investors would quickly replace them with a more "optimal" person.
- Joel_Mckay 2y agoYour perspective is a common myth, as in business ones reputation and integrity ultimately determine the formalized credibility of your firm. This is true with consumers, supply chains, customs bond subprograms, and your partners. i.e. people can only lie, cheat, and steal from people for a finite amount of time. It ultimately leads to competitive disadvantage, and repercussions. In general many VC/Angle "investors" were just predatory loan scams, that could ultimately destroy the founders firm. Warning signs often include proposals to table personal assets, share dilution scams, equity siphon holes, and stock market IPO legal cons. Using debt to grow is generally a bad long-term strategy, and positive cash flow is always king at any scale. If the firm can't make sales, than growth is just a fools errand. In my opinion, the Zuckerberg story ruined a generation of business people. =3
- dragonwriter 2y ago> i.e. people can only lie, cheat, and steal from people for a finite amount of time. It ultimately leads to competitive disadvantage, and repercussions. That’s why you use you initial limited window to establish conditions where you don't need to compete, remembering competitive disadvantage a non-concern.
- Joel_Mckay 2y agoI am unsure that a debt-laden firm with half-baked IP and zero revenue is much of a prize for bandits. lol I have seen it happen, but usually irrational "winners" also evidentially become losers in a year or two. I think it is related to folks that compulsively gamble on other peoples ignorance, and eventually end up losing in court. It is theoretically not impossible to "win" as a bandit, but the collateral financial damage to the people around you would be significant. Thus, the mean time before collapse would be proportional to the specified credit. Best of luck =3 "The Rules for Rulers" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs
- Havoc 2y ago>The post-ZIRP era (2023-2024) created headwinds Post ZIRP is arguable the more normal situation, in which case one really has to ask...was it ever real
- jmyeet 2y ago> Private equity aims for 3-5 year returns I honestly don't understand how private equity makes money at all. The playbook is: 1. Borrow a ton of money and buy a company on an LBO 2. Load up the company with debt, often complicated, exploding debt, to repay the original loan. Possibly sell off assets like real estate to pay off the original loan; and 3. Here's the kicker: sell off the company for a profit. But we've seen time and time again that PE is a death sentence. Toys R Us, Red Lobster, numerous others. The company seemingly always explodes under the debt after the original snake oil salesman have cashed out. But my point is: who keeps falling for this and buying a PE hollowed out husk?
- dehrmann 2y agoYou've seen publicized examples (Toys R Us) where it played out like that, but that narrative doesn't generally pass the smell test–no counterparty would keep making bad loans. There are cases where companies are mismanaged, their value is as a real estate holding company, etc. and PE improves operations and creates a more investable business. The other thing is that like VC, PE has become saturated, so the good opportunities just aren't there anymore.
- bogtog 2y agoI've also wondered how banks get convinced to offer companies the debt in these LBOs. The only explanation I see is that failures (Toys R Us, etc.) become well-known while successful LBOs and sales of companies with long-term profitability are quiet
- kasey_junk 2y agoYou are describing only 1 kind of private equity and only 1 subclass of that. But there are lots of well publicized lbo success stories as well. Hilton, Safeway, Dell, Nabisco. The list goes on.
- cloudbonsai 2y ago> Hilton, Safeway, Dell, Nabisco. The list goes on. For what it's worth, KKR's takeover of RJR Nabisco was actually a flop. KKR bought the company in 1988, and then spent 15+ years trying painfully to exit the position. It is widely believed that it was the major reason why their 1987 vintage turned out to be disappointing.
- mattlondon 2y agoIf at one point your shares are worth 1% of the company (the 1M of 100M startup example), how does that get diluted to nothing on acquisition? I thought the whole point of the early stage investments were you were the first people to get the payout, not basically the last/never?
- ww520 2y agoSold at a fire sale.
- mattlondon 2y agoPrecisely - it was sold so where did your 1% go at that sale?
- ww520 2y agoShe got 1% of the pre-firesale valuation. Fire sale happened. Preferred liquidation of the later round investors probably took most of the sale's proceed, and she got nothing, along with all the founders and employees. It had happened to me a number of times, and I have been disillusioned a long time ago.
- aurareturn 2y agoBecause there are preferred shares common shares. Large VCs or loans will demand preferred shares. They get cashed out first in any exit. What's left could be nothing for common share holders. This has happened plenty of times where a startup in a dire situation had to sell itself or raise a down round with poor terms to survive and the earlier investors got wiped out.
- RainyDayTmrw 2y agoFor "regular" dilution, the way it works is that there's a pre-money and post-money valuation. If a company is worth 1M pre-money, and an investor puts in 1M, then the company is worth 2M post-money. Someone who owned 1% before (effectively 10k of the pre-money) now owns 0.5% (effectively 10k of the post-money). Ostensibly, their stake should be worth exactly the same before and after the deal, a smaller slice of a bigger pie. In practice, there's various incentives to inflate valuations, such that the early investor's slice is getting smaller faster than the pie is getting bigger. Furthermore, investors tend to demand extra terms on top. The big one here is called liquidation preference, which is a clause that says, approximately, if/when this company is sold, this investor gets the first X amount of it, usually corresponding to some multiplier of their investment amount. Later rounds will ask to win out in preference, effectively creating a stack of liquidation preferences. In practice, liquidation preferences can often add up to so much that a moderately-successful sale goes entirely to preferred shareholders, and common shareholders see nothing. Perhaps the dealmakers put in a bit of a sweetener for the founders and/or current executives to grease the deal. Your average employee and angel or seed investors certainly see nothing in this deal.
- lbotos 2y agoThose with angel experience: Do angels not get terms to "cash out" in secondaries/later rounds? I was under the impression that some angels effectively acted as bridge financing to get to later rounds (in this case A/B/C) and to then exit if they wanted to?
- kirubakaran 2y agoWhile that can always be arranged if all the parties agree, it would be a bad idea for the founders to give the angels the option to cash out like that, as the fact that they're choosing to cash out will tank all further investments. VCs will wonder "What do they know that I don't?" Always consider signaling risk. This can be avoided by always cashing out, I guess. But it's bad for angels to always cash out, as letting it ride on the unicorns is the only way to make meaningful returns, if any. Always consider power law.
- RainyDayTmrw 2y agoI've heard variations on this sentiment repeated a lot. The exact message varies, but it's usually some variation of: early investors always lose, small investors always lose, and/or non-preferred shareholders always lose. I've seen and lived a small number of personal anecdotes that seem to back this up, and I'd like to better understand what underlying pathology causes this. I understand that early investors are taking the most risk, and clearly there's a lot of downside. But what prevents them from being able to realize or capture the upside? I've heard a theory, a few different times now, that bigger, later investors effectively collude (descriptive term, not value judgment) with founders to squeeze out early founders and employees (common shareholders) via unfair terms, such as excessive dilution (accepting too low a valuation for larger investment), excessive liquidation preferences (2x or more), etc., and then topping the founders up via side deals. I've heard that, by virtue of squeezing out passive participants, they're able to offer more to the founders, and that incentivizes the founders to take their deal over other alternatives. Does anyone know more specifics about how this happens? In particular, how is this not a breach of fiduciary duty to passive participants? It's definitely possible to write anti-dilution clauses, etc. But, I've heard that more or less no one writes them, and more importantly no one accepts them. If this is a pretty well-known game, why haven't countermeasures become popular? For my personal anecdote, I was once an early engineer - the first hire after their Series A - at a small startup that never found product-market fit. The economy was bad, and they were running out of money, and they took - as I understood it - a dubious Series B led by a dubious investor. The founders were very vague about the terms of the round. In particular, the founders revealed that the investors took liquidation preference, that it was greater than 1x, but absolutely refused to say how much. That always left a bad taste in my mouth. When I left, I didn't exercise my options. In the end, the company floundered, and is a zombie to this day. In that regard, I suppose that the particulars of that round don't really matter - none of us were seeing anything regardless. I'd really appreciate if anyone closer to the money part of this industry could weigh in.
- danielmarkbruce 2y agoIt's people who lose, which is most, complaining about structural issues when actually they just suck at investing. It's a competitive game, they lost.
- bayarearefugee 2y ago> Just since 2023, I have had: > One company that raised over $100M, with my shares at one point valued at over $1M on paper, acquired in a fire sale that returned zero to early investors > Two others that were also “acquired” with some fanfare in the media, but returned nothing to early investors > Four companies shut down after being unable to get to profitability or fundraise > Four others that raised money but with painful recapitalizations that effectively wiped out early shareholders TL;DR - Angel investing became too much like being an early employee at a startup always was, except it was actual money being lost instead of sweat equity.
- mnoronha 2y agoright -- much of the reasoning is also an argument against being an early employee. the main difference is the employee probably has more leverage against being diluted in later rounds.
- bombcar 2y ago“Early employee” used to mean 90% of boring tech job salary + some gambling options. Now it’s often 40% or lower of a tech salary and some gambling options
- dhruvrrp 2y agoIsn't it exactly the opposite? It used to be low salary + gambling, but now that most people know how easy it is to screw early employees, folks ask for high(er) salary + gambling
- asdsadasdasd123 2y ago> Four others that raised money but with painful recapitalizations that effectively wiped out early shareholders I don't get how this kind of stuff happens.
- klntsky 2y agoA little something is better than nothing, so the board can dilute if a shutdown is on the horizon.
- alain94040 2y agoRemember those startup pivots we used to make fun of on HN? When a pivot happens, it often means the initial idea ran its course, the startup is about to shut down because it's running out of money. However, the team seems to work reasonably well together, at least they get along and seem to have a decent balance of engineers and business people. A new idea comes along, some investors could be interested. But the condition for the investment is to reset the cap table and wipe out the previous investors. From the new investor's point of view, it makes sense: for all practical purposes, this is a brand new startup. From the founders' point of view, they don't really have a choice.
- jxjnskkzxxhx 2y agoThanks for that. If you don't mind a follow up: how is it legal that some corporate restructuring applies differently do different investors, e.g. founders Vs angel? Like if I own 90% and you own 10% can I just go "I've decided that you own 0% now"?
- graycat 2y agoTry to make some sense out of the OP. Start with some examples: Google: As I recall, two guys in a garage, literally, until they had a good start on a good business, offered to sell out for $1 million. Amazon: Bezos and a few programmers. FedEx: I was there early on and saw a lot of stuff about the BOD (board of directors), Founder-CEO, executives, General Dynamics, visitors from big NYC banks, funding of the airplanes, deals with Memphis to get space on/near the airport, the worker bees, etc. Was close to the action, office next to the Founder--CEO F. Smith, reported to a Senior VP with office across the hall but really reported just to Smith, was close to the BOD ("you just keep doing what you are doing until someone tells you to stop"), twice in work for the BOD enabled crucial investment and literally saved the company, etc. Plenty of Fish: One guy, three old Dell servers, Microsoft's .NET with ASP.NET and ADO.NET, on-line romantic introduction site, sold out for $575 million. Compared with Plenty of Fish, how Google started, and the arithmetic in the post, a summary: For the invested money: (a) Too many big, powerful chiefs, and not enough working indians. (b) Big hats, too few cattle. Too much overhead for the work done, e.g., per line of code written and running. So, one approach: Start cheap, dirt cheap. Sole, solo founder. Only an LLC and with lawyers and accountants like, say, a grass mowing business -- LITERALLY. Founder lives cheap, say, in an area with low cost of living, in a used manufactured house, that is also the office, old used car. Take advantage of the still exploding Internet and cheap, powerful tower case computers (assembled from parts) for development and servers, $60/month 1 Gbps Internet connection, etc. Find a market need can meet with this dirt cheap approach and can get to profitibility with rapidly growing revenue. So, leave out the time, cost, botheration of: Investors, lawyers, accountants, rented high quality offices, investor meetings, Board meetings, a management tree, manager meetings, reports to investors and the BOD, 10+ employees with all the expenses, legalities, lots of plane travel, employee stock plans, vesting, etc. For a while, tried to raise funding; time wasted. Lesson: In simple terms, most VCs won't look at a business idea or technology before there is rapidly growing revenue. Then nearly all the VC money is used for the lawyers, other overhead, etc. Comparison: (A) Dirt cheap: Invest $50-K a year. (B) Angel, VC, private equity approach: $10+ million a year. Big difference. Problem: Investors need the lawyers, accountants, and other overhead so go for approach (B) where %10- of the money goes for the real work of getting the business going. Back to work!
- Mbwagava 2y agoNb i actually really resent substack for sending me to the app. No; I don't want to pollute my history with this post, I just want to read it.
- astrange 2y agoThe app makes the experience worse because you can only have one article open at a time, instead of using browser tabs.
- crsv 2y agoIt’s hard for me to respond to these kinds of posts with anything other than a dismissive sentiment along the lines of “grats on being rich and playing your rich people sport. I’m sorry you don’t like your rich people sport anymore. Hope your next rich people sport is fun for you.”
- auggierose 2y agoYou got it right, this post is directed at other rich(er) people.
- xpe 2y agoI get your point. Still, there are other ways to respond, even if they are difficult. One is to be curious and take what you can from it. Another is to think about people poorer and less fortunate than yourself who might look at you dimly for what you take for granted. I’m not saying that morality is relative, but points of view sure are.
- baobun 2y ago> It’s hard for me to respond to these kinds of posts with anything other than a dismissive sentiment Nobody's forcing you to respond, you know?
- Archelaos 2y agoThe author seems to be unfamiliar with angelology. The image she uses for illustrating her article does not show an angel, but a statue of Nike, the Greek goddess of victory. Cf.: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nike_(mythology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nike_(mythology) -- Is there an involuntary deeper meaning in this?
- kilimounjaro 2y agoFrom chatgpt: “ In summary, Halle Tecco’s personal portfolio comprises about 34 direct investments, of which 24 have at least one female founder (as detailed above). This means roughly 70% of these companies were co-founded or founded by women. Notable female-founded companies in her portfolio include Everly Health (Julia Cheek), Cityblock Health (Dr. Toyin Ajayi), Kindbody (Gina Bartasi), Tia (Carolyn Witte/Felicity Yost), Hued (Kimberly Wilson), and many others listed in the first section. Halle Tecco’s investment focus has clearly encompassed a large number of startups with women on the founding team, aligning with her advocacy for female entrepreneurs in health tech ” Call it charity or call it buying gal-pals with hubby’s money but primarily investing based on identity seems like a bad idea
- bombcar 2y agoIf X contributions and value are undervalued by the market, investing where X is contributing would be a winning strategy. If
- swyx 2y agomade me wonder who hubby was, so saving others the wikipedia search > Tecco is married to Jeff Hammerbacher, cofounder of Cloudera https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halle_Tecco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halle_Tecco
- unsatchmo 2y agoIf she’s rich and married a successful tech founder, I don’t understand why she didn’t get a lawyer to draft these investment papers to keep herself from getting fleeced. Like the amount she was dropping could probably have been recouped from a buyout without much fuss if the contracts were a bit more assertive.
- danielmarkbruce 2y agoIt's not a legal issue. If you invest your money in failed businesses, you lose. There is no legal machinations that will help.
- gitroom 2y agoOof, the amount of ways angels get squeezed out is kinda nuts, makes me way less excited about the whole early-stage game honestly - you think there's actually any way for small investors not to get hosed long-term or is that just the rules now?
- swyx 2y ago> Four others that raised money but with painful recapitalizations that effectively wiped out early shareholders. That last bullet was the nail in the coffin for me. For new investors to come in and wipe out early investors just because the market was in their favor was painful. It felt like opportunistic resets that enriched later investors at the expense of early supporters (not to mention early employees). what? how does this happen exactly? i'm not aware of the normal mechanisms. are there not minority shareholder protections?
- rorylaitila 2y agoI live in Delaware, a chronically bad market for angel or seed funding. Of the funds that existed, I always thought they took the wrong track of seeking real returns and requiring way too much business validation. It should have just stayed as a way to help foster the local startup community with some potential upside.
- tzury 2y agoWell, it says right there at the beginning: "Next week, I'll follow up with the cold, hard data on my portfolio performance" Here is in fact this follow up post: https://substack.com/home/post/p-162623790 https://substack.com/home/post/p-162623790
- throwaway2037 2y agoMy first thought when I opened the article: I wonder if s/he would have been better in a low cost S&P500 tracker ETF instead of angel investing. Conclusion: Yep. Google AI tells me: <<Since 2012, the S&P 500 has returned about 424.72% or 13.33% annually, assuming reinvestment of dividends.>>
- particle_theory 2y agoAngel investors should do a __post money fixed percent SAFE__ . Why invest if you dont spend the effort doing the payoff math? Just ask an LLM.. > Over the years, I’ve purchased stock in about a dozen companies on the Robinhood app. Some have tanked ... but unlike startups, none have gone to zero. Close to 500 US listed public companies filed for bankruptcy during this period.
- light_triad 2y agoInteresting that some people here are advocating for fewer investments and board seats when angel investing. It's rather the opposite: you need more investments and less time spent on companies. Angle investors are vital to the startup community as they take a lot of risk and are able to fund ideas that sound too crazy to get regular funding. In this case though given a hit rate of let's say 1% for argument's sake, 54 investments in 15 years is too low. You need hundred of investments to make the math work. Also doing it for fun and to learn is laudable but in the end hitting an Uber or an Airbnb is all that matters. It sounds like the job became full time consulting which is great if you're wealthy and want to give back to the community but can become unsustainable otherwise.
- netcan 2y agoSo... angel investing was once a very small and rare thing. An investment class well outside the scope of formal financing channels. The "angel" was a relative of "silent partners," the informal early financiers of small businesses. We can call YC the "turning point," nominally. Now we have an extremely mature web of financing channels. People with degrees specializing in the sector. Formal pipelines. Scale. The key point is that these were investments "no one else is willing to make." Hence "angel." Mike Markkula wasn't competing for his deal with Apple. That changes everything. Most startup investments made today would have happened whether or not any specific investor decides to do it. The market has liquidity.
- jbs789 2y agoUseful framing. Then follows that when supply of capital goes up, returns go down. i.e. we don't need to believe that the world is conspiring against angels, but in the efficiency of markets, and therefore earning an acceptable return is (much) harder.
- corford 2y agoI always assumed angel investing (at least as it emerged originally) was essentially philanthropy with the motivation being it gave very rich people a way to nudge things they liked into existence and provided them with a semi-cheap way to keep their network fresh with young, hungry, interesting new people. Bonus it might very occasionally turn in to a lottery ticket (but that wasn't the primary driver of making the investment).
- thundergolfer 2y agoThis seems to be a big part of it, but is there a separate word for it? It’s definitely not philanthropy because it’s not directed at public good. Economics must have made a term for this part of the venture ecosystem. “Seed capital” misses the significant social and class aspects of the behavior.
- coder543 2y agoHistorically, the term you're looking for might have been "patronage". Wealthy individuals supported artists, scientists, or explorers not purely for financial return, but because they believed in the person, the cause, valued the association, enjoyed the influence, or whatever else.
- corford 2y agoThis sounds right to me
- jxjnskkzxxhx 2y agoAh yes angel investing. Investing in businesses that don't make money. Ok.
- abconsulting 2y agoAn angel investor may also be eligible for a board seat, depending on their contribution to the venture. Factors such as introducing new customers, expanding into new markets and geographies, and driving growth in an industry with promising exponential potential can play a crucial role in securing this position. An Investment Banker