7 ms·
I Cannot Be Technical
- patcon 2y agoOoooooo I love the way this person uses language EDIT: made my comment more specifically about writing style
- wetpaws 2y ago[dead]
- bananabiscuit 2y agoReally? I’m a decent way through the piece and I still don’t understand what she is rambling about.
- croola 2y agosummarized via LLM In her essay "Why I Cannot Be Technical," Cat Hicks, a psychologist specializing in software environments, explores the structural and social dynamics that define the label "Technical" in the tech industry. She argues that despite her expertise in human-centered aspects of software development—such as behavior, culture, and organizational change—she is often excluded from being considered "Technical" because the term is narrowly defined to prioritize engineering and coding skills. Hicks emphasizes that this exclusion is not due to a lack of capability but stems from systemic biases related to gender, class, race, and professional roles. She notes that the designation of "Technical" often serves as a gatekeeping mechanism, determining who is deemed legitimate within tech spaces. This legitimacy is frequently withheld from those whose work focuses on human factors, regardless of its complexity or impact.
- antisthenes 2y agoMaybe the author should just write that? There's a reason there's a saying "brevity is a sister of talent". Whatever point you are trying to make surely could benefit if it actually reaches more than a few % of people who don't give up reading 10 pages of rambling when it should have been a paragraph in reality.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y ago> Whatever point you are trying to make I rather believe she is not intending to "make a point" but instead express herself. One may prefer brief self-expression but certainly not all do. Put another way: the expression is the point.
- alabastervlog 2y agoIt’s mostly a pleasant read, but even as someone who prefers the humanities and studied a lot more of that than most folks in computer jobs, I’ve made it about 40% in and couldn’t tell you what the author means by capital-T “Technical”. Is this something that would be clear to me if I’d worked in FAANG or similar? Is it a cultural thing there? Something to do with a corner of social media I don’t engage with? The closest I can come up with connected to my experience is the opposite: “tech” related labels used to exclude people and dismiss their ideas, in decision-making or business-social contexts, and design processes. I’ve not seen it used in this power(? I think? I really can’t figure this out)-conferring way. [EDIT] The anecdotes are so confusing. > An example of this is every time evidence of efficacy is not able to exert any power versus the votes of engineering disengagement. You could put your diligent little psychologist heart into it and make a good program or policy change and muster up extremely critical evidence for something no one else bothered to measure but you could not demand that all of the engineering managers do it, for instance. The engineering managers always had the power and always would. This is a manager thing. Specifically, modern management culture. Management wants to appear "evidence based" and "scientific" but the appearing is the only part they consistently care about. The "technical" run into this same wall, when they mistakenly believe surface claims that management's serious about working with evidence and "metrics" and such, and try to sincerely help as if that's the actual goal—it isn't. [EDIT 2] > This is one of the paradoxes of software teams: rich people, rich teams, rich environments, described and experienced as utter wastelands by (statistically speaking) men who have (statistically speaking) socked away more than I’ve ever touched and more than generations of my family ever touched, and their entire ownership of not having enough. OK, I think this is confirmation that the piece is about a slice of the tech industry I've not really engaged with, which may explain why I am nearly at the end of the piece and am still not sure what it's about. [EDIT 3] > Tech is immensely global in its activity and so fanatically geo-located in its employment that even the most senior and most unquestionably Technical people worry about moving away from 2-3 certain US cities. OK, yes, this is about a tiny percentage of "tech". Under this article's usage, I'm not "Technical", and few or none of the programmers I personally know are. That helps, wish that'd been stated up front.
- Izkata 2y ago> Is this something that would be clear to me if I’d worked in FAANG or similar? Is it a cultural thing there? Something to do with a corner of social media I don’t engage with? > The closest I can come up with connected to my experience is the opposite: “tech” related labels used to exclude people and dismiss their ideas, in decision-making or business-social contexts, and design processes. I’ve not seen it used in this power(? I think? I really can’t figure this out)-conferring way. There's a recent-ish (5 or so years?) style change people have pushed to capitalize "Black" in news and articles [0], and I think this author is trying to do the same here. Whatever this distinction is, it's entirely possible it's in their own mind and nowhere else. [0] https://apnews.com/article/archive-race-and-ethnicity-9105661462 https://apnews.com/article/archive-race-and-ethnicity-910566...
- blenderob 2y agoI couldn't make it. I gave up after 2 paragraphs. The random meandering from one thought to another without saying what the point of all this is got to me. I'm sure it's not a problem in the post. It's definitely a "me problem". Would someone be kind enough to post TL;DR of some sorts?
- Kye 2y agoIt seems to be about the way "technical" and "non-technical" are thrown around with implicit assumptions in conversations in places like this as hard categories. You're either technical, or what are you doing here? Are you lost? The door is over there. A key paragraph: >> "This is because Technical is a structural designation that operates outside of any actual problem-solving you and I are doing together. Being Technical is about being legitimate. Or to put it more simply: it’s because you are Technical that I can’t be. We have created the identities this way. A person with a PhD in human things and who deals in human problems and human solutions cannot ever be Technical no matter how dense her statistics are, how many conferences she speaks at, and how comprehensively she has given examples of generating outcomes that are often beyond engineering to generate (change over time; impacts on humans; making legible even an imperfect approximation of just one single emotion). These things can be useful, interesting, valuable, heartrending, inspiring and memorable to tech, but they cannot be legitimate." I'm still reading but it does seem to be about gatekeeping while avoiding any language that would set off a Technical person.
- arkh 2y agoThe author just want a medal saying they're Technical. Whatever this means, it is important to them. Like a child and a sheriff medal. "Technical" is the current cool club to be in and they want in. I guess technical is "techbros and their salary", not your average electrician and even less a Toyota Hilux with a 50 cal. in the back.
- aaronbaugher 2y agoI've noticed that a lot in discussions like this. Some people seem to have the impression that if you get the credentials or achieve a certain level of work, someone comes along and bestows a title of respect on you (here, "Technical") or welcomes you officially into that club. They seem to think that's how it works for everyone else (or some other group), and complain because that hasn't happened to them. But I don't think that's really how it works for anyone. I've been doing "technical" work for three decades and no one's declared me Technical or anything else. Some may consider me that and others may not; it's never occurred to me to ask. How I feel about whether I deserve to claim that title is up to me, and shouldn't really depend on others.
- ignoramous 2y agoAt any rate, this faculty member said, "Everything worth studying has an opposite that's necessary to understand what you thought you were studying." I have found this to be true. Isn't this classic Marx-Engels? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialectical_materialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialectical_materialism
- mikelevins 2y agoIt is, but they borrowed it from Hegel. I’m not particularly a Hegelian myself (it seems to me more like a cute trope than a law of nature), but being a Hegelian doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re also a Marxist.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Etheryte 2y ago> A person with a PhD in human things and who deals in human problems and human solutions cannot ever be Technical no matter how dense her statistics are, how many conferences she speaks at, and how comprehensively she has given examples of generating outcomes that are often beyond engineering to generate (change over time; impacts on humans; making legible even an imperfect approximation of just one single emotion). These things can be useful, interesting, valuable, heartrending, inspiring and memorable to tech, but they cannot be legitimate. This is clearly falsifiable, so I'm not sure what the idea is behind dragging this essay out for miles. The author doesn't feel like they're a technical person, fair enough, you do you and your labels. However there are plenty of people out there who tick all of those boxes despite you saying it can't be done. I know many people like this and they're often the best of both worlds, they bring a balanced and well rounded world view to bat.
- pjc50 2y ago> This is clearly falsifiable No it isn't. (Elaborate? You first.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sanderjd 2y agoThey were saying that they know of counterexamples to this statement.
- pjc50 2y agoI'd be very impressed if someone can find a woman in tech who's never had her input dismissed due to "not being a technical person". The frequency of such events goes down but is difficult to bring to zero.
- bluGill 2y agoI have no doubt that every woman in tech has been dismissed due to "not being technical". Even as a man I've been disrespected as not technical - I fit all the tech stereotypes. I'm well aware of the social norms that are against woman in tech that don't apply to me. However there are a lot of well respected women in tech and with not much effort they can find places where they are respected.
- roenxi 2y agoThere is a lot to like about this article. I would not be at all surprised if the author was really enjoying writing "I am not technical" and embedding the thought in one of the least technical essays I've ever read on HN. She clearly understands dot points well and is determined to stay a safe distance from them. I don't think there are any actual take-aways beyond an appreciation of rather well done nontechnical perspective take on what the technical world looks like. Although that is rare enough around here to make it quite interesting.
- admissionsguy 2y agoThis post is an example of what is wrong with non-technical people. Lots and lots of verbiage is used, much of which has not objective meaning. As a result, the reader's brain has to burn copious amounts of glucose to reconstruct what the author meant. The exact opposite of technical writing.
- creesch 2y agoNah, enough technical folks who do the exact same thing just in highly specific syntax equally difficult to follow for anyone regardless of them being “technical” or not. However, you might be one of the people the person in the post is talking about. The people who make “being technical” into a status symbol and something to gate keep. To the point that I have to wonder if you are going for some sort of stereotypical response in order to make a point. If you are not, then your reply is not cool, or productive.
- pjc50 2y ago> The exact opposite of technical writing Of course it's not technical writing! That's the point, it's human writing about the human experience. Which of course some Technical people regard as an imperfection to be ground off the perfect featureless spherical non-human Technical.
- mikelevins 2y agoAs a person with a graduate education in psychology who makes his living by being considered technical, who has made his living around 35% of my 37-year career as a technical writer, and whose technical writing has been described in glowing terms by professionals in the tech writing field and the engineering leadership at FAANGs, some of them famous for their technical contributions, I disagree with your assessment. I think it's a rather well constructed piece about social boundaries that is incidentally somewhat technical (though, I'm guessing, its technical aspects are from outside your field).
- sriram_malhar 2y agoThis is my reading of the article; can someone correct or add to this? The author is a psychologist for software developers. She cannot join the ranks of the technical, just as a judge needs to be wary of bias towards the defence or the prosecutorial side.
- pjc50 2y agoNo, her argument is that "technical" is a label assigned by other people, that she cannot escape being dismissed as "not technical" regardless of any achievements or evidence.
- bluGill 2y agoWhich is in fact wrong - other people have labeled her as technical. Not everyone will label her has technical, but no matter how good you get someone will label you as not-technical. As such her argument is incorrect. Now I do not know her. I have no idea if I would call her technical. She appears to at least have the background to become technical, but she may not want to spend her time doing that. I'm not sure what level of others think you are technical is required to say someone really is, but it isn't unanimous agreement.
- alabastervlog 2y agoCapital-T Technical in the piece appears to narrowly mean "accepted as part of high-comp coastal US tech bro circles". It's not really explained until near the end, but that sure seems to be what's going on, which is why a lot of posters were having trouble following it or misunderstood what was intended.
- worthless-trash 2y agoSo they'll never understand the problem.
- cess11 2y agoThat's a good critique, and a decent attempt at bringing a taste of what exclusion might feel like to "the Technical". I'm looking forward to reading and not responding to the inevitable copium sharing in the comments, hoping there will also be some interesting discussion.
- pjc50 2y ago[flagged]
- blenderob 2y ago> HN doesn't like Not Technical. Is it? I love HN but if I can fault HN with something, it'd be that HN upvotes too many non-technical articles. Too many! Every morning I come to HN to give me company for my morning coffee. And every morning I've to work hard to find the technical articles. The number of political articles, "feel good" articles, social issues stuff and other general non-tech stuff that people upvote makes looking for tech articles like searching needle in haystack. I wish HN had more technical articles.
- swiftcoder 2y ago> HN upvotes too many non-technical articles. Too many! non-technical, and Non Technical are not the same thing here (i.e. you are describing topics that are not directly related to tech, whereas the article is about how Non Technical labels are applied to people within tech)
- bananabiscuit 2y agoI love non-technical writing. Outside of work, the majority of what I like to read is non-technical. It’s a mistake to confound non-technical writing with bad writing. Sometimes you have to admit when the emperor is nude.
- pjc50 2y agoStopwatch clicking off: at the time when the post has been up for 58 minutes, it has now been pushed down to the second page at position #58.
- lalaithion 2y agoI think I understand what the author is trying to get at, and if I’m right then I agree with them, but this seems purposefully written in a style that inhibits understanding by the exact group it purports to be addressing.
- actionfromafar 2y agoOr if not purposefully written that way, it's exhibit A in why communication between disciplines can be challenging. :)
- krageon 2y agoif you write explicitly to not be understood you're not proving anything except that you're not a nice person
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bluGill 2y agoIt is fine if you are writing to a particular audience that will understand you. However even then essays written like this come off as only someone trained like me can figure out what this means and thus I must be great - even though a different writing style would be more accessible to not only the "layperson" but also their peers who are trained in that subject. As such I call this bad writing.
- kylecazar 2y agoIt's a well written essay at least. But, I don't know if the core thesis has anything to do with the matter of being technical. Dehumanization has always been a side-effect of corporatism, and the modern corporation just happens to be a tech company. For what it's worth I'm a liberal arts major that's coded professionally and is considered technical by my peers. The humanity of it all is never too far from my mind, and I've worked with many people like me. I suspect your mileage will vary based on where you work and who's around you. Is this an attempt to justify being non-technical? Because you don't have to.
- hnthrow90348765 2y ago>and the modern corporation just happens to be a tech company. I'd argue this is more aristocratic (or technocratic) social exclusion, which has gone on for far longer than compilers have existed. There does seem to be a persistent coalescing of certain personalities to certain industries that loves to exclude people (before, finance; now, tech) using mercurial standards that really just boil down to "do I like you", "do you entertain me or kiss my ass", or even "will you bang me"
- creesch 2y ago> It's a well written essay at least. Can I ask you to expand on this? I am curious as I had trouble making my way through it. I am also seeing people stating they gave up trying to understand it. So, I am genuinely curious to hear what makes it well written according to other people. Do you mean to say that from a literary perspective, the essay has strengths? Like the use of vivid metaphors, style, clever grammatical sentence structures, distinct voice, etc? Because these I can agree with, but these do not make a well written essay in my opinion. At least in my mind, well written means that the message comes across. Meaning that clarity and readability are factors that weigh heavily into a well written essay. Here it very much falls short, again in my opinion. Sentence length is high, the vocabulary swings between conversational and academic and has trouble following through with what is being said. It feels like it meanders, circles ideas without directly stating them. Basically it lacks a clear organizational structure. By which I don't mean the typical bullet point madness that people seem to overly rely on to make clear points these days. What I mean is that simple things like signposting (basically drawing conclusions at appropriate places) are lacking. Given that multiple people have actually stated they like the writing, I am almost wondering if this is a different form of “technical” where reading long form texts in this same format is a learned skill. Because it reminds me of the sort of writing I see in certain academic circles. Which causes a lot of the same reading "fatigue" I experienced with this specific article.
- dontreact 2y agoI think that “I’m not technical” is often an excuse for throwing work at other people and frankly can be a form of learned helplessness. Nowadays, there is less and less reason to ask other people to write one off scripts/queries, you can ask AI for help and learn how to do that. Since this is HN some disclaimers -no that’s not always what’s happening, when “not technical” is thrown around -no it’s not always appropriate to use AI instead of asking an expert
- bluGill 2y agoIt may be a good thing to throw scripts off to someone else. Division of labor is a good thing. You cannot possibly learn everything to a good (not even high) standard. Even if you could, no lawyer would have themselves as a client - when a lawyer needs legal advice they go to a different lawyer because they want that different perspective: this is often a good perspective for other subjects as well. The question is what you will/should learn for your limited time alive. Society needs well educated (I include things "street smarts" and apprenticeship in educated here) people in many different subjects. Some subjects are important enough everyone needs to learn them (reading, writing, arithmetic). Some subjects are nearly useless but fun (tinplate film photography) and so worth knowing. Things like basic computer skills are raising to the level where the majority of people today need them. However I'm not sure that scripting is itself quite at that level. (though it is important enough that a significant minority should have them)
- dontreact 2y agoLooks like I needed another disclaimer: I’m talking about a general trend I see in use of this term, not that it’s always a bad thing to say “I’m not technical so someone else should write the script” I agree with everything you said! Both things are happening in the world: people using this terminology to throw work at others needlessly, and people doing good division of labor.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- loks0n 2y agoThe essay is beautifully written, but its argument doesn't land for me. The understands "being Technical" as something to be granted for its own sake. But wanting to be Technical without any real problem to solve is hollow. Technical isn’t an identity you earn through argument, it’s something you become in the process of doing the work.
- pjc50 2y ago> it’s something you become in the process of doing the work. Her argument is that she's done quite a lot of such work and is still not guaranteed to be afforded the rank of Technical.
- bluGill 2y agoMaybe in her own mind she doesn't want to take it even though it is earned. That is a common problem, and as a psychologist she should well be aware of that. (I believe that the problem is more common amount women - but I'm not the psychologist she is, and so it would be wrong for me to tell her truths in her field)
- Kye 2y agoEven if she claims it, there's no end of people who will reject it, argue it, make her prove it, etc. I think that's one of the points: nothing she can do can truly make her seen as being worthy of it broadly enough to matter.
- evanjrowley 2y agoI suggest reading the author's About page for some additional context: https://www.fightforthehuman.com/about/ https://www.fightforthehuman.com/about/
- bee_rider 2y agoI propose we resolve the problem of overly centering technical people by gatekeeping harder. Web dev? Just a graphic designer with poor tools: non-technical. Engineering manager? Manager. Non-technical. Write business logic? That’s just office work. Banging out boiler plate code? Something a technical person might do, but not inherently in and of itself technical. A classical engineer must also sharpen their pencils. Eventually we’ll deny the label to enough people that it will become a precise description rather than a trophy.
- btbuildem 2y ago> jungle of rituals and group identities and normative behaviors and seemingly abundant but actually restrictive sociotechnological covenants As my tenure in the industry extends into a third decade, I find most real problems we face (in organizations) are not technical, but people-based. 99.99% of technical problems are solvable, especially for people whom OP labels as "Technical". You may think they are not, but they are -- because they can be reduced to time and resources, reliably. The 0.01% where you're inventing something new, blazing a path, that's different. But most of us are not doing that. The real challenges arise from the tribalism of groups, from emotional immaturity of individuals, lack of self-knowledge, and from the dictatorship-like power structure of most organizations. The inefficiencies and roadblocks posed by these aspects dwarf by orders of magnitude any and all technical challenges we ever come across.
- acureau 2y agoThis essay is dripping with self pity. I do not care that you're a woman, I do not care that you have a PhD, I do not care that you used to be a barista. You can be technical if you apply that label to yourself. You cannot force others to apply that label to you, so why define yourself by their perception? For what it's worth (very little), there are many of us for which the technical label means strictly "expertise in X domain".
- mezzie2 2y agoI had an interesting reaction to this piece in that I agree with some of what she's saying but I think she makes a lot of fundamental errors in her assumptions and her approach is wrong. Some of my thoughts have been mentioned in other comments, but I wanted to get them out all in one place without derailing any sub conversations. For personal consideration/bias purposes before I go into my thoughts: - Like Dr. Hicks, I'm a queer woman from an uneducated family who found success in academia. I had to leave before I could do a PhD because I got MS, but I am the only person in my immediate family with a graduate degree and I worked in academia for over a decade. I say this because, since she's relying a fair amount on standpoint epistemology, I'm in identity categories that according to her own approach say I can evaluate what she argues from that standpoint, and some of my disagreements come from her being overly narrow in interpreting her experience. - Unlike Dr. Hicks, I'm an oddity in that I'm Technical (by her definition) by birthright (I'm a 3rd generation programmer and 3 out of 4 of my grandparents as well as several other elder figures in my family were all hackers/tinkerers/etc. - I started programming when I was 4-5 years old.) I'm not good or spectacularly talented since I've focused on other areas and talents of mine, but I have unambiguously done 'Technical' work and would be/am considered 'Technical' by most people. I've also observed 'Technical' culture for a long time and have what I would consider to be a fairly robust knowledge of the history and development of that culture. A fair number of my disagreements come from my own observations so I think clarifying my own position is important. Where I agree with her is in her pointing out that there is unambiguously a 'Technical' culture that has an often antagonistic relationship with other cultures and that has a sense of self-superiority which often goes unchecked. I also agree that there are various aspects of Technical culture that result in some very, very offputting decisions when those decisions are enacted on a wider society. And that, because of the massive amount of societal power this culture has begun to wield in such a short time (on a historical scale), the faults and downsides of this culture are causing harm and suffering. I relate a great deal to her realization that the people who treat her nicely do not do the same for her friends/loved ones. I'm in the culture and so generally treated decently, but, like Dr. Hicks, I spend a lot of time around people who aren't/don't and the discrepancy in treatment really bothers me. That said, she gets a lot of things wrong: - She pretty much only studies the culture by observing the most materially successful inhabitants. It's like only studying how the royal family lived in England in 1600 and using that to extrapolate about English culture in general. Ironically given her talking about having to study the opposites of matters to fully understand them, she completely discards anyone Technical who is not working in Big Tech. The legions of IT workers and devs at lower companies, FOSS and general non Big Tech techies (like I don't think anybody would question Linus Torvald's 'Technical' status), freelancers, etc. Working at any company or organization usually requires at least somewhat licking the boot of whatever culture they profess - it's a self-selecting pool. Of course people she studies in Big Tech are going to act that way: It's a prerequisite to being there in the first place! - She ascribes a lot to Technical people that she sees as unique, but I don't think are. Like when she talks about not wanting to be a U/X or tech 'People Person' because she can come up with a good, robust idea and can't make the engineering managers do it. Does she think that non Technical managers are any better at taking feedback and policies from people they consider outsiders? They aren't, in my experience. There's a decent amount of friction between academic librarians and other faculty members at a lot of institutions because the academic librarians don't always have a PhD, and good luck trying to convince the Sales and Marketing departments in a giant megacorp to do something that makes sense if it goes against their temperaments. Likewise, it's true that it's a mostly male group and this causes them to overlook some aspects of the female experience. I've found that groups and places that are overwhelmingly female do the same thing in the other direction. The results are different because of how our society is set up, but any group full of one type of person is going to be bad at considering matters outside of that group's experience because humans are pretty self-absorbed. I can also assure her that academia is very hostile and condescending to people outside its bubble on much the same level as high-status Technical people, and I see much of the same discrepancy of treatment there. High-status Technical people treat my working-class friends poorly, and so do academics. She just might not notice because she's in that club - most working-class people who 'make it' end up very attached to the culture of the people who lifted them out. - She seems to think that Technical culture status is conveyed on high by some central authority, when in my experience, squabbles over who is in the culture or not are fairly common and not all of us agree. I, for example, would absolutely consider some devs at Big Tech to not be 'Technical' based on various measures. When people are offering her 'access to the tent', they're saying they see her as one of them. There's not a group chat where we update who's in and out. Likewise, you can absolutely convey 'Technicality' on to someone, but you don't do it by just saying 'this person is a techie'. You do it by introducing them to the culture, teaching/mentoring them, and helping them with projects/work. Then you let them speak for themselves and their own work. Having someone speak for you is actually kind of an anti-signal in some ways, because a strong indicator of Technical culture is being able to speak for yourself, your work, and your thought process. - I think she lacks an understanding of Technical history. A lot of the hostility in Technical spaces came about because the first generation to 'make it big'/be socially accepted and impactful had very hostile interactions with mainstream culture before that point. She notes that she's treated with hostility because she doesn't meet Technical expectations or qualifications, but that's the same experience a stereotypical Technical person has outside of Technical spaces. I move in 'people oriented'/mainstream non Technical spaces well because I'm a bubbly, somewhat charismatic white woman who can read social cues well. I'm attractive/feminine enough to not be considered 'weird' or 'creepy', and I know how to tailor my appearance/speech/etc. to different groups. It's better than it used to be, but a lot of that top down antagonistic culture from Technical people is reactive, and the superiority is partially a defense mechanism/coping. This is also one reason Technical people tend to take critiques from outsiders poorly, especially when that critique is 'you need to be more like us! :)' This is also related to the changing demographics and dynamics of the Internet/Web and a lot of Technical people feeling like they lost a bubble and safe place. IDK, good on anyone who reads my word vomit, I just wanted to get my thoughts out. They're not particularly well formed or organized, though.
- knighthack 2y ago> "...I am a psychologist of software environments and that is something of an anomaly." Right. Translation: "I'm actually incompetent. I have no technical abilities, and I'm lazy to learn." Her entire blog post - and probably career - is just her waffling around.
- thunderfork 2y ago[dead]
- dyeje 2y agoI understand what the author is getting at. It’s really densely written though, I’m hoping the intent is to express the feeling rather than persuade because (as some of the top comments show) I think it comes across antagonistic to that audience.
- lukeasrodgers 2y agoThis reminds me of an interview with Luce Irigaray in which, IIRC, the interviewer asks her if she is (or considers herself to be) a "writer", using the French word écrivain, a masculine noun, and she responds something to the effect of "it is not me who decides that question."
- alganet 2y agoLet's humanize psychology instead.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoI feel like I know precisely how the author would respond to this comment: why not both? > We can rewrite this entire essay to be about my field, Psychology, if you need that.
- alganet 2y agoYes, lets do that.
- Izkata 2y agoThis particular passage sticks out at me as the author not being able to examine their own bias: > Walking across the street during a conference, a car pulled up intentionally fast and close to me and I hopped out of the way, scared. The men with me who did not jump roared with laughter, and this sparked a conversation (monologue) about innate personality differences (rather than, say, height differences). In that moment it was impossible for me to be a PhD who studies how we maintain beliefs about innate characteristics and generates empirical evidence around them and their impacts, even though I am. We are always constructing. In that street, my identity could not be made real against the identity that was offered out of the situation that aligned with a world they preferred, one in which some men could laugh at scared women. Obviously I don't know these particular men, but from my experience "laugh at scared women" isn't what was happening in their minds. I think they would have laughed no matter the sex of the person who jumped, and if it was a man, he probably would have laughed at himself too - it was more like "laugh at reacting to a situation that didn't need that reaction". When stuff like this happens, men tend to use laughter as a bonding and tension-relief valve, not as ridicule.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]