12 ms·
Intelligence Evolved at Least Twice in Vertebrate Animals
- Klaster_1 2y agoAs if Godwin's Law, it amuses me how not a single animal intelligence discussion on HN goes without a Children of Time reference, which has a race of uplifted animals the article mentioned - in this case crows. Amazing series.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jotux 2y ago>As if Godwin's Law, it amuses me how not a single animal intelligence discussion on HN goes without a Children of Time reference, which has a race of uplifted animals the article mentioned - in this case crows At the time of writing this comment, there is not a single reference to Children of Time in this thread other than the one you have added.
- Loughla 2y ago6 hours later and this is still the only reference to that.
- friendlyprezz 2y ago[flagged]
- rbanffy 2y agoor the wheel, New York, wars and so on?
- flanked-evergl 2y ago> That man and brute are like is, in a sense, a truism; but that being so like they should then be so insanely unlike, that is the shock and the enigma. That an ape has hands is far less interesting to the philosopher than the fact that having hands he does next to nothing with them; does not play knuckle-bones or the violin; does not carve marble or carve mutton. People talk of barbaric architecture and debased art. But elephants do not build colossal temples of ivory even in a roccoco style; camels do not paint even bad pictures, though equipped with the material of many camel's-hair brushes. Certain modern dreamers say that ants and bees have a society superior to ours. They have, indeed, a civilization; but that very truth only reminds us that it is an inferior civilization. Who ever found an ant-hill decorated with the statues of celebrated ants? Who has seen a bee-hive carved with the images of gorgeous queens of old? No; the chasm between man and other creatures may have a natural explanation, but it is a chasm. We talk of wild animals; but man is the only wild animal. It is man that has broken out. All other animals are tame animals; following the rugged respectability of the tribe or type. All other animals are domestic animals; man alone is ever undomestic, either as a profligate or a monk.
- thowaway7564902 2y agoWithout any prior knowledge of how to create fire, would you figure it out if given 2 sticks?
- miningape 2y agoDepends how bored I am.
- anonzzzies 2y agoThere was no bored back then; you were dying or hunting. Keeps you busy.
- Detrytus 2y agoAnimals that feed on grass have to eat almost constantly, since grass is very low calorie food. Predators on the other hand are famous for having a lot of free time: lions for example sleep between 15 and 20 hours per day. So I guess early humans would have a lot of time to be bored.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- iamflimflam1 2y agoI guess there’s no reason for survival of the fittest to equal more intelligence. Easy to forget that “fittest” is only relevant to the environment/context you are living in - if intelligence does not make you “fitter” for that then it will probably disappear.
- lo_zamoyski 2y agoFootnote: "survival of the fittest" is circular. Bob: It's about the survival of the fittest. Alice: Fittest with respect to what? Bob: Survival. So, survival of the fittest to survive, or what survives, survives. It is utterly banal, but in popular culture, it has been "elevated" into a deepity.
- harperlee 2y agoI think it is 'fittest with respect with the current / incoming environment', in contrast with 'strongest' / 'fastest' / some other absolute measurement, at the expense of the rest.
- bmacho 2y agoIt's not circular, it's just true in the purest sense. As all mathematical theorems are either tautologies or consequences of assumptions, therefore pure assumptions. For me survival of the fittest just means that with high probability those genes will survive who have a high probability to survive in an evolutionary setting. Is this trivial? In this wording it is trivial. But it can be useful. (And also it is not that trivial in a different wording. Just like other theorems, e.g. the theorem about the perpendicular bisectors of a triangle's sides. If a point O is equal distance from A and B and B and C then it is equal distance from A and C. Tautology, circular, assumption, name it what you want, it's math.)
- SAI_Peregrinus 2y agoSurvival of the fittest to reproduce. Not just to survive, but to spread. The key profundity is that it's so banal, there's no need for a God directing it.
- 2y ago
- boxed 2y agoI'm going to want to throw in jumping spiders in the mix. They are extremely impressive cognitively, especially considering their size.
- rsynnott 2y agoNot vertebrates tho (the article does also mention octopuses as an invertebrate example).
- Steelkiwer 2y ago[dead]
- IX-103 2y agoI'm guessing the reason birds' brains are so much smaller for a given level of intelligence is that there is so much more evolutionary pressure to make things lighter when you need to be able to fly. Mammals are likely more optimized for resilience and less caloric expenditure instead of weight.
- lawlessone 2y agoMaybe it's like how we (most vertebrates) have blind spots built into our eyes due to a quirk of evolution, but some animal like squid etc don't... because their eyes have better cable management.
- mystified5016 2y agoKind of. There was no evolutionary advantage to removing the blind spot because brains adapted to compensate for it on a much shorter timescale than evolution. So most mammals still have the blind spot. Birds, on the other hand, have a disting evolutionary advantage in making their brains as small and light as possible. To me, this implies bird brains are likely to be much more efficient, both volumetrically and energetically. That's the more fascinating angle, IMO
- lawlessone 2y agoHuman brains have gotten a little smaller since we left the stoneage. Maybe the ours are getting more efficient too.
- anthonypasq 2y agoin this podcast, its speculated that we have offloaded a lot of our intelligence to culture and the collective brain. Maximizing individual intelligence is less effective than maximizing social interaction and knowledge sharing for survival, especially for humans. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcfhrThp1OU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcfhrThp1OU
- 2y ago
- morsecodist 2y agoI'm in no way an expert but stuff like this is fascinating to me. A lot of our perceptions about intelligence are informed by human intelligence because it's the only example we have a strong grasp on. Having independent examples can help us understand properties of intelligent systems in general instead of over fitting on systems that are like us.
- lamename 2y agoThis is very cool and lends even more evidence to what has been more or less clear in the avian neuro community. This genetic/dev evidence in a similar brain region supports previous work by Karten (mentioned in the article) and others on bird auditory "cortex". The mantra is "nuclear" or "regional" organization in birds rather than layers in mammals, but the anatomy [0, Fig 4] and electrophysiology [1] abstract this out in similar patterns. [0]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20616034/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20616034/ [1]: https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1408545112 https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1408545112
- Balgair 2y agoPedantry Alert: > The mantra is "nuclear" or "regional" organization in birds rather than layers in mammals, but the anatomy [0, Fig 4] and electrophysiology [1] abstract this out in similar patterns. Marsupials too! Sort of. Generally, marsupials are mostly close to other mammals in brain structure, but they do have a fair bit less layers and some nuclear structures. Comparative neuroanatomy in vertebrates is, like, super interesting (to me at least). It really goes to show off evolution and how her pressure is really towards more babies - however that needs to be accomplished.
- lamename 2y ago+1 for comparative neuroanatomy indeed
- I_Nidhi 2y agoIt’s pretty wild to think intelligence might have evolved more than once in vertebrates. The example of birds and mammals both developing complex brains is fascinating. It makes you wonder how much untapped potential animals might have in terms of intelligence that we haven’t fully understood yet.
- energy123 2y ago> It’s pretty wild to think intelligence might have evolved more than once in vertebrates It's an utter bombshell if true. It means intelligence isn't "difficult" for evolution to arrive at, significantly increasing the odds of other intelligent life in the universe.
- pfdietz 2y agoIt significantly increases the odds if evolution of intelligence was the bottleneck, not, say, origin of life itself.
- guelo 2y agoNot difficult when given the common ancestor of birds and mammals and a few hundred million years of relatively calm environment.
- dboreham 2y agoOnce you have the basic GPU cell design, it's just a case of allowing time to run.
- adrian_b 2y agoWhile typically both mammals and birds are significantly more intelligent than the other vertebrates, it must be not forgotten that there exists an overlap in intelligence between the smartest reptiles, e.g. varans a.k.a. monitor lizards, and the dumber mammals and birds. So also outside of mammals and birds there are some cases of brain evolution towards greater complexity, even if not reaching the typical mammal/bird level, and which are likely to also correspond to a somewhat different brain structure. (Off topic, in my opinion, "reptiles", is a term that is properly applied only to lizards and snakes. Not only crocodiles and turtles are more closely related to birds than to lizards and snakes, but also none of them are crawling, as implied by the word "reptile". Actually the present crocodiles are awkward on land only because they are secondarily adapted to an aquatic life. Their terrestrial ancestors were much more agile, as still demonstrated by some crocodiles that are even now able to gallop.)
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago"Deep Past" by Eugene Linden is an entertaining novel, even if it is not a work of high literature. It is science/speculative fiction, that started from the author wondering about a scenario in which humans had gone extinct 10k years ago, before we developed much, if any, material culture. He felt that had that happened another intelligent species 1M years later would have no idea that we had even existed (different story now, of course). In the book, a discovery on the steppe of Khazakstan leads to revolutionary discoveries about very, very old intelligence. The author has written several non-fiction books on animal intelligence.
- programd 2y agoA similar scenario of a possible ancient industrial civilization on Earth was explored in a serious scientific paper not too long ago: "The Silurian hypothesis: would it be possible to detect an industrial civilization in the geological record?" https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-astrobiology/article/silurian-hypothesis-would-it-be-possible-to-detect-an-industrial-civilization-in-the-geological-record/77818514AA6907750B8F4339F7C70EC6 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journa...
- TMWNN 2y agoSome of my favorite SCP entries are based on the idea of an ancient advanced civilization before recorded history. <https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-1115 https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-1115> <https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-1050 https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-1050> (not main subject, but what anomaly references) <https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-4001 https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-4001>, then <https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/alexandria-burning https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/alexandria-burning>
- palmotea 2y ago> The findings emerge in a world enraptured by artificial forms of intelligence, and they could teach us something about how complex circuits in our own brains evolved. Perhaps most importantly, they could help us step “away from the idea that we are the best creatures in the world,” said Niklas Kempynck, a graduate student at KU Leuven who led one of the studies. “We are not this optimal solution to intelligence.” Some AI startup needs to get this in their marketing, stat.
- titzer 2y agoIt's interesting to think of how bird intelligence is related to their perspective. Perching high in branches and taking to the skies allows them to see a large overview of the many activities of other life forms. They can manage to get relatively safe vantage points and just watch. The better they get at predicting what the low animals on the surface are doing, the more opportunities that they have to sneak in and sneak out safely to get a meal. Being stuck on the surface as a mammal means a more immediate, limited-scope, fight-or-flight reaction dominates daily activities, versus a game-board view of many interactions. Bird intelligence makes a lot more sense in that context.
- Swizec 2y ago> The better they get at predicting what the low animals on the surface are doing, the more opportunities that they have to sneak in and sneak out safely to get a meal The most compelling explanation for bird intelligence I’ve read[1] argues that it all stems from social needs. Birds, you see, form lifelong pairs. But they constantly cheat on each other. Keeping track of this cheating behavior, deceiving each other, hide their actions, predict what other birds know, understanding who will and who won’t rat them out to their partner, that’s why the intelligence developed. Then once you have intelligence, it proves useful for all sorts of things. Many species of bird also use this advanced ability to keep track of who knows what for food. They’ll hide a stash for winter and find it all later. But it’s easier to remember where your friend hid theirs than to get your own. So a whole arms race of deception developed. [1] The Genius of Birds https://www.jenniferackermanauthor.com/genius-ofbirds https://www.jenniferackermanauthor.com/genius-ofbirds
- reverendsteveii 2y agoFunny, I've read the same thing about intelligence, particularly trainability, in both rats and dogs. It's driven by a social aspect. The existence of a peer group necessitates imagination and theory of mind: you have to be able to think about what someone else is thinking about. From there you can have thoughts like "That big monkey wants me to do this thing that we do sometimes and has indicated that they'll give me a thing I like if I do it."
- cryptophreak 2y agoSelecting any text in the body of the article adds that text to your clipboard. Weird.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- circlefavshape 2y agoDoesn't this kinda _have_ to be true? Otherwise we'd need to have a common ancestor with birds that was itself intelligent
- jebarker 2y agoDo we know that that's not true?
- thesuitonym 2y agoIf that were the case, doesn't it seem unlikely that only our two evolutionary lines have kept/reintroduced it?
- AlotOfReading 2y agoOur common ancestor is a group of small lizards [0] that are mostly known for being found inside moss "trees" where they seemingly starved to death, and many of their other descendents aren't especially intelligent either. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hylonomus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hylonomus
- adolph 2y agoProving a negative is a fools errand. The fossil record developed thus far doesn't support it. Additionally there is such intelligence as the Octopus which has an evolutionary split much earlier than mammals and birds. The last common ancestor of [humans] and octopuses is a flatworm that trawled the sea floor 750 million years ago. This is the most recent creature that we both have a direct line of descent from – it represents the point at which we diverged down separate evolutionary pathways. To illustrate just how early this was, this was 80 million years before any animal showed bilateral symmetry – the familiar body plan with a defined top and bottom, and right and left; 350 million years before tetrapods – the first four legged creatures that gave rise to all birds, reptiles, mammals and amphibians – came into existence; and 500 million years before the emergence of dinosaurs. https://eusci.org.uk/2020/06/22/an-alien-in-our-sea-a-look-at-the-intelligence-of-an-octopus/ https://eusci.org.uk/2020/06/22/an-alien-in-our-sea-a-look-a... Nice book about the topic is "The Deep History of Ourselves" by Joseph LeDoux. https://www.amazon.com/Deep-History-Ourselves-Microbes-Conscious-ebook/dp/B07FC1HM7K https://www.amazon.com/Deep-History-Ourselves-Microbes-Consc...
- mewpmewp2 2y agoThere's reference to various animals, like crows or bees learning to "count" or knowing how to "count". However I'm highly skeptical that it's actual "counting". I think it's just ability to learn based on whether there's more or less of something, in most cases. Which if you think about it, is an obvious skill all animals must possess in order to make decisions. And nothing new. I don't think those studies are showing true "counting". For example as a person I can without counting tell if there's 1, 2, 3, 4 or 5 of something, I can tell how many characters are in shorter words on glimpse, but that's not counting. These amounts are just pattern recognition labels. However I can then use these in groups to do actual counting. Animals certainly must be able to tell if something is smaller or bigger, because they must identify whether it's a potential prey, or a threat. Already this ability should lead to the ability of being able to differentiate between there being 1, 2, 3 or 4 of something. There seems to be studies that are using this idea to prove that animals can count. Ultimately these are the strength of certain stimuli and even a simple machine learning algorithm can produce different output based on the amount of that signal. And then talking about planning and self-control. Many animals are willing to patiently stand still, waiting for their prey to make a move, I don't think it means that they are specifically "thinking" about it. A cat can patiently wait for the mouse when it notices the hole.
- lo_zamoyski 2y agoNeuroscience suffers from a rigor problem[0] Sure, you can make observations, even good observations, but these can be lodged within a mushy, interpretive bed of sloppy speculation, bad philosophy, and unexamined assumptions. For starters, what is intelligence? Because defined one way, you could attribute it to virtually anything that responds to the environment in some way. Against mechanistic presuppositions, you'll be stuck with the impossible Sisyphean task of defining it at all (good luck weaving intentionality into mechanistic metaphysics; it is no accident that Descartes believed that non-human animals lack consciousness - he viewed them in mechanistic terms!). Or consider... 'they could help us step “away from the idea that we are the best creatures in the world"' '“We are not this optimal solution to intelligence.”' What is meant by "best" and "optimal"? Without telos, you cannot speak about anything being best or optimal. There is no ordering measure. These are defined with respect to how well something attains an end. Is pencil A better than pencil B? You can answer that once you define what it means to be a pencil, because then you can define what it means to be a good pencil. But is a pencil better than an eraser? Meaningless question w.r.t. what is intrinsic and essential to each, as they are two different kinds of things with two different ends. Measured against human purposes, i.e., purposes extrinsic to the things themselves? You could say that the pencil is superior, as it more directly and fully contributes to the human end of communication or drawing or whatever, while the eraser plays a supportive role. Or consider perhaps some kind of absolute ontic hierarchy (at the very least, human beings can do whatever any other animal can through technology, something that permits the extension and determination of the human power to act). "What are the building blocks of a brain that can think critically, use tools or form abstract ideas?" What is an "abstract idea"? How does it differ from a concrete image? For example, let's say that after a squirrel perceives a tree in its senses, it remembers this perception. Is this an abstract idea? What if this squirrel sees another tree and, through its squirrel brain, is moved to behave with respect to it in a manner similar to the first tree. Does that involve abstraction? Does similarity of image entail abstract ideas? If the abstract idea of "Tree" is not an image, not a similarity between images, and therefore not particular but a universal predicate, for instance, and the brain itself is concrete, then how can brains entertain abstract ideas that escape concreteness and particularity? Some will no doubt claim that answering these questions is precisely what neuroscience seeks to do, but this is confused. Yes, neuroscience can shed light on certain neurological phenomena, and that's great. But neuroscience also operates within "meta-neuroscientific" parameters and makes use of its (often hazy) notions in a way that undermine its coherence. These require philosophical chops to untangle and analyze. [0] https://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2011/01/against-neurobabble.html https://edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2011/01/against-neurobabble...
- steveBK123 2y agoEntirely possible we are due for a third try
- fjfaase 2y agoWhat would be the reason that birds did not develop language? There are birds that have an amazing range of vocalizations, such as the Lyre Birds, and there are examples of birds that have shown the ability to associate human speech with abstract concepts. So, why did some bird specie develop a language and a culture heritage. The developed in parallel with mammals. Birds too spend some considerable effort in feeding there offspring, just like mammals. There are enough examples of young birds with almost the size of there parents still following their parents around to beg for food. How would the worlds have looked if some birds would have developed language and being able to transmit knowledge to sibling and children? Or was it the fact that we have hands that we evolved further? It is sometimes argued that language developed as part of mate selection. Bird vocalizations definitely play that role with birds.
- jes5199 2y agohow confident are we that they don’t? I hear a song sparrow and I can’t help but think their calls sound like compressed data, almost like a modem
- bluGill 2y agoMost birds act like they only know a few calls. You get the "come mate with me" and the "this is my territory stay out". Once in a while a "come help me fight off this predator", but there isn't enough detectable variation in either behavior or the song to suggest they are doing anything deeper.
- steve_adams_86 2y agoWhich makes it so strange that some birds seem to have very sophisticated vocalizations. Why? How does it serve them, and why did they diverge so much? Take ravens for example. There's one that hangs out in trees directly outside of my house now and then. It makes new sounds I haven't heard before quite often. I don't hear other ravens, so I'm not even sure it's trying to communicate. Does it have a social purpose? Is it bored? Do the variations express anything at all? Yet being in a forest with them around, you hear all kinds of noises too, and they do it all together. They interact a lot. Though my experience is that they use fewer variations when they're together compared to the weird one outside of my house. They seem very intelligent regardless. They're such cool birds. Meanwhile most of the other birds around my house, as far as my ears can tell, just make the same sounds over and over. What does any of it mean?
- dan_mctree 2y agoAdvanced intelligence may have evolve multiple times, but wouldn't the origins of simpler intelligence lie much deeper in the evolutionary tree? If Octopi use neurons too, it seems obvious to me that rudimentary intelligence must have originated in or before the common ancestor of vertebrates, octopi and squids: flatworms. Or going back even further, perhaps even all the way to single cellular life which often seems to be able to react in complex ways to stimuli. Even our brains seem to still make use of forms of processing within the cell, isn't there intelligence in those cells? Or do we have some agreed on definition of intelligence that excludes these simpler forms?
- ane 2y agoAlex, the bird mentioned in the article, is also the first animal ever to have asked a question. When shown its reflection in a mirror, it asked what color it was. We've trained chimps and gorillas for decades and they have never asked a single question
- ralphc 2y agoIf “A bird with a 10-gram brain is doing pretty much the same as a chimp with a 400-gram brain,” as the article says, what does this say about dinosaurs, which appear to be the ancestors of birds but are larger creatures? What was their intelligence like?
- lamename 2y agoOddly, what tends to matter for competence in X domain in relation to the brain isn't the absolute size of the brain (or brain region) but size relative to 1. The other structures in the brain 2. Total brain size relative to body size
- TMWNN 2y agoMy question is related to this. The article implies that the separate evolutionary track that resulted in birds is more advanced than the one that led to primates and us. Given that, would a bird with a 3lb brain be smarter than a human?
- NoTeslaThrow 2y agoI don't think intelligence is a coherent enough concept to be considered to have evolved once, let alone twice.
- anon84873628 2y agoIntelligence can be pretty well defined as something like: the ability of an organism to make an internal model of the outside world, and use that model to predict the world and plan its actions. There is of course a lot of variation in which things the model emphasizes and how much simulation is done, but that's the gist of it, and there are lots of ways to measure it in animals.
- NoTeslaThrow 2y agoSure. People who like that definition will find this sort of finding very stimulating.
- alganet 2y agoArticles like these are tricky. It's an obvious clickbaity thing. Humans knew birds are smart since way before science decided to call itself science. I think the text plays more on hammering the "nothing makes sense in biology except for the light of evolution" thing than on the roots of intelligence. The purpose and definition of intelligence have always been a critical point in evolutionary biology. No mention of the foxp2 gene and the peculiarities of both human and bird variants? Seems like this would open a point for an opposite conclusion (there is a common root if you consider language part of what constitutes intelligence). In the sixties, birds were girls, cats were boys, and everyone was kind of an asshole. Why should I trust any kind of research that started back then? :) If we're gonna be weirdly anacronistic, let's at least be clear about it. I am more of a 2025 person.
- djmips 2y agoI always say that the bird brain is the die shrink of ours.
- m3047 2y ago(I own chickens. There's an "Ur-chicken".) The thing that jumped out at me in the article was this implied definition of "intuitive": "In mammals, brain development follows an intuitive path: The cells in the embryo’s amygdala region at the start of development end up in the adult amygdala." So let me see if I understand: Here is rock on hill. Rock stays on hill, or rock falls down hill. Because it's intuitive. I'm not sure I agree that that's what "intuitive" means.
- m3047 2y agoNot the ur-chicken I'm referring to, but a great read... could be a post on HN: https://www.audubon.org/magazine/november-december-2014/stalking-wild-ur-chicken https://www.audubon.org/magazine/november-december-2014/stal...
- eli_gottlieb 2y agoNot sure what's meant by "intelligence" or "twice" here, since the study in question (https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adv2609 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adv2609) concerns the pallium in both birds and mammals. So it seems something about the basal pallium in reptiles was suitable to give rise to bird pallia and the mammalian isocortex, under suitable evolutionary pressures.
- Animats 2y agoPlus octopi, which evolved some degree of intelligence in a very different way than vertebrates. So we have at least three paths to intelligence now. This is an indication that fᵢ in the Drake Equation [1] is probably closer to 1 than 0. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation
- mapt 2y agoI always thought there was a very basic intelligence proof that the biologists & neurologists overlooked. Engineering. What are humans? If we focus on early-noticed similarities with Great Apes, people often took to saying "We are the tool users", but "We are the builders" is maybe just as accurate. We produce not just jackhammers, but skyscrapers. Tool users modify their environment adaptively for utility, builders modify their environment adaptively for utility. The evidence is in the works. Building a stacked stone house requires creating an abstract concept of a future dwelling you would like to have, figuring out how the wall works in that dwelling, modifying the wall according to the layout of the terrain, finding and modifying the appropriate piece of stone that works in the correct position, and then iterating on this piece by piece as each stone provides a slightly different opportunity for the next stone. It requires persistence in pursuit of that abstract goal much longer than routine biological feedback loops; We're talking about a delayed gratification "Marshmallow Test" because you don't get to enjoy sanctuary from the weather until you're done. It requires a consciousness of the environment, the available tools, one's one's own limitations, and the shifting outlines of a hypothetical future. There's literal Gantt Chart type prioritization and preparation involved. I don't see how this could possibly be less complex cognitively than a mirror test. A number of of animals build nests, piece by piece in the fashion of a human rather than purely through biological secretions. I argue that all of them, even the really weird ones (eg ant nests), are in one sense intelligent.
- bird0861 2y ago[dead]