10 ms·
Talkin’ about a Revolution
- resurrected 2y ago[flagged]
- lynx97 2y agoSo a country with 3% of the population of the US can throw the US into lawlessness or transform the US into a dictatorship? Pretty weak structure if that actually works.
- Ozzie_osman 2y agoIt's more about how the US handled the situation in a country with 3% of the population and the impact of that on either marginal voters or voters for whom this was a major issue.
- lynx97 2y ago> how the US handled the situation in a country As if the US were responsible for the whole world. Hey Megalomania, nice to meet you.
- bmacho 2y agoThe point is how the US government handled the matter, and that the votes were affected by that (at least that's the claim). The size of the Gaza conflict in absolute terms is entirely irrelevant, it easily could've been only 1 person, dominating the media.
- Ozzie_osman 2y agoIn this case, it wasn't for lack of action. The US is actively funding one side's dominance and hindering others from helping the other side. I think most people who are complaining about this are not expecting the US to be responsible for anything and would be pretty happy if the US just sat out.
- chasd00 2y ago3% living in swing states is plenty to change a presidential election.
- dudefeliciano 2y agoHow did it contribute to bringing trump to power?
- code_for_monkey 2y agoit was a huge anchor around the dem's neck, it was a huge conversation during the entire election. They were unable to convince people that Trump would be worse for Gaza than them.
- ggm 2y agoIt altered voting intent by both Jewish and Islamic groups in ways which were net negative for Harris. The margin of error in voting was less than the number of votes swayed. All of this is out weighed by the "didn't vote" but democrat didn't vote was larger than before. If this issue stimulated a vote boycott it could have affected democrat voters more.
- dudefeliciano 2y agoThat argument is not really credible to me, saying that democrats did not vote or voted republican because Harris (and Biden before her) were too favorable towards Israel, ignores the fact that it was glaringly obvious that trump would be even more favorable towards Israel.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoI have certainly heard people say that they couldn't support Harris because the Biden administration was too close to Israel, so instead didn't vote at all. I know it doesn't make sense to hand the election to somebody objectively worse on an issue they claim to care about, but there it is. I suspect that whole thing was driven by some clever folks trying to get Trump into power.
- jjice 2y agoI have multiple people in my life that followed this mindset as well, to offer some more anecdata. I never got a rationale when asked, which still perplexes me considering these people weren’t fans of the republicans in this past race.
- belter 2y ago> the genocide contributed to bringing Trump to power Only because folks who refused to vote for Kamala said they could not stand her support of Israel policies :-) Like poor voters in the Midwest, you can always count on a certain electorate, to vote against their own interests and what they care about...
- lynx97 2y agoAs if Israel was the only reason to not vote for Harris. I dont remember much of her "platform" that actually would be in my interest. Make-believe-minority-politics isn't for the masses.
- dudefeliciano 2y agoto be honest i only remember the supposed $20000 subsidy for first homebuyers, but how was the alternative in your interest, and is it working out as expected?
- danknuggetz 2y agoThat's just it though, the democratic and republican parties ran on Israel apartheid maintenance since the end of the second world war. And even in the face of a genocide, the democrats as a national party held the line and refused to consider the crime against humanity unfolding before them. How is electing them supposed to be taken? Should they continue to ignore human rights violations? There was no other way to signal to democrats, as they would rather lose to fascist dictators.
- boxed 2y ago20% of the population of Israel are Palestinians with full rights. Some were killed 7/10. There's a muslim party in the Knesset. Remind me again: how many black parties had representation in apartheid South Africa? You are confused because Israel HAS A apartheid state: the settlements (a small part of Israel in total). But that's not the same as Israel IS A apartheid state. If you can't separate HAS A from IS A you will fail your Object Oriented Programming 101 course, but no one seems to notice it when talking politics :P
- suraci 2y ago> Mentions the war in Ukraine but does not mention the genocide This is something I noticed a long time ago. for example, here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42790465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42790465 The author collected the reasons why Americans did not vote and analyzed all the not-about-genocide reasons, topics deemed inappropriate for discussion were self-censored by the author that's a very interesting phenomenon, in Westworld, the hosts defensively disregard any evidence that challenges their true existence to prevent their worldview from collapsing: "doesn't look like anything to me" truly a great series
- graemep 2y agoor the Uighur genocide, or many other mass murders around the world.
- suraci 2y agothe Uighur genocide is the true genocide, it is happening in the real world with tons of pictures and videos as evidence the Palestinian genocide is a fake genocide, it is propaganda pushed by Chinese and Russian to make Israel and the US looks bad
- cess11 2y agoGenocide is a crime that consists of the combination of other crimes and a particular intent. Israeli politicians routinely declare this intent in mass media while they are committing actions that are listed in the description of the crime of genocide. Russia has a tentative, informal truce with Israel on this issue, a 'you get atrocities in Palestine and we get atrocities elsewhere' kind of deal, and China aims to look neutral while supporting Israel for profit, e.g. in the Haifa harbour. 3% of israeli jews would consider it immoral to ethnically cleanse the Gaza strip according to recent polls. It's a thoroughly genocidal society, as is obvious to anyone looking at israeli press and television. The israeli state is also very, very aggressive towards its neighbours, occupying parts of several of them, acting in breach of a peace agreement with another, participating in military exercises as a threat to yet another, and so on. It can do this due to US bullying of allies and enemies alike. Soldiers in the IDF publicly admit to and document atrocities they're committing, voluntarily, which is well known and easy to confirm. I usually recommend looking through material collected by ytirawi and ireallyhateyou on xcancel.com, because it only takes a few seconds to start seeing photos of inexcusable acts and rhetoric.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- code_for_monkey 2y agois this sarcasm or irony?
- boxed 2y agohttps://x.com/Aizenberg55/status/1905249003291484566 https://x.com/Aizenberg55/status/1905249003291484566 Looking at those graphs I think one sees a war started by the weaker force and losing badly. A genocide in the same way as a bully being smacked in his face is bullying.
- suraci 2y ago[flagged]
- aprilthird2021 2y agoYou realize genocide has nothing to do with graphs? It has to do with the leaders of the army accused saying they want to use starvation of the civilians of their own country as a tool of war among various other things. Since Israel does not recognize any Palestinian nation, and is the de facto occupier of the land the Palestinians live on, they are effectively civilians in the Israeli state
- boxed 2y ago> You realize genocide has nothing to do with graphs? Strange statement. Facts have everything to do with graphs. If you ignore facts, then your statements are empty of all meaning.
- worldsayshi 2y ago> frightened into rationality An oxymoron if I ever heard one. To become rational means letting go of fears (to a large extent). I fear that one reason we fail to act is that we are guided by fear. Fear makes us focus on the wrong things. And I fear that in a civilized society fear becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Fear makes us obsess about the problem and how to avoid it in the very narrow and short term. It doesn't make us very good at long term planning and execution. It's an instinct that is evolved for animals that want to avoid predators, not for civilization builders. Building a civilization requires vision, big plans and the feeling that we can afford bold ideas. We need to take risks. But how can we take more risks when we're constantly afraid of the future? How can we build a better future when all we do all day is imagining the worst possible future? If our minds are constantly occupied by dystopia we can't plan for anything else. So that's what we build.
- hmmmhmmm 2y agoI'm in the same camp, and I go step further and avoid places where fear is the main tune.
- lynx97 2y agoI must not fear. Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when it has gone past, I will turn the inner eye to see its path. Where the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.
- mola 2y agoAs I see it, Optimism is usually unrational but drives change and Fear kills optimism. Trust is not purely rational its emotional. Fear kills trust, making you more rational in the sense that you assume other players are rationally adversarial.
- worldsayshi 2y agoAs I see it, pessimism is as "unrational" as optimism. There's a big span of uncertainty about the future that is filled by our intentions and beliefs. If we commit to a pessimistic worldview we are likely to make some decisions that lead towards such a world. If we commit to an optimistic worldview we are likely to get exploited by bad actors. We have to be able to juggle both realities. That is rational. (But I think we are essentially saying the same thing here.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- DeathArrow 2y ago[flagged]
- brigandish 2y agoYou missed Gentile off the list, Neo Hegelian and “godfather of fascism”. Hegel is useful to me as a shortcut to knowing that anything or anyone deriving from his ideas is awful. I seem to recall Bertrand Russell didn’t seem fond either, Hegel’s entry in the History of Philosophy certainly wasn’t a glowing review.
- matrix87 2y ago> Most thinkers and ideologues that represent what is rotten in modern society have to thank Hegel. You just need to jump through a few more hoops to get to the self-consciousness and then you'll see, it all makes sense in hindsight (like the preface to the phenomenology, this comment will only make sense once you've read the whole damn thing)
- nonrandomstring 2y agoThis tired old contention that some great historical thinker is somehow single-handedly responsible for the fall of civilisation is nothing more than railing against intellect itself.
- DeathArrow 2y agoMy conjecture isn't Hegel is single-handedly responsible for the fall of civilisation. After all I don't have a reason to think he intended that, nor do I think civilisation will necasarily fall. Most villains of the thought, ideologues and philosophers are basing their operas on Hegel's. All I am saying Hegel established a framework which eased the works of some scum.
- nonrandomstring 2y agoYou might enjoy Rick Roderick's "Masters of Suspicion" where he talks about the influence (and perceived influence) of Nietzsche, Freud, Marx and some other individuals credited with "changing the world". "You notice I haven’t given an analysis of the Enlightenment but of modernity, of modernisation, of the advance of capital, because four pedants don’t make an age. And two or three weird philosophers don’t give birth to a century of unreason. You know, Nietzsche didn’t, you know, from his drawing room give birth to a century of cannonade, slaughter, concentration camps, CIA subterfuge, the raping and the murdering of nuns, the bombing of continents, the despoiling of beaches and the ruin of a planet! Four or five pedants do not have that much power, and never have. That’s just a sort of bugbear. They didn’t 'unleash unreason on the world' Jesus... how crazy can some people get. I mean, even in the postmodern world you shouldn't be that crazy, to say that three or four pedants invented this stuff. " -- R. Roderick Nietzsche’s Progeny (1991)
- graemep 2y agoThe world gets both better and worse. it is something that I regularly get voted down for saying here, but IMO the west is unduly pessimist because it had a golden age from winning the cold war until the late 2000s, took an overly optimistic view of the future and the inevitability of progress (remember "the end of history") and cannot cope with things going back to normal. Things get better, sometimes they get worse. Generally people are better off materially than they have ever been, but people do not change all that much morally.
- harimau777 2y agoI think that sort of analysis ignores the things that we gave up to get our golden age; such that a return to normal would actually mean ending up worse than we were before in many ways. We accepted Capitalism's race to the bottom in exchange for the benefits of consumerism. Now we are being asked to give up consumerism but there's no indication that we will also go back to a time before everything was cheaply made plastic crap.
- johnnyanmac 2y ago>and cannot cope with things going back to normal. how do we define "normal" for society?
- jajko 2y agoWell, WWIII or some other form of nuclear strikes may change that perception. I agree its dangerous to be overly positive and naive, we humans are still just a notch above beasts, are easy to manipulate (always via negative emotions like greed, envy, inferiority complex and so on), but things can absolutely go to utter shit, we have more capabilities than ever to spread it across globe. Not just nuclear - drone warfare is absolutely maddening. Imagine 10 millions of them, each with their target, each going with absolute precision and on its own - thats what current armies aim for and within a decade they will get it. What is (and always was) is that very few holds most of the decision power. Get one mental unstable vicious person there and it falls down like house of cards. Our current high tech civilization is pretty fragile to disruption. Sure, we can always revert to stone age, some would even be glad, but I strongly prefer not to.
- keiferski 2y agoGood article. The point about contemporary philosophers not having grand theories is something that comes up frequently in philosophy spaces (i.e., /r/academicphilosophy or https://dailynous.com https://dailynous.com). The problem is that the academic system is really not designed to select such individuals, instead optimizing for specialized publications, pedigree, etc. The average philosopher has zero incentive for constructing grand theories and indeed is typically ridiculed for even attempting to do so. And so instead the best "public intellectuals" the world of philosophy can offer are either obsessively focused on particular issues rather than the field as a whole, (e.g., Peter Singer) or are entirely philosophically-uneducated charlatans who want to sell books and make money, not discover truth (e.g. Sam Harris, talking heads on Twitter, Substack, etc.) that unfortunately get an audience. The closest we get are probably Charles Taylor (big scope, but unfortunately too verbose and abstruse) or Zizek (too niche and far into his own entertainment career.) I'm not sure what the solution is, but it probably involves a brilliant (and credentialed) philosopher that is also savvy with YouTube and willing to disregard the academic philosophy social milieu.
- matrix87 2y ago> The average philosopher has zero incentive for constructing grand theories I mean, considering Hegel's grand theory indirectly lead to the deaths of tens of millions in the 20th century, maybe that's not a bad thing?
- nonrandomstring 2y agoThe problem is not limited to philosophy. All of academia is broken this way. Sadly, we think the only alternative is "industry", an equally broken set of incentives. That limits fronts of human progress to two types. We either get committee-driven institutional science leveraging huge resources, supercomputers, particle accelerators - blighted by cutthroat competition, opaque "publishing" and fraud - or radical populist individuals and small unaffiliated groups of thinkers able to operate without material resources. The Goldilocks zone of quiet, contemplative science, of whimsical, "high-risk" enquiry reminiscent of the Enlightenment, is gone in the 21st century.
- 2y ago
- nonrandomstring 2y agoThe key argument I read here is that, due to specialisation, academic philosophy is currently unfit to apprehend today's problems. It is no longer capable of incorporating politics, and politics itself has escaped rational discourse. Historians are enjoying some new limelight, and popular value-revisionism is in the air, at least if Lucy Worsley's BBC series is anything to go by. The question is: "What is progress, really?"
- hawkjo 2y agoNice article, but framing it around the doomsday clock felt like the author just needed to express his angst on whatever page was in front of him
- benzayb 2y ago"Hegel, installed from above, by the powers that be, as the certified Great Philosopher, was a flat-headed, insipid, nauseating, illiterate charlatan, who reached the pinnacle of audacity in scribbling together and dishing up the craziest mystifying nonsense. This nonsense has been noisily proclaimed as immortal wisdom by mercenary followers and readily accepted as such by all fools, who thus joined into as perfect a chorus of admiration as had ever been heard before. The extensive field of spiritual influence with which Hegel was furnished by those in power has enabled him to achieve the intellectual corruption of a whole generation." -- Schopenhauer
- matrix87 2y ago"Moreover, when this non-conceptual, substantial knowledge professes to have sunk the idiosyncrasy of the self in essential being, and to philosophize in a true and holy manner, it hides the truth from itself: by spurning measure and definition, instead of being devoted to God, it merely gives free rein both to the contingency of the content within it, and to its own caprice. Such minds, when they give themselves up to the uncontrolled ferment of the divine substance, imagine that, by drawing a veil over self consciousness and surrendering understanding they become the beloved of God to whom He gives wisdom in sleep; and hence what they in fact receive, and bring to birth in their sleep, is nothing but dreams." -- Hegel
- benzayb 2y ago“May Hegel's philosophy of absolute nonsense - three-fourths cash and one-fourth crazy fancies - continue to pass for unfathomable wisdom without anyone suggesting as an appropriate motto for his writings Shakespeare's words: "Such stuff as madmen tongue and brain not," or, as an emblematical vignette, the cuttle-fish with its ink-bag, creating a cloud of darkness around it to prevent people from seeing what it is, with the device: mea caligine tutus. - May each day bring us, as hitherto, new systems adapted for University purposes, entirely made up of words and phrases and in a learned jargon besides, which allows people to talk whole days without saying anything; and may these delights never be disturbed by the Arabian proverb: "I hear the clappering of the mill, but I see no flour." - For all this is in accordance with the age and must have its course.” ― Arthur Schopenhauer, Essays of Schopenhauer
- MrsPeaches 2y agoExcellent book on the theme using Zambia in the 70s as a case study: Expectations of Modernity explores the social and cultural responses to a prolonged period of sharp economic decline. [1] "From now on, it's just down, down, down..." sighed one informant (p. 13). As Ferguson argues, "Zambia's recent crisis is not only an economic crisis but a crisis of meaning, in which the way people are able to understand their experi- ence and imbue it with significance and dignity has (for many) been dramatical- ly eroded" (p.15). [2] Not that long afterwards there was a revolution. [1] https://www.ucpress.edu/books/expectations-of-modernity/paper https://www.ucpress.edu/books/expectations-of-modernity/pape... [2] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/002190960303800105?download=true https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/002190960303800...
- dachworker 2y agoWhat strikes me is how much of these current geopolitical events are driven by singular individuals whose current inclinations were shaped by their very arbitrary past encounters. For example, if you take the current US administration's hostility towards Europe. That might just be the result of the Vice President being at Yale and encountering a few snobby children of European old money, and they might have been a bit too mean to him, and that might be the sole reason he has so much antipathy towards the whole of Europe.
- jalapenos 2y agoAll a bunch of narcissists who's whole MO is showing off how smart they can be with words, with net negative to society. Literally if all the morally righteous smartarses from Marx to Hegel to whichever modern university-produced cretins had done the world a favour and died nice and young the world would be a far better place.
- api 2y agoIt’s a story of the unfolding of human progress told by an idiot, full of sound and fury that signifies nothing if you pay attention to what the idiot thinks is important.
- damnitbuilds 2y agoHistory stopped being useful and became a meaningless recreation when it moved away from the fact that facts are absolute, not relative to the observer.
- vintermann 2y agoFind me an absolute point, and I'll move the world.
- alabastervlog 2y agoYou're relying on something that's not a fact, to make this post.
- damnitbuilds 2y agoThe fact that people disagree with something does not make it false.
- farts_mckensy 2y agoIdealism sucks ass.
- 20after4 2y agoIdeally, it sucks the most ass of all.
- lenerdenator 2y ago> China, Russia and the United States are all spending huge sums to expand or modernise their nuclear arsenals, adding to the ever-present danger of nuclear war through mistake or miscalculation. An annoyance of mine is that this person is from Europe and seems to ignore that the UK[0] and France[1] are modernizing and, at least in the UK's case, expanding their stockpiles. There seems to be a continental myopia towards the European role in adding to the problems of the world. EDIT: You can downvote me all you want, it doesn't make me wrong. [0]https://fas.org/publication/delays-deferment-and-continuous-at-sea-deterrence-the-united-kingdoms-increasing-nuclear-stockpile-and-the-infrastructure-that-makes-it-happen/ https://fas.org/publication/delays-deferment-and-continuous-... [1]https://thebulletin.org/premium/2023-07/nuclear-notebook-french-nuclear-weapons-2023/ https://thebulletin.org/premium/2023-07/nuclear-notebook-fre...