11 ms·
Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
- NoNotTheGreeks 2y ago[flagged]
- drbojingle 2y agoWould be nice. Someone should slam it.
- eitland 2y agoVery likely. And sometimes I am afraid we destroy it by laughing at them for it. Recent example, someone I know: Parent: you have to come home Child: No P: It's getting late C: Go to bed Of course it is hilarious, but the reasoning is absolutely on point.
- wongarsu 2y agoThe reasoning is perfectly solid and how this conversation should go between two adults. When children talk about wanting to be adults, this is a large part of what they mean: adults are allowed to apply rules and logic consistently and fairly. If children do it they are called insolent and disrepectful
- watwut 2y agoKids don't apply logic or rules consistently nor fairly. They frequently misinterpret them on purpose and evaluate them in spectacularly unfair ways. Also, it actually make sense to want the kid to go to sleep sooner then adults and also to go home for dinner or whatever.
- dasil003 2y agoKids are spectacularly good at recognizing what’s unfair to them, just not so much at recognizing what’s unfair to others
- macrocosmos 2y agoThis depends on the kid.
- dismalaf 2y ago> just not so much at recognizing what’s unfair to others Or just don't care lol. Children love pushing boundaries. Sometimes it's good (learning a sport, improving a skill, taking on the bigger, scarier feature at the playground) and sometimes it's annoying (wanting more ice cream, staying up late, etc...). I'm convinced it's just part of growing up.
- vidarh 2y agoThey'll often recognise it just fine if the reasoning is spelled out. They can usually understand the logic, but might struggle to come up with all the steps by themselves.
- wongarsu 2y agoKids are more like lawyers than philosophers. They will argue the letter of the law and cite precedent if it is to their advantage, but avoid mentioning it if it's against them. > it actually make sense to want the kid to go to sleep sooner then adults Yes, but it isn't enough if you know that, the child has to know that, and actually agree with the reasons. If the reason is "young people need more sleep, you will be so tired tomorrow" you can make the child see that reason (let them stay up once, show the consequences, hope it doesn't backfire). You still get push back, but not for it being unfair. If the reason is that the parents want time for themselves then the child is right that it's unfair, and the better solution would be "alone time for everyone. You in your room, we in the living room, internet shuts off at 9". Similarly "we eat dinner together" is a fair rule as long as everyone is held to the same standard. You still get push back, but a fair rule is much easier to enforce than an unfair one.
- vidarh 2y agoI think part of the issue is that the child often knows that the adults reasoning is wrong or even deceptive, and as you point out that will feel unfair. As a child, I often read until 2-3am, and was just fine the following day (wish I could do that now). Any actual enforced attempt at going to sleep would have felt unfair because it'd have been earlier than I needed. What my parents actually cared about was that I was in my room, and that I got up without being cranky or letting it affect school the following day. It's much easier to "sell" the child on that, by being honest about wanting quiet time and wanting to make sure the child isn't too tired, than convincing them a bedtime they will have secretly violated multiple times without feeling too tired is reasonable. So from pretty early, my "bedtime" was "alone time" as you suggest, with the proviso that if I couldn't get up without being prodded in the morning that was evidence I was taking the piss, and the consequence would be tightening up of the actual bedtime for a while. That felt fair, and honest, and the rules were understandable, and meant I often stayed up way later than my parents would have thought was reasonable, but since it worked, it was fine, and I self-regulated.
- cootsnuck 2y agoYea, I think that "self-regulation" is one of the most important things we should be encouraging kids to learn and feel confident in.
- 7952 2y agoI guess that laughter provides a lot of context that helps learning.
- tialaramex 2y agoI would like to be sympathetic to this, because it is true that as a child I was free to do what I pleased at "bedtime" the rule being that I may not leave my room or disturb my parents, so e.g. reading until daylight is fine, playing music is not, but whether I'm "in bed" let alone "asleep" is on me. In fact of course almost always I would end up asleep, maybe not exactly when I "should" be asleep, but likely as soon as you'd end up getting a reluctant child to actually sleep if you're trying to enforce that. However, we know lots of children left to their own devices get over-tired, they should sleep but they don't and then they're much worse for it the next day. So in practice most parents are doing the right thing by insisting that children should sleep when they were "supposed" to rather than leaving them to their own devices as mine did. I have a friend who is an angry drunk. The sort of person who door staff may need to kick out of a bar before they start a fight. In his 20s and 30s, loud arguments about nothing of consequence and even occasional violence were a likely end to a previously enjoyable evening. But although he's still an angry drunk he eventually got good enough at understanding his own emotional state that by his 40s he would just leave. Instead of "We need to all go home or J might kick off" it's "Bye J, see you next week" because he's just realised he feels angry about nothing and he has ordered himself a ride home and is leaving, no fuss. This ability to self-regulate is often not something children are good at, but it's important. There's a difference between reasoning that if you eat the whole cake you'll feel bad and not eating the whole cake because you'll feel bad
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 2y agoIt's also a common communications failure, in that you'll do far better not just with children, but with adults to, if you provide a reason instead of assuming that the other party know why you're making the request you're making. Instead you're inviting pattern matching - the child will have been told to go to bed because it is late, so it's a natural statement to make if you don't understand why the parent is stating it. Explain the steps, and the consequence of failure in a way that the child can relate to, and you're likely to get a very different reaction("come home, because it's late and you need to go to bed so you're not too tired to play tomorrow"). But really, adding a "because ..." tends to improve compliance even when the reasoning isn't very sound, and even with adults. It's scarily effective as long as the ask isn't too great.
- Tade0 2y agoWhenever I laugh in such situations I make sure to point out that my child was right.
- kayodelycaon 2y agoI thought this was somewhat obvious. Kids are really smart in their limited context. It’s communication they need to learn. This is similar with people. Many people are quite intelligent, just not in a way we value or understand.
- sejje 2y agoCan you elaborate on ways people are intelligent that we don't value?
- graemep 2y agoOne thing that always strikes me in assessments of intelligence in young children (specially in comparisons with animals) is that they focus on what children can do, where as the really remarkable thing about young children is how fast they can learn.
- lordnacho 2y agoMaybe it's not that we don't value it, but that we don't recognize it. I've run into a number of ostensibly less-educated people who nonetheless made astute observations about their economic incentives. Generally a lot of game-like situations seem to have players who understand the game in some way without having any formal instruction, and without being what we normally think of a being particularly intelligent. I have a relative who does well at poker, despite not finishing school. A drainage guy I know has a good understanding of the business and where the opportunities are. In general a bunch of people in the trades seem to "get it". I've run into a bunch of these people who you don't think of as being intelligent, but if you frame something as a game, they know how to play. None of these people could be taught high school calculus, for instance, but they are still intelligent in a way that's useful to them. If we're talking about kids, from about the age of four they learn to trick you. "Dad, you have to give me ice cream. Mom says so. Don't wake her up." And it gets more and more sophisticated as they get older.
- megadata 2y agoI think their biggest enemy is distorted valuation/importance. Like sweets and toys could easily "sway" reasoning.
- codegladiator 2y agoOTOH adults reason worse than we think, practice suggests
- booleandilemma 2y agoBut are they conscious?
- riffic 2y agowere you?
- xyzzy9563 2y agoMaybe they are just a clump of cells.
- antisthenes 2y agoI think this is a good satirical comment, pointing out all the "water is wet" studies about animal consciousness. Thank you for this. It is appreciated by me, if no one else.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- damnitbuilds 2y agoThe title is somewhat unfortunate.
- sgarland 2y agoMy wife is a Montessori teacher. I showed this to her; she said that the attribute game described is used at the 2.5 year old level in her school. So yes, I’d say people woefully underestimate the abilities of children.
- MBCook 2y agoAnd birds. And fish. And… We seem to have a very very strong bias towards assuming less/no intelligence in anything that isn’t an adult human.
- damnitbuilds 2y agoI disagree. People often anthropomorphise animals and ascribe intelligence to actions that are clearly only instinctive. And people ascribe intelligence to Eliza, a 200-line Basic program.
- aithrowawaycomm 2y agoI am unable to think of a single animal behavior popularly ascribed to intelligence but in fact explainable by rote instinct. Do you have an example? OTOH there are plenty of animal behaviors that can only be explained by intelligence: seeing-eye dogs perform a task which is economically useful for humans yet far beyond the ability of AI (even if the robotics mech eng issues are resolved). But it also doesn't really make sense that one of my cats is "instinctually" able to understanding my words while the other cat is "instinctually" able to outsmart me when we play with toys. The more sensible explanation is cats are intelligent and intellectually diverse.
- damnitbuilds 2y agoSquirrels burying acorns, "wily" foxes, beaver dams, migration, etc. etc. etc.
- jiggawatts 2y agoWhile watching the Apollo 11 documentary with my four year old, he asked about the "beep beep" alarm during the landing. I explained that it was the low-fuel alarm. He gasped in shock and exclaimed: "How will they get back home to Earth?" That was impressive enough, but then he concocted a rescue mission where a rocket would rendezvous with them and refuel their ship so that they could get home. That's pretty much the current NASA plan for humanity's return to the Moon!
- iambateman 2y agoI agree with the conclusion but I’m confused about the study… It sounds like the author effectively spent a day at a children’s museum grocery exhibit and wrote a paper about it. Is there more to the underlying paper than the summary suggests? Anyone who has watched a 4-year-old for any length of time would conclude that at least some of them are capable of classification.
- paintbox 2y agoJust because it's obvious doesn't mean it's not worth investigating. And there are many people who believe that children under 7 can't truly reason, so it's not even as obvious as it seems.
- iambateman 2y agoI agree that it's worth investigating...I was just expecting more detailed analysis from an academic paper. The story linked basically says "3-5 year-olds can classify stuff into groups." For what it's worth, I have a 2- and 5-year-old, so I'd love to know more about how their brains are developing.
- ikanreed 2y agoChildren are most hurt by low expectations. Especially young children. There's subtlety to this, high demands are not high expectations. If there's consequences for not meeting some high standard you set for children, you're going to create a very life-destroying kind of learned helplessness. Kids shouldn't be punished for failure. And if it's something dangerous to try, then of course it's gotta be something you limit. But beyond that, just don't assume kids aren't ready for something without evidence. Let them try.
- worldsayshi 2y agoI think treating partial goals as bonuses is a good thing. Any goal that can be seen as a fun bonus challenge becomes more psychologically rewarding than if it's treated as a requirement? At least I find that works when motivating myself. I didn't expect that I would finish this big skirace this year. But having it as a bonus goal made it very rewarding when I actually did finish it.
- jxjnskkzxxhx 2y agoIt makes my blood boil that my kid comes from the nursery saying things like "I did an ouchie". Kids don't naturally speak like this, they are taught like this. He's 3. At home he speaks his parents languages and he sounds like a 5 year old because we don't dumb it down for him. In English he sounds like every other English 3 year old in the nursery.
- lr4444lr 2y agoSorry for sounding ornery, but it's plainly obvious to every parent I've interacted with that most preschool kids have well developed categorization skills for their toys, coloring objects, etc.
- nostrademons 2y agoThis should not be surprising to anyone who has a preschooler. They're also way better at problem-solving than most people expect, it's just that you often don't want them solving their "problems". When my kid was 18 months old, we had gated him off from a playroom with a bunch of toys used by his older brother that were not baby-safe. We had a DoorMonkey [1] placed up high, about 5 feet tall, so that only adults could reach. My kid gets a chair from across the room, pushes it next to the door, climbs up on top of it, unlatches the DoorMonkey, pushes open the door, climbs down from the chair, enters the playroom, looks at me, and says "Bye!" At that moment my wife gets out of the bathroom, sees the tableau, says "____? What are you doing?" and my toddler says "Uh oh." [1] https://doormonkey.com/ https://doormonkey.com/
- physicsguy 2y ago100%, my son will be 2 next month and he's even started saying his own name in the tone we do when we're telling him it's not safe and then giggling to himself! He can recognise a lot of birds, trees, flowers (daffodils, primroses, hyacinths, tulips) coming out in the garden at the moment, only needs to be told what it is once or twice for it to stick.
- dmoy 2y agoMy kid did the exact same thing with the phrase "be careful!" in the same intonation I used Except in her case it meant "Witness me!!, as I do something exceedingly dangerous!", or alternatively "Look at the aftermath of this dangerous thing I just did, see the blood?"
- stevekemp 2y agoI have a similar story about our child, at a similar age! He waited until I'd left the room before dragging a chair away from the dining table and then climbing it, in order to reach a toy I'd accidentally placed on a high shelf on the book-case. When I came back he immediately knew he'd been caught. Though I wasn't at all mad, it was a wakeup-call that from then on placing things too high was probably a challenge for him, rather than an absolute protection.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MrMcCall 2y agoI always suspected those researchers weren't so bright. ;-)
- nico 2y ago> TIL Psychologist László Polgár theorized that any child could become a genius in a chosen field with early training. As an experiment, he trained his daughters in chess from age 4. All three went on to become chess prodigies, and the youngest, Judit, is considered the best female player in history https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/1d9gjeh/til_psychologist_l%C3%A1szl%C3%B3_polg%C3%A1r_theorized_that_any/ https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/1d9gjeh/til_psycholo...
- MrMcCall 2y agoThere was a 3-part BBC documentary called "My Brilliant Brain" with one that featured Susan, who was the oldest and is today one of the best live chess commentators in the world. The doc talks about her father's theory and practice. His most important understanding was that the child must choose the endeavor of their own free will, and then he merely helped them optimize their learning curve. Susan has a great quote about showing up to a men's chess club, when she was still young. She said, "I don't think I ever beat a healthy man." Because they were always not feeling well, or whatever lame excuse they conjured up. The other two parts of the series are on different topics, but are also interesting, but Susan's is our favorite, and I got them long before our son started chess. And Laszlo's book on chess problems is on my son's bookshelf. It has more than 5000 "problems, combinations, and games". It's been replaced by chess.com's and lichess's puzzle games, but it is still the reference book on chess puzzles, to my understanding.
- gambiting 2y agoThe problem there is that just because you can do it doesn't mean it's good for them. I have two cousins who were trained at playing classical instruments from extremely young age(like 2 years old), one of them went on to become a very successful and well known violinist, but......she hates it. She will be the first one to say that the constant almost daily lessons were an absolute nightmare and that she's had no childhood because of it, and it also locked her into being a violinist despite whatever else she might have wanted to do. Great "achievement" for the parents, but I wouldn't personally do that to my child.
- jonnycat 2y agoThe part of the Polgár story that amazes me the most is that all three daughters showed enough interest and engagement in chess for the experiment to work so successfully. Because with my own children, I’ve seen again and again that you can encourage and expose them to certain interests, but they’re their own people - many of the things I exposed them to and tried to get them excited about just weren’t interesting to them. And that’s completely fine. I was never forceful about it and they have their own deep interests in things that I just never got into or understood. I just find it surprising that in some families, these exceptional skills and interests are so readily passed from one generation to the next.
- helle253 2y agoanybody who has spent time with kids can attest to this i have a 2.5 year old and its extremely interesting just how much her thinking is clearly 'logical', but it operates in what i like to call 'toddler logic'. If you ask kids questions, and really listen, their lines of thinking are very clearly following an internal logic. It just isnt one that is entirely compatible with 'adult' reasoning - unless the adult in the room intentionally chooses to communicate in 'toddler logic' operators. Most adults are, sadly and imo, not very good at this!
- macrocosmos 2y agoThe logic is sound, but all logic depends on the initial premises put forth. I can concoct some flawless chain of logic leading to some conclusion but it’s all for naught if the premises it is based on are invalid. An intelligent listener can listen and find where the base misunderstanding is and teach from there. Teaching from the false conclusion is a mistake.
- helle253 2y agoi dont think this is always true. sometimes the chain of logic and premise is grounded in a different ontology entirely (this is what i am referring to as 'toddler logic' for shorthand). this doesn't invalidate the conclusions or chain of logic used to derive them, when you (adult) is using different ontological anchors, which leads to different conclusions. being able to inhabit the Other's (toddler's) ontological world and navigate it with them helps sharpen their reasoning skills! they can figure out the Adult Ontology stuff later and apply those reasoning skills then. It's important to let kids be kids sometimes :) Encouraging their conclusions, and building confidence in their reasoning abilities, these are important endeavors in their own right.
- abid786 2y agoCan you give some examples? Super interesting to me as someone with no children
- nervousvarun 2y ago
- raggi 2y agoWhy on earth would you think kids are bad at reasoning? Early on we lack experience necessary for as much reliance on derivative thinking.
- erehweb 2y agoLots of people saying that this is completely obvious. I'm not so sure, but the article summary is not much help there - we are almost at the end when the researcher explains what she claims the advance is. A better article would start by explaining the advance, diving deeper into it, and then following up with how she showed this. Something to think about when we're trying to communicate complex ideas.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoA lot of my childhood memories are of being frustrated at how stupid adults seemed to think I was. If you work with children, don't underestimate them.
- falsaberN1 2y agoWhat distresses me about all this is that we are handling children like if they were a separate species....just use your memory! Of course they can reason better than we think, did everyone forget making plans and having chats with other preschoolers as a preschooler? Everyone has been one! No exceptions! And yet we act like if kids were a separate state of matter or something. This strange mental separation can only bring in bad results.
- hzay 2y agoLots of happy examples in this thread. Let me add mine. My 3 year old vastly prefers complex carnatic music to cocomelon (and its ilk). He can listen to a 15 minute, intricate song without losing interest, and will ask for it in a loop. Children can handle a lot more complexity than we generally assume.
- j45 2y agoThis will be helpful to learn from, unsure how parents might feel if they need a study to validate what they have suspected in their lives. Little humans seem to get smarter from generation to generation.
- falcor84 2y agoJust to clarify the slightly ambiguous title, it's that preschoolers can reason better than some adults thought they can, and not (as I first thought) that they can reason better than how we adults do our own thinking.
- sethammons 2y agoKid's are underestimated all the time. Some personal anecdotes that I think show off that kids know more that we expect of them: My daughter routinely remembered things, while 3 and 4, that happened a year and sometimes longer ago. She would bring them up, like "last time we were here, was before my last (2nd) birthday". Me: "wow, how do you remember that?" My friend recalls being ~2yo and deducing how to move a chair and pull a drawer to reach the top of the clothes dresser. After climbing to the top, she recalls sitting, enjoying the view, not knowing how to get down, and crying for help. My very earliest memory is before I was two. It involved an inflatable weighted balloon, the one's typically with a clown on it and if you bat it down, it rocks back upright. I saw one that was a friendly cop. I can recall several elements of the memory. I recall playing with one of those colorful wire sculpture things where you slide the blocks around like an abacus on drugs, went over to the the balloon cop, and thought to myself, "that is a good guy, why would you a good guy on a toy you hit? It should be a clown." Then I smacked it and went over to see my mom who was at the counter. Looking back, that feels like a lot of reasoning for a <2yo. Years later, when telling my mom that story for the first time, she said that the building where that was was for appointments we had when I was a year and a half old.
- phatfish 2y agoIt is possible to talk to young children in a grown up way faster than people think, at least for those that do not have recent experience with toddlers. My son is 2 1/2 and making sure we know he wants to do things his own way. But if you take time to explain a situation like an adult he backs down eventually. Or, it could be I am just boring him to death and he gives in to shut me up.
- mncharity 2y agoI've enjoyed the work of Laura Schulz[1] (MIT). [1] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C33&q=%22Laura+E+Schulz%22&btnG= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C33&q=%22...
- t-3 2y agoBetter than scientists think they could reason. Scientists also believe cats can't recognize themselves in a mirror. Observational studies are extremely error prone.
- wtcactus 2y agoThey aren’t really scientists though, they are social “scientists”. I.E. someone that feels the need to validate their pseudo science as actual science in order to fake credibility.
- mncharity 2y agoGetting things like this clarified can be a challenge. I've a hobby interest in exploring what science education might look like if we could apply much greater expertise. For example, K-1 does descriptive material properties, but it's ad hoc and crufty. Happily, industry has some nicer descriptive ontologies. So what might it look like to adapt those instead? And how might that then be leveraged, to teach other things better? Now rheological quasi-properties provide a way to quantify dynamic material properties. Like sticky, squishy, slimy, ...-y. Which raises the obvious question: Could we do Ashby charts[1], xkcd-ishly simple and discrete, in K-1? Like, foods sticky vs slimy? Well, 2D sort-into-piles is a K thing, with axes ordered and categorical. But... having both axis ordered is very rare. Button number-of-holes vs color, sure. But number-of-holes vs number-of-sides, strangely not. So is this a real developmental bottleneck? Or just the commonplace "we teach it, but we don't really use it, so there's little incentive to teach it well"? Good question - I've found it hard to get feedback like that. I wish there was an HN-like community, with education researchers and master teachers. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=ashby+charts https://www.google.com/search?q=ashby+charts