6 ms·
Raytracing on Intel's Arc B580
- im_down_w_otp 2y agoI love these breakdown writeups so much. I'm also hoping that Intel puts out an Arc A770 class upgrade in their B-series line-up. My workstation and my kids' playroom gaming computer both have A770's, and they've been really amazing for the price I paid, $269 and $190. My triple screen racing sim has an RX 7900 GRE ($499), and of the three the GRE has surprisingly been the least consistently stable (e.g. driver timeouts, crashes). Granted, I came into the new Intel GPU game after they'd gone through 2 solid years of driver quality hell, but I've been really pleased with Intel's uncharacteristic focus and pace of improvement in both the hardware and especially the software. I really hope they keep it up.
- 999900000999 2y agoI have a couple of these too, and I strongly believe Intel is effectively subsidizing these to try to get a foothold in the market. You get me equivalent of a $500 Nvidia card for around $300 or less. And it makes sense because Intel knows if they can get a foothold in this market they're that much more valuable to shareholders. Great for gaming, no real downsides imo.
- DeepSeaTortoise 2y agoThey should drop a $600 card with 128gb of vram. This is just barely possible without losses on every sale. And then just watch heads explode.
- ryao 2y agoAt current market pricing on dramexchange, 128GB of 16Gbit GDDR6 chips would cost $499.58. That only leaves $100.42 for the PCB, GPU die, miscellaneous parts, manufacturing, packaging, shipping, the store’s margin, etcetera. I suspect that they could not do that without taking a loss. I wonder if they could mix clamshell mode and quadrank to connect 64 memory chips to a GPU. If they connected 128GB of VRAM to a GPU, I would expect then to sell it for $2000, not $600.
- DeepSeaTortoise 2y agoYup, just went with the $3 per GB formula. GPU should be about $200 at TSMC (400-450mm2). + about $150 for the pcb, cooler and other stuff, I didn't consider Times a 1.6 to 1.75 factor if they like actually being profitable (operations, rnd, sales, marketing, ...). So about $1.5k, I guess. Multiply that with a .33 "screw the competition" factor and my initial guess is almost spot on. . Real problem: The largest GDDR7 package money can buy right now is 3GB. That's a 1376bit bus right there. GL fitting that to a sub 500mm2 die. In the future you could put that amount of vram on a 512bit bus, tho. Also normal DDR is getting really fast atm. 8 channel can already challenge most vram configurations. Maybe it's time soon to switch back to swappable memory.
- rasz 2y ago>+ about $150 for the pcb, cooler and other stuff, Assuming I had access to gerbers I could order replica of 5090 PCB for $65, including shipping. Intel PCB is half that. Again this is for a dude off the street buying 1-5 copies, not a bulk order.
- imtringued 2y agoThis makes no sense. Currently 24GB is the sweet spot to stay competitive and 32GB is the maximum amount of memory you could stick on a card and still have a decent memory to bandwidth ratio. What they should do instead is make the cards thinner and more efficient so that you can easily put two of them in a case.
- ryao 2y agoThey are definitely selling them at close to no profit, but they are not anywhere near subsidizing them unless they botched their supply chain so badly that they are overpaying the BOM costs.
- 999900000999 2y agoR&D isn't free. Even selling at cost is a subsidy. I'm proud to support them. Intel is also selling their lunar lake chips fairly cheaply too. Let's all hope they make it through this rough patch. I can't imagine a world where we only have one x86 manufacturer.
- hypothesis 2y ago> I can't imagine a world where we only have one x86 manufacturer. Does it even matter? Some people won’t notice even if there are zero x86 manufacturers. In fact I would say lots of people have not bought x86 CPU in while, between Mac, RPi and risc-v boards…
- 999900000999 2y agoX86 is still needed for a lot of software. The emulation just isn't there yet.
- hypothesis 2y agoThat would be news to people on mac with Rosetta Stone / Crossover.
- 999900000999 2y agoA lot of server code and specialized software won’t work. Competition is always good
- ryao 2y ago
- throwaway48476 2y agoThey won't make a B770 or C770 because they lose money on every card they sell. The prices are low because otherwise they would sell 0 and they already paid for the silicon. The intel graphics division is run by fools who won't give their cards a USP in the SR-IOV feature home labers have been asking for for years. Doing what AMD and Nvidia do but worse is not a profitable strategy. There's a 50% the whole division gets fired in the next year though.
- gruez 2y ago>The intel graphics division is run by fools who won't give their cards a USP in the SR-IOV feature home labers have been asking for for years. Intel are "fools" for not adding a feature that maybe a few thousand people care about?
- throwaway48476 2y agoA few thousand people is a lot more than the number of gamers who'd buy an Intel GPU at market price. If they don't raise their ASP into the black they're going to ax the whole division. For reference the B580 die is nearly the size of the 4070 but sells for a third the price.
- sangnoir 2y ago> For reference the B580 die is nearly the size of the 4070 but sells for a third the price. Doesn't this suggest the B580 has worse yields? Die surface area isn't directly proportional to selling price.
- sitkack 2y agoWhy would it say anything about yields? What is says is that given the die area, Intel fails to capitalize on their chip relative to a 4070.
- throwaway48476 2y ago
- sergiotapia 2y agoWas raytracing a psyop by Nvidia to lock out amd? Games today don't look that much nicer than 10 years ago and demand crazy hardware. Is raytracing a solution looking for a problem? https://x.com/NikTekOfficial/status/1837628834528522586 https://x.com/NikTekOfficial/status/1837628834528522586
- im_down_w_otp 2y agoI've kind of wondered about this a bit too. The respective visual quality side of it that is. Especially in a context where you're actually playing a game. You're not just sitting there staring at side by side still frames looking for minor differences. What I have assumed given then trend, but could be completely wrong about, is that the raytracing version of the world might be easier on the software & game dev side to get great visual results without the overhead of meticulous engineering, use, and composition of different lighting systems, shader effects, etc.
- gmueckl 2y agoWhen path tracing works, it is much, much, MUCH simpler and vastly saner algorithm than those stacks of 40+ complicated rasterization hacks in current rasterization based renderers that barely manage to capture crude approxinations of the first indirect light bounces. Rasterization as a rendering model for realistic lighting has outlived its usefulness. It overstayed because optimizing ray-triangle intersection tests for path tracing in hardware is a hard problem that took some 15 o 20 years of research to even get to the first generation RTX hardware.
- gruez 2y ago>When path tracing works, it is much, much, MUCH simpler and vastly saner algorithm than those stacks of 40+ complicated rasterization hacks in current rasterization based renderers that barely manage to capture crude approxinations of the first indirect light bounces. It's ironic that you harp about "hacks" that are used in rasterization, when raytracing is so computationally intensive that you need layers upon layers of performance hacks to get decent performance. The raytraced results needs to be denoised because not enough rays are used. The output of that needs to be supersampled (because you need to render at low resolution to get acceptable performance), and then on top of all of that you need to hallu^W extrapolate frames to hit high frame rates.
- achierius 2y agoIt feels like just yesterday that Chips and Cheese started publishing (*checked and they started up in 2020 -- so not that long ago after all!), and now they've really become a mainstay in my silicon newsletter stack, up there with Semianalysis/Semiengineering/etc. > Intel uses a software-managed scoreboard to handle dependencies for long latency instructions. Interesting! I've seen this in compute accelerators before, but both AMD and Nvidia manage their long-latency dependency tracking in hardware so it's interesting to see a major GPU vendor taking this approach. Looking more into it, it looks like the interface their `send`/`sendc` instruction exposes is basically the same interface that the PE would use to talk to the NOC: rather than having some high-level e.g. load instruction that hardware then translates to "send a read-request to the dcache, and when it comes back increment this scoreboard slot", the ISA lets/makes the compiler state that all directly. Good for fine control of the hardware, bad if the compiler isn't able to make inferences that the hardware would (e.g. based on runtime data), but then good again if you really want to minimize area and so wouldn't have that fancy logic in the pipeline anyways.
- atq2119 2y ago> both AMD and Nvidia manage their long-latency dependency tracking in hardware This is incorrect for AMD, which has "s_waitcnt" instructions in its ISA, which is publicly documented. I believe it is also incorrect for Nvidia, but don't have the receipts to prove it.
- achierius 2y agoYou're probably right on RDNA, since I haven't done any work with it myself, but for SASS I'm reasonably confident that depbar (probably the equivalent you're thinking of) is not going to be inserted after a load from global memory. You see it for things like inter-warp long latency ops, but not within a single thread AFAICT
- rayiner 2y agoThis is so cool! I think this is a video of CyberPunk 2077 with path tracing on versus off: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89-RgetbUi0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89-RgetbUi0. It sees like a real, next-generation advance in graphics quality that we haven't seem in awhile.
- vinkelhake 2y agoJust a heads up - it looks like the "Path Tracing Off" shots have ray tracing disabled as well. In the shots starting at 1:22 (the car and then the plaza), it looks like they just have the base screenspace reflections enabled. Path tracing makes a difference (sometimes big, sometimes small) for diffuse lighting in the game. The kind of reflection seen in those scenes can be had by enabling "normal" ray tracing in the game, which is playable on more systems.
- fracus 2y agoRay tracing is more intensive than "path tracing". From my understanding, they are the same with the only difference being that "path tracing" does less calculations by only considering a light source's most probable or impactful paths or grouping the rays or something. Neither scene is using "ray tracing".
- jms55 2y agoRay tracing refers to the act of tracing rays. You can use it for lighting, but also sound, visibility checks for enemy AI, etc. Path tracing is a specific technique where you ray trace multiple bounces to compute lighting. In recent games, "ray tracing" often means just using ray tracing for direct light shadows instead of shadow maps, raytraced ambient occlusion instead of screenspace AO, or raytraced 1-bounce of specular indirect lighting instead of screenspace reflections. "Path traced" often means raytraced direct lighting + 1-bounce of indirect lighting + a radiance cache to approximate multiple bounces. No game does _actual_ path tracing because it's prohibitively expensive.
- 2y ago
- api 2y agoIntel Arc could be Intel's comeback if they play it right. AMD's got the hardware to disrupt nVidia but their software sucks and they have a bad reputation for that. Apple's high-end M chips are good but also expensive like nVidia (and sold only with a high-end Mac) and don't quite have the RAM bandwidth.
- blagie 2y agoIntel is close. Good history with software. If they started shipping GPUs with more RAM, I think they'd be in a strong position. The traditional disruption is to eat the low-end and move up. Silly as it may sound, but a Battlemage where one can just plug in DIMMs, with some high total limit for RAM, would be the ultimate for developers who just want to test / debug LLMs locally.
- userbinator 2y agoSilly as it may sound, but a Battlemage where one can just plug in DIMMs, with some high total limit for RAM, would be the ultimate for developers who just want to test / debug LLMs locally. Reminds me of this old satire video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s13iFPSyKdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s13iFPSyKdQ
- throwaway48476 2y agoIntel is run by fools. I don't see them coming back. They just don't have the willingness to compete and offer products with USPs. Intel today is just MBAs and the cheapest outsourced labor the MBAs can find.
- audunw 2y agoPlug in DIMMs just doesn’t make sense. Too much compromise on performance. And that difference is just going to get bigger as packaging technology continues to improve. RAM wants to have a connection with as many traces as possible, with the shortest possible length, to the processor. Making some kind of super niche card for a small fraction of developers who might want the option to upgrade RAM, just doesn’t make financial sense. It’ll end up being more expensive for everyone compared to just buying the card with the amount of RAM you need soldered in. I mean, check the Framework Desktop. If it doesn’t even make sense for Framework, who can justify a bit of extra cost for modularity, it doesn’t make sense for any company.
- christkv 2y agoArc will be successful because it will be in all mobile chips. The individual gpu market is smaller by a big factor and they are targeting the biggest part of that market with low cost.
- KronisLV 2y agoI actually have a B580 that I replaced my old A580 with. I didn't manage to get it for MSRP (because living in Europe does tend to increase the price quite a bit, a regular RTX 3060 is over 300 EUR here), but I have to say that it's a pretty nice card, when most others seem quite overpriced or outside of my budget. When paired with an 5800X the performance is good, the XeSS upscaling looks prettier than FSR and pretty close to DLSS, the framegen also seems to have higher quality than FSR (but more latency, from what I've seen), the hardware AV1 encoder is lovely and the other QSV ones are great, though I do wish that I could get a case big enough and a new PSU to have both A580 and B580 in the same computer and use the B580 for games and A580 for the other stuff (not quite sure how well that combination would work, if at all). Either way, I'm happy that I got the card, especially with a decent CPU (even the A series with my previous Ryzen 5 4500 was an absolute mess, no software showed the CPU being maxed out but it very much was a bottleneck) and do kind of hope that I'll get the likes of performance that you get in War Thunder, or even GTA V Enhanced Edition for the years to come (yes, the raytracing works there as well) or even more recent games like Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2. If the upscaling/framegen support was even better in most game engines and games, then it could be stretched further or at least used as a band aid for the likes of Delta Force or Forever Winter - games that come out with pretty bad optimization and are taxing on the hardware, with no good way to turn subjectively unnecessary effects or graphical features off, despite the underlying engines themselves being able to scale way down. At the end of the day, even if Intel Arc won't displace any of the big players in the market, it should improve the market competitiveness which is good for the consumer.