15 ms·
What made the Irish famine so deadly
- pvg 2y agohttps://archive.is/AfeHU https://archive.is/AfeHU
- hinkley 2y ago[flagged]
- dang 2y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here. Especially not on divisive topics, as https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html requests: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive."
- hinkley 2y agoI didn’t provide citations, that doesn’t mean it’s unsubstantiated. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43326908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43326908 This is the story historians and people of Irish extraction (almost 12% of the US population, including myself) pay more attention to. Lots of people fled during the Famine and found their way to the US.
- dredmorbius 2y agoUnsubstantive != unsubstantiated. <https://www.wordnik.com/words/unsubstantive https://www.wordnik.com/words/unsubstantive> <https://www.wordnik.com/words/unsubstantiated https://www.wordnik.com/words/unsubstantiated>
- dang 2y agodredmorbius pointed it out already, but I think there was a misunderstanding here. I don't know what did or didn't cause the famine (that's why I said "maybe so" above). I just know that your GP comment took the form of an internet snark post, rather than a thoughtful informative comment. We want the latter, not the former, on HN. That's the difference, btw, between your GP comment and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43326908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43326908, which I agree was a good post. Your post and that one are taking more or less the same position but one is snarky and lacks information, while the other is snark-free and provides plenty of information.
- rayiner 2y agoA crazy fact is that a higher percentage of Irish died in the Great Famine (well over 10% of the population) than in the Bengal famine in India in 1943 (about 3.5%). This is a fascinating point: > In 1837, two years after Alexis de Tocqueville published the first volume of “Democracy in America,” his lifelong collaborator, Gustave de Beaumont, went to Ireland, a country the two men had previously visited together. The book de Beaumont produced in 1839, “L’Irlande: Sociale, Politique et Religieuse,” was a grim companion piece to his friend’s largely optimistic vision of the future that was taking shape on the far side of the Atlantic. De Beaumont, a grandson by marriage of the Marquis de Lafayette, understood that, while the United States his ancestor had helped to create was a vigorous outgrowth of the British political traditions he and de Tocqueville so admired, Ireland was their poisoned fruit. America, he wrote, was “the land where destitution is the exception,” Ireland “the country where misery is the common rule.”
- abeppu 2y agoMaybe a closer comparison would be famine of 1876-8, where some estimate go as high as 8.6M fatalities on a population of ~58M. > In its first full year, 1846, Robert Peel’s Conservative government imported huge quantities of corn, known in Europe as maize, from America to feed the starving. The government insisted that the corn be sold rather than given away (free food would merely reinforce Irish indolence) Compare this to the 1876 response in which "relief work" camps had workers doing strenuous labor in order to receive a meager ration of far fewer calories than would have been expended in the work. > ... this 'Temple wage' consisted of 450 grams (1 lb) of grain plus one anna for a man, and a slightly reduced amount for a woman or working child,[12] for a "long day of hard labour without shade or rest."[13] The rationale behind the reduced wage, which was in keeping with a prevailing belief of the time, was that any excessive payment might create 'dependency' ...
- Loughla 2y ago>which was in keeping with a prevailing belief of the time, was that any excessive payment might create 'dependency' ... Now where have I heard that recently
- jmyeet 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- markdown 2y agoUSAID has been gutted, and yes, it was political.
- fc417fc802 2y ago> every famine is political Well probably not those directly caused by natural disasters at least.
- lucideer 2y agoAll famines are caused by natural disasters. What makes them political is that people die when their ability to overcome natural disasters is restricted or removed. E.g. for the Irish Famine, the natural disaster was the outbreak of the phytophthora infestans disease affecting potato crops - the outbreak spread from North America across Europe, affecting Belgium, Netherlands, France & the UK. The cause of death in Ireland was the English exporting all food produced in Ireland that wasn't potatoes. An interestingly relevant historical record here is the Australian Convict Collection showing the number of Irish convicts sent to Australia & Tasmania for stealing food during the famine years.
- beezlewax 2y agoMany of those convicts were children.
- fc417fc802 2y ago> All famines are caused by natural disasters. I don't think I'd consider war to be a form of natural disaster, or even related to one in the majority of cases.
- ameister14 2y ago
- sandboxdev 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wesselbindt 2y agoLike the Holodomor, like the Bengal famine, this was a genocide.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- trhway 2y agoto me that is the gist. Genocide by the system without the people in the system intending it to happen (with those people even trying to mitigate its damage) It has been happening again and again - a system follows orthodoxy/ideology despite its subjects mass dying as a result, and we still don't have a machinery in place which should serve as emergency brakes on any system once that system, for whatever, and frequently even good sounding reasons at that, starts to cause such pain and suffering and deaths: >Militant Irish nationalism would follow Jane Wilde in seeing the famine as mass murder and thus as what would later be categorized as a genocide. Under pressure from Irish Americans, this even became an official doctrine in New York, where a state law signed in 1996 by then governor George Pataki required schools to portray the famine “as a human rights violation akin to genocide, slavery and the Holocaust.” >Pataki announced that “history teaches us the Great Irish Hunger was not the result of a massive failure of the Irish potato crop but rather was the result of a deliberate campaign by the British to deny the Irish people the food they needed to survive.” But this is not what history teaches us. A much more accurate conclusion is the one drawn by the Irish historian Peter Gray, who wrote that there was “not a policy of deliberate genocide” on the part of the British. Instead, Gray argued, the great failure of the British government was ideological—“a dogmatic refusal to recognise that measures intended to ‘encourage industry, [and] to do battle with sloth’ . . . were based on false premises.” The British did not cause the potatoes to rot in the ground. They did launch, by the standards of the mid-nineteenth century, very large-scale efforts to keep people alive, importing grain from America, setting up soup kitchens, and establishing programs of public works to employ those who were starving. But they were blinded by prejudice, ignorance, and a fanatical devotion to two orthodoxies that are very much alive in our own time: their belief that poverty arises from the moral failings of the poor and their faith in the so-called free market. The famine was so devastating because, while the mold was rotting the potatoes, mainstream British opinion was infected with a cognitive blight.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoThey literally fired cannons from warships at people protesting the exportation of food when they are starving to death.
- m348e912 2y agoIn 1847, one of the bleakest years of the Irish famine, Khaleefah Abdul-Majid I, Sultan of an Ottoman Empire offered £10,000 (which was quite a sum at the time) to help alleviate the suffering of the Irish people. Queen Victoria, upon learning of this, requested that he reduce his donation to a more modest £1,000, so as not to embarrass her own relatively meagre offering of £2,000. Reluctantly, the Sultan agreed, but bolstered his contribution by secretly sending five ships loaded with food. https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Britain-refuse-Ottomans-aid-to-Ireland-during-the-Irish-Potato-Famine-1846 https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Britain-refuse-Ottomans-aid-to... My conclusion is that the famine was as much political as it was environmental. (as they often are)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- genewitch 2y agoI wrote a song called greenocide where my Irish friend explained this in a particularly straightforward way. The English already owned all the land so they figured let the Irish die out. In essence.
- mritun 2y agoThat’s pretty much what the British did in Bengal.
- spacebanana7 2y agoIs there an academic source available for that?
- lolinder 2y agoWikipedia says that the provenance is... sketchy, to say the least: > The claim that he had wanted to give £10,000 first appears in Taylor & Mackay's Life and Times of Sir Robert Peel (1851), but the book is not referenced and no source is given. A second source, dating to 1894, is more explicit: the Irish nationalist William J. O'Neill Daunt claimed to have heard from the son of the sultan's personal physician that he "had intended to give £10,000 to the famine-stricken Irish, but was deterred by the English ambassador, Lord Cowley, as Her Majesty, who had only subscribed £1000, would have been annoyed had a foreign sovereign given a larger sum…" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ireland%E2%80%93Turkey_relations https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ireland%E2%80%93Turkey_relat...
- lemoncucumber 2y ago"Late Victorian Holocausts: El Niño Famines and the Making of the Third World" is a great book by Mike Davis about similar famines in the late 19th century caused by colonial powers putting profits and the sanctity of markets above human lives during periods when forces in the natural world impacted food production (climate swings in this case).
- morkalork 2y agoEerie.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoOne of the most interesting and informative books I've ever read. Depressing as fuck though.
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoSuch an amazing writer and yet I never want to read his work because... yeah. We lost a real giant.
- senderista 2y ago"There is only one thing about the Irish famine that now seems truly anachronistic—millions of refugees were saved because other countries took them in. That, at least, would not happen now."
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- soperj 2y agoMany countries took in a lot of refugees from both Ukraine and Syria. Syria used to take in refugees from all over the middle east. Canada alone approved over a million applications from Ukraine, numbers that have actually come are more in the 300,000 range.
- metabagel 2y agoBut, would that happen today? Trump has stated the intention to deport Ukrainian refugees.
- poncho_romero 2y agoTrump is not president in Canada (or Germany — see Syrian refugees). I hope this helps!
- __turbobrew__ 2y agoThere is a whole world outside of the USA.
- draw_down 2y ago[dead]
- PedroBatista 2y agoThe present could never be the past. Having said that, never in History there has been so much migration.
- umachin 2y agoThe economist Amartya Sen was awarded the Nobel Prize partially for his research on famines and the conclusion that most are social and political. He was a young child during the Bengal famine (famously not due a food shortage) and witnessed it up close.
- emmelaich 2y agoOf course food shortage was a factor; > Rice yield per acre had been stagnant since the beginning of the twentieth century;[25] coupled with a rising population, this created pressures that were a leading factor in the famine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bengal_famine_of_1943 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bengal_famine_of_1943 Add to that transport impact (floods, war), the drop in imports from Burma and other factors.
- _2d30 2y agoFWIW, your quote doesn't support a food shortage being a cause since it says nothing about the relative change of total planted acreage.
- senderista 2y agoI've always found this song about the Great Famine to be moving: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5onHLICxgc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5onHLICxgc
- frereubu 2y agoThis is another great one by Sinéad O'Connor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZIB6MslCAo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZIB6MslCAo OK, I want to talk about Ireland Specifically I want to talk about the "famine" About the fact that there never really was one There was no "famine" See, Irish people were only allowed to eat potatoes All of the other food, meat, fish, vegetables Were shipped out of the country under armed guard To England while the Irish people starved
- beezlewax 2y agoThe man in charge of the British response to the great hunger was Charles Trevelyan. He famously said of the Irish "[The Famine] is a punishment from God for an idle, ungrateful, and rebellious country; an indolent and un-self-reliant people. The Irish are suffering from an affliction of God's providence." The British actively exported grains meats and other food leaving the local population to starve. It was a famine only because they made it one.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- favorited 2y agoHe also famously suggested that the Irish should simply grow corn, if there was a potato blight. As if, in the middle of a famine, farmers can simply pivot to another crop that they've never grown before.
- hinkley 2y agoI don’t think Ireland grows corn today. The wiki page for Irish agriculture doesn’t even mention it, which I interpret as “not enough grown to be noteworthy”.
- biorach 2y agoWe grow maize, which is what we call corn, here. In significant quantities, using modern agricultural methods. Even with that the climate is not totally suitable and it is mostly used for animal feed. I very much doubt it would have been possible to grow sustainable amounts of maize up until recent decades
- hinkley 2y agoAnd unless something changes with corn strains and agriculture, possibly not again in another four or five. It's a very thirsty boy. Both in water and nitrogen.
- 2y ago
- fergal_reid 2y agoAs an Irish person when I saw the article title, I was immediately sceptical. I personally believe most articles about the famine shy away from the horror of it, and also from a frank discussion. Going to give some subjective opinion here: people generally downplay the role of the British government and ruling class in it. Why? One personal theory - growing up in the 80s in Ireland there was a lot of violence in the north. (Most) Irish people who were educated or middle class were worried about basically their kids joining the IRA, and so kind of downplayed the historical beef with the British. That's come through in the culture. There's also kind of a fight over the historical narrative with the British, maybe including the history establishment, who yes care a lot about historical accuracy, but, also, very subjectively, see the world through a different lens, and often come up through British institutions that view the British empire positively. It's often easier to say the famine was the blight, rather than political. (They do teach the political angle in schools in Ireland; but I think it's fair to say it's contested or downplayed in the popular understanding, especially in Britain.) However that article is written by a famous Irish journalist and doesn't shy away from going beyond that. Perhaps a note of caution - even by Irish standards he'd be left leaning, so would be very politically left by American standards; he's maybe prone to emphasize the angle that the root cause was lassiez-faire economic and political policies. (I'm not saying it wasn't.) I personally would emphasize more the fact that the government did not care much about the Irish people specifically. The Irish were looked down on as a people; and also viewed as troublesome in the empire. Some government folks did sympathize, of course, and did try to help. But I personally do not think the famine would have happened in England, no matter how lassiez-faire the economic policies of the government. A major dimension must be a lack of care for the Irish people, over whom they were governing; and there are instances of people in power being glad to see the Irish being brought low: "Public works projects achieved little, while Sir Charles Trevelyan, who was in charge of the relief effort, limited government aid on the basis of laissez-faire principles and an evangelical belief that “the judgement of God sent the calamity to teach the Irish a lesson”." per the UK parliament website! It's not an easy thing to come to terms with even today. I recently recorded a video talking about how fast the build out of rail infrastructure was, in the UK, as an analogy for how fast the AI infra build out could be; and I got a little quesy realizing that during the Irish potato famine the UK was spending double digit GDP percent on rail build out. Far sighted, yes, and powering the industrial revolution, but wow, doing that while mass exporting food from the starving country next door, yikes.
- hermitcrab 2y agoI went to school in the UK. Unsurprisingly, I don't think the Irish or Bengal famines were mentioned. In fact the whole British imperial project was largely glossed over. But lots of coverge of the Romans, Vikings, Normans, the black death and the two World Wars. The Belgians, the Dutch, the Germans, the Portuguese, the Italians and the Spanish also did horrible things during their colonial periods. Are these taught a schools in these countries? Genuine question - I'm curious.
- mtmail 2y agoIn Germany the colonial period is taught, for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_Conference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_Conference and global maps. The German colonies are hardly mentioned, Germany lost them all 100 years ago, and I don't think many Germans could name the countries/regions even. The https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herero_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herero_Wars ("systematic extermination of native peoples") isn't taught.
- hackandthink 2y agoThe largest german colonial project was based on starving millions of people in Eastern Europe mostly Russians. I did not hear about in school. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunger_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunger_Plan
- dmichulke 2y agoI wasn't aware of this exact plan either, but to the defense of my history teacher / curriculum: It was made very clear that millions of civilians died (even when not counting the concentration camps) due to the war of extermination (Vernichtungskrieg)
- hackandthink 2y agoI guess it depends on the decade and the Bundesland. In the 80s, the Wehrmacht was still presented as a morally decent army. That changed in the 90s, partly due to the Wehrmacht exhibition. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wehrmachtsausstellung https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wehrmachtsausstellung
- Jun8 2y agoAlthough written earlier, Jonathan Swift’s A Modest Proposal is a chilling satire about the destitute of the Irish at the time and the English attitudes toward it: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal.
- ggm 2y agoDuring this time, Ireland exported food to the mainland, lest british contracts be voided creating future doubt about the integrity of trade (or so I was taught)
- 0003 2y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZIB6MslCAo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZIB6MslCAo Sinead O'Connor - Famine
- ww520 2y agoI spent some times in Ireland and Northern Ireland recently. What the locals told me about the famine were: - Most land were controlled by large land owners. Most peasants had very small farm land, which couldn't feed the people if normal crops were planted so they had to plant the higher yield potato to have enough food. When the disease wiped out the potato crop, most people went without any food. - The land controlled by the large land owners were planted with cash crops for export. They were unwilling to stop the export to help the locals. - The ruling class consisted of large land owners and British transplants in the Northern Ireland after the conquering of Ireland by Britain could care less about the shortage of food. They actively hid the problem from the central government in Britain. The governor/duke/whoever tried to sweep the problem under the rug to avoid appearing as incompetent. - When the central government in Britain learned of the famine, they acted too late and too little, unwilling to spend money to deal with the emergency. Britain at the time looked down on the Irish people in general. This led to great animosity of the Irish people to Britain, driving the subsequent independent movements. Fun fact, about 10% of the U.S. population are of Irish descent, due to massive immigration from Ireland in the following years after the famine. Edit: Just looked up the Irish population in U.S., about 11%. https://uscanadainfo.com/irish-ancestry-in-america/ https://uscanadainfo.com/irish-ancestry-in-america/
- begueradj 2y agoIn the Akkadian empire, archeologists found that every family house had a place to store wheat and other grains. That suggests that every family had the right to own enough land to survive.
- h0l0cube 2y agoAnother fun fact: useless buildings were commissioned as a form of charity to the starving poor under the guise of gainful employment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conolly%27s_Folly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conolly%27s_Folly https://www.amusingplanet.com/2017/10/irelands-famine-follies.html https://www.amusingplanet.com/2017/10/irelands-famine-follie... Blindboy did an interesting podcast on this: https://shows.acast.com/blindboy/episodes/pineapplefolly https://shows.acast.com/blindboy/episodes/pineapplefolly
- -__---____-ZXyw 2y agoWith all the respect and admiration I have for vast swathes of the population of that fair and noble land, one could nonetheless answer this title-question in a historically accurate and quite pithy manner, by stating simply: "The English".
- padjo 2y agoExactly the answer I gave in my head after reading the title
- alextingle 2y agoIt's almost as though you didn't read the article.
- -__---____-ZXyw 2y agoI did not read it before posting my little quip, no, as I've already read a lot on the subject. My comment wasn't meant as a comment on the article, but on the title, as I thought I made reasonably explicit in my comment..? Since seeing your comment, I thought oh no, maybe I missed some context or something, so I went and read the article. It's a fine article, but as I expected, nothing new to me. My guess is that you thought I was posting my cheeky response as a "counter" to the article - I wasn't, and I see the article agrees (in more words, of course) with what I said.
- jd3 2y agoI'm Irish and this is the correct answer
- concordDance 2y agoPithy answers don't work. Almost everything is multi-causal.
- epistasis 2y ago> It disproportionately affected those who spoke the Irish language, creating an Anglophone Ireland. It led ultimately to a radical reform of land ownership, which passed to a new class of Catholic farmers. The profoundly uncomfortable truth is that Ireland started to become modern when its poorest people were wiped out or sent into exile—a reality that is too painful to be faced without deep unease. This makes the struggle to keep the Irish language feel like such a vital urge today. Those of you who live in SF be sure to check out the Unite Irish Cultural Center by the zoo. Reading about the export of so much food while people starve reminds me also of the Holodomor, a famine where farmers grain was stolen from them and exported from the country while children starved in the streets. I have never seen a precentage of the population represented as here, but the estimates are 3M to 7M died from famine in the Ukrainian SSR, and today the population is 40M. And it's not as if nobody knew what was going on, when Stalin's second wife confronted him on his actions causing so much death, she was met with such a verbal assault that she committed suicide [ https://archive.is/xsCpP https://archive.is/xsCpP ]. The greed and lust for power and money to cause the death of millions is not limited to capitalism. I know of many strong connections between Ukrainians and Irish people, and have no doubt that this rhyming history may play into it. The cause of these famines may be proximally blamed on a shortage of one type of crop, but when food is being exported from adjacent farms, as happened in both An Gorta Mor and the Holodomor, the true cause is not the lack of growing, the cause is the lack of control of the fruits on ones laber. People not being able to control their own land, not having a widespread group of smallholders of land that can benefit from their own work, from not having administrative control by the majority of people. There's a lesson for us who farm digital land; do we own the land or are we sharecropping? We must fight autocracy in all its forms, lest many of us starve. Those who oppose democracy have killed millions and will do so again if given the chance.
- jmward01 2y agoWhenever I see a tragedy, calamity, crash or whatever I almost always see one common factor: a lack of diversity somewhere. In this case it was in domestic food production. Whenever you look in nature and say 'that looks like a healthy ecosystem' it is almost always a system that is diverse and conversely when you see an ecosystem in distress it is generally lacking in diversity. As far as I know, diversity is the only real long term survival algorithm out there. [edit] I should point out that I am not commenting on the cause of that lack of diversity, just the result of it.
- epistasis 2y agoThe lack of diversity was not in food production, but rather in land ownership, and being able to own the fruits of your own labor. Plenty of food, just none of it for the Irish because they did not own the land.
- baq 2y agoDon’t forget to mention what happened when you tried to get some of that not your food so you could attempt to survive…
- disgruntledphd2 2y agoWhat, like stealing Cromwellian corn so the young might see the morn? Win a free trip to Australia!
- Gibbon1 2y agoI made a guesstimate that it was cheaper for Britain to send unemployed people to Australia than it would be to feed them.
- disgruntledphd2 2y agoDefinitely not. My line was from a very famous Irish song, called the fields of athenry, about exactly this.
- Glyptodon 2y agoSee https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Victorian_Holocausts https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Victorian_Holocausts Ireland was the prototype for the British empire starving millions to death because they were poor.
- Iwan-Zotow 2y ago[flagged]
- s_dev 2y agoLook at JetSetWilly's reply above. He's saying the British should be proud of their role in the Irish Famine and is being upvoted for it. So no -- this isn't undisputed.
- Accacin 2y agoI think JetSetWilly's opinion is not the normal in England, at least around people my age. I was always taught what a lot of people here say, that the potato blight was a natural disaster, but the British government took it as an "opportunity" and purposely did not do enough to help. In my personal opinion, I think that few people would have died if the British government stepped up, not the many millions that died as a result of their inaction. As an English person, I'm not proud of what our government did to Ireland over the years. Ireland is a beautiful country with great people, and it took a long time even to get the relationship between the UK and Ireland to where it is now.
- sunami-ai 2y agoAnswer: The British.
- xinuc 2y agoAfter some discussion with some friends from the former "colonizer", it just occurred to me that apparently it's very hard for people from those countries to appreciate their countries' role for a lot of massacre, genocide or any man made disaster like this kind of famine. They always find ways to deflect their countries responsibilities with some "reasons", although they generally agree that any kind of genocide is wrong. I think this is what we witness today too, with some massacres and genocides going on. People from those colonizer countries just can't relate to the victims. Maybe deep down they acknowledge that those genocides are good, or at least necessary, because those things are what brings them prosperity they enjoy today.
- sunami-ai 2y agoOuch. Yes. I agree.
- JetSetWilly 2y ago“The British” did not genetically engineer the potato blight. Further, in the 19th century state capacity was small and massive modern style relief programmes were not possible. Despite this, Britain managed to spend a large degree of GDP on relief. Proportionately more than it did on covid response recently, for example. The reason people deny british culpability for “genocide” is that there was no “genocide” and britain did what it was able to do, to an unprecedented degree in fact. If anything, we should be proud of britain’s response, especially knowing that it would never get aby kind of gratitude for it.
- Peroni 2y ago>If anything, we should be proud of britain’s response, especially knowing that it would never get aby kind of gratitude for it. Some examples of Britain's response: * Establishing soup kitchens for the starving, where, to acquire food one must renounce your religion, anglicise your name, and abandon your native tongue. * Provide maize for the starving and destitute but not for free for fear it would generate a sense of self-importance amongst the millions who are dying of hunger * Maintaining the exportation vast amounts of food to Britain throughout the Great Hunger * Requiring the starving who couldn't afford to buy food from the British to build pointless walls in order to earn that food * Forcibly evicting the starving and dying from their homes because they couldn't pay their rent for some reason * Denying aid to anyone who owned more than a quarter-acre of land, forcing starving farmers to give up their land and become destitute in order to qualify for relief So, on behalf of all those before me in Ireland; go raibh maith agat.
- skellington 2y ago[flagged]
- mikeInAlaska 2y agoWe went to the Dunbrody Famine ship exhibit in New Ross, Ireland a few years back. It was a neat exhibit, first they seat you in a dark small room and show a movie detailing the situation, then the wall opens up and the ship is nicely framed in the view, sitting outside in the River Barrow. They then take you out to tour the ship.
- ETH_start 2y agoThe author wants you to believe the Irish Famine was caused by free-market extremism. This couldn't be further from the truth. Ireland wasn’t starving because of free markets — it was starving because Britain’s mercantilist policies blocked it from importing food from outside the empire. The British forced Ireland to rely on their overpriced grain, banned direct imports from the U.S. and Europe, and kept tariffs high with the Corn Laws — all while millions starved. That’s not laissez-faire. That’s imperial economic control designed to keep Ireland dependent on politically connected domestic producers. O’Toole’s omission of this amounts to deception. He’s twisting history to fit a narrative, blaming capitalism while letting British trade restrictions, protectionism, and outright exploitation off the hook. The Irish Famine was a disaster of Britain's mercantilist policies. Whitewashing that to score political points for his illiberal domestic agenda is an insult to history.
- DoughnutHole 2y agoWhy not both? The mercantilist economic policy of the UK was an abject failure that made its people poorer and prevented the import of cheap food. But the UK’s unwillingness to provide sufficient aid once the famine had already started was motivated by laissez-faire politics and a Malthusian belief that the famine was the Irish’s own fault for overbreeding. Remember that the government with the support of the Whigs and Radicals actually repealed the Corn Laws, it was just too little too late. Ironically the Whig’s free market beliefs if enacted in policy much earlier might have prevented the famine from happening in the first place, while simultaneously meaning they weren’t interested in properly mitigating it once it did happen.
- ETH_start 2y agoThe blame has to ultimately be placed at the feet of the mercantilist policies. Once they restricted trade, they were responsible for the welfare of the Irish. So, these arguments that they made, that the Irish were responsible for overbreeding, were not a product of laissez-faire ideology, just their bastardized understanding of it.
- anovikov 2y ago[flagged]
- donall 2y ago> Catholic church that pushed people to reproduce without limits [Citation needed] It's hard not to interpret this as just garden variety bigotry, of the same sort that caused the famine in the first place. Let's assume it's correct, though. The Catholic church had been one of the most powerful organisations in Europe for well over 1000 years by the time if the famine. Why did it take until Ireland in the 19th century for their population mismanagement to become truly problematic? Also why did this not also happen in a country like Spain? Hard to find many more enthusiastically Catholic countries than Spain in that time period. The population density of Ireland at the time of the famine was comparable to England (it is now much lower). Ireland produced enough food to feed itself and millions of people in English cities at the time of the famine. The issue was not a lack of food but the "ownership" of the food. The account of capitalism emerging from the black death is a fine theory for continental Europe. At the time of the black death, Irish society was controlled by Irish people. After the 1600s it was increasingly run as a colony, with the indigenous culture outlawed and intensive resource extraction for export to England (timber, food, etc). You might as well ask why industrialisation didn't take off among the Choctaw or the Cherokee. Or maybe they also just have the wrong religion?
- anovikov 2y agoEasy peasy, famines were commonplace in Spain during the Middle Ages (not sure how about part of it that was controlled by the Muslims though, but i don't think it was much different). During the Middle Ages, famines (and epidemics) were the natural regulator of population and were seen as a normal thing. By the XIX century of course, things were very different.... In Spain at the period, there were no famines because people kept emigrating to the colonies. Ireland was itself a colony. That's the difference. In Eastern Europe where countries didn't have colonies, famines were a norm. Irish one is seen as something special because it happened in the West, and because overpopulation there built up for a considerable time being allowed by potatoes farming that for the time being, provided plenty of food allowing population to build up. Then it backfired. As for local populations pre-existing in the colonies, sure they almost all died out. To a much larger proportion than the Irish, and sometimes, went entirely extinct. That is the normal part of absorbing new lands. It's just that Ireland was Christian almost since Christianity became a thing, and was never "discovered", that made it special. But we shouldn't pretend like it wasn't normal or in any way exceptional overall. Genocide is a natural way in which nations interact.
- SwtCyber 2y agoThe parallels to modern crises are unsettling, especially the idea that -the market must be obeyed at all costs-
- switch007 2y ago[flagged]
- aprilthird2021 2y agoIreland is full of resilient people who fought and bombed their way to their own freedom from the British. I think they will overtake the British economy before 2825
- rsynnott 2y agoThe Irish economy overtook the British one by most measures some time ago (arguably partially as a result of the UK’s problems with regional development; the British economy, at this point, is verging on basically just being London and its immediate area).
- automatic6131 2y agoYes, the Irish economy is bigger than the British, all you have to do to get that answer is: count all the revenue of famous Irish corporations such as Apple, Microsoft, Intel (and others) as Irish revenue, and divide by the respective populations (6M and 70M). Definitely do not think any further about these measures, just report them as Ireland ^ and UK v.
- switch007 2y agoLol exactly
- rsynnott 2y agoYes, GDP figures for Ireland and other small open economies (and, for that matter, _London_, which has the same sort of dynamic) are pretty useless; this is fairly well-known. However, Irish average wages overtook UK ones after the financial crisis, concrete economic activity is generally higher (for instance, Ireland builds about 2.5x the number of housing units per capita per year), the Irish state pension is higher, Irish unemployment is lower, Irish inflation is much lower, and so on. And it’s much starker when you compare Ireland to Northern Ireland (the bit of Ireland that the UK still runs), or, really, to the North of England or most other UK regions (again, really, the whole UK economy hangs off the south-east). The idea that Ireland would be _better off in 2025_ if it had stayed part of the UK is… pretty out-there, to be honest. The UK is simply very bad at regional development. Ireland _was_ an economic basketcase for a very long time, but then, realistically, so was most of the UK; more or less since WW2 the UK outside of London and the south-east has been looking pretty unhealthy.
- rorytbyrne 2y agoI grew up on a farm near the hills of The Burren in the west of Ireland. If you look closely, you can see walls made of stacked stones cross-crossing the hills, as if to demarcate farmland - but those hills are not arable farmland, so why? The British refused to offer free food to the starving, so they made people build these completely pointless walls to “earn” the food. They’re now known as the Famine Walls. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Famine_walls https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Famine_walls
- t43562 2y agoMy parents were Irish,English so I'm always caught in the middle. It's obvious that many English people are inclined to ignore the opium trade or the famine and think about bits of history that make them feel good. I'd just mention that almost nobody is without skeletons in their national closet of one kind of another - probably less bad. I am 50 and my understanding has changed over time. Like every teenager I wanted to be proud of who I was but fortunately being a mongrel creates a note of discord in one's head - who to be proud of? The need to feel proud is a driver of all sorts of shit. We shouldn't feel ever more than a little proud or proud of what we personally have done but I'm not even sure of that. It's always a simplification. One should not have to call on history to respect oneself. Irish people made use of the Empire too and went to the colonies to seek their fortunes. My dad was one. I was born in one and saw the recent Irish immigrants behaviour - they were a mixed bag like everyone else. Most were sort of ok and one or two were atrocious but not more or less than anyone else. As a gross over-simplification, I think history is about people conquering other people and building larger and larger groups which become kingdoms then nations then empires or federations or unions. I get this feeling that it's mathematical. Whoever can organise on a large scale will absorb whoever is smaller. So if we want to have a reasonable future, we must learn to organise on a large scale with negotiation and rules/laws so that someone can't absorb us by doing it the violent way.
- throwawaymanbot 2y ago[dead]
- throwawaymanbot 2y ago[dead]
- pbiggar 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thunkshift1 2y agoThe brits made it deadly
- g8oz 2y agoThis discussion is a relevant time to recommend the fantastic book called "Late Victorian Holocausts: El Niño Famines and the Making of the Third World" by the indomitable late Mike Davis.
- banku_brougham 2y agoCalling it a "famine" is a controversial choice.
- adultSwim 2y agoThe British?
- AStonesThrow 2y agoThis may be an unpopular take, and my 99.6% celtic DNA won't justify it, but perhaps St Patrick still hasn't stopped driving the snakes out of Ireland, and these days he's resorted to famine, insurgency and abortion to accomplish it?
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/JxMPq https://archive.ph/JxMPq