6 ms·
E Ink’s color ePaper tech gets supersized for outdoor displays
- jackgavigan 2y agoThere are also plans to use E Ink's technology for digital art: https://inkposter.com/ https://inkposter.com/
- geodel 2y agoPriced between $600-$2000. It can be themed for particular occasions, great for places like corporate offices, hotels which already spend quite a bit to look chic.
- deadbabe 2y agoWhy art, I want to put photos on it that swap out every so often.
- kusokurae 2y ago[dead]
- jsheard 2y agoIs the image fidelity really good enough for that? I thought color e-ink had pretty limited bit-depth and gamut.
- cogman10 2y agoIt's not. They have 4k colors available. Good enough for an eink reader, not good enough for art display.
- hapidjus 2y agoNot all art would work but you could definitely find works that could work within the constraints.
- sho_hn 2y agoThe Kaleido panels features in this article indeed do 4096 colors, but the Spectra 6 panels also from E-ink can be a bit more - they mix particles of 6 different primary colors, and with some advanced dithering in place you can get pretty impressive results that really look quite pleasing. Still, there's a lot of details to consider and trade-ofs to make wrt/ content, and Spectra refresh is also dead-slow. Perhaps to their credit, E-Ink isn't even trying to hide the refresh in their marketing material: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hr_EQaqTK0M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hr_EQaqTK0M (second half has a lot of examples of poster-sized Spectra 6 and Spectra 3100 panels).
- nashashmi 2y agoThe price point is too painful for home use unless you place your frame high above inaccessible without ladders. It should be used for billboard advertising. You don't even need that many PPI pixels per square inch because of how high above it is, and it would save ginormous bucks on printing canvases and technicians changing the ad. Not to mention, timed advertising.
- hansonkd 2y ago> The price point is too painful for home use unless you place your frame high above inaccessible without ladders. When i read this comment i had to go look at the product because i was expecting 10-20k. Looks very reasonable to me. The most expensive is only $2500? and the cheapest only $600? Seems super inline with what I would expect to pay for art.
- jolmg 2y agoYou're not paying for art. You're paying for paper you can later display art on. Also, with e.g. an oil painting on canvas, the cost of producing that is the time of the artist to paint it by hand. I don't think 10-20K is anywhere reasonable for e.g. a mass-produced inkjet-printed thing. Likewise 10-20K for a PNG file would be even more insane.
- bitdivision 2y agoThe displays seem to be available for around $250 https://www.waveshare.com/product/13.3inch-e-paper-hat-plus-e.htm https://www.waveshare.com/product/13.3inch-e-paper-hat-plus-...
- mariusandra 2y ago$250 is just part of the price. I just went through the process and made this for myself: https://www.printables.com/model/1189455-waveshare-133e-6-color-e-ink-spectra-parametric-ca https://www.printables.com/model/1189455-waveshare-133e-6-co... The total price was around $420. This includes shipping, taxes (to Belgium), a pi zero w2, a sd card, and printing a case.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TriangleEdge 2y agoI'd like a smaller one in my home that I could interact with programmatically. Something that could hold weather forecasts, family calendar events, reminders, pictures, etc. I like the matte look of e-ink.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chainwax 2y agohttps://usetrmnl.com/ https://usetrmnl.com/ This was recently shared here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42137513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42137513
- whamlastxmas 2y agoI own 5 of them and love them!
- m463 2y agoCan you point these at your own server instead of theirs?
- jwithington 2y agoYes https://docs.usetrmnl.com/go/diy/byos https://docs.usetrmnl.com/go/diy/byos
- sho_hn 2y agoHere's the one I built for my home: https://imgur.com/a/NoTr8XX https://imgur.com/a/NoTr8XX This is still a black and white panel, but it's not that different with the color ones. Feel free to reach out if you have questions.
- generj 2y agoHow was your battery life performance? I’ve been (slowly) working on a similar project and it’s been easy to get it running on my desk hooked into power but much more difficult to elegantly frame the panel that can just live on a wall.
- CommieBobDole 2y agoCould the folks at E Ink not afford a stock photo of a mall to Photoshop their product into for their press release? That first image looks like a fever dream.
- stevewodil 2y agoWhat is the issue?
- 1317 2y agoi didn't notice it at first either look at the names of the shops
- jodrellblank 2y agoLook at the name of the shop on the left. It's an AI stable-diffusion type image. Look at the person standing on the right in the background who sort of has two heads? The top right the upper walkway has a blue glass wall which also waterfalls into the white wall. The shop on the left, where is that dress? Inside or outside? The window to the left of the dress with the white rectangle outline is in front of the dress at the top of the picture and behind it at the bottom of the picture.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoIt looks like it was AI generated, which makes us question if the product is also AI generated and doesn't really exist. I'm sure this is just bad advertising, they didn't take a shortcut with the product but they took a shortcut in showcasing the product, to the detriment of people actually believing if this is a real product.
- grayhatter 2y agoif you ignore the dystopian hellscape that this comment is about to glorify... this does seem like the ideal (commercial) use case for AI imagery. The first being because I was only interested in the color gamut or fidelity of the eink, I completely filtered out the atrocity that is that AI generated mall... The AI generation they used is very well trained to produce images that, with only an instantaneous glance has no artifacts that immediately jump out as out of place. I'd describe it as a background blur you're less likely to notice. The caveat being a blur would be completely unremarkable, while this background is... unfortunate... fever dream does seem quite apt.
- atulvi 2y agoAll I want is a Guernica sized borderless home art display.
- rbanffy 2y agoE-wallpaper you can lay out modularly sounds like an amazing use case. Tiling edges would need patterned conducting/insulation adhesives but with some clever protocol negotiation each wallpaper tile can self-identify and display the pixels assigned to it. With some printed antennas it can be powered via RF for changing the image and then left unpowered.
- m463 2y ago> Dimensions 349.3 cm × 776.5 cm (137.4 in × 305.5 in) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guernica_(Picasso) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guernica_(Picasso) interesting!
- chainwax 2y agoI personally love this. I have a pretty strong distaste for bright screens everywhere and rather like the look of e-ink screens. I'd love a future where we move away from putting up LCD panels on every surface we can advertise on.
- sho_hn 2y agoI think seeing more public spaces shift away from emissive displays and putting more emphasis on quality lighting again would definitely be interesting. What mainly limits the applications for this tech is that full-color refresh is very slow and very ugly, so it prefers static content. For public spaces this could mean a greater emphasis on graphic design quality as well, since you'd probably only want to refresh out of sight of customers, e.g. outside of business hours. The problem is that puts it into a pretty narrow band of application of displaying information that only changes infrequently, but often enough to offset the high cost of the panels vs. just having someone put up a new print. Overall my gut feeling is that the economics just aren't quite there yet without some more effort put into changing the equation. For examle - I think that E-Ink should actually kind of try making the refresh experience have its own aesthetic. Right now the refresh on the Spectra panels looks like the panel is having a seizure. If they could make it look cool (e.g. doing it a fancy geometric pattern or something), it might make it OK to refresh while being seen.
- zimpenfish 2y ago> information that only changes infrequently, but often enough to offset the high cost of the panels vs. just having someone put up a new print Bus advertising. According to people I worked with back in 2010 that were working on LED panels for buses[0], changing the vinyl advertising on a London bus took something like 3 days. Which is a long time for a bus to be out of service. An e-ink panel is a great solution - lightweight, zero power use until it needs changing, and the refresh rate doesn't really matter. [0] Didn't succeed because LED panels at the time were big, low-res, bulky, and extremely power hungry.
- michpoch 2y ago
- Imustaskforhelp 2y agoI had this idea , a long time ago , my thinking was that e inks don't actually require energy to store data , so effectively we could use e inks for advertisement and only change them when needed , effectively being the best of both worlds ie. less energy cost / carbon emissions and more cost effective / removing the labour aspect of removing / putting up bill boards Advertisements are a fundamental part for a company. Depending on the type of company , it would still make sense for bill boards to be put out. Hot take , but advertising onlines are a threat to security unlike bill boards , most online ads actively try to promote malware simply because of how easy it is to create an ad (google ads , more like yeh you can promote your spyware for homebrew by paying us a buck or two from the money you scam by your infoware) I also don't like ads , simply because they don't understand me. But some do , there are many ads from my country that I & many others do. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVvmLakUtXE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVvmLakUtXE see this , an ad for bike in indian economy Try to guess the number of views , seriously , I am talking to anybody reading this , to genuinely try to guess the number of views for a video whose length is exactly 1 minute. Its 8.3 Million Some people compare it to be a better song than many cinema movies songs for which you go to and pay with your cash https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvGwIFVUK7M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvGwIFVUK7M This ad is by Jindal , I got this in my recommended , yes a ad as a video shoved in my recommended. Some commentors comment how they saw this ad in their movie cinema before the start of movie. And they said , that they felt that the movie they spent on the cinema was already worth it because of this ad alone! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvGwIFVUK7M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvGwIFVUK7M This has 20 Million Views ! I am sure that many american / other countries also have such advertising. But I don't like apple like advertising / bland . Maybe its just me , but I like the old style so much more. Filled with emotions and art , yet it doesn't cross a line of being over. It just fits in perfectly. I am 16 years old and though I don't use twitter , though I don't use facebook / I was never in the time for my space. I still feel nostalgic for that era. I like how old twitter looks. I like how myspace functioned. In fact I created an account on spacehey just for that. I like the old style liked videos , square box , it makes me feel as part of something greater , a bit nostalgic. Also just remembered hamara bajaj ad which is also really nice. from the hero splendor ad that I linked in first link Tu hai toh main hu aur manjilo ka ghar aana chalta rahe A very rough english translation would be You are therefore I am , and let the dreams come to our house. Lets keep going. It captures emotions perfectly. I have spent 15 minutes writing this post & I have no regrets. Thanks for reading.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoI am a little skeptical of this application of e-ink. Is this really cost effective or environmentally friendly? Compared to an LED or OLED panel, sure, but how does it compare to ye olde poster behind glass? If you're willing to give up on snazzy animations anyway, how many times would you have to change the poster before the color e-ink is cheaper?
- ChrisNorstrom 2y agoYes. E-ink doesn't need electricity to show an image, it only uses small amounts of electricity to change the image. Technically, if it ran on batteries, you could pop in some batteries, change the advertisement image, and then take the batteries out and the image would stay like that permanently.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoRight, but how much does the display itself cost compared to $15 to print a poster out and stick it in a frame?
- outworlder 2y ago$15 times the number of posters you want to rotate. Plus the labor to replace them, multiplied by the number that you have.
- floydnoel 2y agoelectricity isn't the only resource to consider, however
- toast0 2y agoHaving a connected display gives advertisers a huge amount of control that they desire. Being able to control the time of day that your ad is shown is a pretty big deal. Being able to edit or take down a poorly considered ad campaign very quickly is also a pretty big deal. Coordinating paper ads and other media is tricky, because the companies that manage the advertising display inventory only have so many workers and therefore only so much capacity to do changes.
- mrkpdl 2y agoSeeing panels of this size is making me want eink whiteboards for planning meetings.
- rbanffy 2y agoTied to AI listening agents drawing as you speak.
- brcmthrowaway 2y agoDoes anyone know where to buy used/surplus digital signage screens?
- rbanffy 2y agoOr panels with slight defects.
- jameslk 2y agoJust wait until they’re on all the walls, floors, and ceilings. In every window of every car and building. Every surface that is blank. The low power required for eink displays makes them an ideal candidate for this use case. Programmatic ads for the physical world. Pick the part of the world you want to see your ad and it’s there. You’ll never have to see an adless canvas again
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoMy Inner Grammar Nazi[0] twitched at this: > Kaleido 3 is good to used as Digital I first thought it was a mistake from New Atlas, but it is actually on the main eInk site: https://www.eink.com/brand/detail/Kaleido3-outdoor https://www.eink.com/brand/detail/Kaleido3-outdoor They are a Taiwanese company, but a fairly major one, so mistakes like this are a bit jarring. [0] http://queenofwands.net/d/20031003.html http://queenofwands.net/d/20031003.html
- novaRom 2y agoDestined to become "best seller" if Aldi/Walmart/Ikea could offer 75" with 4K RGB for $150-200. This would be a perfect indoor wall decor in any room, kind of ultimate poster.
- oefrha 2y agoLol you can hardly get a 7.5’’ for that price. I once looked into making a few programmable ePaper “posters” for myself, and noped out of it when I saw the price.
- mariusandra 2y agoHaving gone through such a search just recently: - This 13.3" panel cost ~$420 to make https://www.printables.com/model/1189455-waveshare-133e-6-color-e-ink-spectra-parametric-ca https://www.printables.com/model/1189455-waveshare-133e-6-co... - This 7.3" panel cost ~$150 to make https://www.printables.com/model/1189420-waveshare-73e-6-color-e-ink-spectra-parametric-cas https://www.printables.com/model/1189420-waveshare-73e-6-col... This includes shipping the panel from waveshare.com, paying taxes, adding a raspberry pi zero w2 + a sd card, and printing a case
- thefounder 2y agoI think you can’t even get them for $1500 - $2000
- daemonologist 2y agoMy understanding is that the yields on large eink panels are horrendous (which is why they cost thousands and thousands of dollars). I would definitely buy one at that price though.
- asoneth 2y agoA 31.5" color e-ink poster is ~$1700[1]. I do not know what these large panels cost but (possibly due to low yields) eink panel prices seem to scale superlinearly with area. I would expect a 75" panel that is five times larger to cost more than a used car. Anything can become a "best seller" if you are able to arbitrarily lower the price by multiple orders of magnitude -- $500 luxury cars would fly off the lot but would not be profitable. [1] https://inkposter.com/products/spectra-133 https://inkposter.com/products/spectra-133
- solarkraft 2y agoOf course they’re trying to pitch it for ads. But ads are intentionally intrusive, so they’re kind of missing the whole point.
- mattmaroon 2y agoIf this were accessible at a reasonable price to food trucks they’d buy it left and right for their menus.
- pathikrit 2y agoCool! I make this as a hobby project: https://framed.news/ https://framed.news/ Would be cool to have a color option too
- elric 2y agoLooks great. I would be very happy to see this used for timetables and service announcements in and around public transport.
- Klaster_1 2y agoThe future is dim.
- nottorp 2y agoHmm why are all those companies trying and failing to make "smart" AR glasses. All they need is to come out with a product that covers billboards in real time. uBlock Origin for real life.
- goda90 2y agoYou could use them to replace everything with messages like in They Live https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yjw_DuNkOUw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yjw_DuNkOUw
- nottorp 2y agoNo in They Live the messages were already there but they were conditioned not to notice them consciously without the glasses.
- BaraBatman 2y agoFunnily enough, a few months ago, inspired by They Live (and by a Simpsons episode) I tried to do exactly that as a POC: block real life billboards https://bart.fly.dev/ https://bart.fly.dev/ https://github.com/bart-ai/bart https://github.com/bart-ai/bart Ideally, one would use something like this on an AR headset/smart glasses and block unwanted stuff from their view
- crazygringo 2y agoAll the examples in the photos are clearly lit, so the idea that these won't use power or will be unlit doesn't seem plausible. Just think of how many paper ads are lit from behind, when you're walking around a mall or airport. Second, the contrast is bad. Most colors wind up looking washed out. It can be nice for reading, but advertisers want their ads to pop. I don't see this taking off for advertising at all, because advertisers won't like it. What it does seem more useful for is informational signage. Building directories, maps, etc. Because those don't need to be lit, and the e-ink can be a lot higher resolution than a lot of jumbo LED displays.
- navi0 2y agoThe Innovator’s Dilemma supports your last paragraph but will likely make your first two paragraphs age poorly. The tech will continue to improve if it finds its niche. Dynamic, low power, color informational signage displays are a big enough market by themselves to adopt and support enough product cycles to address shortcomings that advertisers have. The potential for no mains power (e.g., small solar panel or a vibration energy harvesting power source) means virtually any flat wall could be turned into advertising inventory. Do accident lawyers need their ads to pop or just be displayed over and over again?
- SXX 2y agoWhat you say could be correct for a lot of technologies, but not this one. E Ink tech do not have much traction because of "E Ink" the company and their patents. Basically it's highly proprietary and they dont want to give away control over know-how and production. Until major patents expire no one will it touch with a ten-foot pole.
- catlikesshrimp 2y agoabout energy efficiency of lighting, maybe they can move the lights depending on the time of the day. For some ads at least (like roadside) Unfortunately, advertisers prefer the most distracting light intensity they manage. Only regulation can solve that.
- mystified5016 2y ago
- diego_moita 2y agoSo, it is a product that has no vivid colours, no fast refresh, no video, is more expensive than a big television (i.e.: more interesting to steal if outdoors) and "doesn't cause light pollution" (i.e.: doesn't stand out the way you want adds to do). What are its advantages then?
- rcarr 2y agoCan any of the big e-reader companies just please release an A4 sized color e-reader? It can clearly be done, why are we still stuck with black and white for the 13 inch ranges?
- gamblor956 2y agoCurrently, the cost of the panel alone would be nearly $1000. Yields on Kaleido-family screens aren't great (and are supposedly even worse for Gallery, the high-quality color panels) and they get even worse for larger panel sizes.
- cjameskeller 2y agoFor ~$600, the Remarkable Paper Pro has a color, 12" diagonal display. https://remarkable.com/store/remarkable-paper/pro/details/features https://remarkable.com/store/remarkable-paper/pro/details/fe... I don't have one, but it's closer to what you mention.
- thefounder 2y agoA real killer for me would be to make them rollable.
- bryukh 2y agoThe interesting part here isn't the color - it's the temperature range (-15°C to 65°C) and massive 75" size. This could enable practical solar-powered information displays at bus stops and other public spaces.
- Zopieux 2y agoCan we agree that the first picture used to illustrate the article (and the original source on the seller's website) is AI generated? Where is the disclaimer?
- ashoeafoot 2y agoWhite wall and roof in summer, black wall in winter?