9 ms·
> I've ironically lost more money the more closely I've paid attention to my investments Money Magazine a few years ago compared various investment strategies
by WalterBright 2y ago
> I've ironically lost more money the more closely I've paid attention to my investments
Money Magazine a few years ago compared various investment strategies in stocks. The #2 best performing one was investing in the S&P 500. The #1 best performing strategy was the "dead man strategy".
The dead man strategy comes into play when the investor dies, and his estate gets frozen until it winds its way through the courts. It turns out that doing nothing with your stock investments is (statistically) the best strategy.
I know for a fact that when I do nothing with my stocks, they also perform better.
- safeimp 2y agoDo you have a link to that article?
- WalterBright 2y agoI wish I had clipped and saved it. I can't even tell you what year it was. Sorry. But what I wrote is all one needs to know about it. Here's a similar article: https://www.businessinsider.com/forgetful-investors-performed-best-2014-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/forgetful-investors-performe...
- safeimp 2y agoThanks anyway, this is still interesting.
- WalterBright 2y agoThe conventional wisdom is to sell your profitable stocks, to "lock in your gains", and sell your losers to "cut your losses." I call that "minimizing your gains" and "locking in your losses", and just hold instead. If I "locked in the gains" I would have missed out on 10x returns. Of course, I did ride Enron all the way to zero (!), but it didn't matter. Think of it this way - buy 10 stocks. 3 go to zero. 6 have modest returns. 1 is a 10x winner, that more than makes up for the failures, and becomes the tentpole for your assets.
- WalterBright 2y agoI have a friend who retired, and decided to go into day trading. He spent hours each day glued to the trading portal, making trades. After a year, he ruefully admitted that he'd have made significantly more money if he'd simply done nothing.
- jpcom 2y agoSometimes I ask GPT to run Bayesian analyses on varying hypotheses. I just did that for the several parent comments to see if we could get some reasons as to "why day trading doesn't work." Perhaps this will amuse you as well: https://chatgpt.com/share/67888cf4-1aa4-8011-b46b-77e5e9da125f https://chatgpt.com/share/67888cf4-1aa4-8011-b46b-77e5e9da12...
- WalterBright 2y agoYes, thanks for posting it!
- semi-extrinsic 2y agoIs there any reason to believe the probabilities involved in those computations are not just coming straight out of rand()?
- chii 2y ago> 1 is a 10x winner out of 10 stocks, 1 being a 10x winner is an absolutely rarity and the fact that you would manage to pick it is pure luck tbh.
- WalterBright 2y agoQQQ is up 5x in 10 years. Being an ETF, that means many of its components must be 10x. I suppose it's dependent on your time horizon. MSFT is up around 10x since Nadella took over. It's more common over 20 years, obviously.
- 2y ago
- WalterBright 2y agoP.S. I'm not a financial advisor. Make your own decisions.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> turns out that doing nothing with your stock investments is (statistically) the best strategy The only thing a small investor can control are fees. Minimising transactions minimises fees.
- WalterBright 2y agoYou also get heavily taxed for the short term gains.
- eru 2y agoDepending on jurisdiction.
- eru 2y agoNo, you can also control diversification and taxes.
- tombert 2y agoThis doesn’t surprise me in the slightest. Most of my investing is just in passive S&P index funds, but I do occasionally buy individual shares. Sometimes I make decent money, sometimes I lose money…turns out I consistently do worse than the S&P long term. I treat buying individual shares as yuppie gambling at this point. It can be fun, but it’s usually a bad strategy.
- Scoundreller 2y ago> I treat buying individual shares as yuppie gambling at this point. It can be fun, but it’s usually a bad strategy. Naw, that's boomer gambling. Options are yuppie gambling.
- tonetegeatinst 2y agoI thought that was shorting biotech stock days before clinical trial results get announced?
- Koffiepoeder 2y agoFor extra flavour, also invest solely using loaned money, preferably a student loan that never goes away!
- eru 2y agoYuppies were a thing in the 1980s. I think you have your timelines off.
- fakedang 2y ago> I treat buying individual shares as yuppie gambling at this point. It can be fun, but it’s usually a bad strategy. I would actually recommend the opposite - buy shares of a few companies that you know exceptionally well. That is, not just the companies, but also the market, the industry trends, etc. Charlie Munger recommends holding 5 stocks at max, while Peter Lynch suggests industries that are tangential to your work and daily life. Both solid advice. Revisit the list every year, and you'll already do better than most of the blind duds investing in the S&P500 (which arguably contains a lot of duds). The problem with most ETFs is that you'll still be investing in a bunch of dud companies, whose only reason for staying in the market is by virtue of being big (think HPs and IBMs, for example).
- kqr 2y agoA few years ago cost structures for managing one's investment portfolios were also significantly higher than today! There's an even better alternative for someone willing to put in the leg work: (1) Figure out your investment horizon. For many people, this is way shorter than suggested by generic advice, which makes some diversification beyond "stonks go up" meaningful. (2) Figure out what costs you'll incur by rebalancing etc. (3) Write a short script that optimises the amount of activity in portfolio management that improves performance over your investment horizon, given your costs. Unsurprisingly, the result can vary a lot between people. The result is most likely going to involve a very low level of activity, but the process of finding it out is very informative. What I've found out (and this is replicated also by more authoritative people like Carver) is that for almost everyone, mixing in some 10--20 % of a safer asset like 10 year bonds and rebalancing yearly outperforms a pure equity portfolio over most realistic investment horizons.
- Galanwe 2y agoAgree with you 100%, I did the same simulations and found the same result. I would suggest a step beyond though, because rebalancing your portfolio is fun year 1-5, but not so fun year 5-20: have a look at e.g. Vanguard retirement target funds. Essentially, it's an ETF with a rebalancing rule included for a specific target date. For instance if you buy the target 2050 (your hypothetical retirement age), the ETF rebalances itself between bonds/monetary fund/stocks until it reaches that date, u til it's pretty much all cash in 2050. Lowest hassle diversified retirement scheme I found.
- kqr 2y agoThis is one of those things where again, one will have to weigh the costs of both alternatives. A rebalancing ETF usually has higher costs (management fees, but possibly also internal trading costs that show up as performance beneath benchmark index), but of course, manually rebalancing also has a cost – the cost of one's time and effort!
- agos 2y agoVanguard's ETFs are really cheap. The retirement funds in question are like 0.24%, which is in the cheaper range for ETFs
- WtfRuSerious 2y agoI can think of at least one situation, like expiring options, that you wouldn't want to have happening during your "court frozen" period...
- kragen 2y agoI assume that in-the-money options are automatically exercised at expiration in the dead-man situation?
- Shocka1 2y agoYes, they will automatically exercise if your dead, the same way they auto execute when you are alive. I have sold many options over the years, with many of them exercising. If they expire ITM, you don't have a choice (whether dead or alive) past expiration.
- kragen 2y agoThank you for the confirmation!
- graemep 2y agoDoing nothing saves trading costs which are a major drag. The standard advice for equities investors (at least in the UK) has been to invest in tracker funds for a very long time. it is possible to beat the market. Many years ago I double my money in approx an year - but I invested heavily in I had been covering as a analyst (one of my previous careers) until immediately before. I am more cautious now.
- matwood 2y agoTrading fees are at or near zero in the US now unless you mean capital gains.
- graemep 2y agoNot what I meant, but capital gains are another issue, but I am not in the US. In the UK we pay a 0.5% tax on ever transaction and often around £10 per transaction, so its quite substantial. I should probably have said costs, not fees. How much are total costs in the US? If you trade frequently even low costs add up. If its 0.1% and you trade monthly it ends up being 1.2% over the course of an year.
- matwood 2y ago10+/trade is going back to the early 2000s for the US. Now it's effectively 0 for most common trades. Here is Schwab for example: https://www.schwab.com/pricing https://www.schwab.com/pricing If someone is a big options trader they can probably find a better per contract price out there.
- celticninja 2y agoThis is the same for cryptocurrency. The people who lost accessa and subsequently regained it usually made more than those with ready access who sold earlier or played the market.
- dmos62 2y agoSo invest in s&p 500 and do nothing, right? That's a good strategy for someone young, because it makes sense to be risk tolerant then. As you age you want more and more of your portfolio in bonds/cash, because you want the reduced fluctuation in purchasing power (i.e. comfort) that that brings you. These are the bare fundamentals of portfolio management.
- eru 2y agoIf you are young, you might even want to invest more than 100% of your portfolio into the S&P 500.
- belter 2y agoDid they include the Monkeys? "Most successful chimpanzee on Wall Street" - https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/most-successful-chimpanzee-on-wall-street https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/most-succ...
- yard2010 2y agoThis reminds me of that Mythbusters episode in which they test what is the fastest strategy in a traffic jam or congestion - switching lanes or keeping your lane. IIRC the result was that it's the same, but zigzagging makes you feel it's faster
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoThat's worked for me, for well over 30 years.
- Workaccount2 2y agoJust yesterday it was announced that Bitfinex will be returned the 95,000 bitcoin that were lost in a 2016 hack. These coins will be returned to the account holders which were affected by the hack. At the time the bitcoins were lost, they were worth ~$575 each. Today those returned tokens are worth close to $100,0000 each. I doubt anyone who was affected by that hack realized they just got involuntarily forced into the best investment of their lives.
- fckgw 2y ago> These coins will be returned to the account holders which were affected by the hack. I haven't seen any reporting on that. Bitfinex, the corporate entity, is receiving the coins recovered from the feds. It's up to Bitfinex how they device to dole out those funds, if at all. When these things happen, often times exchanges will make their customers whole by giving back the monetary value of the coins at time of loss. It's very rare they repay them 1:1 in bitcoin.
- ElevenLathe 2y agoIANAL but it seems like whoever is running Bitfinex should endeavour to make all the creditors whole in whatever medium their debt was denominated, according to seniority. So if they owe users X BTC and other creditors Y USD, and the BTC debts are senior, they should hand out the BTC to users regardless of its dollar value and, if there is any left, auction it off for the benefit of the (junior, in this scenario) USD creditors.
- fckgw 2y agoThey could, but there's nothing requiring them to do so. AFAIK the only crypto company who have been hacked (and there are a lot) and returned funds as BTC and not in dollars is, ironically, Mt. Gox. Users got repaid in Bitcoin 10 years after the fact. FTX bagholders were compensated ~120% in "equivalent value" dollars. Lost crypto was not repaid.
- Workaccount2 2y agohttps://support.bitfinex.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003282929-Recovery-Right-Tokens-RRT https://support.bitfinex.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003282929-... Apparently they created a token that entitles you to the lost bitcoin should they be recovered.
- LoveMortuus 2y agoHow can I use the 'dead man strategy' if I've just started investing and don't own any stocks? Because if I already need to have some stocks, than this being the #1 strategy feels like those advice that you get on the internet where if you want to be rich just get born into a wealthy family. Statistically probably true, but not really doable. :/ I feel like you can only do the 'dead man strategy' when your already dead, since before that it's probably better to keep adding money into the portfolio.