8 ms·
China to Build Thorium Molten-Salt Reactor in 2025
- karaterobot 2y agoWell, good. It's a shame nobody else has stepped up to do this first. Maybe China doing it first will help get the ball rolling.
- topspin 2y agoTheir ball is already rolling. They put a pair of high temperature gas cooled pebble bed reactors into operation a little more than a year ago. They're actively exploring every avenue of nuclear power without restraint, including thorium and fast breeders. It hasn't yet occurred to the Chinese that the prosperity afforded by abundant energy is a problem they're supposed to be solving.
- jvanderbot 2y agoWell, good. It's a shame nobody else has stepped up to do this first. Maybe China doing it first will help get the ball rolling. /s In all seriousness, I think they were referring to getting everyone else's proverbial balls rolling.
- chii 2y ago"China's energy independence will threaten our national security!" -- trump, probably...
- lazide 2y agoWell, at some non trivial level it’s also true. The petrodollar and the US’s central role in protecting/enabling it is great for US national security.
- chii 2y agoI think the petrodollar has been given more weight than it deserves. The dollar's utility enabling international trade has more to do with the stability, freedom and general availability, than with the US enforcing it in any way.
- lazide 2y agoThe US spends more on its military than any other country, and actively gets involved in foreign affairs on this front constantly. And has bases in every country in the Middle East except Iran - [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_military_installations https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_military_in...] The dollar is strong because the US military is everywhere. The US military is everywhere because the dollar is strong. And oil is the strongest and biggest motivation for all this, but not the only one. Though the US military burns massive amounts of oil to operate.
- braincat31415 2y agoNot quite. You should look, for example, into the events of 1971, specifically, US policy regarding foreign exchange rates. Using dominant US dollar position, the US has achieved re-evaluation of exchange rates favoring US exports. As a concrete example, US Treasury Secretary drove the pressure to open European agriculture markets to US exports, weakening European farming industry in the process. Similar moves were made against Japan and South Korea.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoOh, they know. They've added 200GW of solar power this year.
- dmd 2y ago> the prosperity afforded by abundant energy is a problem they're supposed to be solving. What does this mean? Did you misplace a word somewhere? Why would prosperity be a problem?
- topspin 2y ago> Why would prosperity be a problem? Excellent question.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoThe way I read it is that the amount of energy available for direct use translates directly to the quality of life. The more energy they have, the more they can do with it. Plus if it’s clean and readily available. Instead of being world’s factory for garbage, or figuring out how to invade Taiwan, figure out how to supply clean, “reasonably cheap” nuclear energy.
- oniony 2y agoAny nation with effectively unlimited energy will develop directed energy weaponry.
- johndevor 2y agohttps://www.copenhagenatomics.com/ https://www.copenhagenatomics.com/
- panick21_ 2y agoThey will hopefully run their first reactor in Switzerland by 2026/2027.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoI’m pretty sure I first heard about China doing this 15 years ago or so. I guess it just takes a long time to go from project planning to reactor?
- chii 2y ago15 yrs is not that bad from conception/design to a prototype.
- tim333 2y agoYou could argue the US did this first with the 1964 oak ridge experimental reactor. Still it's good China is continuing the experimental reactors. That's how science progresses. No one's really tried producing a commercial thorium reactor because it isn't really commercial so far - the costs are much higher than uranium.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- miohtama 2y agoIndia stepped up first, as for some time now: https://youtu.be/k-o8zYEEsik?si=ZNcl0nNQa5DVvGmq https://youtu.be/k-o8zYEEsik?si=ZNcl0nNQa5DVvGmq Though looks like China might win the race.
- ggm 2y agoCommence, maybe. Given their lead in pebble bed, I wonder why? Probably competing teams and competing funding and goals. Thorium was in test decades ago in the USA and its applicability to large scale power with lower proliferation risk is given. I think the article's pointing out how much usable thorium China has as a side effect of rare earth mining may get to the heart of things: people with giant trash piles look for ways to monetise.
- grecy 2y ago> I wonder why? To learn. Do we need a better reason to try something new?
- ggm 2y agoNope. But I suspect it's beyond learning. The Chinese may understand nuclear power better than almost anyone else, France not withstanding. I could believe this is a strategic move, to diversify power input sources as well. Look I am not knocking learning, but I don't think thats the key drive here.
- hangonhn 2y agoyeah I think that hypothesis has legs. China has been trying to diversify their energy portfolio for a long time now. They're also going full steam ahead on wind and solar and is the world leader in battery storage (lithium ion and other types too). Fossil fuel, other than coal, has always been a major weakness for China that can be choked off via the Straits of Malacca. I wonder if powering their reactor using thorium from their rare earth minerals mining is significantly cheaper than using uranium. Thorium also have the advantage of a very low weapons proliferation risk so it might be easier for China to export thorium reactors. This may play into China's long term plan to develop the global south as an alternative market (and counterweight) to the West.
- ninetyninenine 2y agoI mean learning for learnings sake is more surprising then learning for a purpose.
- acidburnNSA 2y agoWoah, looks like this article has a major error in it right up front: "The project follows a 2-MW experimental version completed in 2021 and operated since then. " They completed the TMSR-LF1 back then, and got authorization to turn it on, but have never announced startup or operation, as far as I'm aware. I've actually been bracing for the headline since 2021 because it would be the first time we operated a molten salt reactor since Oak Ridge's MSRE shut down in 1969. For all its purported benefits, fluid nuclear fuel has major challenges because the extraordinarily radioactive fission products are no longer held up inside the fuel pins, but rather are flowing around the entire primary system, coming into intimate contact with (and plating out on) pumps, heat exchangers, the vessel wall, instruments, valves, etc. etc. My guess is that they ran into some trouble with containing this, or remotely maintaining the primary equipment. FWIW, the US started up a commercial thorium-fueled reactor back in 1961 at Indian Point 1 [1] (previously known as the Consolidated Edison Thorium Reactor [2]). We replaced the thorium with enriched uranium in the second core, and all subsequent cores, because it was a lot more economical. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1sWqmPyoYxw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1sWqmPyoYxw [2] https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015086582338&seq=33 https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015086582338&se...
- AnthonyMouse 2y agoWhat makes uranium more economical, fuel production or some aspect of operation? And if it's the first one, is that just lack of scale for thorium or something else?
- godelski 2y agoUranium is pretty abundant. The US has a lot, China twice as much, Kazakhstan a lot more, and Australia puts everyone to shame. Thorium isn't ready to be fuel and must be enriched (granted, you need to do this for uranium too but some is naturally in a fissile state). So there's things like breeder reactors that enrich during the cycle but this is challenging and presents other issues such as turning it into weapons manufacturing (increase proliferation concerns). There's a lot of small details that matter a lot. Fwiw, the parent has written a fair amount on this and runs a website with a lot of useful information for anyone curious. You can check their comments too as they usually participate anytime nuclear comes up https://whatisnuclear.com/thorium.html https://whatisnuclear.com/thorium.html
- wesselbindt 2y agoBut at what cost?
- blacksmith_tb 2y agoNot sure if you mean financial cost, or possibly environmental / human losses - but since it's in the middle of a desert, I assume they're trying to minimize the risk?
- vuurmot 2y agoIt's a meme. Just google "china but at what cost" There are probably hundreds of articles with the title at this point China is getting smarter - but at what cost? https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-50658538 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-50658538 China's wind industrial policy "succeeded" – but at what cost? https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/energysource/chinas-wind-industrial-policy-succeeded-but-at-what-cost/ https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/energysource/chinas-wi... China Invests in Environment – but at What Cost? https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2018-04-20/china-takes-different-approach-than-us-on-climate-change https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2018-04-...
- deyiao 2y agoThe sources you've listed don't seem to show any environmental damage. In fact, China has been leading among major nations in environmental protection efforts in recent years. For instance, the destruction of natural forests has been virtually halted, and China has been the most successful country in combating desertification through massive reforestation projects. Ironically, some Western media outlets are now criticizing China for "having too many trees" and reducing desert areas across the globe.
- vuurmot 2y agoWhat are you on... I am not interested in the political slinging that both the west and china deploy large capital in. I just think it is funny
- rachelgunn 2y ago[dead]
- cynicalsecurity 2y agoI don't understand why the West hesitates with nuclear power.
- kleton 2y agoAbout one third of China's politburo, including Xi Jinping, have degrees in Engineering. The West's leadership is all attorneys or finance.
- cedws 2y agoIn the case of the US, the latest president is a failed businessman who is more concerned about trans people, abortion, and immigrants than progress. According to media I’m supposed to hate China but I don’t hear Xi Jinping spouting nonsense like that.
- makeitshine 2y agoYou can hate the Chinese system for how it limits human rights, cracks down harshly on dissent, and stifles many creative outlets. Hating China or the Chinese people, which are like anywhere, generally lovely people, is silly. There's plenty of nonsense coming from the mouth of the Party, but it doesn't make the US news, because it's not aimed at the US. There's also a lot less news overall which discusses and critiques the Party and what its representatives say, for obvious reasons.
- russli1993 2y agolol, abortion is perfectly legal in China, the government doesn't control women's bodies. Certain policies are more set and less up to discussion after a period of experimentation. Political system in China is more geared towards not letting human or interest groups desires reflected in national policies. Instead, national policies reflect the common good and common sense. And political system helps to unify common sense, values, individual knowledge. There is healthy level of diversity, but also a necessary level of unity to prevent extreme polarization, left and right fighting. For example, no prostitutions, human trafficking, surrogacy, so women from disadvantaged communities are not taken advantage of after decades of that happening in Qing and ROC era. Instead, they are given opportunity to have a proper education, such as in STEM. And they have the opportunity to work in 5G, AI, semiconductors, EVs, batteries, medicine, which interestingly, USA government doesn't want Chinese citizens to work on. U accuse China has no human rights, but China moved from the country with the worst women's rights to one amongst the highest amongst East Asian countries. In my view, women's societal standing in China is equal or higher than South Korea and Japan. And leaps better than India, the largest "democracy" and country closest to China's level 100 years ago. No drugs, harsh on drug trade, production. So disadvantaged communities are not exploited by drug dealers. We will not let what is happening in the US with fentanyl crisis happen to us. U accuse China caused US"s fentanyl crisis because we make the drugs. Lol, so if we make the drug then why don't we have fentanyl crisis? Shouldn't be its much easier to sell and traffic it where it is produced? Drug issue is a demand problem, there is a demand in the US, no matter how much you squash the supply, people will find a way to make it. U need to end it at the demand side. Climate policy is set now, no debate on some company can get lax air pollution policies to help their bottom line. Economic policy is free market, center right, but with basic social safety net in health care, pensions, poverty, high level of social safety net in education, security, crime levels. We worked hard to lower the price of solar panels, so the world has an alternative energy source in age of global warming. Yet, u accuse us of evil intent to dominate and overcapacity and now expanding hydrocarbon production. So, is global warming not an issue anymore? Or was global warming a narrative used to attack China? The reason we worked hard on lower price of solar is in a perfect free market, solar has to compete with coal and natural gas. And it takes technology and innovation to reduce cost. Cost reduction is a good thing, Moorse law is also cost reduction, if we don't have cost reduction, we will still be using Pentium 3s. So, sorry a lot of solar companies went down, because they can't compete on technology, supply chain, and manufacturing. Ur competitor is not Chinese solar companies, ur competitor is cheap coal and gas. Unless ur solar industry is banking on government subsidies for the rest of their lives. But wait, I thought the west is against government subsidies. U say Chinese government stifles many creative outlets. When Chinese people work on, dream and create 5G, tiktok, DJI, EVs, solar panels, batteries, semiconductors, AI, phone apps, games, USA is attempting to kill them all, taking away Chinese people's freedom, rights to survival, development and dream. So Chinese people can only do certain things approved by US government? The only thing we approved to do is to overthrow our own government? Or civil war in our country? Or have our country broken into many pieces? Everyone has the right to pursuit of happiness, not Chinese people according to USA. And how interesting the West is stifling Chinese speech by saying their Chinese propaganda? Speech is "free" if it agrees with West narrative, it is propaganda when it does not. I used to admire the USA, but not these days. When Chinese people are doing better, being empowered, USA 's response is to attack, oppress, sabotage Chinese people's livelihood. Instead of "it's nice to see good human progress", "we have trade and commerce disputes, but let's resolve that by making the pie bigger for everyone". Tesla and Apple can sell their products without government led market and non-market obstruction, let me know if I can buy a BYD or Huawei in the USA. And US import tariffs of Chinese goods is now much higher than the reverse. USA accuse us stealing your jobs, no, your own companies shipped these jobs overseas, you should ask your own companies, not attacking some mom and dad working in factories to support their kids in another country. USA is already the richest country on Earth, your problem is most of your wealth is concentrated on top 1%, instead of distributing your wealth better, or help the people in need, you attack regular mom and dads' livelihoods in another country, making them not able bring food for their families. And most people cheer for this and think it is moral? Great values you got there.
- cyberax 2y agoEh. Just like the first reactor, this is going to be a toy for scientists. Thorium reactors are a dead end. Just keep building regular PWRs, operating on regular fuel (maaaaaybe MOX fuel). That's it. It's a proven, scalable method.
- merb 2y agoI‘m not in favor of nuclear at all. But I do not like the term ‚are a dead end‘. If everybody would do that we would probably not have blue led‘s and that would’ve hindered the growth of many modern computing devices.
- cyberax 2y agoThe problem is that the amount of effort we can spend on nuclear energy is finite. And we _need_ it. We have a good, well-known solution that has been in wide use for 60 years. So we just need to build it.
- anyfactor 2y agoThorium powerplants, nuclear fusion powerplants, solid-state batteries, quantum computing, and TSMC producing chips in the US are news that should be considered speculative until they go into production. There has been plenty of coverage, but little real-world utility or impact from these technologies so far.
- err4nt 2y agoCool! Hope it works well and convinces more people to try it (if it works out)
- grumpystiltskin 2y agoThe reason the United States pretends like it doesn't have plenty of rare Earth metals, is because of the insane anti-nuke cult that causes you to have to discard thorium as if it was a dangerous waste. Thorium is usually co-deposited with rare earths. So nobody in the United States or Canada can afford to mine or process rare earths because they can't afford to dispose of bananas. Or Rather thorium which has the same radioactivity as a banana.