7 ms·
Insurers rely on doctors whose judgments have been criticized by courts
- ceejayoz 2y agoThis seems like a good spot to start with policy changes: > In interviews with ProPublica, federal judges criticized a system that fails to address problems that arise in court case after court case. They faulted the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, which governs many insurance claims in court, for not allowing for punitive damages, the sort that can rise into the millions of dollars and deter companies from bad conduct. > To one federal judge, who like others spoke about cases on condition of anonymity, doctors and the insurance companies they work for essentially get off scot-free. “They might have to pay 10 claims,” the judge said, “but if they can avoid paying a thousand claims, then why would they change anything?”
- nothercastle 2y agoFraud is the business model and it pays extremely well
- the_errorist 2y agoWhatever happened to Primum non nocere.
- NickC25 2y agoReminds me of a joke i once heard: a regulator walks into an insurance corporate office and exclaims "wait a second, you're supposed to be running a racket! instead, you're committing fraud!" while in a parallel universe, the same regulator walks into the same office and exclaims "wait a second, you're supposed to be committing fraud! instead, you're running a racket!". the regulator then slams his head against the wall, and realizes that there is no parallel universe - that insurance corporation is indeed blatantly running a racket AND committing fraud on a massive scale. RICO charges need to hit, and stick.
- xyst 2y agoMiddle class Americans have been dealing with this awful middleman for decades. Peaceful protesting got us nowhere. Politicians are bought by these conglomerates. Court systems give these companies a slap on the wrist. Only thing I have seen work: full sending 3 bullets into a healthcare industry CEO. The subsequent public indifference was quite eye opening. Didn’t matter if you identified as Liberal, Democrat, Progressive, Conservative, Republican - it was a unified response across the nation. Conservative talking heads getting ripped apart by own audience for being “out of touch.” Democratic leaders (Tim Walz for example) getting ripped a new one for fake sympathy. We are well beyond “policy changes”, especially as we go into this next administration.
- hahamrfunnyguy 2y agoThese "doctors" should be barred from practicing medicine. I am not a lawyer, but it would seem that this practice also borders on criminal negligence.
- ceejayoz 2y agoOddly, it's not currently considered to be. > Having the weight of an MD behind a decision can be powerful, but lawyers and judges who’ve handled these sorts of cases say it can be misleading. Although doctors ultimately determine whether to cut off insurance coverage for a particular treatment, those decisions are generally not considered the practice of medicine and therefore cannot be challenged in a malpractice lawsuit. The doctors advising insurance companies can’t be individually sued on medical grounds, even if something goes wrong after the denial. As a result, their names are cited in lawsuits filed against the insurers, but they are not defendants in suits brought by people denied insurance.
- franktankbank 2y ago> Oddly, it's not currently considered to be. Odd indeed. Is it some semantic thing? Denying care is the purest form of not practicing medicine?
- ceejayoz 2y agoI'm guessing it's some thin veneer of bullshit like "well, the patient can still pay $500k directly out of pocket, so we're not technically interfering with the care, just the payments!"
- razakel 2y agoThey're not the responsible clinician, so they're not practicing medicine. It's like taking legal advice from me: I'm not your lawyer (or even a lawyer) and I'm probably wrong. But it was your decision to take it.
- ceejayoz 2y ago
- NickC25 2y agoMore light needs to be brought to this, and serious action needs to be taken on behalf of insurance policy holders, NOT on the behalf of shareholders of "insurance" corporations. Well done, Propublica. Keep it coming!
- Aunche 2y agoIronically, I think that the increased attention to the denial of claims plays straight into insurer's hands. Healthcare isn't expensive because insurers don't pay enough to healthcare providers. In fact, it's the opposite. The ACA mandates that at least 80% of premiums must go towards medical expenses. This means that insurers are actually incentivized to overpay for care to maximize the size of their 20% slice. If we want to decrease healthcare costs in the US, we need to focus on how insurers are failing to negotiate on behalf of consumers.
- londons_explore 2y ago> incentivized to overpay for care to maximize the size of their 20% slice. This. You see it anytime you mandate some profit cap or limit as a percentage of revenue. Companies will just manipulate the other variable to get more profits. Or they'll buy other related companies so they can do sneaky internal pricing shenanigans.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoOnly if no competitors exist, or all the competitors are colluding.
- londons_explore 2y agoI feel like nearly every industry is colluding, at least a little, with a "we wont screw you over if you don't screw us over" approach. Competition focuses on trying to expand the market, rather than screwing a competitor and stealing all their clients.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoThat is a unnecessarily narrow definition of competition, and businesses don’t steal clients (absent illegal methods), they provide better products or services at a preferable utility to price ratio such that customers choose them over another business. Just like a person performing better in a job interview isn’t stealing from other applicants who performed worse.
- azalemeth 2y agoI'm not American and grew up (and work) in Western Europe. Everyone is born, and, at some point, will get sick and die. Why does each of these cost tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars? I've heard American doctors at conferences describing their system as "the worst imaginable". Every American I know hates their system. It costs a lot more, has worse outcomes and shovels money and privilege towards the rich. Why don't you change it? What are the reasons why moving to a single payer system is so bad? Denmark has the same system as the NHS, puts more money into it than the Brits do, and has some of the best health outcomes in the world. If a politician seriously suggested copying them -- with an income tax deducted at source with employee and employer contributions -- what would happen?
- alistairSH 2y agoCombo of the truly wealthy buy politicians AND many professionals and union employees have employer-subsidized health plans AND 100 years of “socialism bad!” messaging from the political right.
- afthonos 2y agoEveryone hates “the system”, including the people in it. But every party of the system is perfectly fair and reasonable for the people benefitting from it, even if they hate every other part. So every part of the system will have people fighting for it—and if you try to change the whole system, the entire system will fight you. It’s an equilibrium, even if it’s obviously far from optimal.
- potato3732842 2y agoAnd it has only gotten worse with time. https://www.statista.com/statistics/184968/us-health-expenditure-as-percent-of-gdp-since-1960/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/184968/us-health-expendi... That's 20% of the country that will be less well off if you "fix" healthcare in any meaningful way and the overwhelming majority of them will fight tooth and nail to prevent that from happening. That is a hell of a minority to overcome when the issue is one of personal economics (i.e one everyone will experience directly, not some abstract social policy thing that people will ignore as long as their lives are good), dare I say basically impossible in a democracy. (yes I know I'm assuming that the healthcare industry is a cross section of the country, no I don't care if that isn't 100% accurate)
- ShinyNewFeature 2y agoIn many jurisdictions in the US, there is a requirement for the casino and lottery operators to pay a certain percentage (typically 90+%) back as winnings. Do health insurance companies have to follow similar requirements? If so, individual cases of insurances denying insurance would be bad, but would indicate that the overall system is still working reasonably well.
- Someone1234 2y agoIndeed, they do. The ACA set a 80% requirement. Unfortunately unintended consequences have resulted in that meaning it benefits health insurance companies to increase the cost of care so their 20% share is more.
- feoren 2y agoHealth insurance companies conspiring with each other and with providers to drive up costs is not an unintended consequence of the ACA, it is a predictable consequence of monopolistic collusion. Imagine saying "all the grocery stores are intentionally increasing the cost of eggs in order to increase their cut" -- that's just straightforward illegal behavior that should be a slam-dunk anti-trust suit. Don't blame the ACA for that.
- Workaccount2 2y agoThe tragedy at the heart of this "hate health insurance companies" is that they aren't even very profitable businesses. Their margins are actually below average, and pretty poor investments compared to things like tech and finance.
- ceejayoz 2y agoWalmart has low margins, too. Still a very profitable business, because the raw revenue numbers are so huge. The same applies to health insurance.
- Workaccount2 2y ago
- xyst 2y agoThe absurdity of American healthcare industry can be summed up by this series by “Dr. Glaucomflecken” on YT. Some of the videos are even based on Propublica journalism. https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpMVXO0TkGpdvjujyXuvMBNy6ZgkiNb4W https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpMVXO0TkGpdvjujyXuvMBNy6...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- unwise-exe 2y ago<< To do so, court records reveal, the insurers have turned to a coterie of psychiatrists and have continued relying on them even after one or more of their decisions have been criticized or overturned in court. >> ...ok? Is ProPublica seriously trying to assert that they should be barred after a single decision ("one or more" includes "one") has been criticized ("criticized or overturned" includes "criticized but upheld")?
- paxys 2y agoWhat do you call someone who graduates bottom of their class from the lowest ranked med school in the country? Doctor.
- geodel 2y agoTrue. This makes me think long list nothing burger achievements that IT/ Software/Agilist folks put on Linkedin seems inspired by medical field where everyone is hero and saving lives.
- toasted-subs 2y agoThe entire medical system when it comes to the court system is unbelievable. I live in one of the largest medical centered cities in America. Yet I had multiple doctors tell me and did things to me other doctors told me should be considered medical malpractice. When I went to try to sue I found there's literally one judge who could deal with it but they refuse to even try to deal with my case in the court system. Then the doctors try to shame me for dealing with my issues without taking the meds which the Doctors themselves told me would make my situation worse. Instead I get a ride through Charlie's Chocolate factory showing me how America works.
- rqtwteye 2y agoQuestion for the techies here: Due to lack of political will and deep-seated corruption I believe a lot of issues in the US system are almost unfixable but I always wonder why it has to be so convoluted (besides being hyper-expensive). Why can't the insurers have an app where the patient (or the provider) can type in the procedure codes they are planning to use and then the insurer returns the co-pay, co-insurance and other cost based on the plan the person is in? The insurer must have these systems already internally so why not mandate to give access to the calculations to patient? I had several occasions where I tried to figure out how much something would cost and the answer was "we can only tell you after the procedure was done". This seems to be totally doable to me.
- patja 2y agoIn my experience this behavior is due to the fact that they don't really know on the insurance side how the care provider is going to code something until they have actually done the procedure and have submitted it with the coding. And there is a very high wall between the insurance/patient billing side and the care providers, even in a case like Kaiser where they're all employees of the same company.
- nradov 2y agoInsurers have an app where the patient (member) can type in a procedure code and see prices for local network providers. It's literally right there in every member web portal! Every health plan has sent out multiple notifications to their members! How are people still not aware of this? https://www.cms.gov/healthplan-price-transparency/consumers https://www.cms.gov/healthplan-price-transparency/consumers
- rqtwteye 2y agoI have never received anything.
- HDThoreaun 2y agoTrump actually forced hospitals to release their prices during his first admin. There are a few problems. First, quite a few hospitals refused and just took the fine instead. More importantly though, theres no standardization of codes. Your procedure might sound routine but there are usually quite a few different things being billed and there usually isnt a one to on relations hip between codes at different providers. Even if there was standardization a lot of the time unforeseen stuff comes up so you cant just get an out the door price before the procedure.
- Yeul 2y agoIf an insurance company has a problem with a doctor they shouldn't take it out on a patient.