11 ms·
AI company that made robots for children went bust and now the robots are dying
- fajmccain 2y agoThis is the premise of the short story 'The lifecycle of software objects' by Ted Chiang. In that story the employees of the company take it upon themselves to maintain their human-like pets. If the concept of future AI/robot friends like this 'dying' is of interest to you give this story a read: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7886338-the-lifecycle-of-software-objects https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7886338-the-lifecycle-of...
- riwsky 2y agoBeat me to it!
- 101008 2y agoI came to comment this. It was a weird story, to be honest. Like I didn't know where it was going, but at the same time I couldn't stop reading it. Highly recommended it.
- emmelaich 2y agoand partly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supertoys_Last_All_Summer_Long https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supertoys_Last_All_Summer_Long Made into the film https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A.I._Artificial_Intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A.I._Artificial_Intelligence
- ahazred8ta 2y agoDitto the shelter for obsolete dinosaur-toys story by Chwedyk (2001) https://www.reddit.com/r/BKCNoSpace/comments/rkkl80/the_measure_of_all_things_by_richard_chwedyk_12/ https://www.reddit.com/r/BKCNoSpace/comments/rkkl80/the_meas...
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- kombookcha 2y agoAlso check out the lovely novel Klara And The Sun, about a solar powered AI robot friend, gifted to a sickly child. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klara_and_the_Sun https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klara_and_the_Sun
- doublerabbit 2y agoOh, I read that as robots for chickens. Which, could be interesting.
- edlea 2y agoSo did I. Was the title changed?
- alwa 2y agoFrom the Octopus Poultry Safe to the Chicken Boy, to the Spoutnic that hassles them off the floor and into the nesting boxes, chickens seem amply served by robotic companions: https://www.canadianpoultrymag.com/rise-of-the-robots-30876/ https://www.canadianpoultrymag.com/rise-of-the-robots-30876/
- aliasxneo 2y ago> But relying on large language models to socialize children, particularly neuroatypical ones, seems like a bad idea on every single level I mean, yes.
- johnea 2y agoOh No! They're dying?! The Humanity!!!
- justin_oaks 2y agoI hope for a day where "Caveat emptor" will no longer be needed, but today is not that day!
- mongol 2y agoPerhaps a useful lesson for the children that became attached to the robot. They got to experience grief but no living thing was actually harmed.
- alterom 2y ago>They got to experience grief but no living thing was actually harmed. Except for the kids, that is, who've got hit by unneeded and unexpected grief. Yay.
- YurgenJurgensen 2y agoIf the grief puts them off Software as a Service for life, I’d say it’s a net positive.
- netsharc 2y agoHoly smokes, coming to a CV in ~20 years: "I cannot work with cloud-based services due to childhood trauma.".
- latexr 2y agoYes, I’m sure that’s exactly the lesson that autistic children will take from this. That won’t be hard to explain at all. Publishers are already rushing to make a children’s book on the perils of trusting SaaS with your friendship. Let’s be real: This is at best a lesson for the adults, and not one they’re concerned with learning right now.
- jorblumesea 2y agoorphan crushing machine > nfl player pays for 15 kids to go to college > student organizes bake sale to pay for school lunches > chemistry teacher finds creative ways to pay for chemo
- quantified 2y agoI was thinking something along those lines. Basically every pet will die before its owner, perhaps in tragic fashion. However, parents who shelled out $800 recently may not appreciate that.
- ryandrake 2y agoAs someone with a kid, I feel bad for these little ones. When a stuffed animal gets beat up or a toy gets physically damaged, it's easy to explain to them what happened and why. When a pet dies, it sucks, but at least it's an opportunity for them to learn about life and death. Good luck as a parent explaining to a kid that her beloved friend is going to stop working because some company far away screwed up, they don't care, and they designed the thing stupidly to only work as long as they were perpetually in business. Buyer beware again and again.
- netsharc 2y agoWell, just like the robot is a simulacrum of a friend, the cloud disconnection can be a simulacrum of death, no need to explain to them about LLM tokens and their costs and how the MBA's costs-profits graph ended up not being sustainable for this shitty company.
- soperj 2y agoThat sounds like a good life lesson right there. There's going to be sooo much stuff that's set up that way in their future unless they don't buy into it.
- joshjdr 2y agoAs someone with a kid I feel bad too, but in response to your point, if your kid weren’t developmentally aged to understand what was happening here, would explaining a pet death be so much easier to handle in comparison? I’ve had to explain to a toddler in active crisis that his toys have run out of batteries, went missing, and/or otherwise stopped working… It’s never fun, but putting the kind of existential crisis of owning hardware that is dependent on cloud based services onto your kid seems either sufficiently advanced or totally unnecessary.
- jedberg 2y agoIf the company had any sort of ethics at all, they would release a patch that let you point it another LLM so you could at least keep it running. Or release their software as open source. Or just do something so that they don't just "die". Another example on the long list of "there should be a law that you have to open source your server if you're shutting down a server based service".
- pixl97 2y agoCompanies only ever have ethics when forced.
- thot_experiment 2y ago100% this, we need right to repair, we need EoL mandates, we need to restrict IP protections, especially in time.
- latexr 2y agoDoes it count as being ethical if you have no choice?
- terribleperson 2y agoForce means the society has ethics, rather than the company.
- araes 2y agoThere's zero (0) motivation. They have their $800 / child. It implies there's someone who actually cares about children, or who can even possibly comprehend sympathy in charge of the company. Rather than: "AI is hot. Parents with children spend money on toys. Selling children AI toys will make money. Profit." Notably, does not look like that many people were actually swindled. Only 5000 downloads for the App companion on Google Play, and 27 reviews, and many are scathing. [1] > Like a Jipsy moxie will keep taking your money And lie to to convince you to keep paying for it. It's $100 a month and cost $1,000 to buy. > Do not buy this product. Technical support is non existent. I opted to return the robot. They acknowledged return. 3 weeks later still no refund for this $1K robot. Only after I created a PayPal dispute did PayPal refund me. Still not a single reply from the company to any of my emails. [1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.embo.embodied.parent&hl=en_US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.embo.embod...
- janalsncm 2y ago> any cloud based device is subject to the health of the company and LLMs are not cheap to run Perhaps the technical angle to this story is the promise of edge ML. If your language model runs on the device, your cloud inference costs go to zero and the device works as long as it has power. Aside from the financial benefits, there’s a huge privacy upside as well since no audio or text is sent over a wire. Might be notable for a children’s toy. Of course, this is very difficult for large companies and VC-backed startups to care about because 1) it involves hard technical problems rather than API calls and 2) as long as you can keep asking for money the inference costs don’t matter and 3) there are no criminal consequences (prison time) for privacy violations.
- anonym29 2y agoIn spite of my hugely biased pro-privacy stance, I'm skeptical that real privacy is a feature or selling point that can contribute to the financial interests of corporations enough to consider, broadly speaking. To the corporations, data is the new oil, and to the vast majority of consumers, there's this very defeatist attitude around privacy, something like "I already don't have any privacy, what's one more recording device going to do?". I think we should not expect privacy to meaningfully improve until the gap between end-user perceptions of the value of their privacy and corporate perceptions of the value of their customers' (or users') data shrinks, and I sadly don't see much hope here at all. In fact, I think a substantial plurality, if not an outright majority, even have the technical aptitude to critically evaluate the accuracy of corporate claims of privacy, like those misleading claims of privacy offered by Apple. Humans are highly adaptable creatures, and sadly, I think most have settled quite comfortably into the panopticon that modern society has mandated for so many of us, embedded deep down in the terms of service that everyone agrees to but never reads.
- burningChrome 2y ago>> I think we should not expect privacy to meaningfully improve until the gap between end-user perceptions of the value of their privacy and corporate perceptions of the value of their customers' (or users') data shrinks, Do you see this as a generational thing? I remember working for wireless companies in the 1900's when GPS got huge and companies wanted to start using tracking apps for their fleet management and every company we talked to refused to install it because of privacy concerns and the drivers (and sometimes unions) being 100% opposed to it. Now? We have what? Two to three generations who have never valued their privacy enough to really do anything about it. While I agree with your assertion, I whole heartedly believe the road back to people seeing privacy as important may have effectively died with the Gen Xers.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vouaobrasil 2y agoThe real problem is that parents are giving children AI technology for socialization, not that the robots are dying.
- pojzon 2y agoThank you, I was losing faith in humanity.
- CharlesW 2y agoMaybe this is the straw that breaks childhood's back, but they've said the same about every boogeyman since the 19th century. "The real problem is that parents are giving children [books → radio → comic books → rock music → television → video games → D&D → rap music → computers → internet → smartphones → social media → toy that uses AI], not [the actual problem]."
- smokedetector1 2y agoThe truth is probably somewhere in between "social media/technology is the cause of all problems" and "social media/technology causes absolutely zero problems that wouldn't be caused anyway"
- CharlesW 2y agoFor sure, there are problems ascribed to all of these things consumed [ignorantly | irresponsibly | in excess]. Still, I've lived long enough to see many of these featured in hysterical "for the children" propaganda, and I find myself recoiling from that, maybe more than most. It's easy to see that AI (LLMs) are next on the list to be vilified, which seems absurd to me.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoUndue alarmism against a thing does not render that thing harmless, even if the original alarmism is excessive.
- neuroelectron 2y agoI find the video in the article really interesting. This person is clearly an adult and is crying while discussing the robot's future "death" with it. She's clearly quite attached despite the robot being quite inhuman with sub par text to speech. This company is a take the money and run type of operation. No subscription plan and I doubt the API fees were making a huge part of their obscene profit. They would have eventually, but clearly they were not going to wait that long.
- Spivak 2y agoWell yeah, I would cry if one of my stuffies got destroyed and it's even less animated than the robot. It being less animated actually helps the attachment because it's more like a pet than a person. Humans will pack bond with anything.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- klntsky 2y agoThis video is reaction bait, crafted specifically to maximize engagement
- MarkusWandel 2y agoWhen will people learn about cloud dependent gadgets. And if this thing already cost $800, how much more would it have cost to put some basic AI into it for use as a fallback? Can't you run stuff like that on smartphones these days?
- hwc 2y agoyeah, be aware that many things you buy today depend on some cloud service that may go away. for example, a computer system that routinely checks for updates will hopefully still function if the update server goes away. and you can always install another operating system. since I listen to most music via a streaming service these days, I don't consider the music owned and don't mind moving to another service (which I have gone twice, losing playlists in the process). the worst is "digital copies" of movies. I try not to buy these, but occasionally do. I'm pretty sure that Blu-rays I buy today will work until the media degrades, but have no such confidence in digital copies.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- smoyer 2y agoI'm a former hardware engineer with a lot of ties to communities that include handicapped children. Happy to help reverse engineer and resuscitate these as a side-project if I can get my hands on a "dead robot".
- oscillot 2y agoWho has one we can take apart and try to jailbreak? Not even joking
- mschoch 2y agoSounds like a great opportunity to teach them about the shitty real world we all live in.
- shiroiushi 2y agoA fair amount of the shittiness comes from people actively enabling that shittiness, such as by throwing large sums of money at fly-by-night companies selling products dependent on cloud services and then getting mad when the fly-by-night company goes under and their product stops working, and then voting for politicians who oppose any regulation that would curtail such behavior.
- Hizonner 2y agoIf you work on "social robotics", just remember that this one of the least concerning of the corporate abuses that will arise from your work. There is no ethical way to build robots to which humans are meant to, or predictably will, become emotionally attached.
- beau_g 2y agoIf you think humans getting emotionally attached to robots is bad, wait til you hear about the type of stuff that stems from humans getting emotionally attached to other humans
- bouke 2y ago> and if you bought the device on a payment plan it’s out of their hands Woah. So you'd have to keep paying for this now-defunct plastic piece of garbage?
- araes 2y agoCorollary on another thread discussion: Never ever buy anything that depends on Software as a Service on a payment plan. They go out of business too quickly these days, and run away with the money.
- iamleppert 2y agoI'll take one of these units off someone's hands for $400, if they have it. I would like to disassemble one on video in a video marketed toward children.
- bbogdn2 2y agoGreat idea, we should teach the kids how to do robot surgery to revive their dead friend.
- Gedxx 2y agoI know of a similar project but focused on medical rehabilitation. https://en.inrobics.com/ https://en.inrobics.com/
- pvaldes 2y agoI'm fine with that. Those children will learn valuable lessons about loss and death. The kind of lessons that having a goldfish pet will provide, but without killing a goldfish. Or: "Robots will need to go hibernating now in order to return to its far, far away planet". You are welcome, coward parent.
- kazinator 2y agoParents who can afford $800 toys for small children, made by startups that have not quite made it, can probably get them the therapy they need to get over this.
- mediumsmart 2y agogreat lesson for kids
- mkrishnan 2y ago[dead]
- apwell23 2y ago[flagged]
- leosanchez 2y agoI actually had to double check the title.
- billsmithaustin 2y ago[flagged]
- rvense 2y agoSo this is OK? Selling somebody an $800 thing that might stop working is fine and people should just get over it? This "business model" should not exist.
- stavros 2y agoSo it's fine if someone steals your daughter's favorite teddy bear, because you shouldn't delegate your kid's emotional state to a stuffed toy?
- latexr 2y agoThis is specifically and overtly marketed to autistic kids, not as a mere toy but as a tool to help with emotional development. https://moxierobot.com/pages/robot-for-autistic-child https://moxierobot.com/pages/robot-for-autistic-child
- sebastianconcpt 2y agoYes. Not having the market validating this as business in a time where AIs are full of ideological biases is good news. Incredible that parents would trust this much in the blind. Remove the marketing gimmicks and is like asking to accept in advance a close 24/7 new friend of their kid before knowing if that's the behavioral influence they want from that "friend" (interestingly this would bring the alignment issue and, as a side note, makes us meditate on how aligned we are with friends and friends of our kids, etc).
- Freak_NL 2y ago> Moxie can’t perform core functionality without cloud connectivity. The usual story, and more e-waste generated.
- woliveirajr 2y ago> According to Embodied, Moxie can’t perform core functionality without cloud connectivity. As always. Everything that relies on some cloud can become a brick without warning. And many things shouldn't require it...
- passwordoops 2y agoIdea: if a cloud-connected product is bricked within 7 years of purchase, the company responsible must make the code open-source and freely available in a public repository. This would not only allow consumers to continue using the product they supposedly own, but will also cause investors and managers to pause before developing and marketing an exclusively cloud-based device. CPU and memory are good enough that most regular consumer devices shouldn't need an internet connection
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bArray 2y agoIn this case it makes a lot of sense to open-source the product, at least the non-proprietary parts. It would be extremely cool to provide a build process, a framework and drivers for each actuator/sensor. From there these devices could live a new life quite easily.
- drvladb 2y agoI’d like that idea, but I feel like more would have to go into it. Things like user-accessible updates/reflashing, or someone to care enough about the software to fix it for use by everyone else. Support requirements + this are probably a better way to go.
- cjrp 2y agoWhat if they're going bankrupt anyway though? No fine will matter surely
- amiga386 2y agoOn the one hand, that's sad. On the other hand, what a great way for both parents and children to learn about the idiocy that is IoT in the Clown. And oh boy do people need to learn! It could be worse. Imagine that the children had to hand over private information to use the toy, and for that entire dataset to be leaked because the toymaker knows nothing about security. Oh, that already happened: https://www.bitdefender.com/en-gb/blog/hotforsecurity/vtech-toymaker-hacked-millions-of-families-have-their-personal-info-exposed https://www.bitdefender.com/en-gb/blog/hotforsecurity/vtech-... Or imagine the toy had cameras and microphones uploading continuously to the Clown, then "hackers" released all of it.
- devsda 2y agoOr an attacker gaining control of a specific device to make kids do stupid/bad/illegal things. We can teach children not to trust a stranger offline or online. How do you teach them to be on guard about an interactive emotional support robot friend thats a parental gift?
- tempaway486734 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lifecycle_of_Software_Objects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lifecycle_of_Software_Obje...
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoRule #1 in the Techno-oligarchy: If you do not own the platform you do not own the product.
- robblbobbl 2y agoMost important
- niemandhier 2y agoAt least for Europeans there could be a mandatory 2 years warranty: https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/shopping/guarantees-returns/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/shopping/gua... The robot was never officially sold in Europe, but the claim might extend to the reseller.
- IanCal 2y agoI don't think that really helps if the company doesn't have any money.
- Someone 2y ago> but the claim might extend to the reseller. That EU legal guarantee is only between seller and consumer. The manufacturer does not have any obligations under it. In this case, it likely would come down to the “If this is impossible or the seller cannot do it within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience to you, you are entitled to a full or partial refund” part
- niemandhier 2y agoIt might be a bit more nuanced in the case of platforms like Ali Baba, that claim to not be actual resellers but only service providers to the actual seller.
- plagiarist 2y agoAnother lesson to never purchase anything connected to the cloud. It is unfortunate that the majority don't care. I'd prefer if the Invisible Hand pushed the economy towards products that weren't e-waste in waiting.
- alentred 2y agoHonest question: but what can a company really do if it goes bankrupt and shuts down, since there is no money to pay for infrastructure and workforce? Of course, they could probably release code to the open-source. Still someone needs to run the service. Also, if the code contains intellectual property, wouldn't existing investors enforce the company of selling the IP rights in case of a bankruptcy? I am not taking sides here, just trying to understand what options a company (any company) could explore in this case.
- pdimitar 2y agoAllocate money for 5-10 years of support for this contingency, beforehand, as long as the seed round is secured (so in this case: in the past). $800 is an okay investment for a household item for 10 years. For 2-3 though, or even 5? Not at all.
- from-nibly 2y agoAllocate money before you have any? Allocate the money you need to become profitable before you can become profitable? Where would that money come from? Presumably if you had that kind of money you could just skip the whole make a company bit and retire in luxury.
- Muromec 2y agoSounds like you can't sell the product then. Maybe the product is bullshit and it should not be on the market. General sentiment in the comments says the product is bullshit and can't work. Maybe it's correct. Or maybe you should be smart about it somehow and invent a contingency plan and legal structure that doesn't involve putting that much money into escrow. And everybody who isn't that smart will become rich. Imagine you have 10k and want to become rich by building a luxury appartement building. Can you start selling property titles without first having funding? Can you raise capital, sell not-yet-existing properties, then close up and expect everything to be okay?
- Muromec 2y agoIf you sell a product with a promise to run servers for N years, you put a deposit to run servers for N years, or you have a contingency plan to let a third party run it for N years after you went out of business. If you can't deliver on a promise and didn't make a good faith effort, maybe you committed fraud. I have no idea about bankruptcy law -- does the company defaulting on their contractual obligations make their customers their creditors? Maybe the customers are entitled to get rights to whatever code the company had and is free to run it at their own expense. Or maybe nobody really cares enough about 800 dollar teddy bears.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- le_knight 2y agomake it open hardware!
- dave333 2y agoLet your kids do a hardware autopsy/reverse engineer/disassembly on it. Can play medics or just see how it looks/works inside. Not $800 worth but better than tossing it.
- Habgdnv 2y agoI support jail time for cases like this, but with mandatory physical consequences (like a daily beating with a stick). Since that is kind of unrealistic (sadly), here's a more raelistic idea: In case a company goes bankrupt and bricks its cloud-dependent products, I as the (now a defunct) product owner must become a co-owner of the company. By extension when the company holds licenses for software (e.g., QT), those licenses would transfer to me as well. This would grant me the right to receive a copy of the source code and build it myself. With access to source code I (and everyone) can easily change any hardcoded dns name. And even without changing it, everyone can run a pi-hole, why not add a special case for their domain to point to my server? (I don't use pi-hole but i guess it have that option)
- tivert 2y ago> I support jail time for cases like this, but with mandatory physical consequences (like a daily beating with a stick). I hear you, but I think corporate dissolution is the one case where no one can really expect a device to remain supported, so punishing that will do no good. Punishment only makes sense when you have an ongoing viable business that drops support for no good reason (like the Spotify Car thing). IMHO, for dissolution, it makes more sense to require open-sourcing all device and server code if there's no entity willing to take on support. For an ongoing business, there should be some onerous punishment if they decide brick a connected device too early (e.g before 5 or 7 years after the last version sold), and if they decide brick it later they need to open source the related code.
- Muromec 2y agoIt's like DORA, but enforcement arm is outsourced to Singapore?
- jareklupinski 2y agoif Dreamcast fans can find a way to make their consoles believe Sega's servers are still running and play long after support is over, i'm sure some hacker will come along and create the tools necessary to bridge the gadget to a desktop or something i'd give it a shot, but i dont have one :(
- skyzyx 2y ago1. If you have $800 to spend on an emotional support robot — OR you’re dumb enough to spend $800 on an emotional support robot, I don’t see this as a big loss. 2. Never spend money on multiplayer-only video games. Never buy a robot that is 100% cloud connected — ESPECIALLY from a startup. This is the same concept stated twice. 3. You buy things for what they are today; NEVER for what they might be tomorrow. I feel no remorse. Stupidity should be painful.
- stevefan1999 2y agoAnother creepypasta 10 years down the road...the "dead" robot haunts back