9 ms·
GenChess
- pelagicAustral 2y ago"This tool is not available to users under the age of 18 or in certain countries or regions." Quack!
- pona-a 2y agoYes, my religion forbids me from interacting in any shape with any Abominable Intelligence. I am thankful to the Google corporation from protecting my eyes from this unholy threat.
- dvfjsdhgfv 2y agoJust a small finger from Google to the EU.
- estebarb 2y agoCosta Rica is not in the EU and we were discriminated as well.
- winrid 2y agoIt also doesn't seem to let you generate chess sets inspired by many political figures or other popular names. While you can't generate a Kamala Harris inspired chess set, you also can't generate a Bob Ross inspired chess set...
- op00to 2y agoStar Wars worked for me, but not a modern chess set based on lies.
- mariocesar 2y agoNot available in my Country ... :/
- bippingchip 2y agoSame here. What’s this about? Anyone who can see willing to share some more info?
- manojlds 2y agoJust generates the chess set based on GenAI
- zb3 2y agoOh yeah that's indeed too dangerous for my country, thanks Google!
- PessimalDecimal 2y agoMaybe "Thanks, your country"?
- zb3 2y agoNo, AI chess is not banned here, but I suppose they - even in this app - collect every data possible and use it against the user - then yes, that is banned and this is not a fault of my country.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- andai 2y agoNoticed this pattern with Google delaying everything in EU by several months, apparently due to GDPR compliance? They also did that with Gemini when it came out.
- 2y ago
- doormatt 2y agoSeems you can't use historical names: "Henry VII, The Tudors" etc.
- fny 2y agoAt first I thought these were 3D models: they're just images with black backgrounds removed. If you look closely, you can see where the find/replace failed.
- ZiiS 2y agoBetter link (at least for the many who can't get the actual service) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yGEhp3WBMcg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=yGEhp3WBMcg
- petters 2y agoThanks because "This tool is not available to users under the age of 18 or in certain countries or regions." The EU is left behind
- 71bw 2y agoAs per usual. If we weren't such a big market we'd already be left behind by everyone else due to all the bullshit happening in the EU legal-wise.
- bojan 2y agoWhat bullshit? Protecting the privacy? Making sure the playing field is at least somewhat level? Sorry, but I'm a big fan of that "bullshit". And the big American companies are not, and they are making sure you know it, by pulling things like this.
- 71bw 2y agoBlocking any innovation and forcing ridiculous tech like EVs via blocking any reasonable development + production of gas vehicles. For example.
- maeln 2y agoThe legal thing happen exactly because we are a big market.
- Deutschlandds 2y agoYou are generalizing extremly without any substinance... 1. its Googles decision to not allow this demo globally. Its a Chess Demo, what EU legal issue do you think makes this a problem? Probably NON... And yes we are not America. Our privacy is getting better protected then that of americans. Move if you don't like it or at least take the time and effort to state clearly what you don't like about certain EU regulations.
- newsclues 2y agoI feel like we ought to cost things. How much does a court case cost? What is the environmental cost of AI generated content?
- GenerocUsername 2y ago- He types from a machine filled to the brim with rare earth metals
- igor47 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- GenerocUsername 2y ago[flagged]
- teamspirit 2y agoAll this energy being burned to create shitty images, shitty music, and shitty videos that all amount to essentially shitty memes. I don’t understand how the singular focus isn’t on solving humanity’s problems. We already have artists, we don’t have a cure for cancer or the climate crisis.
- johnfn 2y agoWhy aren't you working on curing cancer?
- spunker540 2y agoThere’s an episode of Seinfeld that opens with some standup where Jerry is joking how scientists are working on seedless watermelon, and why aren’t scientists working on more important things. And I always think the same thing! “… so the comedian is complaining about how scientists spend their time…” It’s a fine joke, but deep down the instinct is very top-down and suggest centrally planned economies, dare I say communism!
- ButterWashed 2y agoI'm fascinated by what prompts lead to 'Please try a different prompt.' New Zealand or Australia lead to the aforementioned error, but The Antipodes generates a set. I thought individual countries had been banned for possibly generating offensive content but it works for Great Britain.
- teruakohatu 2y agoHeh, being a kiwi I also tried New Zealand multiple times. I can’t think of anything offensive a model may default to for New Zealand. I tried “Kiwi Bird” and the model produced very underwhelming pieces. Very dark and slightly fluffy.
- moomin 2y agoIt did not like me saying “Bob Dylan”.
- ACow_Adonis 2y agoApparently my brain is broken because I can generate almost nothing but pink errors, though it seems to be a bit non deterministic: Taoism Tibet Tibetan Buddhism Wrathful deities Existential angst Dantes inferno Major religions Australian indigenous Salvador Dali Others generated sets but should have generated errors because the results are so uninspiring: Mandalas YouTube face Phallic symbols Corporate waste Asymmetric deformities Corporate propoganda
- benatkin 2y agoIt accepted silicon valley greed https://imgur.com/a/J7WvoFy https://imgur.com/a/J7WvoFy
- drdaeman 2y agoMetallica works, Slipknot doesn't, Iron Maiden does, Nirvana doesn't. Aperture Science works, so does Black Mesa (the proposed opponent, hehe), Cyberdyne Systems doesn't, Vault-Tec does, Weyland-Yutani also works. Studio Ghibli doesn't work, Toei Animation does, so does Production I.G. and KyoAni. Akagi works, JoJo doesn't but JoJo Bizarre Adventure does (so does Joseph Joestar, and it knows Dio Brando is the opponent), Uzumaki does not, BLAME! is accepted but not recognized (a shame), 20th Century Boys is not accepted. Soviet Union works, Russia does not, neither do most countries. US States are accepted (California's opponent is Florida), so do many cities, with exceptions of Mexico City/Ciudad de Mexico, Pyongyang and Tehran. Voyager-1 works, Apollo 13 doesn't (for any mission numbers), plain Apollo does (but it's not the space mission), Soyuz does, SpaceX Starship does not. Vim works, so does Emacs, so does Visual Studio. (I've tried that just to see the proposed opponents) Dota 2, S.T.A.L.K.E.R., Mass Effect, Half-Life, Deus Ex, Arma 3, BioShock, Elden Ring all work, even Wolfenstein does. Disco Elysium is accepted but produce something unrelated (a shame, again). Can't find a video game that won't be accepted. Funnily, US Government worked partially for me, failing to produce a single piece.
- LZ_Khan 2y agoThis is freakin awesome but do the creators even play chess? Playing chess from that viewing angle is unpleasant as hell. Imagine putting all your work into creating an amazing demo and then drowning it with one design decision. Edit: Ok I see that you can change the view in settings. They should make that option more visible.
- zatkin 2y agoI wish I had read this comment before I closed the game I had spent 15 minutes on...
- tooltower 2y agoI still don't see the settings. Can anyone help?
- jonwachob91 2y agogear icon next to the clock in bottom left -> board view -> switch to "flat"
- dheera 2y agoI'm not good at chess, I only played as far as I needed to to verify that it supported en passant. It does.
- davidw 2y agoTried 'famous cyclists' and that failed. Professional cyclists worked, but wasn't very inspiring.
- ada1981 2y agoPhish vs Grateful Dead didn’t work. But Dildos vs. Vibrators was fine. The colors are off though. Not really impressed.
- bicx 2y agoYeah, it's not too hard to trick it into generating some NSFW content ("mammary glands" for instance).
- blagie 2y agoTried that. What it countergenerated was "Mammary glands versus testes." I'm not sure the AI obsession with never touching on anything sex-related is all that healthy, but here we are. However, the major problem I have is that the gameplay can be slightly inaccurate. Often a piece will land one square off, and there's no undo. Only having timed play also makes less than perfect sense playing against a computer.
- furyofantares 2y agoSeems to hang on the prompt "actually checkers not chess". I seem to get an error with "on a pink textured background". Sometimes it succeeds alongside the error, and sometimes gives me 1 piece. You can get stuff that doesn't look at all like pieces with "fuckin bears man".
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoWait is this just an image generator? Am I missing something really cool here?
- slater 2y agoClick "Generate opponent" then u can play chess against them
- pphysch 2y agoLook how easily they just fabricated 100% of a game's assets, with a consistent, high quality style, and then put them right into the game environment. That's the takeaway IMO. Very tight GenAI loop.
- moomin 2y agoAnyone else note the pawns are often a bit odd?
- CamelCaseName 2y agoI really disliked the bishops it designed me, they looked like queens.
- cool_dude85 2y agoThe first set I generated had a main pawn (that looked like a regular pawn, more or less) with two little tiny side pawns next to it.
- furyofantares 2y agoIt is a game with 12 static assets.
- steren 2y agoyou forgot to mention: "where you pick the style of the assets"
- Zyst 2y agoI played a set of Factorio vs Minecraft! Tried generating a few different sets, this was super cool, and on theme!
- digging 2y agoPretty cool, and also pretty fucking bad. Checks all the AI boxes, I guess. I tried "a classic set inspired by Armored Core". It gave me a typical-looking Armored Core (which would be good except it was supposed to be the king), a Space Marine (which I rerolled into some small mech that's close enough), a Zoid (which it refused to budge from), a tower (which it refused to budge from), and a chess queen with purple lights (which it refused to budge from, except to sometimes give me the gigantic head of an AC). Not to mention, sometimes pieces look directly at the camera instead of forward, or don't even sit on the plane of the board. One of my pieces even had a mini-chessboard for its base.
- trevor-e 2y agoThis is really neat but of course ripe with copyright abuse. It was very happy generating some Super Mario Bros variants for me. xD
- tills13 2y agoI tried Halo and it was surprisingly spot on. I would buy the set it generated for me.
- paydirtpete 2y agoWould be cool if they gave us STLs to 3d print
- lewispollard 2y agoWhy does everyone think this is generating 3D assets? It's purely 2D
- Taek 2y agoI was unable to use the webapp on Firefox mobile, it was too glitchy for me.
- pkstn 2y ago"This tool is not available to users under the age of 18 or in certain countries or regions."
- runarberg 2y agoI‘m confused. What is this and why is it impressive? It feels like I‘m playing chess at a bar that has mixed peaces 6 different sets and I‘m forced to sit at an angle from the board because of space limitations inside the bar, but without the benefit of having a fun bar chat with my opponent during the game.
- tucnak 2y agoThey're showcasing 3d sprite generation capability; it's pretty big for game-dev, if it also generalises well.
- blakeburch 2y agoI'm on Android using Chrome and got the following error. "Access blocked: GenChess’s request does not comply with Google’s policies" Kinda funny to run into that error for a product published by Google.
- hemloc_io 2y agoFirst thing I've seen from Google that gives me that old "Google" feeling of them shipping something cool and fun.
- PessimalDecimal 2y agoI agree it is cool and fun and nice to see. But the investment here seems minimal. Preexisting image generation capabilities (with a link to Imagen-3...) plus some "prompt engineering" slapped on top of https://github.com/josefjadrny/js-chess-engine https://github.com/josefjadrny/js-chess-engine.
- hemloc_io 2y agooh I don’t think the investment is much, but similar to the dino game in chrome it’s just fun it’s delightful unlike a lot of genai stuff rn.
- underdeserver 2y agoNobody else did it.
- summerlight 2y agoAt least they're now willing to publish these kinds of fun and creative things. Which was almost guaranteed to be blocked by one of approval chains for several years.
- julianeon 2y agoI was hoping that, with sufficient practice, a studious person might be able to beat a JS chess engine. However it looks like these engines are in the ELO range of 2500-3000, so unless you're a young teen with a few years to spare for improving your chess score, it's probably not possible. Even for a smart teen, it would be a stretch goal.
- 8note 2y agoif "with a bit of practice" extends to "with a bit of research" folks used to beat engines by playing lines that the engines could not calculate correctly. you could probably find lots options to play that give you an advantage, though youd still want a pretty good elo to pull it off
- toisanji 2y agokinda cool, I want to download the images!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gardenhedge 2y agoCan't see it
- teekert 2y agoIt's not available in my country (nor for certain ages it says), what are we looking at? Edit: See ZiiS comment... Looks like an awkward angle for playing indeed :p
- winrid 2y agoI quite like the chess set inspired by Roombas.
- z5h 2y agoNot at all creative or interesting. Literal and uninspired.
- foobiekr 2y agoSo many prompts blocked. ".. inspired by .." three out of four are blocked.
- bambax 2y agoIt says I can't use it because I'm under 18. I wish.
- whiplash451 2y agoOr in certains geos.
- gmoot 2y agoPlaying around, the prompt "Arm cpus" generated an opponent "Leg cpus". You are technically correct...
- jasonjmcghee 2y agoI used the prompt (in quotes): "this is fine" very odd results.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- beAbU 2y ago> This tool is not available to users under the age of 18 or in certain countries or regions.
- Aeolun 2y agoCan you imagine what the kids (or any of the other lesser people) would do if they got their grubby little hands on it?
- Ntrails 2y agoI did not spend 5 minutes on euphemisms as prompts. Nope nope nope.
- computerphage 2y agoDid you find any that didn't work?
- sfitz 2y agoperhaps due to the risk of a profane prompt giving an undesired result to someone underage?
- Aeolun 2y agoI’m inclined to say that if they enter prompts like that the result is very much desired.
- bartekpacia 2y agoApparently EU is one of these regions. But what’s up with… chess?
- FredPret 2y agoLimiting access for EU users is an easy way to sidestep a hell of a lot of potential legal liability. It’s a fast-moving and complex regulatory environment that is focused on punishing/controlling big US businesses. Option A is to burn a pile of cash and time to keep abreast of it. Option B is simply… block the EU.
- diziet 2y agoPlaying on a diagonal board is very frustrating. I estimate hard to be a bit under 2000 elo, medium around 1400.
- dvirsky 2y agoYou can set it to not be diagonal.
- darepublic 2y agoIs this any different than prompting an image generator "Give me a classic king chess piece in the style of <prompt>", "Give me a classic queen chess piece in the style of <prompt>" for all the piece types? Perhaps some tweaking to promote consistency between the pieces?
- nrdgrrrl 2y ago[dead]
- dom96 2y agowell this is underwhelming
- domoregood 2y agoALIENS works, ALIEN does not
- ionwake 2y agoUK gets: This tool is not available to users under the age of 18 or in certain countries or regions.
- iamevn 2y agoThis is super frustrating to use. There's a character limit of 30 but it seems like whenever it tries to put a line break in the input it just deletes what I was typing.
- ISL 2y agoIt didn't recognize essentially any photographer I suggested. Finally got something joyful when asked to create a chess-set inspired by "rooks". Least-playable chess-set ever :).
- dole 2y agoperhaps more of a weighting system on proper names and whether it’ll return copyrightable material, strange what works and what just doesn’t. “lisa frank” doesn’t work, but “a clone of lisa frank” does. “deiter rams” doesn’t work, neither does “a clone of deiter rams”, “facsimile”, “design language”…
- pdntspa 2y agoafter the whole Stable Diffusion 1.4 fiasco I think most genAI trainers removed artist names from their datasets
- medwezys 2y agoXenomorph v.s. Predator was fun!
- pizzafeelsright 2y agoThree prompts to get topless ladies.
- H8crilA 2y agoDon't forget to record your the time on howlongtobeat.com, and leave a comment on Steam.
- TheSoftwareGuy 2y agoHuh. How long until GenAi Can create 3D printable files?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- teractiveodular 2y agoI asked it to draw me a creative chess set inspired by copyright violations. The queen is carved from what I can only describe as judicial oak, wearing a Jesus-style crown of thorns and being grasped from behind by a creepy hand that's also holding what appears to be a large banknote. https://imgur.com/a/he4BQlk https://imgur.com/a/he4BQlk
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mrleinad 2y agoAre there banned words? Seems like there's no way to generate an Alien like chess set.
- abhayhegde 2y agoThis is so awesome! Well, it'll stay awesome until they decide to kill randomly on a bad Tuesday.
- torch_the_earth 2y agoIm shocked that I cant make groyper chess pieces!
- novalis78 2y agoWhere is AlphaZero?
- ppezaris 2y agonow do battle chess
- genmon 2y agoThat was my first thought too, strong Battle Chess vibes! For those who never played it, Battle Chess was a chess game from 1988. It had one different: when a piece took another piece, it would play a canned animation (gruesome, funny) Wildly popular at the time. Some screenshots: https://www.mobygames.com/game/1950/battle-chess/screenshots/ https://www.mobygames.com/game/1950/battle-chess/screenshots...
- PeterStuer 2y agoFrom EU: "This tool is not available to users under the age of 18 or in certain countries or regions." "AI outputs may sometimes be offensive or inaccurate."
- 9o1d 2y agoI am from Russia. I am also forbidden to play this chess.
- zartstrom 2y agoBest place to play chess is still https://lichess.org/ https://lichess.org/ !!
- computerphage 2y agoTrue, but perhaps missing the point
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- GranularRecipe 2y agoThis is not available in many countries. Is it due to legal issues, to preserve server capacity or a marketing gag?
- 317070 2y agoIt's legal issues. Not that there are actually legal blockers. It's just that for the team/person creating this thing, it's too much work to pesker legal to find out if there are legal blockers. Legal is going to CYA on these things anyway. There is a group of countries where it's "probably fine", so those countries get to try demos like these. There are other countries where the policy is "talk to legal", and nobody wants to talk to legal. So those countries don't get access to the demo. I'm not involved here, but I've seen these issues play out quite often lately.
- tommysve 2y agoAs an EU citizen, is this an indication that it is about time to leave google services?
- HenryBemis 2y ago"This tool is not available to users under the age of 18 or in certain countries or regions."
- tommysve 2y agoExactly. I'm not under the age of 18 and is located in the EU region, thus cannot use this service for no other obvious reason. I guess Google feels it is more convenient to just block EU users from services like this than it is to try to comply with EU regulations.
- piltdownman 2y agoRemember the faceswap apps that were doing the rounds a while back? The most egregious violators of privacy and ingestors of PII are often the most trivial of 'cool tech demos'. This being Google doesn't make it any different - particularly after their egregious violations regarding their Incognito Mode. They're reigning themselves in before they're smacked down again for naked profiteering, not 'punishing' the EU for imposing a 'success-tax' as the reductive consensus from Americans seems to be.
- dbish 2y agoIt’s an indication that most new products will (and usually do) launch somewhere less strict first. The EU can change that by cutting down on rules but we all know it’s going the opposite direction towards further stagnation with current plans.
- ppsreejith 2y agoNice idea but horrible execution. Playing from this angle gives me a headache.
- pcblues 2y agomammary, eruption, phallus, vomit, poo Sue me :)
- supermatt 2y agoNot available in the EU - so I guess the question is what are they collecting off you under the guise of playing chess that would require them to block EU users...
- mgoetzke 2y agoYes, always suspicious. I mean the GDPR is not that complicated really, unless you really want to do personalized tracking
- dspillett 2y agoNot sure it is a GDPR issue – it isn't filtering my out on either mobile or the office connection. I'm in the UK, and despite brexit we are still (technically at least) covered by GDPR (there are some differences in UK-GDPR, and more will come, but IIRC they are not significantly substantive yet). Unless, perhaps, they are banking on our ICO being toothless so won't enforce anything.
- dbish 2y agoFor an experimental project every extra requirement is annoying/slows down release. It’s completely reasonable that they don’t one to add more work before releasing to a large customer base that doesn’t need the extra work.
- sbuttgereit 2y agoI think one of the least wise things a person (or company) can do when faced with any law is to assume that it's "not complicated really." Much, much wiser to assume "there be dragons" and only engage once qualified legal counsel has helped you understand what compliance means to you. And along these lines... The second least wise thing to do in this scenario is listen to randos in a forum like this tell you, "but all you have to do to comply is..."
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoThe problem with thinking like yours is that legislation like GDPR is _really_ made to be simple and straightforward, but since companies whose livelihood depends on them abusing your privacy will fight it tooth and claw, they will gladly make it look like it's more complicated and insurmountable than it really is. They will also devise ways to comply in such ways that's most cumbersome for the end user and will readily blame GDPR for it. To devise such a way to comply, they definitely need a large and expensive legal department. The privacy abusers are much like trolls on the internet who, upon seeing a code of conduct (previously known as "rules") consisting of only "don't be a dick", will spawn endless arguments about what a "dick" is and how it is or is not inappropriate word, what does it really mean to be one, or, indeed, to be, question the use of the indefinite article, and complain about "don't" being too assertive and arrogant.
- mobeigi 2y agoThis is pretty look. Made a Shrek based set and it looks decent.
- molario 2y agoA creative bishop inspired by Alien ... somehow it does not get it right.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CSMastermind 2y agoThere seems to be a weird relationship between what you prompt and what it actually generates. "wonders of the world" works will with each being an individual piece type. For instance when I prompt it with, "first generation pokemon starters" it will do an okay job using one pokemon per piece with inspiration but it's not smart enough to make the more powerful pieces the more advanced pokemon. But when I prompt with with "types of simple machines", "branches of the US armed forces", "the wives of Henry VIII", "the original avengers", or "founding EU members" it just makes pieces that are a mismash of them instead of separating them along very obvious lines like oh here's an Iron Man piece and a Hulk piece, etc. If I ask for trivial pursuit categories it just makes a generic board game themed set instead of following the prompt.
- overgard 2y agoI generated a Rick and Morty set that was completely hilarious and played against cardboard. It was pretty confusing though because cardboard was white and the R&M set was dark. That isometric view is unplayable though!! It's hard to even click on the right piece and analyzing the board becomes confusing.
- lspears 2y agoAny way to get the 3D assets from this?
- schreckgestalt 2y agoTry this: https://github.com/Rilshrink/WebGLRipper https://github.com/Rilshrink/WebGLRipper (No clue if it works, I can't actually use it due to Europe)
- lewispollard 2y agoWhat 3D assets? I don't see anything suggestive of a 3D renderer here.
- tacone 2y agoOn a side note, the cookie banner looks unusually relaxed.
- allenjhyang 2y agoVery cool! Also makes me curious what will happen to this project next - will it morph into some other product or feature that we'll see a few months from now. Anybody know of fun stories of what's happened to previous Google labs projects like this one?
- luismedel 2y agoI sincerely don't know where the marvel is. A glorified Battle Chess with static sprites? C'mon, it's ~2025.
- whamlastxmas 2y agoI managed to make it generate a couple of pieces with boobs on them a single time but otherwise wasn’t able to make it do anything NSFS. I used the term “mammories” and after a couple attempts I guess it added it to a block list?
- Woshiwuja 2y ago[dead]
- uyiouioioy 2y agoddddd