10 ms·
Bluesky is on the verge of overtaking Threads in all the ways that matter
- mustime 2y ago[dead]
- taspeotis 2y ago> Meta-owned Threads started November with 5 times the daily app users of Bluesky. That number is now down to just 1.5. Is this because Threads is fading into obscurity and has fewer daily app users than their peak, and Bluesky has a bit more than they had before in November? Today are either within an order of magnitude of X?
- willsmith72 2y ago> Is this because Threads is fading into obscurity and has fewer daily app users than their peak, and Bluesky has a bit more than they had before in November? Looks like no, threads is pretty flat and bluesky is hockey stick-ing from this graph: https://bsky.app/profile/jburnmurdoch.bsky.social/post/3lbmpgiqt622h https://bsky.app/profile/jburnmurdoch.bsky.social/post/3lbmp... not sure what x data looks like
- threeseed 2y ago> Is this because Threads is fading into obscurity Threads has ~300m MAU and will be on track to being larger than X in a year. In fact X is struggling so much they now provide the option to hide engagement metrics: https://www.newsweek.com/elon-musk-hides-x-engagement-figures-user-exodus-1990065 https://www.newsweek.com/elon-musk-hides-x-engagement-figure...
- dylan604 2y agoBlusky started at 0. Threads started with existing meta users. That seems like a big difference to me.
- senojsitruc 2y agoFor all the ways that matter, find a more meaningful bar.
- bobthepanda 2y agoHow is Threads? I keep getting ads to push me to join it on Instagram, but whatever they recommend me via those ads is usually vapid Linkedin-type drivel. And I can’t see it on phone without the app.
- janalsncm 2y agoI open it up once in a while but it mainly seems to be ranked by predicted CTR/engagement. For example, out of the first 20 posts in my feed I got a ton of travel/finance guru garbage and multiple posts with some variant of “Do not buy a Tesla, plenty of better EV choices.” And random memes stolen from other sites. Tons of posts trying to get me to click on them to read more. None of the accounts in my feed are ones I follow. It’s basically algorithmically driven slop.
- ks2048 2y agoI have gotten lured by engage-bait from Instagram. IMHO there is something off about Threads. It surely depends on who you follow and how you use it, but I find it totally un-engaging. Bluesky recently, seems better.
- akira2501 2y ago> overtaking Threads So the lowest bar possibly imaginable?
- tmaly 2y agoI downloaded threads when it came out, but I only used it once.
- johnchristopher 2y agoReally ? Right in front of my lemmy username ?
- jrs235 2y agoI can think of a "Truthier" "social network/platform" that is lower than Threads...
- peanuty1 2y agoTrumpet (AKA Truth Social)?
- enjaydee 2y agoI don't think it's that low of a bar. Threads benefited from easy account creation and promotion from Instagram (2b MAU?) Bluesky started from word of mouth invite only
- glenstein 2y agoYeah, getting anywhere near what the major tech companies are capable of should be understood as a triumph. Does anyone remember now Spoutible? Substack Notes? How about Spill, Hive, or Post? Being even with in anything approximating striking distance of Threads would have been a triumph for any of them.
- ks2048 2y agoI've fallen for the Threads-links shown in Instagram. Obviously the instagram connection is what gave them a great start at a user-base. But, everytime I try to use Threads, something seems off (mainly see lame, boring, engagement-bait). Bluesky seems different and better. Also a much better story in-terms of open data, open protocol, etc.
- janalsncm 2y agoIs it all the ways that matter? The author mentions one way, DAU. Sure, that is important but I can think of other things that matter. The number of “creator” accounts matters just as much as the number of lurkers. From my experience Bluesky is way better and has respect for the user’s choice front and center. Lists of users to follow is a first-class citizen feature. Their algorithm is a chronological feed, not boosting engagement bait.
- willsmith72 2y agowouldn't things like creator-lurker ratio be captured within DAU? as in, poor ratio leads to poor DAU?
- luplex 2y agoNot necessarily. There could be different types of content that requires different types of creators, like imagine professional video producers vs your friends posting about their day. There could also be a different algorithm/network that allows for a few creators to feed a large number of consumers.
- dylan604 2y ago> Their algorithm is a chronological feed Why does a chronological feed get considered and algo? Do we consider SQL queries with WHERE and ORDER BY clauses an algo now?
- threeseed 2y agoPeople keep missing the point of Threads. It isn't designed to be a pure Twitter clone and doesn't want to become the public square for news, politics etc. It wants to be a text-centric network that helps release Instagram to be more video-centric to compete with TikTok. And so it wants content that is fun, interesting and light. And of course easily monetisable. So I know people like having a fight but I see the two sites as being complimentary and both needing to thrive in order to relegate X to the dust bin.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoInstagram was the only social network that kept me around because it was mostly art and nice photos. Recently i caught myself scrolling past endless videos and thought, shit, I've been tiktokked. Back to scrolling through hacker news comments to rot my brain instead.
- danielbln 2y agoI had to disable my YouTube watch history recently because I got trapped into shorts frequently and the only way to disable those is to kill the watch history. One might think it's only Gen Z/Alpha that is susceptible to the Tiktok dopamine squeeze, but no, works just as well on us old geezers and it's pretty nefarious how well it works.
- pythonguython 2y agoLow quality article aside, Threads also had a major spike in usage that quickly dropped off. I could be wrong, but I’m going to guess Bluesky will be the same. They don’t seem to offer anything new/different other than moderation, which I’m not convinced is enough to shift momentum from x to bluesky
- shigawire 2y agoThere is more momentum against Musk now than when threads launched. Not sure it is enough to overcome the network effect - but there is a lot of illwill towards his projects. I can see how something like SpaceX is overall a net good, but I don't see that upside for X.
- unnamed76ri 2y agoFree speech is the upside of X. People leaving to join the echo chambers of Bluesky or Threads, only serves to turn X into the echo chamber they claim it is.
- madeofpalk 2y agoI know I'm falling for the bait, but saying X is some last bastion of free speech is baffling, considering it's actual actions. Why do the remaining posters keep self-censoring "Blues*y"?
- unnamed76ri 2y agoI don’t know what you are referring to. I’ve never seen someone self-censor Bluesky. I see people talking about it on X all the time. Mainly to highlight some of the worst content they find there but that’s another subject… I tried checking out Bluesky the other day. The feed was mainly unhinged political rants of a very particular flavor.
- threecheese 2y ago
- mhh__ 2y agoThreads has a massive problem in that it recruits its users from Instagram (there are others but primarily its still a branch of Instagram) which is the domain of AI generated slop and people I actually know in real life. The whole point of the twitter style firehose is to be not be either of those things. Bluesky honestly probably has a decent shot but I think its still attracting some hyper-orthodox, censorious, thinkers. Musk has gone too far with X[0] but I don't think his vision in the abstract is wrong. [0] Every accusation is a confession - X is now near-directly attached to the US Gov!
- cosmic_cheese 2y agoI think the Bluesky crowd will probably chill out with time, but right now if you don’t readily use the block feature there you’re going to have your feed and notifications peppered with the same trolls that are currently making X inhospitable. The majority of users getting blocked aren’t interested in actual discourse, they’re just there to get a rise out of people. It’s difficult to envision any social network staying healthy in the long term without either decent moderation or robust tools to help users manage harassment and the like. There’s just too many bad actors who will take advantage of low-control environments.
- skybrian 2y ago> inevitable I don't get any trolls on either platform. I guess I'm too boring :)
- cosmic_cheese 2y agoI don’t get much trouble myself personally either, but it shows up in the replies to the posts in my feed which isn’t great and why a good block feature is necessary.
- skybrian 2y agoYes, but the root cause is that Twitter doesn't stop rendering posts when there are no replies left to display. Instead it fills the silence with posts that aren't replies. BlueSky just stops, like a normal program. When there's nothing more to show, silence is okay. So I don't need a blocklist there.
- klntsky 2y agoTwitter does not need a replacement. There seem to be a popular opinion that it does, but it's not something people are willing to act on. It's a better app than it used to be, overall.
- ks2048 2y agoAll politics aside (not a minor point for many), Twitter has been made much worse IMHO in the Musk era. They de-prioritize links, prevent 3rd party apps, closed the API, and blocked access for non-logged-in viewing. And a smaller meta-point: changed from an iconic name to a simple non-informative letter (Besides Google and maybe Uber, who have added a popular verb to the lexicon?)
- anon291 2y agoI feel this is a downside only to a particular bunch. For most people, Twitter is doing better than ever. Community notes are amazing and innovative and should be adopted by every social media platform. X feels legitimately more fun than most other apps. Plus, at this point, I think a solid portion of people have been banned from social media apps. You can't exile your way towards whatever ideal society you want. The barbarians are always at the gates. I especially feel this sort of enforced community separation is so prevalent among those who are so reticent to build a border wall, but I'm sure psychology has an explanation somewhere.
- eadler 2y agoCommunity notes was designed, implemented and released before the acquisition. Only the name is new. Previously it was called birdwatch.
- anon291 2y agoThat's great. Unfortunately, Twitter still had a Kafka-esque moderation policy that is antithetical to the most basic understanding of free thought.
- 2y ago
- frithsun 2y agoIt's inevitable that social media will split up into separate and distinct networks of people who can no longer stand or even undertand the other sociopolitical tribes. All of us sharing a singular global network was an exceptional and ephemeral circumstance.
- PittleyDunkin 2y ago> All of us sharing a singular global network was an exceptional and ephemeral circumstance. Did this happen at all? Social networks have always been balkanized by culture.
- EasyMark 2y agoI use both X and bsky. I would say the behavior on bsky and the hate language is dialed down by a factor of 10.
- shiroiushi 2y agoIt shouldn't be any surprise: it's not like the internet's userbase of 1990 represented a broad cross-section of American society, let alone western or global societies. It was mainly a bunch of academics and college students and government users. It's just gotten more and more fragmented as more people have been added.
- ipaddr 2y agoAnd social media didn't exist
- orbat 2y agoUsenet, BBSs, mailing lists etc. are social media
- lolinder 2y agoIn most ways they were far more social than modern social media, in that they were about socializing. The distinguishing characteristic that sets modern social media apart from the old school stuff is the performative aspect of it—where everyone is now encouraged to behave as a content producer optimizing for engagement—which is hardly social.
- the_black_hand 2y agoThreads is a good product. My twitter feed is dumpster fire of right wing politics and rage baity post. Threads has been much more balance. Open the app and have a good time. People have been trying to make Bluesky happen for years. It won't. I believe moderation is fundamental to any social network, otherwise the bad actors always take over. Meta has been content moderation for years and understands the nuances. People seek "Political discourse", but they will quickly realize our politics are too much of shit-show to have any kind of intellectual conversation. The rage bait and culture wars have taken over. Important discussions of policy, small vs big govt, taxes have taken the backseat. Our "politics" are no longer politics, and won't be for at least the next 4-8 years.
- pacomerh 2y agoI've tried both Threads and Bluesky and I like Bluesky much better, I mean both UI & UX. One issue I have with Threads is that I stumble upon many users that came from Instagram automatically that are not used to post in this format. So the content is mostly a mirror of IG which makes it pointless. In Bluesky I feel like the posts come from people that fleed X and it's just more interesting somehow.
- pajeetz 2y agoBig names like Lichtman announced he was leaving X for Bluesky and came back on X in less than 24 hours. What makes social media work is the echo effect, you just won't be able to get it on a heavily censored platform like Bluesky and Reddit and a big reason why X is overtaking even mainstream media as much as people who lean left. Its a huge problem to be imposing political leanings of the moderator on a public square because you end up creating an echo chamber which people inevitably abandon because you just won't reach enough people.
- epistasis 2y agoWho is Lichtman? Doing a web search for that name brings up many different first names in the top hits. I don't think you can consider whoever that is a "big name." And who wants "big names" on social media? Screw that, only echo chambers need "big names" to bring views. >Its a huge problem to be imposing political leanings of the moderator on a public square because you end up creating an echo chamber which people inevitably abandon because you just won't reach enough people. This describes the problem that X is facing. It censored heavily, and heavily penalizes politically "incorrect" posts that its owner doesn't like, creating an echo chamber that only fringe weirdos can enjoy. I don't need to see any more low-signal hate posts. Please just auto-delete anybody using copious slurs or with a username like N*iggerSlayer42069, it's not an "echo chamber" to not expose oneself to the lowest of the low discussion levels, it's an echo chamber to let those people dominate conversations while censoring technical terms I use every day in the workplace.. I don't need to go to 4chan to "broaden my horizons" and any platform owner that decides to shove that stuff down my throat will not find me on their platform any more.
- vanjajaja1 2y agothreads federates with mastodon, what stops threads getting on the AT protocol? is it just their assumed desire to not share data? they could be a mastodon / AT bridge
- rsynnott 2y agoThere are a couple. They’re… shaky, but they exist.
- 2024user 2y agoCertain groups are trying to will bluesky into being successful. From my personal experience, X/Twitter is still killing it. I'd imagine Threads will be successful unless Zuckerberg kills it to focus on other things. It's integrated with Instagram and could potentially be integrated into Facebook and WhatsApp too.
- phb01 2y agoI think the factor which will determine which networks survive is the ability to handle bots driven by modern AI agents. I’m not sure how even the best moderation features can detect and mitigate these.
- wmf 2y agoAI doesn't matter. Moderation should apply to humans and AIs equally.
- emseetech 2y agoAI has the ability to overwhelm systems of moderation at a much greater scale than humans. That's the issue.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoGood.
- devnullbrain 2y agoCare to share your IP address?
- emseetech 2y agoCan you explain how that's a good thing?
- mcphage 2y ago> Moderation should apply to humans and AIs equally. Unless you’re trying to create a social network to promote human voices and not bots.
- glenstein 2y agoIt does matter because AI can be more effectively leveraged and scaled to support "coordinated inauthentic activity" campaigns.
- 2y ago
- Zigurd 2y agoI made a Bluesky account long ago and started cross-posting my tiktoks, often on the popular and titillating topic of project management. For a long time it was sleepy as I would have expected. I got a sudden uptick recently, which prompted me to figure out how to port my follows from X, which I did with "sky follower bridge." Bluesky has been a lively, friendly place. Sky follower bridge was able to scrape my X blocklist, but could not turn it into a Bluesky block list. No troll problems yet so that's OK for now. I still have to host my videos on titok because some are too long for Bluesky. My tiktok "for you page" has turned to sludge and my followers are not getting my posts without setting notification options. I wonder if the magical algorithm was sequestered in China to hide it from inquiries. Hopefully a Bluesky presence helps.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 2y agoI see the Fediverse as pretty left-wing, but Bluesky seems unlikely to stay that way because moderation works differently. (No admins blocking each other over policy.)
- paxys 2y ago> but now the Bluesky app has exploded to 3.5 million daily active users, putting it just 1.5 times behind Meta’s Threads Are they implying that Threads has just ~5 million daily active users? Adam Mosseri shared in the beginning of November that they have 275 million monthly active users. Bluesky meanwhile has 20 million total users. Considering the author hasn't shared a single source for their claim, I find it hard to believe. Realistically he is off by at least an order of magnitude. Mashable used to be one of my go-to blogs, but I haven't been there in a while. Has it really fallen this far?
- sockaddr 2y agoI’d bet Meta is counting all the random Instagram users that accidentally interact with the forced threads clickbait posts in their feed.
- EasyMark 2y agoI click on it randomly to see if anything is going on and usually close it pretty rapidly, so that is almost a false positive. I find bsky much more of of a time sink
- ElCapitanMarkla 2y agoBe interesting to see if they count people with the app or not. As far as I’m aware you need the app to view threads in their entirety. I tried it but uninstalled shortly after
- 101008 2y agoTreads is accesible via the browser now too
- subarctic 2y agoBut that doesn't really matter right? They got tricked into using it but they're still using it
- 2y ago
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoDid thread have significant traffic to begin with? The last four to six times I logged on it was a ghost town.
- peanuty1 2y agoThey claim to have about 300 million MAUs but it feels empty compared to X.
- reissbaker 2y agoI'm moderately active on X, and helped build an early version of what became Threads (on which I am almost entirely inactive these days). I'm not surprised Bluesky's been more successful than Threads as the X-alternative: * A lot of the popular content on X is political; Threads' decision to downrank or ban political content makes the posts less engaging. It's understandable from a certain perspective — a lot of the political content is just dishonest ragebait (and I learned to unfollow most political X accounts as a result). However, one of the most interesting things about X is that it's where news travels fastest, and it's significantly less-filtered than traditional journalist editorialization. It's hard to compete with X if you don't allow it, or downrank it. * Obviously Elon's massive political spending will have an impact on the userbase of the product, since the spending is so one-sided. X has become dramatically more right-wing since he took over, and even more so after Trump's campaign, so there was pent-up demand for something else... Especially something else that allows left-wing political content (i.e. not Threads). There are a lot of conspiracy theories about Elon changing the X ranking algorithm to favor right-wing content, but TBH I think it's simpler than that: more left-wing people left the site (or used it less) due to distaste for Elon, and Elon unbanned hordes of right-wing accounts, who are very enthusiastic about supporting it. * There's also one way in which X is (openly) biased in its ranking: paid accounts have their posts ranked higher than free accounts... And paying for X is public: you have a blue check next to your name if you pay. In right-wing spaces, having a paid bluecheck account is a badge of honor, in part due to it supporting Elon; in left-wing spaces, it's a badge of shame for the same reason. Although from a technical standpoint the ranking change isn't specifically political, in practice it's very political: many more right-wingers are bluechecks, so in practice you see more of their content and less left-wing content. Bluesky doesn't have paid accounts, and even if it did, it wouldn't organically result in right-wing content being prioritized to the same extent, so for left-wing users it's a much friendlier place. * This is perhaps more of a personal gripe, but Elon Musk's decision to downrank external links has been pretty bad for the quality of X content. I understand the reasoning: he's trying to keep people engaged in-app, and external links make you leave. But plenty of interesting people use X as a promotional channel for their (interesting) content, which I want to see, and which often doesn't suit tweet formats. So by downranking posts with external links, I see less of the things I actually am interested in. I don't think I'm alone in this, and Bluesky doesn't do it — and I've heard (anecdotal) reports of people really enjoying being able to more reliably engage with that kind of stuff again on Bluesky. Mastodon is too complicated and segmented to take off. But Bluesky isn't, so I can see why it's having a zeitgeist post-Trump's-election, which Elon helped fund. I'm not sure how much Bluesky will manage to retain its current spike in users: Threads at one point had a similar spike, and most users churned back to X. But it makes sense to me that Bluesky is a more natural home for the ex-X diaspora than Threads, given the reasons many of them left X.
- thekevan 2y agoI still feel that an enormous amount of why threads shows up in data analytics is because Instagram just added it on and made an account for everyone. It wasn't adopted, it was falsely created. I'd go even further to say that it isn't a social network, it's an add-on to another social network.
- rcpt 2y agoThreads is so confusing. I have no idea who's replying to who when I click into a discussion.
- xyzabcrst 2y agoSame thing happened to TikTok and Lemon8 recently, though the move had to do more with US banning.
- bloomingkales 2y agoYou know, they stopped Amazon from buying iRobot because of I guess unfair robot vacuum competition (why does that sound hilarious?). It's almost luck that Threads isn't that successful, because then they'd have to deal with monopoly concerns. At least now they can just say it's a shitty twitter knock off, don't bother us.
- hughesjj 2y agoIt reminds me of google plus. Technically better than the existing top dog, but the forced migration and trying to bootstrap with a huge but only semi involved userbase let it fizzle soon after the start. Has there ever been a successful case of bootstrapping a new social media product with an existing userbase? Like not just added features or merging two together.
- AlchemistCamp 2y agoYes. WeChat bootstrapped off of QQ accounts, which were basically like Yahoo or MSN messenger + pages for desktop users.
- citizenkeen 2y ago
- sirolimus 2y agoWhats the point? bluesky, threads, mastodon, we have x.com works just fine.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kivle 2y agoFor me it's a very easy choice to go with Bluesky over Threads. With Threads you can already see that Facebook/Instagram is in it's DNA. There's no pure "following" feed. It's instead an algorithmic feed that mixes people you follow with people Threads decides to push. So it's going down the enshittification path from day one. With Bluesky there's at least some hope that it will not end up as the algorithmic time sinks all other social media has slowly become. I'm all for discoverability, but allow me to decide when and how I discover new people to follow. Never touch my "following" feed, and I'll be happy.
- vitorgrs 2y agoHuh, there is a following feed...
- sakesun 2y agoI find it's interesting that React which Bluesky was built on, was originally license with BSD + patents, which disallow building Facebook competing products.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoI agree there's some irony to be had but I must make a correction: it revoked your license if you infringed on patents owned by Facebook. Does Facebook have patents on "add friend" buttons and "timeline"s ? (Asking, I don't know the answer)
- Numerlor 2y agoGotta ask, am I missing something with how bluesky is supposed to be used? Every time I open something from there it takes over 30 seconds to load on my phone
- elicash 2y agoYou're experiencing a bug.
- RickJWagner 2y agoICYMI, Actor/director/activist Rob Reiner just proclaimed Bluesky to be a racist platform full of evil. https://www.msn.com/en-us/tv/news/rob-reiner-says-maga-scum-have-already-wrecked-bluesky/ar-AA1uvShn https://www.msn.com/en-us/tv/news/rob-reiner-says-maga-scum-...
- jazzyjackson 2y agoCatch me checking into a mental facility cause all the padded rooms online were taken
- cynicalpeace 2y agoI predict Bluesky will go the way of Threads and Mastodon.
- jaimex2 2y agoProbably worse. Mastedon runs on self hosting, Threads has a parent company with deep pockets and is a Instgram mod at best. Twitter burned cash for years and it could because it was new, innovative and growing quickly. Once BlueSky burns through its initial money whats the plan and why would anyone invest in it?
- stiltzkin 2y ago[dead]
- amiga386 2y agoAnother day, another advert for Bluesky. There've been 70 stories with "bluesky" in the title submitted to HN this week alone, compared with 130 in the past month. For all the talk of leaving Twitter, Twitter has 30x the daily visits of its rivals: https://www.axios.com/2024/11/14/elon-musk-x-attention-war-social-media https://www.axios.com/2024/11/14/elon-musk-x-attention-war-s... My personal view is if you're on Twitter, leave it and don't replace it with anything. Find peace and tranquility in your life.
- mcphage 2y ago> For all the talk of leaving Twitter, Twitter has 30x the daily visits of its rivals. Over the whole world maybe, but perhaps not among the HN crowd.
- mwinatschek 2y agoSocial media was doomed the moment its users were demoted from customers to exploitable sources of data. Bluesky will inevitably follow the same path of enshittification as every other social network before it. Its current success hinges solely on the nostalgic desire for a single platform where people can gather in peace. The real question is: How many cycles of doom will people endure before they finally stop jumping from one sinking ship to another?
- izzydata 2y agoThere are no ads so that is one aspect that could prevent enshitification. Businesses can't just spend money to force their way into peoples feeds. At least not in a traditional advertising kind of way.
- afavour 2y ago> Bluesky will inevitably follow the same path of enshittification Why do you say that? Bluesky is a protocol-first non profit. To my knowledge no company set up that way has achieved this level of success before. They don’t have the same motivations to enshittify that other networks do.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoOpenAI was a nonprofit to make sure benefit of AGI was distributed equally. I think it's plausible AT protocol allows a new level of interop/portability between services. It's also possible Bluesky burns through Blockchain Capital's money and starts doing crypto air drops like Keybase.
- potamic 2y agoHow is a company that has received investments, a non-profit? Those investors will require returns, which means the primary objective must be profit. Otherwise they would have just asked for donations.
- afavour 2y ago> Those investors will require returns, which means the primary objective must be profit It doesn’t mean that has to be the primary objective, just that at some point it should happen.
- wnevets 2y agoThe head of instagram/threads (Mosseri) appears to have no idea how the algorithm on these platforms work. He is shocked to see how many people are talking about threads in his feed. It may explain how threads has managed to waste such a large captured audience.
- cryptica 2y agoI refuse to use Bluesky because it is clearly being pushed on the masses, in collusion with mainstream media, as an alternative to X. Clearly another attempt by certain people to control information. It's shocking how people fall for this stuff over and over again. I hope if backfires, mostly draws in users from existing speech-unfriendly platforms and then the number of social media platforms will multiply from here onward and a large number of platforms will compete based on who is most permissive with regards to speech. Most of the highly suggestible masses already moved off X to Threads... So now that Bluesky is being pushed hard, I hope the suggestible people from Threads will switch over and split up their censorship ecosystems. It makes sense from that perspective. The censored ecosystems should be separated into lots of small platforms because you need a lot of different filter bubbles to maintain the deceptions and impermeable information silos. A large centralized ecosystem will create too many opportunities for exposure to alternative information so it cannot be controlled as well. In the future, there will be a different platform for every kind of delusion and each one will focus on its own delusion and will make up stories to discredit rival platforms so people always doubt information received outside. It's a matter of time before large corporations start preventing their employees from using non-approved platforms. They'll probably use cybersecurity safety as an excuse. They might carry out hacking false flags on their own employees to convince them to not use other platforms they won't feel forced.
- drivingmenuts 2y agoAnd you don't think the desire to get away from Elon Musk and the MAGA crowd had anything to do with it? Nothing good was ever going to come about because of Elon's stupid acquisition. That was made painfully obvious when Xitter stopped paying their bills - I guess in the hopes that creditors would be forced to arbitrate lower payments on debts owed to them (which is bullshit for a billionaire to be doing, but you don't get to be a billionaire by being nice, fully ethical, moral or legal). Then we had a demonstration of sheer stupidity Elon told advertisers to fuck off, so they did, and now he's all hurt and lawsuity. What good do you see in that? Who wouldn't want to get away from that stupidity?
- cryptica 2y ago
- dgudkov 2y agoAn extension to port your following from Twitter to Bluesky: Chrome: https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/sky-follower-bridge/behhbpbpmailcnfbjagknjngnfdojpko https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/sky-follower-bridge... Firefox: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-CA/firefox/addon/sky-follower-bridge/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-CA/firefox/addon/sky-follower-... Disclaimer: I'm not affiliated in any way. I just tried it and it worked well.
- elphinstone 2y agoWhere's Google's Twitter clone? It can have AI nobody wants, a bland name nobody will remember, and be quietly sunsetted when nobody uses it.
- slater 2y agoCan't help you on the first item there, but everything else: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaiku https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaiku
- rsynnott 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Buzz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Buzz It was actually okay. Half-surprised they didn’t bring it back when Twitter self-immolated.
- ogou 2y agoThreads attracted a lot of people that I left behind on Facebook. It also gets a lot of people that cross-post to every platform. I can't think of a single post that I saw and still remember. Bluesky lets you block reposts and that has been the killer feature for me. Original content from people I choose is the best recipe for my tastes. Also, I spend a lot of time on niche creative feeds and really enjoy the things I see. I also like the idea of seeing regional and local feeds. That was an interesting part of early Twitter that was obliterated by national political emphasis. No more political hot takes, where is a good Korean BBQ spot?
- damnloveless 2y agolive bluesky user counter: https://bcounter.nat.vg/ https://bcounter.nat.vg/
- elisharobinson 2y agothey are afloat using VC math . I dont think modern web is a place for a social media company. the AD revenue / AWS bill does not make sense. Unless they become a data broker like Meta. Or become the microphone for a group or individual.