14 ms·
The 'Return to Office' Lies
- dgfitz 2y agoThat last point about a large retirement effect looming is a pretty salient movement to bring up. I wonder if most of the RTO-enforcing people will be swept up in that 50%.
- tayo42 2y agowhere does that number come from? and i cant imagine it applies equally across industries if it is true. 50% of software related job cant be 5 years to retirement?
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoIt’s BS through and through. Covid led in the most early retirement ever seen. We’re are not expecting a spike in retirement by any measure that I have seen.
- dgfitz 2y agoYeah that’s fair, I didn’t do any research on behalf of the author, and they didn’t cite any sources. I do think that there a lot of baby boomers hanging out in the workforce still, Covid just pushed the RIP (retired in place) people over the edge. Reflecting on my place of employment though, I can only come up with a handful of people planning to retire in the next year. We also fired a lot of them recently, so there’s that.
- shermantanktop 2y agoI have heard every possible sentiment about RTO at this point. The post is a well-written spleen vent, and I mostly agree, but I didn’t see anything new in it. But because everyone has an opinion, I’ll share mine: I like being in the office, sometimes. I hate going to and from the office.
- smallnix 2y agoHere is mine: I like the commute, it marks the beginning and end of my workday and I get fresh air. I loathe being in the office, it is mentally taxing and I have to put in more for the same output.
- orangesun 2y agoFair point. Nice separation between personal life and work.
- derekp7 2y agoI have an easy commute (35 - 45 minutes, but not bad traffic and pretty roads), and a comfy car. The commute is my peaceful time, when I don't have to answer to anyone.
- willcipriano 2y agoI'd rather go to the gym than be in a car for the same effect.
- ghaff 2y agoI guess I don't really consider that an easy commute though I've done something along those lines off and on over the years. It's not bad like when I commuted about 90 minutes a few days a week. "Easy" for me is a 15-30 minute walk with maybe some mass transit mixed in there if the weather is bad. And, yes, if I had an office to go into, I would do so some days if that were my option.
- hmottestad 2y agoMy commute is a 15 minute bike ride. 9/10 days it’s nice weather, I get some air and possibly some sunlight. Office isn’t too bad, and it’s nice to meet other adults. I don’t think I would enjoy it as much if I had a desk in a big, shared office space and a 45 minute bus ride. Ironically those days that are so bad that I think that I almost shouldn’t try to bike, those are the days that the busses don’t run because the busses and more sensitive to the weather than my e-bike with studded tires. Busses in Oslo don’t work if it’s raining a lot or if it’s snowing a lot. It’s really sad since it’s snows and rains quite a lot every year. Our locally public transport is more interested in trailing self-driving cars than testing out new tires :(
- Trasmatta 2y agoWhen you work in an open office everyone ends up just talking on Slack most of the time anyway. Except those people who have no sense of boundaries, and will gladly invade your personal space and interrupt your train of thought at any time for any reason, leading to a constant state of anxious hypervigelence preventing you from ever fully concentrating on something.
- rectang 2y agoMeanwhile there are those who expect you to process every Slack ping, making them in some ways worse those who interrupt in person — since they don’t feel the distress of the person they’re interrupting through the screen. A workplace’s culture of consideration is expressed through communication channels, but is not determined by the choice of channel.
- Loughla 2y agoIM's and the like are the bane of my existence. If I'm busy I can close a door or put a sign up. I can close email. Nobody expects me to immediately respond to email anyways. But instant messages? Everyone expects instant responses. Even when their message is something like, "hey,I see you have your door closed. Are you busy?" FFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUU
- savanaly 2y ago>But instant messages? Everyone expects instant responses. My understanding is people don't expect instant responses, but that's never been made explicit. What do you base your understanding on? Do folks tell you?
- zenogantner 2y agoIM software can be closed, too, and in a healthy company the expectations around IMs should not be that they are "instant", but more of an async medium like email.
- mulmen 2y agoIn my 15 year corporate career I have never met anyone who expects an immediate reply to an IM.
- spaceywilly 2y agoI resisted RTO as much as anyone but eventually I took a job that required me to be in office 3 days a week because, well, didn’t have much of a choice. I have to say being in the office has been better than I expected. I recently got together with a group of former coworkers, who I worked with for many years at a startup, and have kept in touch all these years later. We noted that this kind of friendship definitely would not have happened if we were working remote. My only thing is, I would rather have the flexibility to choose where I work, even if only at the team level. It gets cold where I live in winter, I would love to be able to go stay someplace warm during those months, and come to the office when I want to be there. I feel like for me, this debate isn’t really about working in the office vs working from home, it’s about control. Companies have realized that they gave over too much soft power to employees during the pandemic, so they are now working together to claw it back. They could care less where we work, as long as they are the ones in control.
- Loughla 2y agoI just turned down a job that I would've been amazing at, because they're in person 3 days a week. They lost literally tens of millions in grant opportunities that I have written and the experience I bring, because they wouldn't go remote 3 days instead of just 2. I understand wanting some time in person, absolutely. I hate it, but it does make certain processes much easier. But to not negotiate at all, even when the candidate is perfect for the job and happy with everything else? Ridiculous.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoI’m sure the person that took that job is grateful.
- Loughla 2y agoIt's still open. So instead of filling it with a massively qualified candidate, they chose pain.
- 2y ago
- eterm 2y ago[flagged]
- csa 2y ago> The title mentions "lies" but the main article doesn't use the word once. The entire second paragraph (after a short intro paragraph) is about the lies, and it doesn’t really seem ambiguous. That said, I agree that it comes across as an immature rant.
- good4u 2y ago[dead]
- good4u 2y ago[dead]
- jvanderbot 2y ago> mentions "lies" but ... That's not fair. I didn't finish it, but they spent at least half the article pointing out deliberate misconceptions and misrepresentations of the reasons for going back to office. That is definitely lying, either repeating someone else's lie or making your own. They just used different words. > Immature > Throwing toys Sheesh, the point is "It's hard and not useful for me - and likely hard and not useful for others". You may not find this convincing, but let's recall the main rhetorical mechanisms, all the way back to Aristotle: Pathos, Logos, Ethos. Using Pathos (emotion, in this case sympathy) is a fine way of persuading. It didn't work for you, but it's not "immature" to point out physical, emotional limits when asked to do something.
- KronisLV 2y ago> The title mentions "lies" but the main article doesn't use the word once. > This is just someone angrily reacting to a frustrating situation, it's not a reasoned argument for the effectiveness of working from home. I feel like the "fake positivity" and various arguments for supposedly better productivity or innovation (or even the claim that there is the sort of innovation that would better happen in person vs remotely, in a given environment) would fit the role of being described as lies. At the same time, anyone calling for data is going to struggle to find an unbiased look at it: between corporations trying to equate hybrid work to a fully fledged alternative to being in the office all the time (and replace the idea of fully remote work), that hybrid model still having a certain amount of being present in person being set in stone (in a top down fashion) and in addition to some people just functioning better remotely or in office (the same as how some will thrive/be miserable with synchronous/asynchronous communication or the preference for various levels of social interaction), you'll struggle to find anything that is applicable across the board. I think best anyone can do is not buy into others trying to make absolute claims one way or the other and just look at works best for them. I feel best working remotely and being in the office all the time would both take away some freedom from me and make me feel miserable. If anyone was trying to erase that with a plethora of claims that feel shallow or made up, then it'd surely be frustrating. And if that's the direction that the whole industry eventually goes, well, I guess I'll just be a somewhat more miserable employee then. > An immature rant that doesn't make the point very well. > This person is obviously frustrated by a much less understanding employer, but the article is written in such a childish way it's hard to be as sympathetic as it would if they were more carefully considered in their writing. I disagree with both of these. The writing feels genuine and I don't think there's anything wrong with it.
- tayo42 2y ago> We are not pioneers or a Silicon Valley tech firm! Working in a silicon valley tech company your still not innovating, I spend lot of my time making bullshit suck less. And if I was innovating, and for the few times I did actually get to do something cool, I want a quiet room with no distractions so I can focus and research and hack on things. I think one of my most productive and innovative times at work I did a work-cation for a couple week, to a different timezone by 3 hours, no people interutpions and no slack interruptions.
- bitwize 2y agoJohn Carmack was said to take a weekend and lock himself in a hotel room so he could achieve total focus on difficult problems. What surprised me about this article is that it's not the typical Hackernews fare of "Hi, we're Cerridwen, a transenby fox-weasel hybrid plural system and CISO of Eoana, a startup building enterprise static container verification tools in Rust." It was just someone with kind of a shitty job who does tech on the side because it interests her. There are more people like her out there working in "tech", by far, than there are Cerridwens, and yet the Cerridwens are the ones who bubble to the top of Hackernews. And so the thinking of Hackernews tends to be within the Cerridwen bubble, whether we're aware of it or not. So it's great to get a more ordinary perspective on this kind of issue.
- VinLucero 2y agoMy biggest takeaway from this was the ableist messaging: “You cannot dangle what people need to effectively work in front of them like a carrot and subtly threaten to take it away. It’s ableist. You wouldn’t dare to do that with elevators or other accessibility features at the office, so don’t do it with that either.”
- Bjartr 2y ago> You wouldn’t dare to do that with elevators or other accessibility features This is only because there's usually legal protection for that kinds of accessibility features. If employers could legally, it would be way more common to threaten to take them away. I have no doubt there are some that do so illegally.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoYou have “no doubt” that employers threaten to take away elevators?
- Bjartr 2y agoThey're are some extremely callous assholes out there running businesses (as there are in every walk of life) so it doesn't take much effort to find stories of terrible employers taking advantage of underinformed employees. Why would this particular item be any different?
- devmor 2y agoI would agree with their sentiment. I don't know how common it would be, but it would certainly happen at least in some occasions. When I was young, I worked in a call center in which the bathroom was taken away as a punishment for bad rates on multiple occasions, until someone called the Dept. of Labor over it.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoIDK, sitting in a call center can’t be good for you. So imagine complaining at the beneficial favor they did for you.
- Conscat 2y agoI'm currently negotiating a deal to get relocation assistance in exchange for being in the office sometimes, on a job that was intended to be fully remote. In my case, I need to leave my current state of residence for health reasons soon, and this company's campus is attractive enough that I'm excited anyways.
- surgical_fire 2y agoI go to the office a couple of times per week. Those are largely unproductive days, and being in the office is a massive waste of time. If the company is willing to sacrifice productivity to pretend any collaboration is happening because butts in seats look nice, oh well.
- cube00 2y agoYet the deadlines don't move to accommodate this.
- carimura 2y agomaybe this is an unpopular opinion but this culture of aggressively and publicly airing all grievances of current employer seems counterproductive for the job search when this person leaves due to said grievances. or maybe it's just a pre-match for future companies that "appreciate" this type of transparency. :shrug:
- Apocryphon 2y agoIt’s an anonymous blog…?
- christhecaribou 2y agoThat’s what life is all about, right? The job search, the grind, the hustle…
- cle 2y agoI'd bet that most people agree with you, which is why the people who actually do it get a lot of attention--from the other folks who want to, but can't. This particular topic notwithstanding, employers have so much leverage that it's risky to stick your neck out but I'm thankful there are people who do it.
- christhecaribou 2y agoI’d rather hire a brave asshole than a compliant, meek little ship.
- cle 2y agoI'd bet that a large amount of them are not "compliant, meek little sheep", but are balancing risk-taking with providing for their families. Does that make them cowards?
- christhecaribou 2y agoYes.
- jaysinn_420 2y agoI quit my FAANG job yesterday to join a fully remote company. I took a >50% pay cut but I think it is a 100% life saver. I remember spending 3-4 hours/day commuting and I am just not willing to do that any more. I've cut back on expenses and simplified my life, built up some savings so I can make do with less. My retirement savings will slow down dramatically, but if I don't hate my work life then those savings will be less of an all-consuming goal. Thank you senior leadership for your wisdom, "If you don't like it, find another place to work". The first good advice I've heard from them in 5 years.
- poniko 2y agoSounds like a correct action .. good on you, enjoy the extra time in your life, it's the real value.
- argentinian 2y agoMoney can't buy time.
- switch007 2y agoWhat do you think about private jets, passes to skip theme park queues, world class life saving medical treatment etc?
- argentinian 2y agoYes, good point. In those cases it can be said it allows you to extend your lifespan, or reduce the time spent in an undesirable situation. So I'll reformulate what I wanted to express before: The time that somebody chooses to spend in a 80 hour workweek can't be recovered. So you'd better be sure that spending so much time in a job is what you really want to do. Also, there's an interesting article about the topic: "Top 5 regrets people have when they die, says ex-hospice care worker" https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/07/phrases-that-are-often-peoples-last-regrets-says-author-what-we-can-learn.html https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/07/phrases-that-are-often-peopl...
- gdiamos 2y agoMy favorite environment is a 5-10 person office, no more than 5 miles from everyone’s home. I know how to make that work in a startup, but its premise doesn’t scale beyond a pizza box. Has anyone figured out a better way that works at 100 people? One idea I’m curious about is pods. Could you build a small team who all live close enough together? Could they coordinate remotely with the mothership? The default seems to be to just embrace remote. Or issue a RTO as a ‘polite’ way to decimate the team and reduce burn.
- ghaff 2y agoSo what happens when someone wants to change teams for whatever reason? Or they're presented with a new opportunity? On the other side of the city--or in a different city. Do they have to move?
- gdiamos 2y agoThere are clear flaws. I haven’t figured it out. Being able to form and disband teams dynamically is an advantage. That does seem to favor a big enough pool of people in the same place. Or relying on remote for projects spanning pods.
- mxuribe 2y agoI actually would not mind a slightly bigger org - like even up to 100 or so...but everything else you noted i'm 100% in agreement with. I'll call this the "village way"...because what you noted - to me at least - seems like how villages, small towns, whatever you want to call them had to exist a hundred years ago or so...like, not just before digital, but i mean, even when base telecom was not a common thing....so i would imagine most folks in a town/village worked for one of a few extremely local workplaces. I'm not saying having only very few employers in an area is good, since that would be giving a central group way too miuch power. But, yeah, i kinda yearn for a sort of village approach. And, yes, it could also mean that the "local pod" is everyone in the local area working together in one place, but remotely coordinating with a mothership as you put it. That all sounds pretty decent! But, this approach is not something that powers-that-be would even begin to support...even though, i betcha, this approach would have tons of people actually invested in the success of the org because of the good that it represents in allowing people to earn a living without making commutes and such that much more difficult. I know that if my employers supoorted this sort of model, i would not only work karder, but actually give more of a damn, and really care to have the org succeed. Basically, i would contribute far more to the org. But, nah, the bosses just want to squeeze the lemons, and not care how they get their juice produced. ;-)
- creaktive 2y agoFAANG are not-so-subtly forcing people to quit because they over-hired in the last years. Slow clap.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoAnd if people are just interchangeable widgets, that's a clever strategy. People aren't, though. The most valuable people are the ones who have the most options, precisely because they are valuable. If you play that game, you're going to differentially lose your most valuable people. That's not a smart move.
- neofrommatrix 2y agoThe assumption being made is the most valuable people can be replaced by a couple of “less valuable” ones by make them toil harder and re-learn all knowledge the valuable ones had.
- IshKebab 2y agoThis is not a good article. It has pretty much no argument against RTO and is entirely one-sided, not even mentioning any of the real advantages of working in an office. Hopefully by this point everyone understands that office working has significant upsides for some jobs/people, and only downsides for others. Can we please stop saying "it's good" or "it's bad". It's like arguing whether marmite tastes nice. For me, as a lowly code monkey I could never work anywhere where going to the office was mandatory again. The advantages aren't worth the commute. I would imagine if I was in upper management I might be more tempted though. Zoom just can't match real life.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y ago[flagged]
- mariusor 2y agoI think OP is not arguing if working in the office is good or bad. The point, as far as I can understand, is about the way the return to office is presented to the workers. With sugary lies and fake cheer. It's like they're addressing toddlers in preschool.
- christhecaribou 2y agoI’m so disgusted by the entitlement of “founders” and business folks who have never coded, forcing the technical people who make their lives possible to suffer for a pointless commute. It’s to the point that I realized the tech industry may not be for me. I don’t want to be a shill for Bezos or Musk or some other tasteless billionaire. I may opt to leave entirely. I’ve started religiously studying for the LSAT. Maybe if I work hard, I can push to make America better so these insipid fucks cannot play with our lives.
- juped 2y agoYou are going to love law firms, then.
- hackable_sand 2y agoVery much feel that sentiment. I'm grinding to start a cooperative company with a non-abusive work philosophy. I have respect for the people I collaborate with. It's easy. Yet so many managers and business owners rely on explicit abuse and manipulation... for what?
- hartator 2y agoworking from home != working remotely You should still have a seperation of spaces with your home and your work. If not, you focus less when working and relax less when chilling. It's doubly counterproductive.
- evantbyrne 2y agoSkill issue. Newton did just fine in his home office.
- fire_lake 2y agoIn this economy? Most can’t afford this in Europe.
- mistercow 2y agoYou can have a separation of spaces within your home. I have a home office. The only time I go in there when I'm not working is if I left something there (and it's really nice that "swinging by the office to grab my earbuds" doesn't involve a commute). As a result, I just don't think of that room as part of my home. I'm never tempted to go in there and use that room for something else. For the most part, it's as if that room only exists during the workday.
- christhecaribou 2y agoAny data, bro? Or should we just take your word
- righthand 2y agoSome people enjoy going to the office to get out of the house though. I agree some of the messaging about needing to RTO is illogical but going to an office for work can be beneficial to fighting loneliness. That shouldn’t be a reason to RTO however. I think if you don’t enjoy the office it’s time to find a remote job and that anti-return to office rhetoric doesn’t necessarily apply to every company.
- christhecaribou 2y agoAnyone younger than a boomer knows how to make friends, they don’t need office hostages for that.
- righthand 2y agoNever suggested that. Nice ageism though.
- sevensor 2y agoThere’s what I view as a common misperception embedded in the article. RTO isn’t about empty real estate, or not mostly. Leases can be broken, everything is subject to negotiation. Sure, there’s a cost, but it could be paid. It’s not about real estate, it’s about power. For a brief period, during the great resignation, executives felt the sting of at will employment, a weapon that was never meant to be used against them. RTO is about showing us all who is really in charge.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoYeah, well, see, if you're an exec and you didn't like feeling "the sting of at will employment", forcing RTO is a great way to feel it again.
- ipaddr 2y agoFor smaller companies yes leases can be broken but for others spending billions building college like campuses where they sublease space to businesses to sell to employees part of their worth is connected to real estate value. Others getting tax breaks by having people in an office in a downtown core. For Faangs it's about power, control and real estate. For the yc startup crowd it's often about investor control forcing it and fake signalling (come to my trendy office and look at people working) and inexperienced management who needs to see what effects their poor decisions are having with their eyes so they can pivot.
- rachofsunshine 2y agoI run a remote company, so I don't have skin in trying to convince anyone that RTO is a good idea. And there might be some truth to this in a wider, more systemic sense, in that employers and employees are always in some degree of zero-sum negotiation. But...like, do you think management actually thinks in these terms? I've known some pretty rich and powerful people. None of them talk this way behind closed doors, or at least they haven't around me. Even the ones that denigrate social programs or support for workers or poverty don't frame it this way. They think - rightly or wrongly - that it's a more effective way to run their company, usually because they don't trust workers not to abuse remote work, or sometimes because they've bought into some hustle-culture narrative that wanting comfortable work means you're not a Scrappy Highly Motivated Self Starter or whatever.
- zeroonetwothree 2y ago> The point is micromanagement and needing to justify the large office spaces they invested into. Justifying office space is not a useful business strategy. I think it’s best to treat people you disagree with as reasonable and consider what their motivations could be. In this case I think it’s clear there is one big one—-productivity. It’s clear that some people (not everyone!) use remote work as a way to do minimal work (see r/overemployed). Moreover there are some benefits to in person collab in terms of being able to discuss things quickly and rely on people to be there. And I say this as a remote worker who loves it and never wants to RTO. But I don’t assume the other side is acting in bad faith, I think there’s pros/cons to both. Mostly remote work is great, but not always. Sometimes my teammates randomly don’t respond to me on an urgent issue and I have no recourse. Sometimes they aren’t making progress on work I am counting on and I can’t tell if they are even working.
- ipaddr 2y agoBeing able to jump into a zoom call with everyone immediately outweighs trying to book a room or walking over to someone's desk. I can easily waste more time and look like I am working in the office where at home it's hard to coverup nothing has been done. There has been some bad faith over hiring and then forcing rto to avoid termination payouts. We see Musk plans to do the same even moving government offices to states like Wyoming. Most companies are not bad faith actors just copying others.
- Aloisius 2y agoFunny, I find the expectation of having to immediately join ad-hoc zoom calls, interrupting me while I'm busy working, to be a pretty huge negative. I miss being able to look over and check to see if someone was busy before interrupting them. I also miss being able to read body language during meetings and not having to stare at the camera the entire time or having people talk over each other repeatedly due to network delays.
- seadan83 2y agoRather than sharing our own anecdotes about how we feel about RTO - maybe we can try something different and discuss the specific points raised in the article? Particularly this point: in office collaboration is digital I feel the other points have been hashed out to death on other similar HN discussions: - in office socialization is shallow and distracts from more meaningful socialization with family and friends - at home office is far more accommodating to fit an individuals needs
- tdeck 2y agoSure, I'll bite: > in office socialization is shallow and distracts from more meaningful socialization with family and friends Many people's adult friends come from work. Sometimes their spouse does too. I've noticed a phenomenon where more junior team members in particular would go into the office, even though the senior folks rarely did, and I think part of this is just to meet people because they may not have built up a friend group in their city yet. > at home office is far more accommodating to fit an individuals needs That's the case for me, although it depends a lot on your physical home situation and the social dynamic at home. I think for some folks the office is an escape.
- jovial_cavalier 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tikhonj 2y agoOh no, if only it were possible to collaborate without being forced into an office! Hopefully we can invent some sort of technology for communicating asynchronously to make this possible.
- jovial_cavalier 2y agoIt's perfectly possible to collaborate remotely, but the casual contempt many of you display towards your coworkers shows that you do not play nice with others - remote or in person.
- surgical_fire 2y agoEhh, you don't need to be pals with your coworkers to have a healthy professional relationship with them. It tends to work pretty well remotely too. You don't need to be in person to collaborate when needed.
- christhecaribou 2y agolol, “entitlement”? Do you believe companies pay over $200k out of charity? They pay what they have to pay, and that $200k is artificially lowered by illegal backroom deals by the FAANG cartel. You sound like a bitter contractor. And even if you aren’t, support your fellow proles.
- jovial_cavalier 2y agoI'm not a contractor. I'm saying, if I were you, I wouldn't be pissing and moaning about the terms under which I'm being given $200k a year to drink smoothies and pretend to do engineering work.
- TrackerFF 2y agoMy observation has been: Those that are most pro back-to-office are the ones that are either very extroverted, and have human-to-human roles. Or the people that simply can't disconnect between work and home. I know some people that say they simply can't focus on work, unless they're at the workplace, or some other non-home office. But by far, it's the extroverted managers that seem to hammer on about return to office.
- bbqfog 2y agoThey're afraid that people will see that they're not needed in the organization. It's easy to fake that when everyone is forced into the same location and the people who like to talk do just that.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ragnardan 2y ago"At my place, we don’t innovate, we don’t develop new products for a mass market; we do lots of data entry, emails, and writing reports in SharePoint or with comments and track changes in Word." "...we are not designers or knowledge workers solving issues, we handle data!" The second sentence is what got me. I know it's implied as the author's perspective, but speak for yourself. I am a developer, designer, knowledge worker, and my products are used to solve business issues. There would be no point moving data around and making dashboards, products, automation, except for solving business problems or pushing the bottom line up through innovation. The whole point of our jobs is to facilitate the needs of the business. I agree with the general thrust of the article, that in person routine working isn't needed. I work fully remote and collaborate better in many respects that way. There is also value in having face to face meetings and conversations, body language, microexpressions, aspects of tone are all significantly more palpable in person. BUT, that doesn't mean we should be in the office all the time, just for occasional face to face meetings. My employer is in another state, I visit for a bit every quarter or two. It also doesn't change the fact that the return to office is motivated by micromanagement and stop losses on real estate.
- jagged-chisel 2y ago“ The whole point of our jobs is to facilitate the needs of the business.” But people conflate the needs of the business with the “needs” of the executives or investors. I have little faith that any exec that I have met that is capable of putting their own ego aside and honestly describe how RTO helps the business. Maybe it does help the business, but I haven’t seen anyone make that case.
- thepuppet33r 2y agoThe thing I keep coming back to here is how we all must sound to the janitors, security guards, baristas, etc, who can't ever work from home. I understand that most of us worked our asses off to get to a skilled position and that in many ways it makes far more sense to be able to work from home. I myself am being dragged back into the office 5 full days a week and it's a 45 minute one way commute on a good day, so I'm salty about that. But hearing people who live 10 minutes from the office in $450,000 houses complaining loudly in the lobby about being forced back into the office right near the minimum wage security desk is a little uncomfortable.
- jm20 2y agoNever think that pure hard work leads to success, placement, privilege, or anything else. The farmhand in a field works harder than 99.9% of high paid tech employees. Hard work is important, sure, but it’s all about relative value contribution in the market, nothing else. It’s easy to find another farmhand, it’s hard to find another ML engineer
- thepuppet33r 2y agoI agree, and I've argued vocally against RTO from my privileged position because I have that value that makes me hard to replace. I just want to make sure that we're not forgetting the people who weren't able to become high-level ML engineers for various social and economic reasons and are locked into 10 hour hard days in person.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoA lot of people bullied the ever hell out of the current ML engineers today. A lot of those bullies are only just now experiencing the economic effects of their actions from 10-30 years ago. Kids knew which kids they’d have to clean to the house of 20 years in the future and they intuitively want to knock those elite kids down a peg while they still can. Never forget the extreme resentment that those around nerds have for a nerds mind. When this country stops treating nerds like shit and celebrating anti-intellectualism, I’ll start being worried about the plight of the lowly security guard.
- jzellis 2y agoI've worked remotely my entire career since the 90s with only a few short exceptions. It's a dealbreaker for me and always has been. I do not like to have people around when I'm working, I don't do office politics, I'm not willing to keep my mouth shut when Ted from Accounting starts talking right wing bullshit, and I'm more productive sitting on the patio of a cafe than I am in some shitty cubicle. On the few occasions I ever was required to come into an office and desperate enough for a paycheck that I did it, I always figured out the company was shady somehow. I'm closer to the end of my career, such as it is, than the beginning, but I'll be damned if I'll ever work in an office again. If you rented some luxurious ass space somewhere and spent your seed money on expensive furniture that's your problem. I need a laptop and a chair and a table and coffee and nicotine and for everyone to shut the fuck up and quit bothering me so I can do my job.
- f3z0 2y agoI think there is a fallacy “if I am more productive at home than therefore all must be more productive at home”. Consider though that the most sophisticated companies in the world when it comes to analyzing human behavior are asking for employees to return to work, do you really think they would do this if this meant a productivity decrease. I’m suggesting the harsh reality is that while you may be more productive at home the majority of your colleagues are not and they unfortunately have ruined it for everybody. I don’t think this has anything to do with sunk office space costs, it’s about bottom line productivity.
- AgentOrange1234 2y agoAre you saying: our colleagues have performed poorly while WFH, and because of their poor performance, management is forcing RTO on everyone?
- ipaddr 2y agoThis is a free correction for over hiring force someone to pull the kids out of school and move across the country or lose severance.
- dakiol 2y agoWork is not only about what the company wants but also about what the employee needs. I don't see much difference between the ability to work from home and the ability to avoid working on weekends; the later is an acquired rights in many places, the former can come over time.
- bbqfog 2y agoI would never work in an office again or for a company where the leadership pretends like there's some value to working in-person. My time and space are way too valuable to give them to some company. They can get my work on my own terms.
- indulona 2y agooffice work does not have to suck. main thing is to have small offices, 3-4 people per room. no open spaces. flexible working hours(if there is no trust between the employer and the employee, don't take the job in the first place). very few mandatory meetings. commuting should be no longer than 30 minutes by any means. good lavatory/facilities(you'd be surprised how important this is). small kitchen(home meal prep, or making simple lunch from scratch if needed), good dining and shopping options close by. air conditioning. no direct sunlight or strong neon lights. good furniture so you don't feel like you have travelled back in time into the 90s. good chairs and large computer monitors. and that is about it. it is not that hard to offer good working conditions.
- Apreche 2y agoThere should be a law that says for absolutely every job whatsoever, you are on the clock as soon as you leave your home, and 100% of all commuting expenses must be reimbursed by the employer. If employers expect you to travel to a particular place to work, they should pay for all of it including your time. The only reason this doesn't make perfect sense is because the insanity of commuting on your own dime has been normalized. If such a law were in place almost no company would ask any employee to commute anywhere unless it were absolutely necessary. Return to office is really easy for them to ask for when they aren't the ones who have to pay for it.
- PrismCrystal 2y agoI can see commuting being regarded as a total time waste requiring employer compensation in the US, where most people commuting are driving. But in countries where commuting is done via public transportation, the time spent commuting can be productively used for personal improvement in the form of reading.
- ajb 2y agoOnly in some cases. Often public transport at commuting hours is too crowded to practically do so, or is a bus rather than a train so that many people would get travel sick if they tried to read.
- robsh 2y agoIf employers pay for commute time they can also use home location as a hiring criterion.
- layer8 2y agoThis would just mean that people living farther away would have a harder time finding jobs, or negotiating salary/promotions, because they are more expensive for their employer. Yes you could have laws making it illegal to discriminate based on commute distance, but you know that employers would find other pretexts.
- 2y ago
- thrownotyourzip 2y agoMy job is still remote but pay is now based on zip code for both new hires and for self-driven relocation. If I move and the zip code is not near one of the few office locations in major cities, my pay and/or the pay band for my job title is adjusted. I was hired during COVID with the expectation of a fully remote first policy, for good. Now it's this micromanagement where I need C-level approval to change my address. And there are one-off exceptions all over the place both for hiring and for relocation. It tells me that leadership and the board don't give a shit about me. I am a cog in their machine. Expendable. I am quietly looking for a new job and not stretching myself as much at my current job. Not coasting, but also not answering those slack pings as quickly, or referring people to the help desk process instead of solving their problem then and there. Putting me and my needs first more often. Truly remote first companies should be at an advantage both for hiring and for cost efficiency.
- rachofsunshine 2y agoThey absolutely are at an advantage in hiring - our data set has remote companies with 5-10x the candidate pool of non-remote ones, even ignoring differences in salary asks. The question is: are they at an advantage in effectiveness? I think they probably are, but it seems like a reasonably open question, one that we should see an answer to in the coming years. If in five or ten years remote companies aren't crushing non-remote ones, that's going to be pretty strong evidence that there is good reason for in-office work.
- JSDevOps 2y agoNo one is going back to the office full time.
- steveBK123 2y agoI think a lot does boil down to generational differences in real estate entry prices. Sometimes I think millennials fell into a trap following GenX back to urban living, but missed out on the sweet spot late 90s/early 00s where cities were attractive but also cheap. I worked with guys 10 years older than me who bought apartments at 1/5 the prices my generation saw, but had starting salaries more than 1/2 of what ours were.
- pessimizer 2y ago> Sometimes I think millennials fell into a trap following GenX back to urban living You should be more specific, because the cities were always inhabited. Which millennials are you talking about?
- steveBK123 2y agoFor example in NYC, population peaked in 1950s around 8M, went down to 7M by the 80s. Losing 12% of your population can make housing pretty affordable. Population started increasing in the 90s, re-crossing 8M around 2000... and ~9M today. If one wants to be really pedantic, a lot of that growth was in outer boroughs that were relatively sparse in the early/mid 1900s. Manhattan is still below its peak population of ~2.3M in the early 1900s. Fortunately we don't have overcrowded tenement housing anymore. Manhattan population was about 2M in 1950 and bottomed around 1.4M in 1980s.. so a 30% draw, and is now at about 1.7M.
- binary132 2y agoTotally agree on the RTO forced memes. I recently participated remotely in a mostly-in-person team summit that went great. At the end of the session, Big Boss gave a rousing pep talk about how much this proved the value of in-person collaboration and my heart sank. Was that the whole point of this session, and not the technical solutions we spun? I was literally right there on the projector meeting room, and had obviously weighed in as much as anyone else. I’d been feeling hopeful because $EMPLOYER has been encouraging about the prospects of sustained remote work there, but they also own a lot of business property and I know they are going to follow suit with the others.
- thegrim33 2y agoIs anyone aware of a study between political affiliation and RTO views? I feel like it's become just yet another political/social echo chamber warfare topic and I wouldn't be surprised if there's a huge correlation between political ideology and RTO opinion.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoLiberals dominate the jobs where RTO is even an option. Conservatives are trying to eliminate it from the US government for a reason. It’s entirely political. Conservatives hate the idea that “lazy” limp wristed soy boy ML engineers can make more money than their good old boys making tractors at catapiller.
- christhecaribou 2y agoYup. And in typical conservative fashion, they’d rather denigrate and ruin the lives of the talented liberals than pull up their own bootstraps.
- dakiol 2y agoMany people overlook a key benefit of remote work: the ability to live in cities where good companies don't have offices. E.g, living in Montpellier while working for a company based in Paris (700 km away), living in Düsseldorf while working for a company headquartered in Munich (600 km away), or living in Seville while working for a company in Barcelona (900 km away). I'm not talking about global hiring (something many people don't like because salaries tend to go down), but companies allowing remote work within the same country. This, imo, is the greatest advantage of remote work
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kleiba 2y agoTo the people here talking about switching to fully remote positions (while taking a pay cut) - how and where did you find your new positions?
- assimpleaspossi 2y agoI take issue with these statements as if they apply to most workers: >You’re asking me as an immunocompromised and chronically ill person in pain and dealing with fatigue to show up and do the same stuff I do at home so others can play family at work? >Home office is the only way for many people to have a decent work output because family, household, caretaking, further education, illness and free time activities are better taken care of this way and people can work focused in silence without noise and interruption. How is one taking care of those things mentioned and still "focusing in silence without noise and interruption"?
- lowercased 2y agoTime slicing? Being able to effectively 'work from home' may often mean 'work as productively at 7pm as at 2pm'. Working from an office often (not always) implies synchronous work with others, which often is tied to the 9a-5p 'office day'. Companies that embrace 'work from home' usually can accommodate more asynchronous work from folks as well.
- from-nibly 2y agoIt's not that nuanced guys. zirp ended they did layoffs, and they got bad PR for it. Now they have to do layoffs again but they don't want the bad PR. The people at the top couldn't possibly, with all the time in the world, make an actually informed rational decision about who to cut so an RTO where completely random people quit is just as good as "picking".
- release-object 2y agoI would prefer to WFH 100%. However I’m a team lead. And no matter what I try I can’t train my juniors as quickly remotely. My seniors and I can show them how to work, and solve problems so much faster on-site. We catch bad habits sooner and in-still the teams approach to working via example. Which so far I’ve found hardest to replicate remotely. Yes you can pass skills on remotely. But many people aren’t willing to spent extended periods on a call. And it is time people need more than anything else at the start of their career. Many juniors - understandably - don’t know what skills they are lacking. And those that do don’t know which to focus on first. Only 10/20% have the right personality type to self-source these skills independently. They need our help. Just as we needed the previous generations help. And to provide that we need to really get to know them.
- christhecaribou 2y agoIf you cannot train your juniors up remotely, that’s a management failing. Why punish them for that? In a world with any worker’s rights, you wouldn’t be able to.
- the_snooze 2y ago>If you cannot train your juniors up remotely, that’s a management failing. Why punish them for that? That's an unnecessarily aggressive and uncharitable read of the situation. While it may be possible to train up juniors remotely, many people (myself included) have given it a serious try and have found it far too risky to be worth the effort. An intellectually honest manager will say "it's not for me, I can't do it," and their higher-ups have to make a value judgment about whether it's worth it to force them into a shape that they're not, or accept that the tried-and-true method of socializing juniors in-person is still valid. If you're honestly curious as to why it's so hard, my experience is that it's a socialization task: you have to make the junior folks feel like they're part of the team and have standing to ask questions. That's really hard to do when everyone is just words on a screen, or occasionally floating heads on a video chat. Embodied communication has something that gets lost online.
- brians 2y ago
- 2024user 2y agoRemote working is the future. The forced commuting days are so silly. My open plan office is like a call center with everyone on different meetings. Sometimes 2 or 3 people sitting together are on Teams/Zoom calls because 1 or 2 others aren't in the office.
- neofrommatrix 2y agoOne of my wife’s female bosses was completely lacking in empathy when my wife had our baby. She wanted my wife to come in every single day after her maternity leave even though her company was hybrid. According to her, taking care of a baby and toddler is no big deal. It was so disheartening especially coming from a woman. And then she revealed that she had a nanny flown in from her country and the nanny handled everything kid related. Don’t be this kind of a boss.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CraigJPerry 2y agoI wouldn’t sweat it. The market has a way of working these things out. Want top tier talent but can’t afford it in your area? There’s likely a cheat code available to you now. It’s inevitable that zoning laws will change. When the bag holders for corporate real estate have an exit strategy, I wonder if we won’t magically find the question of RTO features a lot less in the ambiance of life. I don’t know enough to say whether it might be true that the kinds of people to have large investments in media conglomerates are the kinds of people who’d consider large investments in corporate real estate as a sound and obvious diversification strategy (and vice versa).
- hananova 2y agoMy boss has been trying to bully me to RTO for several months now. Unfortunately for him, he promised me verbally that this job was remote forever during the interview, and where I live verbal contracts are just as valid as contracts on paper. Because of their bully tactics I've essentially been paid for doing absolutely nothing at home for 2 months now. They can't fire me for cause, because they did contract with me under the stipulation of WFH, and they can't lay me off without cause because they know perfectly well that I can and will sue them if they do because the reason is obvious even if not explicitly stated. I guess the point of this post is that companies will cut off their nose to spite their face.
- ThalesX 2y agoI'm sure this'll help provide them with a positive view on remote positions.
- christhecaribou 2y agoWho cares what they think? If they operate like this they won’t exist much longer.
- JansjoFromIkea 2y agoOut of curiosity, assuming some companies which embraced hotdesking in the last few years have also since implemented some form of return to office mandate, has it come along with dedicated desks for each person? I don't mind a few days a week in an office, I absolutely hate having no clue where I'm going to be sitting those days.
- mancerayder 2y agoReturn to Office. What this means today is, set your alarm, brave the commute (more than likely into a major city or within its subway systems[1]), go to the office. Enjoy the bright new white new LED lights (the latest trend), a temperature you cannot control (too cold, too hot, better bring the right clothing for it). Noise levels, interruptions. All to jump on a Zoom call at 9am with folks in other remote offices. But middle-managers should come in, for collaboration, we're told, and to mentor junior staff, right? Bad news for you - 50%+ of your work week is in meetings and, you guessed it, on Zoom with headphones, where you'll blabber out loud next to your engineering colleagues, everyone with headphones on. But, we're told, if you don't want a 45 minute commute, you should move closer to the office. Bad news, there: if you want to actually own your home, you're facing a record affordability crisis (in the United States and as far as I can tell, in major European cities like London, Paris, Lisbon, etc. as well). And rents are through the roof, if you want to live near the office. And if your office is a city environment like New York, Paris, etc., and you want to live near it, then you should enjoy living in an apartment with people above, below and on the sides, playing music or doing whatever noise they want at any point. If you're not neurotypical, and find the sounds of other people stressful (apartments and office), then tough bananas, your dreams of working remote from a quiet, comfortable, affordable environment in nature are shot, because the brass decided we "collaborate better" in the office environment. Personally speaking, I actually enjoyed coming into the office during Covid because the office was empty, it was lonely at home, and there was no one on the commute. And then I enjoyed coming in a few times a week when they brought that back, because I do think there's value in it. Now, the company has decided we must all come in, suddenly, in a few weeks. And of course I'm infuriated and ready to move on this company I've been at for years. Is it any wonder that people gamble in options and crypto to try to 'get rich quick' when the working environment can deteriorate so rapidly, when the housing costs can deteriorate so rapidly? I think there's something to the idea that these types of get-rich-quick dreams are the lottery ticket equivalents of the blue collar workers. 1- No we're not all privileged enough distance-wise or weather-wise or safety-wise or fitness-wise to bike everywhere, guys.
- PeterWhittaker 2y agoMy daughter, SIL, and I are 100% remote (three different companies, all located in different places). RTO was an important but not deciding factor in her recent job change, but 100% remote made the new spot all that much more attractive. She's a marketing event manager, he's an accountant manager, and I'm a, well, it depends on the day; let's say senior systems architect and programmer across our HW-and-container-based security products. Of the three, mine needs the most in person time, which we mostly satisfy with ad-hoc whiteboarding sessions, but we've gotten good at doing even that in video calls. When we do get together, it's for team lunches, mini-golf tournaments, etc. It's great. My co has people in TO, NYC, London, with most of us around but not necessarily in Ottawa.
- kkfx 2y agoReasons behind RTO have NOTHING to do about productivity. I've identify two kind of reasons: - giant's needs for slaves. That's is. I know many do dislike such strong term but again that's damn is. Take a look at https://youtu.be/MJBz66H5QIU https://youtu.be/MJBz66H5QIU than see what happen around the world, from Jakarta "will be abandoned" for Nusantara, Cairo for "New Administrative Capital", Iran recent announce they'll count moving the capital in a to-be-built new smart city, failed Saudi's Neom, Arkadag, Innopolis, ... everywhere current ruling class knows well we need to built new settlements and infra because we can't evolve/keep the existing ones for long. Why smart cities? Because they are the best way to enslave people keeping them amused at least formally, while keeping them owning nothing. Let's say you own an apartment, what you really own? A portion of a building, no more, and most in cities do not own but rent. Cloud+mobile, the modern mainframe, what to you own, a thin client/endpoint practically managed by the OEM and nothing else? Current fintech, where instead of giving signed transactions via APIs (like here in EU, OpenBank, de jure since 2017 but not down to the customers) the substantial owner gives next to nothing, some banks nowadays do not even gives pdfs receipts for most operations? What else? In cities people under-utilize large buildings for less than 12h/day, commuting between them like a ritual every day, just to consume collective transport, privately owned by someone, ready made food, fast fashion and fast tech (really, if you WFO you do not buy much dress or wearable devices) for what? In the '80s most factories have flee the city, only offices remains to keep the economy running and we all know there is no needs for offices, the only who need people in cities, so offices too keep them there, are the giants; - ruling class, more and more a kleptocracy, who need to been able to surveil and controls slaves, again, in a city you easy surveil anyone and locking some access networks with very little forces you control many people, especially if they do own nothing, like they do not have cars to move, large food stock, water from natural sources, way to heat in winter and cool in summer autonomously and so on; - needs to keep people moving without thinking about the world and the society, because cities are essentially artificial environments easy to hide the rest of the world with panem et circense model, as long as the dictatorship could withstand them. These are the reasons for RTO at the high level. The the reasons many follow the trend: fear of change and personal ignorance of the modern world. Most CEO do know next to nothing about IT, so most middle man and so on, including many at the bottom of the social pyramid, all of them fear to being alien in a modern society because they do not know it. They know how to confront with a human in an office, they do not know what to do with mails, calls and so on. That's is. However reading hear and there it's clear all these pushes end up in nothing, they might hold for a moment but not more. Especially when we talk about resilience and the war loom, resources might became scarce and so on, because while most do not even think about having a blackout or some food supply issues, sooner or later they'll start thinking and they'll realize in cities there is no possible resilience. There is no room for p.v. and storage on the upper end, there is no nearby wood to source for emergency stove-based heating and cooking, no natural water sources, way too many people to nourish/relocate and no one who actually produce food etc. Skyrocketing prices to impoverish people for the sake of 2030's Agenda, looming service availability/stability issues, climate change, natural infra aging will kill any will to be in cities. And so will kill offices anyway.