12 ms·
The AI reporter that took my old job just got fired
- tomcam 2y agoIncredibly, no videos linked in an article about a video newscast. I think this is an example. The AI doesn't even pronounce "AI" correctly. Interestingly, it looks slightly offscreen just the way real newsreaders do when they're on prompter. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aa7Q2S7VWUk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aa7Q2S7VWUk They do a lot right. There's interaction between the bots. They look kind of professional but not Los Angeles/New York quality, which is what you'd expect from a smallish market. Their movement is also kind of stiff and amateurish, which I believe is intentional.
- dylan604 2y agoNewscast teleprompters are directly in front of the camera lens specifically to not have them looking away from the lens. This has been a solved technology for decades. Perhaps you're thinking of cue cards or the teleprompters speakers use in a speech live audience type of setting?
- tomcam 2y agoWell you got me. I haven't watched broadcast TV for decades. I do see that phenomenon a lot with vloggers at present. Am I also incorrect that they appear not to be looking directly at the camera? Looking back after your comment I still think it feels like they aren't.
- dylan604 2y agoThe AI characters? Nothing about them feels right. The audio looks out of sync with the fake lip flaps. The dude's arm gestures are horrendous. It's AI/cgi, yet the fake background looks like a bad chromakey. You already pointed out some of the audio/voice issues.
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> It's AI/cgi, yet the fake background looks like a bad chromakey. I genuinely wonder if that's intentional. Maybe that looks more "realistic", and gives the audience something to stumble over that's not other AI artefacts?
- dylan604 2y agoThe result to me looked more like a Zoom background replacement rather than a weather chromakey. That's what really looked bad to me. Even the full studio chromakey looks much better where the anchors are at a desk in front of a color vs a full studio.
- beepbooptheory 2y agoLove this so much, not in the way intended. Its just so strange! I can't put my finger on it, but feels like something Tim and Eric, or Tim Robinson, or even Alan Resnick would have a hand in. There is a kind of aesthetic immanence to whole thing, everything is right on the surface. The voices are only just embodied "enough," their unearned confidence, their "affectations." The deadpan delivery on an absurd stage. The colors all feel like a cake that is too sweet. Like approximating a memory of a broadcast. It is hilarious and beautiful. No notes.
- tomcam 2y agoYeah I can see all of it, but the problem with me is that I bet I would have watched it a few seconds and clicked off out of boredom, never suspecting they were AI. I really want to claim I would have figured it out instantly, but I can't. If I were a regular consumer I think I'd notice. They mention right up front they're "powered by AI" but to me that implies they had help with article writing. I would not immediately assume from that statement that the actual newsreaders themselves were AI.
- dsjoerg 2y agoYes! There is something massive and beautiful available in this direction.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rightbyte 2y agoThe guy locks like a deceised used as a marionette and the girl speaks like a tenor. But I guess it will become better. TV will turn so soul less, even when compared to today. Imagine Rakuten Dog Does Funny Stuff channel with this added as some filler. Dystopic.
- chasil 2y ago"James began his tenure as lead anchor, at which point he was unable to blink and his hands were constantly vibrating. He was demoted to second anchor in mid-October, where he began blinking more regularly and his odd hand vibration was replaced by a single emphatic gesture."
- yardstick 2y agoThe first thing I thought of when I saw this is that some mid-tier dictatorships could replace a lot of their newscasters with this approach. Can always guarantee they’ll say what they need to say, and a lack of emotion is a plus maybe? Except with the dear leader passes then you bring out a real person for the emotions.
- jvanderbot 2y agoWell if the article is to be believed, they actually can't guarantee they'll say what they need to say, but I think your larger point holds.
- pawelduda 2y agoAI's not mandatory for that
- onemoresoop 2y agoWhat problem are they trying to solve though?
- Spoom 2y agoPaying human presenters.
- tartoran 2y agoHuman presenters aren't too expensive and are quite flexible, are easily replaced and can make or break a show. Yeah, there's the novelty factor now but am not sure how long it'll take until GenAI on broadcasts will signal second rate, subpar knockoff.
- ruined 2y ago>Human presenters aren't too expensive and are quite flexible, are easily replaced and can make or break a show. well, if you owned 257 local media outlets across an area five thousand miles wide, you might have the experience and the insight to see it differently. you might identify an opportunity for innovative advancements in efficiency
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- onemoresoop 2y agoBut then wonder why people don’t stick around… Unless they have some info channels which ultimately don’t need any presenters in the first place.
- jazzyjackson 2y agoMaybe we can increase the efficiency by having bots watch the automatic news, too, that way they can vote so we don't have to. With enough innovation we may live to see the first automated senator!
- joe_the_user 2y agoI could only find this video. James' arms go up and down in an alarming manner. Rose has more natural movements but the voice you hear when her mouth moves is worse than the worst foreign film voice-over. Somehow the person and the voice mismatched in "tone" in a way that's hard to describe. https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1040710730435452 https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1040710730435452
- namaria 2y agoUncanny, I'd say
- syncsynchalt 2y agoI was surprised at how game the AI was to pronounce the Hawaiian place names, it was confident enough that I assumed the pronunciation was correct. The article notes that it is butchering the placenames though. To me this illustrates a common cognitive mismatch when evaluating AI, it can be confident in a way that most humans can't, and that misleading social cue is another reason we trust its output.
- lmm 2y agoI've seen plenty of human newsreaders be confidently incorrect about place names. And some pronunciations aren't necessarily "wrong" so much as contested.
- 1024core 2y agoJames' lips don't seem to move at all. The problem with such "videocasts" (as opposed to "podcasts") is that there is another channel that the AI has to control: the video. Generating convincing video is much harder than generating convincing audio.
- chrononaut 2y agoThe way the mouths move are so far off from the words they're speaking that my first impressions would be they're just playing a video loop of these people talking about other random things and dubbing over it.
- janalsncm 2y agoThey could’ve definitely fixed the audio by making it sound like the avatars were wearing mics. Honestly the whole thing is so off-putting and lazy.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago"James" arm motion in a loop.
- mock-possum 2y agoOoh wow I hate this. Totally soulless appearance and delivery - and the robot fidgeting the dude is doing with his hands completely distracts from everything else. It’s totally normal to do that movement while speaking for emphasis - but whatever he’s doing does not look normal. (The mouths look nightmarish as well)
- itronitron 2y ago>> The AI doesn't even pronounce "AI" correctly. You can call me Al.
- esafak 2y agoThe Al robotics test: can you do that thing with your knees like Chevy Chase?!
- vbarrielle 2y agoLooks like they're using something like motion matching to recover fragments of the presenter's motion that match the pronounced phonemes. The actors were probably instructed to avoid almost all movement to make sure it was blendable. That would explain why the guy's hand have such erratic and non-natural movement.
- pbronez 2y agoThanks for the primary source. Concur the quality is poor. Google’s NotebookLM podcast summary is way more natural sounding. The video was even worse than the audio. The lip sync was off. The girl looked like someone else’s mouth was mapped onto her face.
- cowsandmilk 2y agoThe male host’s hands are literally on a loop, it is disturbing. And the female host had several nonsensical sentence fragments. The script isn’t even up to par with what you would see in a college news show.
- shepherdjerred 2y agoNot great, but it's surprisingly good if you can make this with just a text prompt.
- glandium 2y agoWatching this, I'm left wondering why my brain doesn't want to blend the visual and the audio. I don't think it's the bad lip sync. I have this weird feeling that these persons, were they real, wouldn't have these voices. But I can't quite put my finger as to why. I haven't watched movies dubs in a while, but maybe that's the same kind of phenomenon that makes dubs sound bad. Or maybe we grow an intuitive sense of what a person's voice might sound like based on the appearance of their face's bone structure and muscles?
- bpm140 2y agoNGL, the pronunciation of Waikiki as “Why, Kiki?” made me laugh out loud.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fny 2y agoGive it time y'all. This is the first inning, and I'm already terrified. I encourage you to have a conversation with ChatGPT's advanced audio for a taste of what's to come. If you can, have someone talk to it in a relatively unpopular language like Afrikaans or even Icelandic--they will shit their pants.
- alternatex 2y agoI'd be terrified if anyone considers this reporting watchable. I felt depressed after 30 seconds. It's like an episode of Black Mirror.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Xenoamorphous 2y ago> This is the first inning I think this is the key part.
- namaria 2y agoHow is a very off putting start a good thing?
- Xenoamorphous 2y agoThe videos in question would’ve been considered science fiction a mere 5 years ago, so I definitely don’t consider them a very off putting start. That doesn’t mean that I think they’re perfect or that the technology will keep improving at a fast pace (nobody knows for sure).
- namaria 2y agoYeah it's very hard to do and once it's done it's very off putting. And this is not about first results, this has been on the works for years and after hundreds of billions of dollars of investment it is very off putting. We're not at the concept phase, we're at the top of the logistic curve and the whole shtick is arguing that we're at the bottom.
- vunderba 2y agoSlightly tangential, but this is the reason I'm baffled why people think that AI-driven podcasts would ever be worth listening to. If you can find an LLM+TTS generated podcast with even a FRACTION of the infectious energy as something like Good Job Brain, Radio Lab, or Ask Me Another, then I'll eat my hat. I don't even own one. I'll drive to the nearest hat store, purchase the tallest stovetop hat that I can afford and eat it.
- thomasahle 2y agoI've yet to hear an LLM-generated podcast about an article that wouldn't have been better if the AI had simply read the article aloud.
- tokioyoyo 2y agoI totally agree, but I also think it's just not geared towards us because of our age and preexisting beliefs of "what podcasts/news/videos are supposed to be". Think of kids around age <12. If they'll keep consuming AI-driven media, they'll take that as normal and won't blink twice if that becomes the de-facto standard in about 10 years. It's the same as short-video format for me. Sure, I can watch some TikToks from time to time, but making them, or continuously getting my news from them? Yeah, that's not gonna fly for me. However, for my niblings (age 8-17) that's basically where they're getting all the "current affairs" from. Microtransaction is probably one of the easiest example as well. 15 years ago, anyone who bought games would laugh at you if you said every game that you paid $80 for would also have endless amount of small items that you can buy for real money. Right now? Well, kids that grew up with Fortnite and Roblox just think that's the norm.
- mjr00 2y agoThe younger generation loves short-form, to-the-point stuff. Which is the exact opposite of what the current crop of GenAI makes. In a tiktok video, every sentence, every word counts because there's a time limit. If people don't engage with your content in the first 3 seconds, it's worthless. The video linked in another post starts off with 15 seconds of complete fluff. You'd have better engagement if you have a guy opening with BIIIG NEWS!! LABOR DAY BREAKFAST GOES HAYWIRE!!! and hook people. GenAI is great at generating "stuff", but what makes good content isn't the quantity. What makes good content is when there's nothing left to take away.
- ricksunny 2y ago"Those responsible for sacking the people who have just been sacked, have been sacked."
- schlauerfox 2y agoA way to lay off with justification, then hire back cheaper talent? If i'm being cynical.
- sailfast 2y agoClickbait title for a decent write-up. The author left Hawaii, and as indicated in the article the local press resorted to AI presenters because it was hard to keep talent on board. This is not a "job replacement" story so much as a "backup plan" story in my opinion.
- jandrese 2y ago> local press resorted to AI presenters because it was hard to keep talent on board I see a phrase like that and my first thought is "the pay is crap" and/or "the bosses are awful" and nobody in their right mind would work there.
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- mmooss 2y agoThe disruptive technology adoption process is at least somewhat predictable, including: * Most people react negatively to the disruption because of the risk, fear of the unknown, and also because people don't like change. * Also, early in the development and adoption of a new, immature technology, there is a lot of trial and error regarding applications, mostly error. Sometimes those failures are because the application isn't a good match for the technology; often they are because the technology isn't mature and will still improve and add major features, or because the details of the interface between technology and application are still being worked out. * The people reacting negatively will point out those errors as signs that the technology is hopeless. Often they are wrong: the tech will mature and improve, and those people will be eclipsed. The good news is, they won't remember it that way: First they laugh at you, then they tell you it isn't in the Bible (i.e., it violates the orthodoxy, the way things always have been done), then they say they knew it all along. AI is in stage 2.
- tartoran 2y agoAt least this is funny in the way it looks robotic and dorky. When it gets better it will become increasingly scary to go on this road. Why would anyone want to watch anything gen AI other than a one off curiosity?
- CaptainFever 2y ago> Why would anyone want to watch anything gen AI other than a one off curiosity? Case in point. We've heard this statement so many times. Just substitute "gen AI" for "the Internet", "video games", "radio", etc... https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/1c75mic/internet_just_a_passing_fad/ https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/1c75mic/...
- mmooss 2y agoI take it back then: AI turns out to be in the First they laugh at you stage.
- syncsynchalt 2y agoI _had_ to hear the pumpkin clip in context (at 2m50s): https://www.facebook.com/TheGardenIsland/videos/1120021172878886/ https://www.facebook.com/TheGardenIsland/videos/112002117287... Any ten seconds of that clip will do though, really.
- andix 2y agoThanks, this is really important context, I expected a link to an example video as the first comment. And yes, it's really bad. No idea how someone could think this could replace a human.
- datahack 2y agoWhile I enjoyed the article, it’s just another in a line of the same article with different flavors and authors that all have the same fundamental error. The prevailing counterargument against AI consistently hinges on the present state of AI rather than the trajectory of its development: but what matters is not the capabilities of AI as they exist today, but the astonishing velocity at which those capabilities are evolving.
- lawn 2y agoIt's getting old but there's an xkcd for your kind of reasoning: https://xkcd.com/605/ https://xkcd.com/605/
- nsavage 2y agoIsn't this essentially the same argument as "there are only 10 covid cases in this area, nothing to worry about"? It's really missing the point, the point is whether or not exponential growth is happening or not. It doesn't with husbands, it does with covid, time will tell about AI.
- SiempreViernes 2y agoNo, because as you rightly point out we know exponential growth is very possible with Covid but we don't know if that will happen with AI. In fact, the only evidence we have for exponential growth in AI is the word of the people selling it to us.
- namaria 2y agoTransformers have been around for 7 years, ChatGPT for 2. This isn't the first few samples of what could be exponential growth. These are several quarters of overpromise and underdelivery. The chatbot is cool and it outperforms what awful product search has become. But is it enough to support a 3.5 trillion dollar sized parts supplier?
- lawn 2y agoThe graph depicts linear growth, not exponential. And neither is the growth of AI.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoUnfortunately, I see this as only a small temporary setback in the unstoppable quest to replace humans with AI to cut corporate costs. The aspect of AI that isn't discussed enough is not what are those formerly employed going to do next, but rather that it will potentially represent the largest transfer of wealth in history as money which was going into employees' salaries is instead going to shareholders via those large companies who have the ability to produce the AIs (even if there are a host of small companies who act as an intermediate layer, such as the Israeli firm in this case). I do think there is going to be a backlash because of our need for and desire for human connections, which AI won't provide. But that will become more expensive, and not the norm. Just like we can still buy farmer-fresh food but only a minority segment of the population can afford it because it costs 3x what is pushed as "food" at Walmart.
- Workaccount2 2y agoThe article might give the impression of some kind of LLM SOTA model being slotted in, but visiting the website of the company they used, Caledo, it looks like they are using 2014 level technology. Poorly animated CGI newscaster reading an "AI" written script. Really their tech looks awful and dated.
- cryptozeus 2y agoIs it just me or does everyone feel this way ? Its an instant put off for me when i hear that article was generated by AI. I would lose trust of that publication and move on. People think AI is the magic answer for shitty content. In some cases AI is only adding speed not quality.
- INTPenis 2y agoThis is an extreme example, also this person would never lose their job that easy if there were laws protecting workers. But what I have seen here in Sweden is AI voiceover used in news reports where people have hidden identities. So clearly this has taken a job from someone who used to do this voiceover. But it's working, we have to adapt to these small changes that AI is bringing.
- jprete 2y agoI think it's really the AI content that people care about. Devices to disguise a voice have been around for a long time, so I don't think it was a particularly widespread job in the first place. (And maybe technological changes in that space have always been about style and perception instead of effectiveness? I mean you can always get a paid actor to pretend to be the disguised interviewee and use a radio to relay the answers the show wants.)
- hansonkd 2y agothe CocaCola commercial that everyone "hated" that "destroyed the brand equity" according to numerous news outlets solidified to me that we are passing a mark and this is the last desperate gasp of multiple industries coping with the rapid advancements AI is bringing. Sure the Coke ad was a bit cringe. But the reality is in 5 years most ads you see will be AI and nobody will care. That along with the Ben Affleck Rant that AI won't replace Hollywood. Watching Ben Affleck talking about how you can't replace the chemistry of actors working on set made me imagine what the conversations of famous stage actors were when film came along. You can argue film didn't replace the stage, after all broadway is still there, but it is not comparable to the economic influence of TV and Film. In 10-20 years, human made Film, TV will still exist. But it will most likely be a small amount of the economic activity that AI produced media will be. It doesn't matter if you care how terrible or how cringe AI is. Or that AI quality is worse than what existed before. What matters is in 5-20 years with a new generation what 90% of them care and if AI has more utility that not using AI. In the authors case in the short term for that particular medium, AI was not more useful. But in the long term AI will dominate every facet of our media.
- hnthrowaway6543 2y ago[flagged]
- hansonkd 2y agoThis isn't an economically driven platform that is directly revenue driven like ads, movies, news articles, podcasts, etc for one. go to reddit or even linkedin which is revenue driven and it is a sea of bots parroting the same tired points with comments that are 1 or 2 words different from other comments directly above them. My entire point is that human production is not going to zero, but is moving to a minority. I still go to the theatre and listen to live orchestras but I would be a fool to say that other mass media types didn't replace the cultural role of entertainment that those forms once had.
- hnthrowaway6543 2y agoYeah but why are you consuming human-generated garbage comments on HN instead of just getting infinite comments from ChatGPT? Pontificate on this, then return.
- anoncow 2y agoI felt conflicted as I listened to the AI generated audio.
- yoyopete 2y ago[dead]
- lazystar 2y agohmm no one has discussed this "carpenter group", who appear to be on a spree in 2024 of snatching up smaller news orgs, and cutting 50% of the staff. seems like a pretty big gamble on AI. > Carpenter Media Group announced earlier this month it had acquired another group of newspapers, Pamplin Media Group, in Oregon. The company now owns and manages 180 newspapers in the United States and Canada. > “We are committed to Everett, The Herald and all who have a stake in its success,” Chairman Todd Carpenter said. “We have deep sympathy for those affected by these changes and will work hard with each of them to see they are well-compensated through a transition period that helps them move forward in a positive way. “Our responsibility to the community and our readers requires us to make difficult business decisions, and then invest in and organize our team to move forward to produce a product that continues to improve and serve. Our track record in this process is good." https://www.heraldnet.com/news/this-breaks-my-heart-roughly-half-of-everett-herald-news-staff-laid-off/ https://www.heraldnet.com/news/this-breaks-my-heart-roughly-... would be very interested to see todd carpenter's data on that last point. edit - the carpenter media group does not have a wikipedia entry, but the companies it owns do. interesting https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pamplin_Media_Group https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pamplin_Media_Group
- imglorp 2y agoIf you're wondering just how much to cringe, here's a sample. https://youtu.be/48Y-pCffh10 https://youtu.be/48Y-pCffh10
- Unknoob 2y agoOpened the article and decided to try out the "Listen to this story" section. After reading the article name and author, it proceeds to state "This is an AI generated narration". Well, well, well.
- moffkalast 2y agoHow the turntables...
- _whiteCaps_ 2y agoI doubt that author Guthrie Scrimgeour is the one deciding to add AI narration to the Wired articles.
- throw_a_grenade 2y agohttps://archive.is/20241121120946/https://www.wired.com/story/the-ai-reporter-who-took-my-old-job-just-got-fired/ https://archive.is/20241121120946/https://www.wired.com/stor...
- grahamj 2y ago"The AI Reporter That Took My Old Job" ... "James and Rose did not actively supplant any existing newsroom jobs"
- voytec 2y agoWe seem to have a weird drive towards testing one sci-fi dystopia after another as a potential way to go. This is Max Headroom.
- Havoc 2y agoPity that I can’t read the article thanks to all the popups and signups and adverts and cookie banners. Tempting to build an A.I. scraper and filter this stuff out. And then it becomes even less economically viable
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 2y agoThis has the feeling of smugly declaring victory too early. The objection to AI in journalism has to be something other than that the technology is janky. Because it will improve. The people selling this AI product to news stations are counting on that. Assume that it will one day do a human presenter's job as well as they do, at a fraction of the cost. The argument against this use of AI technology needs to be able to survive after that happens, so the argument has to be based on something that won't change any time soon, like ethics, or morality, or even epistemology. Something like that. I'm telling you, don't just rely on AI being this bad forever, or you'll lose the argument in the long run. It doesn't help that the value of the news has been so thoroughly diminished by the news industry itself already. The trend lines of AI performance going up, and trust in journalism going down, are going to cross sooner than you think, and that's the point at which James and Rose will be back to stay.
- cwbriscoe 2y agoThe voices just don't match the people. Uncanny valley.
- up2isomorphism 2y agoVery few people will listen to any thing for an extended period of time if they can tell it is generated by a robot. And as of today they can.
- mediumsmart 2y agoCollateral on the highway to hell in a hand basket
- Natfan 2y agohttps://12ft.io/proxy?q=https://www.wired.com/story/the-ai-reporter-who-took-my-old-job-just-got-fired https://12ft.io/proxy?q=https://www.wired.com/story/the-ai-r...
- aeuropean12 2y agoWho on Earth wants to listen to AI podcasts or read articles generated by AI bots? I'm a human and want information about the world from a human. Seriously.
- gnabgib 2y agoSmall discussion (10 points, 23 hours ago, 5 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42203016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42203016