18 ms·
Undergraduates with family income below $200k will be tuition-free at MIT
- alsetmusic 2y agoAwesome. Now let’s lower the bar further and do it everywhere. And then let’s keep doing more until students can pay their tuition with a summer job, like they could when our elders went to school. I’ll hold off on asking for higher education to be free, as the culture still pushes back on that. But a return to the former model would be most welcome.
- onename 2y agoWhy not be more ambitious and aim for free?
- emptiestplace 2y agoIt is difficult to enact meaningful change in a country that doesn't see supporting its people as an investment in itself. Discussing the price when it should be free is a distraction.
- rty32 2y agoIt's never going to happen in a country where politicians try to convince people that college education == elitism, and a significant part of the population actually believes that
- mixmastamyk 2y agoWon’t happen as long as the govt is giving out free loans, which is the driver of increasing tuition prices.
- contingencies 2y agoClearly nothing to do with inefficient administration, then. Here in Australia, where a friend's wife works as the PA for the Dean in one of our foremost universities, and I know numerous lecturers, some of whom are moving overseas for better opportunities (in Southeast Asia of all places!), the faculty-members-over-beer perspective is largely that the universities are head-in-sand about AI and about to become far less relevant. IMHO MIT OCW is great, we need more of that, and more mini-courses.
- stewarts 2y agoI was going to comment that free loans and inefficient/outsized admin go hand-in-hand. On further thinking if you take away the loans, the admin has no choice but to shrink and achieve higher efficiencies.
- tzs 2y agoI tried to check if that was true, but couldn't find much historical tuition data online. What little I did find showed that tuition adjusted for inflation has been increasing fairly steadily for over 100 years, and I didn't really see any change in the rates between before government loans and after. Maybe if I had found data for a wide range of schools instead of just a couple of hard to get into schools there would have been a more noticeable effect.
- readthenotes1 2y agoAs far as I know, and countries where tuition is free entrance is restricted and the students do not expect to live the United States university lifestyle. Free would be fine if we could expect actual return on the investment instead of extended high school, delaying adulthood, and channeling people from useful vocations within their grasp.
- tmpz22 2y agoI'd like to see a future where a student can have free tuition but (with exception) is required do meaningful civic service work that benefits the community and country that is paying for tuition, ultimately graduating with zero debt if requirements are met. Maintaining national parks? Helping support inner city? Tutoring and improving public education? Imagine having the majority of American college students contributing to these worthy causes AND getting a strong education.
- Izikiel43 2y agoDoesn't the federal government already do this? Work for them 10 years and student debt is cancelled?
- sethammons 2y agoI think they are suggesting that you would graduate debt free for having done service while getting your education
- Izikiel43 2y agoBut how would you have time to study full time and work full time?
- sethammons 2y agoPeople do that all the time. Besides, who said full time for either
- csh0 2y agoThis is basically the point of PSLF[0]. The cost to participants is not $0, but it can ultimately be very low if they only make income adjusted payments during their 10 years of service. https://studentaid.gov/manage-loans/forgiveness-cancellation/public-service https://studentaid.gov/manage-loans/forgiveness-cancellation...
- kasey_junk 2y agoDo we also return the facilities to the state they were in before, particularly the residential programs? College enrollment percentage? What about a near universal military draft for men? Not that I think lowering the cost of education is a bad effort but appeals to some prior culture like they are apples to apples comparison is dishonest.
- tedunangst 2y agoAnd the classrooms should be an easy stroll from the dorms, downhill, both ways.
- bigstrat2003 2y ago> Do we also return the facilities to the state they were in before, particularly the residential programs? Yes, please. Students learned just fine without all the fancy facilities. Perks are great and all, but I would trade them for a low cost of education in a second.
- kasey_junk 2y agoThe university’s would argue that the students voted with their feet, and that those facilities are an arms race that if you lose you lose students. I do t know that they are disinterested parties in this that can be trusted uncritically but there is a community college near me that has nicer gym facilities for their students than my big 10 Alma matter had for its “student” athletes when I was in school. Something drives that.
- itronitron 2y ago>> pay their tuition with a summer job, like they could when our elders went to school. or like it is currently for EU citizens in any EU country. Americans are getting ripped off from all sides.
- Nifty3929 2y agoIn the former model, which I also would love to back to, college was cheap because the government didn't keep inflating the price with huge loans, coupled with every adult in range telling kids that the HAVE to go to college and the more prestigious the better. Get rid of government loans, bring us back to how universities used to operate, and education will once again be something you can pay for with a summer job. All we're doing with these government loans is transferring the wealth of society to the universities.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kevinventullo 2y agoThe article claims 80% of American households meet this threshold. I wonder what % of their incoming class (say restricted to Americans) meets this threshold.
- chews 2y agoThat's a great question, I'd bet it's fair to say that 80% of their applicants would not qualify, and yet it opens the door for some really deserving humans. (Not being able to afford it is why I didn't go to MIT, I also wasn't accepted at Cal, yet UCLA (and all of the UC system for that matter) was under 4,000 a year and that's what my folks and I could afford so that's where I studied.)
- dleink 2y agoPrinceton has had a similar rule since 2001. Their current number is $100k. 25% of students pay nothing to attend. [0] [0] https://www.princeton.edu/news/2024/03/29/princeton-trustees-set-2024-25-budget-increasing-spending-undergraduate-financial https://www.princeton.edu/news/2024/03/29/princeton-trustees... (go tigers)
- WorkerBee28474 2y agoApproximately 60% of American households earn less than $100K. That's quite a difference in relative size.
- jknoepfler 2y agoHouseholds with earners in their 20's and early 30's don't tend to have a lot of children of university age. One would want to use the median income of households with university-aged children. (Median income by age rises sharply from 20->40, then flatlines... the median age of a mother is around 27?)
- DebtDeflation 2y agoI'd also think you'd want to adjust by geography based on COL. A two earner family earning $200K in SF or NYC is different than one earning that in suburban Arkansas.
- bko 2y agoMIT is a great financial investment. There is financing already available (federal and private) so presumably if someone wanted to go they likely could. They may leave with debt however. The median salary of an MIT graduate is 120k and the median debt is 12k, and less for lower income families (2023-2024): $0 - $30,000 family income: $6,866 $30,001 - $75,000 family income: $9,132 $75,000+ family income: $12,500 Bumping this up to families making $200k seems really unnecessary and helps people that don't really need to help. https://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-attendance/making-mit-affordable/ https://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-atten...
- rahimnathwani 2y agoMIT is a great financial investment. How do we know that is true? Among folks whom MIT would accept, do we know whether those who choose to attend MIT get a greater return on their investment (of time and money) compared to those who choose to not apply or not attend? families making $200k seems really unnecessary and helps people that don't really need to help There are certainly families earning $200k who need help. $200k income for a family of 5 in San Francisco is different from $200k income for a family of 3 in rural Idaho.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- FuriouslyAdrift 2y agoWhen I looked at MIT in 1990, tuition was fully covered but housing was BRUTAL. More than twice my parents mortgage. I'm sure it's worse, now.
- mmcwilliams 2y agoIt definitely is and is made worse by institutions like MIT and Harvard that don't pay their full tax burden to the city due to the PILOT program. They're allowed to accrue more and more real estate while paying a fraction of the taxes that other property holders would and drive prices up dramatically.
- 2y ago
- araes 2y agoStarted looking and found out there's some much worse, and far more obvious cases that need to implement these reforms. [1] UPenn is THE most obvious. Sitting on a $20,000,000,000 endowment fund that went up +170% over 10 years while Philadelphia rots with drug use, poverty, and gun violence. BTW, amazing site to be horrified by gun violence (and vaguely fascinated). Look upon the awfulness of Philadelphia. [2] Sitting in their safe little haven while East and South is wounding murder land with overlapping murder / wounding statistics. (12k from 2014-2023, 190/100000 urban) [3] Northwestern and the violence everywhere South in Chi-town is maybe a personal second choice. ($13,700,000,000, +74%, 26.9k, 280/100000 urban) [4][5] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_colleges_and_universities_in_the_United_States_by_endowment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_colleges_and_universit... [2] (Guns, Philadelphia) https://www.thetrace.org/2023/02/gun-violence-map-america-shootings/?place=Philadelphia-Pennsylvania https://www.thetrace.org/2023/02/gun-violence-map-america-sh... [3] (Location, UPenn) https://www.google.com/maps/place/University+of+Pennsylvania/@39.9352876,-75.1739704,14067m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m6!3m5!1s0x89c6c65a7f3bccc1:0x9eaa6a2b2d6fe94!8m2!3d39.9515013!4d-75.1910161!16zL20vMDd0ZHM?hl=en&entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI0MTExNy4wIKXMDSoJLDEwMjExMjMzSAFQAw%3D%3D https://www.google.com/maps/place/University+of+Pennsylvania... [4] (Guns, Chicago) https://www.thetrace.org/2023/02/gun-violence-map-america-shootings/?place=Chicago-Illinois https://www.thetrace.org/2023/02/gun-violence-map-america-sh... [5] (Location, Northwestern) https://www.google.com/maps/place/Northwestern+University/@41.9057033,-87.7756436,62770m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m6!3m5!1s0x880fd00b703e4c39:0x2c37b567fad56106!8m2!3d42.0564594!4d-87.675267!16zL20vMDE3ajY5?entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI0MTExNy4wIKXMDSoJLDEwMjExMjMzSAFQAw%3D%3D https://www.google.com/maps/place/Northwestern+University/@4...
- Slava_Propanei 2y ago[dead]
- nadermx 2y agoThetrace.org is in fact pretty sweet looking. Interesting that philly seems to be shot to injur and next door camden seems to be shoot to kill.
- njtransit 2y agoWhat is the argument here, exactly?
- knowitnone 2y agoYeah, education should be free. Record all lectures and put them out there. Charge a small fee to view them if you must but lecturers repeating themselves is not my idea of a great use of their time. Yes, I know lots of lectures are already published.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoWatching non-interactive lectures is a small part of the overall experience. I'm not commenting on whether the experience is 'worth it', but assuming the only thing people get is the ability to watch lectures doesn't make the point.
- jacobgkau 2y agoOn the other hand, many people act like "talking to professors over beer" (or to your classmates, for that matter) is supposed to add "value" to the college experience, when it's perfectly possible to get at least a bachelor's and a master's without ever doing that (source: I did).
- rahimnathwani 2y agoTwo people with the same GPA and same piece of paper from the same college, may have gotten different amounts of lasting value from their college experience.
- mullingitover 2y agoA big part of it is having a long-term peer group of people who were disciplined and motivated enough to get into MIT and succeed there. Arguably true for any university. We're products of our environments, and if you surround yourselves with hardworking people it rubs off on you.
- p-a_58213 2y agoIt really depends on the subject matter and the institution's focus (and tier). For disciplines where foundational knowledge remains relatively unchanged (say, Latin) recorded lectures could be an efficient way to disseminate information without requiring professors to repeat the same material. A "flipped classroom" would offer opportunities for more dynamic interaction and deeper understanding, and of course this would cost money. However, as a professor myself in a rapidly evolving STEM field adjacent to AI, I update at least 20% of my course materials each year to keep pace with new developments. As it happens, about a third of the new content is derived from my research group's latest work. Recording lectures isn't a one-time effort; it would require constant updates to remain relevant (and let me tell you, if you want to get the voice-over right, it is a lot more time-consuming and soul-crushing than simply turning up in class and giving a live lecture). The value of live lectures goes beyond just "transmitting" content. They offer real-time interaction, immediate feedback, and dynamic discussions that adapt to the students' understanding. This level of interaction devilishly difficult to replicate in recorded formats. I would ramble on more, but I need to return to the lecture materials I am developing for this Friday on Vision-Language Models :P
- TheJoeMan 2y agoThis is a great step in the right direction. I can't speak directly for MIT, but there are issues with how these programs don't apply to parents with small family businesses. My parents had a small business, with my father taking home a salary of $XX,XXX. Duke University used the business assets to determine the EFC (expected family contribution) of literally 90% of the salary. Essentially saying to sell off the family business for the college fund, which was a non-starter. Small businesses are allegedly the backbone of America, and I feel these tuition support programs overlook this segment of the middle-class.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoIt’s incredibly difficult to structure these rules in a way that doesn’t discriminate against small businesses while not opening a giant loophole for the rich.
- changoplatanero 2y agoWhy is the price you have to pay for something dependent on how much money your parents make? Feels so unfair
- mh- 2y agoIn my opinion, you're reasoning about it incorrectly. What if I said: the price is the same for everyone, but people with less access to money get proportionally more assistance paying that price?
- changoplatanero 2y agostill seems weird to me. is there any other product for 18-22 year olds where the price changes depending on their parents wealth?
- mh- 2y agoInteresting question. I can't think of anything outside of the education sphere, no. Maybe someone else will chime in with an example.
- d2049 2y agoWhen I was touring colleges as a high school senior I met someone who had gotten into MIT but whose family could only afford to send one kid to an elite college, him or his sister. He decided to go to a state school which was a lot less expensive but whose academics weren't close to the same level. This stuff matters to people.
- blackguardx 2y agoMost students go into debt to attend college. I fell into a bracket where I didn’t get any financial assistance but my parents didn’t want to/couldn’t pay for tuition. I got personal loans for everything. I think this is a common scenario.
- accrual 2y agoSame here. I paid "full price" for my degree coming from a normal middle class family. Fortunately I was able to pay it all off a few years out of school with my first job.
- bmitc 2y agoThe large majority of MIT undergraduates graduate debt free.
- grecy 2y ago* in the US. In many developed countries higher education costs the same as high school.
- akavi 2y agoWhen was this? MIT's financial aid was already very generous when I was applying (in 2008); IIRC the no-tuition threshold was 100 k$ back then
- d2049 2y agoThis was more than several years prior to that, I just tried to look up the financial aid of previous years and for some reason couldn't find it. If someone else finds it, I'd be curious to take a look.
- meetingthrower 2y agoYes but the algorithm also is that they take 5% of your assets each year. So if you've saved $1M (not much for a $200K a year couple in their 50s), that's $50K a year out the door.
- daveed 2y agoWhere are you seeing this?
- brewdad 2y agoFAFSA. That's one of the calculations that goes into Expected Family Contribution. There is an expectation that parent's contribute some % of income (20%?), 5% of assets, and that the student basically contributes 90% of any income or assets to their name before a single dollar of aid, usually federal loans, will be offered. For all of you younger folks just starting your families, expect to pay full price for college if you are anywhere near the top 25% of earners (most of this site presumably). Any scholarship money is a bonus but aid probably isn't going to be forthcoming. The subtext of this MIT announcement is that any family making more than $200,000 will be paying full price to subsidize the poorer students.
- robnado 2y agoHonestly, that wouldn’t be a bad way to fund education: education is free, but the university gets taxation power over you so they can tax you at x% of your income. It aligns incentives better than the current system.
- Engineering-MD 2y agoIn which case you may like how it’s done in the UK. it’s technically debt but in essence works as a graduate tax. The government pays for your education with a loan. You then only pay back 9% of your income over a certain income threshold. You do this until you pay back the loan or 30-40 years have passed. So in practice this is a graduate tax.
- 2y ago
- bell-cot 2y agoThis part seems to be getting overlooked - > And for the 50 percent of American families with income below $100,000, parents can expect to pay nothing at all toward the full cost of their students’ MIT education, which includes tuition as well as housing, dining, fees, and an allowance for books and personal expenses. > This $100,000 threshold is up from $75,000 this year, while next year’s $200,000 threshold for tuition-free attendance will increase from its current level of $140,000. - even though that's the article's 2nd and 3rd paragraph.
- pledess 2y agoThis may have unintended consequences on chances of a successful application. Now, as a high school senior, you have to compete against an additional pool of strong students who aren't especially interested in MIT's offerings, but have parents pushing them toward the least expensive of all top universities.
- janalsncm 2y agoIt’s not an unintended consequence. Another way of phrasing your concern is “MIT will have an especially strong applicant pool” which is a desirable outcome.
- crowcroft 2y ago100% agree, isn't this the meritocracy we want? The other side of this is saying the status quo is; as a high school senior with wealthy parents, you don't have to compete against as many strong students if you apply for MIT because it has high barriers to entry (that aren't based on merit), and so you should apply even if you aren't particularly interested in their offering. Also, the reality is most kids will be applying for all of the schools. MIT might want to improve their yield rate.
- janalsncm 2y agoYep. I just got done reading The Meritocracy Trap and the gist of it is that wealthy kids already have tons of educational resources thrown at them to get into good high schools, colleges, and careers. So they don’t also need financial advantages and legacy admissions. This doesn’t solve all of those problems but it’s a start.
- Yabood 2y agoUVA does this for households that make less $100K. Hopefully, they’ll follow suit and bump it to $200K as well.
- Yhippa 2y agoWith their endowment it's criminal that they don't
- 999900000999 2y ago>Newly expanded financial aid will cover tuition costs for admitted students from 80 percent of U.S. families. What percentage of MIT students... Two teachers in a HCOL city are going to be above 200k.
- petesergeant 2y agohttps://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-attendance/making-mit-affordable/ https://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-atten... > 58% of full-time undergraduates received [some form of] MIT Scholarship [but not necessarily a full one] during the 2023–2024 academic year.
- xqcgrek2 2y agoSorry, but this is peanuts for MIT and merely a performative stunt. Time to tax these endowments.
- jedberg 2y agoOr, crazy idea, have the government pay all tuition up front for everyone and then collect an extra .5% on your income tax for every semester you attend (or .33% for every quarter). Obviously you'd have to put some limits on what colleges can charge to get paid from that pool of money. Then you can't go broke from debt because it's a percent of your income, but it's also not "free" to address those who have concerns with that. You could apply it to all outstanding school loan balances too. Get your loans paid off in exchange for an extra 4% income tax.
- enjaydee 2y agoSounds similar to how it works here in Australia
- spacebanana7 2y agoI actually quite like the system we have in the UK. Graduates pay roughly 9% of their income above £27k towards debt repayment, and the remaining balance is written off after 30 years. Typical tuition fees are just over £9k per year. This strikes a nice balance between encouraging people to carefully consider alternative non-university careers whilst also not preventing too many people from not being able to afford it. Note my numbers are approximate because they can vary depending on when & where a person went to university a couple of other factors. Also I do think the system could be slightly improved (especially around maintenance loans) but on the whole has a good structure.
- zipy124 2y agoIt would be a good system if the interest rate on the loan wasn't absolutely insane.
- walthamstow 2y agoIt was funny when they capped the rate at 7% recently. The calculated rate of RPI + 3% reached 14% and it became just a bit too obvious that it's a scam. Luckily I went in 2009 when tuition was 3.5k.
- 2y ago
- kqr2 2y agoWhat about wealthy people with low AGI but lots of assets?
- testfoobar 2y agoCheck out CSS or FAFSA calculators to figure out your expected family contribution. Financial Aid offices at places like MIT that are need blind fill in the gap between your expected contribution and cost of attending with aid. The answer to your question is it depends. Some assets like your primary home and retirements can be shielded from expected family contribution. If you've got assets sitting in a taxable account....
- softwaredoug 2y agoIs this going to create some weird incentive for me, a parent of a college kid, to go 4 years unemployed traveling the world?
- rKarpinski 2y agoHoney, think about how much money the divorce will save us on tuition!
- softwaredoug 2y agoTBH My parents got divorced my Freshman year, and as much as it sucked, I did somehow get more Federal financial aid out of the deal...
- pie_flavor 2y agoIt creates an incentive for you to get married, so you are the relevant family instead of your parents.
- alkonaut 2y agoIs that how "family income" in this context is calculated in the US? That until I'm married I count as being part of my parents' family but as soon as I marry I have my own? No age restriction or consideration whether I live with my parents or anything?
- yapyap 2y agowow that’s amazing
- tomcam 2y agoOn a related note, why does an institution so commendably progressive as Harvard charge tuition at all?
- wnc3141 2y agoI've come to realize what we think as progressive places are what I consider "inclusively conservative" as in liberal socially, but very much bound to keeping wealth strata in place. San Francisco + older bay area cities are a prime example of being a bastion of free market capitalism in the guise of progressivism.
- orangecat 2y agoSan Francisco + older bay area cities are a prime example of being a bastion of free market capitalism in the guise of progressivism. The main reason SF is unaffordable is that the city government forbids people from building housing, which is the exact opposite of a free market.
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoSF is already one of the most dense cities in the USA. If the government forbids people from building housing, they've historically done a poor job at it. They are the second most dense city in the USA after NYC, and no would accuse NYC of not being unaffordable either. The real problem is that more people want to live in SF than they have allowed housing to be built for. But it isn't clear that if they went with Houston-style "anything goes", would they still be that desirable? Or only as desirable as less popular Houston?
- asdff 2y agoSf is 7 square miles. You can cut a swath out of that size out of other cities and find that density. Possibly more density. Koreatown in LA has like 45k people a square mile, over twice as dense as sf. Several other areas there clock in at a higher density too. Really you need to consider it as just a region in the greater Bay Area metro region. And given its prominence in position as a transit hub with billions invested over decades in just that effort, it makes sense to add density there.
- laidoffamazon 2y agoIs there a term for doing beneficial things for a tiny fraction of people and coasting off of the PR for it? What's this going to do for people that aren't good enough to be in the top .1% of merit? Why do we care?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kevinsync 2y agoJust read an adjacent banger that interrogates the underlying reasons why our (US) education system is broken, how it got that way, how it's influenced culture beyond our (individual) control, insinuates why these institutions are so preposterously expensive, and proposes thoughts on how to fix it (TL;DR prolly won't get fixed) https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/12/meritocracy-college-admissions-social-economic-segregation/680392/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/12/meritoc... https://archive.ph/OC81c https://archive.ph/OC81c
- rKarpinski 2y ago80% of American families... but what % of MIT students?
- kleton 2y agoA sham marriage (get a prenup if you want) is sufficient to have parents' income not counted by FAFSA.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 2y agoIf true, this is wild. I've never heard of it, nor of anyone exploiting it.
- burkaman 2y agoI've never heard of anyone doing this either, but it is true and it's a pretty reasonable rule in my opinion. If you're an "independent student" then you don't need to report your parents' income, and the government is fairly generous about who qualifies as independent: https://studentaid.gov/help-center/answers/article/independent-student https://studentaid.gov/help-center/answers/article/independe.... You can definitely game some of these qualifications, but that's fine, the overwhelming majority of people who qualify for this are legitimately independent from their parents and should be considered for financial aid.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoAnother way to save money is to rent an apartment and make that your permanent address freshman year than to pay out of state tuition and room and board. I always thought this scheme could never work until I met someone who played it and saved tens of thousands in the process.
- vharuck 2y agoIt might be a "scheme" the school and the state quietly approve. Students living in the community should be more likely to set down roots with employment, social groups, or marriage. Brain theft, instead of brain drain.
- slackfan 2y agoWould have been lovely about 20 years ago. Oh well, no MIT for me.
- macrocosmos 2y agoI knew a student at my high school whose parents earned enough to be able to both take simultaneous sabbaticals for a year so that their child could avoid tuition at a school with a similar program.
- nickpsecurity 2y agoPlease tell us that counts for the Micro-Masters certs like Data Science. That would open up a lot of opportunities for people who can’t put in as much time due to working to pay bills.
- j45 2y agoI'm sure this causes pause for more than a few people who always wanted to go to MIT, knew they could, and didn't. Tuition wasn't appetizing even 20 years ago. In addition to pioneering Open Courses that were of high enough quality that you'd want to take them, this is hopefully the start of another trend/wave.
- balderdash 2y agoWhile I think this is well meaning, I’d be much more impressed by institutions actually cutting costs, The ratio of administrators to students is insane as is the faculty ratio at most universities, not to mention the outlays for extravagant projects like sports centers and student centers.
- EasyMark 2y agoYeah my school was a -lot- less nice 20 years ago when I graduated. I was amazed visiting my nephew in his dorm. It was like something out of an extremely nice hotel and concurrent works space for students to lounge and study, and the sports stadium was insanely improved. He said almost all the dorms were that nice or better. I can’t help but feel all that likely came out of his an other students back pockets, as the state has only been cutting funding for public universities. And yes I realize this has more than one cause, but virtually unlimited student allows allow a large portion of the out of control tuition costs.
- projectileboy 2y agoThank you for this comment; articles on the rising costs of college almost always uncritically treat it like a law of nature, and rarely have I seen articles that attempt to study in-depth the extent to which college administrations have become bloated, self-perpetuating jobs programs. All while at the same time departments are cut, professors are expected to do more with less, and more and more classes are pushed on to adjunct faculty who get paid a pittance. Until this is addressed, any efforts to improve the ways in which students finance their education is just a band-aid.
- balderdash 2y agoIf you’re interested. https://www.goacta.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/The-Cost-of-Excess-FINAL-Full-Report.pdf https://www.goacta.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/The-Cost-o...
- barfingclouds 2y agoVery much this
- nothrowaways 2y agoWhat's the logic for choosing 200k
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoMore than 100k but less than 300k
- geuis 2y agoIs this age dependent? For example I'm in my 40s and make a good salary, but am under this limit. If I got accepted would that apply?
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoPresumably yes
- synergy20 2y agothat means if the parents earn 300K a year, one can just quit his/her job and take the free ride? One couple, both PhDs, when their daughter went to Harvard, the mom quit her job to qualify for the free tuition. What about if someone has a large net asset? will the 200K still apply?
- User23 2y agoOne more reason to select deferred comp!
- BalinKing 2y agoI saw a similar headline just today (albeit on a much smaller scale) for Carnegie Mellon University: https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/news/carnegie-mellon-university-new-program-free-tuition/ https://www.cbsnews.com/pittsburgh/news/carnegie-mellon-univ... I feel like the timing is too close to be a coincidence—does anyone know if there's a link?
- zaptheimpaler 2y agoMaybe it has something to do with the incoming Trump administration and federal student loans. They seem to want to reduce government spending and may see federal student loans as waste, especially since some were forgiven. Maybe there is some amount of arm-twisting involved. Better for the universities to not mention any of that and appear altruistic.
- arcmechanica 2y agoThe freshman class of MIT pays enough to cover all other students every year.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoIt's not really something new; most top universities like CMU already have a similar policy. MIT has had it as well, they just raised the threshold for qualification.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoThis is only tuition though. Using their estimates you would still be expected to spend $30k/yr https://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-attendance/making-mit-affordable/ https://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-atten...
- insane_dreamer 2y agothat's nice, but it's become nearly as difficult to get into MIT as winning the lottery The MIT undergraduate student body is about the same as it was in 1960, but the number of applications rose from around 4000 in 1960 to 11000 in 2000, to 20000 in 2024. This isn't just an MIT problem. The undergrad populations of the top universities (Ivy league and similar) have hardly grown over the decades despite a large increase in student population overall in the US, not to mention the very large increase in foreign students over the past 25 years. This is by design to create increasingly exclusive brands. Deep dive into this: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-university-of-impossible-to-get-into/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-university-of-impossibl...
- lolinder 2y ago> The undergrad populations of the top universities (Ivy league and similar) have hardly grown over the decades despite a large increase in student population overall in the US Why should we expect individual universities to scale up their class sizes proportional to the student population in the US? Some universities may choose to, and new universities could spin up to serve the increased student body, but I don't see a compelling reason to argue that any given university should scale up just because college has (somewhat arbitrarily) become the default path for the entire middle class. There's nothing wrong with MIT wanting to stay small, and it's not necessarily a conspiracy to build exclusive brands. They could also just recognize that their system won't scale up to an order of magnitude more students.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> it's not necessarily a conspiracy to build exclusive brands except that it is about branding and ranking; these top unis have the money and the capability to double their undergrad student size; they have no problem attracting top talent as far as professors are concerned I didn't just make this up[0] [0] https://www.nber.org/papers/w29309 https://www.nber.org/papers/w29309
- lolinder 2y ago
- rubyn00bie 2y agoThe decrease of buying power, post Covid, makes this pretty much moot at best. It’s sort of depressing to think that even if I had children, or magically qualified to attend a prestigious school like MIT, I’d still be surely priced out. Just like I am buying a house. Making $200k a year ensures I’ll never own a home unless I want to move to an area I don’t feel safe in. I imagine having children make that trade off better, but not without substantial intrinsic costs to one’s self and one’s children. If someone makes $199k at this point, they’re likely unable to afford a home in any major metropolitan area. While being able to have your gifted children receive a free education is great, I imagine many folks will push ever so slightly past that, assuming two years working parents, by the time their children would be of age to go to school. It’s just depressing. Sorry, I’ll go back into my hole.
- herewulf 2y agoWhat urban hellhole do you live in where you can't buy a home in a safe neighborhood while earning $200K?! You need to look outside your immediate area. Or at another state. Most of the USA is nothing like that.
- VincentEvans 2y agoWhat happens if family earns $200,001 ? Follow up question - what is a “family” here? A single parent with 3 kids? A married couple with one child?
- ttyprintk 2y agoI bet this describes Whitfield Diffie, who started at MIT in 1961. A riot happened that year over tuition rising from $1200 to $1400 [0]. He’d intended to transfer to Berkeley where tuition for residents was something like $120. [0] https://alum.mit.edu/slice/what-50000-i-better-practice-more https://alum.mit.edu/slice/what-50000-i-better-practice-more
- roschdal 2y agoThe poor regards will study for free at MIT.
- gttalbot 2y agoThis is great and all, but will we be addressing the fact that the acceptance rate of these institutions are all artificially low? The size of freshman classes are the same or smaller than the same in the 1980s, and the population of the country is much larger. Tuition isn't the only problem here. If we want a country with social mobility, our higher ed institutions should reflect this and not create artificial scarcity.
- snvzz 2y ago[flagged]
- mgoetzke 2y agoI never like these hard cut-offs. We should establish a name/expression for all these rules a simple wording which represents 200k=0% and eg. 250k=100% or something. Otherwise we always have a situation where making more money suddenly leads to less net
- DC-3 2y agoSometimes they are called 'cliffs' - in the UK people talk about the tax cliff at 100k income where your marginal rate increases and you lose free childcare.
- OJFord 2y agoIt's 'not progressive', but that might not fly in the US. i.e. in a progressive fee structure, your marginal fee if your family earns 250k would be whatever%, but that would only be due on the amount over 200k.
- aurareturn 2y agoAgreed. For the parents who make $200,001 in income, they're screwed.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chengiz 2y agoYou mean there's no sliding scale here as in tax brackets? Citation please?
- maxerickson 2y agoThey don't give a lot of details, but they cover a substantial portion of the tuition for families making $200,000 or even $225,000: https://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-attendance/making-mit-affordable/ https://sfs.mit.edu/undergraduate-students/the-cost-of-atten...
- tossandthrow 2y agoIt seems insane that your personal choices are bound to your family situation- especially when you are an adult. Just the idea that parents in the US are expected to pay for their children's education is so wrong.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- oh_fiddlesticks 2y agoI sort of understand where you're coming from, but on the other hand, if parents aren't to be expected to provide for the children they (most commonly) decided to give life to, then who in your view should bear the financial cost of that decision?
- tossandthrow 2y agoIt should be a public good as an educated populous is a public benefit. This is about MIT, which along with their Ivy League peers probably represent symbolism and no more than a dent into the total number of education programmes carried out in the US. But again, hearing advisors on personal finance talking about saving for your kids education as a high priority is so insane for me and is completely contrary to what I would expect from a meritocratic society (which I know the US aspires to be).
- fragmede 2y agoto be clear, schooling until the age of 18 is free in the US, it's higher education whos cost is borne by the parents
- random42 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- theGnuMe 2y agoMan.. I am highly paid yet poor enough for my kids to go to MIT for free. Awesome.
- Malidir 2y ago"MIT’s endowment — made up of generous gifts made by individual alumni and friends — allows the Institute to provide this level of financial aid, both now and into the future." This 'free education' is a great argument for MIT to persuade Wealthy Lefties to donate/leave them their inheritence. And do the senior people get any bonuses related to number of applicants/places? But regardless, the increase to the current thresholds are great!
- rldjbpin 2y agofrom my personal experience (an outsider trying to apply), the admission process was by itself intimidating enough to keep me from even applying. let me explain. thanks to purchasing power parity and exchange ratio gap, i was already from a broke family that would meet the cutoff for most universities a decade ago. however, the act of paying hundreds of dollars for application fees was enough to not make it like you lose nothing by trying. to put things to perspective, a few hundred dollars, which could cover a handful of applications, were equivalent to the take-home salary for a month during that time. maybe i was unaware of some concessions or perhaps there has been improvements on this front, but i wonder if some applications might still be this hard pressed despite these initiatives.