8 ms·
Hacking 700M Electronic Arts accounts
- SeattleAltruist 2y agoDidn't read. Reading white text on black background is like staring into an oncoming car's high beams. Good grief this is bad formatting and people keep doing it.
- asvirts 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bearjaws 2y ago4 months from report to remediation... absolutely pathetic. This could have been exploited to just unban every account that has ever been banned. This guy would have made a fortune selling just that exploit to cheaters.
- ronsor 2y agoSelling the exploit? No. What you do is offer an unban API and charge $1 per call.
- h1fra 2y ago$1 is not very ambitious when people have sometimes thousand of dollars worth of games :D
- bearjaws 2y agoNot to mention mainstream cheats are going for $50+ a WEEK.
- tomschwiha 2y agoYou could turn it into a simple subscription based service: pay to stay (unbanned). Pretty sure "price restructuring" (price increases) will be paid by most users (cost sunk fallacy).
- darkwater 2y agoYeah, if Alice and Bob are at war, accept a huge payment by Alice to ban Bob, and then ask Bob a small recurrent fee to unban his account til the next payment. Mafia style. The second part is called "pizzo".
- edm0nd 2y agoYou would be able to charge much more than $1 per call and the real $ wouldn't come from unbanning but banning instead. Think about being able to empower a kid to ban anyone they want. It would turn into chaos but I do not think such a service would be long lived as it would generate so many support tickets and issues that EA would start looking into how it was happening.
- jerf 2y agoIf someone was out to maximize chaos and not just make money, this is in all seriousness in the class of problems that someone intelligent could have used to all but destroy EA. You don't offer an API with targeted usage, and you sure don't ban everyone. There's lots of fun ideas you can go for here, but just as one, suppose I spend a month banning accounts that haven't played much, but more than zero. Then go quiet for a couple of weeks. EA frontline support notices but if you play your cards right they don't put the pieces together and nobody is quite roused to investigate. Then you start up again, somewhat faster, spend a couple of days banning a good chunk of medium sized accounts. Then maybe at the end you ban the biggest accounts as quickly as you can. Now the bannings are news. EA's PR is probably completely blown out by the crisis and starts saying contradictory things. (My guess is that initially they end up backing their right to ban people and releasing statements to the effect of how right they probably are; this is, in the end, a huge mistake on their part.) Gamers can be reliably expected to start a ton of rumors, take them in the worst way possible, and antagonize EA, and EA is pretty likely to make at least one class-A error in being antagonistic back. (The hackers could even supply some of the rumors and some bots to get them going, though I doubt it'll be necessary. The gamer community is pretty well primed to turn on EA.) A ton of people who are curious but figure this can't be affecting them because they hardly use the service log in and discover they've been banned despite not having done anything on EA in six months. The fire rises as they post to reddit and hundreds of people chime in with "WTF, me too!", even if it's only a small percentage of the total people who check. Several days later, EA puts all the pieces together confidently enough to be sure that they can announce it's a hack. They're right. Nobody cares. Half of the gamer community doesn't even believe their defense. It's hard to guess what the upper bound of damage is on this scenario.
- Aachen 2y agoThen you're on the hook and the income dries up when they find out. Selling for cash up front means you got 90% of the law if the prosecution decides you've done something wrong and finds you in the first place (the use of exploits is commonly illegalised, and often indirectly the discovery or development, but not the knowledge or sale) Not that I'd advise either course of action for the players' sake
- grantwu 2y agoThe timeline says that the initial report was 6/16 and the initial patches were 7/8 and 7/18. It's not clear to me what was exploitable when.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Jerrrrrrry 2y ago[flagged]
- mooreds 2y agoI enjoyed the detailed explanation of how he moved from point to point. I imagine it wasn't as straightforward as is laid out in a blog post It would be interesting to see what I imagine to be the reams of notes from one of these to show how much time and effort it takes to perform this kind of attack.
- echoangle 2y ago> It's also disappointing that EA has yet to start a bug bounty program. Without any real incentive to report vulnerabilities, I know people who have instead chosen to keep them to themselves. I would love to see EA follow the rest of the industry's lead here. Does that mean the author got nothing for reporting this?
- richbell 2y ago> Does that mean the author got nothing for reporting this? Correct.
- jandrese 2y agoIt's not true that they got nothing. There's always the possible threat of legal action against them for reporting the vulnerabilities.
- gchamonlive 2y agoI mean, after all, that's what we are all here for right? Fish and legal liability.
- _lvbh 2y agoIt's disappointing how many companies don't offer a bug bounty. I have a hoard of vulnerabilities I've found over the years just sitting in my head. It doesn't help that there are legal risks with reporting them & they can technically sue you to hell (EU/UK)
- gosub100 2y agoIt's probably the result of some very backward-thinking rationale: "If we get hacked by the bad guys, our shareholders will point to these bounties and say 'wait, you're activetly paying people to hack you and now they did and you're going to have to write down and additional $X Million?'. " Execs afraid of having egg on their face, perhaps.
- 2y ago
- sailfast 2y agoWait this person didn’t get paid for finding this? No bug bounty? Seems like they could at least toss them some free credits or something…
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thesurlydev 2y agoFor anyone who's enjoyed reading this, there's plenty more to read about on the bug bounty platforms such as HackerOne's "Hacktivity": https://hackerone.com/hacktivity https://hackerone.com/hacktivity
- tommica 2y agoHmm, someone tried to login to my account few days ago
- edm0nd 2y agounrelated
- xeromal 2y agoWould've been fun to ban every account and hope they didn't have DB backups
- m4tthumphrey 2y agoI thought about this... What would be the outcome here do you think? Ie if this guy didn't report and did decide to mess around for real? Could he have been tracked? Would EA be down for weeks?!
- mooreds 2y agoI mean, Kevin Mitnick spent time in jail: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Mitnick https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Mitnick I wouldn't mess around with this stuff myself.
- m4tthumphrey 2y agoMe neither, but would it have been easy to trace him? I mean if he was going to use this for bad, I would assume he would have waited a month or so then done it all via a VPN etc. But point being he _could_ have done this and to be honest for all we know, someone else _has_ been abusing it until it was patched...
- manbash 2y agoVPN is used to bypass regional restrictions. The VPN provider will share information if an active investigation is underway.
- akdev1l 2y agothe VPN provider can try to share whatever information but most reputable providers would have nothing You can pay for a VPN using monero or cash and then connect to the VPN from TOR - VPN provider doesn’t need to know anything
- Fokamul 2y agoIt's ridiculous EA didn't pay any bounty for this
- qmarchi 2y agoBattleDash - "Here's XSS, Account Takeover, Ban Reversal, and a heads up before I publish it" EA - "So here's $0." If anyone is at EA, this man just saved the integrity of your entire empire, you might want to give him at least a token amount.
- londons_explore 2y agoMy experience with big companies is even if the whole IT security team thinks this is worthy of a bounty, and the team has plenty of budget they could allocate to it, the process of giving money to an individual is frequently so difficult to get through the bureaucratic purchase order system that it's basically impossible to do unless you are contractually obliged to pay.
- nijave 2y agoProbably easier to hire them on as a consultant than "give them money"
- JohnFen 2y agoEA is a famously horrible company. I don't think they care much about the "integrity of their empire" because their customers don't care.
- foobranded 2y agoWhen I was in college, I once found some bad exploits in the sims social on Facebook, the subsidiary (Playfish?) behind it asked me for my address and which console I owned and then unexpectedly sent me a huge number of games and goodies. It was great. Better than money, I think (I sold some of those games anyway). I reached out to employees via unofficial channels. I'm sure if I had spoken to some exec I'd be in jail right now.
- wavemode 2y agoSometimes I wonder how it feels to be an engineer at such a company, having all your private APIs, weird bugs and dirty laundry aired in a public breach disclosure. Though it's likely in a case like this, no single person was responsible for the vulnerability. Probably 5 or 6 different teams owned different parts of what he exploited (which is probably why the exploit existed in the first place - big complex system where everyone only understands their tiny piece of it).
- captainkrtek 2y agoI would have a pit in my stomach if I read a post like that knowing I implemented those APIs
- treflop 2y agoWhat if you implemented the APIs but - someone else proxied your API to the public - someone else leaked credentials you assigned them in the public code of a game As someone working on a team that publishes APIs to the greater large organization, you can't trust other people. People be doing wild things.
- ryandrake 2y agoI would hope that my employer had a postmortem culture that encouraged looking into every point of failure and identifying process changes that will prevent a repeat of the incident. Instead of pointing the finger at Team X who messed up and/or just "blaming hackers" and continuing on with your defective processes.
- Sparkyte 2y agoBad, especially if you have no control because you don't work in that department but you know you could do better than that department.
- sqeaky 2y agoOn a team you are emotionally (or maybe even just financially) invested in it feels bad, but when I was at EA they almost worked hard to make it hard to become emotionally invested. At a company the size of EA almost certainly this will be used to play politics and even if it hurts the company as a whole people will use it to have larger control over the now smaller company.
- All4All 2y agoWhat's most wild about all of this to me is that EA has claimed for years a "technical impossibility" to unlink an existing Xbox account and re-link with a new one. (See https://www.reddit.com/r/XboxGamePass/comments/12gsy4i/ea_xbox_linking_completely_messed_up_and_you_cant/ https://www.reddit.com/r/XboxGamePass/comments/12gsy4i/ea_xb... and many other forum posts on EA). I ran into this wall and after spending hours on support calls with EA they were unable to link a very old Xbox account I had, meaning I can't login to any EA games on Xbox, making the majority of them unplayable on the platform. Yet, here, we see, it is very much possible.
- ajvpot 2y ago> Unfortunately game entitlements, friends, and game save data for newer cross-platform games like Battlefield 2042 are stored in the EA account itself, not the persona, so that data isn't transferred.
- 3abiton 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CoopaTroopa 2y agoMost likely they were in the process of adding this feature to fix your issue when it was sadly exploited before they could announce it
- jonwinstanley 2y agoHahaha!
- stepupmakeup 2y agoLikely a bureaucratic problem and much easier for these social media PR teams to pass it off as a system issue
- klaussilveira 2y agoIs there a best practices guide somewhere on how to setup a bug bounty program?
- Aachen 2y agoI work in the field so it's hard to know what info you might be missing. To me it seems quite straightforward: you post to your website somewhere that you're happy to have people probe your technical security provided that they follow coordinated vulnerability disclosure (you'll want to flesh it out a tad more than this one sentence of course) and what kind of reward you're willing to hand out for what kind of bug and in which part of the scope. Any exclusions, such as that you won't pay out to young or old people or if you're born in the wrong country and got sanctioned or so, are also things you'll want to mention up front to prevent sour grapes afterwards Perhaps I can answer a specific question or look for good pointers if you have a specific question about this?
- cantSpellSober 2y agoThanks! Any good examples? Valve comes to mind: https://hackerone.com/valve?type=team https://hackerone.com/valve?type=team
- Aachen 2y agoI'm not a bounty hunter myself, but trying to think beyond the big names I found the Dutch government's <https://english.ncsc.nl/contact/reporting-a-vulnerability-cvd https://english.ncsc.nl/contact/reporting-a-vulnerability-cv...> as an example that looks good to me. One point of improvement could be that they're not very concrete about any reward (or the lack thereof, also fine, but better to be up front). Some of the exclusions are also a bit broad, e.g. I'd still say XSS on a static site is worth fixing even if it's not a major risk, but I can understand where they're coming from when you consider there's thousands of websites run by the government. On the plus side, they give a clear timeline so you know they're going to pick it up in a timely manner, and they have practical guidelines on what (not) to do Just remembered: One thing I didn't like about e.g. Google's report mechanism is that it basically required a Google account. There were instructions for if you don't have one, but they didn't work (probably outdated) so you just have to agree with the extremely broad blanket statement that is the Google privacy policy. That could be something to avoid if you're setting up a policy of your own: don't require agreeing to wholly unrelated terms; hackers (in the HN sense of the word) sometimes don't take very well to that A good experience I had was with Threema (private/encrypted chat application like Wire or Signal). The report process consisted of just sending a service account a chat message (probably there's also other ways), which was nice and easy. My report turned out to be mostly invalid (the risk was real but my imagined fix was flawed and it turned out contact discovery is a hard problem) but their answer was quick and thorough, I was impressed that they didn't just brush it off like so many orgs do. Being on something like Hackerone, like Valve and Keybase, has pros and cons. I'm probably just old but it feels odd to me to let direct threats to your organisation be handled by a third party, sometimes even having them triage and decide whether to inform your org of a claimed vulnerability at all (recent story on HN; probably it works fine in 99% of cases), as well as it being an instance of having to sign up for something unrelated when I just want to ping an email address with the steps to reproduce. On the other hand, it standardises the whole thing so you know where to find different things if you use it more than the sporadic amount I have. I also wonder if this attracts the beg bounty hunters who see potential easy money, based on that the orgs on Hackerone seem to take reports less seriously when you didn't invest a ton of time in developing an exploit, or if the causality is reversed (maybe they chose Hackerone because they already had too many beg reports, hoping to be able to use accounts' reputation as an indicator for triage)
- jfactorial 2y agoFrom the article: > I had found a way to obtain a privileged access token within the environment (a story for another day, but a certain game's executable had hardcoded credentials!), but I wasn't sure what I could do with it. Can someone speak to this a bit more? I'm under the impression an executable binary shouldn't be easily read to find such credentials, and I don't know what else a game dev is supposed to do if their executable needs to authenticate itself with a remote server.
- hobs 2y agoThe strings command is pretty old can do it if you're naive enough to embed a username and password into the game client. The main thing is that its privileged - having a token shouldn't let you do anything besides say, report your game stats to a central server or enumerate the server lists, things like that.
- NikkiA 2y agoTBF strings might not trivially show up the password if you took the most basic of provisions (a non-ascii password, not stored right next to the username separated by a \0), but most programmers likely wouldn't even bother with that.
- nijave 2y agoEven then you can MITM if you have elevated access to the platform and can tinker with the certificate store. Games like Pokemon Go use a highly obfuscated algorithm to sign requests which makes it much harder to actually use the key if you can retrieve it
- NikkiA 2y ago> I'm under the impression an executable binary shouldn't be easily read to find such credentials Why would you assume that? binaries are perfectly easily readable on non-locked-down platforms. You'd have to have a system where the executable is encrypted and a secure part of the CPU die handle decryption against a private key, and even then it'd probably be only a matter of time before someone delidded the chip to get the key.
- throitallaway 2y agoEA can get rekt. Their account suspension/banning process is obtuse and opaque. I bought a game, created an online account to play it with a friend, and was banned 2 days later (making my purchase useless.) I did absolutely nothing wrong and their team won't give any details other than "read the account agreement."
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mdaniel 2y agoWell, fun story: you can just use this api to unban yourself :-D I am not a lawyer but I bet a sane judge would have little sympathy for a CFAA claim against your own account
- JohnFen 2y agoI'm not so sure about that. If your account has been banned, that's terminating your contract. It's no longer "your account" (if it ever was, but that's a rabbit hole I'll ignore here). Subverting access controls to do anything with it would be a clear CFAA violation because the fact that you were banned means that you no longer have permission to access the system. The legally correct way to address throitallaway's problem is to sue EA to recover the money lost. In the US, this would likely qualify to be a small claims suit, which makes it feasible for a normal and nonwealthy person to do. Plus, when taking a large company to small claims court, the company often doesn't even bother to send a representative, in which case you win a default judgement. It's not an amount of money they really care about, and they know you still have to go to the effort to collect on the judgement.
- cgoode 2y agoIs it typical to just present findings and hope to get rewarded? What would the expected reward amount be in similar circumstances where they did pay up? Do companies pay more to prevent articles like this being published? Sorry if these are stupid questions - I know little about this area.
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoEA doesn't care. They definately should pay and I'd imagine this would be in the high 5 figures or more. Their customers don't care if their code is secure. 99% just want to play Madden.
- j1mmie 2y agoSo, like any sane person would, I overnighted an Xbox, installed Battlefield 2042, and waited for the moment of truth... I was in! I love hackers <3
- bayindirh 2y agoWhen I read the line, I thought "that's the spirit!". Kudos to him.
- cantSpellSober 2y ago...and no bounty. I hope they were at least thanked! (great writeup thank you)
- sanktanglia 2y agoEa loves using generic systems across all their games. When poking around at Madden I found they have a common backend called blaze that has generic web and tcp endpoints. We built out a tool to call these endpoints (having to upload xml) and only later found out that every time we made the call it was crashing their servers but since we were grabbing a new server each request we were crashing all of their madden servers one by one. They ended up building an API to discourage people poking around
- Thaxll 2y agoBlaze is the name of the C++ framework/service to build custom backend for online games. It allows game team to developp online features in a standard way, it's backed by MySQL. From what I remember you need roughly one Blaze instance for 5k/10k players.
- dijit 2y agonot to be confused with “blaze” the PHP backend used for Respawn games. Who are also owned by EA.
- unit149 2y agoThumbing through iterations of PSN client IDs, attempting to sign in to the EA gateway proxy returns 'namespacename' value that's pulled from personal data. 2F-A token info should be hashed in /tokeninfo/ endpoint pulled from JUNO. Attempting to integrate, post-ex-facto - infrastructure for a C++ API would return the PSN user id.
- chatmasta 2y agolol, I think I saw this API recently for another game. It’s a GraphQL frontend right? They disabled introspection but their error messages will helpfully offer suggestions for misspelled field names BTW, pro-tip when reversing APIs of popular services like this: use GitHub code search! Put some unique endpoint names into it and see what comes up. You’ll often find some kindred spirits who have hacked their own little API clients to do something you never even thought about, but which nevertheless helps you advance along your own quest…
- Zopieux 2y agoWhat a deeply unserious company.
- Jerrrrrrry 2y agoElectronic Arts has been, and still is, vulnerable from its Xbox gateway. I legally/ethically/mentally cannot read this article but if its not related, there is more work to do. Not that anyone should do it for EA, but for the collective they've swindled.
- warambo1010 2y ago[dead]
- theogravity 2y agoThanks for the article. Made me check our dev and prod API servers to make sure we weren't exposing the OpenAPI UI / JSON descriptor routes.
- batch12 2y agoHopefully those endpoints do a better job with authorization than these did
- Havoc 2y agoI mean my expection with EA is basically 50/50 on whether I can actually get to render frame 1 of the in-game. Played one of their high profile games daily for a while. It is literally a crap shoot day to day whether something works as in join a game. Imagine the same on a big cloud. Oh sorry S3 storage...not happening today. We're just having an off day and decided we're not doing S3 today. ...that's how the gaming industry rolls. In infra world people would just laugh because it isn't a plausible scenario but in EA consumer world people call it Tuesday.
- theWreckluse 2y agoWhat game did you play?
- Havoc 2y agoOne of their premiere titles - battlefield. I assume they test in prod on their billion dollar title because it sure felt like a daily stream of nightly builds. Can't believe that circus has a market cap of 40bn. You kidding me? Their launcher barely does what it says on the tin reliably - launch things
- rzgarkurdish 2y agoRzgarkurdish
- 486sx33 2y agoso spoofing, or using a real console, bypasses 2FA! I think the most interesting observation was this... "never seen a 2FA prompt on a console". There must be other opportunities for such... investigating :)