8 ms·
200k subscribers flee 'Washington Post' after Bezos blocks Harris endorsement
- jrepinc 2y ago[flagged]
- SavageBeast 2y agoIt would hurt Bezos even more if the US Govt found a way to cancel the massive use of AWS cloud services because his media arm endorsed the non-winning candidate. Given the business AWS does with the US govt, the size of his remaining stake, I can't make a good case for endorsing a candidate either. Microsoft is always lurking around ready to push their Azure solution so not like AWS can sit back and rest easy here.
- freejazz 2y agoAre people to find this comforting?
- SavageBeast 2y agoIt's a free country and a guy made a decision regarding what he was willing to have HIS company say publicly. It was his call to make. His company. Privately funded. He's got the right to run it any way he sees fit. You have the right to cancel subscriptions and decline to read it. Advertisers have the right to flee. Everyone has a choice. Thats how this whole America thing works. Besides, who was making their decision based on the Washington Post's editorial board endorsement anyhow?
- freejazz 2y agoYou could have just said "no." Also, I don't think it's a traditional feature of America to have highly concentrated media ownership.
- ajross 2y agoThe linked article is literally about people being upset about that and exercising exactly the same freedom to cancel their subscriptions, though. In which direction are you arguing?
- RussBrown00 2y agoAre you suggesting the govt should change who they did business with because one of their other businesses didn't politically support a certain candidate for President?
- mooreds 2y agoI think he is suggesting that government might do so.
- Ashwin1212 2y ago[dead]
- ZekeSulastin 2y agoI don’t think they’re suggesting that Trump should, but that there’s a good chance that he would.
- NickC25 2y agoIt's not a matter of if Trump would. He absolutely will. Donald Trump has an ego the size of the universe, and if someone slights him in any way, he will be out for blood.
- chucke1992 2y agoThey are basically implying that the government should support businesses that fall in line with the government. Which is a strange thing to support though, but it often happens anyway.
- Terr_ 2y agoOr to put a finer point on it: Suggesting that some President would abuse the powers of the office, using the government as a tool to harm others out of corrupt personal revenge. The prisoner's dilemma here is that each group that surrenders to the potential threat makes it more likely the bad situation will actually come to pass.
- Sabinus 2y ago>It would hurt Bezos even more if the US Govt found a way to cancel the massive use of AWS cloud services because his media arm endorsed the non-winning candidate It didn't even take that much illegal retaliation and abuse of power by Trump to incentivise capitalists to please him.
- NickC25 2y ago>Given the business AWS does with the US govt, the size of his remaining stake, I can't make a good case for endorsing a candidate either. Honestly. I am not a government contractor, but I do own a small business - and I stay the fuck out of politics. There is nothing to be gained from making any political overtures of any type. I have my own political opinions, but I don't broadcast them - I simply vote. And my opinions are not those of my company or brand - because my brand/company has no political values - it has a product. Jeff literally has tens of billions of dollars on the line, both his own and his investors' money. Preventing his media arm, which is supposedly independent, from making a political statement is just absolutely dumb, because this draws MORE attention on him and Amazon than if he just did nothing. If Harris wins, I wouldn't put it past her to put Lina Kahn on the case of breaking up Amazon. Dumb move by Jeff, and probably a dereliction of duty as a founder who has taken public money.
- lukan 2y ago"Dumb move by Jeff, and probably a dereliction of duty as a founder who has taken public money." Unless Trump wins and Bezos benefits from the secret deals that were just made behind the curtain.
- ajross 2y agoThat logic would have made sense in April, or in 2022, or even earlier. Certainly not within two weeks of an election. Very clearly Bezos interceded on behalf of one specific candidate here, not out of general principle.
- sva_ 2y ago8%. I wonder how many they gained, if any significant amount
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- duskwuff 2y ago> I wonder how many they gained, if any significant amount Very few, if any. WaPo already had a reputation as a liberal paper; one refusal to endorse a candidate is hardly going to convince conservatives to subscribe.
- bad_username 2y agoIt is disappointing that the only viable alternative to "liberal bias", at least according to comments here, seems to be "conservative bias". One would hope that there'd be a sizable pool of readers who are not really taking a particular side and would appreciate honest, neutral coverage. That's certainly what I'd appreciate (and pay for).
- duskwuff 2y agoAn endorsement from the editorial desk of a paper is entirely orthogonal to neutral news coverage from the reporting desk. One of the major reasons for concern here is that the non-endorsement was the result of executive meddling by Bezos. If he's stepping in to override the paper's editorial positions, who's to say he wouldn't also interfere if the paper were to report on something he found inconvenient?
- 6yyyyyy 2y ago"Honest, neutral coverage" is a contradiction. You can be honest, or you can be neutral.
- AdamN 2y agoThat's a big fat zero. No MAGA people are paying for WaPO (or any newspaper aside from WSJ for that matter).
- ashconnor 2y agoThis might be bad if the point of owning a newspaper was to make money.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- potro 2y agoThis is likely bad even if the point was other then making money.
- Sabinus 2y agoThe less prestige and readership the paper has, the less influence it has.
- chucke1992 2y agotraditional media is already losing the influence to be honest. Even big networks like CNN or Fox News are basically dying. In the era of tiktok, twitter, podcasters and other services - traditional media is just too boring source of news. I would say that even the traditional search will die sooner or later.
- wkat4242 2y agoI think CNN and especially Fox are already way too sensationalist. I prefer a good writeup like the guardian does. Not every fart needs to be "BREAKING NEWS". I'm sure some people crave the hollow mindless screaming of random influencers but there's still mindful people out there.
- chucke1992 2y agothey are sensationalist because they are trying to imitate the discourse like on TikTok or Twitter - some short sentence that makes people pay attention while reading the headline. It is like "click on us!!!" And it is getting worse because media has to compete with online media. > I'm sure some people crave the hollow mindless screaming of random influencers but there's still mindful people out there. For sure, there are event podcasts with cool and calm discourse too. There are options.
- bpodgursky 2y agoBezos is 100% checked out guys. Have you seen him recently? He's a non-entity [1]. He's living his best life There is no chance he had his finger on the trigger here. He probably hasn't even noticed this controversy. I'm not saying it's beyond him to do so — I'm not vouching for his ethics — but he literally is not involved in running any aspect of his financial web. He barely even checks in on his pet projects like Blue Origin anymore. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/27/technology/jeff-bezos-washington-post-dc.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/27/technology/jeff-bezos-was...
- duskwuff 2y agoNPR, from another article on the same topic: > Shipley had approved an editorial endorsement for Harris that was being drafted earlier this month, according to three people with direct knowledge. He told colleagues the decision to endorse was being reviewed by the paper's billionaire owner, Jeff Bezos. That's the owner's prerogative and is a common practice. - https://www.npr.org/2024/10/25/nx-s1-5165353/washington-post-presidential-endorsement-trump-harris https://www.npr.org/2024/10/25/nx-s1-5165353/washington-post...
- insane_dreamer 2y agoIf it helps Blue Origin or AWS get a multi $B gov contract under a Trump admin, then the loss will be more than worth it from a purely Bezos financial standpoint.
- chucke1992 2y agoI don't think it was that expensive of a purchase to care. In the first place it was done in order to stop bashing Bezos himself (I remember how the pivoted from saying how millionaires should not exist to millionaires are good). Plus a lot of left leaning media hate Bezos anyway.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> I remember how the pivoted from saying how millionaires should not exist to millionaires are good funny how large amounts of money corrupts one's own values
- chucke1992 2y agowell, values don't feed you. I am pretty sure a lot of folks would abandon their own beliefs if somebody gave them 1m.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoI don't think Bezos was having to choose between eating and $1M.
- atombender 2y agoIf money makes one abandon one's values, I would argue they weren't ever really values in the first place.
- Mistletoe 2y agoThis didn’t seem to go well. Reminds me of Elon not knowing that nice liberals like me used to buy his Tesla cars.
- lukan 2y agoTo be honest, I hope the greatest service Musk can do, is making electric cars somewhat acceptable to certain people, who only considered anything Diesel otherwise just by general principle. But in general I would like my car to be as unpolitical as possible.
- delusional 2y agoI love this. It's a direct contradiction of the old myth that people want "objective" journalism (whatever that's supposed to mean). People want journalism. They want an editorial angle that's relevant to the current debate. They want viewpoints and edge. They don't want some sort of detached dead "neutral" tone that just reports facts without taking a stance. I'm not saying that's what WaPo was doing anyway, but it's the rationale used to defend blocking the Harris endorsement.
- ant6n 2y agoOr perhaps a neutral viewpoint could still consider many problems/issues with one particular candidate. Perhaps being objective is more important than „not taking sides“ in an unbalanced contest.
- dingnuts 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throwway120385 2y agoOr that people who aren't likely Trump voters don't want to give money to an organization that eventually pays out on someone who will pay into Trump's campaign. It doesn't have to have anything to do with bias. In fact you're the one who is making it about someone wanting their biases to be confirmed. Kind of like not eating Chik Fil-A.
- standardUser 2y agoReporting should be objective. Editorial opinion, by it's very definition, should not be. Many people seem to not grasp this fundamental aspect of journalism.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y ago> Reporting should be objective Reporting cannot be objective. The most basic reason is the framing problem: deciding what facts about the world are relevant to the story being told. The things left in, the things left out. How much history do you include? How great is the geographic scope? Whose grievances matter, and whose do not? Every decision you are forced to make about such questions moves you, inch by millimeter, away from any conventional definition of "objective reporting".
- jimbob45 2y agoHow many typically leave after a general election though? I would certainly expect a dip in two weeks anyway.
- potro 2y agoI wonder if this is also a indication how much people actually value their WP (and by extension other major newspapers) subscription? And how much paying for subscription is kind of charity for them (support of independent journalism, etc.)?
- jansan 2y agoSo you think they pay for a subscription to get independent journalism, but cancel that subscription if the independent newspaper does not endorse their candidate? That's funny, don't you think?
- anamexis 2y agoThe point isn't that they didn't endorse a particular candidate, it's that this decision was made in a way that was completely antithetical to independent journalism.
- thethimble 2y agoHow is not endorsing a candidate “antithetical to independent journalism”? I understand that Bezos stepped in to perhaps overrule an endorsement but in what sense is maintaining neutrality antithetical to independent journalism?
- tim333 2y agoThe journalists obviously favour Kamala but were reined in by their capitalist master.
- bediger4000 2y agoHave you read their coverage? This is not in evidence.
- tim333 2y ago
- DonHopkins 2y ago[flagged]
- chucke1992 2y agoOh, they had more subscribers than I expected.
- A1kmm 2y agoThe ideal is that a good newspapers' jobs are to provide unbiased facts, not to tell people how to think. Not endorsing a candidate, but instead focusing on the facts, and on what they genuinely think will be of the most public interest in selecting content, is in fact closer to that ideal. It is the biased presentation of information, and the corresponding polarisation and information void that lead to the success of candidates using deception to get elected. So while Washington Post has many biases, this particular decision seems like a step in the right direction process-wise.
- yboris 2y agoFor context: "Washington Post didn't endorse in White House race for first time since 1980s" So, for the first time in 40+ years ... did they share a philosophical stance for why they are not doing it - one that we could point to and argue about?
- bediger4000 2y agoYes. It leaves out the Jeff Bezos intervention, so we can conclude it's a post hoc rationalization. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/10/25/washington-post-endorsement/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/10/25/washingto...
- standardUser 2y agoTraditionally, newspapers have editorial boards that are separate from reporting. And traditionally, editorial boards make political endorsements. This is in addition to printing editorials and opinion pieces from a variety of perspectives. All of that is separate from reporting, which strives to be objective. Both coexist within most media organizations. Fox News pioneered the blurring of those lines, but the lines remain clear at most traditional major media outlets. This is a case of a major paper deviating from the norm and succumbing to political pressure, which is outside of the established norms in a society with a free press.
- mike_hearn 2y ago
- WalterBright 2y agoAn "independent" newspaper should never be endorsing political candidates.
- umbra07 2y agounder any circumstance? No newspaper can claim to be independent. The WaPo's slogan is "Democracy Dies in Darkness". This, in and of itself consists of multiple political statements (ex: Democracy is important, information is crucial to the health of a democracy).
- WalterBright 2y ago> under any circumstance? No article is ever free of bias. But endorsing candidates means they don't even try. An independent news outfit would publish editorials in pairs - one on each side. Wouldn't you find that more interesting? I would. Like the old "Firing Line" TV show.
- maxerickson 2y agoThere's not 2 easy, equal sides to every issue. I'm not sure how to politely say more.
- WalterBright 2y ago> There's not 2 easy, equal sides to every issue. True, but there's value in making an effort. And in this particular case, there are only 2 candidates that matter. > I'm not sure how to politely say more. Feel free to be as rude as you like.
- maxerickson 2y agoSaying that there are only 2 candidates that matter is political advocacy!
- 2y ago
- jfengel 2y agoThe Post employees (including acquaintances of mine) are begging subscribers not to leave. They insist that Bezos doesn't interfere with the news reporting, only with the op-ed pages. I feel for them, but I don't see how they can justify that. This was a big, obvious incident, but it's impossible to imagine that it won't spread out from there. Every editorial decision is suspect. I don't see how the paper survives this. The news business is marginal at best, at least for organizations that want to do actual journalism. The Post was one of the few remaining papers originating national-scale reporting. They eked out a living on a reputation of doing good work. All of that gets thrown away in one decision. It's an astonishing hail-mary. Trump and Bezos get exactly one shot at this. I suppose Bezos imagines that the odds are good enough that Trump will win and he'll avoid whatever negative consequences were promised to his other business. But he will have literally destroyed this business in the process. Not that it was ever going to be a major revenue source for him. But whatever goal he wanted from owning a newspaper, this is all he'll get. Too bad for the employees, though.
- dahdum 2y ago> The Post employees (including acquaintances of mine) are begging subscribers not to leave. They insist that Bezos doesn't interfere with the news reporting, only with the op-ed pages. Even if you plan to resubscribe in the future, cancelling is the only action subscribers can take that will make any difference in the future.
- pushcx 2y agoIf one would like to subscribe to a national paper owned by a billionaire who supposedly only interferes with editorial and not reporting, the Wall Street Journal is cheaper.
- rsynnott 2y agoGiven that WSJ broke the Theranos thing (in which Murdoch was made to look very silly) one might even be inclined to think there’s more evidence for its independence at this point…
- mike_hearn 2y ago
- kbenson 2y agoMaybe the silver lining is that billionaires and large corporations might look less favorably at owning newspapers when it's seen as a net negative and a lever for someone to use against them. If Bezos didn't own WaPo, it wouldn't be a bargaining chip to get Trump to the table with Blue Origin, and wouldn't suffer in this way because of that causing him a loss.
- up2isomorphism 2y ago200K left but some other might also join. And if taking no stance makes your audiences leave, it might just be a symptom of an existing condition. BTW, I do not think Bezos needs npr to remind him the financial consequences.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 2y ago> if taking no stance makes your audiences leave Do you really think that is why people are leaving?
- throwaway314155 2y ago> BTW, I do not think Bezos needs npr to remind him the financial consequences. The story is newsworthy. I seriously doubt people at NPR are trying to...communicate directly with Jeff Bezos via...journalism?
- ceejayoz 2y ago> 200K left but some other might also join. News media keeps making this mistake - "if we go centrist enough the right-wing will join us!" It never works. Even Fox News is losing viewers to further-right outlets. Nothing the WaPo does is going to please the MAGAs - certainly not to the point of paying for a newspaper! - but they can piss off their existing readership (and staff). > And if taking no stance makes your audiences leave Taking no stance after taking a stance every election for almost fifty years is a choice.
- skissane 2y ago> News media keeps making this mistake - "if we go centrist enough the right-wing will join us!" It never works. There are right-wingers who read the NYT for Ross Douthat. > Even Fox News is losing viewers to further-right outlets. Fox News is rather low-brow, and further right stuff like OANN is even more low-brow. Not the kind of thing who attracts the more intellectual right-winger who reads First Things, Commentary (in its current neoconservative incarnation, not decades ago when it was still left-leaning), The American Conservative, Compact (which isn't purely conservative, more a strange medley where you'll find a Marxist on one page and a Catholic theocrat on the next), even National Review. But they might read NYT for Douthat. WaPo has Jennifer Rubin, but she seems much less conservative nowadays that Douthat does. Rubin's current output seems to be mainly targeted at liberals who are looking for a conservative who agrees with them.
- rootusrootus 2y agoWell, way more people are aware of the intended endorsement than would have paid any attention if it had been published as expected. Nobody was going to be surprised about WaPo endorsing the democratic candidate.
- rKarpinski 2y agoAs a major media organization they definitely should have known better with the timing but I suppose they weren't expecting their employee's to turn it into a major story.
- xethos 2y ago> but I suppose they weren't expecting their employee's [sic] to turn it into a major story. "I can't believe the journalists did that to us"
- rKarpinski 2y agopretty much, I doubt they thought their own weapons would be turned against them
- SubiculumCode 2y agoI've never been a fan of news organizations making endorsements. However, the idea that such an endorsement is being suppressed because of an owner's fear of reprisal against their other businesses by a candidate should they win the election is very very very bad. Intimidation of a free media is how fascist regimes begin and thrive. As Timothy Snyder wrote: Do Not Obey in Advance. In general politics is to be avoided on HN, but I will sacrifice every point I have to for my fellow Americans (international viewers, apologies for the American centric writing). 1)Russia is at war with the United States of America. 2)The goal of this war is to destabilize America. 3)The battle-ground is here at home. 4)The weapons in this war include pervasive laundering of Russian money into a) bend the minds of Americans through pervasive propaganda, b)direct corruption of U.S. citizens with money in return for favors or for promoting propaganda (e.g. influencers), c) corruption of politicians with promises of power, d) our divisions and our platforms for communication. Too few Americans accept or appreciate the veracity of points 1 thru 4, and this makes us weak. We have a free and open internet, and while this is great, it means that U.S. citizens are accessible, viable targets to any foreign-influence campaign, which can be all the more effective given the amount of data accumulated on each individual, and the ease at which these attacks can be individualized at scale. The United States does not protect its citizens from these attacks. Its hard to do right, and it poses difficult questions about freedom of speech, and freedom more generally. Nevertheless, we are exposed and blind, and in a war, that is asking for defeat. Offense is a form of defense. Why not take it back to Russia? Maybe we are. I do not know. But there, free-speech is dangerous, and the rebellious mind gets crushed quickly. China has the great firewall, and for all the terrible things this allows, it does protect their citizens from easy targeting to influence campaigns. Could the West do the same? Is it time to imagine an internet that excludes Russia, one which only includes liberal Democracies, partners and allies? [1] Do not obey in advance. Lesson 1, first page, by Timothy Snyder's pamphlet "On Tyranny." https://snyder.substack.com/p/on-tyranny https://snyder.substack.com/p/on-tyranny
- ashildr 2y agoThe US will stay the country that voted for Trump (and is close to doing this again) and the Washington Post will stay the newspaper where the billionaire owner decides what is published. None of this can be repaired for a generation.
- psadauskas 2y ago"Democracy dies in darkness" went from motto to mission statement.
- suncherta 2y agoI understand the reaction of people canceling their subscription, but I think it is a mistaken one. To me it is looks a lot like punishing the victim. The primary victim here is WP whose employees didn't do anything wrong in this situation and didn't have much of the choice. Even Bezos, at worst, is the person who didn't manage to stand under pressure put on him.
- chomp 2y agoI have no use for a weak willed news product. Endorse Trump, Kamala, or a third party, but if your tagline is “democracy dies in darkness” and you’re embracing that slogan in the opposite direction, I’m just going to cancel.
- Sabinus 2y agoYou put all the blame at Trump's door then? Still, someone has to say no to the pressure. If that's up to the subscribers then so be it. Let their money go to media that isn't beholden to Trump's threats.
- suncherta 2y agoYes, pretty much all of it. For sure Bezos handled this badly. But the problem in my opinion is not his management skills or even his civic valor, but apparent fear of business and public people of retributions for supporting a wrong candidate.
- JumpinJack_Cash 2y agoBezos has always been a Libertarian. Also I don't get it why people left (no pun intended). The pinnacle of journalism has always been the AP, AFP, Reuters etc. The 5 W (what, who, when, why, where) delivered in a fast manner. No speculation or anything, no partisan BS. If anything this move brings the WP close to the aforementioned agencies and thus more worthy of consideration.
- javier_e06 2y agoI am going nuclear on Bezos. I am cancelling Amazon Prime too. I had it with these technocrats and their ego-driven quest to rule the world.
- hintymad 2y agoSo is this so-called loyalty that is not absolute is absolutely no loyalty? Joke aside, I don't believe such rage is necessary. Do you still like the writing of WaPo? If you do, why not just continue the subscription? Heck, I still read WaPo even though I believe they are too biased towards the left and sometimes become hysterical and dishonest, as I still value their perspectives.
- jacobjjacob 2y agoIt leaves you wondering what other WaPo coverage is being edited by Bezos. Erodes trust in the publication. You can agree or disagree with the endorsement they were going to make, but the fact that the owner blocked them from making it means that they lack journalistic independence.
- rsynnott 2y agoTraditionally, quality broadsheets, even where owned by a person or company rather than a trust (the latter model is often preferred) have editorial independence. “Owner controls editorial policy” is more of a tabloid thing, so consumers looking for a quality broadsheet will likely go elsewhere.
- KevinMS 2y agoPaper was already losing tons of money a year. Maybe he's trying to make it more neutral for a larger customer base.
- gmoore 2y agoThe idea of balance is BS - it's a meme created to confuse people. What the media should provide is true and accurate information. Creating 'balance' doesn't do that. Sometimes there aren't two sides to a story.
- NoGravitas 2y agoAnyone who cares about journalistic integrity and an independent press should have dropped the Washington Post and the New York Times in 2003, when they helped the US government lie its way into the Iraq War. Anyone just dropping it now was already way too trusting.