11 ms·
Apple granted preliminary sales ban of Galaxy Nexus
- jellicle 14y ago>According to Judge Koh, “Apple has articulated a plausible theory of irreparable harm” in its argument against Samsung and the Galaxy Nexus, because of “long-term loss of market share” along with “losses of downstream sales.” This is not what "irreparable harm" used to mean. Apple's lawyers are celebrating tonight. EDIT: If I plan to kill a cat, and you file a lawsuit to stop me, the judge may issue an injunction for me not to kill the cat until the lawsuit is complete. Humanity does not know how to unkill a cat, so if I did so while the lawsuit was pending, I would make the lawsuit moot and evade justice. That is "irreparable harm", at least if it's your cat. On the other hand, if my actions are causing you mere monetary harm, we know exactly how to repair that: take money from me and give it to you. Injunctions should not be issued in such cases, because the plaintiff can always be made whole later on by simply receiving an appropriate amount of money. Apple has managed to have a bogus patent issued - the patent, as far as I can tell, covers any sort of "search-as-you-type" system. Any sort. The Firefox awesome bar, Android search (every Android device that exists), Google Instant, any webpage with javascript autocomplete... you're all violating Apple's patent. And if Apple can find judges as friendly as Ms. Koh, all of these products can be taken off the market indefinitely. And now they're grabbing up that stick and going to town with it.
- taligent 14y agoOf course it is. Apple can't get back lost sales and revenue as a result of patent infringement by their direct competitor.
- ars 14y agoOf course it isn't. It's easy to repair: Apple gets paid a fine. This is almost a classic example of repairable harm. The harm to Samsung is actually much worse (they are blocked, as opposed to just having to compete), yet the bond is supposed to make them whole.
- jellicle 14y agoYou don't know anything about the law, but you felt you had to chime in, huh? >Apple can't get back lost sales and revenue Unless Samsung was, you know, required to write them a check. For damages. If they lost. Which is how such cases usually proceed.
- taligent 14y agoSure. If you naively assume that lost sales/revenue is just for the iPhone device itself. But every lost sale of an iPhone is also one less person within the ecosystem. An ecosystem that plays off each of its elements to drive revenue e.g. iPhone user buys movies which they can only watch if they buy an AppleTV etc. It's borderline impossible to quantify all of the indirect revenue Apple would lose not just now but in the future.
- electrichead 14y agoFollowing from that logic, what about the harm that Apple is doing to the Android ecosystem by preventing the sale of these phones when they are supposed to be sold? If Apple can't prove what it claims, then what of the phones that are not sold in the meantime? Is that equivalent to the value of the bond? Where does that money go? Disclaimer: I am in no way a lawyer, but I think my familiarity with law is about the same as the familiarity of the judge with technology.
- smokinn 14y agoHow is it borderline impossible? There's a technique pretty much every company that knows what's it doing applies to figure out exactly what you mentioned and it's called downstream impact analysis. I'm absolutely 100% certain if you're an executive at Apple and you ask your finance department what the downstream impact is of an iPhone sale the finance department will come back with numbers for the profit variance when the customer wasn't already a customer, when they already were and a bunch of other scenarios.
- flatline3 14y agoI think it's unfortunate that taligent has been downvoted into the negatives, because he (or she) is correct. How much is market leadership worth? How big of a check would Apple have to write RIM to restore their market advantage? How big of a check would Apple have to write Nokia to put them back where they were in the marketplace 4 years ago? I'd argue that there is no check large enough to restore a lost market advantage. If Apple won their current market position through innovation, and Samsung is eroding it by taking advantage of that innovation counter to patent law, there's no reasonable amount Samsung could pay to set things to right.
- jvm 14y ago> I'd argue that there is no check large enough to restore a lost market advantage. I think you're considering the status or intangible satisfaction of being the market leader. That is not what Apple's shareholders are interested in. They are interested in money. If Apple had the choice between getting a check for all the money they would ever earn for all their products and liquidating the company, vs. remaining in business, they would close their doors, cash the check and pop the champagne. And that check would be worth much more than a "lost market advantage." Now they're probably not going to get such a check. But if not that's because the court will deem they don't deserve it. But the real reason they want this is that it will clearly do much more harm to Samsung than it will diminish their case against Samsung, better yet, they still get to bloody Samsung's nose even if the court eventually rules against them!
- flatline3 14y agoApple hasn't innovated into market leadership for status or intangible satisfaction. They've done it because that's what you have to do to keep those "big checks" rolling in. If Samsung gobbles up market share, a big check won't bring that back, and a check big enough to account for it would probably bankrupt Samsung (assuming you could ever calculate what that numer would be). Let's pretend that Samsung drove Apple out of business by rapidly copying Apple's R&D and competing directly on price. Just how big of a check would be required to set things to right? We can use an analogy instead of hypotheticals. Imagine I've stockpiled grain for the winter. Winter has arrived, and suddenly, so does the army. They commandeer my grain and promise to write a check for its market value. The next spring, I get the check in the mail. Unfortunately for me, my family already starved.
- mythz 14y agoIt is irreparable harm considering they can't get back the monopoly/leading market-share effect at this very young stage of the tablet market. i.e. Sales and profits now is a lot more important than Sales and Money later.
- dguaraglia 14y agoYeah, but AFAIK this economic model (and the Constitution) was supposed to work by trying to break monopolies, not encouraging them.
- Tloewald 14y agoYou do realize that a patent is a deliberately created, temporary monopoly.
- dguaraglia 14y agoYes, and that's why I think (most) software patents are a crock of shit, same as most design patents. The very idea that someone can get a patent something like 'a tablet with a metal casing and rounded corners' is revolting. But then, the whole patent system has been fucked up for umpteen years because of the way lawyers lay out the legalese on most patents. Something as specific as a new protocol to transfer data (say, SPDY) can be massaged into being a vague generic definition ("a binary transmission method designed to make HTTP-like data structures and operations possible in a more efficient manner") that could cover a lot of ground, giving the owner of the patent the power to halt innovation (ZeroMQ could very well fall under the umbrella defined of such 'patent') while giving exactly 0 benefit to anyone. I'm just waiting for someone cheeky enough to come up with a vague wording for describing a 'wooden and/or plastic object designed with the purpose of holding items and or facilitating common household tasks' (i.e. a piece of furniture) and sue IKEA.
- JoeCortopassi 14y agoWhere would Google be without the PageRank patent to give them a monopoly on search? Don't think many people have an issue with that.
- JabavuAdams 14y ago> Apple has managed to have a bogus patent issued - the patent, as far as I can tell, covers any sort of "search-as-you-type" system Is this from reading the claims, or from reading the introduction (whatever that's called)?
- jmduke 14y agoThe patent in question: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=8086604.PN.&OS=PN/8086604&RS=PN/8086604 http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec... I'm bad at legalese, but it seems to pertain to search-as-you-type amongst multiple libraries (songs, texts, emails, etc.)
- dguaraglia 14y agoSo, basically what Launchy, Spotlight, Android's 'search' toolbar, even Google's homepage, have been doing for a decade now. Nice.
- Tloewald 14y agoIf you are correct, then Apple obtained this patent before any of these things you mentioned existed. I'd mention On Location as prior art though -- On Location was truly awesome.
- chacham15 14y agoYour exact claim has been taken into account, just the opposite direction: "Apple was ordered to post a bond of $95 million to enact the injunction, which would be used to pay Samsung damages if the decision is later reversed."
- jvm 14y agoOh wow, interesting! Although of course if this really has such a definable cash value, why can't that just be part of the award if Samsung loses?
- saurik 14y agoDamages are not symmetric: the damage to Samsung of a prophylactic injunction might be comfortably converted to a dollar value, while those to Apple might still be "irreparable".
- ars 14y agoI'm starting to hate Apple more and more. Apple: Are your products so terrible that you have to force people to buy them by preventing any other competition? I think it may be time for high profile developers to boycott Apple till they stop acting like this.
- jtsai256 14y agoWhile I share a similar sentiment of disliking Apple's litigious nature as of late, can you really blame the company for attempting to protect its intellectual property?
- gatlin 14y agoYes. It has the choice not to (ab)use the law in this fashion and yet it does. Assuming free will - which is the only sane assumption to keep this conversation focused and tractable - then yes. I can blame them for their own actions.
- taligent 14y agoSo boycott Apple and do what. Jump over to Android ? Would that be the same Android platform that has the main OEMs (Samsung, HTC, Google) under FTC/EU investigation for anti competitive behaviour due to FRAND abuses. Abuses which undermine the entire foundation of key IT/CE standards. The fact is that nobody's hands are clean. It's a bloody mess that is only going to get worse.
- 14y ago
- aristidb 14y agoSo this actually _is_ about software patents this time, and clearly anti-innovation. I dare anybody to argue that the patent system as it is does not hinder innovation in software.
- rbanffy 14y agoI don't think it's a software patent problem. But it is a ridiculous patent problem. Who could consider checking two databases is a significant innovation over consulting one.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- MattLaroche 14y agoThe Galaxy Nexus is stock Android. Apple is suing Samsung because of stock Android software - not firmware, not hardware, but software. Is there a legal reason Apple is suing Samsung instead of Google, or is it tactical / political?
- azakai 14y agoBecause Samsung is shipping a device with the software. Parent law does require that the patent be tied to a physical device. IANAL.
- jrockway 14y agoIndeed. Source code is speech, and speech cannot infringe patents. (Not saying this is logical, that's just what the case law says.) That's why you can build an mp3 player from source without paying the license fee, but Debian can't ship you a compiled mp3 player.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoSo if shipping source only is perfectly legal, what's to stop OEMs from simply shipping infringing components as source only and compiling on first boot? Strictly speaking, the user initiated the compile (by powering on the device), so Samsung would be in the clear. Technically legal, but I have the feeling this wouldn't survive court.
- chimeracoder 14y ago> Indeed. Source code is speech, and speech cannot infringe patents. (Not saying this is logical, that's just what the case law says.) Are you sure about this? So I could write any patent-infringing code I want, distribute source-only (or even write it in a purely interpreted language) and then nobody can complain that I've violated any of their patents?
- Calamitous 14y agoThose who can compete, do. Those who can't litigate.
- praxulus 14y agoGiven their profitability, Apple is just doing both.
- redthrowaway 14y agoI guess not every judge can be an Alsup.
- noonespecial 14y agoKoh was a patent litigator before becoming a judge, Alsup is a mathematician who served as a special counsel in the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice. Her bias is showing. How embarrassing.
- tikhonj 14y agoThis is particularly sad because the Galaxy Nexus is a brilliant phone running stock Android. I've found the stock Android ICS experience to be much better than what you can find with a version of Android modified by the vendor (at least for the other phones I've seen). I'm pretty sure it's one of the best options for Android phones, period.
- karolist 14y agoWhat other options have you tried? My experience with stock ICS (AOSP based ROMs) are terrible, the GUI is unintuitive, simplistic to the point of being ugly and rather limited in functionality as opposed to older versions of MIUI (not based on ICS). Sense is not only ugly, but slow too, I have not tried touchwiz to comment on that.
- saket123 14y agoThis is a sad news. One that feels me with disdain. The conceptual patent thing is such a farce. Didn't google just reduce the price of this phone to $349. I am pretty sure it was not due to lack of demand. The phone is beautiful, feels different then previous versions of Android and looks different then Apple's iPhone. The judge involved here is the same judge who did the same thing to Galaxy Tab (which sucked anyway). But doing this to such a good phone which could have brought smartphone to life of millions of people is shameful. Its not the intellectual property , its a anti-competitive move.
- kenster07 14y agoApple is implicitly admitting Samsung is a huge threat to them. Apple has intelligent people making these decisions. So they know in their heart of hearts that the patents they hold are overly broad to the point of bogusness. They know that the majority of the tech market is also intelligent enough to come to this same realization. They have an awareness that lawsuits exercising these quasi-bogus patents will have a negative impact on Apple's public image. Therefore, the only logical reason for going through with the lawsuits is because they have concluded that the alternative -- letting Samsung + Google have their way in the mobile market -- would be far more damaging to Apple. Apple's interests aside, is this good for society at large? Doubtful.
- jpxxx 14y agoNope. But it's a great deal of (nasty) fun watching a former hundred pound weakling pulverizing three gorillas at once in the ring.
- creamyhorror 14y agoWhen Apple was a weakling, it wasn't even in competition with Samsung, and Google didn't exist. It's not fun, imo, watching a gorilla (one might say the biggest one) pulverizing three others.
- jpxxx 14y agoThe -4 on my post argues you're right. :) But nonetheless, I'm popcorn.giffing over this whole kerfuffle. Apple has descended into hell, rose again from the dead, ascended into marketshare heaven, and is seated at the right hand of Oracle the Litigant almighty. From there it will judge the clone and the KIRF. I believe in the Holy Mothership, the holy Apple Store, the communion of Genii, the forgiveness of GSODs, the resurrection of the product cycle, and maddeningly ill-thought-out and sporadic iLife updates everlasting. Amen.
- enraged_camel 14y agoIt's more like Samsung explicitly admitting that they cannot find a way to unlock a phone without the swipe gesture.
- chj 14y agoWhat A Patent Hell. FYI: The patents held against Android: 1. A means of detecting and marking up data like a phone number or an e-mail address, and then initiating a phone call or an e-mail when the linked data is clicked 2. A means of searching multiple databases and sources for data. 3. A slide to unlock feature. 4. An autocorrect-type function that completes the word as a user types and allows the user to accept or reject the word. This must be a joke!
- slavak 14y agoSeems like the reason the US patent system is so fucked-up is the logical disconnect between the two following concepts: * The USPTO approves most patents applications without the most cursory examination by a qualified person. * Patents granted by the USPTO are assumed to be valid unless overturned by a court of law. You can't have it both ways and still expect a logical result. And seriously, how the hell did #4 up there even get approved? Did the examiner rubber-stamping that mess seriously never in his entire life use Microsoft Word?
- Symmetry 14y agoAs to (4), patent attorneys earn the big bucks for writing the patents in as obfuscated a manner as possible. That lets them get the patent past the Patent Office by saying "Look how very narrow our patent is" and its granted on those grounds, but when they go to sue other companies they choose an interpretation that amounts to the text in the grandparent, so that they can sue the maximum number of people.
- epo 14y agoThat is not the wording of the patents so your post is nonsense.
- saket123 14y agoDo anyone here thinks that it will lead to rise in sales of Galaxy Nexus for remaining stock and it will sell very very quickly. Couple of my friends are already ordering one. If this patent battle turns out to be farce for Apple, this could be lightning in dark clouds.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ericdykstra 14y agoDoes this kind of thing make anyone happy? Does anyone feel better about Apple the company because of this? It would be nice if supposedly innovative companies could, you know, just keep innovating instead of worrying about copycats catching up on stale technology (in this case, I don't think it's even clear that there is any sort of copycat-like activity). Apple makes a few excellent products, but this kind of thing lowers my impression of the brand overall.
- rorrr 14y agoIt makes Apple happy. But fuck them. I will not spend a dime on their products anymore (iPod/iPhone 3/Iphone 4 owner).
- juliano_q 14y agoI agree with you and I am feeling a little guilty for just having received my new Macbook Pro (had an old macbook white previously). I am just not being happy buying their products anymore in consequence of their actions. I am using Android phones for a few years and it just feels right to me, I think it is because my views are much more aligned with Google.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoWhat if you are the innovative company and somebody is coming along and stealing every innovation you put in front of the market? Since they are one step behind, they don't have to spend money on the innovations that fail, thereby having much lower costs than you do? This is much more complicated than "Dude, Apple are such duches. They can't think of anything new so they just sue everybody." IP protection in the US (and world, thanks to treaties) is seriously messed up. Apple is aggressive, but it is naïve to think any large company wouldn't be (and small companies need to recognize that!).
- 14y ago
- cromwellian 14y agoBoy, they are getting a lot of mileage out of that regular expression "data tapping" patent, even though people were doing the same thing years before, including a NeXTStep app released with source and published on USENET in 1995 1 year before the Apple patent was filed https://groups.google.com/group/comp.archives/browse_thread/thread/40eec7c07815ae25/68b1e859b82d3a3e https://groups.google.com/group/comp.archives/browse_thread/...
- SoapSeller 14y agoIBM Simon(1993/4) also had the same functionality[0]. Also, it seems that their main patent(8,086,604[1]) for this case describe a metasearch engine, something that have been around at least since the mid 90s(long before the patent was filled in 2004). [0] http://youtu.be/wnFsJ9z_caY?t=1m57s http://youtu.be/wnFsJ9z_caY?t=1m57s (warning: terrible video quality ahead) [1] http://goo.gl/jjG1P http://goo.gl/jjG1P
- bishnu 14y agoIs this kind of stuff not brought up in court? How can you possibly patent something that already existed?
- vibrunazo 14y agoIANAL, but as far as I my very limited understanding goes. Prior art isn't verified when a patent application is applied. Only after that, when someone files a suit trying to invalidate the patent. Which is a separate case from the injunction. So Samsung would have to file a separate suit to invalidate the patents. If then win that, then and only then, they'll be able to stop the injunction by saying Apple patents are invalid. Which of course, would cost Samsung a lot of money and time. So you can file any bogus patent, the USPTO won't verify. They'll only check if all the paperwork is in order. It will only matter if your patents are bogus if someone tries to invalidate it. Or am I talking crap? Please correct me where I'm wrong, I'd love to learn more.
- 14y ago
- LVB 14y agoI really wish I hadn't read this just as I start the weekend. I've been irreparably harmed by the high blood pressure it has caused within me.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- guelo 14y agoJudge Koh was a Silicon Valley patent litigator from 2000-2008 before being appointed a judge. Makes me wonder what companies she represented.
- jusben1369 14y agoRather than cast aspersions on her credibility I think this actually bolsters it to learn this. At least she has deep expertise in a (very flawed) system.
- epo 14y agoThis pathetic innuendo is typical of so much of contemporary American debate. If you have something to say, say it. This "makes me wonder" style is just a gutless, moronic attempt at mud slinging.
- gcb 14y agoHope you felt good upvoting all those articles stating how ridiculous patent law is FROM YOUR DAMN APPLE DEVICES Time to vote with your wallet is way overdue. And while you're at it may think about the Sony stuff you own.
- tikhonj 14y agoSony may be evil, but they're much less insidious than Apple. Why? Simple: Apple is, whether we like it or not, popular. Sony isn't. The real problem is not just Apple's behavior, but also how many people like them despite their behavior. Of course, I won't claim any moral superiority here. While I don't have any Apple devices, it's not because of moral reasons but simply because I am genuinely unimpressed with their efforts. Overrated, over-hyped and fashionable, but never practical or optimal.
- gonzo 14y agoA bit over 15 years ago, Sony was extremely popular.
- entropy_ 14y agoWell, I'm reading this from my GNex :-)
- rimantas 14y ago> Time to vote with your wallet is way overdue. Damn right! So I will never buy anything from that court again. And from USPTO for that matter. And from US legislators. As for Apple—I enjoy using their products and I enjoy developing for iOS. As for Google—as I get older I start to hate ads more and more. I want to pay myself for the products I buy and use. A little more privacy is a nice side effect of that. So yep, I will vote with my wallet.
- gcb 14y agoThat's a bit extreme, but totally fine. And will save you a lot since i know Apple pays well thanks to their hold on some markets. Lots of people refuse to pay taxes for similar reasons. just don't do it before trying other methods, like writing to your representatives and all that.
- rogerchucker 14y agoCan Google not sue to invalidate that "Siri" patent because of prior art? I thought this kind of unified search existed back in the days of Google Desktop...
- dguaraglia 14y agoBack in the day of Copernicus if you want to go far enough (lol, I wonder how many people would actually get that reference... it was an old program that'd search for your terms in a bunch of search engines and display the results in a unified interface)
- ddlatham 14y agoMake no mistake - all the major smartphones out there are infringing someone else's patent. If this is the precedent, next thing we'll have iPhones banned for infringing on Motorola, and Windows Phones banned for infringing on RIM patents. This is bad news for consumers, bad news for innovators. Everyone loses.
- bstar77 14y agoI support your comment, but the lawyers are making a killing.
- Tloewald 14y agoInfringing on patents pooled to create standards is different (viz Motorola). your patent goes into the standard in exchange for your agreeing to make it available for a reasonable price. This is obviously a Good Thing or standards would not be created or adopted. Similarly, the price of simpy ditching patents would be the proliferation of trade secrets and obfuscated mechanisms.
- bstar77 14y agoI got annoyed when this happened to HTC, but Samsung is a different story. Their entire business model is based on dumpster diving at 1 infinity loop. I agree that these patents look silly on their own, but when you add them all up you see a concerted effort to copy apples products, and in some cases deceive the ignorant.
- ThePherocity 14y agoThere is no abuse of the law, there is law, and there is not law. Using the law is not an abuse, regardless of what it may seem from the cheap seats where we are all sitting. If you don't like it, fix the laws.
- gergles 14y agoThe law is intended, in the Constitution, to 'promote the progress of [technology]'. Using the patent system to browbeat your competitors out of business by wielding bullshit imaginary software patents does not promote the progress of anything but Apple's business. Therefore, it is clearly an abuse of the law.
- rimantas 14y agoWell, fix the courts then. They should make sure laws are applied as intendend, shouldn't they?
- slavak 14y agoThere is most definitely such a thing as abuse of the law. The law should be followed in spirit, not only in letter. The courts often underscore this, but unfortunately by that point it's already too late, as the abuse has been done.
- ThePherocity 14y agoCan you refer me to the amendment that states that law should be followed in spirit? Just curious, cause I don't recall seeing it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- zmmmmm 14y agoThis seems to be based on the most bogus of Apple's patents - things like "slide to unlock" (something used on physical door's for hundreds of years, moving it to pixels doesn't suddenly make it inventive) and auto-converting data to links (well documented back into the 90's. It's a shame that the places where Apple really moved forward are not where they are exploiting their patents. It seems, those ideas were already beyond Apple's ability to patent, so instead they got a bunch of bogus stuff through and are using it anyway. It really besmirches their actual amazing record of inventiveness that they take rubbish like this forward. I hope these all get overturned.
- methodin 14y agoThis actually got me wondering if Google has ever sued someone in the same manner and it does not appear as if they have. I find that very interesting - does anyone have any links to the contrary?
- evmar 14y agoGoogle (like many tech companies, I think?) promises their employees that patents will only be used defensively. The only related example is that Motorola Mobility recently began a patent suit against Microsoft and then Google acquired them (in that order) so it's unclear whether that promise applies.
- roguecoder 14y agoHow have we not abolished patents yet? This is ridiculous, and everyone appears to know it except that judge.
- bryans 14y agoThis is starting to read like a Rod Serling original.
- JabavuAdams 14y agoSlightly unrelated question: where does this "make you whole" language come from? It seems to be cropping up more and more recently, but I hadn't heard it before about 2 years ago. Perhaps it's a term of art that I just didn't know about? It's a bizarre and clumsy piece of corporate-speak. Money can't make one whole. It could set things right, though.
- gergles 14y agoIt's a legal term of art. Search around for the "make-whole doctrine".
- creamyhorror 14y agoI am absolutely going to persuade my mother to switch to an Android in a few months' time. And then recommend it to every friend of mine who's upgrading their phone, mentioning in passing that Apple has actually gotten Galaxy Nexuses and Tabs blocked in the US. I'm glad Android is actually good enough at this stage for me to do this. The '604 search patent is a big hot mess of ideas thrown together to cover all sorts of "maybe-this-maybe-that" use cases and potential improvements. It basically means having a unified search system that relies upon "search heuristics" for multiple domains. Like the other allegedly infringing patents in the case, it's another broken patent that IMO shouldn't have been granted. Does anyone know of prior art (prior to Dec '04) for a search mechanism that obtains search results from multiple domains using sub-plugins and combines them into a list? That seems to be the core of the idea, and further ideas are thrown on top of it in the patent application thereafter. Read it yourself at http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=8086604.PN.&OS=PN/8086604&RS=PN/8086604 http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec...
- pbz 14y agoThere used to be plenty of search sites that were querying multiple search engines and showing a combined result set.
- ralfd 14y agoWell, in the mobile space everyone is suing everyone else. Google is using Motorola for that and are banning in Germany important parts of Apples e-mail and iCloud services. http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/04/german-court-extends-push-e-mail-injunction-against-icloud-mobileme/ http://arstechnica.com/apple/2012/04/german-court-extends-pu... Because of that and as a German I wont ever buy Android and also telling my friends.
- cskau 14y ago> [..] in the mobile space everyone is suing everyone else. [..] > Because of that and as a German I wont ever buy Android and also telling my friends. So you won't ever buy anything ever again? As you say yourself it's the whole industry that is playing this game, so it seems unfair to take it out on just one company. Biased much?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jQueryIsAwesome 14y agoMaybe if a big enough amount of people gave them some bad PR they would stop doing this monopolistic and unethical actions. I propose to make #AppleIsAnUglyTroll a trend on Twitter (for the masses "Ugly Troll" is more appealing than "Patent Troll")
- oemera 14y agoYou are all way to biased about the whole thing. Thing about it. They just freaking copied Siri. Would you feel cool if someone else just copies your innovative product feature. Apple has all right to sue them and get them blocked. You can hate my comment. You can down vote me. You can hate Apple as much as you like but all of you know before there was iPhone and iPad there was nothing close to any of it. So how can anyone say all other companies aren't copying? Eric Schmidt just stole every inch of the iPhone...
- pook1e 14y ago> They just freaking copied Siri. This article is about the Samsung Galaxy Nexus, which doesn't have any integrated voice assistant as far as I am aware. > Eric Schmidt just stole every inch of the iPhone... While it may be true that Android has "stolen" certain things from the iPhone, there are also plenty of things that the iPhone has also "stolen" from Android. Saying Android copies everything that Apple does while Apple continues to build everything from the ground up is completely unfair.
- oemera 14y agoAFAIK you would voice assistant in Android 4.1 which is damn similar what Apple introduced with Siri. I really can't understand how some people can just ignore the fact that there happens a big stolen product here. How on earth will you argue that Google has now a similar voice assistant like Siri without copying Siri. You don't want to say it is coincendence, do you? People always claim Apple had stolen from Android too but they never can give any evidence. What did Apple copy from Android which become a major selling factor? Copy paste? No. Multi touch? No. Multitasking? No. App Store? Hello no! Please just tell me how entrepreneurs all seem to hate Apple because Apple just fighting for there right. The right to say: Hey if you want to make a product, but don't just copy our product! Apple didn't sued Microsoft over WP7 cause they didn't just copy The iPhone. They found something new. Something different. But Android And Google just trying to copy the hell of iOS as much as possible. EDIT: This has nothing to do with being a die-hard Apple guy. Everyone should have the right to fight copy cats. Or would like it that your product is getting copied and you as a the creator earn just nothing from it at all. Not even the respect that it was your idea and your product.
- arpit 14y agoFor the last couple of years I have been trying to stay objective about this (I actually do quite a bit of iOS programming in my day job in addition to Android) and have always tried to be more pro-android than anti-Apple, but I am finally done trying to walk the fence. Enough of this bullshit. Its time for consumers to be aware that every time they buy an Apple product, they are damaging the software industry and the spirit of innovation. Its like buying blood diamonds. Sure they are pretty but the cost isnt worth it. My question: Is there a central point for sending out this message? I would love to see someone setup a messaging page like "Say No to Apple" or something like that that I can link to. Some activity the level of the SOPA blackouts would be awesome (though probably not realistic, but hey, I can dream), with JavaScript popups for idevices etc.What about things like Twitter badges or sidebar widgets that we can install on our blogs, profile pages etc? I think the normal folks (consumers) don't get how bad this is.
- prodigal_erik 14y agoFor all that time, Apple's iOS strategy has been reducing developers to sharecroppers and selling deliberately crippled appliances instead of human-worthy tools. The average consumer is fine with that; there isn't even a majority of hackers here somewhat troubled like you were. So why would this suddenly be objectionable to them?
- moultano 14y agoWhen you work for a company that does this, you owe it to your integrity to resign. The government is too incompetent to fix this mess, and market pressure isn't going to do it either. That leaves us, the actual engineers. It's our job to tell the companies we work for that litigating instead of competing isn't acceptable.
- rogerchucker 14y agoWhen will Anonymous take down Apple?
- hastur 14y agoI will never buy an Apple product again. Their tactics are pathetic.
- kombine 14y agoEspecially sad considering how people in the tech industry use and promote Apple products. Sadly, I'm a user of MBP too. All of the "hackers" these days use Mac laptops to write in Javascript/Ruby/other_todays_hyped_language. All to satisfy the consumeristic needs of population. And frankly you can't do much with the platform anyway - Apple disallows JIT and other low level stuff on iOS. They move towards the same restrictions on MacOS X, starting with Mac App Store Apps. I wouldn't be surprised if in few years they disallow installing apps not through the app store. Fuck you, Apple! Your soul interest is to make more and more cash.
- beedogs 14y agoIf Apple keeps pissing off all the vendors it needs to work with, pretty soon they'll have to start fabbing their own fucking chips for their phones. This is getting out of hand. And I'm blaming Apple for most of the lunacy.
- Tichy 14y agoSounds like they managed to get a patent on machine learning 101. I am sorry, but stuff like that just makes me despise Apple. Maybe the greater public will eventually catch on, too.
- rosejn 14y agoApple Corp. sucks as a member of society. As one of the wealthiest and most successful companies on earth they continue to play dirty by abusing the patent system for their advantage. Most of the patents they are "protecting" are describing pretty obvious ideas that any group of good engineers working on this class of devices would bump into, and this behavior does not benefit society in any way. They are clearly protecting a virtual monopoly on tablets by fighting with patents rather than focusing on out innovating the competition. I hope their will one day be real competition in this space.
- mdkess 14y agoWhat is the effect of this ruling, if it is upheld? Will Samsung have to disable this functionality? I imagine that they are not doing that immediately because that seems like an admission of guilt. Will they be able to ship their devices without software and have users install the software in question?
- DenisM 14y agoOk, so I just went ahead and ordered a Galaxy Nexus phone. I've been meaning to do this for a while now to see if I want to port my apps to the Android platform, and here Apple just pushed me to do it. :/
- DenisM 14y agoGalaxy Nexus is a direct competitor to the iPhone, and Galaxy Tab 10.1 is a direct competitor to the iPad. Now, if Apple goes after Nexus 7, we will know that they are planning a 7" iPad-mini.
- josteink 14y agoApple has clearly lost it. Whatever once made them cool and different is long gone and all that remains is a pseudo-legalese ganster, using its giant pool of money to hinder software development at the cost of everyone else. You cannot be a software-developer and support this monster with your money. As a software developer there should be no way you can support this. Apple is the SCO of this decade.
- mharmon14 14y agoIrreparable harm seems to imply that this could hurt Apple in a major way. But it's easy to see what game-changing technology is. Look at what people want in a phone: http://mashable.com/2011/10/03/iphone-5-wish-list-starts-with-4g-and-bigger-screen/ http://mashable.com/2011/10/03/iphone-5-wish-list-starts-wit... There's tens of similar surveys published online. None of them include "search-as-u-go". In fact Apple doesn't seem to think that it's that big enough of a deal to promote. They advertise tens of features & this isn't one of them. And that's because it's expected (everyone uses it already) or it's not that important to a buyer when choosing a phone to purchase. It's just not reasonable to assume that the "search-as-u-go" technology could give any sort of significant advantage to Samsung to be the cause of a shift in market share or something with similarly unascertainable consequences, which is precisely what the ruling of irreparable damage relies on.
- dobalina 14y agoI picked up my new Galaxy Nexus (phone) today. Loving it so far! Decided to go with the Nexus over the S3. Better price/performance ratio, and of course better support from Google on the pure Android experience. :)