7 ms·
How to delete your 23andMe data amid the company's turmoil
- more_corn 2y agoAs a California company the data is subject to the CCPA. You can download your data but more importantly you can request they delete it. I highly recommend that everyone do so. I can think of no more sensitive biometric data than your dna.
- tombert 2y ago> I can think of no more sensitive biometric data than your dna. I dunno, is that actually true? You leave DNA everywhere don't you? If someone really wanted tombert's DNA, they'd just have to follow me onto the train and swab the poll I'm grabbing, or grab the cup I was sipping on at McDonald's, or any number of things that could lead to a number of cells containing my DNA in a state that could be collected being dropped.
- adamc 2y agoIf they know who you are, it's easy. If all they have is the DNA, that database will link it to you. They have caught several serial killers because close relatives were in DNA databases, which allowed honing in on a small number of living suspects.
- groby_b 2y agoYou do realize there's a difference between obsessing about tombert (or groby) vs hoovering up DNA at scale, right? Your insurance company probably won't follow you around personally, but if they can buy a bunch of DNA (yours included) for a few dollars/person and use that to strategically deny claims/increase costs, yeah, they'll sign up for that. The issue with digital data is almost never the individual targeting case. Cheap mass surveillance is the concern.
- newdee 2y agoHardly the same. Your day to day DNA “leavings” aren’t neatly packaged up and associated with your other PII like name, location, email address, etc in a stolen, searchable dataset.
- AyyEye 2y agoFollowing you probably costs more per hour than buying a whole country's DNA from a broker. And definitely costs more than a leaked dataset.
- whalesalad 2y agoI feel like that ship has sailed. Every software company I have ever worked for is dysfunctional in this regard. You might think your "delete my data" request succeeded but there is absolutely zero way to guarantee that it actually did, and chances are it didn't.
- bluetidepro 2y ago100% this. It's laughable if you believe those requests work as expected. Sure they may "delete" some surface level bs like your account or login, but there is no way it's 100% scrubbed in the way it's supposed to work.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoA lot of recourse is around intent and liability. I would like to believe my request is honored; in the event it is later proved to not have been honored, recourse is potentially available through legal and regulatory mechanisms. 23andme didn't implement strong customer identity and auth mechanisms, for example, and it cost them ~$30M to settle their data breach liability [1]. Take action, keep receipts, and failing good faith actions, step back while regulators and the legal system whack whack whack with a hammer. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41536494 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41536494 ("HN: 23andMe settles data breach lawsuit for $30M")
- bluetidepro 2y agoOh nice, "~$30M to settle." That <$100 you get back in the class action will be amazing compensation. Sadly the legal route is a joke at this point.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bluetidepro 2y ago> I'm happy if it contributes to the death of the org. But the not the death of your data. That will be sold onto someone else.
- kanzure 2y agoI don't think I have ever seen a correctly implemented data deletion request system that worked well with the company's backups. If it's backed up, it's likely not getting deleted.
- kccqzy 2y agoI have seen plenty. The key is to take frequent backups and aggressively delete older backups once you know you won't be restoring from that backup. Also, don't appropriate backups to do other things, such as audit logs.
- ethbr1 2y agoOne instance where I am disappointed to be vindicated. Considered doing 23andMe at the hype peak, discovered they had avoided HIPAA requirements, read through their privacy policy, and marked them off the possibility list. It was pretty clear the delta between sequencing costs and price they were charging consumers equaled how much they thought they could make from your genetic information. And because they don't fall under HIPAA, your data is theirs after they get it. PS: Sequencing costs were also falling rapidly, so it isn't that expensive to get it done.
- outworlder 2y agoThey do not do DNA sequencing. They do genotyping. It's far less detailed.
- ethbr1 2y agoThat too. And at full sequencing for <$1000 now, why not just pay for the whole shebang? It's not like someone is doing it monthly.
- j-bos 2y agoDo you know where one can get sequencing done at a HIPAA regulated provider?
- burningChrome 2y agoI would talk to your primary care person, they should know. I've had two members of my family die of ALS and was wondering what my odds are of getting it. One of the steps could be a full DNA sequence. In order to get to that step however, you have to do about six months of counseling, and several blood tests before they do the full DNA sequence. The counseling is to prepare yourself for the possibility of them essentially giving you a death sentence with the blood and DNA results. I never got that far. My father convinced me its better not to know and live your life accordingly, rather than trying to live a life always looking over your shoulder. But my primary did have the information on how I could get it done, so I would start there.
- Jerry2 2y agoThe (consumer) company I used to work for also allowed their customers to "delete" their data. Deletion was implemented as a boolean filed in the database "deleted - true/false'. We called it "soft deletion". And why was it implemented like this? It's because actually deleting data is hard. There is no single database and the data is distributed across many servers. It's also backed up in different places. Running the delete operation can be extremely costly and can also create service interruptions and data integrity issues. I think there was a script that was supposed to actually delete the entries but it was not run very often and was there for legal and compliance issues. Just remember that when you request to delete some data on the internet, it doesn't actually get deleted (right away anyway). The best way to deal with this is not to give random sites your real information in the first place. However, that can be difficult or impossible when dealing with government, financial institutions or shopping sites. Edit: And just to address questions below, the actual delete script was not run daily. I don't know how often it was run (I was not an SRE) but I presume it was run at least once a month. I have no idea how other companies do this.
- williamdclt 2y agoLet’s be clear that what you describe is absolutely not gdpr compliant, so it would be illegal if you do business in Europe
- tantalor 2y agoDid you read the whole comment? They say there was a batch script to comply with legal requirements.
- itake 2y ago> but that was not run very often GDPR has strict rules about how long data can persist after the deletion request is made.
- tantalor 2y agoWho knows what "not very often" means. It could mean once a day or once a year. The point is that this could be made to be compliant with little extra effort, so pointing out "um actually it's not compliant" is not saying much.
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoWhen you ask a company to delete your data, you're actually asking them to pretend they deleted it by making it invisible to you. There's too much $$$ sloshing around for them to behave ethically.
- excalibur 2y agoWhat, you mean sending your DNA to a random startup to have them analyze it for you was a BAD idea? #surprisedpikachu
- criddell 2y agoWhy was it a BAD idea? What negative consequences have people faced so far? If they've also benefited from the service, how are they supposed to judge if it was a mistake or not?
- excalibur 2y agoOf course it was a mistake. That data will 100% be compromised, if it hasn't been already. If there's a way for it to be used against them it will be found.
- yoavm 2y agoHow will it be used against them? What's so secret about my DNA, considering I leave traces of it everywhere I go?
- programjames 2y agoObviously health insurance costs may go up, or on a national scale one country could target a virus for it's enemy's population. Also, your rhetorical question is a red herring. It isn't about secrecy it's about privacy.
- yoavm 2y agoIf we don't want insurance prices to be tied to customers' health condition, let's make a law against that. I don't know how it is in the US, but I wouldn't be surprised if they're already using the results of bloods tests etc for pricing? Creating a virus to target another country sounds like sci-fi at the best case, or a conspiracy theory[0] at the worst case. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine_bioweapons_conspiracy_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine_bioweapons_conspiracy_...
- FloatArtifact 2y agoThey might delete it from their database, but it doesn't change the fact that it's been sold and shared in a way we can't also follow up and remove that information. There's no transparency. It not only implicates you, but your relations and future generations. Genetic testing done through the hospital for a completely unrelated procedure can impact your life insurance. ( Example genetic testing for a child) Minnesota State Law prevents health insurance from changing. Laws need to protect right to know, not just right to use genetic information.
- resters 2y agoI tried to download my raw data recently and it took days. Seems like a lot of customers are trying to download it and cancel after the turmoil. I think 23andme has always been held hostage by its scientists who have stopped it from offering a lot of entertaining information about health related studies that are not considered methodologically sound enough to constitute health advice. Why not just add a "speculative or insufficiently replicated / peer-reviewed" section and let us have fun with our data!
- AStonesThrow 2y agoI tell ya, it's a great party conversation that begins with "Hey, I'm a Libra, 3% Neanderthal, and I share a haplogroup with Genghis Khan! Let's go out for some tacos with extra cilantro, and a dark chocolate churro!"
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoIsn't it because there aren't ways around US laws regarding giving medical advice? That's my understanding why the places that do it are outside the US.
- iwontberude 2y agoHonestly it doesn't even matter. There is no proof the DNA is yours because they do no validation of users identity.
- bdamm 2y agoSpeculative results with statistical likelihood are still highly valuable to the right buyers.
- SoftTalker 2y agoPeople are convicted all the time without any "proof" of guilt. It all goes to "beyond a reasonable doubt" and with enough circumstantial evidence, that "beyond" can be achieved.
- iwontberude 2y agoRight, it will still need to be corroborated with some other hard evidence like DNA from a close relative.
- filchermcurr 2y agoI lied about my birth date and apparently there's no way to delete your data without the fake date or a photo ID... with the fake birth date... sigh
- j-bos 2y agoThanks, I want to get my genes sequenced but I'd also like to get my records deleted from the service provider. I guess it'l have to be real name?
- bee_rider 2y agoHave you tried emailing them a bit? It is worth a shot I think: you made a typo (people make them all the time), but you don’t really need to fully authenticate, because you are just making a deletion request anyway (not trying to access the data). (Also keep in mind, customer service people have to argue with assholes all day long, staying polite but clear but on-target can go a long way. Stick to the topic and never give them an excuse to cut off communication).
- filchermcurr 2y agoYep. That's how I learned that I need the photo ID with the original date of birth. My last e-mail was asking if there is any other way to delete the account but so far I haven't heard anything.
- xelamonster 2y agoI think the GP was suggesting, and imo it's a good idea, that you should first ask them to update your birth date saying you entered it incorrectly. Then you can request deletion again and your ID should be accepted.
- filchermcurr 2y agoThat was how I initially approached them. I told them I made a mistake with my birth date and asked if there was any way to correct it. They asked me to send a photo ID with my name and birth date, which I assumed was to replace the old date. I then realized they meant the ID had to have the fake date and we went 'round and 'round (and 'round) on that until I gave up on them understanding what I actually wanted to do. Now I'm trying the more direct 'Please help me delete the account.' approach. I'm not hopeful, but you never know!
- outworlder 2y agoNote that even if they delete the data, if you have close relatives that submitted their samples a company can still infer quite a lot from that.
- renewiltord 2y agoDon't know why you'd bother. I, and my friends, and soon my family are in All of Us. We'll be in every genomics dataset you want.
- roughly 2y agoI’m in a weird spot with 23andMe - when I signed up, I used a fake name as a fig leaf in case they decided to sell to insurance or whatever. Since then, several members of my immediate family have all signed up, so “the child of X and the sibling of Y” means that fig leaf is pretty useless now - except I can’t issue an actual CCPA now, because fake name. All of this is super predictable, but I wasn’t nearly cynical enough 15 years ago when I mailed my spit to them.
- bee_rider 2y agoI wonder if you can convince them through the customer service portal? People make typos all the time…
- junon 2y agoDoubt it. I assume they're under HIPAA regulations and it'd be a massive cost if they did it even once.
- bee_rider 2y agoThere’s no HIPAA concern if you just want to delete your info, I think.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoI don't know enough about HIPAA to know if it would be a violation for them to delete my data upon your request but, assuming it is, that would be a good case for requiring identity verification.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoHIPAA also includes the right to correct incorrect information in your records. 23 may have to get unconventional to verify the individual but they're a DNA lab and have everything they need to make a positive confirmation.
- dekhn 2y ago
- chx 2y agoI still find it astonishing anyone would be so careless of their own and close blood relatives' privacy to hand over their genetic material to a private company. What were you thinking. You can't undo that and you can't change your DNA ever. You have no idea where it ends up any time -- and that "any time" covers your life time and your close blood relatives entire lifetime too. These companies should have never been able to get a single customer but I guess. And here we are 18 years later and some people still think they can delete this. What else do you believe in? The tooth fairy? Santa Claus? Come on. Also what have you thought they can tell you? An archaeogenetics teacher described this belief as "they think we throw a bone in the machine which tells us it was half hun, half avar, half bear and spoke slavic". Y'all surrendered an intrinsic part of the privacy of your, your sister, your brother, even your unborn children for snake oil -- and paid for the privilege. I can't even. commence the downvotes but you can't put the toothpaste back once it's been squeezed out.
- uhtred 2y agoI agree completely about it being careless etc but I am not astonished at all that so many people have done it. Have you seen how simple minded the masses are? They find it hard to think! They are barely sentient!
- fwip 2y agohttps://xkcd.com/610/ https://xkcd.com/610/
- programjames 2y agoThey're probably applying more of an Übermensch mentality than a self-centered one.
- fwip 2y agoIt's basically the same belief system.
- programjames 2y ago
- kulesh 2y agoI moved my DNA data from 23andMe to Genomelink ~5 years ago. Sort of saw it coming.
- carimura 2y agoI've been dealing with their support trying to delete my data. Here's the latest response [1]. The way I read it, they won't delete your genetic data, and it sure seems personally identifiable to me. Am I reading this wrong? [1] This is a follow-up from the 23andMe Team. Your inquiry has been escalated to me for review. To clarify, once you confirm your request to delete your account, we will delete your data from our systems within 30 days, unless we are required by law or regulation to maintain data for a given timeframe. For example, your Genetic Information, date of birth, and sex will be retained by 23andMe and our third party genotyping laboratory as required for compliance with applicable legal obligations, including the U.S. Federal Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments of 1988 (CLIA), California Business and Professional Code Section 1265, and College of American Pathologists accreditation requirements. It is important to understand that the information stored is distinct from the raw genotype data available within your account. The raw data we receive from the lab has not been processed by our interpretation software to produce your individual-level genotype data (in your account). You can read more about our retention requirements in the retention of personal information section of our Privacy Statement.
- 10u152 2y agoSo they'll happily delete everything unless it has value to them. Charming.
- psunavy03 2y agoIt literally says they have legal obligations to retain data and cite the exact laws that require them to. Did you even read the post you replied to?
- 10u152 2y agoI did read it. The response is we will delete unless… and it lists a bunch of possibly applicable laws. Based on the vagueness of the response (which law in particular, what are the details etc) I’d argue they won’t delete anything ever and claim that they thought they might run afoul of some law.
- artursapek 2y agoinb4 Blackrock lol
- tamimio 2y agoGlad I never did any of these tests, I refuse to use biometrics in my own iPhone let alone sending my whole DNA to some company.
- yoavm 2y agoJust a reminder that you're leaving your biometrics basically on every surface you touch, and your DNA pretty much everywhere you drop a hair.
- lm28469 2y agoThat doesn't mean sharing them online with whoever buys the data is good... Every time I change my clothes at the gym I'm fully naked, I wouldn't want that to be showed on live TV, it's really not that hard of a nuance to grasp
- yoavm 2y agoTrue, but the analogy is far from fitting. Your nudity is shared with people in the gym, your biometrics is shared with anyone that has access to anything you ever touched. Your nude picture being shown on TV isn't the same as you-and-15-other-million nude pictures being shown on TV, and while sending your nude photo to your boss can be harmful, it's hard to think about what harm can be caused by sending your DNA to... anyone.
- lm28469 2y agoSure but unless you're a state level threat no one will collect your old coffee cups Once your DNA is in some random company's DB it's there forever and available to whoever has the money > it's hard to think about what harm can be caused by sending your DNA to... anyone. Oh yeah ? Is this something that was determined by some kind of god and will be true forever ? https://theconversation.com/life-insurers-can-charge-more-or-decline-cover-based-on-your-genetic-test-results-new-laws-must-change-this-212183 https://theconversation.com/life-insurers-can-charge-more-or... > In Australia, life insurance companies can legally use the results of genetic tests to discriminate. They can decline to provide life insurance coverage, increase the cost of premiums, or place exclusions on an individual’s cover.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- marcell 2y agoI used to work at 23andMe, AMA Previous: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41575685 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41575685