14 ms·
Who Pays for the Arts?
- takinola 2y agoI’m surprised no one has posted this gem from Yes, Minister https://youtu.be/Zl0aEz34A4o?si=D9RcUnMq0oI370Lg https://youtu.be/Zl0aEz34A4o?si=D9RcUnMq0oI370Lg
- niceguy1827 2y agobut did Shakespeare ever get a subsidy? /s
- shams93 2y agoThe artists themselves do, in the era of easy creation we are all conceptual artists now.
- hdivider 2y agoA classical philosopher once told me that many ultra-wealthy people have ancient papyrus scrolls hidden away in their collections -- full of ancient Greek and Roman knowledge currently unknown to the outside world. Keep the value up by keeping it secret. Or at least keep your bragging rights with fellow ultra-rich apex parasites.
- jessriedel 2y agoWouldn’t the value be a lot higher if it wasn’t secret? Or is it the risk confiscation/opprobrium?
- geor9e 2y agoExample of something valuable with secret contents: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Once_Upon_a_Time_in_Shaolin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Once_Upon_a_Time_in_Shaolin
- jessriedel 2y agoThat's importantly different, unless the existence and authenticity of the scrolls is public and only the contents are secret (which is not what I understood the commenter to be suggesting).
- colonelspace 2y agoSounds like the kind of thing children tell each other in the playground.
- onlypassingthru 2y agoIf you're ever in Kyoto, be sure to check out the Miho Museum to see what one billionaire family's private collection of works from antiquity looks like. I don't recall any papyri, but it wouldn't surprise me one bit if they have things tucked away that aren't ever on display. https://www.miho.jp/en/ https://www.miho.jp/en/
- vundercind 2y agoI dunno—quite a few things that are true about (at least some set of) rich people also have that kind of ring to them. I wouldn’t be surprised.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoIt is in some ways equivalent to a One Piece. Ultiamtely, people want legacy, and what better way to have people talking about you centuries later than by suggesting you have this huge treasure buried somewhere that no one can ever find?
- geor9e 2y agoIf I heard someone brag about depriving the public of historical documents, I'd see them as nothing more than slime. Even the Vatican Secret Archive is finally getting digitized https://digi.vatlib.it/ https://digi.vatlib.it/
- marcus_holmes 2y agoI'm always torn by this. If you can't attract an audience for your art, does it deserve funding? How do we decide that? Can anyone just make a papier-mache turd and get funding for it? If not, then who decides what is worth funding? On what basis? How do we stop nepotism and elitism from being the main factors for arts funding? But should all art have commercial appeal? Do we force all artists to be marketers first and foremost? Are we going to get better art because of that? The age-old question: how do we decide what is "good"? If we train a bunch of experts on the entire history of art and let them decide, then we seem to get decisions that are based around those experts competing amongst themselves for intellectual snobbery points. But if we let the masses decide, then we get art that appeals to the lowest common denominator. Letting the rich folks decide isn't any better (or worse) than letting civil servants decide. Maybe we train an LLM to decide what deserves funding for us, and move one step closer to The Culture.
- jltsiren 2y agoThis is not an either-or question. Let the public decide, and you get popular art. Let the rich people decide, and you get whatever art the elites value. And also have some public funding, and you get the kind of art experts and some politicians value.
- fallingknife 2y agoLet the rich decide by their own preferences. Let the public decide by their own preferences. Take money from the public and give it to politicians and bureaucrats so they can decide for the public. The first two make sense. The last does not.
- marcus_holmes 2y agoBut there is an argument that some people are truly experts in art, they have studied it and made it their life's work. That we should allow them to make the decision for us, because they will be able to make better decisions. We do this in a lot of other areas, after all.
- 23B1 2y agoPeople in this thread will spend more time deciding if they agree or disagree with various aspects of this article, fret over some nonsense about the 'economics' of art, or paint with broad brushes a world they do not understand... instead of doing what they really ought, which is to close the spreadsheet/terminal/pitch deck and... SEE ART Loving art is extremely sexy, sophisticated, fun, complex, challenging, and indulgent. It also breaks you out of a rut, gives you totally bonkers 'out there' fresh ideas, helps you be less of a self-centered human. Anyone can do it. The more interested and involved you are in up-and-coming artists –people who are struggling to make it in that world – the better. You can go to a gallery show once a week, or buy every art book you can get your hand on, or dedicate your next vacation to visiting a world class museum. You can find this world aligned with your tastes - maybe you like abstract expressionism, maybe you like bronze sculptures of cowboys, maybe you like slutty polaroids. There are niches nested in niches, one you'll be comfortable in and ones you won't be, (which is even better, to be uncomfortable). BTW you can start this journey on the internet but it cannot be fully realized from the comfort of a screen. You will have to go outside, be near other humans, smell the glue and the wine and the turpentine of real art; what better excuse is there? Oh and one more thing, since this is HN: stupid AI art isn't art at all, for the reasons above and more. SEE ART
- sharkjacobs 2y agoGoing to a gallery and smelling glue and wine and turpentine is a fine thing to do but it’s not like it is The Worthwhile Thing To Do. Reading magazine articles and thinking about them is a fine thing to do sometimes too.
- 23B1 2y agoHow pedantic. Obviously it's not the smelling, it's the experiencing and the socializing and the development of taste, immersed in the qualia of meatspace.
- bowsamic 2y agoI don’t think loving art is easy at all. I still haven’t completely learnt how to do it
- julianeon 2y agoI'm reading a book called Culture Crash, which is relevant here. I also read Sinykin's Big Fiction a while back, so you could say I've been reading abou the culture industry. Culture Crash makes this interesting point: Did you know there used to be widely read, culturally relevant, AND Nobel Prize worthy (like actual contenders to win), poets? Unimaginable now but true in living memory. They didn't even have to be attached to a University, financially speaking. Like your male or female co-worker might hear that such an such a poet was coming out with a new book, and buy it, and then for a few weeks the cultural conversation would be dominated by this - a book of poetry. Which people 50 years from now would be reading in lit classes. The general point of these books (summarizing a lot here) is that the cultural infrastructure has been falling away for decades now, and there isn't much left. At this point literature has been "captured" by the University, but it's for a good reason: you can't survive as a fiction writer without it. People complain "but they're so insular" but the truth is: they don't have an alternative. You can work at a University or you can not be a full-time writer: that's your choice. This is true of other industries too. Music: you used to be able to support yourself as a studio musician. You might also be the guy who was the resident expert on classical music for the neighborhood at the store, who would recommend operas conducted by Karajan and the best recordings from Deutsche Grammophone (I remember those guys). Art: you could paint signs or design posters, back when there was a real demand. Writing: you could write for the alternative weeklies (I'd read those) or be a regular journalist, writing as little as one story a day. Movies: you could be a video clerk (I also remember this). And those 'subcultures' were incubators. Quentin Tarantino graduated from the video store in a sense. Who can follow him, if there are no video stores anymore? So this crisis in nonprofit funding really is coming at the end of a much longer crisis in the arts in general. It should be seen in that context.
- chongli 2y agoWhat do you mean by cultural infrastructure? I think I agree with the general thrust of the argument but I’m fuzzy on the particulars. For example, the video rental store has been replaced by a multitude of sources: Netflix et al, torrent sites, YouTube, Twitch. It’s never been easier to make a film and distribute it to a lot of people, yet I can’t deny a sense of loss from the demise of the video store. What is the difference here?
- lynx23 2y agoAll I can think of while and after reading this article: Socializing Risk. Why exactly should I, as a citizen, pay for random art pieces indirectly through taxes? I already do, but I question the practice. To simply answer the headlines question: "Who Pays for the Arts?" How about the consumers pay for what they want to consume?
- keiferski 2y agoI didn’t see any mention of how the actual “rich people” have changed from a hundred years ago to today. The industrialists of yesteryear tended to care about what high society valued and subsequently funded cultural projects. Carnegie Hall (essentially the top destination for classical musicians) or the Carnegie Library system are prime examples. Compare that to today, where many of the newly rich are from tech or finance. They don’t seem to care at all about supporting culture or the arts, instead focusing on politics, medicine, or their own pet causes. This has to be a major factor, and also explains why Bezos Hall or Gates University of the Arts seem like completely implausible things to exist today.
- silvestrov 2y agoI think it is not the rich people that has changed but the artists. Suppose the reason that rich people bought art in the old days was mostly to gain respect and status from other people (and personal pleasure secondly). Art like a Vermeer painting is good at that: everybody can see it is a good painting and many people would want such a painting in their home. But modern art (including architecture) is often only understandable in narrow artist circles and not by people at large. Most people look at modern art and wonders if this is a piece of art or some junk that needs to be thrown out. So modern art fails at making the population give the rich person higher social status. Example: A rich guy in Denmark built a new opera house (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ae/Copenhagen_opera.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ae/Copenhag...) to replace the old one (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/18/Royal_Danish_Theatre%2C_Copenhagen.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/18/Royal_Da...). I think the attempt at improving status failed with the new building. This interpretation is the style of Clayton Christensen: The Theory of Jobs To Be Done https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/clay-christensen-the-theory-of-jobs-to-be-done https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/clay-christensen-the-theory-of-jo... So it might be that the rich people has concluded that currently is is not possible to create "public works of art" that would increase the rich peoples social standing.
- keiferski 2y agoWell, a few things: 1. The term here should be contemporary art, not modern art. Modern art refers to art from roughly 1890-1960. Typically people that don’t know much about contemporary art and claim it’s all stupid make this basic mistake, which highlights their ignorance of the subject. 2. The contemporary art market is absolutely driven and perhaps even survives because of rich people. So much so that artworks have become financial instruments. The difference, which is what my comment was trying to get at, is that the ultra rich, society-defining wealth tends to come from the tech world and generally has little interest in arts or culture. For example the entire contemporary art market is only about 65 billion, which is orders of magnitude lower than tech. https://www.ubs.com/global/en/our-firm/art/collecting/art-market-survey.html https://www.ubs.com/global/en/our-firm/art/collecting/art-ma... 3. Even then, this is only “art” and not “the arts” as a whole. So I don’t think it’s very comprehensive of an answer. One related conclusion I came to awhile ago, and wrote a short post on, is that it’s very difficult to invest in “public art” vs. “private art.” I wrote more about it here: https://onthearts.com/p/modern-culture-is-too-escapist-part https://onthearts.com/p/modern-culture-is-too-escapist-part But the most relevant part for this discussion is this: Today, if a wealthy benefactor wanted to emulate a Renaissance patron and fund an architect or artist to create a new town square or city park, it’s unclear how he or she would even go about doing so. There don’t appear to be any financial instruments specifically designed for rewarding investors that fund integrated artworks. The design of the public space would almost certainly be watered down and subject to various governmental councils and community groups. Hostile attitudes toward the wealthy would probably result in the park being vandalized, if it were actually built. Consequently, it is much easier and more creatively rewarding to instead spend a few million on a rare painting or backing a film project. Put simply, there are very little incentives for the wealthy to fund integrated arts. Even then, though, this is already a subset of the potential wealthy founders of art, a subset that largely excludes most of the tech billionaires that don’t care about art culture at all.
- gillesjacobs 2y agoIn Belgium, it is relatively easy to get "artist-statute" which is a subsidized higher monthly welfare income (Basic Income for artists). Belgium runs on the "subsidize-and-conquer" paradigm, the tax burden is one of the highest in the world. The government keeps lower class happy with welfare, the upperclass with culture and mainly business subsidies. The productive middleclass is effectively squeezed. The art sector here is mostly publicly funded. This too has advantages for our gov: no artists will criticize the subsidizer of their lifestyle, so no real anti-authoritarian culture takes hold. Don't bite the hand that feeds. You'd think Belgium would have some impressive world-class artists, since so many can work unbothered by the oppressive forces of market trends. Not surprisingly, mediocrity, irrelevance and low-output are the norm.
- OptionOfT 2y agoBeing from Belgium, and having gone (suffered) through high-school there, I remember going to see a theater play which was about a red square and a blue circle. That's all I remember. It was horrible.
- Yeul 2y agoThe problem with the arts is that nobody really gives a shit. The vast majority of the population doesn't visit the opera or is interested in modern art. Despite a century of government funding the needle hasn't shifted. The first thing any artist should realize is that they live in a bubble. You're not going to change the world. As for market forces: our beloved Rembrandt did commission work he had a very expensive lifestyle to fund.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dapf 2y ago[dead]
- taylorius 2y agoI think the internet and the general ascendancy of computer science,and algorithmic thinking has a part to play in this. There is a certain notion of efficiency (perhaps also expressable as convenience) which has become a well trodden path to success in the market. This has been widely beneficial of course, but amongst it's side effects are a marginalisation of anything other than the most focused, popular artistic offerings. (Think Mr Beast, Taylor Swift etc).
- ocular-rockular 2y agoAlgorithmic thinking and optimizing one's life (whether in a video game, workplace, or in a hobby) lives rent free in my mind. It's prevalence and inertia has made my life only miserable, yet it's so hard to escape when almost everything your sold on is to optimally squeeze your life.
- HPsquared 2y agoThe powerful and/or rich. Same with the sciences. EDIT: However individual contributors "fund" the arts and sciences by their work; those can of course come from people of any social status.
- schnitzelstoat 2y agoIt makes sense for everyone to fund the sciences though because we all benefit from it as we saw very clearly with the mRNA vaccines for covid most recently. Other examples include semiconductors, the internet etc. But it's hard to see how I benefit from someone making a messy bed because it's 'art'. (That is a real example. A literal messy bed. 'My Bed' by Tracy Emin.)
- HPsquared 2y agoIndividual people don't fund the sciences though. As in, they don't direct funding to the sciences. That's done by representatives of some kind - who fit into the "rich and/or powerful" category.
- mykowebhn 2y agoNo one would expect an artist to say anything sensible about technology...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- eszed 2y ago"Sensible" in what sense, or on what scale? You probably shouldn't ask an artist about a useful formula for concrete, or to troubleshoot your jacquard loom, or which js framework to use: that's what engineers are for. But the products of those tools will be more successful if someone other than an engineer has input into the building's proportions, or the cloth's colors, or the page's layout. That's all art, and imminently sensible - even by the most nakedly commercial definition of "sense". At a larger scale, and just to pick the least controversial and most popular on this board: did Ridley Scott and Matt Damon say nothing sensible about technology in The Martian? Or Neal Stephenson in, like, anything? At a still larger scale, artists have always engaged with the ways technology changes society (or, in fact, the way that technology changes art) - in celebration and in warning, in observation and in speculation, and in all modes between. Turner's The Fighting Temeraire is an easily-graspable example. Often artists are wrong, of course, as anyone (including technologists and venture capitalists) can be, but that's very different than not "sensible".
- mykowebhn 2y agoI agree with you. Please note the ellipsis at the end of my original statement. Sorry it wasn't clear, but it was said with irony.
- eszed 2y agoHa! Thanks. Irony's so easy to miss on the internet - and this topic especially seems to attract "non-sensible" responses on this board, so my antennae are a bit too finely tuned. Time to go touch grass. :-)
- sashank_1509 2y agoJust focusing on movies, my sense is that money isn’t the big issue, it’s the lack of prestige involved in art that’s really killing it. The necessary conditions for creating great art is an elite group (that holds significant societal power), that ranks, discusses and promotes all the excellent art being released in a year. They give great artists prestige and some money but money is the smaller part of the equation. Instead of this what we have now is a mass market art where art gets ranked by the millions/ billions it brings in, and so we are fed with a never ending fill of Marvel Slop/ Franchise movies and rarely risky, through provoking movies. And when we do have such a movie, we have no effective way of showering its creators with prestige. The Oscars used to play this role, but now apparently most voters don’t even watch the Oscar movies and so it’s corrupted beyond repair. Besides the Oscar crowd is filled with actors and the maximum prestige an actor can give to another actor is limited greatly. Compare it to an Oscar crowd filled with heads of state, industry etc like a royal court of the past and that would be an insanely strong incentive to produce great art.
- abe94 2y agoWhats surprisingly missing from this conversation, and only hinted at in the article, is that there a massive new infrastructure for funding "the arts" today that did not exist 20 years ago. Youtube, instagram, and tiktok allow many more people to pursue creative pursuits and find audiences for their work than before. The people who succeed on these platforms may call themselves creators, but a lot of them are artists. IMO the people who refuse to use the new tools, or do so unseriously find it hard to fund themselves.
- nitwit005 2y agoWhen they say "the arts", they generally mean high status arts. The things young people like rarely fit into that category.
- tubignaaso 2y agoI agree, they certainly are artists. Perhaps artists that are good at making content for that particular platform, though. A painter who is dedicated to her craft wouldn’t be able to dedicate as much time getting good at YouTube’s algorithm. How can we support those people?
- abe94 2y agoI see what you are saying and agree to a point, but you don't have to become excellent at 10 minute long form youtube videos to sustain yourself, for example you can create 2 minute behind the scenes videos on tiktok instead or simply share images of your paintings on instagram. artists can be creative about building audiences. Here are some local NYC artists/groups i follow in order of followers: https://www.instagram.com/secret_riso_club/ https://www.instagram.com/secret_riso_club/ https://www.instagram.com/sahanabanana/?hl=en https://www.instagram.com/sahanabanana/?hl=en https://www.instagram.com/naomi.basu/?hl=en https://www.instagram.com/naomi.basu/?hl=en
- achenet 2y agoI don't have any firsthand experience in this subject, so I could be wrong. However, from my limited understanding of the YT algorithm, it rewards consistency. If you make at least one new video every week, and each video is "well recieved", i.e. most of the people who click on it finish it, and ideally like it/subscribe to your channel as well, the algorithm will start pushing your stuff on the "recommended" list.
- Tobi_Olabode3 2y agoIn the UK, throughout the 80s various rock bands were getting government subsidies for their music. We call it Rock on the Dole. Many people do argue this led to the rise of music from that era.
- helboi4 2y agoyep, I've heard very good arguments for this.
- every 2y agoKMFA is a non-profit, listener-supported classical music station that has been broadcasting for over half a century. They also stream their content for the web: https://www.kmfa.org/ https://www.kmfa.org/
- motohagiography 2y agoa problem is the people involved in The Arts are more interested in being prescriptive about what people should like instead of discovering what we in fact desire. we make this same mistake in tech all the time, building things we think other people should do instead of what they want, shopping it around to "get funded," without any customer traction, and then ending up on some government services vehicle just to get enough money to keep making the same mistake and hoping maybe the state will mandate our solution to someone. It's every non-US startup ever, and it comes from the same welfare state mentality that produces the funded Arts nobody cares about. the main people who support artists are the market makers who connect audiences, dealers, managers, distributors, marketers, students, and collectors. trying to replace "aristocrats and corporations," with another patron just continues the cycle of dependency and paternalism that produces the same token flattery nobody wants. if you want better art, learn what it means to make a market, and then grow one.
- abe94 2y agoI agree with this, having interacted with a number of artists, a lot of what is produced simply isn't that great, different or interesting. Of course if creating things makes you happy go for it, but don't expect to be able to live off of that.
- Handprint4469 2y ago> a problem is the people involved in The Arts are more interested in being prescriptive about what people should like instead of discovering what we in fact desire. The thing that grinds my gears is that they do this by trying to redefine language. They don't come out and say "you should like X". They say "X is beautiful" (and if you think otherwise, you're obtuse/privileged/etc). Nevermind what beauty used to mean, since it's just a cultural artifact of a capitalist white patriarchy, and you don't want to be associated with that, do you? What one considers beautiful stops being an instinctive felt sense coming from within, and becomes just an empty statement used for signaling others how sophisticated/class-aware/etc you are. It's pure neurosis, and I'm not surprised such disembodied people have trouble actually creating beauty.