6 ms·
A Bendy RISC-V Processor
- eric__cartman 2y ago> Performance varied between a 4.3 percent slowdown to a 2.3 percent speedup depending on the way it was bent. I have practically zero knowledge on the physics behind semiconductors to try to think why this could occur but I find it fascinating nonetheless.
- dragontamer 2y agoMy expectation is that the core clock circuit has its capacitance and/or inductance change, this changing the timing of the clock. +/-5% is a region where everything in the digital domain probably still works. Your rise/fall time and dead-time / other critical timings need to be robust against some degree of variability. Transistors can have rather wide manufacturing variability after all (certainly wider than 5%). So everything still works but the core clock is changing. Which btw, happens in traditional silicon circuits as they heat up or cool down. A low precision RC oscillator changing by 5% or so between 20C and 100C is within expectations. I'm fact, a -50%/+100% change wouldn't surprise me. -------------- Old var-caps (variable capacitors) by twisting them tighter or looser. No joke. So that's where my expectation that they've changed the capacitance of some core element that controls an important clock.
- adrian_b 2y agoMany resistive materials, especially those that are semiconductors, have changes of resistivity caused by mechanical strain. This so-called piezoresistive effect is frequently used for measuring the deformations of various objects, by attaching piezoresistive wires to them, which can measure for instance the amount of bending of the object. Such a flexible integrated circuit might also have changes in the resistance of the transistor channels or of the interconnection traces, which will change the maximum permissible clock frequency. If an RC oscillator is used to generate a clock signal, its frequency will change with the bending of the circuit, more likely due to variations of the resistance than of the capacitance, because it is not likely for the bending to cause large variations in the thickness of the dielectric of the capacitors or in the area of the electrodes, even if that is also possible. The variable capacitors whose capacitance is changed by twisting have this behavior because their electrodes overlap only partially and the twisting changes the area of the overlapping region. No such thing happens when twisting or bending a normal capacitor.
- dragontamer 2y ago> which will change the maximum permissible clock frequency. Emphasis on _permissible_ clock frequency. Because how is the core logic supposed to figure out how much the clock frequency changed or how much the resistance of the wires have changed? > because it is not likely for the bending to cause large variations in the thickness of the dielectric of the capacitors or in the area of the electrodes, even if that is also possible. Yes but no. Everything you said is correct, but you're looking at the wrong dielectric. The plastic PCB is obviously unchanging, even as it gets balled up. However, there's another dielectric here that's normally ignored that suddenly becomes relevant. The _relevant_ dielectric (to this discussion) is the air. As the capacitor rolls up into a cylinder shape, the copper-air-copper capacitor has the dielectric (air) get thinner-and-thinner. ------------------- However, to your point that this is "resistance"... the fact that "rolling one way" leads to -speed and "rolling the other way" leads to +speed suggests that its a resistance issue. Because the spring/resistance relationship is known. So stress/tension causes resistance of copper to grow, while pressure causes resistance of copper to drop. If the oscillator is an RC-type oscillator (ex: a 555-timer like oscillator), then yes, I can see the resistance theory playing out. And 60kHz is slow enough that RC-type oscillators are possible.
- adrian_b 2y ago> Because how is the core logic supposed to figure out how much the clock frequency changed It is frequent for such logic circuits to use clock generators made with a so-called ring oscillator, i.e. with a chain of inverters containing an odd number of them, which is connected in a loop. The clock period will be a multiple of the delay through a logic inverter. In this case the actual clock frequency tracks exactly all changes in the permissible clock frequency, regardless of their causes, including temperature and mechanical deformation. > As the capacitor rolls up into a cylinder shape, the copper-air-copper capacitor has the dielectric (air) get thinner-and-thinner. I am not sure which is the copper-air-copper capacitor to which you refer. On a PCB, there are parasitic copper-air-copper capacitors between traces, but they have very little influence on clock frequencies. On a normal integrated circuit, there is no air. The metal layers are separated by insulator layers and the top metal is covered by a passivation layer. This flexible circuit should also be covered by some passivation layer. Replacing in your argument the copper-air-copper capacitor with a copper-insulator-copper capacitor, any circuit has two kinds of capacitors, those that are made intentionally, with two overlapped metal electrodes and a very thin insulator layer between them, and the parasitic capacitors that exist between any metal traces. Your argument is valid for the parasitic capacitors, because the distance between traces will vary with bending and some parasitic capacitors will become larger, while others will become smaller. The effect of each of the parasitic capacitors on the permissible clock frequency is small and the global effect of all parasitic capacitors is unpredictable without a concrete circuit layout, because their changes with the bending may compensate each other. For an intentional capacitor, the effect mentioned by you also exists, but in most technologies for integrated circuits the thickness of the insulator of the capacitors is very small in comparison with the lengths and widths of the electrodes. In this case only a very small part of the electromagnetic field is outside the internal space of the capacitor and its influence on the value of the capacitance is negligible. Perhaps the capacitors made with this flexible technology are not as thin in comparison with their area as in other technologies, in which case the effect mentioned by you could be measurable, but I doubt it.
- crest 2y agoNeither do I, but I can tell you if you manage to bend a normal CPU die the performance loss is 100% (because you broke it).
- EligibleDecoy 2y agoWhat’s interesting to me is that it loses 4% efficiency when bent. Like, I get why there’s some loss because of parasitic capacitance/inductance etc but 4% seems like… not very much?
- Someone 2y agoI guess it helps a lot that it’s running at 60kHz. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasitic_capacitance#Effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasitic_capacitance#Effects: “At low frequencies parasitic capacitance can usually be ignored, but in high frequency circuits it can be a major problem.”
- Someone 2y ago> The research team found Flex-RV could run as fast as 60 kilohertz while consuming less than 6 milliwatts of power. They don’t give all details, but I think it’s safe to say there’s work to do w.r.t. performance/Watt, probably more so given that the CPU seems to be bit serial (https://github.com/olofk/serv https://github.com/olofk/serv), which I think means an addition takes 32 cycles.
- therealcamino 2y agoFrom the linked Nature article: "The 5.8 mW power consumption is predominantly static (99%) because of the resistive pull-up logic."
- yapyap 2y agoCan’t wait to never hear about this again /s
- joelignaatius 2y agoWhat's the smallest commercially available electronic and can it be inserted into the brain? Why am I having headaches?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 2y agoNearly any uses for flexible electronics would also be satisfied by sufficiently small electronics such that lack of flexibility doesn't matter. Eg. rather than having every pixel in your flexible screen be flexible, you make each pixel rigid and have the joints between pixels flexible. In this case, this design is based on SERV, which uses ~2100 gate equivalents, which in a recent tech node would be 40 um^2. That means you could fit a 10x10 grid of these in a single pixel on an iphone screen. I really can't think of a use case where a region 1/100th of an iphone screen pixel being rigid would be a problem.
- wslh 2y agoSo, nothing particularly interesting here? When I first saw 'flexible' I immediately thought about balancing a chip's specifications, not its material flexibility!
- dragontamer 2y agoFlexible circuits are interesting and worthy of discussion. Really, the whole process here is fascinating to me. There's been a lot of progress in flex circuits over this recent decade. None of it is electrically or computationally new. It's 1980s tech from a computation perspective. But mechanically?? Being able to weave circuits seamlessly into clothes, tapestry, and such is pretty cool. If only for the cosplay / costume designers but that's still a pretty / beautifully kind of display (especially with a few fiber optics to move lights around). One of the interesting electro-mechanical issues is that flex circuits are necessarily thin, making grounding / return currents exceptionally consistent. On the downside however, solid planes / ground fills are bad for flexibility, so you apparently need to make a ground-grid instead of ground-fill. Very interesting tech overall. Even if it's applications are quite small right now.
- grayhatter 2y agoIt's funny, I thought the exact opposite. > Flexible... isn't that the point of any central processing unit, to be able to handle many differing types of work? Oh, pliable? that's cool, I wonder how that works?
- 2y ago
- dragontamer 2y ago> Each Flex-RV microprocessor has a 17.5 square millimeter core and roughly 12,600 logic gates. The research team found Flex-RV could run as fast as 60 kilohertz while consuming less than 6 milliwatts of power. This is pretty bad from a power efficiency perspective. KHz speed silicon microcontrollers are closer to ~dozens of microwatts, about two decades of magnitude less power than this flex-circuit. Furthermore, small silicon dies can be placed into flexPCBs. I'm sure a flexchip has more flexibility than a solid silicon die on a flex board but there's a question of how much flex is actually needed in products? --------- Still, I recognize that a fully functional CPU on this process is a major achievement. I'm just trying to think of a commercial application, that's all.
- mystified5016 2y agoE-textiles, probably. There's a small, but real, niche trying to put circuitry onto/into fabrics. Traditional flex PCBs get you pretty close, but any large IC creates a limited bend radius and a stress point that will fail very quickly. Using lots and lots of tiny dice for this would technically work, but it's extremely impractical unless you're building your widget by the millions. But yes, the potential applications are quite limited. Flexible electronics just aren't as useful as people think. I guess it just sounds really cool, like transparent LCDs.
- dragontamer 2y agoThe thin nature of flex circuits have interesting implications for capacitance / parasitic inductance. I've been told that flex circuits are far easier to pass EMC testing due to the physically closer ground/reference return path. Of course: with the caveat that solid planes of copper are not flexible and will crack. So ground-grid are the best you can do. But physically closer / physically thinner circuits have niche advantages. ------- But I'm talking about traditional silicon dies on a flexpcb. This article is about printing some kind of flexible chip to begin with. It's cool and relatively new, but silicon + flexpcb will be the main technique for e-textiles (and other flex applications) for the near future. Still, one more tool in the toolbox for electrical engineers. Niche as it is, it's still a tool with likely some good application somewhere.
- kragen 2y ago60 kilohertz on 6 milliwatts sounds pretty bad (that's 100 milliwatts per megahertz and so 20 milliamps per megahertz if we assume 5 volts, while 0.06 milliamps per megahertz is common for low-power processors) but it's actually far, far worse than it sounds because serv is bit-serial, requiring, i think, 32 cycles per instruction. so you're looking at something like 5000 times the energy consumption of existing off-the-shelf microcontrollers the suggested price of a dollar is about 10x worse than something like the py32, ch32v003, or pmc150, which are also faster and more power-efficient that doesn't mean this is bad research! it just means it isn't yet developed to a state where there's likely to be a market for it. it's very helpful to know that serv occupies 12600 gates, for example, and that the flex-rv process provides 720 gates per square millimeter. it's very plausible you could design something useful with it that had 600 gates, was less than a square millimeter, used 300 microwatts at 60 kilohertz, and cost five cents, for example; that's a niche that silicon photolithography is struggling to fill because of high per-chip costs. you could fit a 6502 into twice that another potentially interesting niche is low power density; for implanting into your body you don't want hot spots that can burn your tissues (though you'd have to encapsulate the igzo behind something biocompatible)
- hajile 2y agoThe 1-bit serial version is 2100kGe (excluding registers). Their talk claims the 4-bit variant is 2.5x larger (while being 4x faster) which is around 5250kGe. Add in all the registers and you get pretty close to that 13kGe number (assuming you're using 31 registers instead of 15 in the 32e spec).
- kragen 2y agothank you for the extra context! i had assumed they were using the 1-bit serial version and that for whatever reason they just needed a lot more gates than anyone had expected from fpga simulations. i didn't realize serv had a nybble-serial option, and that's a very significant difference. so it's closer to 1000× the energy consumption of off-the-shelf microcontrollers than 5000×
- ForestCritter 2y agoBecause wrapping it around a pencil is clearly a benefit(:
- Conscat 2y agoFlexible PCBs are convenient to embed in fabric.
- vitiral 2y agoThis is super exciting, I love to see advances in low temperature semiconductor manufacturing. HOWEVER > The research team found Flex-RV could run as fast as 60 kilohertz while consuming less than 6 milliwatts of power. Those are TERRIBLE specs compared to silicon. Similar microcontroller specs are 1,000x faster at similar power consumption.
- gradschool 2y agoAny ideas on why they'd use NMOS [1] instead of CMOS if they're aiming for low power? Too many layers? My (amateur, outdated, and probably wrong) recollection is that CMOS dissipates very little power except when switching, but not so for NMOS. [1] https://www.pragmaticsemi.com/app/uploads/2023/07/Pragmatic-Pocket-Guide-to-Designing-for-FlexICs.pdf https://www.pragmaticsemi.com/app/uploads/2023/07/Pragmatic-...
- dragontamer 2y agoCMOS requires very tight tolerances for the PMOS + NMOS transistors to cancel each other out exactly. Otherwise it doesn't work at all. In particular, you need to ensure that the PMOS and NMOS turn on at the same voltage, otherwise you risk just shorting Vcc to Vss (aka: Power to Ground). NMOS was common in the 1970s before CMOS on silicon was figured out. I'm surprised to hear that this circuit is old-school NMOS, but I probably shouldn't be, as the CMOS step took a lot of research and effort back then.... If we're still at NMOS stage of production on this process, then its probably more relevant to think of analog-based designs. CMOS seems necessary if anyone is to achieve low-power modern-like designs. NMOS was still core to a lot of older chips though, so digital logic still can work on that. But the power consumption will be necessarily huge in comparison to CMOS.
- adrian_b 2y agoOnly in few semiconductor materials it is possible to make good transistors with both polarities, silicon, germanium and the silicon-germanium alloy being the main examples. In most semiconductor materials it is possible to make good transistors only with a single polarity, either N or P, depending on the material. So CMOS logic cannot be implemented in most semiconductor materials. This is the main reason why silicon has remained the principal material for complex logic circuits, even if there are a lot of materials with much better properties, except for allowing both polarities for transistors. In the first decades of the semiconductor industry, the main advantage of silicon had been that it was possible to create a high-quality insulator layer on its surface by oxidation. However there are many years since this advantage is no longer relevant for high-density logic circuits, because all their MOS transistors use now insulators with high dielectric constant, e.g. based on hafnia, which are deposited on the surface of silicon in the same way they would be deposited on any other semiconductor.
- ddtaylor 2y agoThe positioning of this product is strange to me. The features and specs of the product don't seem very impressive, as others have pointed out, and the overall tone of the writing suggests someone who found something and is looking for what drawer it goes in.
- rbanffy 2y agoThe best things in life are the ones that can't be easily put in a drawer.
- worik 2y agoVery cool. As Moore's Law runs out of steam it is time for the low end applications of computers to shine. Lots of comments here saying how [relatively] inefficient this is, that utterly miss the point. Putting cheap, good enough, CPUs into all sorts of places the "efficient " processors cannot go is going to revolutionise all sorts of applications This is not unique, but representative of its class
- Taniwha 2y agoFor those who don't know SERV is a serial RISC-V architecture - really small, fits in a Tiny Tapeout tile https://github.com/olofk/serv https://github.com/olofk/serv
- GeorgeTirebiter 2y ago> 60 kilohertz while consuming less than 6 milliwatts of power The IBM1401, the most popular computer in the world in the early 60s, ran at 11.5 microseconds per memory cycle = 87 kHz. True, it processed six bits at a time versus SERV's serial architecture but, still, both of these seem to be in the same ballpark, speedwise. The 1401 takes 13 kilowatts of juice. So not even in the same universe with respect to power consumed per computation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pixelfarmer 2y agoYoutube link from 7 years ago to give some context about the progress and also "flexibility": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01y6bR6ETpA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01y6bR6ETpA