5 ms·
The future of Boeing's crewed spaceflight program muddy after Starliner's return
- lenerdenator 2y agoThe future in doubt should be the one of Boeing's C-suite and board.
- ivan_gammel 2y agoThey just recently replaced their CEO.
- jajko 2y agoSomething tells me it wasn't directly just CEO telling everybody to ignore any concern, fake safety reports. Yes he is ultimately responsible, but at 1-2 levels below him are actually more responsible for setting culture and controls in given department, something proper investigation can easily uncover.
- jxcole 2y agoHe would need to fire at least 30% of the staff to make a difference. You can't fix the rot that started with the McDonald Douglas purchase by changing one person.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoI struggle to conceive of the sheer number of working professionals in our global economy right now that have received an irreversible taint from the corporate piracy era. This is going to take a couple generations to fully go away I suspect, and of course that assumes that it ever does since unqualified MBA holders are still being hired and still running profitable enterprises into the fucking ground left and right.
- Jtsummers 2y ago* McDonnell Douglas
- bell-cot 2y agoNASA obviously needs a new, reliable horse in this race. If only the development of Sierra Space's Dream Chaser wasn't moving at a snail's pace. (That project started back in 2004; they're currently hoping for the first test flight, of an unmanned cargo version, to happen in 2025.)
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoWhy Sierra Space vs Blue Origin ?
- imglorp 2y agoApples and oranges. Sierra is making a reuseable orbiter which needs a launcher and is pretty agnostic which one. Blue is making an orbital launcher but doesn't have a orbital spacecraft.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoOK, but surely NASA would like multiple suppliers for all components, and the launcher is the hard part, so Blue Origin seem closer to being a (single vendor) alternative to SpaceX. They were also tendering for the Artemis moon landing vehicle.
- imtringued 2y agoI'm not sure the launcher is the hard part. Heat shield tiles and re-entry seem to be much harder problems. Boeing Starliner had no trouble launching, returning on the other hand was risky. SLS worked flawlessly, but the returning Orion capsule's heat shield was severely damaged and the heat shield does not appear to be safe enough for crewed missions. Starship's super heavy booster landed as planned, but the upper stage got damaged during re-entry and just barely managed to perform a landing. STS/The space shuttle disaster was caused by damage from the launch, but arrived safely in LEO. The catastrophic loss occured during re-entry.
- bell-cot 2y ago
- htrp 2y ago> The space agency, under a fixed price agreement, agreed to pay Boeing $4.2 billion to develop the Starliner spacecraft; SpaceX would receive $2.6 billion for the development of its Crew Dragon vehicle. > The NASA officials at the press conference said they were confident that Boeing would continue despite losing at least $1.6 billion so far on the fixed-price contract and facing more losses amid investigations into the thruster failures on Starliner's latest flight. But there were no Boeing officials to ask. In the immediate aftermath of the landing, the company issued a short statement that included this noncommittal comment about its plans: "We will review the data and determine the next steps for the program." From the article, it seems like the implication is that the program is under review from the Boeing side and not the Nasa side.
- tedivm 2y agoSo despite getting 61% more money for the project, they not only failed to achieve what SpaceX did with less money but actually lost another $1.6b on top of it while still failing to achieve the necessary result. Boeing just seems to be really, really bad at this.
- mschuster91 2y ago> Boeing just seems to be really, really bad at this. Boeing isn't contracted for results, it's contracted to disperse pork (aka jobs and money) across the districts of politicians who vote for earmarked NASA funds.
- bobthepanda 2y agoNormally you’re supposed to make money off of pork though.
- BobbyJo 2y agoThe communities where Boeing employees live did indeed make money.
- rob74 2y ago> It was not immediately clear why the Boeing officials declined to participate. Shannon in particular is well-loved at the space agency, and the long-term press corps appreciates his candor. That's probably the reason why Boeing pulled him out of the press conference right there...
- indoordin0saur 2y agoWhy did they wait so long to make the decision to not use the Starliner for the return? Seems like an obvious choice, if the thrusters on the ship aren't functioning properly and we've got a well tested alternative ready to go in SpaceX.
- valine 2y agoNASA wanted to understand if the malfunctioning thrusters could operate within a margin error for safety. Boeing spent a month running a study that produced non-definitive answer as to the root cause of the problem. Had Boeing definitively demonstrated the root cause of the thruster issue NASA probably would have sent the Astronauts home on Starliner. It’s not that NASA necessarily thought that Starliner was unsafe. It’s more like they lack confidence that Boeing actually understands the problem.
- indoordin0saur 2y agoJust seems weird they aren't getting picked up until February. Oh well, I guess from the astronauts' perspective this is sorta great because you spend your whole life preparing for this one great moment in your career and to get to stay up there for longer can't be a terrible thing.
- Aeolun 2y agoTo be entirely fair to Boeing, while it’s too bad they do not understand the problem, props to them for admitting that. Or at least, realizing that saying it’s totally safe only to have the thing explode would cause irreparable reputational harm.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoIt landed safely, the astronauts would have been fine returning on Starliner. Given the absurd number of thrusters that Starliner has, it's still safe with a couple thrusters missing. So the question was "is it safe enough"? It's a hard judgement call. They made the right call, and making it at the last minute while waiting for more data from tests both on the ground and in space was also the right call IMO.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]