9 ms·
DOJ claims Google has "trifecta of monopolies" on Day 1 of ad tech trial
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoGoogle controlling web standards and owning Chrome is a big part of the problem. They get to only allow changes that protect their monopolies, allow invasion of privacy, avoid commoditization of their native Android APIs etc.
- NightlyDev 2y agoTo be fair, Google as done a lot for the web. Google is also the one who has been pushing for the web as an alternative to native apps, while Apple has been the one to actively sabotage. If only everyone used Firefox and Mozilla was the one with the most influence...
- cageface 2y agoRight. Without pressure from Chrome we'd be locked into proprietary, incompatible native app stores with no recourse over arbitrary, anti-competitive review processes. The flourishing of web apps like Figma and Notion would never have happened. The web has many shortcomings as an app platform but at least you can still build what you want without getting permission from a trillion dollar tech giant.
- gerash 2y agocomplain all you want but without Google web would've been an obsolete platform. You had to write things in iOS, or Facebook OS or potentialy Azure Intelligent Cloud API.
- bpodgursky 2y agoAlmost nobody outside adtech understands that 3rd party cookies are only alive today because Google was afraid that removing them would give the DoJ additional antitrust ammunition. Google would gladly have removed them and acted as a broker for anonymized targeting data, but it would have killed other players in the ad ecosystem and given them exclusive power as the distributer of chrome.
- hughesjj 2y agookay, I'll bite. Assuming everything you said is true, for the purposes of discussion, I'm curious.... Are third party cookies a good thing? (Context for anyone interested, also note citations 1 and 2) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_cookies https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_cookies
- jchw 2y agoMy opinion: No, definitely not, regardless of whether or not what they said is true. What they suggest, however, is a strong argument for not allowing the same company to be both an ad-tech leader and the dominant browser vendor, because it gives them severe conflicts of interest in either direction. I don't know what we can or should actually do about this, but it's pretty obvious that it can't really work.
- benoau 2y ago> Are third party cookies a good thing? Theoretically yes, they are intended to hold some piece of state that is relevant to or derived from your usage and that's not bad by itself. Third-parties aren't always ads either, you might embed maps or AI or countless other things that can use this. In practice, they have been abused for tracking very widely and they support all these other uses so much that we expanded this idea to include local storage, session storage, indexed storage etc.
- foota 2y agoIt depends on your POV. Privacy advocates would argue no, but basically all the major players (google, websites, and the rest of the ad ecosystem) except for truly independent web browser developers (of which... I don't know if there are any) want them because they're what makes ad targeting work.
- nebula8804 2y agoLets say you have a corporate app that serves thousands of internal users that has its backend hosted on a separate webserver. This app can implement super simple auth by having the backend query the company's AD server to prove identity, then fetch what is allowed to be viewed and store the session in a third party cookie. An app like this is probably not ideal for outward facing sites but I have seen apps like this serve its purpose very well as an internal app and the simplicity allows it to have less tech overhead.
- jordigh 2y ago> On Sunday, Google posted a blog warning that any attempt to break up its ad business could rattle customers who choose to use Google's ad tech because it "is simple, affordable, and effective." Has that ever been true? Every instance I know of monopolies being broken up has been good for customers.
- benoau 2y agoOne time Google accidentally forgot to refund $70 million they thought they had refunded for ad fraud, and they only found out when they were sued for a $500k piece of it someone definitely knew they had not received. This was back when they were in the tres commas club so I'm sure consumers will benefit immensely from smaller companies with smaller responsibilities. In a way it's like having a single one-million-line file vs a clean separation between API, UI, etc etc. https://www.theregister.com/2017/12/13/google_click_fraud_lawsuit/ https://www.theregister.com/2017/12/13/google_click_fraud_la... (I think it was this one but search results are saturated with other litigation and antitrust since)
- Spivak 2y agoThe best-faith argument I can make of it is that Google/Meta really are the lifeline for a lot of businesses who have zero chance of being able to leverage large-scale advertising blasts that big companies use. The customers using mega-scale digital ad exchanges get the benefit of being able to buy 0.001% of a billboard the moment someone actually interested in their product walks past. If you want to increase competition and stop the market from consolidating into a few players it's not immediately obvious that breaking up these ad exchanges goes that direction because it deprives reach from everyone except already large companies.
- LeonB 2y ago> being able to buy 0.001% of a billboard ^^ this is possible because the ads are delivered digitally, not because of any magic power google has. Even if every website was its own independent advertising space (an extreme opposite), they could all still be open to advertising companies big and small by using “open standards”. The innovations are all technological.
- curiousWaste 2y agoI don't really feel the "power" of google in any way. Search is so crappy i rarely even use it.
- christina97 2y agoThis is focused on the customer: advertisers, not the end users like you.
- odyssey7 2y agoGoogle broke its reputation as the ideal employer and now it’s in an antitrust trial. I have to wonder whether the two are related.
- richrichie 2y ago[flagged]
- hkt 2y agoGoogle has been heading this way for twenty years. Maybe just consider its behaviour in a very general way.
- glenstein 2y agoGoogle has certainly been less able to avoid antitrust scrutiny than the other tech giants. I think underappreciated aspect of Facebook's brand reinvention to Meta was the role it played in transforming their brand perception away from evil and toward merely bizarre. I do think a significant part of that transition was to avoid the fever pitch of antitrust scrutiny that they had been under, that now seems to have gone away. The heat was on Facebook, but they got out from under it. And now it's on Google.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoWhat market does Meta control?
- hughesjj 2y agoSocial media is what they're under antitrust for. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Trade_Commission_v._Meta_Platforms,_Inc https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Trade_Commission_v._....
- janalsncm 2y agoThe DOJ has a case open against Apple as well: https://www.justice.gov/atr/case/us-and-plaintiff-states-v-apple-inc https://www.justice.gov/atr/case/us-and-plaintiff-states-v-a...
- TZubiri 2y agoI'm not convinced this will go anywhere. For one, the entry to compete is very low with something like Google Search, same with web browsers. I will admit that Operating Systems are winner take all monopolies and as any other such monopoly should be regulated. But everyone has the freedom to download another browser, it's open protocols which anyone can implement. And search? You literally Ctrl+L and type bing.com from a user perspective. From a competitor's perspective you just write a web crawler and run it, it's a CompSci year 1 project.
- bbor 2y agoThis isn't about browsers. It's about Display Ads, aka the images and videos you see on the side of blogs and at the start of shitty mobile games.
- riku_iki 2y agoI think complain actually about monopoly for segment of large high traffic sites which use "Publisher Ad Server", specifically newspapers and such.
- TZubiri 2y agoArticle mentions google has monopoly trifecta but doesn't clarify what that it is exactly. From the body I assumed it refers to the monopolies of: Operating System, Browser, and Search Engine. I don't see ads as being a monopoly, that's just the monetization system, of the core products. It's like saying they have a monopoly on money?
- bbor 2y agoThat's a great guess, partially because they're indeed involved in antitrust suits for all three of those at the moment! Plus the "attorney-client privelege" action as the metacherry on top. That said, I think they're talking about three monopolies within Display Ads: publisher network, ad exchange, and advertiser network. AKA "sellside", "the auction", and "buyside". I see what you're saying with monetization, but this is slightly different than what you're thinking of: this is "Display Ads", which is indeed a product (or, again, 3+ products) that they sell to others. A name you might know is "AdSense". The whole search part of their business is completely separate, and you're absolutely correct that they're a natural+benign monopoly over Google Search ads, just like Microsoft has a monopoly on Bing Search ads. But, again, this lawsuit is more about the little images and videos you see on blogs, news sites, forums, etc.
- bediger4000 2y agoI'm sorry, I have a very cynical view of this. The economics of it - don't matter. If the US couldn't break up Microsoft in 2000, all this trial indicates is that Google got on someone's bad side.
- eastbound 2y agoOr maybe the Biden administration wants to be seen doing something just before the election. “Vote for us again so we continue doing these good things that we didn’t do during the last 4 years.”
- shiroiushi 2y agoBasically in the US, with the Presidential election, you have 2 choices: one candidate who's not going to do anything useful at all, and instead will do a bunch of highly counterproductive stuff (possibly disastrous, even), and another candidate who won't do anything disastrous, probably won't do much that's counterproductive, and maybe if you're really lucky will get something that's somewhat useful passed. Great choices, huh? But obviously one is better than the other.
- jmyeet 2y agoSo the DOJ complaint alleges that Google's "monopoly" reduces publisher earnings and increases how much advertisers pay and that's where the alleged 30%+ margin Google gets comes from. If this is true, 2 of the 3 parties here are motivated to bypass Google to increase the money publishers earn and how much advertisers play, are they not? If's not that hard to set up an ad server from scratch. The issue of course is inventory. But publishers and use multiple ad servers. In fact there are tools for them to pick whichever impression will pay them the most from those available. Advertisers are free to buy on multiple platforms. At least I see no allegation that Google is actually or effectively restricting the use of other tools. So can't Google use this to say that publishers use them because they pay the most? And advertisers use them because the ads are the most effective? Advertisers in particularly are heavily metrics-focused. In the background, they're analyzing ad performance (in terms of impressions -> clicks -> action) based on audience segmentation. Now the DoubleClick cookie does have value because it's so widely deployed, Google has a lot of information to derive behavioural characteristics about the user. Just based on what sites you go to, Google builds a profile of your interests, your likely (implied) demographics and so on. You can argue that this cookie is anticompetitive. But I don't see "cookie" mentioned once in this article. So I'm really not sure where this goes. It could be the reporting just isn't great on the case because it requires some legal knowledge. I guess we'll see.
- hiddencost 2y agoNo, it is not easy to compete with Google on ad sales. It's much harder because of how much behavioral data Google hordes. If Google were to sell its behavioral user data to anyone, at a fair price, that would increase competition. If Google were to allow anyone to bid on the search page, that would increase competition. If Google stopped acquiring competitors with any sign of life, that would increase competition. If Google sold their pricing and bid matching algorithmic advances that would increase competition.
- bbor 2y agoAhh an expert! All right on, but I think you're missing the big picture: advertisers can buy from multiple (networks of) publishers, and publishers can sell to multiple (networks of) advertisers, very true. But there's a sneaky little box in the middle of that system diagram that actually coordinates all that: AdX. I think. IMO they intentionally conflate product names and acronyms in this space to confuse us lol. But either way, that box is singular -- they control some insane percentage of the market, ~~like 95% or something.~~ This is profitable for a few direct reasons (charging fees) and a lot of indirect ones (privileged insights into market trends, ability to tip the scales of auctions to favor whoever you want, a threat to hold over buyside or sellside customers that get out of line, etc). Lots of links in my other comments in here - in particular you might find "project Bernanke" of interest, if you've spent serious money on Google before. EDIT: Their exact market share is really hard to pin down... again, definitely a situation that Google encourages. But the trend is clear: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-google-monopolizing-digital-advertising-technologies https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-googl...
- asdasdsddd 2y ago> the DOJ hopes to prove that Google's alleged monopoly has shuttered newspapers across the US and threatens to do more harm if left unchecked What does this mean lol. Isn't the real reason that newpapers a shuttering because no one reads newspapers.
- braiamp 2y agoNewspapers get monetized via ads. Google search being the prime entry point was "preventing" clicks by summarizing articles. Also, Adsense being the biggest kid in the block could set prices due their position as a king maker.
- bbor 2y agoHmm close but not quite, IMO. That all happens, but this article is about Google's tendency to actively defend their monopoly over the "Ad Exchange" market, which is how publishers (newspapers) are connected to buyers of advertising space (advertisers, both brand advertisers like Coca-Cola and performance advertisers like mobile games). It's nothing complex, just the same ol' man-in-the-middle racket that impoverishes both sides as they skim off the top, confident that neither party can go to a competitor. https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/www.google.com/en//adexchange/AdExchangeOverview.pdf https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/www.google.com/en... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jedi_Blue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jedi_Blue They very much are trying to muddy the waters here, so no hate for the misunderstanding. This is the third active anti-trust suit they're currently involved in, after all! Also, as always: AFAIK ;)
- skybrian 2y agoIt doesn't look like Google summarizes news articles, though: Google News has headlines and photos. It used to have snippets, but that was many years ago. In search results, there is a very brief snippet from the article.
- pkaye 2y agoLot of newspapers in the US used to rely on money through classified ads but that was taken over by Craigslist. https://www.minnpost.com/business/2014/02/how-craigslist-killed-newspapers-golden-goose/ https://www.minnpost.com/business/2014/02/how-craigslist-kil...
- bbor 2y ago"by engaging in a systematic campaign to seize control of the wide swath of high-tech tools used by publishers, advertisers, and brokers, to facilitate digital advertising." IMO this is, by far, the most slam-dunk case against google, and the slow discovery of that fact is part of the reason I broke down while working there. This article is good, but just to make a complex issue a bit clearer: There are people who sell Display Ad space ("Publishers") and people who buy ad space ("Advertisers"). Google AdSense is a well-known name, but that's actually their division for small blogs and such -- the big bucks come in from news sites, homepages, and other high-traffic publishers that use a different product altogether. Google isn't a monopoly on the publisher side (say, ads on your "Google Home" screen in the Google app), and obviously isn't a monopoly on the advertiser side; the issue comes about in the middle of the two, the "Ad Exchange" side. Google runs the show, and has spent roughly infinity dollars to keep it that way, even though this whole segment (Display Ads) is a pretty small slice of their overall revenue. The graphic published by the DoJ does the best job of explaining the overall issue, and the pieces involved: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-google-monopolizing-digital-advertising-technologies https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-googl... For example, they staved off Facebook's short-lived attempt to break into the exchange market (a meta-market, if you will!) by drowning the issue in money, then eventually doing the corporation equivalent of "I'll pay you $5 to fuck off": cartel formation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jedi_Blue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jedi_Blue According to the draft lawsuit, Facebook agreed to reduce its participation in header bidding in return for "information, speed, and other advantages" that would come from staying with Google. Facebook allegedly would receive a guarantee of 90% of auctions regardless of the bids; 300 ms to bid (vs 160 offered to others), along with the ability to identify 80% of smartphone users and 60% of web users. But IMO by far the most egregious behavior was that time they made a cool $230M off "project Bernanke", so-named because it was deemed a "bailout" of Google's struggling Advertiser clients by favoring them in the Exchange auctions. Somehow said with a straight face! The absolute fucking brazenness of stealing from others to please your clients and grow your pocket book while honestly seeing yourself as the good guy helping out little mom n' pop advertisers is breathtaking. Article: https://adtechexplained.com/google-project-bernanke-explained/ https://adtechexplained.com/google-project-bernanke-explaine... Major points to anyone who can find the actual slides, they're made for middle managers so very digestible, and they have the hilariously illegal "ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE" warnings up top that Google is now known for. But somehow they're nowhere to be found as of today, even on Kagi. If nothing else, once the dust settles and the redactions clear this will be a fascinating snapshot of how normal, kind people are made to do wildly asocial things with a smile on their face. I never once met a single person at Google who wasn't kind, intelligent, and well-spoken. And yet...
- imiric 2y agoIt's pretty wild that the case against an adtech giant is based on its monopolistic practices and the harms it is having on publishers, rather than its privacy violations and harms to the general public and to society at large. They do mention one negative societal effect in passing: > “The result is less news where it is needed most,” Gannett’s lawsuit said. “Communities throughout the United States now do not have a suitable local paper to advise on local events." Their issue is that there are not enough newspapers(!), which as we all know are the primary source of modern information... Not that the advertising business has corrupted every form of media it touches, to the point where news outlets don't even report events that don't get them views. Advertising has been instrumental in killing journalism as we knew it, and we're all letting it continue to wreak havoc to our other institutions, because, hey... profit. > Google has accused the DOJ of having a "narrow view of the ad tech market" that's outdated and "doesn’t reflect reality." Hilarious take, considering adtech has consistently kept the ways it conducts its business hidden from public view. When users of their services are kept in the dark when their data is being collected and how value is extracted from it, is it really surprising that governments have a wildly inaccurate sense of what's going on? "Senator, we run ads."
- HWR_14 2y agoThe harms to publishers are more quantifiable than privacy violations, so it should be an easier case. Anti-trust lawsuits are about damage to the economy, not just negative outcomes.
- staplers 2y ago[flagged]
- cornel_io 2y agoJustice that is not bound by the letter of the law is not just at all.
- marginalia_nu 2y ago
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoFantastic. Hopefully Google is broken up completely. And then do Amazon and Facebook next. This mental oligarchy has gone on for too long. We need to go back to capitalism and a healthy playing field.
- doublepg23 2y agoI'd be curious if Amazon is exploiting their market position somehow but frankly they're just better than the competition. Every time I got to a brick and mortar retailer beyond Aldi I regret it. I also have many friends who work there who say it's hard work but the pay is great and there's a clear path to climb. I can't say the same about old brick and mortars.
- containedgravel 2y agoYou can both abuse your market position and offer a better service, possibly because of the former enabling it.
- Melatonic 2y agoI think usually when people talk about Amazon they are also talking about AWS - not just the consumer storefront.
- freediver 2y agoThey’re chasing ad tech monopolies but missing the point. Ads ruin user experience, violate privacy, and have become a global tax on the web - paid by the most vulnerable, non-tech-savvy users. It’s not just about competition. It’s about building something better for the people. Focus on that, and the rest will follow.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- csdreamer7 2y ago> It’s about building something better for the people. Focus on that, and the rest will follow. Strongly disagree with this part. The courts have adopted a very narrow view of anti-monopoly law focused on monopolies that increase prices. Politicians have yet to correct the courts on this. This would be a losing strategy for the executive branch.
- chii 2y ago> It’s about building something better for the people. which google has already done (their search engine). But the payment comes due.
- ApolloFortyNine 2y agoYou can only install apps on 50+% of phones in America that are approved by Apple, and they also have to grant 30% of all revenue to Apple for the privilege. Including subscriptions or even digital stores (ebooks). Imo going after for Google for antitrust is like cracking down on jwalking and ignoring the murders taking place downtown.
- jamil7 2y agoApple being worse doesn’t make Google better.
- nwienert 2y agoGoogle controls information and the wider marketplace, Apple controls hardware and a smaller marketplace, imo they're going after the right one first.
- cageface 2y agoNo but Android is the only competition Apple has and is already losing ground. If you knock Google out of that market you're just going to cement Apple's dominance, in the US where DOJ has jurisdiction, of the most important computing platform for a generation. And mobile is too hard for any newcomers to enter now.
- jamil7 2y agoMaybe, but I don't think the DOJ makes decisions this way. They'll evaluate and deal with Apple separately which I think makes sense. They can't really make the decision that yes Google is a monopoly but they'll allow it to stave off another monopoly, this is private-sector thinking. Android spun-out as an independent company might actually be a good thing for the platform allowing it operate and compete on its merits.
- cageface 2y agoEven with all of Google's backing Android is already falling behind in the US. How exactly is Android without Google behind it supposed to do better?
- teaearlgraycold 2y agoBreak them up!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ggm 2y agoI'm going to make a prediction. There may be some good outcomes from this, and some bad ones. I'd say there would be more good outcomes if Google was made to segment in several planes at once, across product and location, and if transfer pricing models were forbidden. Basically, if the EU and a competent Asian market regulator got involved as well. I don't see why alphabet can't share s.w. over the federated Google.eu and like, but with datacenter locality maintained jurisdictionally. BTW, if anyone wants to run "inevitable balkanisaion of the internet" it's an interesting topic. Because it may be true, and it may still be true more benefit than harm stems.
- Havoc 2y agoI don’t see google walking away from this unscathed. No doubt there will be much squabbling about definitions but seems pretty obvious that it is. Eg See browser market. There is basically no competition. And the competition is Firefox that Google is funding heavily to keep it alive - arguable to avoid being called a monopoly. That’s basically an admission in itself.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gerash 2y agoInstagram ads are as big as Google ads if not bigger (ask any teenager) but this DOJ is on a mission it seems.