10 ms·
Physics is unreasonably good at creating new math
- Almondsetat 2y agoCould this be a case of physics being more "tangible", thus leading to more obvious paths? Like, if you only study pure maths and you stay in your field, can you really point to a concrete direction for where to look for new stuff? In physics, your job is literally to study how the universe already behaves, so you have a frame of reference to take inspiration from and the efforts are a bit more concentrated. In fact, since models don't describe reality perfectly, you can always observe where it fails to know in which direction to attack. In maths, on the other hand, everything that is proven is correct forever. The model is reality. So it seems to be more difficult to find criticalities to look for. It's more of a "I wonder if this property does or doesn't hold" ordeal, which seems much more vague. Just a question.
- cjs_ac 2y agoOne of my physics lecturers at university made the offhand observation that the distinction between physics and mathematics is a twentieth-century idea: it wasn't made during the nineteenth century or before, and it seems to be disappearing in the twenty-first.
- goatlover 2y agoWhat does that mean? Physics is still empirical at the end of the day. Experiments decide what theories best explain the world. Math doesn't have such a requirement. It doesn't need to model natural phenomenon. Your physics lecturer sounds like a Platonist.
- tombert 2y agoI don't think OP is really wrong here. Wasn't there a debate in the late 19th century that basically asked if math had to have some mapping to the natural world, or should it work independently? I though there was some argument about this with Hilbert and Poincaré about this, and Hilbert more or less won.
- mrtesthah 2y agoSee Our mathematical universe : my quest for the ultimate nature of reality by Max Tegmark https://archive.org/details/ourmathematicalu0000tegm https://archive.org/details/ourmathematicalu0000tegm
- goatlover 2y agoThat's metaphysics not science. I'm not against metaphysics, but philosophy is distinct from physics. And it's Tegmark's particular metaphysics. Interesting but hardly a consensus among physicists or philosophers.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lupire 2y agoIt's a very weak loose statement, but I think the idea is that leading scientific and mathematical thinkers (think Newton as a quintessential example) were "natural philosophers" who studied whatever caught their interest and took it wherever it went. Astronomers invented lenses and ground them and studied the starts and developed algebra and calculus to model the observations. Some people were more narrowly focused, like Gauss who did mostly math (but an amazing breadth of math!) There was a lot of hesitancy about math that couldn't be empirically illustrated by building out of atoms, like irrational numbers and then transcendental numbers and imaginary numbers and then infinite structures.
- tines 2y ago> it wasn't made during the nineteenth century That's because people were totally focused on physics, and math was just a useful tool sometimes. Doing physics was the true goal and observation the final arbiter of truth. Nowadays, that distinction is blurred but for the opposite reason; people think that anything conceived by sound math must be true, and observation has taken a back seat.
- selectodude 2y agoTo some extent, observation has taken a back seat because we're at the point in our physics journey where we pontificate about things that are too small or too dark and far away to see. We simply can't observe this stuff anymore.
- LeifCarrotson 2y agoFurthermore, we might not be able to observe it but we can observe simulations of it. If it was not possible to simulate, I think we'd be less invested in the math and physics of it.
- TheRealPomax 2y agoFurthermore, even if you can write down the math, it might not even be solvable (sometimes provably so) and simulations (or more accurately, numerical analysis and the finite element method) are our only option.
- dizzant 2y agoThis is an interesting take, the article touches on it too. > “Physicists are much less concerned than mathematicians about rigorous proofs,” says Timothy Gowers, a mathematician at the Collège de France and a Fields Medal winner. Sometimes, he says, that “allows physicists to explore mathematical terrain more quickly than mathematicians.” GP is right that the currently observed physical laws go far beyond our ability to observe them in reality because of the cost of observations. International effort over decades is required to create facilities capable of making helpful new observations: think of LHC, LIGO, James Webb, etc. On the other hand, once the facilities are built and ground-breaking observations appear, we suddenly have a debt of theoretical and simulated exploration to understand all their implications. The low cost of computation greatly extends the value we can take from every truly new observation of reality. In order to observe something new, we must be able differentiate it from something already understood. It seems like the physics and math communities are currently in a season of increasing our understanding of the existing models well enough to motivate trying to break them.
- tech_ken 2y agoWell also the idea of physics as the field we currently have didn't exist much before the 17th century. Movement of bodies, astronomy, fluid dynamics, electromagnetics, optics, etc. all kind of were their own thing (if they existed at all). Fundamental developments in calculus in the late 1600s enabled these subjects to be collected under one method of study/analysis which we now call physics. As much of modern math follows from the lineage of calculus the border between the things being modeled and the tools for modeling them is naturally kind of blurry, however the distinction did still exist quite strongly throughout this entire period. Look at ex. probability or algebra, although often researchers were pursuing both physics and math, they were aware that the subjects were distinct.
- nobodyandproud 2y agoIt—that is, science at the time—all fell under the umbrella term of natural philosophy.
- waterhouse 2y agoMathematics is a part of physics. Physics is an experimental science, a part of natural science. Mathematics is the part of physics where experiments are cheap. — V.I. Arnold: "On teaching mathematics" (1997)
- janalsncm 2y agoPhysics is the subset of mathematics with physical application. However mathematics need not have physical applications in order to be valid math.
- trashtester 2y agoPure Calculus is not Physics even though it has applications in Physics. Just like English isn't Physics even if you can have describe aspects of Physics using English. For Math and English to be Physics, it needs to specifically define what physical meaning the variables and parameters involved have. Typically, you recognize it as Physics when it comes with units.
- naasking 2y agoMath probably split off a bit because of the attempts at formalization. That was a useful tangent though, arguably giving us computer science via the lambda calculus, Turing machines, etc.
- SkiFire13 2y agoI would argue that in the twenty-first century the distinction is even greater thanks to computer science.
- namaria 2y agoI think you don't understand enough physics, maths or cs if you think there's a way to draw a neat line between any pair of them.
- SkiFire13 2y agoSaying that there's a distinction between them is different than drawing a neat line. Surely you aren't arguing that they're the same discipline instead?
- FromTheSteppe 2y agoHaha in my country half the computer science degrees are titled "Applied Mathematics".
- hirvi74 2y agoSuch a title makes me feel like I might come off smarter than I actually am -- I like it. Especially when considering my mathematically understanding and abilities.
- speedchess 2y ago> One of my physics lecturers at university made the offhand observation that the distinction between physics and mathematics is a twentieth-century idea: It's actually a 19th century idea. The discovery or acceptance of non-euclidean geometry in the 19th century untethered math from physics or physics from math. > and it seems to be disappearing in the twenty-first. It can't disappear because math is no longer tied to the physical world. Math is simply theorem generation regardless of whether the axioms and theorems apply to the physical world. The math used in physics is only a tiny subset of possible math.
- Onavo 2y agoPhysics is also great for machine learning, though the approaches can be rather unintuitive. For example message passing and belief propagation in trees/graphs (Bayesian networks, Markov random fields etc.) for modeling latent variables are usually taught using the window/rainy weather marginal probability analogy and involves splitting out a bayesian/statistical equation into subcomponents via the marginalization chain rule. For physicists however, they tend to teach it using Ising models and magnetic spin, which is a totally different analogy. A lot of the newer generative ML models are also using differential equations/Boltzmann distribution based approaches (state space models, "energy based" models) where the statistical formulations are cribbed wholesale from statistical physics/mechanics and then plugged into a neural network and autodiff system. The best example is probably the Metropolis-Hastings algorithm which was invented by nuke people. https://web.archive.org/web/20150603234436/http://flynnmichael.com/2015/06/01/my-favorite-algorithm-metropolis-hastings/ https://web.archive.org/web/20150603234436/http://flynnmicha...
- whimsicalism 2y agoWhat modern ML uses those techniques? my understanding is ebm is quite rare
- Onavo 2y agoResearch mostly, lots of these techniques are used for speech synthesis and occasionally image models (not LLMs)
- hangsi 2y agoThe common method for choosing the next output token for an LLM is sampling from a Boltzmann distribution. If you have seen the term "temperature" in the context of language models, that is a direct link to the statistical gas mechanics.
- whimsicalism 2y agoi don't find the connection between softmax and boltzmann really all that deep tbh (compared to say, the connection between field theory/ising models and EBM)
- verzali 2y ago> “Bad” physics can sometimes lead to good math. cf. string theory
- crazydoggers 2y agoI’m not sure how it could be otherwise. On some level mathematics is a description of reality that we can use to compute things in reality. For example, pi is the ratio of a circle’s circumference to its diameter. It’s just what a circle is in two dimensions. The value of pi isn’t any more mysterious or connected to physics than the existence of this thing called a circle. If you have some other Euclidean shapes you’ll have other ratios and values that have other relationships to other things in physical reality. And if reality was different, hence the physical laws were different then the math would be different.. and the beings in that world might wonder why their math and physics were so interconnected.
- vehemenz 2y ago> On some level mathematics is a description of reality that we can use to compute things in reality. This is contested by nominalists. They'd say you have it backwards. Mathematics is just an abstraction/language that can be used as a tool. The reason we're able to understand the world through mathematics says more about the power of mathematics than it does about the world. If the physical world were different, math would still work.
- gitaarik 2y agoWell if the fundamental constants were different, math would still work the same way. But if a universe acts in a completely different way, say like a dream world, where they is no logical physical causaulity, our universe's math would be irrelevant. You could still think about it but it would be irrelevant to that universe, and not applicable. And so you would also not be able to derive that math from within this universe, at least not the same math as ours. So we have to admit that our mathematics is tied to the universe we inhabit.
- vehemenz 2y agoThe properties of the universe affects mathematics insofar as matter is organized and living agents have a use for it, but its abstractions and logical relations still do not require the universe. I think a metaphysical position like physicalism would have to be invoked for that.
- throw0101b 2y agoSee also perhaps the article "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences": * https://web.archive.org/web/20210212111540/http://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/MathDrama/reading/Wigner.html https://web.archive.org/web/20210212111540/http://www.dartmo... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unreasonable_Effectiveness_of_Mathematics_in_the_Natural_Sciences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unreasonable_Effectiveness...
- jordanpg 2y ago`"Well, now you are pushing your joke too far," said the classmate, "surely the population has nothing to do with the circumference of the circle."` I've always loved this line and paraphrase it often. It's an eminently reasonable and yet accidentally profound thing to say.
- glenstein 2y agoI understand that one huge reason for Ed Witten's optimism about strong theory is this very fact. That, in his terms, the process of building out string theory has led to the uncovering of so much "buried treasure" in the form of novel developments of maths. Of course it's not anything like a proof but something that bolsters an intuition.
- 77pt77 2y agoAnd that amounted to 60 years (and counting) of absolutely nothing in terms of how the physical world works. Even Witten's achievements objectively reduce to an alternate proof of the positivity energy theorem in GR. This is an abject failure by all metrics.
- paulpauper 2y agoAnd that amounted to 60 years (and counting) of absolutely nothing in terms of how the physical world works. this is in part because it's outside the scope of existing technology
- glenstein 2y agoWitten has revolutionized mathematical physics, and his development of topological quantum field theory was nothing short of monumental. Much of Witten's own point above is that advancements in string theory have cashed out in revolutionary new mathematical approaches that would be of lasting value even string theory itself never receives any experimental confirmation. I think article highlights something very beautiful about how physics, including string theory, have lead to the creation of new math, and how that is suggestive of an unmet promise. To ignore that just to come in and repeat for the 1000th time the world's most repeated thing about string theory, and take a completely unnecessary cheap shot at Ed Witten is the perfect embodiment of why comment sections can too often be a depressing waste of time.
- 77pt77 2y agoThe only cheap thing here is the amount of actual physics that came out of all of this ptolemaic endeavor. And writing ptolemaic is probably too charitable because the Almagest at least predicted movements quite well at the time (apparently it now deviates too much).
- marcosdumay 2y agoTry to make some innovative software product without talking to any user. You'll see why physics is good at crating new math.
- slashdave 2y agoDo you value the quality of a mathematical theory by the number of applications, or the intrinsic beauty of the theory itself?
- Retric 2y agoTo be beautiful it must first exist. It’s far more difficult to come up with novel mathematics without some external inspiration.
- munk-a 2y agoI judge the beauty of math and code by the how concisely and simply they can model the object in question - if the math exists abstractly and isn't trying to model any actual thing or concept it isn't particularly beautiful to me because it isn't an accomplishment of expressiveness - it's instead just a coincidence that if you put some symbols together you only need those symbols. There are, of course, times that concise expressions aren't possible and multiple strange and arbitrary values come into play (coefficients of friction or earth's gravity at sea level aren't particular nice numbers or expressions) and that just tends to highlight how beautiful things are when those icky real-world numbers can be canceled out and you're left with a clean expression.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- qubyte 2y agoThis is really interesting to me. It could imply that an ugly theorem is less valuable. What if a theorem is ugly but useful vs a beautiful but esoteric one?
- mrguyorama 2y ago
- 77pt77 2y ago“Physicists are much less concerned than mathematicians about rigorous proofs. ... That allows physicists to explore mathematical terrain more quickly than mathematicians.” The end. There's no magic here.
- tech_ken 2y ago> Hitchin agrees. “Mathematical research doesn’t operate in a vacuum,” he says. “You don’t sit down and invent a new theory for its own sake. You need to believe that there is something there to be investigated. New ideas have to condense around some notion of reality, or someone’s notion, maybe.” This is kind of it I think. It's not just physics that drives interesting math, and it's not just recently that this relationship holds. Math is, IM humble O, the ultimate domain-specific language. It's a tool we use to model things, and then often it turns out that the model is interesting in its own right. Trying to model new things (ex. new concepts of reality) yields models that are interesting in new ways, or which recontextualize older models; and and so we need to reorganize, condense, generalize, etc; and so the field develops.
- verisimi 2y agoI agree, I think. I would say it like so, that maths is a sort of highly technical, rigorous language, but like any language it will describe what you want it to. It is easy to think that it is describing the underlying terrain, but it is actually working on three (shared) and model which have of the terrain. So, as we consider different things, maths will follow.
- TheOtherHobbes 2y agoIts grammar is limited in ways we don't understand, because the grammar is based on abstractions of our experiences of the world and the relationships between them. If we can't imagine entire classes of relationship - likely because we do not have limitless intelligence - then the model will always be a partial analogy, not a full and complete abstraction.
- verisimi 2y agoI think we agree.
- groos 2y agoG.H. Hardy would like to disagree. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Mathematician%27s_Apology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Mathematician%27s_Apology
- graycat 2y agoPhysics research gets funded because of applications, existing or promising, for curiosity, fundamental science, the economy, medicine, and national security, etc. Since math can help physics research, that research is funded and motivated to make applications of math, old or new. Math alone is less involved with applications.
- torrefatto 2y agoThis is the well known litany from string theorists to try and justify the inordinate amount of money threw at them to get back nothing of physical value: no falsifiable prediction. Instead of reasoning on the worth of the effort spent in this direction to investigate nature (a very tangible companion) they try to steer the discourse toward this nonsense. We spent >50 years listening to these tales and the time has long passed since we are required to stop playing with these smoke and mirrors.
- jjk166 2y ago> justify the inordinate amount of money threw at them They're theorists, you're paying for pencils and paper. String theory may not have produced a theory of quantum gravity yet, but neither has any other line of inquiry.
- paulpauper 2y agosorta. the construction of particle accelerators has been justified to test the hypotheses of string theory
- torrefatto 2y agoYou are wrong. Particle accelerators have been built since way before any string theory was formulated. The biggest and most powerful existing accelerator (LHC) has been built to fulfill the high energy/high luminosity requirements to explore the Highs boson energy regime (that has been found) and at most the lightest supersymmetric particles (not found as of today). The Higgs boson is a cornerstone of the Standard Model. Supersymmetry is an extension to it that does not involve strings. https://home.web.cern.ch/science/physics/supersymmetry https://home.web.cern.ch/science/physics/supersymmetry
- torrefatto 2y agoYou are right, the amount of money spent in string theory proposals has been staggering if you take into account the size of the field. For decades competing (or even just non-aligned) research lines have been starved to feed this behemoth.
- jmyeet 2y agoI'm not a physics or math whiz but isn't the relationship more of a virtuous cycle? I think I read that the 20th century was a revolution because of the marriage between physics and math. Quarternions are key to relativity. Discrete math is littered all over quantum mechanics and the Standard Model. Like U(1) describes electromagnetism, SU(2) describes the weak force and SU(3) describes the strong nuclear force. In particular the mass of the 3 bosons that mediate the weak force is what led directly to the Higgs mechanism being theorized (and ultimately shown experimentally). One of the great advances of the 20th century was that we (provably) found every finite group. And those groups keep showing up in physics. The article mentions how string theory has led to new mathematics. This is really interesting. I'm skeptical of string theory just because there's no experimental evidence for "compact dimensions". It seems like a fudge. But interestingly there have been useful results in both physics and maths based on if string theory was correct.
- throwawaymaths 2y agoWe need "beermaking is unreasonably good at creating new stats"
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoDo we know if it’s better at creating new math than other fields? For example, computers sure created a lot of new math. Statistics was entirely driven by external pressure from medicine, social sciences, and business. Finance and economics created a lot of math around modeling and probability. And so on.
- marxisttemp 2y agohttps://archive.ph/yUiis https://archive.ph/yUiis
- slashdave 2y agoIf you want to bring physics and mathematics closer together, then string theory is a rather bad example to follow.
- pyb 2y ago"Mathematics is the part of physics where experiments are cheap." (V.I. Arnol'd)
- 77pt77 2y agoArnold was an unusual high quality thinker.
- aithrowaway1987 2y ago> Might there be certain laws of physics that are also “necessary” in the same way? In his paper, Molinini argues that the principle of conservation may be one such law. In physics, some properties of a system, such as energy or momentum, can’t change. A bicyclist freewheeling down a hill, for example, is converting her gravitational potential energy into movement energy, but the total amount of energy she and her bike have stays the same. Arithmetic itself is a consequence of physical conservation: if you have a collection of four acorns, another collection of three acorns, then combine them without dropping an acorn, then you must have a collection of seven acorns. It is our deep physical understanding of space and causality which leads to simple arithmetic being intuitively true to most (if not all) vertebrates. (If the squirrel only got six acorns after combining then there must be a causal explanation for the quantitative discrepancy; another squirrel stole an acorn from the older stash, or maybe it fell in a hole.)
- nyc111 2y agoThe subject of study of physics is "physical quantity" which is defined as a number with a unit. Physical quantity doesn't have to be a "physical" quantity. So physics does not study exclusively physical objects. I think this is how mathematics and physics are related, mathematics does not deal with units (except unity).
- goldfeld 2y agoObviously, physics never creates any math but discovers it, there are no new things under the sun.
- MaxPock 2y agoDiscovered Vs invented
- fuzzfactor 2y ago>Physics is unreasonably good at creating new math Newly devised math also seems to be unreasonably good at creating new particles. Not out of thin air, nothing like that, truly out of stuff thinner than air!
- imchillyb 2y agoDiscoveries are made and measurements are taken with the tools available. The measurements, theories, and currently understood or applicable math may not match up with observations. People ponder and discover, then attempt to explain the observations and measurements with a new theory. If the theory pans out, a deeper explanation of that theory is necessary and that's where the new math's at. It's not that physics is good at creating math. Physics is good at describing our observations /with/ math. That's kind of its whole job. Next time you look at raindrops in a puddle, try to imagine how you would describe those movements scientifically. One needs math for that. Sometimes the available tools and math are sufficient for a thorough explanation, and sometimes one needs to invent a universe of math to describe a tiny fluctuation.
- tim333 2y agoI've long thought physics is a subsection of maths and reality is a mathematical object that exists the same way that prime numbers or the Mandelbrot set do. Hence the unreasonable effectiveness of one in the other.
- jjgreen 2y agoA physicist, walking home at night, spots a mathematician colleague under a street lamp staring at the ground, "something wrong?" he asks; "I've dropped my keys" he replies, "whereabouts?" asks the physicist, keen to help. "Over there" says the mathematician pointing; "So why don't you look over there?" retorts the physicist, "the light is better here" says the mathematician. Disclosure, I'm a mathematician.
- mettamage 2y agoI don’t get it. Disclosure: I’m a software developer
- Ankaios 2y agoNon-software-developer humans often use things called "lamps" to illuminate spaces at night. Unfortunately, illumination inhibits effective nighttime coding.
- hirvi74 2y ago> humans often use things called "lamps" to illuminate spaces at night I call those "monitors."
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 2y agoThat's a bug. We should fix that.
- sameoldtune 2y agoMathematicians like to develop new math right at the boundary of what is known. Physicists don’t have that luxury because they have to describe/model/build/etc things that correlate to what is actually going on in the world. The mathematician of this joke would scan the edge of the light, finding nothing. Then he would keep lighting little lanterns at the perimeter to make the lighted area larger until finally his keys were within sight. The physicist in this joke would presumably root around in the dark where she thinks her keys actually were. Upon finding them through brute force and luck, she might think “wow maybe one day this place will be illuminated so I can tell wtf I just did”
- pseudostem 2y agoFeynman on mathematicians vs physicist https://youtu.be/obCjODeoLVw?si=2akBzyo-fC2j90OH https://youtu.be/obCjODeoLVw?si=2akBzyo-fC2j90OH Entertaining viewpoint
- scotty79 2y agoString theory seems more like a branch o mathematics than anything else.
- deeznuttynutz 2y agoWe have lived long enough to see Physics become Modern Math and create no new provable Physics
- Anon84 2y agoAs one of my Physics Professors once said, "Math is Physics without a purpose." (I was once a reasonably successful Physicist, so I might be biased :D)
- openrisk 2y ago> the mathematics of known physics is just a tiny fraction of all the mathematics out there But the opposite is also true: the physical reality that has been explained by mathematical thinking is just a tiny fraction of all the reality out there.
- niemandhier 2y agoI think it’s the other way: math is unreasonable good at describing physics! Imagine a universe where the laws are best described in iambic hexameters under the condition that the last letters of the stanzas form specific words. The ancients held some believes like that: kabala, astrology and the like. How wonderfully absurd it must have felt to them that the answer was something even more removed from reality.