11 ms·
State of S3 – Your Laptop is no Laptop anymore – a personal Rant
- misiek08 2y ago> Apples move to force USB-C on everyone It wasn’t Apple move. They were forced with possibility to loose whole EU market if they don’t.
- agubelu 2y agoThey surely weren't forced to create laptops with no other ports than USB-C
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rationably 2y agoCan relate, try searching "s0ix battery drain".
- mintplant 2y agoMy new ThinkPad, which I absolutely love otherwise, keeps the CPU fans running if I put it to "sleep". Which left me completely flabbergasted the first time it happened! I've had to force-enable hibernation and use that for any kind of backpack travel. Which will shorten the lifespan of the SSD, but what else am I supposed to do?
- gertop 2y agoYou can reenable S3 support on many thinkpads, it's in the bios they call it "Linux sleep".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mintplant 2y agoUnfortunately not on mine, it's unsupported at the hardware level :/ This is the norm for newer laptops sadly.
- matejn 2y agoI think Windows will shorten the lifespan of your SSD even if you use "shut down", at least if you don't disable "fast startup". "Fast startup" basically replaces "shut down" with a light form of hiberation, which makes shutting the machine down take a long while and turning it on about a second faster. Not worth the tradeoff in my opinion. I also got some bugs when using fast startup, sometimes the sound wouldn't work until a reboot or my WiFi took weirdly long to connect. This is on a Lenovo Yoga/IdeaPad.
- chippiewill 2y agoUnfortunately a lot of Laptop manufacturers were forced to leave the fans on all the time due to overheating which would cause battery issues if they didn't run the fans. I remember getting a BIOS update on my Dell a few years ago that permanently turned the fan on too.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoThere shouldn't be any overheating when in S3, from what power usage ?? And they can wait to switch to S3 (and shut down the fans) once the temperature got low enough, a bit like how with S3+swap, the computer won't enter suspend until the RAM has been copied to swap.
- vladvasiliu 2y agoIs it running Windows? I've found that on Linux this specific issue doesn't happen, it will turn off the fans, and they will stay off. But the battery is still drained, even though, on average, I tend to get better battery life than with Windows on the same machine. But Windows tends to wake it up randomly and do God knows what, since the PC will actually be hot to the touch. Bonus points for attempting to install updates, then reboot, only to end up stuck waiting for the BitLocker PIN.
- liminalsunset 2y agoThe BitLocker thing is definitely a problem. On Apple systems which have a similar FDE system, the preboot environment will shut the machine down if the page is left open for too long. The CPU/GPU (if present) are in a pre-power-management state during this time too, so the laptop will really heat up. I wonder how limited the preboot BitLocker screen environment really is. Could there could be some flag set by the UEFI that says "I'm a laptop and the lid is closed without power connected, shut down after a timeout".
- vladvasiliu 2y agoIn my case, my computers will end up on that screen in two cases. The first is my desktop, without a TPM, which will ask for a BitLocker password. In this case, if I'm not fast enough, it will shut down the computer. The second is my work laptop, which I usually expect to reboot or otherwise am around when it ends up there, in which case I'll usually type in the PIN quickly enough. However, I expect it to have a similar behavior as the first case, although I haven't tried. But the reason I know this happens, is that I once left this PC attached to my 32" screen next to my bed, and it woke me up at night. I just went and forcibly shut off the thing.
- liminalsunset 2y agoSo apparently this is actually configurable, but it's either on or off, and it's set to one minute by default (either 1 minute or no shutdown, no inbetween). The command in question is ```bcdedit /set {bootmgr} bootshutdowndisabled 1```. https://www.tenforums.com/antivirus-firewalls-system-security/103966-bitlocker-tpm-pin-laptop-shuts-down-after-60-seconds.html https://www.tenforums.com/antivirus-firewalls-system-securit...
- paranoidrobot 2y ago> Which will shorten the lifespan of the SSD Technically true, but not enough for you to notice. Modern SSDs have drive write lifetimes in the high hundreds of TB of writes. If you had 128GB of memory in your laptop, writing that down to disk isn't going to consume much of that write lifetime.
- immibis 2y agoOn the contrary, you're telling me that shutting the laptop lid three times a day for a year will wear out the SSD by 20% of its lifespan.
- calineczka 2y agoWhat you say and the math does not agree. Do it 10x and in your scenario already 1TB is consumed of those "hundreds of TB of writes".
- paranoidrobot 2y agoMost laptops don't have 128GB RAM, they're probably 16GB or 32GB. Samsung warranties their 990 Pro SSD at 600TBW for 1TB, 1200TBW on 2TB, and 2400TBW on 4TB. So, lets assume you've got a laptop with 32GB RAM and a 1TB SSD. If you hibernate it 3x per day. After 10 years you'll have used 350TB of your writes. (32GB * 3) * 365.25d * 10y = 350.64TB
- redundantly 2y agoIf your notebook has 16 GB of RAM that needs to be written out every time it hibernates, and you do that three times a day, five days a week, you’d accumulate about 63 TB of writes over five years. That’s roughly a third of the TBW rating for an average 256 GB SSD. A typical 1 TB SSD would have three times the endurance or more. I think your SSD will handle it just fine. :)
- was_a_dev 2y agoI'd say 1/3rd is a rather large chunk of an SSDs TBW if its just for hibernating. In practice, for reasons you outlined, it would be a smaller amount but I would only find 1-2% tolerable.
- redundantly 2y agoChances are, the computer will break or be replaced in five years or less. It doesn’t really matter if you reach 2%, 33%, or even 90% of the TBW if the system or component is replaced before it uses up all its writes.
- consteval 2y ago> Chances are, the computer will break or be replaced in five years or less. I think this is less and less true as time goes on. I have a laptop from 5 ish years ago I still use and it's actually pretty fast. And, even so, it's not like the ONLY wear on your SSD is the hibernation. So this 5 year figure, I'm not sure it's right. I think, maybe if you're someone who stresses your hard drives a lot (maybe you work with photography or videography?) hibernation might make an impactful difference.
- redundantly 2y agoThe five-year estimate is based solely on hibernation writes, which is a very conservative figure. In reality, most users will use closer to 2% of the TBW for hibernation, not 33%. For those with heavy I/O workloads, they likely have higher-grade or larger SSDs with a higher TBW rating. Additionally, TBW isn’t a hard limit and can often be exceeded, with some drives lasting beyond 200%. For most users, TBW won’t be an issue, and other components are more likely to fail before the drive wears out.
- amne 2y agoLTT had a rant about this [modern sleep] and I really hoped it would draw some attention given his size and reach. It is truly mind-blowing that not even Apple got it right.
- nottorp 2y agoFrom personal experience, it's still safe to never shut down an apple laptop, just throw it in the backpack/suitcase and it will be cool and with the same battery at the destination. Tbh all my Apple laptops, including the piece of shit one with the emoji keyboard, have had no problem sleeping. Ofc that's on mac os, not sure what they offer if you install linux or windows.
- mschuster91 2y agomacOS has its own fair share of sleep bugs, particularly stuff like Parallels, IntelliJ or MS Teams for whatever reason routinely manage to prevent sleep or to randomly activate and hog the dGPU, turning a "lap top" to a "testicle airfryer". More than once I went on a train ride to the office, having clicked "Suspend" in the main menu and watching the screen go black before placing the laptop in my bag, just to find out the battery was completely drained and the 2019 MBP so hot that it not just required cooling down before it would power up again but also hot enough to fry an egg - an IR thermometer showed 70 °C! If anyone knows or writes an application that could place a red warning icon in the menu bar warning me that "suspending" will not actually work, I'll be glad to exchange it for a crate of beer.
- nottorp 2y ago> particularly stuff like Parallels, IntelliJ or MS Teams for whatever reason routinely manage to prevent sleep or to randomly activate and hog the dGPU mac os is nice enough to allow applications to prevent sleep. Check "pmset -g assertions" to point out the culprit. A couple years ago it was Chrome for me. It kept an assertion saying "WebRTC has active peer connections" on all the time. This has only lead me to have a pathological hatred for WebRTC and I turn it off in all my browsers now. As for the dGPU, i've never had one but I do have a feeling that spells trouble, especially with these electron apps and their Helper (GPU) processes. I'm old fashioned enough to do most of my work on desktops that are plugged in and only buy lightweight laptops (13-14 inch mbpros wit no discrete GPU).
- daft_pink 2y agoI’m hopeful that ARM based laptops will have better power management on Linux. Totally agree with what you have written. Ironically though, Microsoft standby sucks on Linux and Windows. Happy to be running a Mac. I’m curious how well Asahi linux works with standby on a Apple Silicon Mac.
- vladvasiliu 2y agoIME experience, at least on HP G8 EliteBooks, both AMD and Intel, Linux actually keeps the machine quiet and cool during "modern standby". With Windows, it absolutely will turn on the fans at some point, and the machine absolutely will get hot for whatever reason. This seems to have been fixed for a while now (say a year or so), but when the Intel machine was new, Windows would sometimes not wake up from sleep, or if did, the screen would be garbled. The AMD still has an issue where Windows will "unexpectedly shutdown" (according to the event log) during modern standby. This happens every single time I leave it on standby during the night. This is an almost four-year-old machine by now, not some brand-spanking-new thing, which works otherwise perfectly, especially on Linux.
- daft_pink 2y agoIt’s not so much the heat that bothers most people, but the fact that when you close the lid of a windows laptop and throw it in your backpack, it will be totally out of battery, be running and you have to actually physically turn it off. Simply close the lid ane leave it in your backpack on a Mac and it will still retain most of it’s charge. I think most people intend their laptop to retain it’s charge when they close the lid and standby used to do this, but on windows machines, it really doesn’t anymore. It should really write all the ram to hd after a short period of time in your backpack instead of quickly depleting the battery.
- vladvasiliu 2y ago> It should really write all the ram to hd after a short period of time in your backpack instead of quickly depleting the battery. In the default config on my machine, it actually starts to hibernate if it's asleep and unplugged for a while. Don't know what the delay is.
- moffkalast 2y agoMy old ASUS laptop that triggers complete poweroff when a sleep command is sent to the motherboard, making sure you lose any work you had open as punishment for assuming it had a sleep mode: "I'm four parallel universes ahead of you."
- gnampolo 2y agoWell, they're making the world harder to live in every day. So also acquiring a new laptop is now a pain in the ass... good to know.
- tim333 2y agoOr get a Macbook Air. Got the M1 in a few minutes in John Lewis and still good. No sleep problems, no fan to whirr. The previous Macbook Air 11 also was great for sleep/wake. The Windows 7 Thinkpad before that was ok but took like 30 seconds to restart from sleep and would crash sometimes.
- sakjur 2y ago> Therefore Consumers have the option to state their disapproval with the current state of S0ix by buying Laptops that still support S3. I’d like to do this, as I find a laptop that cannot last in sleep for at least a week ill-suited for my needs. Where do I go to figure out if my next laptop supports proper sleep?
- BlueTemplar 2y agoYou would think that reviewers (especially professional ones) would point that issue out ?
- dammaj 2y agoI didn't know S3 vs S0 but this may be the reason why I never keep my laptop in sleep mode and I prefer to put it in hibernate. What about hibernate? Couldn't it be an alternative to the "legacy sleep"?
- shiroiushi 2y agoHibernate mode takes a long time to enter and exit, as it involves writing a lot of data to disk and then reading it back upon resuming. The whole point of Sleep mode is that it's fast: you just close the lid and you're in sleep mode, saving power. Then if you want to check something quickly, or resume your work, you just open the lid and in a few seconds or less, your computer is fully operational again.
- dammaj 2y agoWell, you're right but of Sleep is impractical with S0 mode as explained, hibernate with slightly longer transition time may be acceptable. Hibernate has really became fast on modern computers.
- consteval 2y agoYou're in luck, Windows shutdown is now actually hibernate (and has been for a few years). So if you just shutdown your laptop, you've been using this hibernate for a while. Turns out all those people saying "shut down your laptop before you close the lid!" were actually right.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoAre you sure about this ? Hibernate = S4 https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Power_management/Suspend_and_hibernate https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Power_management/Suspend_an... Do you get all your workspace back exactly like it was before, after a shutdown and turn on again ?
- urbandw311er 2y ago> Microsoft describes S3 as “Legacy Sleep” There’s something breathtakingly arrogant about that
- shiroiushi 2y ago>There’s something breathtakingly arrogant about that "Breathtakingly arrogant" is pretty much exactly what I would think of if someone asked me to describe Microsoft in 2 words.
- netruk44 2y agoAs someone who used to work at Microsoft, this is spot on. The sheer amount of arrogance coming from (some of) my peers who worked there was incredible. Microsoft decides for you how you would like to use your computer. If you don't agree, use Linux. Or Mac, but Apple is really no better than Microsoft with regard to arrogance.
- consteval 2y agoI'd say Apple is even more arrogant, but at least their software is arrogantly functional. Maybe I could look past this sleep nonsense if their super cool new sleep actually worked. But it just doesn't, instead it cooks your laptop 10% of the time and it you open it up and it's dead.
- DoingIsLearning 2y agoWords matter in this case. The fact that they are pushing S3 as "Linux Sleep" or "Legacy Sleep" and S0ix as "modern sleep" is absolutely not innocent from a marketing perspective. We ought to reverse Uno this non-sense. Perhaps the Linux Foundation and all the distro development teams out there should start calling S3 _True_Sleep_™ in all their official communication.
- Terr_ 2y agoNot-Spyware Sleep.
- minkles 2y agoI have no idea how this is still as fucked as it is. Nothing in this space has worked properly ever. Moved to Apple Silicon in 2021 after my Dell Precision cooked itself (and my lunch!) to death in my bag on a train. No issues since.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoIt's gotten better but it's very dependent on chipsets and driver support for those. I have one Samsung laptop with an Intel chipset that more or less goes standby reliably. Sometimes it still messes up and it's dead when you open it. But mostly it's fine and it's gotten more rare with recent kernel versions. The fingerprint reader is pretty much the only thing that doesn't work on that laptop and probably never will because it's a cheap Chinese thing with some proprietary firmware. The core issue is that the firmware in most laptops is just ancient garbage and nobody seems to really care about it. Apple has full ownership over their own firmware so it's less of an issue for them (though it still has issues). But most chip manufacturers servicing the wintel laptop market treat software as an afterthought. They aren't very good at it and they just put in the minimum effort that they can get away with. So, it's all proprietary, poorly designed, decades old, etc. If it breaks they bang on it until it sort of works again (windows only). Laptop makers then make things worse by just buying a lot of cheap components. Synaptic seems popular for touch pads, for example. My Samsung has one. It's not good. I've actually never come across anything made by them that wasn't garbage. With Linux slowly creeping up in market share on desktops, it's something that could start changing. Most Linux users are very selective in what they buy and there are certain brands that are just so hopeless that people actively avoid them. Lenovo bought a good reputation from IBM when they acquired their laptop division. That's ages ago but they sort of nurtured that and it's probably helped a lot. It's not rocket science to just make sure things work on Linux. My work laptop is a macbook. The hardware is just miles ahead of the competition. It's just not even close. Everything else is a major downgrade. I bought that Samsung to replace a mac because I was waiting for the M1 to come out when my old laptop died. I worked on that thing for half a year. Going back to a mac was just such major upgrade in every way possible. You forget how great they are. Software wise I'm actually fine with Linux. Everything I use is open source or available for Linux. I don't use any of the Apple software (the i* stuff). I'm there for the hardware only. If Linux support catches up, I might switch actually.
- ericcholis 2y agoS3 basically killed a perfectly good Dell XPS 15 a few years ago. The fan would never stop running.
- minkles 2y agoI think every Dell Precision 5550 in our company died from thermal issues within a year. All cooked. At least yours was trying to stay cool!
- churros_train 2y agoFor anyone reading this, I thought S3 was referring to the AWS S3 and was really confused initially. Instead S3 here refers to a sleep state - https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/how-to-enable-s3-sleep-state-and-disable-modern/507c85fb-977d-4891-b5b1-d302c918ee0e https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/how-to....
- airtonix 2y ago[dead]
- echelon 2y agoSame! It's unfortunate that the names collide. I was also totally confused. From the article, > Traditional Sleep requires all system hardware and software components to work together. The operating system must support Sleep, as well as the hardware (e.g. CPU) and the BIOS/UEFI. According to the UEFI to Hardware Interface Standard (ACPI), this usual form of sleep is referred to as S3. S3 is a Sleep State in which all system components, except for the RAM and CPU Cache, are powered off.
- kristianp 2y agoI agree, the term "S3 Sleep" would be better, I think it would be understood by many in the audience of HN.
- jll29 2y agoMe too - to those using acronyms and other abbreviations in their writing, even "obvious ones": it is a good practice to introduce what each stands for the first time it gets used. ACL = Access Control List / Association for Computational Linguistics AAA = Authentication Authorization, Accounting / American Automobile Association / Triple-A Battery Size ... S3 = AWS Simple Storage Service / ACPI Sleep States: S3 is one of them, they range from S0 - S5) / Suspend-to-Idle (S0ix) "Windows 10" mode selected in system firmware, "s2idle" selected in /sys/power/mem_sleep, and Suspend-to-RAM (S3)
- liminalsunset 2y agoIs there any application of "Modern Standby" that is actually delivering significant value to customers somewhere? A lot of the theoretical benefits of it, IMO, have been relatively theoretical. Perhaps Windows updates, but the computers I've used with Modern Standby still have to spend time installing updates when awake. I cannot imagine what the benefit of receiving notifications and other information like this on a Windows system would be. As far as I know, very, very few apps are programmed for the native "App" development flow (or even to use the notifications api) as opposed to "desktop" apps, and the number only gets smaller as you go into long tail enterprise apps. Perhaps this was designed for Outlook, but I think the use case is dubious. Of course, there are millions of laptops in the wild, many of which are undoubtedly used by the people who work on Windows. Every time I find the laptop closed and running its fans, or find a computer in a bag that is slightly warm near the CPU (expected behaviour of working Modern Standby), I wonder whether it's just my computer or if it's every single one of them out there. Do people just accept that their computer has to be either shut down or will have an unknown amount of remaining power? It seems like there would have been a huge push to get this fixed if it was really broken, but I rarely hear users talking about it. Of course I do wonder whether with the advent of the new Qualcomm ARM CPUs, whether they have finally managed to get Modern Standby to be a good clone of what Android devices do...
- shiroiushi 2y ago>Is there any application of "Modern Standby" that is actually delivering significant value to customers somewhere? Why is this important, or even something to consider? The only thing that's important with Windows and features in it is whether something delivers value to Microsoft.
- creshal 2y agoBut does it? Nobody asked for it, it's not even meaningfully used by any Microsoft product and can't drive sales for them, its endless litany of bugs just increase support workloads.
- shiroiushi 2y ago
- theginger 2y agoState of S3 turns out to literally be what this article is about, but I still feel mislead expecting cloud storage not machine sleep states.
- kristjank 2y agoI use an IdeaPad with a 4000 series Ryzen. It works fine for the time being. Articles like these make me afraid that the damn thing will break eventually and I'll have to spend exorbitants amounts of money on something like a Framework to get a usable Linux experience. Not to mention that having a fake-off state like S0ix is a golden ticket for covert surveillance (like our phones don't do enough for the gestapo). I don't think anybody cares about Cortana, even less so on a suspended laptop. The notifications and update angle is really suspicious as well.
- sph 2y agoThis is hearsay, but I remember reading complaints about S0ix and sleep (or lack thereof) in Framework laptops, which is the reason I didn't buy one.
- dmm 2y agoMy intel 12th gen works find in s2idle or deep(s3) running Fedora. deep is lasts a little longer but that might be because of configuration, which is a bigger part of s2idle. The community.frame.work forum has reports from people running newer boards so you don't have to guess before buying.
- haspok 2y ago> receive Windows Updates during Sleep mode That is just peak level stupidity. I sometimes boot into Windows, and every time Windows Update runs, the fans are on high, my system is taken hostage ("Do not turn off your computer - updates ready 100%" - showing for 15 minutes), and there is nothing I can do about it. Compared to this, an `apt upgrade` is basically an instant action (only kernel updates take a bit longer). Too bad Ubuntu is trying to break that with snap, but it is still a minor inconvenience.
- taspeotis 2y agoWindows updates take 5 minutes max on any semi-recent CPU and NVMe SSD. The major H1/H2 releases take a bit longer, up to 15 minutes. But not stuck at 100%.
- adezxc 2y agoYou are completely missing the point of the original comment. Why is my computer unusable for X minutes when I didn't expect that and perhaps, needed some critical work done?
- _imnothere 2y ago> and NVMe SSD Yeah right, implying everyone should get specified hardware to have a decent user experience definitely seem to be making sense.
- creshal 2y agoAnd apt/dnf/pacman finish major system updates in seconds on that sort of hardware, so Windows still underperforms by orders of magnitude.
- vasco 2y agoYeah but nobody calls Torvalds about national security if he doesn't push out an upgrade pack, but the same cannot be said about windows.
- 2y ago
- hakanderyal 2y agoOne of the top reasons I'm staying with MacBooks. It's not unusual for my laptop to have hundreds of days of uptime. Going back to shutting down everything every time I close the lid is unusable for me at this point. Whoever fixes this first will make a lot of money. Edit: SteamDeck is also very good at this and that's why I'm sticking to it for handheld gaming.
- dailykoder 2y agoThat's interesting as my post just describes the exact opposite. I love to shut my PC down. It gives me a feel of "I am done. It's okay to stop now"
- hakanderyal 2y agoClosing the lid and putting it into the bag has the same effect for me. I've my own ritual for preparing myself for the "I am done" phase. Doing the last commits, writing down a few sentences on what should I do when I go back to work and closing the lid.
- jerlam 2y agoI have had this exact problem on many of my previous Macbooks (2009, 2015, 2019). I'm hoping my newest Apple Silicon one will solve it. edit: maybe not the specific S3 sleep problem but a general inability to sleep correctly
- hakanderyal 2y agoIt's solved, perfectly.
- bzzzt 2y agoIs there a specific piece of software or driver you got installed on all of them? I've owned 2 of 3 of your MacBook model years and 'sleep on lid close' was very reliable on all of them. Apple Silicon works even better, resume from sleep is instanteneous instead of taking 1-2 seconds.
- blkhawk 2y agoI see S3 as another victim of the enforced convergence of PC and mobile that MS did get into with Windows 8. On paper modernizing S3 made even sense since getting all the system components to work nicely with S3 is not an easy task. What wasn't thought off is that handling the same task in modern standby generally isn't easier.
- sirspacey 2y agoThis is a great rant! Steve Jobs had an insight that a computer was just another household appliance But it was built by engineers who came from the homebrew world This is a great example of how our appliance has gotten worse, even though it’s on hardware that is 1000x the throughput, and we’ve lost the ability to configure it too
- creshal 2y agoAnd now the homebrewers ruin appliances too with low quality IoT garbage.
- findthewords 2y agoWindows has too much desktop legacy, it's not built for mobile devices. Windows laptops are portable desktops that should never leave the outlet.
- jiggawatts 2y agoThis has destroyed one of my older laptops, it decided on its own to patch itself while in a laptop bag in sleep mode. It was a "workstation" laptop that can draw something like 60W from battery, and it promptly cooked itself. The plastic melted and smoke was coming out of the bag. On a moving train. Here's the thing: this self-serving behaviour from Microsoft will eventually kill someone, or quite possibly a large number of people. It's just a matter of time until a high-powered laptop does this in someone's luggage on a plane, catches fire, and then there will be congressional investigations like we had with the Boeing 737 MCAS system. In both cases near-monopoly companies are gambling with peoples' lives to meet some internal KPI that in the grand scheme of things just doesn't matter... but it does to some manager's bonus, so you see... people are going to have to die.
- erinaceousjones 2y agoThing is.... My gigantic desktop computer has thermal cutoffs, it will shut down if the CPU gets too hot. I remember desktop PCs having that for ages. I've had overheating laptops do the same. Are laptop manufacturers just getting lazy and skimping on failsafe hardware temperature cut-offs!?? Like, as a hardware manufacturer I would always add that factor-of-5 "the software side WILL fuck up" safety measures. How is the HARDWARE allowing software to let it melt itself in this day and age!?
- misiek08 2y agoHaving accountants and not engineers architecting software and hardware gets you to that point. Crappy engineers don’t help too, there are too many unskilled people in „IT” „old” and „legacy” hardware 8-10 years ago was fighting with the tasks and you could still put laptop on your legs. Funny enough yesterday I went into this sleep stuff, because my 5yo Dell battery drained while being „shut down” after 1.5 weeks and while charging I tried to run 2 tabs in browser to look for fix and my legs burned - so I had to put it diagonally on the table to cool down. We have order of magnitude faster hardware capable of doing order of magnitude less things.
- rcxdude 2y agoIt's probably because the hardware was not designed to be operating at full power surrounded by insulation (i.e. in a bag). In that scenario the parts that the hardware monitors may still be at 'acceptable' temperatures (which can be ~100C), while other (unmonitored) parts that would not normally get that hot get way too hot.
- mikewarot 2y agoGiven how little I use my Windows 10 laptop these days, I just turn it off off when I'm not using it. It seems to stay that way.
- oliviergg 2y agoI remember the same kind of annoyances already in 2009 with Windows (Vista!). It's one of the reasons that made me switch to Mac without any regret. Nothing seems to have changed in 15 years.
- reacharavindh 2y agoWhich are those laptops that have the proper S3 sleep support?
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoTheir aim with S0ix is relatable and can somewhat be compared to Apples move to force USB-C on everyone - which is great and a necessity to be done by a market leader. So, wait for the EU to mandate companies use the same standard? Even then, there were rumors that Apple was going to cripple non-Apple brand chargers.
- preisschild 2y ago> Even then, there were rumors that Apple was going to cripple non-Apple brand chargers. They tried, but the EU shut that down real quick and forced them to use the actual standard.
- moffkalast 2y agoApple: We're gonna only offer thunderbolt on all of our devices, so you can always rely on our super special premium connection! EU: Ahem. Apple: We're gonna only offer USB-C for great interoperability with competitors' systems, aren't we generous and great? Also this was our idea this whole time, stop asking questions!
- roshankhan28 2y agoi have debloated my windows 10 system. i only use it for gaming and some work stuff. there is youtuber named chris titus tech who explains in detail how to have a debloated windows and also how to debload the graphics card.
- omgtehlion 2y agoYup, I'm using S3 even with windows just to save battery and not have laptop in "drained and hot" state when it is suddenly needed. F--k microsoft. In lenovo x1 they call it "Linux sleep" in bios settings.
- sph 2y agoI got a Yoga Pro 7 in the mail, I really hope Linux sleep is still around.
- quotemstr 2y agoOh, come on. S0ix is fine. If we don't want things to happen during this kind of sleep, we should arrange at the OS level for them not to happen. Nothing about the underlying mechanism forces your OS, at a policy level, to go download cat pictures and software updates while your machine is asleep. This post reminds me of the people who complained about the transition from APM to ACPI. Despite much wailing and gnashing of teeth about "Why can't my laptop just support nice simple APM? Why do I bother with ACPI?", ACPI won, and we're all better off for it.
- Sakos 2y agoSo tell me how to tell Windows to stop using modern standby. I've never seen any benefit to it, but I do see Windows misusing it all the time and I see my battery life be wasted due to S0ix. What the fuck is the point of sleep if it's just going to keep wasting my battery life by doing shit I don't need it to do. I want a sleep mode that works as advertised, not "I'll turn the screen off but do whatever the fuck I want when you're not looking".
- BlueTemplar 2y agoI heard that S4 («Hibernate») is hidden on Windows, but you can still dig deep in the settings to configure it to happen when you press the Suspend button / close the lid ?
- jeppester 2y agoI get where you are coming from, but from a user's perspective I really struggle to see the benefits of S0ix. More parts are kept on, for the sake of updates and notifications. Notifications that you will get on your phone anyway (and that the laptop won't be able to get if it's not connected to a wifi anyway), and updates that will likely cause too much excess heat to be safe to perform inside of a bag. If you see the benefits more clearly, perhaps you could elaborate on what they are?
- skrebbel 2y agoI struggled to get through the top half of this post, which is about various Thinkpad model types that the author had. But the second part, where the author explains the various sleep modes and what it means, was very informative & worth a read! I've personally always solved this problem by enabling "Hibernate" (not sure if that's a Windows-specific term) which writes the entire RAM contents to a file and then shuts down completely. The downside is that it takes a few seconds to boot (impressively few seconds on a modern machine, actually), but still, the laptop doesn't come on instantly. But I like knowing that there's no chance the laptop somehow turns on and overheats/drains in the backpack, because it's completely off. This doesn't take away from the author's rant at all, the idea that a sleep mode would need to support notifications or updates (!) is absurd. A good sleep mode would need to only support "minimum power usage" and "fast wake-up" and nothing else. But with MS's usual mix of excellence and absurd stupidity, that appears to not exist, and "hibernate" is to me an acceptable compromise. My understanding is that Macbooks have gotten this right for decades already, pretty nuts that PCs lag behind so much.
- spyke112 2y agoPretty anoying when you have more than 64G of memory though.
- jll29 2y agoTo date, I have always use 16 GB RAM on laptops, and "hard work" is done on a remote server via SSH. This also alleviates the problem of sync'ing between multople laptops, as I use both a MacBook Air (lighter + better mobility: wake-up, WiFi, handling media) and a Lenovo X1 (Linux environment for software development and research).
- skrebbel 2y agoYep that's true. It's impressively fast on my brand new 32GB HP Spectre though. Side-rant: It's nuts how hard it is to find a good laptop that has 64G RAM, let alone "more than 64G" as you cite. I finally thought I found one in a Thinkpad X1 2-in-1, but then it just had terrible build quality, broken speakers (low rumbling sound, unfixable even after a repair and a replacement), badly working components (eg fingerprint reader) etc. I ended up returning it. The HP is a full 1000 euros cheaper (!), and it's better in every way (incl processor speed) except the smaller RAM. Oh how the mighty have fallen.
- AlexAndScripts 2y agoMy solution to this was to setup my laptop to boot in less than ten seconds. I could generally go from shut down to logged in with Obsidian, Firefox, and Anki open in about 30 seconds.
- binkethy 2y agoI am completely fed up with OEM presumption that broken Windows shall forevermore be what computers come preinstalled with. Windows has been broken since XP and linux desktop has been usable for decades now. I refuse to buy more computers preloaded with windows or built with ANY consideration of what incompetent Microsoft want. Why do we accept being spat upon and treated like basement bums when we put our money on the table???
- leptons 2y ago>Why do we accept being spat upon and treated like basement bums when we put our money on the table??? Tell me you aren't in the target market without telling me you aren't in the target market. Microsoft will never, ever, ever be able to make everyone happy. I do not agree with the direction they are going either, because I (as a long-time developer on Windows) am not in their target market.
- kbolino 2y agoThe term "target market" is itself misleading. The end user of Windows is, generally speaking, not buying anything from Microsoft (an Office 365 subscription notwithstanding). It doesn't even matter what any segment of the end users want anymore, so much as what the largest segment of them will tolerate.
- leptons 2y ago>the largest segment of them will tolerate This is the target market. It's not power users, it's not computing professionals, it's not me, it's likely not you. It's my mom. It's your mom. It's people that don't really know what their computer is doing.
- kbolino 2y agoThe end user doesn't pay for the software and so is not even a part of the market at all anymore. The target market of Windows is OEMs and Microsoft's "business partners", with a shift lately from the former to the latter. Windows is no more sold to your mom or mine than it is to either of us. It's sold to people who aren't even users.
- switch007 2y agoOh this hits deep. I recently installed Windows on a laptop after a long time of only using it on a desktop. I thought I was going crazy - where had proper sleep gone ?! 'Luckily' hibernate only takes about 4x as long as sleep while still being just quick enough not to be too annoying. I agree with the author that it totally defies the purpose of a laptop. Another terrible move by Microsoft It is why I will fork out 2-3x for a Macbook, because apart from the screens being amazing, when I close the lid, I know it does exactly what 99.99999% of the population expects it to do, and I can safely put it in my bag.
- omgtehlion 2y ago> ...it does exactly what 99.99999% of the population expects it to do... Nope, it does not, but Apple is miles ahead of MS in this implementation, so it works almost as intended (not really sleeping while not preheating your lunch in your backpack).
- devsatish 2y agoS3 is one of the sleep states (various levels of sleep S1 to S4) . S5 is full shutdown . https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/kernel/system-sleeping-states https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/k...
- dailykoder 2y agoI don't really understand what the fuzz about fast boot is. Why can't most people just wait a few seconds? It's not like boot still takes minutes. I almost always shut down my laptop. This serves me two purposes: 1) It saves power 2) I always start with a fresh session, keeping distractions at a minimum and having habits to "finish" the current task I am working at. (I do the same with browsers for example. Here I even less frequently save my session). There are a few exceptions where I know I'll just take a quick break and resume work shortly, but they are rare. No, you don't have to have everything always available within milliseconds. No, I don't need notifications always on (so I guess I agree with the author here). But maybe just different tastes, different habits. I don't know if this is true, but I talked about a broader topic along those lines with my therapist recently and she was like: 'We invent all these smart things to save time and have more for ourselves, but in reality people have less time, because then they just want to put more tasks into the same timespan'. I have absolutely no idea if there is any truth to that, but it feels true on my empirical observations. Embrace slowness!
- jraph 2y ago> 1) It saves power Shutting down and booting are intensive operations, it's likely that for short enough periods of time, sleep is actually more power-efficient if it works well. I don't have numbers though and with SDDs and fast boot times, maybe booting is way less power hungry than before in the end. Can't argue with 2) of course.
- andai 2y ago#2 I have a Python script to close all my open windows.
- ddmf 2y agoThe main pushback we get is from our floor planners who work offsite in customer's homes - that extra 2 minutes or so while it boots from scratch apparently seems like an eternity when you're in a dirty and hazardous environment.
- BlueTemplar 2y ago
- Neil44 2y agoS0 standby sucks. The laptop inevitably turns into a fan heater in my backpack and when you get it out to use it the battery is dead. You can spend ages on google finding obscure registry keys to tweak to turn off network in S0 and tweak hibernate settings which partly helps but it's like we've gone a big step backwards here.
- v1ne 2y agoI don't get why the author blames bad drivers on the standby mode. I remember similar issues with S3 back then. You had to jump through many hoops on FreeBSD and Linux to make it work without draining your battery while still being able to resume from standby successfully. Disabling some drivers, but not others, etc. Thus, a faulty implementation of a device or driver is not to blame on the standby mode. FWIW, Modern Standby works fine on my Thinkpad X1 Titanium Yoga with Windows 11. The only device that drains more battery than necessary if not disabled is the Qualcomm WWAN modem. That stops once you disable it, like in the "good old days". So for me, it's nothing negative, but actually adds convenience because with Modern Standby, my device goes to sleep and resumes much faster than the devices ever did with S3.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- genericacct 2y agoHad the backpack problem for some time... my current fix is a bash script that goes while true; do pm-suspend; sleep 12; done I just ctrl-c it when i need to use it and then restart it when i am done. Dirty but it works..
- andai 2y agoI got halfway through the article and the font suddenly switched to an unreadable monospace! (Sorry for bikeshedding but it was a uniquely bemusing experience.)
- andai 2y agoI noticed my laptops kept turning themselves on and sitting at login screen during sleep. Several brands. This is apparently a feature?
- Anamon 2y agoYeah, I have the same. Usually, they do it when I'm on the train and they're in their neoprene cover, in my backpack, cooking themselves until they're too hot to touch. Windows Event Viewer says that it's Windows Update waking them up to install patches, so it's a cherry on top that invariably, the update installations have not started, either. The laptops will literally just power up, stay on the login screen, and do bugger all until the battery is dead. (Observed on Lenovo and HP, with both W10 and W11).
- andai 2y agoTangential but I found it amusing: today Windows rebooted while encrypting my disk with BitLocker, and decided that now would be a great time to retry those updates that bricked the laptop last time...
- ohthehugemanate 2y agoI've been on the "modern standby" hate train for as long as it's existed. Not because it's such a terrible idea per se. You can debate that if you like. I hate it because it fundamentally changes the behavior behind an existing API (lid close, suspend button, or ACPI S3 trigger, take your pick) without warning, and in most cases, without the ability to get the old behavior back. Regardless of a valid use case for "modern standby", there is DEFINITELY a use case for "old suspend to RAM" and "old hybrid suspend to RAM", which have de facto been blown away by the change. I have no problem with adding a new sleep state that makes sense for other users. Go ahead and add S22 for that exotic sleep state manufacturing robots use between shifts. S344 for bluetooth devices waiting for reconnection. Whatever, I don't care. But don't replace an existing PRIMARY UI PATTERN with them. To be fair this is not on microsoft for inventing S0, or even pushing for it for windows devices. It's on device manufacturers like Dell and Lenovo for dropping S3 from UEFI in favor of it.
- raverbashing 2y ago> To be fair this is not on microsoft for inventing S0, or even pushing for it for windows devices. It's on device manufacturers like Dell and Lenovo for dropping S3 from UEFI in favor of it. It's like they don't even use their products Oh who am I kidding, if they used they would notice all the bloatware on it and the shoddy build quality, etc
- immibis 2y agoDevice manufacturers just want windows to run. And why wouldn't they? They sell the devices with windows. If windows doesn't use S3 then S3 never gets tested, whether it's present or not. So it doesn't work, whether it's present or not, and you can't use it, whether it's present or not.
- Arnt 2y agoWhat's the market share of windows on laptops these days, 20% perhaps? I don't know, but I know that Chromebooks and Macos are ahead, far ahead. Once upon a time, there were fifty times as many Windows laptops as Linux (by which I mean debian, mint, etc) and Linux was ignorable. Now the factor is closer to ten, and I find it difficult to believe that device manufacturers simply ignore that. If they don't support S3, there likely is a better reason than the dominance of Windows.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sharpshadow 2y agoCan very much relate have an Linux XPS 9570 myself and sleep states are a mess especially in conjunction with power saving tools. Did as much as I could to decrease boot time and shut down of most of the times. Now I have an M2 Apple and it’s like a day and night difference. Close the lid works exactly how it should work. I maybe did shutdown the Mac onces.
- KolmogorovComp 2y agoI don't understand how a laptop manufacturer can ship products with such a fatal flaw and still be in business. Is the windows laptop market so dreadful it does not stand out? Or do people do not care because they do not use laptops on the go anymore?
- immibis 2y agoNot up to the manufacturer any more. Windows does what Windows wants. If Windows doesn't use S3 then it never gets tested, and what isn't tested is broken. On the negatives of S0ix (your battery running out), all laptops will have this same flaw because it's a Microsoft-induced flaw.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoEven laptop models with the highest market share of Linux ?
- pacifika 2y agoThe article is qualified as a rant so I don’t expect to read proposals there but how can we pick a laptop with a working sleep mode? Is there a database like proton db somewhere?
- 71bw 2y agoMacBook or hibernation, pretty much...
- jll29 2y ago1. I'm even surprised that in the 21st century, personal computers (even in iPhone form!) still need to "boot" their operating system (not so: coffee maker, washing machine, TV). This is bad UX, loses productivity (users waiting for the machines to fire up), and appears to be a relic - ancient machines needed it and then it was perhaps never questions. 2. For desktop PCs, it's not a problem if wake-up time is a bit slow, but laptops should be up instantly (<4s).
- ddmf 2y agoWe've had a have a few issues related to the move to modern sleep - in that "shutdown" is now hibernate (with fast boot enabled) - so any issues that would be fixed with a restart remain. With some machines, the modern sleep where it stays connected to the network can sometimes cause connection issues that aren't as obvious to the end user. In a lot of cases we disable fast boot, and disable modern sleep and the problem goes away - but having the ability to select which parts should be enabled and disabled, like how you get the option with PS5's rest mode, would be very useful - especially if controllable by GPO / Intune.
- lozenge 2y agoIf you choose Restart in Windows then it avoids Fast Boot and actually restarts.
- mmwelt 2y agoAnyone have a suggestion, how it would be possible to schedule an overnight backup on a Windows 11 laptop with Modern Standby? This used to be possible using the task scheduler, but that doesn't seem to work anymore.
- vadersb 2y agoIt's just futile to to get any kind of sleep working on Windows laptop. An alternative strategy is to just shut it down for long breaks, and keep it working for short breaks ("closing lid does nothing" setting), and that's it. Maybe you will be loosing a few minutes per YEAR waiting for boot, which is nothing compared to hours trying to get sleep working.
- lifeinthevoid 2y agoIt's one of the main reasons, together with battery life, I went from Linux laptops to a Macbook.
- dvh 2y agoLast time I didn't have video tearing on Linux was on Ubuntu 8.04 (in 2008, I think on Intel i810)
- Yizahi 2y agoI'm always amazed by the tales of people who seemingly use sleep mode on the laptops without issues. In my experience every time I try this trick the laptop wakes up on its own in my backpack and turns into a heatbomb. This reliably reproduces on all half a dozen laptops I've used over past decade or more. So I was kinda trained to always turning off laptops for transporting. Is sleep really fixed and finally can be used on Windows? Do you tweak power settings or configs for that in any way?
- nine_k 2y agoThere are laptops that are sold with Linux preinstalled as an option. They do support sleep correctly. In particular, sleep worked for me on T series Thinkpads: T420, T450, T490, my current T14.
- mmaniac 2y agoThis has frustrated me too. I've completely avoided using sleep these days, and instead use hibernate. Bizarrely, Microsoft also wants to hide this option from you too. But it still exists and modern SSDs are extremely fast.
- yaro330 2y agoKinda telling how Google switched to S0(s2idle) on Android since Pixel 3 or 4, fixed up most of their own drivers, submitted fixes to mainline (and probably to firmware developers too) and a few years later every Android device uses S0 and sleeps flawlessly. Meanwhile MS have been trying to do the same since 2012 and there are still numerous issues. I'm just glad my Lenovo Legion still uses S3.
- justinmayer 2y agoHaving owned countless Mac notebooks over the last 30 years — starting from the PowerBook 140 up through the M1 MacBook Pro — I can tell you with confidence that Apple has made the same sleep change shenanigans mentioned in OP’s article. It used to be that you could count on a sleeping Mac to stay asleep until you explicitly woke it up by opening the lid, pressing a key on the keyboard, or pressing the trackpad (or separate trackpad buttons — yes, those used to exist). Perhaps more importantly, you could count on the sleep function to have barely any effect on the Mac battery. I don’t recall when, but at some point over the aforementioned three decades, Apple started changing the terms of this sleep contract. It seems Apple decided that some functions should still be available when the Mac is “sleeping”, with no way to restore the previous behavior. As a result, random wake-ups are the new normal, replete with unexpected battery drainage. I have seen modern MacBooks go to “sleep” with an 80% charge at night, only to be rendered dead with a 0% battery level by morning. Does something this extreme happen often? No. But it never happened before. And moderate battery loss while sleeping? That happens very often on today’s MacBooks. Your mileage may very. And Apple probably continues to implement better computer sleep behavior than competing vendors. But I would argue that people who think MacBook sleep behavior is excellent… have never experienced how it behaved in the past. That behavior was superb. But sadly, I imagine most people have never experienced that excellence.
- MarkusWandel 2y agoWithout getting technical about it... my previous work laptop (2019 vintage) when suspended, would blink a light until unsuspended - hours or days later - with still usable battery capacity left. The current one. Fold it shut, stick it in my backpack. No noticeable powering-up or overheating issues, but if it's more than a few hours, the thing has a drained battery and is fully shut down. Luckily Windows "fast startup" mitigates the pain - it doesn't take very long for it to unsuspend-from-disk and reach a usable state again, with apps still open etc. No idea what Linux would do here. I actually have Linux on my previous work laptop (Elitebook 840 G6) and "proper" suspend works just fine on it.
- o999 2y agoTIL many people share my suffering.
- joshstrange 2y ago> But in Contrast, Apple kept the legacy Lightning and even brought back Magsafe (and if it only were to milk the cashcow). I don’t quite understand this line. Are they talking about Lightning or MagSafe with the parenthetical? MagSafe specifically is something users were begging them to bring back and they did it without removing USB-C charging (best of both worlds).
- _V_ 2y agoOh yeah, I've spent many hours on DELLs trying to solve S0ix sleep states... What a pain in the butt that is. There are few major pain points: 1) Every component has to be in the right "state of mind" in order for Si0x sleep to work properly. Do you have shitty NVMe that has buggy PCI powersaving? Too bad, battery will drain 10%/hour. Your yubikey keeps USB bus by constantly sending interrupts? Ha, enjoy your new backpack heater and watch out for fires... 2) It is extremely hard to debug these issues. I've figure out the yubikey and few things, but some of them are esoterical! ifconfig eth0 down = some part of Intel AMT stops sleeping and is now fully on all the time. Why? Because fck you, that's why. If you want to get some debug info, you can get some very cryptic state-flags for (some) components and you really have to guess what these really are - there is no documentation unfortunately. 3) UEFI is a mess - one would say that you want critical component, such as BIOS/boot chain to be as simple as possible and not* to be extensible in nature - because if some malicious code manages to get in the UEFI modules, you are simply hosed. But the other problem is that UEFI provides quite a lot of interfaces through ACPI and ACPI tables are buggy as hell. I had to patch DELL's DSDT tables in order to get back "deep" sleep - unfortunately it stopped working some time ago as they must have changed something somewehere and the computer would not wake up anymore... It is impossible to debug (or rather it is a royal pain to debug).
- mensetmanusman 2y ago“Your computer should be able to allow for the usage of Cortana and receive Windows Updates during Sleep mode, among other features.” Sounds like a nightmare!
- rsynnott 2y agoOne of the big reasons that I moved to MacOS in ~2004 was that, at that time, for reasonable money you couldn't get a laptop that had any sort of reliably sensible sleep behaviour in Linux, and even Windows was iffy. The iBook had no such issues. It's somewhat surprising that this is still the case, 20 years later.
- jitl 2y agoThis sounds totally nuts. I guess I’m happy to be running a laptop where when I close the lid, it will sleep and have battery when I open the lid, in an hour or in 2 days. I thought that was the basic requirement for being a laptop? The essential feature. It’s so surprising to hear things have gone backwards in the Windows world. My suggestion to anyone dealing with annoying power management is to get a MacBook Pro (you can get tons of ram, we are ordering 96gb models for our engineers) and run your preferred OS in a full screen VM if you don’t like MacOS. I did this for years because I don’t trust Linux to manage battery or reliably pair with Bluetooth devices (especially Bluetooth audio), but I much preferred Linux window management and access to Docker. Parallels runs Windows quite well, and either that, Virtualbox, or the various apps that are thin layers over the system Hypervisor.framework all do the trick.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoThat sounds more fraught and of an hassle than replacing MacOS by Linux on it ? (Though I still wouldn't recommend that, as it's still supporting Apple by giving them money & mindshare.)
- jitl 2y agoAsahi Linux is totally unready as a daily driver / production OS in my opinion. They are doing great technical work and I love reading the progress updates, but there's too many limitations as of today: No microphone, Thunderbolt/USB4, USB-C displays, or fingerprint reader; and much worse sleep/suspend compared to macOS. I mean, if you're happy with <48hr closed lid battery life, then you can get any general market "laptop" with all the issues described in the original article.
- 0x_rs 2y agoLaptop manufacturers on their own clearly didn't hurt this (dying) category enough over the years prioritizing shallow form over functionality and constant design regressions, Microsoft had to push some more of their deranged "vision" too. S0ix was a joke when introduced years ago and remains one, but it's not funny to laugh at it anymore because its existence eventually killed the actual sleep state an user expects. There is, without an ounce of doubt, no benefit for an user to have their laptop device continue operating when it's expected to be "sleeping" without intentional, conscious instruction to resume work. Some of the proclaimed advantages to it I distinctly remember were "receiving emails" and "automatic updates when the device is not in use", and while the former is mostly useless because it's not a smartphone, the latter is actively harmful to an user's interests when unprompted. Hibernation on linux and windows (where it's secretly kept away for whatever reason since 8 or so) is far more predictable with any modern sabotaged devices missing S3 support, and modern drives are performant and large enough that it's not going to make much of a difference, at least for pauses that one expects to last more than an hour or two. Some more of the endless compromises to put up with because of unrestrained "courage".
- phh 2y agoThe "fun" part is that smartphones/tablets implement those features with S3 (CPU off, RAM in self-refresh). Updates? Well here is an RTC to wake-up. Voice control? Well here is an always on audio dsp. Remote wake-up? Well here is a WiFi frame filter to trigger IRQ. I think it isn't tractable on most laptops because of all the hardware that has been onloaded to software, and the hardware isn't capable of those hardware filtering, and partly OS and drivers are probably to blame too. An embesded OS takes under 1s to wakeup, so even managing TCP KeepAlives wih resume/suspend is realistic on those devices. Not so much when wakeup takes 10s.
- yaro330 2y ago[dead]
- edude03 2y agoOne aspect I've yet to see covered is how existing hardware doesn't seem to be designed for s0ix to work as intended anyway. For example, on mobile phones it used to be the case that the application processor wasn't actually the main processor of the phone, it was actually the baseband, and relatedly, this meant that the application processor could be shutdown and woken up when the phone received a text message or phone call. Similarly, modern arm processors have a big/little configuration where you can switch to the efficiency cores when the system is asleep. While I'm aware that at some point intel started offering efficiency cores, the vast majority of devices that run windows, AFAIK, don't have any way of being awake in sleep mode other that just leaving the CPU running with the screen off. Maybe s0ix will make more sense as big.LITTLE and other secondary CPU schemes become common, but today seems like it's just upsetting existing users for no apparent gain
- OptionOfT 2y agoI have never opened up my laptop thinking: oh I wish my new emails were already there. Annoyingly when I enable S3 on my P1 Gen 5 Windows 11 give me a whole bunch of warnings in the security center. Seems like S3 itself is incompatible with some modern firmware protections. But frankly, I don't care whether it's S0 or S3. I just want it to sleep, and I don't want the OS to NOT offer me the options to say 'don't do stuff in sleep mode'
- senectus1 2y agothis is one of the reasons I've always preferred Hybernate over sleep. More reliable even if it does take just a little longer.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoI didn't seem to have this problem yet so took a look at my recent machines: cat /sys/power/mem_sleep starlite mkv 0yo Intel(R) N200, has deep. framework0 2yo Intel 12th gen, has deep. framework1 1yo AMD Ryzen 5, lacking deep! That explains it—I haven't really taken the last one out of the house yet. So what can we do about this? Can we start a class action lawsuit for breaking the PC? Probably too late to return the AMD. Finally I recommend calling S0ix/s2idle nap, and leave s3 as sleep.
- gregoirelafram 2y agoI can totally relate. There are some relatively modern processors though that still support the old but gold S3 state. The i5-1240P and i7-1260P processors support these, but not all manufacturers integrate UEFI support for this sleep state. I found that Dasharo offers the ability to switch to S3: https://docs.dasharo.com/dasharo-menu-docs/dasharo-system-features/#power-management-options https://docs.dasharo.com/dasharo-menu-docs/dasharo-system-fe...