13 ms·
Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims
- InDubioProRubio 2y agoFinally, the great IP washing machine hums and can dissolve the whole structure. Bring forth your disassembly, to generate a draft, to re-generate clean source code. Cooperate-communism! It is done!
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoThat was the point of a clean-room implementation of a spec, which is how the Phoenix BIOS was done for PC clones clear back in the 1980s. So "finally" may not be an accurate word...
- kmeisthax 2y agoI don't think this proves you can just launder away copyright - nor do I think even we want that at this point. First off: the claims dismissed have to do with 17 USC 1202, the part of the DMCA that deals with copyright management information. It's a bit of a plaintiff meme[0] to add a CMI claim onto a copyright infringement lawsuit. Obviously, if you infringe copyright, you're also not going to preserve the CMI. And if an AI were to regurgitate output, it doesn't even know that it did so, so it can't preserve CMI even if it wanted to. Problem is, the AI doesn't regurgitate consistently enough to make a legal claim of CMI removal. The model does generate legally distinct outputs sometimes. You need to point to specific generations and connect the dots from the model to the output in a way that legally implicates GitHub, OpenAI, and/or Microsoft in ways that would not be disclaimed by, say, 17 USC 512 safe harbor. This is distinct from the training-time infringement claims which are still live, wouldn't rely on secondary liability, can't be disclaimed by honoring DMCA takedowns, and which I think are the stronger claim. Let's step out of the realm of legality. Why do we want to get rid of copyright? For me, it's because copyright centralizes control over creativity. It tells other artists what they can do and forces them into larger and larger hierarchies. The problem is that AI models do the same thing. Using an AI model doesn't make you an artist[1], but it does move that artistic control further towards large creative industry. This is why you have a lot of publisher and big media CEOs that are strangely bullish on AI, a bunch of artists that ordinarily post shit for free are angry about it, and the FOSS people who hate software copyright were the first to sue. In other words, AI is breaking copyright in order to replace it with more of the thing we hate about copyright. [0] Or at least Richard Liebowitz liked to do it before he got disbarred. [1] In the same way that commissioning an art piece does not itself make you an artist
- kelnos 2y agoThank you for this; you really hit the nail on the head as to why this is so gross. If building, training, and operating an LLM was something well within the resources of anyone to do, I'd probably have much less of a problem of my open source code being copyright-laundered through products like Copilot. But that's just not where we are right now, and the result of that feels awful.
- CaptainFever 2y agoOpen source models exist and can be run locally. It doesn't matter if training from scratch is impractical for the average person, if we already have free (as in freedom) models we can build off of.
- kmeisthax 2y agoI have several "open" models sitting around for experimentation and occasional use, but I don't think downloadable weights solves the underlying issue. First off, none of the good models are FOSS in the sense we normally expect - i.e. the four freedoms. At the least onerous end of the scale, Stable Diffusion models under the OpenRAIL license have a morality clause[0] and technical protections[1] to enforce that clause. LLaMA's licensing is only open for entities below a certain MAU, and Stable Diffusion 3 recently switched away from OpenRAIL to a LLaMA-like "free as in beer" license. Not only is this non-free, it's getting increasingly more proprietary as entities who are paying for the AI training start demanding a return on investment, and the easiest way to get that is to just demand licensing fees. The reason why AI companies - not the artists or programmers they stole from - are in a position to demand these licensing terms at all is because they're the ones controlling the capital necessary to train models. If training from scratch at the frontier was still viable for FOSS tinkerers, we wouldn't have to worry about OpenAI reading all our GPT queries or Stability finding ways to put asterisks on their openness branding. FOSS software development is something you can do as a hobby, so if a project screws something up, you can build a new one. That's not how AI works. If Stability screws up, you still have to obey Stability's rules unless you train a new foundation model, and that's very expensive. You see how this is very "copyright-like" even though it's legally contravening the letter and spirit of copyright law? Barriers to entry drive industrial consolidation and ratchet us towards a capitalist, privately-owned command economy. If I could train models from scratch, I'd make a decent model trained purely on public domain datasets[2], slather Grokfast[3] on it, and build in some UI to selectively fine-tune on licensed or custom data. [0] To be clear, I don't have much against morality clauses personally, that's why I've used OpenRAIL models. But I still think adding morality clauses to otherwise FOSS licensing is a bad idea. At the very least, in order to put moral values into a legal contract, we have to agree as a community as to what moral values should be enforced by copyright. Furthermore, copyright and contracts are a bad tool to enforce morals. [1] e.g. the Stable Diffusion safety filter [2] Believe me, I tried [3] An algorithm that increases the speed of grokking (generalization) by taking the FFT of gradients and amplifying the slow ones.
- pfdietz 2y agoThis makes me think we need models to deliberately try to make code that's equivalent to copyrighted code, but sufficiently changed that it's not infringing. The end state would be to make the rewriting powerful enough that trying to claim infringement would also hit manually created code. Alternately, generate code that is optimized for some task by some metric, and show that because the code is best by this criterion, it doesn't show creativity. Another possibility here is for the LLM vendor to log the code generation tasks typically asked for and then salt the model with vetted, correct, non-infringing code for those questions.
- kelnos 2y agoWhile I think that would probably get around the copyright infringement issues, it still bothers me. I don't like the idea that a corporation can hoover up countless open source code and contributions (including mine), and then use that to make money selling code generation assistance to other people, even if the output of that code generation would be different enough to any specific copyrighted block of code such that it couldn't result in a copyright infringement claim. It's not even clear that we can stop this from happening; it's certainly possible that a "GPLv4" that had a provision against using covered code for LLM trailing would be legally (if not just practically) unenforceable. To me, the ickiest part is centralization. While models and training tools will probably (maybe?) get cheaper over time, building and operating something like Copilot requires a lot of money and resources. Do we really want these capabilities to be locked up inside big, well-capitalized corporations? For me, the answer to that is a resounding hell no.
- 23B1 2y agohttps://sfconservancy.org/GiveUpGitHub/ https://sfconservancy.org/GiveUpGitHub/ I was lucky to learn early-on that publishing important things to the web meant relinquishing control of not just the IP, but my own agency and fate. The cost far exceeded the benefits of generosity, be it contributions to FOSS, public blogging or documentation, or even just writing. Time is the only fixed resource, and mine is proprietary, exclusive, and for sale to the highest bidder.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Xeoncross 2y agoThankfully, others are more altruistic. I have benefited from many developers freely sharing their ideas in forums, code on github, and leanings on blogs. Sure Google has stolen it to build an empire that most are complicit with. Sure OpenAI has stolen it to build products most are supportive of. Sure evil benefits from good, but that doesn't mean we should neglect to help others just to spite them.
- yoyohello13 2y agoNobles exploiting the labor of the peasants. It's how it has always been and how it will always be.
- dingnuts 2y agothere's "sharing ideas on forums" and then there's giving all of your source code, public and private, to Microsoft to host, instead of just setting your git remote to user@yourownhost:/path/to/reponame and setting up SSH keys I appreciate the viewpoint of the GP and it's telling that it is downvoted when it is not spam, it is not abusive, and it is fully in-line with the stated and implicit etiquette of this site. It's just unpopular, so people are down-voting it. FOSS is kind of culty and it's very apparent in the reaction to opinions like the OP's. If you don't believe what he said about giving up your agency and your fate when you give away your code online, look into what happened to fommil[0] https://medium.com/@fommil/hide-your-real-name-in-open-source-3d67e74a8c56 https://medium.com/@fommil/hide-your-real-name-in-open-sourc...
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoInteresting. The parts that survived are the contract claims and the open-source license claims. Contract is understandable - it supersedes almost everything else. If the law says I can do X but the contract says I can't, then I almost certainly can't. It's nice to see open-source licenses being treated as having somewhat similar solidness as a contract.
- tialaramex 2y agoThe FSF's argument for their copyleft was always based on exactly the same foundations as typical copyright licenses. If Alice can say that you must pay her $500 to do X with her copyrighted thing, then logically Bob can say that you must obey our rules to do X with his copyrighted thing. This invites courts to pick, smash copyright (which would suit the FSF fine) or enforce their rules just the same (also fine). It makes it really difficult for a court, even one motivated to do so, to thread the needle and find a way to say Alice gets her way but Bob does not. Structuring your arguments so that it's difficult for motivated courts to thread this needle is a good strategy when it's available. If you're lucky a judge will do it for you, as in Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co (the foundation of contract law) or indeed Bostock v. Clayton County - hey, says Gorsuch, the difference between this gay man and this straight woman isn't that they're attracted to men, that's the same - the actual difference is one of them is a man, but, that's sex discrimination, so this is a sex discrimination case!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoMisleading OP, Discussion from July: Judge dismisses DMCA copyright claim in GitHub Copilot suit https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40919253 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40919253
- Malidir 2y ago[flagged]
- granzymes 2y ago>judges are often paid multiples less than leading lawyers and they are not desireable jobs The first part of this is true, but the second part is laughable. Federal judgeships are highly prized and nearly impossible to get. There are only on the order of 900 Article III judges in the country and they serve for life. >The public often don't have access to all documents, transcripts and mostly what is published is the Judge's version of what the parties submissions are Completely false. While there can be redactions for sensitive information like trade secrets, in general everything is public record. And in particular, there is a strong presumption rooted in the first amendment and the right to a public trial to unredact anything that the court relied upon in reaching its decision. >When a judge dismisses a case and classifies it as not refileable, always raise an eyebrow. You get a chance to refile when the judge thinks that you could plausibly plead more facts that, when taken as true, establish your claim. When the claims fail as a matter of law, leave to amend would be futile since you can’t plead around that.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pdabbadabba 2y agoAs a lawyer who has worked in the federal judiciary, it's understandable that someone outside the legal profession would have some of these views ... but they're actually pretty off base. > judges are often paid multiples less than leading lawyers This part is true. > and they are not desireable jobs and so many were attracted to the power/low competence ones. No, no, and no. Judgeships are some of the most prestigious and desirable jobs in the entire legal profession. You have to be literally nominated by the president of the United States and confirmed by the Senate. Then you enjoy constitutionally protected life tenure. It's common to see elite lawyers, making millions as partners for large firms, leave their jobs to become federal judges. (Note that I'm talking about federal judges.) > And also add in that with a single judge, a party/the state only needs to influence a single person. I guess, in theory? But, in practice, this really doesn't happen. This is partially because judges highly value their independence. And their decisions are appealable, so this kind of corruption would be easily detected, or at least reversed, making it both risky and not very useful. > The public often don't have access to all documents, transcripts and mostly what is published is the Judge's version of what the parties submissions are (i.e. one person writing history) Nope. This is generally all public, unless there are specific confidential materials that need to be redacted. But this is unusual and disfavored. > When a judge dismisses a case and classifies it as not refileable, always raise an eyebrow. Eh. It's much more complicated than this. There are situations where this might raise an eyebrow -- like if the claim was recently filed and there's reason to think that it could be amended in a way that would rehabilitate it. But if it's obvious fundamentally doomed, or if it would unfairly prejudice other parties to allow it to be refiled, or for various other reasons, this can be totally legitimate.
- maronato 2y agoThe judge argues that copilot “rarely emits memorised code in benign situations”, but what happens when it does? It is bound to happen some day, and when it does would I be breaching copyright by publishing the code copilot wrote? Just a few weeks ago a very similar suit for stable diffusion had its motion to dismiss copyright infringement claims denied. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/08/artists-claim-bi https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/08/artists-claim-bi...
- blackoil 2y agoYou'll get a second system, that searches your code against index of copyrighted code. If found say > 70% matching against some unique code, it will be flagged for rewrite. It can be automated in Copilot to simply regenerate with a different seed.
- bschmidt1 2y agoIn some languages there are few ways (or 1 way) to do things, so everyone writes the same looking for loops, etc. And sometimes in the same order, with the same filenames, etc. by convention - especially in the case of heavy framework usage where most people's code is mostly identical % wise. The flagging system would have to be able to identify framework usage separate from IP and so-on. Beyond that, it seems like you'd need a highly expressive language for this to work well. You can effectively scan for plagiarism in English because it's so varied that it really is an outlier to see several lines of text that are identical to each other from different sources, but maybe it's not that strange to see entirely identical files, or at least very similar code, in totally distinct, say, React or Ruby-on-Rails projects. I think of code methodologies as more like construction techniques. Maybe some pieces and parts are patentable, and some can even be productized as tools, but a lot of it is just convention and technique.
- hadlock 2y agoLooking forward to the "rewrite this over and over until it no longer triggers the copyright-warning alarm" button in my IDE
- deleted 2y ago
- robswc 2y agoI honestly just don't see how all this will work legally, in the future. I don't know anything an LLM (or "AI") can do that a human couldn't, with enough time. If it can get a human in trouble, it should get the operators of the AI in trouble too. Likewise, if a human can do it, I don't see why an AI is any different.
- qup 2y agoWhich operators? The ones running it, or the ones asking it to do troublesome things?
- kbenson 2y agoDepends on whether you have a service relationship with a third party and they are providing a service or you rolled your own. If, for example, I paid a third party company for consultants to write some code for me but they provided source code they didn't have the right to, I think I should be able to hold them accountable for that. Whether it's a person or some automated process doesn't change that IMO. I expect a court case would be used to determine what a normal person could expect, what was represented buy the consultant company, and what exactly I requested to determine how much fault each party has.
- qup 2y ago> I think I should be able to hold them accountable for that You should? Or the owners of the copyrighted code should?
- tialaramex 2y agoEverybody whose rights were infringed. The GPL often technically makes that "everybody else" by granting what were otherwise exclusive rights (to make and distribute copies) to everybody and then taking them away from infringers. So e.g. Company X makes a GPL'd program to do A, but Company Y just copy pastes it into famous product P and acts as though they made it and obviously doesn't give out source. As a random person who doesn't even own P, the argument would be that technically the GPL says you should be able to get source code for the program from Y, even though you didn't buy their product P - you were harmed by their refusal to do what the GPL requires, so you can sue them. Now, suing is probably not a good idea in this case, a court is likely to either insist you aren't really injured or that they can't help you, or both, but I think it could work at least in theory.
- darby_nine 2y agoHuh I guess you can just avoid legal liability by laundering through a chatbot
- IncreasePosts 2y agoAnother way to look at it is anyone can look at source available code to learn how to program without breaking a license.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anileated 2y agoAnyone can, that’s orthogonal. This is about an automated tool that launders copyright at scale, generating revenue for its operator. (And if you seriously say that this tool is learning how to program, ask yourself if that tool’s operator is effectively a slave owner.)
- stale2002 2y ago> Anyone can, that’s orthogonal. Ok. So anyone "can" use a computer to do the same thing then. With the added part of "using a computer" it is now directly comparable and it is allowed. > And if you seriously say that this tool is learning how to program The tool is used by a person. The person is the one who takes the action, not the computer. So the point stands.
- anileated 2y agoIf you “use a computer” to watch a pirated film, does that make the practice legal? > The tool is used by a person. The person is the one who takes the action, not the computer. So the point stands. If watching that pirated film helps you learn something, does that make it legal? If the film was pirated not by you but by some for-profit company that charges you for watching it, does that make it legal?
- btown 2y ago(July 10, 2024)
- PaulKeeble 2y agoThe consequence of all the abuse of the intent of open source licenses has just resulted in me not writing any open source code. I have a lot less issues with a code generator trained on GPl code that produces GPL code with the LLM being under GPL as well. Its the commercial licensing and paying for it that seems to breach the intent of these licenses to me. I guess Microsoft has gotten what it wanted and has got to the extinguish stage of its plan for open source finally and all it needed was a chatbot.
- CaptainFever 2y agoJust to have a separate story, I started licensing my stuff as public domain after the AI stuff happened, so I can encourage the development of AI models without any restrictions. While I believe attribution (a requirement in MIT and GPL) doesn't make sense for AI because of its nature, the arguments just made me say "fuck it" and remove the attribution legal requirement altogether. It's still a good thing to attribute when it makes sense, though right now legally it's just too crazy for me to want to participate in this copyright regime.
- austin-cheney 2y agoThe comments seem to misunderstand copyright. Copyright protects a literal work product from unauthorized duplication and nothing else. Even then there are numerous exceptions like fair use and personal backups. Copyright does not restrict reading a book or watching a movie. Copyright also does not restrict access to a work. It only restricts duplication without express authorization. As for computer data the restricted duplication typically refers to dedicated storage, such as storage on disk as opposed to storage in CPU cache. When Viacom sued YouTube for $1.6 billion they were trying to halt the public from accessing their content on YouTube. They only sued YouTube, not YouTube users, and only because YouTube stored Viacom IP without permission.
- BeefWellington 2y ago> When Viacom sued YouTube for $1.6 billion they were trying to halt the public from accessing their content on YouTube. They only sued YouTube, not YouTube users, and only because YouTube stored Viacom IP without permission. Now do these steps for OpenAI instead of YouTube. Only OpenAI doesn't let users upload content, and instead scraped the content for themselves.
- anticensor 2y agoOpenAI actually lets users to upload content to the chat input.
- advisedwang 2y agoFrom the article it sounds like the plaintiffs were alleging that ChatGPT is effectively doing unauthorized duplication when it serves results that are extremely similar or identical to the plaintiff's code. They aren't just alleging that reading their code = infringement like you seem to imply.
- paulddraper 2y agoI don't think the author was implying that. But yes, that is the charge.
- KyleBerezin 2y agoI will throw in a random story here about chat gpt 4.0. I'm not commenting on this article directly, just a somewhat related anecdote. I was using chatgpt to help me write some android opengl rendering code. OpenGL can be very esoteric and I haven't touched it for at least 10 years. Everything was going great and I had a working example, so I decided to look online for some example code to verify I was doing things correctly, and not making any glaring mistakes. It was then that I found an exact line by line copy of what chat gpt had given me. This was before it had the ability to google things, and the code predated openAI. It had even brought across spelling errors in the variables, the only thing it changed was it translated the comments from Spanish to English. I had always been under the impression that chat gpt just learned from sources, and then gave you a new result based roughly on its sources. I think some of the confounding variables here were, 1. this was a very specific use case and not many examples existed, and 2. all opengl code looks similar, to a point. The worst part was, there was no license provided for the code or the repo, so it was not legal for me to take the code wholesale like that. I am now much more cautious about asking chat gpt for code, I only have it give me direction now, and no longer use 'sample code' that it produces.
- vundercind 2y ago> I had always been under the impression that chat gpt just learned from sources, and then gave you a new result based roughly on its sources. I think some of the confounding variables here were, 1. If I’ve understood the transformer paper correctly, these things probabilistically guess words based on what they’ve been trained on, with the probabilities weighted dynamically by the prompt, by what they’ve already generated, and by what they “think” they might generate for the next few tokens (they look ahead somewhat), with another set of probability-weight adjustments applied to all that by a statistical guess at which tokens or words are most-significant or important. None of that would prevent them from spitting out exactly what they’ve seen in training data. Keeping them from doing that a lot requires introducing “noise” to all the statistics stuff above, and maybe a gate after generation that tries to check if what’s been generated is too similar to training data and forces another run (maybe with more noise) if it is, similar to how they prevent them from saying racist stuff or whatever.
- slowhadoken 2y agoI’ve heard corporate types call open source projects “security risks” and “commie nonsense” but it does stop them from trying to acquire the work for free to profit off of it. It’s greedy and duplicitous. It’s capture.
- beeboobaa3 2y agoGuess microsoft paid them off
- nadermx 2y agoThe purpose of Copyright is to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries. "Sciences" refers not only to fields of modern scientific inquiry but rather to all knowledge The hacker ethic is a philosophy and set of moral values within hacker culture. Practitioners believe that sharing information and data with others is an ethical imperative hrmmm...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Palmik 2y agoCurious to see if the same will apply to other materials like news, books, images, music, movies, etc.
- seanw444 2y agoWhere do we draw the line between AI learning from codebases to offer code solutions, and humans learning from codebases to offer code solutions?
- greenthrow 2y agoThis is such an absurd canard I can't believe anyone falls for it. One is a product and the other is a human being.
- cokeandpepsi 2y ago[dead]
- muzani 2y agoNow you just have to legally draw that line. Legally, a company is a person too. Lately in Malaysia, we've been redefining a lot of laws to cover "natural persons" (aka humans) because what would happen is that companies would steal money and other unethical things, and the company would be blamed for such actions instead of the humans running them.
- chrsig 2y agoFlesh?
- bionhoward 2y agoTell that to all the closed AI companies with stronger legal protections for chatbot output than for human input
- garciansmith 2y agoOr maybe the ability to properly give attribution to your source and not just pretend you made it up or hallucinate a fake one?
- stavros 2y ago
- jsyang00 2y ago> leaves only two claims standing: one accusing the companies of an open-source license violation and another alleging breach of contract these seem to be major claims?
- sidewndr46 2y agoIt really depends, even if found to be in violation of the license the outcome could be "promise not to do it again".
- lucb1e 2y agoCould still be monumental if that creates the case law to be referenced in the future. Lawsuits are a lot easier to start when you know you're going to win because a previous case was extremely similar, which is to say this could have a major impact on the industry even if the punishment (this time, for doing it while it was uncharted territory) was a slap on the wrist
- nickelpro 2y agoRead the decision, the breach of contract claim simply survived dismissal, but the surrounding discussion makes it clear it doesn't have much of a prayer (which is the same as the "open-source license violation", the OP article is trash).
- nl 2y agoThe original reporting has more details: https://www.developer-tech.com/news/judge-dismisses-majority-github-copilot-copyright-claims/ https://www.developer-tech.com/news/judge-dismisses-majority... In particular this: An amended version of the complaint had taken issue with GitHub’s duplication detection filter, which allows users to “detect and suppress” Copilot suggestions matching public code on GitHub. The developers argued that turning off this filter would “receive identical code” and cited a study showing how AI models can “memorise” and reproduce parts of their training data, potentially including copyrighted code. However, Judge Tigar found these arguments unconvincing. He determined that the code allegedly copied by GitHub was not sufficiently similar to the developers’ original work. The judge also noted that the cited study itself mentions that GitHub Copilot “rarely emits memorised code in benign situations.” I think this is the key point: reproduction is the issue, not training. And as noted in the study[1] reproduction doesn't usually happen unless you go to extra lengths to make it. [1] Not sure but maybe https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3597503.3639133 https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3597503.3639133? Can anyone find the filing?
- baybal2 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- omeid2 2y ago> reproduction doesn't usually happen unless you go to extra lengths to make it. And who is to say that people who want to copy your code without adhering to your license terms or pay won't go to extra lengths? or am I missing something here?
- umeshunni 2y agoAt that point, they might as well copy your original code without going through an LLM to do it
- williamcotton 2y ago
- coding123 2y agoIts always fun to see a AI copyright thread on HN - the same people that want copyright abolished suddenly want the strongest copyright ever to exist.
- elicksaur 2y agoCommentors on any website aren’t a monolith. You’re making up some fictional person to be mad at.
- tedunangst 2y agoThat said, the presence or absence of these individuals in specific threads is curious. The "all forms of copyright are unethical" people are all over the Disney threads. Surely anyone with such a keen interest in copyright law and policy would wish to comment on this thread as well, the topics being so similar?
- latexr 2y agoFor crying out loud, this submission is an hour old. People have barely had time to even know it exists. Do you think people are just seething to have arguments and set up alarms to be woken up one the middle of the night whenever there’s a conversation involving copyright on HN?
- trueismywork 2y agoIt's not a contradiction. Copyleft is the ultimate Judo move. The stronger copyright is, the stronger copyleft is.
- latexr 2y ago> the same people Or may, just maybe, it’s different people and HN is not an amorphous hive mind where everyone thinks the same thing all the time. It boggles the mind how there’s always someone on HN complaining about HN’s hypocrisy. Clearly not everyone on this site shares opinions on everything, else you wouldn’t be making the criticism.
- 2y ago
- panic 2y agoIf you have access to the Copilot weights, you should consider leaking them. We shared our code with you because we wanted it to be free, not sold back to us at $10/month.
- e-clinton 2y agoSo if a developer uses “free code” in their software, must they only do it for free?
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoThat depends on the original license.
- tbrownaw 2y ago... because GPU-hours are worthless?
- ozr 2y agoFwiw, I've never paid for Copilot. I was automatically given free access for open source contributions. My largest public repo had maybe 100 stars. I've made minor commits to larger repos. I don't know what the threshold is, but I'm fine with the trade-off I received.
- stale2002 2y agoThen you should be happy to know that there are multiple open source coding weights out there already! Some of which are as good as, or possibly better than co-pilot. That should satisfy anyone who actually cares about this as opposed to only being interest in making a snappy gotcha one liners.
- man4 2y ago[dead]
- tidenly 2y agoA lot of people dislike LLMs and generative AI (fairly) and are reflexively trying to reach for tools in our legal framework, claiming it's obviously already illegal. I don't think this is going to work. Generative AI is quite obviously novel to anyone who isn't in denial - and claiming existing copyright laws are going to cover it seems like a lost cause. We need new laws. Especially regarding deepfakes, it's shocking how many people think revenge porn laws and such are going to be enough here. Rather than just focusing on the data usage, we need more fundamental laws and rights, like the right to control representations of ourselves, like Japan has, where producing images or voice/video in your likeness is prosecutable straight out. Likewise we need laws that explicitly target data use for training that is separate to copyright. The way LLMs are trained is obviously too similar to how humans learn, and the transformation and then output produce works that are novel based on that "learning", just like humans do. This is so fundamentally different to what copyright laws were made to cover, I find it infuriating how many people handwave these arguments away. Only in perfect 1-to-1 regurgitation does it even feel close to something copyright would be able to cover.
- cowboylowrez 2y agoI'm one of the "dislikers" although the neural network stuff is itself an amazing tool in my opinion. I like to fall back on a much easier argument (IANAL and this is not legal advice), can these code generating things generate code without reading (training on) encumbered code? Humans can learn syntax and basic programs then independent of any "similar code", humans can produce new algorithms that solve specific problems. Now sure, similar code can be searched for on the internet but the code is "attributed" and will likely contain a license. If the human copies it too closely, attribution and licensing rights come into play. The LLMs apparently just bail on attribution. The way LLMs are trained is that they are fed an absurd amount of code, humans cannot train this way because the volumes of code to be read are too great.