19 ms·
Meta cancels high-end mixed reality headset after Apple Vision Pro struggles
- mrbigbob 2y agoit still baffles me how Apple decided to release the Vision pro as an actual consumer product and not use this generation as just dev. kits and release a successor to the vision pro and have a cheaper one based on on the mobile chips too in 1 to 1.5 years
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoMAANG - N need to make compact AR goggles to assist with visualizing and interacting with the world containing additional context and interaction rather than a simulation of one in VR.
- taylodl 2y agoThe Vision Pro is a solution looking for a problem. This is the same problem plaguing Apple Home. It just feels very - so what? Tech nerds like it because it's "cool", but everybody else is wondering why would I ever need this thing? Personally, I think they need to be thinking of a more Apple Watch type device wearable in normal glasses frames. Something more akin to Google Glass, and yes, I'm familiar with the term "glasshole." But maybe it was a product too far ahead of it's time? Or maybe these are just products we don't need?
- ubercore 2y agoYou mean HomeKit? I'm a big fan, despite the warts. I think that's really useful.
- kevinventullo 2y agoI contend that almost every problem solvable by a wearable can be solved “well enough” by a smartphone, to the point where an additional device is not worth the trouble for the marginal benefit (unless you’re a person who likes gadgets). For exercise specifically I do see the value of a watch form factor since people don’t want to carry a phone in their exercise gear. But, that’s pretty niche.
- fullshark 2y agoYeah we might end up just circling back to VR over AR and prioritizing immersive gaming, the only thing you can't do on a smartphone / desktop.
- AlexandrB 2y agoThe problem with VR gaming is that movement that doesn't match real world movement tends to make people barf. The types of games you can build in VR is just so much more limited as a result. For example, it's very cool to imagine a VR MMO but it would be hell to actually play it.
- danans 2y ago> I contend that almost every problem solvable by a wearable can be solved “well enough” by a smartphone, to the point where an additional device is not worth the trouble for the marginal benefit I've found glanceable notifications on my smartwatch to be really useful. Dismissing or answering calls without taking out my phone (or without my phone at all since the watch has mobile connectivity), quickly seeing text messages (especially 2 factor auth codes). The remote viewfinder for my camera lets me actually be in family photos. And of course exercise tracking (reminders to get a few thousand more steps today are helpful). AR/VR goggles would be useless for any of those, and make the last two worse.
- jemmyw 2y agoBut as the parent poster said, most of those things are adequate without the watch. I have a watch but it's a nice to have rather than essential.
- danans 2y agoA mobile connected tablet could do everything a smartphone can well enough (and more), but I still prefer to carry a phone over that. I definitely wouldn't get a smartwatch instead of a phone (except for a kid), but there are definitely some small set of things it does better.
- NameError 2y agoI think something with the "wow" factor of the Vision Pro but the form factor of a pair of glasses would be the holy grail of AR/VR. I wonder if there are fundamental tradeoffs which would make that impossible in the near term? I think it would remain very niche indefinitely in that case.
- pocketarc 2y ago> Or maybe these are just products we don't need? That's exactly it, they're products we don't -need-. If you already have a smartphone, that's good enough. This is the same problem that plagues the AI assistant devices - it doesn't matter what they can do, they won't replace your smartphone. Which means you're asking someone to carry (and pay for) a smartphone + an extra device. That's a big ask. It's also the reason why you see these stories of people living smartphone-only lives, doing everything on their smartphones without needing or even having a desktop/laptop. Smartphones are good enough for everything, for a lot of people. For the record: I -love- the Vision Pro. Tried it out, loved it. But I fall into the `Tech nerds like it because it's "cool"` part. I recognize that that's not going to be the popular opinion. Not now, not ever. There's just not enough value in VR/AR to really change societal norms to the point that everyone's going to want to wear these devices. Ultimately: Just because a product is a cool idea, doesn't mean it's society-altering. Some products just aren't that valuable.
- sroussey 2y ago> they're products we don't -need-. If you already have a smartphone, that's good enough. I disagree. If LinkedIn made AR glasses that told me who the person is I’m looking at (that I’m connected to on LinkedIn) and why/how we were connected, I’d buy that in a heartbeat.
- ffgjgf1 2y ago> If LinkedIn made AR glasses that told me who the person is I’m looking I could only hope that the EU would ban it ASAP if such a product existed making it unviable anywhere else. Except maybe China and such, should be pretty useful for the CCP enforcement agencies.
- bsimpson 2y agoGoogle Home was kind of magical when it launched, but as its reliability has degraded over time, its appeal has worn off. It is still nice to be able to ask it to play music or set an alarm or whatever without engaging with a screen. I haven't used a HomePod, but I suspect it's Apple's version of that experience.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoThe Sonos patent wars sucked. Things are somewhat back to ok, but man, it's just absurd & sad seeing basic networked av get ravaged by lawyers like so. I'm super glum about audio casting at the moment. It feels like less and less speakers have audio casting builtin. For a while there was a spare of speakers, some even battery powered, but it's turned into a trickle. There's also incredibly few options for amplifiers with builtin audio casting; what the NexusQ originally did! So frustrating. This is an ecosystem I am super bought into, and it feels like it's fading and there's not a replacement (especially with Sonos's recent enshittification seppuku).
- hughesjj 2y agoI ended up just getting normal speakers and attaching a dedicated box to them. I hate how it looks though, so many more wires, and you better hope your speakers are close enough to route a long USB cable for power to a wall outlet
- hhh 2y agoI don't know if it's similar, only because I don't really use Google products. You can ask the HomePod to turn on the Apple TV and play something, or to read out your messages (depending on your settings and whatnot). I don't really have an issue with it doing anything but playing music. I use it for HomeKit controls constantly, and love my HomePod mini's.
- 1propionyl 2y agoApple Home (as an integrated Matter/Thread client) is far more useful than the Vision Pro. It's easy to fixate on things like colorful lights, but consider instead automations based on how much energy is used when. For example, if I have a box fan or a portable AC unit on a smart plug, I can automate it running while I'm gone only if the temperature gets to a excess (for the benefit of pets, fruit on the counter, running computers, etc) or only when electricity is cheaper and/or cleaner. The most useful IoT devices, I think, aren't purpose devices that have a microcontroller integrated into them... so much as ones whose primary and only purpose bridge digital and physical by allowing you to actuate something remotely, be it the flow of electrify (smart plug), or physically flipping a switch (switchbot type).
- makestuff 2y agoYeah I frequently look at the vision pro reviews and think it would be cool to try, but I know after about a month I would get bored with it. $3500 is alot of money to spend on what is essentially the perfect device for watching movies on an airplane. It is an insanely impressive technology; however, like the iPadOS I think it is going to take a decade or so to have enough functionality to even consider being useful for professional tasks. I don't want to have to buy a macbook just to stream it to the vision pro to do any coding tasks.
- jordanb 2y ago> Or maybe these are just products we don't need? Silicon valley needs a product that will make us spend even more time online than our phones, in order to sell more ad inventory and make the line go up. This is pretty much what's driving all of this, especially the AR stuff. It's not a solution in search of a problem. The problem is they need to sell more ads. The only issue is that it's a solution to their problem, not ours.
- FL33TW00D 2y agoOr, on the other hand, AR could BLOCK all ads that you ever see. Sanitise your entire visual input, replace all ads with a grey square!
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoWhy do you think the manufacturers would allow that? Sure, you can effectively block ads in a web browser, on a desktop. Everything on mobile is in an app which explicitly does not allow you to tailor your experience, erm, nuke the ads from orbit. And every platform that's followed smartphones, from tablets to headsets, has followed the phone model of pushing software: closed-down OS, software through app stores or gtfo. It's incredibly naive to think ads will get better and not a hell of a lot worse.
- FL33TW00D 2y agoBecause you can just build things yourself. You don't need permission from anyone else.
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoA suggestion to build a computer or headset from scratch, having to factor in all the compatibility hoops the big players throw at you before they nuke you anyway for having unsanctioned hardware, is proof of your unseriousness.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThere are very few situations where I'd want to wear a bulky headset for any length of time. Although I don't play video games, I could see that people who are into it might find them pretty cool. The TV ads showing people at business meetings all wearing headsets and manipulating a shoe protoype in mid-air are just ridiculous. Or the one where a guy is trying to assemble a furniture kit and wearing a headset. Come on, you'll do better with a YouTube video and unobstructed eyes.
- psunavy03 2y agoThere was a time when you didn't "need" a PC, either, and they were seen as just nerd toys and things yuppies used to balance their checkbooks, back when "balancing your checkbook" was a thing you had to do. This changed with the advent of the Web, and held until desktops gave way to smartphones. If you could time-travel back to the 80s and 90s, plenty of folks would have scoffed that anyone would ever "need" a computer, let alone a computer in their pocket. But a lot of that is because "a computer" was a bulky beige thing with a CRT monitor, and maybe if you were really into it a 2400 baud modem. But then you'd have to splurge for a second phone line or pick which device to use, the modem or the phone. So I'd be wary of writing off AR/MR/XR as a dead end, as opposed to a technology that still needs more innovation to reach the mainstream. Glasses themselves are mainstream, and have been for centuries. What's holding AR devices back is the ability to miniaturize the necessary holographic technology, as well as the batteries and processing power. This will eventually be solved, just like an iPhone now has more processing power than the supercomputers of decades before. The problem with VR will always remain the same. You can't interact with other people while you have a big thing on your face that's designed to supplant your entire field of view, which limits desirable use cases.
- tqi 2y ago> If you could time-travel back to the 80s and 90s, plenty of folks would have scoffed that anyone would ever "need" a computer, let alone a computer in their pocket. Is that true? I feel like people have imagined portable communication / computing devices forever[1]. People maybe couldn't imagine that they could ever be small enough to be practical, but the utility of such a device was pretty obvious. Similarly, I think "VR" as a concept has obvious value and applications. However current implementations fall far short of what is necessary to unlock that value for most people / scenarios. [1] https://www.geeksandbeats.com/2016/02/star-trek-technology-today/ https://www.geeksandbeats.com/2016/02/star-trek-technology-t...
- Terr_ 2y ago> I feel like people have imagined portable communication / computing devices forever Another example would be fictional comic-book detective Dick Tracy's wristwatch, which started as two-way audio in 1946 and got upgraded to video in 1964.
- tootie 2y agoI'm pretty convinced that AR and specifically headset AR is just a dead end. No amount of sensors or pixels are going to make it viable for anything besides some tiny niches. VR is fun and has some uses. Everything else just needs a tactile keyboard or touchscreen.
- theshackleford 2y agoNot everyone is capable of using a keyboard or touch screen even today. For this reason I hope to see continued advancement in voice capabilities. I have it better than most but have to rely on dictation a lot due to issues in my hands/arms following an incomplete spinal cord injury.
- PaulHoule 2y ago(1) Price matters. If Detroit was selling $25k reasonably sized EVs they'd be selling like hotcakes, even if they had limited range. There are a few people who will pay $75k+ for a luxury EV but they bought a Tesla 10 years ago. If Detroit wanted to sell XXXL EV SUVs at crazy high prices they should have done it ten years ago. Now it's too late and they have to make the kind of cars BYD does or pass legislation to keep BYD out of our market. The Meta Quest consumer has proven they'd rather save a few bucks and buy an MQ2 instead of a better MQ3. It's a big problem for Meta because they're never going to move towards making better games that need an MQ3 to run. (2) VR > AR Apple's just plain wrong about the focus on AR. The Apple Vision Pro has the hardware to provide far superior immersive world application story than the MQ3 but the software (and maybe controller) story isn't there. Apple acts as if there was something morally wrong with VR, like it is putting your hands in their toilet with all the conviction they have that it is OK to take 30% of all the revenue of the app economy. Sorry, visiting VR worlds is half the value you could get out of a product and throwing out half the value is like doubling the price. A cheap set of XReal glasses can say "this is just good for watching the HDMI output of a game console" but at Apple Vision Pro prices product that expensive really has to "do it all" with no excuses. People really do subscribe to VR fitness apps, they really do have fun playing games like Asgard's Wrath 2 or games like Riven. Have you ever heard anyone say that they were engaged with an app for the Vision Pro?
- salzig 2y agoIn regards to VR, I think Valve could really move the hole situation by building/providing SteamLink VR on AVP, as they do on Meta Quest. Buy any Bluetooth (VR) Controller and enjoy games streamed. And maybe in some future I will be able to stream from Linux hosts via SteamLink.
- PaulHoule 2y agoExactly, a device that expensive has to deliver as much value as possible. Trying to sell a lifestyle accessory for people who have to own every Apple product that there is the beginning of the end for Apple that they’ll be talking about in business school the way we talk about DEC, Tandem and Commodore today.
- spacemadness 2y agoI feel like Apple missed the ZIRP window to release this to a larger quantity of tech nerds who weren’t continually worried about being laid off.
- pzo 2y agoIf they wouldn't be too greedy they could make a device that combines: Apple TV, HomePod, Apple Router, Time Machine - that would be an ultimate smart home device... but they want to sell both Apple TV, HomePod and iCloud for storage.
- pie420 2y agoaww man i was looking forward to consuming even more content and seeing even more relevant ads in virtual reality!
- OsrsNeedsf2P 2y agoThis is another big problem for VR: The headsets are very locked down. Getting something like an Ad Blocker, sideloading apps, or general functionality hacking is too cumbersome. You burn out and go back to your laptop before long.
- jayd16 2y agoSideloading on the Meta headsets is trivial. Its probably as hard to change the bootloader as it is on Android (I mean, it IS Android) but I'm not sure what you would need that for.
- zooq_ai 2y agoBefore the bandwagon jumps on "Metaverse is dead", Meta is pursuing multiple headsets, devices strategy and trying to find the right Features / Price mix. Quest 2 is the most successful headset and it seem to have the perfect balance. Quest 3 although great, probably is slightly expensive for the mass market. But there will be a chatGPT moment for Metaverse in the next 5 years and Meta's strategy will pay dividends. It's Ray-ban smart glasses is already a huge hit. Like a startup, you just have to keep iterating and I'm glad zuck is on it
- juanani 2y ago[dead]
- GaggiX 2y ago>But there will be a chatGPT moment for Metaverse in the next 5 years Honestly I doubt it. ChatGPT is a free service that is genuinely helpful. For the Metaverse you need to buy the headset and the hardware to run it for what? Wasting time in a virtual store instead of just using a UI? Using it on a worst version of VRchat?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cut3 2y ago> It's Ray-ban smart glasses is already a huge hit. Sure, "huge hit". Anecdote but the only time Ive ever seen anyone wear one was when I interviewed at meta and one of the folks interviewing me was wearing them.
- jowday 2y agoAlso, completely anecdotal, but the only people I’ve ever seen wearing them are Facebook employees.
- throwway120385 2y ago
- SunlitCat 2y agoFor VR really taking the next step, (realistic) haptic feedback is needed. Just better graphics and the like won't do anymore.
- smm11 2y agoComputer headsets. Blockchain. AI. Really hitting the mark recently.
- zaphod420 2y agoI use all three of those things every day... Couldn't imagine my life without them now.
- input_sh 2y agoThere are dozens of you, dozens!
- jayrot 2y agoI’m racking my brain hard to try to imagine how someone uses the blockchain everyday
- rauljordan2020 2y agoI use Ethereum / Arbitrum every week at least. I use it for managing a lot of my finances. I provide liquidity on exchanges, provide liquidity for lending protocols, and use GMX for opening long/short positions and trading perpetuals. I also use USDC a lot, and also do self-custody
- user9925 2y agoNot sure why AI is on that list.
- nozzlegear 2y agoMaybe "what most companies use AI for" (i.e. glorified data collection) or "what most companies try to pass off as useful AI" (i.e. what we used to call machine learning, but now that ecommerce app can also tell you your latest sales in the form of a poem).
- wrsh07 2y agoHonestly, this is a shame, because I think a lot of the vision pro's flaws are Apple problems. That said, meta seems to have found a sweet spot in price/performance, so maybe in a few generations we will have something with the quality of vision pro that is not locked down
- spacemadness 2y agoI still can’t believe they expected people to be excited about a floating iPad OS UX as the main experience.
- threeseed 2y agoIt is just a launcher for your applications. The main experience are the apps just like on every other device.
- aprilthird2021 2y agoSaying this is like the most anti-Apple thing ever. It literally sounds like Microsoft when they were designing Windows and when Apple started eating their market share away because they cared about the little details
- asadotzler 2y agoIt's not a sweet spot. It's less then 10 million MAU over 5 years for about $40 billion dollars. How is that a sweet spot. If you can't get 10 million MAUs in 5 years for $40 billion dollars, you're a failure. Quest is a failure. AVP being an even bigger failure doesn't make Quest a success.
- hollerith 2y agoMAU == monthly active users.
- wrsh07 2y agoWhat is the goal of quest? Is it to get mau? Is it sales and marketing for eng (come work at _, where we have fun projects like these Glasses - sounds familiar), is it to develop and flex hardware muscles? Is it to make sure Meta is competitive if/when there is a paradigm shift away from mobile? I think Mark is thrilled to have a hardware product that they can deploy their ML models to. Was that intentional? Obviously no, but at some point they're paying for optionality. They want the option to build a million hardware units in a year, they want the option to build a competitor to Apple's next hardware device (frankly, in the counterfactual that AVP took off, Meta was extremely well-positioned) Meta is a money-printing machine, and so they have choices: invest in moonshot hardware (or ai) projects, stock buybacks/dividends They have a huge dividend. What do you want them to do? More stock buybacks? Make less money?
- paxys 2y agoI feel like they have struck gold with the Meta Ray-ban glasses. Perfect form factor, looks cool, not obtrusive, has actual features that people want to use. That IMO is the future of wearables + AR/VR + AI, not a bulky headset.
- jowday 2y agoEvery company knows this, the problem is that you can’t fit the compute you need for AR/VR + AI into a form factor like this, at least not right now.
- cdchn 2y agoI don't think you'll ever be able to. Maybe not for decades for AR/VR. The AI stuff is cool; you can offload that, but mostly they'll just be a glorified camera mount and headphones for the actual 'glasses.'
- redundantly 2y agoYour comment won't age well.
- cdchn 2y agoGuess we'll see in a few decades. People thought VR was on the brink of mass market breakthrough in the 90s too.
- p1necone 2y agoYou already can in something the size of an old cassette walkman, run an extra flexible USB c cable to the glasses or something and problem solved
- cdchn 2y agoThe offloading is easy, I don't think the optical aspects of breakthrough VR/AR will be overcome for quite a while.
- xyst 2y agoZuckerberg really is grasping at straws now. Failed projects: - metaverse - VR - digital currency - failed to reel in on misinformation campaigns on social networks - meta/facebook killed “crowdtangle” (misinformation tracking tool) The only thing keeping them afloat is advertising money (which has been dwindling due to people fleeing their shit platform).
- screye 2y agoA counter point on premium VR headsets. They are teleportation devices. I've used every popular VR device, but one Vision Pro experience stood out - 'The Haleakala environment'[1] It was literally like being transported there. I know because I had been in that exact spot a few years before. I have a rich visual memory which served as reference, and no exaggeration, it felt like was there. I was immediately in tears. It was profound. The Vision pro's lack of a killer app because development is unintuitive, userbase is small, the UX is alien and the hardware costs of constructing these experience is still rather high. Give it a few years. The hardware is already there. This isn't a solution in search of a problem. This is PalmOS, a solution that is too early to the market. I have family with disabilities. Being able to teleport my loved ones to places they could never go themselves is worth the $3000. If I could record my most profound memories with 'VR recorder', I would. My parent missed my graduation because of being continents away. You think they wouldn't want to be teleported to it ? Wedding photographers cost $4000+, so we can relive those memories through shoddy snapshots. Why not be teleported back to the most beautiful day ? Don't knock it till you try it. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wK63OSmF1FM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wK63OSmF1FM
- jrm4 2y agoMakes sense: But do you need to BUY one? This is the thing I realized with VR sets, personally. They are a great day at the fair, but who goes to the fair EVERYDAY?
- riehwvfbk 2y agoAn addict, that's who. And this is exactly what this technology will eventually enable - seeing the world through an influencer's eyes while sitting on a ratty couch in a dilapidated apartment. William Gibson painted this picture beautifully in Count Zero.
- devchix 2y agoCTRL-F Gibson, the tech and root parent comment eerily reminded me of Fragments of A Hologram Rose. We're closing the gap between fiction and reality. The short story was written in 1977! Gibson was prescient about so many things. "He bought an ASP cassette that began with the subject asleep on a quiet beach. It had been recorded by a young blonde yogi with 20-20 vision and an abnormally acute color sense. The boy had been flown to Barbados for the sold purpose of taking a nap and his morning's exercise on a brilliant stretch of private beach. The microfiche laminate in the cassette's transparent case explained that the yogi could will himself through alpha to delta without an inducer. Parker, who hadn't been able to sleep without an inducer for two years, wondered if this was possible."
- numpad0 2y agoIsn't it simple why AVP isn't moving? They don't treat anime-loli-porn content, chiefly VRChat, as first class citizens, if they support those at all. Tons of people have bought and are buying Quest 2 and 3 as well as its competitors with sole intent of using it with VRChat. Don't you guys all remember that iPhoneOS had YouTube since version 1.0, before it even had App Store? Where would you think iOS would have been if it didn't? No way it could have been like Apple TV+ would have launched years earlier and completely obsoleted YouTube. But to me it looks that that is what Apple is banking on.
- nox101 2y ago$3500 is also a big reason. Why pay that when I can get a Quest2 for $199 new for the anime-loli-porn content?
- RockRobotRock 2y agoThat’s a slightly unfair characterization. VRC kept me sane during quarantine as I suspect it did for a lot of people. It’s also a nice oasis for people with a lot of social anxiety. Sure there’s unsavory content on there, no denying that. So does every platform with user generated content. Have you seen Meta Horizon? It’s no less than an Orwellian nightmare. I’ve seen people form meaningful relationships, and achieve amazing things by fostering a real sense of community.
- pzo 2y ago
- Keyframe 2y agoRaise your hand who was there during the first boom and doom of VR/AR headset/glasses in the 90's? A cycle or couple of more and we'll be there, maybe.
- talldatethrow 2y agoI feel like I have spectacular eyes. I can read absurdly small texts that shocks other people, great low light, yada yada. The quest2 made my eyes hurt after just using it for maybe half an hour. Tried it a few times over several weeks and decided that my vision is worth more than some entertainment. I'm not sure how they're going to get around that aspect.
- andybak 2y agoNever had that personally and I regularly code (or at least interact with code) in VR
- kalium-xyz 2y agoIve work vr googles over 20 hours without issues. Are you sure youre not having dry eyes? I cant do it as long after ive had lasik
- talldatethrow 2y agoIt's not dry eyes but more the 'muscles' in the eye that feel fatigued. I don't remember if it's from focusing or moving the actual eyeball around in an attempt to see edges of the screen instead of moving my head.
- theshackleford 2y agoI’m short sighted and have been using VR for close too if not on a decade and have never experienced this. I spend entire days in VR and I’m completely fine with it.
- bbatsell 2y agoThe Quest 2 has minimal inter-pupillary distance (IPD) adjustment — only three fixed options. If your eyes don’t match closely enough to one of them, it can be very uncomfortable. Mine don’t, and I have the same experience as you, but I can put up with it for short bursts. More expensive headsets have much better lenses and adjustment options. It’s not an inherent problem with VR, just concessions to make a cheap device.
- salzig 2y agoIMHO: the AVP is a DevKit that is sold to consumers. But more polished then the typical DevKit. But looking into the past and seeing how many people where eager to buy GoogleGlas/Oculus Devkits, why shouldn’t a brand like apple decide to push out a devkit as high price consumer device, instead of trying to keep a devkit for a upcoming product a secret? I’m still wondering what direction the product can and will take from here on. If you compare it with iphone1 vs iPhones today, it could be quite interesting.
- layer8 2y agoI disagree, given Apple’s marketing around it, features like Persona FaceTime, and integrating spatial camera shooting on iPhones. But even if it were true, it’s also failing as a devkit, given how few devs are interested in it.
- gyomu 2y agoBecause they invested billions of dollars into making said devkit and despite seeming promising the actual general usefulness of it was still extremely unclear, so it was down to 2 choices: a) kill it, or b) ship it and see what happens when the rubber meets the road. Arguably Apple has never done b) before, but then again they’ve also never poured billions into a R&D project like this before. (The only other example that comes to mind is the car, and that one got killed, so maybe they were loath to kill the two billion dollar science fair projects at the same time).
- ynniv 2y agoYou mean 21st century Apple. Because 20th century Apple had plenty of good flops: Newton, Pippin, Macintosh TV (no, not Apple TV). https://www.macrumors.com/2023/01/14/apples-biggest-hardware-flops/ https://www.macrumors.com/2023/01/14/apples-biggest-hardware...
- dotnet00 2y agoI think the issue is just that the developers Apple wants to poach for this are the ones that they push away the most. Not only does Meta already control a large chunk of VR game development (to the point that even regular PCVR has been kind of starved for content), but game developers, besides for the iPhone, don't really care for Apple, and considering that the AVP does not have the things that the iPhone has going for it...
- pzo 2y agoI wish Meta also created something similar to xreal glasses or even better: some modular RayBan smart glasses that can be transformed into xreal with addon.
- khazhoux 2y agoI have an AVP. It’s the best TV and movie-watching experience I’ve ever had, in some ways even better than Metreon IMAX
- jkubicek 2y agoThe best TV and movie-watching experience _if you aren't eating or drinking_. I love watching movies on my AVP, but the experience of groping for a popcorn bowl semi-blindly is enough of a turn-off that I end up just using our regular TV most of the time.
- paxys 2y agoAnd if you don't watch stuff with your friends or family.
- khazhoux 2y agoAVP is for when I want to binge Fallout in 2 days on a jaw dropping huge screen floating above me, when my fam has no interest in watching five minutes of it.
- aprilthird2021 2y agoYour fam doesn't find it weird when you're strapped into a slightly smaller Daft Punk helmet for 2 entire days, just taking breaks to eat and do basic hygiene? Maybe you can say it's the best movie watching experience ever. Id rather watch a movie on a $20 TV from Craigslist with my wife. Even if she hates it, we bond over it and that matters more, imo
- nusl 2y agoWell, you do that then. Not everyone has to conform to your world view or preferences. Some people are perfectly fine with using a VR device.
- amelius 2y agoThe killer app is pr0n, but Apple won't allow it while Zuck loves to watch over your shoulder.
- Ancapistani 2y agoIt’s really not. Porn isn’t really any better on a Vision Pro than it is on a Quest 3 - or, for that matter, a Quest 2.
- hughesjj 2y agoI think they meant for AR/VR in general and not specifically for the AVP vs Quest et all
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- seydor 2y agovr porn ain't that good. the artists need to up their game
- saagarjha 2y agoBe the change you wish to see in the world.
- slashdave 2y agoNot an expert, but my first impression was that once Meta got ahold of the Apple Vision Pro and took it apart in the lab, the conclusion was that had no chance of beating it, from a hardware point of view.
- ProAm 2y agoThey do, but Meta's knows the market for $3500 device is way smaller than Apple realized. Sub $1000 is a must. Apple doesn't respect or support developers so there are no apps for it, no games for it. Everything but the screens are sub-par for the Apple device (to date, things might change). Meta will come out with a Quest 4 that will be better than the 3 and sell WAY more than Apple's device. As heard on a podcast, I've seen more Cybertrucks than I have Apple Vision Pro's in the world.
- m3kw9 2y agoThis is good news for Apple because their foot is not going off the pedal and now can create more firsts which can lead to more standards gearing toward them
- thr0waway001 2y agoNever bought any headsets of any sort. And until there is a compelling, application, or a killer app I probably never will. Gaming is definitely not it.
- zmmmmm 2y agoI think the chain of logic is that due to anaemic reception and the Quest3 being unexpectedly good, Apple has pulled forward the cheaper Vision Pro. This has lead to Meta launching head to head with that product, and hence needing to either produce something with comparable specs or do it for a much cheaper price than they thought previously. That not being feasible, they are falling back to their mass market strategy - fully own the low to middle end. But none of this is about either company stepping back from the overall vision. What they are doing is jostling for market strategy, fit and timing - and adjusting to each other's moves as they go.
- fidotron 2y agoIt has been clear from fairly early on the AVP should never have launched - it just has no reason to exist. I cannot escape thinking there must have been some internal argument where the choices ended up as kill the project or release what we have, and the latter was chosen because it was seen to be easier. Let’s face it, without Zuck’s personal interest reality labs would have gone years ago. It is one thing for companies with billions to burn them chasing non existent markets but when they attempt to drag in lots of smaller third parties in order to build demand for their platforms . . . well, developers should be a lot more skeptical. The low hanging fruit of the personal computing age appears to have been picked.
- jayd16 2y agoAt least Meta has bootstraped a niche in the console market. They identified a market and can iterate on it. Apple seems content to provide essentially nothing to do on the device.
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> the choices ended up as kill the project or release what we have Yeah, kill the project would have made the shareholders very displeased. I don't think what Apple has is incomplete, VR is just not all that. Immersion for most people is like a roller coaster — fun for a bit but who wants to ride all day?
- aranelsurion 2y agoIt would be great to have a personal rollercoaster at home.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoC'mon, you know after the first week it would sit in the backyard and gather rust.
- audunw 2y ago> it just has no reason to exist I’ve seen plenty of people who have found a legitimate use for it. And as many have pointed out it serves as a dev kit that also happened to be sold to consumers. It helps Apple and developers figure out what people actually want to use the device for. There also seems to be a lot of people who find it to be a near perfect implementation of VR/AR, except for size/weight, price and perhaps the resolution and fov could be just a tad better. These seem like things they could fix with a second gen non-pro headset. The automatic eye adjustment and external screen may be an expression of an ultimate VR experience but can easily be dropped with a non pro version. With less heat the fans can be smaller. Perhaps they can start using those new piezo based blowers. The metal body and external battery pack will already help keep things cool despite the powerful chips and high power consumption. The existence of the pro version will give a halo effect that will make it easier for Apple to sell a non pro version, even if it’s still more expensive than the most expensive Oculus headsets. Whether they’ll increase resolution and fov is uncertain. They might wait until it can inherit the tech from a second gen pro version.
- mhh__ 2y agoApple probably need to choose between vision pro (i.e. experimental hardware) and making movies and TV. If they do the latter, everyone (i.e. netflix) will fight them.
- AndrewKemendo 2y agoIf you’re asking yourself: Why are all these giant companies going hard on AR and repeatibly in cycles it’s for one reason: Egocentric data and full control of the highest bandwidth human I/O (vision + sound) is the most important possible data pipeline to get Its the penultimate data pipe, with direct connection to the brain being the ultimate data pipe (see:Neuralink) Every company that is winning and going to win in the future is the company that can best predict human behavior, such that it’s directly shaped by the platform itself Google had a internal teaser trailer about this a decade ago that I’m sure someone has seen. Hyperreality was a short video about this probable and likely future So it’s all a game to get perfect attention and the best way to do that is - literally - something like the interface that is used for the matrix on each hovercraft If you introduce that too quickly - like now - then you scare everyone. So Apple rushed it and Meta is a actually good at timing in AR cause they have a giant lead, so they can wait till people forget. The goal is titration of all encompassing spyware that eventually literally controls your behavior. The short story Manna is currently, unironically, and not hyperbolically what the employee experience at Target, Amazon warehouses and Walmart are 1:1. The corporate goal is to have everyone in their ecosystem deterministically creating, consuming and engaging at the peak for optimal tuning of the attention system.
- loeg 2y agoIt's dumber than that. Meta just wants to own an App Store and get 30% of some platform's revenue.
- talldayo 2y agoI'd believe that better if Meta didn't also deliberately provide a sideloading mechanism and encourage homebrew. It's a believable end-goal, but it doesn't seem to be the direction they want to go in the immediate future.
- deisteve 2y agoyou are reading too much into Meta. They arent the NSA
- whiterknight 2y agoJust want to point out this headline or article doesn’t say that one is the cause of the other, just that they coincide.
- voidfunc 2y agoThere is no future for the Vision Pro unless they can scale it to a comfortable stylish form factor or establish a killer app. Nobody wants to walk around wearing goggles all day just to read email.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bpiroman 2y agoI think everyone knew this wouldn't work or simply because we aren't ready for this tech yet? But kudos to Apple for giving it a go!!
- Animats 2y agoAs Carmack (the game guy, head of Oculus, etc.) says, until the headgear gets down to swim goggle size, it's not going to get any traction, and until it gets down to eyeglass size, it's not going mainstream. The Apple Vision Pro was an unexpected dud. Something more eyeglass sized, with phone-like functionality and good design, would have been more in line with Apple's aesthetic. Instead, it was another half brick on your head VR headset. Apple had a success with iDweebs, their ear pieces, as something worn full time. The Apple Vision Pro could not be used that way.
- EasyMark 2y agoI love daft punk’s music but I have no desire to look like them while going about the day’s business.
- FileSorter 2y agoThis is HackerNews, we all know who Carmack is. >Apple Vision Pro was an unexpected dud ??? Just about everyone (even diehard Apple fanboys) knew this would flop.
- umvi 2y agoI have a Quest 2. Half Life: Alyx is one of the most amazing games I've ever played. And yet... I haven't finished it. When I have free time to play games I'd rather play my Switch. It's a lot more hassle setting up HL: Alyx, and the heavy headgear bugs my nose and causes eye strain headaches eventually if I play too much. So instead I play Tetris 99.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anonyfox 2y agoIt struggles mostly because it’s far too expensive, which also prevents bootstrapping some ecosystem of usecases.
- light_triad 2y agoThere was an interesting email from Zuck released during one of their trials where he explained why they were focused on VR: it was basically all about Apple and wanting to own the next platform. Makes sense although gaming is and will remain the most significant use case for VR in the foreseeable future The original email is from 2015, posted on HN in 2022: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33538742#33540359 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33538742#33540359
- mrkramer 2y agoIf I remember correctly; Zuck wanted to acquire Unity because he thought Unity would be the next big AR/VR platform, which Meta would hopefully control, instead of Apple and Google controlling the next big distribution platform. In retrospect, it would've been better that way because Unity's management will destroy Unity sooner or later.
- rajnathani 2y agoYes, also whatever high-end device they launch would also have a lower market capture from the TAM of high-end VR/XR headsets thanks to Apple being nearly uncompeteable in the hardware for it.
- whoitwas 2y agoI learned from these comments Apple Vision Pro isn't intended for gaming. No wonder Buffet sold out of them. WTF are they thinking? Might have to transition to Linux fully at some point before I die if they continue doing stupid things.
- whitehexagon 2y agoI suspect these newer headsets have struggled because of walled gardens and crazy pricing, and thus lack of developer interest. The Oculus DK2 was just a second monitor, amazingly simple and fun to develop for. One of the most developer friendly devices I worked with. Oculus CV1 proprietary driver, forced experience, worsening SDK and dropping linux basically killed the device (and VR) for me, even before fb got their grubby mits on it. So I struggle to understand these premium devices, when there seems to be no developer incentive to build for these platforms. Shame, I think VR still has some great potential, but I will never don a headset that needs an account or shows me even a single advert.
- SunlitCat 2y agoI ordered my DK2 a few hours after it got announced. The FB take over was between the release of the DK2 and the CV1 and with the CV1 (and the FB takeover) came that terrible Software.
- koolala 2y agoIf Valve makes a Deckard Linux headset thats fun to dev for and achives a solid Linux VR experience it could change the field of computer science.
- barrkel 2y agoI got a Quest 3 recently, and the necessity for side-loading apps onto it to make it useful is kind of puzzling. SideQuest is almost mandatory. You can't easily copy files on or off it to network locations without CX File Explorer, side loaded from an untrusted source, hidden from the default application launcher. You'd think they'd loosen the reins a bit in order to get a bigger installed base, but it's trying to drive so hard towards this Horizon Worlds metaspace thing that I just do not give one whit for.
- jncfhnb 2y agoThey struggled because they didn’t actually have good software to run
- laweijfmvo 2y agoMeta thinks they got screwed by Apple’s (and to a lesser extent Google’s) walled gardens, so now they want their own.
- moi2388 2y agoVR will probably never be more than a gimmick imo. AR is where the market is at. Regular glasses, with current phone capabilities, like painting the actual road you’re going to travel green would already get hundreds of thousands of adopters.
- FMecha 2y agoMy perception is that AR is also a gimmick that won't seem to take off any time soon. How many times AR technologies have come and went in whimper?
- moi2388 2y agoBecause the glasses are too big, or the implementation sucks. I don’t want to see an arrow where I need to go. I don’t want to wear a VR headset. I want regular glasses. I want the road I need to travel to be a yellow brick road. I want to see the person I’m calling in front of me. I want some details about the building or business I’m looking at when I ask for it, like opening hours, phone number, reviews. Instead we get shitty shooter games.
- naveen99 2y agoIs it time for another company rename to llama or data or something a la AI ?
- germinalphrase 2y agoI have been bearish on VR, but could never overcome motion sickness. This obviously puts a limit on viable content types for me. Can anyone speak to any differences in motion sickness between VR and Apple’s implementation of AR/MR?
- boringg 2y agoVR just isn’t going to happen for a long time. It does have a real purpose or a strong drive to use. I have meta 3 and i played for a bit but then it ended up on the shelf for a variety of reasons. It has a lot of good specific uses but struggles past that. It continued to be very impressive technology wise but something that wont be adopted en mass for a long time. Tim Cook was right to be worried about this product - should have trusted his intuition on that one.
- makoConstruct 2y agoWhen you say "a long time" do you mean 2026, or 2029?
- boringg 2y ago2030s
- barrkel 2y agoI'm going to try out the new travel mode on a transatlantic flight tomorrow - mildly excited by the possibility of escaping the claustrophobic confines of 11 hours in an airplane.
- H8crilA 2y agoDon't you worry, Apple is still looking for a product market fit. And when you have enough billions, do enough brainstorming and cool ad videos you can actually find things that never existed in the first place. Then we will see mass adoption of this millennials' dream tech.