7 ms·
Workers are stuck in place because everyone is too afraid of a recession to quit
- throwuxiytayq 2y ago> “I feel trapped here,” Amanda said. “I’m financially screwed if I leave, and that’s why I don’t, or can’t leave.” This is so common. People are afraid of and unprepared for income and status setbacks. Sometimes you need to take a couple steps back to get back on track. (I’m currently taking a step back and I’m intimately familiar with the uncertainty of it.)
- jt2190 2y agoWhat is "taking a step back" exactly? Leaving a job that you don't like for one that you do like but pays less?
- fy20 2y agoThat's the position I'm in. My current employer has not grown as they sold to me when I joined (they've actually got smaller) and has gone through a big cultural shift that doesn't jibe with me. I've received an offer from a company that seems to have a lot better alignment... But it pays 10% less. Meanwhile my current salary has not kept up with inflation over the past couple of years.
- mcsniff 2y agoIMO, it can also be a philosophical thing. "What do I want out of my one short life? To spend it toiling away unhappy 90% of the time and spend money trying to be happy the remaining 10% or find something I enjoy doing the majority of the time that can also pay some bills?" A lot of people are asking themselves these questions, and if you're not -- why not?
- Loughla 2y agoI think there has also been a massive shift in the game though. More young people are seeing work as a means to an end instead of a calling. Jobs don't define people like they used to. So, trading your week days for money to do everything you want in the weekends is pretty okay now. Being a company (wo)man is sort of seen as being a class traitor? Maybe that's just because I work with low income college students, though.
- marcuskane2 2y agoThere was a period of time (80s-90s) that the American middle class was booming and thriving. Boomers with stable but unfulfilling jobs regretted not following their dreams, and the future looked bright, so they told their millenial kids to chase their passions and the money would follow. Then a generation of millenials collectively got millions of degrees in liberal arts and humanities, but the degrees didn't have any class-signaling power or economic value the way a college degree in 1970 did, so instead of getting cushy careers they ended up in low-paid, low-status unfulfilling jobs, with debt from a useless degree. Gen Z saw that happen and took a more practical view towards college, careers, etc.
- razakel 2y agoAnd the stable unfulfilling jobs all went to China.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoIt could be "pay cut for different domain" or "pay cut for better location but lower CoL". In a more extreme case you can re-spec to another industry altogether. You may not make anywhere close to what you made in tech, but you have 7 figures in stocks and 6 figures in savings anyway. Money is no longer a worry, why not follow a passion? In addition, it can be non-job motivations. e.g. you take a year off to travel for a bit, or engage in some hobby that you know won't make any income. I wouldn't mind doing some art classes if I ever got to that kind of money to live off of for years.
- thr0w 2y ago> better location but lower CoL How does that work?
- johnnyanmac 2y ago"better" is very subjective and doing a lot of heavy lifting, my apologies. The easy snarky response is "move from US to EU". But it can be a personal choice to simply get out of the metropolitan areas in favor of a quieter area, or one with better transportation or less crime or friendlier communities.
- Copernicron 2y ago> you have 7 figures in stocks and 6 figures in savings anyway I honestly can’t tell if you’re serious here. I’ve been in tech for almost twenty years and the only way I could have 7 figures in stocks is if I still lived at home and didn’t contribute anything to the budget. There is a whole world of people working in tech outside of Silicon Valley’s ridiculous compensation. Money is still a concern for the vast majority of us. No one in my company has equity except the founder. On the off chance we actually get far enough for me to get equity I’ll be lucky to get $100k out of it.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoI'm a game dev so no worries, I'm about as far from the minmax total comp bubble as you can get. But yes, it was a purposeful use of extremes. Unless you rush to young retirement or are in that SV scene and move out, most people won't have the means to metaphorically move out to the pastures and become a farm hand. But that is in fact an option for a few in tech. I recall some 20+ year googling choosing to leave and pick up comedy as a career.
- chasd00 2y agoThis is what’s called the “golden handcuffs “. You want to leave but the current job is pretty good and you likely won’t be able to find something better.
- paxys 2y ago"I want to leave but I have $2.5M worth of RSUs vesting in the next two years" = golden handcuffs. "I want to leave but if I do I may not be able to find another job and may not be able to pay rent" is instead the reality most Americans face.
- charlie0 2y agoGolden handcuffs only happen because of lifestyle inflation that prevents you from building F U money. $2.5M is more than enough to retire on.
- auntienomen 2y agoYou can't retire until you get the $2.5M, and your employer isn't going to give it to you if quit early. That's what makes it handcuffs.
- charlie0 2y agoVesting period is generally 4 years, so while you're right, 4 years is a very short period of time to wear the cuffs.
- marcuskane2 2y ago> $2.5M is more than enough to retire on For a single, childless person who wants to live a lower-middle class lifestyle in a low cost of living area, sure. But if you want to live in a decent location, you're looking at needing at least a million just for a house. That leaves 1.5 to generate income, so at a 3% safe withdrawal rate that's $45k per year. After taxes that's now like $35k. And you're not getting health insurance from employer so budget $6k per year for premiums (and be ready to pay out up to $6k per year more if you end up in the hospital). So in the end, you've got something like $20k-$29k per year to live on. That covers groceries, car maintenance/insurance/payments, upkeep on the house, phone, etc sufficiently for one person. But you're probably not joining your friends on their ski vacation or even going out for drinks with them too often. And of course, the whole thing falls apart with a family. The average cost of health insurance for a family of 4 is $24,000 per year.
- jokoon 2y agoI live in France, and financially I'm fine not working, I have a few savings, welfare is enough for me. What is truly problematic is the social isolation, the inactivity, and a feeling of not being included. I could go working any job for 20h per week if it did not feel alienating and so competitive and busy. The work mentality is survival of the fittest on steroids. Work is a binary ingroup or outgroup. People who are out are seen as undeserving and seen as lesser people. That's why people want to keep their job.
- 2-3-7-43-1807 2y agogiven your financial situation, aren't you in a position to trade salary for satisfaction?
- jokoon 2y agosure but still can't get a job anyway
- bix6 2y agoWhich companies have great training programs and happy lifetime employees? The main one that comes to mind is Costco.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoIf you read /r/costco, supposedly the new bosses have changed a lot of things for the worse, especially for the non floor employees.
- Spastche 2y agothe only thing I can think of is the military and that's only in some circumstances
- silisili 2y agoAnymore, it's rare to find. UPS used to create lifers because their benefits were so good, including free education and a stipend for an apartment even. That's all gone, I think, as they were paring it back in the late 90s already. And nearly everyone has gotten rid of pensions, sadly.
- ghaff 2y agoDefined-benefit pensions stopped making sense for a variety of tax and other reasons--including that to get any benefit you typically needed to stay at a place at least 5 years with 10-20 years to get a big benefit. A benefits friend of mine tells me there are some newer programs that work differently from the traditional ones though they're still not that common as far as I can tell.
- zem 2y agowhen i interviewed with nvidia they said they aimed to be the kind of company where people stayed forever and worked on long term projects. ultimately the interview process moved too slowly for me (i had been laid off and needed to find and accept another job fast), but i was impressed with everyone i talked to and would believe that that was not just a pitch but actually reflected their values.
- fundad 2y agoIt seems like the employers have a lot to gain by spreading the fear of a recession to make the job market to be more favorable to them. Didn't the Treasury secretary quip “The enemy keeps postponing when the recession’s going to come... They are dying to have a recession. They can’t bear going into next year’s election with the economy the way that it is.” https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2019/07/wilbur-ross-democrats-enemy https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2019/07/wilbur-ross-democrat... Wait, that's the former Treasury secretary, they sure knew how to do petty.
- Vaslo 2y ago“Vanity Fair” lol
- prewett 2y agoAnd now the wheel turns... Two or three years ago everyone was quitting.
- robotnikman 2y agoJust one part of a cycle that keeps repeating, hopefully.
- wahnfrieden 2y agoWealth transfers are resulting in greater accumulation at the top with each pass
- thr0w 2y agoI have a feeling the party's over for good for software engineers. The industry has had a lot of time to build up abstractions and deliver them via frameworks and SaaS products. Now the market is mature - everyone and their mom is glued to the internet, cozy with their well-worn apps. I'm struggling to think of some new frontier that will require mass quantities of raw skilled labor. At least not in our lifetime. This is the internet boom come to rest.
- HaZeust 2y agoWhat are you even talking about? Something comes around every 3-5 years to replenish the software engineer's existence - this time around it's AI.
- coffeecloud 2y agoIn 1 year I can stand up a system big enough that it would require 2 engineers to manage its ongoing maintenance, feature requests, bug fixes, 3rd party API updates, etc More software requires more software engineers to maintain it, who then write more software, which then require more engineers to maintain it, on and on and on…
- thr0w 2y ago
- rachofsunshine 2y agoWe hear this from candidates pretty often (it's the second most common specific reason for a candidate to turn down outreach for a job, after "please don't match me with crypto companies" [1]), although we're new enough that I can't make an apples-to-apples comparison for how common it was prior to the current environment. What's odd is that, on paper and for the engineering jobs we work with specifically, it doesn't seem like that's actually more justified now than it was a year or two ago. The tech hiring market seems to have bottomed out and to be (unsteadily) on its way back up. Two years ago, prediction markets [2] were pretty confident a recession would occur by this point, but it hasn't. They're now down to about 25% that it'll occur by the end of this year, although the fact that the percentage has stayed flat even as time has run out suggests markets are a bit more bearish now than they were six months ago. And they think [3] that large interest rate cuts are coming. But perhaps a few years of frustration and seeing others struggle has taken its toll in ways that go beyond object-level economic predictions. Experience with rough conditions might've made people more risk averse, or make them feel more secure in the job they do have (after all, there's a good chance they've survived some layoffs at this point), both of which could (rationally) make them stick where they are even if their opinions of the broader economy were the same or better. ---- [1] EDITED to add: reasons they turn down outreach we actually send, meaning it's not disqualified by some structured info we have about their preferences. For example, we know whether a candidate wants a remote job, so even though ~60% of our candidates are looking for remote jobs only, that wouldn't be in this ranking. [2] https://manifold.markets/chrisjbillington/will-the-us-enter-a-recession-by-20 https://manifold.markets/chrisjbillington/will-the-us-enter-... [3] https://manifold.markets/barak/by-how-much-will-the-fed-cut-intere https://manifold.markets/barak/by-how-much-will-the-fed-cut-...
- tomcam 2y agoGreat perspective, thanks. Are you seeing fewer openings? Same quality or lower?
- rachofsunshine 2y agoMore and higher quality. That's not a data-driven observation, though, it's just my own subjective impression (though it is one backed up by everyone else in the hiring space that I speak to right now).
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- nine_zeros 2y agoTech industry has actually had a recession in jobs but not a recession in earnings. This is a prime example of how our society has become so precarious for the middle class while the rich just keep getting richer.
- tootie 2y agoThat's not really true and not really a thing. Unemployment in tech is even lower than the general economy. It just stopped being massively overheated.
- ghaff 2y agoThe 2010s and early=on in the pandemic were extraordinary for (certain) jobs in tech. The meme of I can quit my job Friday and have a significantly higher-paying job by the end of the next week may not really have been the norm in tech, But it was certainly unheard of with professional jobs, inclusing in engineering, historically unless you were a celebrity of some sort in the field.
- jdietrich 2y agoThis article appears to be plagiarised from Business Insider: https://www.businessinsider.com/us-job-market-recession-outlook-workers-quitting-hiring-trends-2024-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/us-job-market-recession-outl...
- jawns 2y agoIt's not technically plagiarized, because it attributes many of the direct quotes to Business Insider. But it's an example of repackaging content produced by other sources, a practice sometimes called "churnalism." This type of appropriation of content has been happening for well over a century. See this Supreme Court case from 1918: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_News_Service_v._Associated_Press https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_News_Service_v._...
- tacticalturtle 2y agoNo, this is straight plagiarism. Those references to Business Insider were self references that the original BI article made: > A 24-year-old employee working in histology named Amanda, who spoke with Business Insider And > Raymond Lee, the CEO of the career outplacement firm Careerminds told BI. There is no rearranging of facts here - these phrases, and the rest of the article - are copy and pasted.
- dredmorbius 2y agoEmail the mods suggesting a link to the original source, and if you feel that the submitted site should be penalised or banned, why. At hn@ycombinator.com
- dang 2y agoThanks - we've updated the top link and banned the other site (https://boredbat.com/american-workers-are-stuck-in-place-because-everyone-is-too-afraid-of-a-recession-to-quit/#google_vignette https://boredbat.com/american-workers-are-stuck-in-place-bec...).
- jawns 2y agoIn 2020, COVID caused the most dramatic rise in unemployment the U.S. had ever seen. Employees who were lucky enough to avoid being laid off during the first few months of the pandemic largely hunkered down and resolved to stay with their current employer until the dust settled, even if they would otherwise have been looking to change jobs. This led to a phenomenon in 2021 and 2022 called the Great Resignation, a period where hiring began opening up again. All of those employees who'd been itching for an exit saw an opportunity to make their move. One of the interesting effects of this higher-than-normal employment migration in a relatively short period of time is tenure synchronization, where a large percentage of employees have been with the company for the same amount of time. Naturally, there will be some variation in when they decide to make their exits, but this synchrony does increase the chance of a mass exodus event once they've passed the year of average tenure. There are other macroeconomic phenomena that are contributing toward sustained "phase locking" of the amplitude of employment migration. Post-pandemic, we saw an era of high inflation, and that caused many companies to veer back into more cautious territory and question whether they'd over-resourced themselves during the hiring boom. This led to rounds of layoffs in 2022 and 2023. These conditions have also led to downward pressure on wages. Thus, many employees are waiting until the next hiring wave to make their move. These factors are likely to induce even more phase locking than the tenure synchonization alone, which means that we could see a second or even third "Great Resignation" event occur during the current decade as employees' synchronized tenures lead to voluntary exits that coincide.
- keyle 2y ago> In 2020, COVID caused the most dramatic rise in unemployment the U.S. had ever seen. I'm afraid this isn't accurate, unless your history of the U.S. is 10 years.
- Izkata 2y agoThis goes back to 1948 and they're correct for that time span: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE The lockdowns forced a lot of people into unemployment for a variety of reasons on top of the normal "it was a recession" ones.
- tmiku 2y agoNot related to the content of the article, but did anyone notice how those graphs become more saturated when you mouse over? It made me expect an interactive graph but it's just an artifacty jpg. Interesting little flourish.
- cryptica 2y agoSituation is quite ridiculous. People are working jobs they don't like and being low-performers on projects they have little control over while working on side projects that they like (for free) and not able to monetize their high performance on those projects. But no matter how good their side projects become, they cannot monetize them due to monopolizing forces. Earning money nowadays is all about having access to money which comes out of a safe money printer. Yes, I could be doing all this useful stuff which makes 100x better use of my skills than my day job but those things don't pay because I won't be able to find any users for it. I don't have much time for it. I could find users but not users who are hooked to a money printer and can afford to pay. I'm sure most users would love it if they spent 20 minutes trying my side project, however, this is too high of a barrier. The company I work for is already well hooked into a money printer and already has its own users but, unfortunately, I cannot produce my best engineering work there because there is too much legacy code and, understandably, my colleagues are as beaten down as I am over this industry so the will to innovate is severely limited. The best we can provide is stability. I've (unfortunately) learned to perceive software complexity as a friend; in the same way as security consultants perceive hackers, as pharma companies perceive chronic illness and as those who build mouse traps perceive mice. I already got burned badly for innovating at a previous company and experienced politics getting in the way in a mind-bendingly disturbing way so I'm not keen to experience that again! Repeatedly in my career, I have seen the low-performers and outright saboteurs being promoted and the innovators being suppressed so my goal now is to emulate those people and engage in political bs. It's the only way. I'm a little bit older, I have to think about my finances now. I know how money flows through the economy and I just go straight for the jugular straight out of a money printer... Printing leafy, digital monetary goodness straight into my bank account. Oh that feels nice.
- dgfitz 2y agoI too cared once about technical excellence, and was burned badly. Good code ships, even if it’s dogshit. Works for everyone else, fuck it.
- matrix87 2y agoI used to have the same cynical feeling until I realized that there's very little overlap between the things that are actually cool to work on vs the things that other people need done. And if you prioritize the former over the latter, you're essentially trading off easy money for more stress During the 9-5, the goal is to solve other people's problems. It's not pretty but it's what we're paid to do
- corbinbb 2y ago[dead]
- whack 2y agoI can empathize with the article. Earlier in my career, I would interview with any company that offered a significant pay increase. "Why would anyone turn down a 30% pay raise" was my mentality. Then I had a couple of jobs that didn't go well because of personality mismatches and politics. Which made me realize that even if I'm confident about my technical skills, that's no guarantee that I'll land on my feet at a new gig. Fast forward another few years, and the recession made me realize that I can't just snap my fingers and land a new better-paying job anytime I want. Combine both these factors, and I'm now ignoring recruiters who are begging me to interview for insanely well-paying openings. I have a decently well-paying job with good work-life balance, and colleagues who respect me. And I have no interest in throwing that away just to navigate a political minefield at a new job
- away271828 2y agoI do know various people who left a job with a former employer because they weren't happy and seemingly landed fine AFAIK. I mostly stuck things out for a bit because I was mostly retiring. Otherwise, I'd probably have done the same even if the end-result was retiring a bit early.
- whateveracct 2y agoyeah i don't love my job at all but it's...fine. they call it work for a reason. a few years ago, i'd bail. not an option today since i like money. gonna ride this gravy train a bit more. not gonna do it with a smile though.
- keyle 2y agoThis is a fair point. Earlier in my career I jumped ships so many times I had to move to another city to find 'new work'. It was a rather small city with companies buying off each others etc. I learnt throughout these episodes that people make companies, not some branding or marketing dep. My motto for the last 20 years has been "find good people, do good work". Emphasis on __good__, not great, best, immaculate, amazing, nonsense. But definitely good. My standards are pretty high though!
- brightball 2y ago“Don’t mess with happy.” - Brad Scott
- OptionOfT 2y agoAs someone who has been left of couple of months ago, I really feel this. There is very low movement in companies, and this makes it hard to find a new place. I hope to find something soon, but to be honest, unless people start hiring again in larger volumes, it's hard to get into the larger companies. They let go of a lot of people before, and rather hire those again then someone new. After all, those people are known quantities, I'm not. Shameless plug: contact me if you need a Senior Software Engineer. Rust, and a whole other bunch of languages.
- keyle 2y agoWhen people started to coin the term "silent quitting", it was a tell-tale sign of what was to come: a screwed up economy with positive unemployment rate. The measurements and metrics of the Keynesian economy need to evolve, they're about the same nonsense for the last 50 years. They have no consideration for the modern days, open economies, globalisation, remote work, isolation, depressive open offices and meaningless work. Meanwhile we're still looking at the same job figures as a primary indicator of doom and gloom. There is no measurement for innovation, happiness, self-worth or satisfaction; if they had one, it would show that it plummeted to never seen levels of despair. Job figures don't show how the economy relies on how much we can screw people over with things they can't get away from ("moats"), while being stuck in jobs they never wanted to do in their right minds ("career"). It all started with mortgages if you ask me. It never became about how much you could afford a house, but how much a third-party thought they could get out of you to afford a house - they inflated the prices of. The idea that we buy these extremely expensive "permit to live here", paying for the rest of your life is mental.
- theappsecguy 2y agoNot sure what silent quitting had to do with the unemployment rate increase? This is mostly a result of utter incompetence and irresponsible spending during the pandemic. Economy got pumped with cheap money and there was always going to be a day when the gravy ends. Doesn’t help that tech over hired and poured funding in just about anything. I’m calling it right now, AI will see the same crash within a few years.
- keyle 2y agoI wrote "positive unemployment rate". I meant that it's overall positive numbers even though it's complete doom and gloom on the market. see the 5Y chart https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/employment-rate https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/employment-rate
- meroes 2y agoQuiet quitting was a way to blame worsening economy on younger generations, or just to take a swipe at them, that's the extent of the relationship AFAICT. With you on the AI crash.
- outside1234 2y agoJust like the execs wanted…
- charlie0 2y agoI'm stuck in place because getting a new job is really hard, or so I hear.
- fzeroracer 2y agoIt's not just the prospects of finding a new job that sucks, it's also that no one can actually afford to start a business. The continual draining of wealth from the lower and middle classes has had a severe effect on the lower and middle class's ability to compete. The only way to actually start a business with some potential degree of success involves being a suck-up to massively wealthy individuals so you can onboard an angel investor for your product. This also generally means gimmicks that appeal to the rich and wealthy. A great example is smart kitchen appliance whose goal is to do something worse than what's already on the market so that they can corner people with dark patterns and subscriptions.
- windex 2y agoNot just that, I am tired of wanting to actually work than kowtowing to office rituals like drive to work in rush hour traffic to only then get on teams calls in the open. I am also hearing horror stories of new workplaces being completely obstinate about hierarchy and weird HR rule keeping. In short, many workplaces now have "ritualistic work" rather than actual tasks to complete. These aren't small names either. I am guessing that top level executives actually have no work other than aggregate from below and look busy. Looking busy needs minions.
- debacle 2y agoThe very first sentence is "...who are having an increasingly tough time landing a new gig as hiring slows and job boards run dry." So is the cause and effect backwards?
- randerson 2y agoThis is a great time for engineers who saved their money during the good times to get together and start a startup. The easy money will come back eventually, and you'll have an MVP to pitch to investors at worst, and a bootstrapped and profitable business at best.
- binary132 2y ago>the easy money will come back eventually or we see the end of the petrodollar as the global kingpin so maybe not
- jmyeet 2y agoThe 2010s was a boom time in tech. Total compensation ("TC"), particularly for engineers, went way up. Employers didn't like this. They're not above colluding either. They did it with the Steve Jobs anti-poaching deal too. Businesses made accomodations during the pandemic to stay open. Remote work really took off. Also, TC continued to rise. But then some companies failed and the door opened to what I called Permanent Layoff Culture. Most companies end up laying off 5% of their staff every year. This is really an extension of Corporate America's "up or out" culture. The likes of Jack Welch extolled the "virtues" of firing the bottom 5-10% every year. If you believe the companies, this is necessary. They over-hired. If so, there was a decade of "over-hiring". Why was it fine then? Market conditions changed such that with a wink and a nod companies could effectively collude on lyaoffs to suppress wages. The goal in cutting staff is to spread their work to the remaining employees (ie free labor) and to stop people getting raises (ie reduce labor costs). It's really no different to how one food company will raise their prices and every other one will follow suit. There's no direct collusion. That's price manipulation and it's illegal. It's price leadership. What's the difference? Price leadership is legal. There's just no agreement in a smoke-filled room. Workers afraid to quit? Mission accomplished. They won't be asking for raises.
- philip1209 2y agoI’ve heard from some friends at major tech companies that their stock grants are not being renewed as they vest. This is leaving them with sometimes >50% effective pay cuts. And, many are choosing to stay put because they don’t think they have other options.
- bravetraveler 2y agoOnly the scared ones, I left/found new. It worked out and I'm so burned out I rub people the wrong way.
- theknocker 2y ago[dead]
- kelvinwalter 2y ago[dead]
- blanchehomer8 2y ago[dead]