12 ms·
Can we stop the decline of monarch butterflies and other pollinators?
- swayvil 2y ago[flagged]
- Carrok 2y agoMy take away from the article, as with most articles which utilize a question as a title, is "No". At least not as long as we continue to allow the agriculture industry to blanket a not-insignificant portion of the earth with glyphosate.
- doctorpangloss 2y ago> At least not as long as we continue to allow the agriculture industry to blanket a not-insignificant portion of the earth with glyphosate. How is it possible that something so obvious and so catastrophic has been allowed to go on for decades? Why have so many well-meaning smart people been co-opted by Green Revolution stories?
- mulmen 2y ago> Why have so many well-meaning smart people been co-opted by Green Revolution stories? What does this mean?
- nerdponx 2y agoBecause the ugly truth is that you can't actually feed the world population any other way. Once your money is in the Ponzi scheme, the only way to get anything back is to ride it out and hope you're at the bottom of the pyramid.
- Carrok 2y ago> you can't actually feed the world population any other way Citation very much needed. This sounds like it was written by a member of the Monsanto PR team. There are.. other ways, than indiscriminately spraying plant poison everywhere.
- AlexandrB 2y agoYou can certainly farm in other ways, but it's a question of yield. High yield requires removing any competition to the plants you're cultivating - including milkweed. The fact that it's done with glyphosate is an implementation detail. If you want to produce the same amount of food with lower yield techniques you need more land - so more deforestation and destruction of natural habitats, which is hardly an improvement.
- Carrok 2y agoConsidering we waste almost a full 1/4th globally [0], and almost 40% here in the USA [1], do we need to produce the same amount of food? 0: https://www.wri.org/research/reducing-food-loss-and-waste https://www.wri.org/research/reducing-food-loss-and-waste 1: https://www.rts.com/resources/guides/food-waste-america/ https://www.rts.com/resources/guides/food-waste-america/
- bradley13 2y agoAdd to that stupid crops, like corn grown for ethanol or HFCS. Both could completely stop, and the world would be a better place.
- Mistletoe 2y agohttps://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2022/7/15/23218969/sri-lanka-organic-fertilizer-pesticide-agriculture-farming https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2022/7/15/23218969/sri-la... This is a very famous example.
- Carrok 2y agoIt's almost like there is more involved in a successful migration to a less synthetic approach to agriculture than simply stopping using fertilizers and pesticides.
- artursapek 2y agoSure you can. Glyphosate is used because food prices got stuck in a race to the bottom due to commoditization. Farmers deal with shrinking margins and rely on govt subsidies and poison in competition with each other to raise commoditized corn and other crops. The ultimate result is we have cheaper, less nutritious food and a devastated natural ecosystem.
- pfdietz 2y agoGlyphosate was demonized to create justification for trade barriers in agricultural products. The anti-GMO clamor is similar.
- artursapek 2y agoBless your heart
- pfdietz 2y agoPerhaps because it's not catastrophic?
- galangalalgol 2y agoI thought glyphosate killed plants, does it kill insects too?
- Carrok 2y ago> "As a result, farmers increased glyphosate use while reducing the use of other herbicides," Swinton noted. "This became particularly concerning for monarch butterflies since their host plants are strongly associated with row crops and their numbers began a sharp decline during the period of glyphosate adoption." It kills the plants where insects happen to live and breed.
- colechristensen 2y agoRoundup kills milkweed, a common weed in corn and soybean fields, also used in some other crops. Monarch caterpillars _exclusively_ feed on milkweed. This is not a case of glyphosphate toxicity, but habitat destruction because it does the job on the label well. And folks tend to apply it lots of places it doesn't necessarily need to be used. Heavily farmed areas need to have some more land set aside for biodiversity and better managed to that end. Additionally there are concerns about insecticides affecting monarchs in an entirely different thread, in particular increasingly banned neonicotinoid insecticides.
- throwup238 2y ago> And folks tend to apply it lots of places it doesn't necessarily need to be used. Glyphosate is the easiest way to keep a property clear of plants for fire insurance reasons in California, which is really unfortunate. My family had a big conflict with our neighbor over his use of roundup to clear his land because they were trying to grow a bunch of their own stuff.
- pfdietz 2y agoIf he got herbicide on their property a lawsuit would have been justified. If their concern was over slight contamination, not enough to noticeably affect plant growth, then not. It's not like it would have significant effect on human health in that situation, if it has any effect at all.
- dyauspitr 2y agoI don’t understand how people grew things without glyphosate. Getting rid of the weeds manually is extremely labor intensive. It’s many hundreds of hours of hired labor every week.
- marcosdumay 2y agoPeople didn't remove all the weeds before glyphosate. Nor did all the work manually.
- dyauspitr 2y agoWhat do you mean they didn’t do it manually?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 2y agoThere are several types of weed removal equipment one can plug on a tractor at the different stages of the life-cycle of the crops.
- bluGill 2y agothey used a culivator. Basically a hoe you pull behind the tractor. this of course burned a lot more fuel [read CO2]
- pfdietz 2y agoAnd chewed up the soil.
- stevenwoo 2y agoSmaller farms, smaller plots, greater variety in crops. There's a bit in episode eight of the documentary series Omnivore contrasting farmers in Mexico versus industrial farming in the USA, showing one of the remaining farmers in Mexico and how they do corn, talking about how a million Mexican farmers were put out of work because they could not compete with lower cost imported corn from the USA after NAFTA.
- ta_1138 2y agoIf I look at the crop that isn't useful for pollinators, and occupies the largest amount of land area in the US, the result is not corn which is sprayed with insecticides: It's lawns. The Kentucky bluegrass or fescue that is cut so short it never seeds? Might as well be concrete as far as insects are concerned. But we not only allow, but often mandate that acres upon acres of land are kept that way, or the owner gets a fine. American suburbs make more space ecologically dead per inhabitant than anything else we do: The greyest of cities at least take less space.
- keybored 2y agoThat’s hard to believe. Lawns take up such a small space. It had to until recently (robots) be mowed manually, at least for residental lawns. The American West is so devoid of lawns clusters (metro areas) that all of it except the West Coast should have excellent insect conditions, if lawns have such a large impact. This feels like explaining pollution by studying how many bottles are thrown into bodies of water in Orange County.
- jonstewart 2y agoThe article specifically cites a study from the past year that shows the major current factor in pollinator decline is not RoundUp, but insecticide use. I don't mean this as an apologia for RoundUp (or Monsanto). There's a need for more attention on, and regulation of, harmful pesticides, though.
- kyrofa 2y agoI've started keeping my own chemical-free bees. My hope is to build a healthy apiary of local bees that casts swarms, which will help replenish the wild bee population around me.
- mglz 2y agoIf you are new make sure to contact your local beekeeper club (if available) to learn about bee diseases. From parasites like varroa mites, to fungi, to viruses: They can get really sick and if you accidentally produce an unhealthy hive it can be bad for other hives nearby. Definitely go ahead, this is a great thing to do! Just positng this as a hint :)
- kyrofa 2y agoIdeally, colonies that are unable to keep mites etc. under control will simply die. I expect some losses before a strong colony emerges that I can split.
- cryptonector 2y agoThat's a good approach. But don't let your bees swarm. Split them instead. If you end up with too many hives, sell the excess hives.
- colechristensen 2y agoHoney bees aren't native to North America, "replenishing" isn't really the right idea, and if you do a bad job, especially "chemical free", you could be cultivating and spreading bee diseases. If you want to help native bees, plant lots of flowering plants with blooms that span the seasons.
- RoyalHenOil 2y agoPlease, please, please don't let your bees swarm unless you are 100% certain you have the support of local conservationists and professional beekeepers. Where I live, feral honeybees are an extremely damaging invasive species, causing huge declines in both native pollinators (by taking their food) and native birds (by taking their nest sites). Feral honeybees also threaten domestic honeybees by spreading diseases. Up until recently, we were 100% free of verroa mites, but now they are spreading through feral populations and will cause major population losses of domestic bees.
- ArcaneMoose 2y agoMy wife really loves Monarchs so we have planted a garden of milkweed and butterfly bushes. Monarchs will lay their eggs and then we make sure the caterpillars are doing well and have plenty of food. When they reach 5th instar and look for a place to turn into a chrysalis, we put them in a mesh enclosure to keep them safe and then release them once they emerge as butterflies! It's been such an exciting thing to do every year and the kids love helping out too. It's a fun, satisfying, and easy way to help out! Highly recommend :)
- Zeetah 2y agoThank you for doing this. I'd like to do the same. Any suggestions for getting started?
- bityard 2y agoNot who you replied to, but we do this with our kids. The only things are you need are a milkweed patch (there are many varieties besides the big ugly broad-leaf ones you see everywhere) and and a mesh enclosure off Amazon for a few bucks. The process is: You go out, look for the tiny eggs on the milkweed, bring the milkweed leaves in, wait for them to hatch, and bring in fresh milkweed leaves for food once a day. We put them in a paper-towel-lined baking pan so that they have something soft to crawl on if they wander off to taste-test new leaf. They start out rather tiny and grow to into big fat caterpillars. Eventually they stop eating to go on walkabout and anchor themselves somewhere near the top of the enclosure. (Sometimes they are dumb and you have to relocate them with pins or tape.) Once they emerge as butterflies, set them free. We do black swallowtails too. They like dill and parsely. We never get tired of it. We have had 20-something butterflies at a time in a 2-sqft enclosure.
- WheatMillington 2y agoDo you really need to go though all this trouble? We just plant a bunch of swan plants (milkweed) and watch the caterpillar and monarch populations go nuts. Add a bunch of flowers they like too (like zinnias) and that's about all I do.
- sixothree 2y agoI feel like we're just one collapse away from unrecoverable scenario. And we just don't know which extinction will be the one that ends it all.
- resource_waste 2y agoObligatory: Our calories don't come from pollinated crops. Hope that lowers your stress levels a bit.
- colechristensen 2y agoYes, this idea sells well. Folks have been selling that idea as long as we have records of folks doing anything at all. It is just not helpful to think like that and to address problems as if each one is an existential threat.
- andy81 2y agoUse of many natural resources jumped by orders of magnitude since the industrial revolution; comparing the current situation with historical records would give you a false sense of confidence. That's actually part of the problem with climate change.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- brainzap 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nritchie 2y agoAs a reformed bee-keeper, I've come to understand that it is the native pollinators that really matter. Monarchs and other native pollinators do most of the work. Except in exceptional (and artificial) situations (like almonds in Ca), domesticate bees mostly get in the way. However, I will add all the "helpful pest control contractors" who want to kill every insect on my property probably don't help.
- gerdesj 2y ago"As a reformed bee-keeper," I take it you mean honey bee keeper and I'll assume American (you) and European honey bees (ie non-native to US). There is nothing wrong with that, provided you also allow for solitary bees and other pollinators too. Note that even "foreign" pollinators are still useful for pollination. Do try to discourage "helpful pest control contractors". As a honey bee keeper, you can't be faulted. Yes you would deploy colonies of 50,000 insects at a time into an area where the locals are not that well organised. However, thanks to the likes of neonics and monocultures, any pollinators at all are welcome. I'm a 53 year old Brit and I live next to a park and have a very insect friendly garden. Butterflies are really down compared to my memories as a child. I do see quite a few social bees (eg bumble bees) and solitary bees (eg masonary bees) but again, they seem to be rather sparse compared to my memories. Also, a summer drive does not leave my car covered in bugs. I have a customer: https://butterfly-conservation.org/ https://butterfly-conservation.org/ ... you'll have a local equivalent. I think we should all try to follow their advice, otherwise we may be the last humans to remember something and the world goes a bit "Mad Max". That's a bit unlikely but it won't end well if we do nothing.
- RoyalHenOil 2y agoI can't speak for every location, but where I live, feral honeybees (escapes from beekeepers) out-compete many native pollinators. They also outcompete many native birds by taking their nesting sites (tree hollows, man-made bird houses, etc.). For example, in my region, there is exactly one species that can perform buzz pollination (a specific pollination technique that is required by certain plants, including tomatoes) — blue-banded bees — but they are in decline due in large part to wild honeybee colonies. I have worked very hard over the years to grow lots of plants specifically appealing to blue-banded bees, but I still very rarely ever see them. The flowers are overwhelmingly dominated by honeybees. I don't mind a few of them around, but there are WAY too many of them. They leave so little food for other pollinators and so few nest sites for native birds. Professional beekeepers prevent their colonies from swarming, and many of them — certainly all the ones I know of in my area — will also capture wild colonies (and kill the colonies they cannot capture) as a service to the public to help control this nuisance invasive species. But there is only so much that a few good beekeepers can do; they are massively outnumbered by feral bee colonies released by less responsible amateur beekeepers from years past.
- bloomingeek 2y agoMy wife called our city hall to see if we could let a small patch of grass grow tall in our backyard for insect support. They said a "pollinator garden" was highly encouraged, so we did. Last June we saw more lightening bugs then ever before. Now in hot August, just before sunset, we have butterflies and bees and lots of others bugs. We didn't plant any special flowers, we just let the grass and whatever else grow. Next year I'll plant some flowers.
- belinder 2y agoYou have to call city hall to get permission to grow grass in your own backyard? Is that a HOA thing or what's going on there that that's required?
- WheatMillington 2y agoYour comment is being downvoted, but I'm curious about this, too. Is this an American thing, that the government forces you to mow your BACK yard?
- foobarian 2y agoThese kinds of things are highly localized and I would not be surprised if there are municipalities that would have this kind of restriction.
- hettygreen 2y agoCanadian here, I let my entire back yard grow wild for 7 years. My neighbor was mad about it "because of ticks" and if the town found out about it, they would have come and mowed it and charged me for the "service" plus a fine.
- Thiez 2y agoWouldn't these hypothetical ticks only be a problem for him if he wants to walk through your barkyard? Never mind that ticks can and do live in short grass just fine...
- vouaobrasil 2y agoI wish we could stop the increase of humans.
- ggm 2y agoWe have. Demography stats show we're going to hit peak ahead of time, and enter a down trend. Worldwide trends are to less babies not more. Curves don't feel like they're slowing down and I do agree the peak is north of where we are, but there is a peak coming, and a decline the other side. Japan, China, Korea are all ahead of trend. Australia too but it's masked by immigration. Developing economies with high birthrates especially rural see huge declines with increases in local economy, opportunity.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoThe relevant peak would be the population at the consumption level of Americans/other developed countries. Probably one of those 80/20 relationships, where 20% of the population is consuming 80%, so if you reduce total population, but there is still plenty of population that can pick up the slack of consumption, then peak population won’t be the beginning or the downward trend.
- randomdata 2y agoWhile it is currently not in fashion to have children, fashion trends tend to not last forever. Why do we see the trend of today as being forevermore?
- Cloudef 2y agoWe did, unfortunately the foundation of our society and economy is built on the assumption that the age pyramid is not reverse. Expect hard times ahead.
- winslow 2y agoI've been planting milkweed for monarchs. We just had 4 hatch today! Another 11 in their chrysalis and 12 hungry little caterpillars. The biggest pest I've seen personally has been flies. Tanchid flies will lay their egg inside the caterpillar and the larve eats the caterpillars from the inside and they die. So we round up caterpillars we see on our outdoor plants and place them in a protected mesh enclosure with potted milkweed for them to eat. In 2021 I successfully raised 81 monarch caterpillars to full grown butterflies. In 22/23 we still had some success but I didn't have a garden so we raised 10-20 wild ones. But 2024 we have a house now and a big garden full of milkweed! Make sure to plant native milkweed in your area!
- cevn 2y agoI have a milkweed too. Last year it was kinda small since it was its 1st year but we had 5-6 monarch caterpillars, but gradually they disappeared 1 by one with no chrysalis I could find. This year none yet, I was hoping the migration hadn't started, because my milk weed is giant and ready to raise these lil things if they would just show up.
- winslow 2y agoThey can travel a far way to setup their chrysalis. Though I've also found that when they disappear they tend to be dead from tanchid flies or something else.
- asdasdsddd 2y agoAren't flies also pollinators
- winslow 2y agoYes, and tanchid are an important fly. However, they don't seem to have much issue in regards to population etc. I'm not exterminating nor killing the flies just protecting the caterpillars. I still lose many caterpillars to the flies. In 2021 when I got 80 successful caterpillars I still had a ton that died from the flies. I was approximately 40% success rate with my caterpillars growing into butterflies the rest 60% died mostly due to the fly. Thus far in 2024 I have 23 dead from flies. With my other 4 hatched, 11 chrysalis, 12 caterpillars that's 46% dead from flies (thus far) I suspect some of the 12 caterpillars are already gotten by the fly so roughly ~50% dead to the flies thus far.
- swayvil 2y agoDismantle the "rts for billionaires" that our society has become. 99% of our effort is wasted fighting each other (in "business" and otherwise). We don't need it. Maybe we could go totalitarian world government. Or put facebook in charge. I dunno. Somehow take away everybody's freedom to digest everything within reach. It would certainly reduce the incessant grinding effect that we have upon the world. Choke the volcano of pollution and ecosystem destruction. That would save many butterflies, and other of our co-earthlings too.
- bwood 2y agoOne of the biggest contributors to pollinator decline is loss of habitat for native bees. Most bees are actually solitary (don’t live in hives) and live in little crannies or holes in the ground. One of the coolest things I’ve come across recently is the idea of “bee homes” that you can put in your garden to provide habitat for bees. I’ve bought a couple beautiful wooden units from Scopa and we just got our first bee resident this week! https://scopabio.com/ https://scopabio.com/
- throwup238 2y agoIf you've got a lot of carpenter bees in your area, those bee homes are actually a good idea, otherwise they'll burrow into the wood of the house: https://imgur.com/a/cxQFNWG https://imgur.com/a/cxQFNWG
- Brideau 2y agoHey there, I actually make these homes! Unfortunately, carpenter bees don't have any interest in the model we have now as they like to make their own holes in softwoods. I'll be working with a professor that specializes in larger carpenter bees (Xylocopa) over the winter to build some habitats that are suitable for them, though, and plan to test them at her research site in the spring.
- thinkingemote 2y agoNote that each year you are supposed to clean out the homes.
- Brideau 2y agoWe design our blocks so that they are easy to clean. They are pre-split, but held together with UV resistant bands so that they are tightly sealed. The need to clean them mostly comes from the agricultural sector though, and isn't required for small habitats with only a handful of nesting sites. My partner is a wild bee researcher, and they've been using these in the field for about 60 years. As long as the density is low, the requirement for cleaning them is optional.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoIf you mow your grass and spray herbicides and pesticides and buy non organic food you contribute to their decline.
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoI see maybe 1-2 a year. I used to see them all the time when I was younger.
- user3939382 2y agoWasn’t there some guy in Mexico trying to do this and the mafia murdered him or something? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-51488262 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-51488262
- FDAiscooked 2y agoLocally? Yes. Globally? No.
- Tiktaalik 2y agoThe approach to the problem at this point seems to be relying on every day people to plant things in their backyard, which seems ultimately too minor to be impactful. I don't see a good future unless: 1) the Federal and various State governments buy up substantial lands all through this migratory corridor to preserve along this corridor as butterfly habitat. 2) Enact severe limitations on herbicides.
- scoofy 2y agoI have written about the role of urban green spaces, such as golf courses, as taking an active, and mandated role on this issue: https://golfcoursewiki.substack.com/p/golf-for-non-golfers-golf-courses https://golfcoursewiki.substack.com/p/golf-for-non-golfers-g... I love golf and hate that it's often a deeply problematic game, when, if we line the out-of-play areas with native flora, they have high enough area, and low enough humans per sq mile, that they can be effective wildlife habitats... if only the players would be satisfied with non-pristine conditions, by not using herbicides and pesticides. This is happening here and there with municipal courses in CA, but the culture of golf is still focused on surreal conditions and monostand grasses. It's an imperfect solution, but as spawl and farmland eat up more and more native areas, I honestly don't have much of an idea what else to do.
- pfdietz 2y agoI see two mutually reinforcing avenues that should be pursued. The first is creation of natural preserve areas. The second is control of invasives by introduction of biocontrol species from their native ranges (yes, there is concern of attack on other species, but there's often no other way than biocontrol to stop an invasive, and it takes time for local controls to evolve.) Invasive species are having a huge effect on natural ecosystems, to an extent I don't think some people understand. Beyond that, maximizing yield on farmland is important so more area is available to be set aside for nature.
- O5vYtytb 2y agoMy wife and I started a native plant nursery (for Southern Wisconsin) this year for exactly this reason! Save the pollinators!
- leptons 2y agoYou can plant all the milkweed you want, and it won't matter if we don't fix the climate first.
- bradley13 2y agoClimate us not the problem here. It is mass agriculture destroying the plants (milkweed) that monarchs depend on.
- leptons 2y agoYou're missing the point. With global warming out of control, the climate will be unsuitable for butterflies within a few years. You can plant as much milkweed as you want, but there simply won't be any butterflies left in the world to eat it very soon.
- MrVandemar 2y agoNo. As a species we are a pitlies, merciless, relentless machine. We poison the sea. We poison the land. We poison ourselves. We are geo-engineering our planet to a point way beyond our environmental tolerances. Because we need our phones. We need our cars. We need population to grow because otherwise nobody's making money, and we need arable land to feed that population. We will burn. You will all burn with us.
- chickenchase-rd 2y agoLet's all have another Orange Julius.
- ghostDancer 2y agoThink of all the profits and growth that would be lost if we take care of Earth. Think of the rich.
- ponector 2y agoYou are wrong. Rich will be rich and can easily pay x5 price for free range grass-fed eco friendly zero emission kosher halal no-gmo food. Who suffer are actually poor people. There is even a recent example: chemical fertilizers ban in Sri Lanka. It destroyed local farming and many poor people struggle a lot as the consequences.
- ghostDancer 2y agoI think I should have added the /s. I agree with you and that was the point as it mainly affects poor people the owners/rich people don't mind, in fact it's better for them as desperate people are easier to be abused as we can see all around the world. They tell us not take long showers while they keep the water for golf courses. Not to mention airplane traveling, etc ... In the end it will affect them but in the meantime all the rest are going to pay the bill.
- madaxe_again 2y agoIt isn’t even that complicated. Humans just like destroying things. I sit here, listening to a bulldozer demolishing woodland just outside the perimeter of our land in order to turn it into bare earth. Not to plant. Not to use. Just to clear, because that’s tidier, and there are wild animals in the forest. Such is man. Our road will wash away this winter because of what they’re doing today, and while they destroy, we plant. Like fighting the tide with a teaspoon. People tell me there are no bees here any more - the apiculturists who put their hives in their olive groves that they spray several times a year to deter hornets (not asiatic hornets, just boring, gentle, European hornets) are puzzled by their decline. Meanwhile, I throw hives into random spots in the forest, and they are all full of bees who chose them as home. Butterflies and moths abound - we have Europe’s largest moth, and the world’s smallest butterfly, and meadow fritillaries coat the riverbanks like a gently breathing carpet, scattering in clouds as you approach. All we do is we let nature be, work with existing systems, cut some dead brash here to make a path, scatter some seeds and saplings there to grow the patch of scrubby trees. Even the custodians of nature have completely lost their connection, as when one owns a tractor, one must use it. So on I go with the teaspoon.
- sequery 2y agoIt‘s interesting how the impact of roads and traffic on our insect population is always ignored in these discussions. Neither the article nor any of the top comments mentions it. I highly recommend the book „Traffication“ by Paul Donald about this subject. It explains how cars harm our wildlife, not just by road kill, but also through noise-, light-, air- and salt-polution. These influences cover far more area than just the road surface, for some species the negative effects extend to more than 2km on each side of the road. Moreover, for species that rarely cross roads, they also cut up the landscape in little pieces, reducing genetic diversity. And all this harm definitely and directly affects insects, not just mammals. The book cites numerous studies on the subject, and it also highlights how nature conversationists seem to mostly ignore this problem, focusing more on agriculture and other harms (exactly like the article). While these other problems certainly also negatively impact our wildlife, we do seem to have a collective blindspot for our roads.
- pandemic_region 2y agoCan we also stop the hordes of big brown slimey snails destroying pretty much everything in my garden. Any pointers greatly appreciated. I mean i love animals, insects, birds and whatnot but these snails are just way out of order.
- thinkingemote 2y ago1. Easy: Attract the things that eat the snails. 2. Harder: Go out at night, pick up the snails, walk 1 mile away, deposit snails. Snails will find their way back if they are relatively close to where you are so you have to go to an unfamiliar place
- pandemic_region 2y agoI've seen magpies eating them, but I dunno about attracting an army of those.
- yarg 2y agoOne thing that seems interesting to me is Paul Stamets' work around mushroom nectar. Now I have no bloody idea whether or not anything he's come up with has been independently validated (and I really should) but his claims (at least at the time) were that the nectar derived from a number of different mushrooms reduced viral load in bees by a staggering amount across a number of significant viruses. Including the deformed wing virus - which is exactly what it sounds like. The virus not only limits how efficiently and thus how far a bee can fly, it limits how long they can do it for. They live short and die young. This majorly constrains the hives in two very significant ways: A reduced grazing radius: a bee that can only go half as far only has access to one quarter the food supply. A bee that dies young needs to be replaced early, so the hive gets hungrier. Increased needs and reduced resources kills the hive.
- bradley13 2y agoThe biggest problems are monoculture agriculture (few places for milkweed to grow), and widespread use of insecticides (kill what few butterflies there are).
- Brett_Riverboat 2y agoI have seen one monarch butterfly this year, I remember when I was a kid I would reliably she flocks of them so thick you could spot them from a mile off. The massive drop in biodiversity is terrifying.
- thinkingtoilet 2y agoWe paved paradise and put up a parking lot. What do you expect to happen?
- Jemm 2y agoYes, reduce the human population.
- Moldoteck 2y agoI mean we can... We can eat less animal food and cut down the farming areas used to grow food for them, we can ask politicians to ditch zoning, parking minimums, enforce more taxes on fossil vehicles, build better public transport, better bike infra and plant more trees and other vegetation for insect corridors. We can at least stop investing in fossil energy and redirect those $ on solar/wind/hydro/nuclear/geo. We can increase the taxes for car ownership to reduce it. But ultimately the question is will we? I don't think so. Ppl like their current lifestyle, politicians do like money from fossil industries and are invested in those. So...
- Spivak 2y agoI think the route that doesn't require 300mil people coordinate to solve a problem against their individual interests, which like you say probably isn't going to happen, is purposely growing the plants pollinators need and artificially constructing homes for ground-nesting native bees, treating those things as crops, and paying large landowners to use their land for pollinator habitats. Our system doesn't know what to do with land that isn't directly economically productive but I bet a lot of farmers would choose a "farm" that requires almost no effort and money to maintain for like 40% of what they would have got growing corn.
- Moldoteck 2y agoin the end it boils down to political will. It could facilitate planting more stuff polinators do like with tax incentives, or could ditch zoning/park mins or invest more in pub transport/bike infra to reduce pollution, but again, will they? Pub transport can longterm be cheaper than facilitating car infra and it's costs (the more cars - the faster you need to repair the road and the more parking you need over time) so it's clearly not even costs are enough motivators for them to act...
- keybored 2y agoWhat do you know about what ppl like? The car-centric infrastructure wasn’t built because a thousand would-be-drivers (consumers) voted for it and it won’t be changed to something else because a thousand reluctant drivers vote against it. People can “ask” all they want but like you reference the politicians’ phone lines are probably busy with the people they actually work for. And politicians do like their money but it’s not fundamentally so frivolous. You can try to not get millions in funding from some industry or other but good look in the election when the other candidates invests hundreds of thousands in attack ads against you. Which you won’t be able to do even if you wanted to because you have no money. Politicians are greedy and corrupt but that’s because the system selects for that. Ultimately you can say that the ppl do not want change hard enough to dedicate hours a week to work for the issues that you so easily list in a comment and then dismiss as impossible because ppl apparently do not want it. But that’s not a revealed preference for the status quo. You cannot make that conclusion.
- pipeline_peak 2y agoAre they asking if we have the ability to, or is it in a stuck up way like “can you not”?.
- gwbas1c 2y agoWhen my mom was in her last week, she told my sister she'd come back as butterflies. (Of course, I don't believe in that.) At the time, there was a single sprig of milkweed near my mailbox. Since then, the milkweed has exploded. I can't bring myself to trim it back, because every time I look at the milkweed I think of my mother's statement. Of course, it's magical thinking on my part.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bmgxyz 2y agoMy mother said similar things before her death, and I accepted them with love while privately dismissing them. But since then I've softened a little. I still don't believe in those ideas in a literal, empirical sense, but they have emotional value for me anyway. I guess I'm trying to say that, at least for me, it's been more pleasant to entertain these ideas as comforting fantasy, and I don't think that small personal allowance has eroded my more practical abilities elsewhere. Not struggling so much against this kind of thinking has freed me in a certain way.
- phrotoma 2y agoAs a quite skeptical and secular person, I have been spending a fair bit of time and energy reflecting on what is precious / miraculous in recent years. An idea born in her now passed mind still reaches you across time and me across the internet, and is capable of touching both our hearts. That's not magical thinking, that's _magic_ <3.
- pfdietz 2y agoI see common milkweed and swamp milkweed all over the place around here (upstate NY). I have swamp milkweed in my garden (deliberately planted, it's attractive; I prefer native plants.) I have never seen a Monarch caterpillar around here in the five years I've lived here. I don't think host plant availability is the problem here. In an opposite situation: when I planted Pearly Everlasting the thing was eaten the ground by (non-Monarch) caterpillars. A bit too much of a good thing! It survived, thankfully.
- jonstewart 2y agoI have a summer home on 38 acres of hardwood forest and prairie in southwest Wisconsin. We keep it basically as a nature preserve for birds and butterflies. Last year was a drought but we had plenty of monarchs. This year's been extremely wet, and there are extremely few monarchs, consistent with the observation of the article. We've had plenty of swallowtails, fritillaries, and red admirals, though.
- cryptonector 2y agoI see a lot of local pollinators here. Because we're beekeeper as a hobby, I do worry about honey bees out-competing local pollinators, though I have not noticed any fewer local pollinators since we started. In fact, I rarely see our honey bees on our flowers -- they seem to prefer to go out foraging in the direction that we've pointed their hive entrances, which is towards another property. What I might do next Spring is start doing a weekly local pollinator census so that in the next couple of years we might notice if there is a noticeable change in their population.
- Log_out_ 2y agoYes, by transplanting biomes. Climate changes the world, but plants are slow when it comes to travelling to where the new home is. Sp food sources "vannish". But if you move a biome piece towards the new home that is climatewise its old, you stabilize that transition.
- pvaldes 2y agoThe answer is yes. Same as "Can we stop using lead on gasoline?". But the real question asked here (and in a lot of other cases) is if can be done --without the pain of allocating resources-- Translated: "Could people please do it for free (so the government don't need to move a finger?". Not always. People can design (and should design) more natural gardens. Just because is nice, save energy and will improve their lives. But gardeners can't stop chemicals to enter their gardens, specially if they live near a farm. Pesticides will not respect the borders of a garden or a natural park. Only the government can force people to use chemicals in a more sensible way. A "war for better control of chemicals that kill people" would save animals but most probably alleviate also a lot the obesity epidemic and save a lot of healthcare money. Several birds for one shoot. The problem is that politicians don't want to pass those laws. They know that they would be viciously attacked and called "socialists", "hippy fairies" or "against the American way". Unfortunately the benefits will not be visible until an lot of time on "politician's years" scale.