19 ms·
A Swiss town banned billboards. Zurich, Bern may soon follow
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://archive.today/zvgZO https://archive.today/zvgZO
- Animats 2y agoSão Paulo did this in 2006, and it worked out very well.
- G3rn0ti 2y agoWorked out very well in clearing the city of advertisements or in improving the quality of life of its people because they see less public advertisement? In Berlin the largest bill board provider (Wall GmbH) also builds public toilets. Thanks to them they are much more plentiful around parks. Forcing them to go out of business would take those with them.
- arrowsmith 2y agoSão Paulo is ridden with crime, poverty and homelessness, the traffic is atrocious, the air is terrible, the public transport is built for a city 10% the size and the infrastructure is stuck in the '70s. But I do enjoy the lack of billboards.
- nwatson 2y agoDidn't the city come close to running out of water? ... per ChatGPT: "The most notable crisis occurred between 2014 and 2016 when the Cantareira water system, one of the main sources of water for the metropolitan area, reached critically low levels." Running low on water in São Paulo would be a huge disaster.
- azlev 2y agoImprove quality of life by removing cognitive load from people. There is legislation to grant permission to place some ads in exchange of, say public toilets to use your example. But removed billboards from buildings or external area weren't taxed or had any positive result to society.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoCould Berlin not buy the public toilets from the billboard provider and pay to operate them? Why are we relying on an advertising business for public toilets? They’re…public?
- nanoxide 2y agoBecause they're expensive and Berlin doesn't have money. They were also coin operated and thus frequently broken into and out of service because of that. They mostly have contactless pay now, which has disadvantages as well because its less accessible (especially for children and senior people).
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThe capital of Germany with almost 3.85 million people (one of the EU’s most populous cities) and it cannot afford public toilets. Thanks for sharing ground truth, despite it being exceptionally depressing.
- mschuster91 2y agoBerlin has the disadvantage of historically being an enclave of Western Germany in the communist GDR, very hard/expensive to supply as a result and always at risk of the commies forcibly annexing it. No large (and thus: tax-paying) company wanted to set up its headquarters there for that reason, and additionally as it was an enclave there was no place for industry to set up production facilities. Nowadays, Berlin has a shit ton of "startups" HQ'd there, but they pay barely any taxes compared to production industry heavyweights.
- realityking 2y agoBerlin’s economy is unique for a major capital. Berlin is one of the weaker states economically in Germany. Mostly an effect of the division when most major industry left towards a place where the Soviet Army is not 5 minutes away and the city might be cut off from supplies at any moment. It’s been getting better but only recently the GDP per capita of Berlin rose above that of Germany overall. This was radically different before World War 2. In 1938 Berlin made up 10% of GDP (and Germany was bigger back then). Major companies like Lufthansa and Deutsche Bank were headquartered in Berlin. It was the center of the new Electrical industry being home of both Siemens and AEG.
- tdb7893 2y agoPlaces with billboard bans don't ban all ads, if the bathrooms aren't billboards they aren't banned. If the bathrooms are huge billboards next to parks then yeah, you'll have to find other bathrooms and that seems fine.
- seoulmetro 2y agoIn most first world countries, public toilets are a right not a privilege that people have to pay for. Europe is so backwards on their public toilet investments.
- shiroiushi 2y agoExactly: here in Japan, public toilets are all over the place: train stations, public parks, or frequently just random places in the city, on the street. And they're free, of course.
- autoexec 2y agoThe bathrooms in Japan are crazy to me. Depending on where you are the toilet might be the most luxurious experience your ass has ever had, or sometimes it's a literal hole in the ground and not even toilet paper is provided. I've never had a problem finding a toilet there when I needed one, but I kept kleenex in my back pocket because I never knew what to expect. I still prefer the holes in the ground to pay toilets.
- shiroiushi 2y agoYou have to go to really rural places to find the squat toilets these days, or maybe some poorly-maintained park. All new bathrooms these days have western-style toilets. One thing to watch out for, however, is that many bathrooms have no way to dry your hands, even in very nice bathrooms in fancy buildings, so you should bring a small towel with you. Some bathrooms don't even have soap, though this is pretty rare in my experience, but a lack of drying towels or hand dryers is somewhat common.
- amluto 2y agoThere also seem to be no public trash cans. How do people dispose of the utterly absurd amount of disposable packaging that everything comes with?
- 2y ago
- pedrogpimenta 2y agoahahah that's beautiful. So it's all good because they built public toilets? Like when big companies have programs for the disabled, that makes it all good all of a sudden, we forget all about the other stuff? Damn...
- G3rn0ti 2y agoYou are laughing. But the city of Berlin was not able to provide this service. Spending a day in the park or on the playground with kids and needing a rest room meant either hiding in a bush, going home early or to the next restaurant where you had to pay a fee, usually (bc they provided a rest room to hundreds of people daily). I see this public private partnership a win-win.
- account42 2y agoYet many other cities are able to provide free public toilets, including ones much much poorer than Berlin. Perhaps it's not really a matter of Berlin not being able to do it themselves.
- pedrogpimenta 2y ago> the city of Berlin was not able to > the city of Berlin was not willing to Fixed that for you.
- account42 2y agoAnd I'm sure the mega rich also donate a lot (in absolute terms). That doesn't mean the current levels of wealth inequality are good for society. The term for this is whitewashing bad behavior with good deeds.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoAllow ads on/in only the toilets themselves. Problem solved.
- gglnx 2y agoNo, ads and toilets are separate in Berlin since 2019 [1]. Wall won the contract for the new Toilettenvertrag [2] by the city. The city says now what and where to build. Before that, toilets were only built where it was profitable for a billboard. Now the city can make the toilets even free [3] and the toilets are ad-free. [1] https://taz.de/Toilettenvertrag-sorgt-fuer-Wirbel/!5431891/ https://taz.de/Toilettenvertrag-sorgt-fuer-Wirbel/!5431891/ [2] https://www.berlin.de/rbmskzl/aktuelles/pressemitteilungen/2022/pressemitteilung.1223271.php https://www.berlin.de/rbmskzl/aktuelles/pressemitteilungen/2... [3] https://www.rbb24.de/panorama/beitrag/2024/07/107-oeffentliche-toiletten-berlin-kostenfrei.html https://www.rbb24.de/panorama/beitrag/2024/07/107-oeffentlic...
- G3rn0ti 2y agoWell, however, it’s still the Wall GmbH building public toilets. So what’s your point?
- pqdbr 2y agoI think São Paulo is the largest megacity in the world that has deployed a ban like this. Amazing decision. Nobody misses them.
- methuselah_in 2y agobut is it worth? These companies now go to online and push more in ai thereby increasing the carbon footprint.
- PlunderBunny 2y agoI can run an ad blocker online - I can’t do that walking down the street.
- szundi 2y agoFollowing the parent commenter logic, extra resources are going to go into ad-blocker-blockers then
- grues-dinner 2y agoNot with the attitude! An ad-scrubbing AR filter is certainly thinkable, though probably not actually practical as long as strapping goggles to your face in public is considered the preserve of terminal dorks. However, if it did happen, the arms race to prevent ad evasion in real life would be interesting. Glass Earth, Inc. by Stephen Baxter is a good short read along the extension of those lines (though the image of a multibillion satellite communications monopoly using a vast fleet of, uh, 67 geosynchronous satellites hasn't dated well!)
- perihelions 2y agoIronically there's an AI filter that's classified you as an ad, and is erasing you from our field of vision as we speak. HN's spam filter is... not a frontier AI, to put it politely. You can email the mods to get your new account whitelisted!
- matsemann 2y agoOne cool thing I noticed about my polarized sunglasses is that they block most screens at public places. No ClearChannel ads for me while waiting for public transport!
- awestroke 2y ago
- user3939382 2y agoI watched a baseball game for the first time in a while and there was a logo on the pitcher’s mound. I’m beyond sick of incessant ads.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- awestroke 2y agoBut won't somebody think of the shareholders????
- lifestyleguru 2y agoYou wish, the dividends are miserable. Executive boards, rather.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoHow much I hate these standalone ad displays and billboard size ad displays.
- bravura 2y agoPeople are taking the piss out of you everyday. They butt into your life, take a cheap shot at you and then disappear. They leer at you from tall buildings and make you feel small. They make flippant comments from buses that imply you’re not sexy enough and that all the fun is happening somewhere else. They are on TV making your girlfriend feel inadequate. They have access to the most sophisticated technology the world has ever seen and they bully you with it. They are The Advertisers and they are laughing at you. You, however, are forbidden to touch them. Trademarks, intellectual property rights and copyright law mean advertisers can say what they like wherever they like with total impunity. Fuck that. Any advert in a public space that gives you no choice whether you see it or not is yours. It’s yours to take, re-arrange and re-use. You can do whatever you like with it. Asking for permission is like asking to keep a rock someone just threw at your head. You owe the companies nothing. Less than nothing, you especially don’t owe them any courtesy. They owe you. They have re-arranged the world to put themselves in front of you. They never asked for your permission, don’t even start asking for theirs. – Banksy
- lifestyleguru 2y agoWhen you touch these ads, this will be vandalism and marketing company will dispatch security company on you. Everyone in the ad food chain feels very entitled to litter public space and to violate your attention.
- RCitronsBroker 2y agonot getting caught is the secret sauce here, just ask banksy lol
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Towaway69 2y agoReminds me of the old adage „it’s only illegal if you get caught“. That’s also applies to corporate corruption and politics.
- jfoster 2y agoBillboards tend to be used by larger companies. I wonder what they do with the newly freed up ad budget. I'm guessing it goes to online ads rather than a reduced ad spend.
- JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B 2y agoThey could contribute to society and humanity in general, and find something useful to do. That’s what we all have to do. Society should ask itself why they are exempt from such a duty.
- bruce511 2y agoThey do contribute to society, and they do useful things. This is evidenced by the fact they are still in business and their customers still give them money. Now granted they may not benefit -you- directly, they may even make -your- life worse, but -society- as a whole keeps them around. Personally I'm not a smoker, so cigarette companies (to me) are a net loss. On the other hand enough people see them as a gain so I bow to societies vote.
- Two4 2y agoBy your logic, heroin dealers benefit society too.
- exe34 2y agoas long as it is counted in the gdp (not the gdp per capita, it's only the people who care about that sort of silly thing)
- kachapopopow 2y agoif you ask some people, the answer is yes.
- kachapopopow 2y ago(The people that want to legalize drugs and drug distribution)
- slipheen 2y agoThe American state of Vermont has banned billboards since 1968. It makes spending time in the state extraordinarily pleasant.
- cchi_co 2y ago[dead]
- tdb7893 2y agoHawaii also has a billboard ban. It was really jarring moving back to Illinois after getting used to not having them. It seems pretty clear that the negative impact of billboards far outweigh the benefits so I'm always hoping more places outlaw them.
- bruce511 2y agoYes travelling can really create a sense of what you have, or lack. Where I live there are very few billboards. I rarely see them. When I travel (especially to the US) it's very jarring. They are very visually polluting.
- hollerith 2y agoThere is a ban on billboards in Marin County (on the other side of the Golden Gate Bridge from San Francisco). Legally speaking, billboards are only banned within 500 yards or some other distance from the highway with the most traffic (where billboards would be most valuable, namely, US 101) but actually there are no billboards anywhere in the county and this has been the case since the 1960s (according to an old newspaper article). My guess is that the community has some way to exert "informal" (not based on formal governmental processes) pressure on landlords. Real estate prices are very high here in part because it is a very attractive landscape with plenty of hills and greenery and bodies of water, so maybe most landlords perceive that billboards have the potential to depress prices and keep the occasional landlord who contemplates erecting billboards in line somehow. Also as an exception to the general rule, bus shelters (structures owned and maintained by the city or the county to keep the rain and the sun off people waiting for a bus) near US 101 have ads on them (4' by 6' or so) and the buses themselves do, too, or at least they used to--it's been a few years since I noticed.
- malthaus 2y agoit is very likely that this ban might be prevented by lobbying, as one of the main providers (even visible on the picture in the article) is, let's say "well connected" to our legislative
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- OldGuyInTheClub 2y agoMeanwhile, Los Angeles has raised them to massive and blinding levels. Visual goose-stepping.
- eesmith 2y ago1950 SF predicted this advertising for the future, at https://archive.org/details/FirstLensman/page/n47/mode/2up?q=cough https://archive.org/details/FirstLensman/page/n47/mode/2up?q... : > He wormed his way over to the left-hand, high-speed lane and opened up. At the edge of the skyscraper district, where Wright Skyway angles sharply downward to ground level, Samms' attention was caught and held by something off to his right—a blue-white, whistling something that hurtled upward into the air. As it ascended it slowed down: its monotone shriek became lower and lower in pitch; its light went down through the spectrum toward the red. Finally it exploded, with an earth-shaking crash; but the lightning-like flash of the detonation, instead of vanishing almost instantaneously, settled itself upon a low-hanging artificial cloud and became a picture and four words—two bearded faces and "SMITH BROS. COUGH DROPS"! > "Well, I'll be damned!" Samms spoke aloud, chagrined at having been compelled to listen to and to look at an advertisement. "I thought I had seen everything, but that is really new!"
- aspyct 2y agoYes please, more of that!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thefaux 2y agoWould love to see this in SF. It's especially bad on 101.
- lemoncucumber 2y agoI agree, but it's also pretty funny how so many of them have this tiny techie audience and 99% of the people driving past will just be like "wtf is that about, what are all those acronyms?"
- autoexec 2y agoCompanies are still waiting for augmented reality to become a thing so that they can correct this problem and place ads on every available surface within your field of view no matter where you are.
- b112 2y agoThat would require brain implants or implanted lenses or some such, and no one would ever leave that platform open enough to be constantly tracked, and constantly barraged by it. Who would do that to themselves?! And really, for it to be all encompassing, you'd need everyone to have to use such systems, such as forcing everyone to have such devices to log in to services, or even order food, or pay for things, and no one would force people to have a device to even pay for things, or eat.. I.. um, oh right, smartphones. (I firmly suspect that within 25 years not only will brain implants -> visual cortex happen, but that if you don't have one you won't be able to work effectively, you won't be able to identify yourself effectively, and you probably won't even be able to pay for things) mcmcmc: Nowhere did the GP state that AR would be inescapable. Yes, I know. I stated it. See above? My whole point revolves around the fact that I believe, just as with smartphones, that people will be severely hampered without said tech. That it will effectively be a requirement to have such tech. Statements such as "But you can just...", fail to realise just how much is dependent upon it. In many respects there are NO workarounds without a smartphone, there are jobs that require you to own one, there are tasks/things you do in life that absolutely require it, and if you don't have one? Often you cannot find a work around, or the work around is literally a monumental task, thus people simply capitulate. This is what brain implants and AR will be like in 25+ years.
- mcmcmc 2y agoNowhere did the GP state that AR would be inescapable, just that ads would be inescapable in AR. I’d imagine high tech contact lenses would be a preferable approach to a seamless interface for most people who aren’t born with this stuff already at mass adoption.
- account42 2y ago> Who would do that to themselves?! Enough people that it eventually becomes unavoidable for the rest. See: all the other horrors of modern civilization that you cannot avoid without becoming a hermit.
- miklosz 2y agoThe city of Cracow in Poland banned billboards (and other visual advertising quite aggressively) about 2 years ago. Great outcomes. There are still some workarounds that companies do to put this s..t out in the public (e.g. covers of renovation works can contain up to 50% of advertising area, so we have renovations of just finished buildings only to put the covers with ads). Now, when I visit another city when there's no such ban I cannot stand this visual garbage. This should be banned everywhere.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoHopefully you like looking at the face of Lewandowski because it's all over the place.
- ptsneves 2y agoA true classic. It looked extra cheesy when he advertised for Huawei. The man is a sellout and it has a kind of charm, because he knows his place: He is a just football player on the verge of retirement and he wants to squeeze the juice for the last drop.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoI remember his silhouette of size of entire building printed on scaffolding covering entire facade of a multi-storey building and advertising Huawei. Now Iga Świątek is slowly taking over, recently she popped out in payment terminal when I was trying to touch in the debit card. Get the fuck off, greedy girl. Please don't force me to watch you bloody face.
- badpun 2y agoIf it's not her, it will be somebody else. The system is the problem, not specific people.
- 1992spacemovie 2y agoLol that’s the last name of one of my Polish coworkers. Super common name I imagine.
- whiplash451 2y agoI don’t know if this includes subways but that would be welcome. Subway corridors full of billboards are an absolute brain drain.
- account42 2y agoExactly I already pay for my fare and the government is already heavily subsidizing the transport company using my taxes but somehow I still need to pay with my attention? Fuck that.
- adalacelove 2y agoI have always wondered how a world without marketing would look. I think marketing has a net negative effect. I also think that maybe you cannot eliminate all marketing but you can easily eliminate most of it just by controlling the spending of big companies, so it's possible. I have no ethical problems with eliminating it, as I consider it a form of manipulation and falsehood spreading, and anyway I don't consider companies have a right to free speech, or any real rights for that matter.
- m463 2y agoI kind of wonder how far you want to go with these sorts of things. Would controlling things like this bleed into adjacent social controls, like how HOAs will prevent any house from looking too different? Or possibly take on other dimensions, like sponsored in-real-life product placement and word-of-mouth?
- pedrogpimenta 2y agoAs far as it makes sense and has a positive effect, don't be a pain.
- dwaltrip 2y agoI don’t think this is a real concern. Regular people living their lives like to make arbitrary changes to their houses, which is why HOA rules are contentious. Regular people aren’t paid to advertise as they go about their day. It’s not very comparable. And I’ve never heard anyone suggest that word of mouth recommendations should be banned... That’s kind of an insane idea that isn’t even remotely possible.
- 6510 2y ago> I have always wondered how a world without marketing would look. We would all be standing there at the entrance of the supermarket exchanging awkward looks not knowing what to do until an old lady shows up and we grab a cart because she did. Then we follow her around the store pretending not to be looking, buying the same products. When everyone has paid and the old lady is long gone we have conversations about what to do with the things we've just purchased.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rustcleaner 2y agoCan we please ban advertising from society and into convenient little directory books where everything is categorized? If I want something, only *then* I [still most likely won't] want to see ads. Why am I acting so entitled about it? I just am, and frankly you should be too! :^)
- amatecha 2y ago"We didn’t recognize any public interest in having billboards" Seems about right - hopefully the same rationale can be employed in more and more cities.
- account42 2y agoAnd for different topics too. Corporations need to understand that the only reason they are permitted to exist is to benefit the public. If they are a net negative there is no reason we cannot or should not get rid of them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- riffraff 2y agoI don't like billboards much, so I'm fine with dropping them. Although this ban still allows sport advertisement, looks like sport brands will just start advertising every single match and gain exposition on the cheap. And of course we all can prefer "cultural" advertisement to soft drinks, but If the intent is to reduce visual pollution, why does the content of the advertisement matter?
- hnlmorg 2y agoYou’re assuming that every single billboard switches to sports advertising. Which might not happen.
- wiradikusuma 2y agoOn the way from office to home, there's a junction with a HUGE LCD display. At night, the screen is so bright it's very annoying. It's like being in a dark room and putting your laptop display to max. In front of everyone stopping at the red light. Not sure who's the genius behind it, but I think the ad has opposite effect of people hating the product advertised there.
- Narhem 2y agoAh yes the worm is being spread.
- secretsatan 2y agoI'm all for this, I'm in a city not so far away, and there's so many nice areas with tree lined roads, parks, beautiful buildings and then suddenly a giant ugly billboard. I have noticed they are frequently vandalised, adverts are regularly torn off, and particularly large and ugly one has been removed down the road
- nyc111 2y agoThis is great. I wish something similar could happen where I live but civic consciousness is very low around here
- SSchick 2y agoTangential: I live in a rather rich suburb in the US, there are barely ANY billboards, drive ~10-15 miles away from the city everything is littered with billboards. Most of them advertise what I can only summarize as "probably spam". Tt is an interesting corralation and I would hope the state would just ban them.
- 98cnwpisufdh 2y agoSomething I like to do, to keep my personal space a tiny bit more ad-free: when on a flight, bus-ride or similar, where you have ads placed right in front of your eyes (mounted on the back of the seat in front of you), it's usually possible to slide the cardboard with the printed ad out, sideways, simply flip it and put it back. Enjoy a nice, calming, white rectangle for the rest of your trip.
- timbit42 2y agoI do this with ad plastered place mats in restaurants. So far none have put ads on both sides.
- GJim 2y ago> ad plastered place mats in restaurants Good lord! Where on earth do you live where this dystopia is commonplace? One goes to a restaurant to relax. I'd be puzzled to say the least if the restaurant owners sought fit to try and sell me crap during a meal.
- Lutger 2y agoGrenoble also banned all ads in 2014 and put in a lot of trees. It is truly an audacious move, yet completely rational. My dream is to also ban parking of cars in neighborhoods and most car traffic, cars can be parked along the edges in solar covered parking spaces. Add car sharing, better public transportation, urban agriculture, community gardens and parks: soon you'll have an efficient paradise of a city. Unfortunately mayors of cities in the Netherlands do not have sufficient power to change rules like these, its the state which makes these rules. This is why we won't see such a thing in my country. There are progressive cities where it could fly, but overall the Netherlands has become extremely conservative.
- systemtest 2y agoThe majority of people in The Netherlands drive their car to get to work. They don't want to have to walk 10 minutes to an edge parking or city hub. If we want to lower cars in neighbourhoods, or want people to get rid of cars, our public transit system needs to be come a lot better first. If public transit was a good option to get to work for people, more people would use it. For me going to work is either a 20 minute car ride, with parking right in front of my house and right in front of work. Or it is a 10 minute walk, 45 minute bus ride where I likely have to stand and then another 5 minute walk. And I can't work past 20:00 because that's my last bus. Make it so public transit is less than 20 minutes, goes 24/7 and picks me up within 5 minutes walking of my home and I will use it. And no I don't even live in a village. Population of 140.000 people and I work in a city of 300.000.
- bgnn 2y agobusses are so bad here to be honest. a lot of metropolitan cities solved this problem by having frequent and efficient bus lines connecting to major train/tram/metro lines. Randstad is one big metropolis without a coherent public transportation planning. I moved here from Istanbul 12 years ago. the progress there was positive in this timeframe while in Randstad it was backwards to be honest. public transportation became more expensive and unreliable. busses are often empty and they seem to compensate this by increasing prices and cutting down the frequency, so it becomes less reliable for people to use it.. my commute to work is 15 km. it's 20 min by car without traffic but post-Covid traffic is so bad that it's 50 mins in average (1 hour+ on Tuesdays). bus is 30 mins with 1 connection but often I miss the connection and wait 15 mins, so it's 45 realistically. both are bad options, so I cycle instead in half an hour with my e-bike. if it's bad weather I take the car because busses are not on time so I can't plan being at the office for a meeting or so. plus, bus is much more expensive than my not so fuel efficient old car. go figure.
- 7e 2y agoAdvertising is business owners paying to take a dump in your brain. Google, Meta et all are no better than billboards.
- whatever1 2y agoWithout billboards,How will they know that Jesus loves them?
- ktosobcy 2y agoReading comments it's amusing to see people, seems like, brainwashed into not being able to function without ads... Well, for once - maybe making more informed decission when buying stuff (starting with "do I even need that" instead of emotional impulse buying becasue hot chick/guy told them to)
- account42 2y agoMore often than not those making such comments are themselves involved in the ad industry or have been in the past. It's just another example of men being able to comprehend something being bad when their salary depends on it.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoWhere do you draw the like between information of a product and advertising? technical data sheets, pictures of a product, or talking to potential customers are potentially advertising. Can you show your product in a trade magazine? Can you list your business in a phone book?
- ktosobcy 2y ago> Where do you draw the like between information of a product and advertising? I guess anything that's invides my brain without my consent (so all billboards, bus-stop LEDs, etc) is annoying ads. Now, if you see a product ad in a magazine related to the filed that makes more sense (and I'd love to go back to the internet where ads were based on page context and not user tracking data btw)
- s1artibartfast 2y ago>I guess anything that's invides my brain without my consent (so all billboards, bus-stop LEDs, etc) is annoying ads. Consent is interesting framing due to it's interactions with public commons and shared spaces. Does one give consent by entering the common space? How much consent does one give by entering the common space? My opinion is that public spaces can have rules, and you consent to anything that falls within those rules by entering them. For example, Everyone is consenting to billboard because they choose to drive on the highway instead of staying home. The way to withdraw consent is to change the rules, and can not be done unilaterally. I think this framework can also explain the difference between a magazine, which is essentially a private space. You consent to the rules of the magazine when you choose to open and read it. I think it would be pretty bogus if I published S1artibartfasts newsletter to my subscribers, and some third party thought they had the right to ban me placing ads because they didnt consent. The internet is an interesting mixture of these different spaces. Google serach results make sense as a private space, so they can show as many ads as they want. nobody is forced to go to google.com. A webpage is clearly private, but is the world wide web a public or private commons? that I am less sure about.
- benknight87 2y agoThe EU's love of banning things is lazy policy-making. It's better to disincentivize and let markets take care of it. That way you preserve freedom while also encouraging desirable outcomes. Further reading: "Nudge" by Richard Thaler.
- frankjr 2y agoI agree with the laziness but Switzerland is not in the EU so not really relevant.
- Ylpertnodi 2y agoPoster above you (in my hnreader) points out Seattle is pretty ad free, so maybe its not just a Swiss (noted as 'not in EU') thing. If 'lazy policy-making' improves quality of life, why would you be so against it? Especially in Switzerland, where voting isn't so much about screaming headlines, but more about maintaining/ improving said qol.
- secretsatan 2y agoNot EU, and a direct democracy
- panick21_ 2y agoSwitzerland isn't in the EU. And no, banning things isn't 'lazy', its 'committed'. Markets are often the right solution, but in many case its not about manipulating marginal prices, its about making a clear statement. Our towns will be better, our collective living standard will go up without ads. There is not clear way how we can get a market to arbitrate this. > "Nudge" by Richard Thaler. That book is way, way over-rated and also just completely wrong and informed at times. Even the best example of 'Nudge' about opt-out organ donor barley hold up in the real world. This podcast about the book is pretty good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjArvN9cfgE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjArvN9cfgE There is a Part 2 that goes into 'Nudge' being used by governments around the world. You can find the show-notes with lots of sources they used here: https://old.reddit.com/r/IfBooksCouldKill/comments/137g83j/if_books_could_kill_episode_nudge_part_1_a_simple/ https://old.reddit.com/r/IfBooksCouldKill/comments/137g83j/i...
- 2y ago
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThere are no billboards in most of Seattle and it is great. There are also very few buildings with signage on them. It gives the place a very different, calming, and aesthetically pleasing vibe compared to cities like SF or LA.
- avidphantasm 2y agoVermont is way ahead on this one. It’s one of the things that makes Vermont feel so different from the rest of the US.
- AlexDragusin 2y ago* Manila has entered the chat https://x.com/moonlight2129/status/1624712320059600897/photo/4 https://x.com/moonlight2129/status/1624712320059600897/photo...
- pietervdvn 2y agoFor those living in placed with advertisements: I've made a website based on/contributing to OpenStreetMap where one can add advertising items, such as billboards: https://mapcomplete.org/advertising https://mapcomplete.org/advertising A few anti-pub groups are using it to map the issue and to lobby against it with data in hand.
- account42 2y agoNeat but it groups points too agressively. Is there any way to still see the individual icons while zoomed out a bit more to see e.g. whole cities?
- dailykoder 2y ago>Markus Ehrle, the industry association’s president, said that money would instead “flow to big internet companies like Google or Meta,” When I saw the headline, I thought 'oh, what a nice idea', but the quote above might have a point and I am not entirely sure how right it is. But I guess there is probably some truth to it. I hate digital, and especially animated, billboards very very much. It's super annoying and just plain distracting. Maybe just analog billboards might be a good way. So local businesses get a way to advertise themselves. Maybe it has to get some regulation so that big companies won't buy all the ad space? I am not sure.
- yreg 2y agoDisabling ads on the web is trivial while disabling ads outdoor is currently impossible.
- tcfhgj 2y agothey can advertise themselves, just not in public
- jajko 2y agoIt steals drivers attention where focus should be 100% on whats happening on the road and around it. Every % of attention stolen is a big win for advertisement, and increases chances of bad accident. Do a bit of statistics on number of drives per day globally, number of accidents, increase that chance even by 1% (which is very debatable but in many cases its much more), and you get nice number of number of deaths and damages done daily by ad business around the roads.
- culebron21 2y agoSão Paulo city banned them around 2008. The entire Brazil followed within a decade.
- mft_ 2y agoThis is Swiss direct democracy in action. Bravo. (They have a very interesting system, for anyone interested in learning about how politics may be done differently. And it's supported by [or generates?] a culture of significant political engagement within the populace.)
- cchi_co 2y ago[dead]
- Eumenes 2y agoMaine and Vermont did this years ago. Its very nice. Meanwhile, driving through other urban areas in the US, the # of billboards make it seem like a hellscape. At least personal injury and bail bonds industry is doing well!
- sandworm101 2y agoFyi, drive through many parts of Canada and billboards often mark political boundries. They are generally banned, except on tribal land where the native community largely governs its own land use. https://www.bcbusiness.ca/industries/general/board-politics/ https://www.bcbusiness.ca/industries/general/board-politics/
- jonathanlydall 2y agoI live in the greater Johannesburg area of South Africa, the area I'm in is probably amongst the very highest economic contributors of the country, and while sitting still in traffic there is no where one can look without some advert being in view, it's dystopian and depressing. Even worse though, there is this amazingly fancy huge electronic billboard and then all around it (like most streets here) everything is, if not messy from litter, just generally scruffy, unkept plants / grass, weeds growing on the verge of the road, streets not swept, etc. Technically, the depressing mess is the fault of the local government which is generally incompetent, but considering that they already charge these billboard companies for the rights to show these adverts there, they could just make another part of the deal for the rights is that the billboard companies are obligated to ensure that part of the road is kept neat. It wouldn't be the primary reason for the brain drain here, but definitely just one more reason that people give up on the country. (The reasons why skilled middle-class people are fleeing include: Crime, corruption, constant load shedding (it's been better as of late, but it remains to be seen if it's gone for good), we pay a significant amount of income tax, and then also 15% VAT on practically everything (on top of the import fees for most things). Despite the amount of taxes the middle class pays, government education, healthcare and policing are not to be relied on, so we also need to pay for private versions of those too. The bottom line is we get terrible value for money for the taxes we pay. I consider my taxes to be largely charity to the majority of the population which is in poverty and don't pay taxes, so I do feel absolutely aggrieved with the apathy, incompetence or corruption of our government which results in very little of that money being used where it should be.)
- anonylizard 2y agoEhhhh.... Why can't the government keep the road neat? Isn't that the government's job? The problem with including a stipulation in the contract, for the private company to keep it neat, is its hard to objectively monitor (Unlike say the money paid for advertising), which will therefore 100% become a way to extort the private companies. The optimal solution will just be 'pay off the government inspectors & spend as little on actually keeping it neat as possible'. People need to understand a government policies is like a software program, its not trivial to just 'add a feature'. An extremely corrupt government, is like hardware that flips bits randomly all the time, so please don't make it do even more things.
- ano-ther 2y agoI’d like that. In some cities (at least in France and Germany), the advertising companies have a deal: they build and maintain bus stops, public toilets and rubbish bins — in return, they get an exclusive right for advertising in these spaces. In these cases, there will be a cost associated to turning off billboards.
- TiredGuy 2y agoWhen traveling to other countries, and sometimes even just to other major cities, I always enjoyed seeing the different billboards. Often they would be for local businesses that I wouldn't otherwise know about, and they also convey some of the local culture. I enjoy seeing the creative typography to style a foreign language, the appeals to this or that "ideal", the quirky attempts at humor. It always seemed to me to be part of the antidote to the "this city looks like all the other cities" trend of cultural homogenization that seems to be eating the world. Sure, there are also the ubiquitous global or luxury brand ones, but you take the good with the bad like everything else, and even these will often have a different twist based on the country you're in.
- greenie_beans 2y agothere are no billboards in vermont and it's great. there's a baseball field by my house with a bunch of billboards behind the fence and it feels like getting saturated with american advertisements whenever i walk by it, like a weird reverse zen anxious feeling, seeing all of those ads after not seeing any for a long time
- drblastoff 2y agoIf they want to limit “visual pollution” they should crack down on graffiti. Zurich is covered in it and it’s really ugly. Local Swiss claimed it’s no worse than other cities, but it was worse than any place I’ve seen.
- Anamon 2y agoBy graffiti, I assume you mean tags, i.e. not the ones with some artistic value? I live in Zurich and also wasn't under the impression that it's noticeably worse than elsewhere, but it's certainly an unnecessary eyesore. There was some reporting on it recently, saying that a major issue are private building owners. Public spots are usually cleaned up quickly. They said the city has some form of very cheap service/insurance offering that building owners can get, which assures that any reported sprayings will be washed off by city workers within x days, but that this service seems to be not widely known. So at least, people seem to be aware of the issue and doing something. Nothing preventing tackling both issues at the same time, in any case.
- drblastoff 2y agoYes, tags, and really anything illegally spray painted on public or private surfaces. No problem if the city or a building owner wants to commission or invite graffiti artists. I spent time in several European cities recently (and in the past), and Zurich was the only place where the amount of graffiti really stood out to me. Maybe there was an expectation that a wealthy city/country wouldn’t have tagging, which made it stand out more. Berlin had a lot of both good street art and tagging, but the tagging seemed more concentrated in specific areas. The graffiti stood out more to me than billboards, but as an American I’m surely desensitized to billboards.
- alexawarrior3 2y agoITT: if you're rich enough you don't have to see the billboards saturating the landscape of the customers feeding the investments you own.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Rebuff5007 2y ago> ads online are much more energy-intensive than billboards. Is this quote from the article remotely true or even verifiable?
- DaSHacka 2y agoJust on its surface I find it extremely hard to believe sending a small HTTP GET request to the advertisers webserver and pulling a .webp is anywhere near as energy consuming as: 1. Arranging for the billboard to be built 2. Hiring workers to drive to the site and build it 3. Finding an advertiser to put on the billboard 4. Printing their advert on a canvas 5. Hiring someone to go hang it up Plus every time a worker needs to drive to the site to perform maintenance.
- Night_Thastus 2y agoI've said it before and I'll say it again: Advertisement is a pollution, a parasite, a cancer on modern society that we've all put up with for too long. It makes our physical and online spaces uglier. They waste space. They waste electricity. They waste computational resources. They waste brain space for the people viewing them. The most aggressive advertisers often sell low-quality services/products or outright scams, which harms those least educated and poorest individuals. They encourage people to spend outside of their means. They make people feel they need a product or else they're lesser or ugly or poor or a bad friend or a bad spouse or a bad parent or whatever it is they're preying on. And don't even get me started on advertising for medication. The fact that's not illegal is insane.
- lolinder 2y agoYeah, a lot of people in tech have gotten fixated on privacy as the problem with advertisement. You get companies like Mozilla that have come to the conclusion that we need ads but we also need privacy, so maybe we need privacy-preserving ads! For me, privacy isn't even half the problem with ads. Billboards along highways are dangerous. Ads represent a ridiculous percentage of the paper sent via snail mail today, most of which gets immediately thrown away (or best case, recycled). Ads on web pages prevent me from actually reading the content on the page, and incentivize an insane writing style that I frankly don't want to read even with an ad blocker. Ads are bad, in and of themselves. Avoiding tracking doesn't solve their fundamental issue. As G.K. Chesterton put it in 1920 [0]: > Advertisement is the rich asking for more money. A man would be annoyed if he found himself in a mob of millionaires, all holding out their silk hats for a penny; or all shouting with one voice, "Give me money." Yet advertisement does really assault the eye very much as such a shout would assault the ear. "Budge's Boots are the Best" simply means "Give me money"; "Use Seraphic Soap" simply means "Give me money." It is a complete mistake to suppose that common people make our towns commonplace, with unsightly things like advertisements. Most of those whose wares are thus placarded everywhere are very wealthy gentlemen with coronets and country seats, men who are probably very particular about the artistic adornment of their own homes. They disfigure their towns in order to decorate their houses. [0] https://www.gutenberg.org/files/13468/13468-h/13468-h.htm https://www.gutenberg.org/files/13468/13468-h/13468-h.htm
- 2y ago
- hooverd 2y agoI love this. Although, now how will I know that HELL IS REAL or JESUS SAVES?
- wunderlust 2y agoThe American mind cannot understand this.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoPeople think of advertisements/sponsorships as "free money" to support things that otherwise couldn't be budgeted for (arts, sports, infrastructure), but if you think a bit deeper companies wouldn't pay for ads if they didn't expect a return on it. If an ad during a sports game pays the teams/league 10 million dollars, that means they expect the audience to spend in aggregate 10 million more dollars on the product. Sure, the company might be making a bad bet, and sometimes they do, but surely it would be better for everyone involved (except the advertisers and advertising company) if the league/teams just charged customers 10 million dollars more (not necessarily 10 million/ticket number per ticket, it could be merch, or perks, or upcharging for the nicer seats, but they do that anyway). If you think about it, ads are basically a tool to fix broken monetization. But as long as they exist, we'll never address why monetization is so broken, and I suspect people would be more willing to spend disposable income on the things they actually enjoy, instead of the things they see ads for.
- arresin 2y agoThe article mentions the economic gain from the billboards but what about the negative externality that the advertisers don’t have to pay?
- zoklet-enjoyer 2y agoGot keys to my new apartment yesterday and noticed there are 3 billboards within a block from my place that will be slightly ruining the sunrise
- ErikAugust 2y agoVermont resident here. We don’t have billboards. They are illegal.
- pseudosavant 2y agoThe city I live in in So Cal banned billboards and has had limits on business signs for a very long time ago. I have always appreciated the reduced visual noise. It is really obvious when you cross over into the next city over because it is nothing but billboards all over the highway for dispensaries, casinos, ambulance chasing or divorce attorneys, and car insurance. They've been so strict about it that it took about 15 years longer to get an In-n-Out.
- mythrwy 2y agoOk, but how are they planning for people to find personal injury attorneys now?
- m3nsr3a 2y agoAds are necessary evil. Though fight will(and should) continue on all mediums. Was building a case for German offline event posters. 1: https://pasteboard.co/2IJsohNRRpQd.jpg https://pasteboard.co/2IJsohNRRpQd.jpg 2: https://pasteboard.co/nFpogptFxuty.jpg https://pasteboard.co/nFpogptFxuty.jpg 1: https://pasteboard.co/IGaRJDbNWLFG.jpg https://pasteboard.co/IGaRJDbNWLFG.jpg 1: https://pasteboard.co/3sclWRFcjRFb.jpg https://pasteboard.co/3sclWRFcjRFb.jpg
- meagher 2y agoAdfree Cities is worth checking out - https://adfreecities.org.uk https://adfreecities.org.uk HN post from 7 months ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38629763 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38629763
- neonate 2y agohttps://archive.ph/zvgZO https://archive.ph/zvgZO
- hoosieree 2y ago1. buy real estate in a billboard-infested city 2. ban billboards 3. sell
- self_awareness 2y ago4. ads appear again
- hoosieree 2y agodang it!
- elitan 2y agoThis is the #1 feature of my Meta Ray-Ban glasses.
- keraf 2y agoA metro station in Prague (JZP) got recently renovated and shortly after the opening, ads were absent. It was a breath of fresh air, finally being in a space without visual pollution. In the following weeks, the metro station was plastered with ads again and people complained. I can’t remember the details of the story, but it was found out that whoever owned that space (council, city or public transport company?) charged a really small amount for the ad space, to the point where removing it was a very negligible loss in revenue. So they removed all the ads again. It’s undeniable the most beautiful metro station in Prague. Freshly renovated, cool design and no ads.
- zuluonezero 2y agoI'm feeling the irony of not being able to read this article due to the banner advertising in the Bloomberg site.
- robwwilliams 2y agoIs this uncommon: Germantown, Tennessee banned (or severely limited?) billboards and loud signage long ago. We had a hard time finding any stores in this town for years. https://library.municode.com/tn/germantown/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=PTIICOOR_CH14SI https://library.municode.com/tn/germantown/codes/code_of_ord... And based on this article billboard were banned in Alaska in 1949! https://movia.media/moving-billboard-blog/why-are-billboards-banned-in-certain-states/ https://movia.media/moving-billboard-blog/why-are-billboards...
- floridagameshow 2y agoMy home state Maine hasn't allowed billboards since the last one came down in 1984. Alsaka and Hawaii have similar laws. https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/maine/12-terrifying-places-me/ https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/maine/12-terrifying-places-m...
- hilbert42 2y agoI can vividly recall visiting Prague in the Communist era and was amazed to see no billboards, it was like stepping back in time. What amplified the effect for me was that the Communists had done very little development since they'd come to power which meant that not only the old centre of the city but also some of its suburburban parts had remained essentially unaltered since the 18th Century. No doubt, those who lived there would have noticed changes but to my jaded eyes the city was a time capsule. It seems I wasn't alone thinking that, the producers of the 1984 movie version of Peter Shaffer's play Amadeus used Prague as a backdrop because it was historically 'pristine' in that it had not been spoiled by ads. When I returned some years later after the fall of Communism things were very different, there were ads and billboards everywhere. I was both shocked and saddened at what had happened, the billboards had visually polluted the city. I'd love to see billboards removed but I can't see it happening in the major centers of capitalism anytime soon.
- bicepjai 2y agoPersonal story around billboards: When I visited time square in NYC for the first time, I for some reason had this expectation that was created by Hollywood and was so disappointed to see that it’s nothing but a big electronic billboard showcase.
- simonebrunozzi 2y agoSao Paulo too.
- oslis 2y ago[dead]