16 ms·
The Delusion of the Polygraph
- phibz 2y agoI never understood why people believed this BS. The process of administering an exam requires direct interpretation from another human. They are just as fallible as I.
- ttyprintk 2y agoMore so. Becoming a polygraph examiner is possible with problems in your background that would exclude you from Public Trust. One guy in Florida was drugging and fondling people taking the test.
- dboreham 2y agoLots of these. E.g. changing car engine oil every 20 minutes. Although this doesn't extend to the US government -- the army periodically samples oil and changes when it actually needs to be changed.
- amtamt 2y agoSituations like these https://www.thehulltruth.com/boating-forum/183583-fuel-tank-sabotage.html https://www.thehulltruth.com/boating-forum/183583-fuel-tank-... could be the reason to test oil frequently.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rascul 2y agoThe US Army changes oil in their trucks based on the schedule in the Technical Manual, not based on sample analysis.
- Timothee 2y agoI discovered the engine oil thing in the past two years. In the US, I’ve always heard something like every 3 months or 3,000 to 5,000 miles. The cars even warn you in that timeframe. In Europe, a mechanic was very confused when I talked about an oil change when one was done the prior year. He said it’s more every 2 years or 20,000 to 25,000 kilometers. Once again the cars were set up to warn at that distance. I’d love to get to the bottom of it. Why such a difference? I can understand the garages wanting the extra business, but why would the car manufacturers go with it?
- vundercind 2y agoFree oil changes from dealers are often offered on new cars. Getting you in to the dealer more often may benefit them in some ways: 1) Opportunity to upsell other services, 2) Some people (quite a lot, actually) have alien-to-me car buying habits and might be convinced to trade in their new car after only a year or two and buy another new one if you can just get them into the dealer at the right time. No clue if that’s why they do it, but maybe.
- karaterobot 2y agoFWIW, every time I've had my oil changed at the dealership (dozens of times, but only 3 different dealers, so take it with a grain of salt) it's always been done by the service department, with no interaction from sales at all, and therefore no upselling or discussion about trading.
- kevstev 2y agoIn this case I think the times have changed but old advice has stuck. From my understanding, cars until the 80s or so did need their oil changed this often, but newer cars with EFI and especially if you use synthetic, its no longer necessary to do so. Its been many years since I bought a new car, but IIRC even the mid 2000s you were supposed to get an oil change relatively soon after getting a car as fine particles that weren't entirely machined off should have been worked off in the first thousand miles or so and you were told to get an oil change then. There is also the case of changing oil for hot and cold seasons- getting thinner oil in the winter and thicker in warmer weather to adjust. I think thats more or less a thing of the past as well, my Honda does not specify/recommend this in the owners manual but perhaps some cars do? Old adages sometimes stick around forever though- especially when there is money to be made in keeping them alive.
- Terr_ 2y ago> But the machine remains useful for extracting confessions. [...] Despite a growing body of evidence, including hundreds of exonerations based on DNA evidence, most people don’t believe in false confessions. Arguably the bigger/worse false belief right there. > First the exam makes you doubt or forget your memories. Then, by forcing you to re-access them again and again under stress, it literally rewrites them. To some extent this happens naturally, so if the questioner really wants accuracy, you won't force people to re-access the memory for no good reason.
- Netcob 2y agoThere is an entire little ecosystem/subculture around "repressed memories" doing a lot of harm to vulnerable people. Basically you go to a "therapist", they do some sort of hypnosis/interview session where they ask you a lot of very leading questions, and then you leave having been convinced that your family or a satanic cult abused you as a kid (or in some cases that you have been abducted by aliens). The person performing this interview might not even be aware they are doing anything wrong, to them those leading questions ("Do you see anyone else in the room with you? Look closer, are you sure?") may just be how you get to the truth.
- denton-scratch 2y ago> (or in some cases that you have been abducted by aliens) Really? There are therapists who will try to convince you that you were abducted by aliens?
- nemomarx 2y agoI don't think anymore, but in the last century there were several cases of therapists using hypnosis to unlock "repressed memories" of alien abductions. They usually wrote up books about it for profit.
- RIMR 2y agoNot specifically, but they will follow the absurd path of asking you leading questions until you convince yourself that you were abducted by aliens, and then being quacks will decide that their methodology couldn't be wrong, and so they validate your own invented beliefs no matter how stupid. If it keeps you coming back for another session, they'll keep doing it, even if they know the whole process is bullshit.
- dvh 2y agoFirst sentence on Wikipedia: >A polygraph, often incorrectly referred to as a lie detector test, is a junk science device or procedure that measures and records several physiological indicators such as blood pressure, pulse, respiration, and skin conductivity while a person is asked and answers a series of questions.
- crystal_revenge 2y agoI awhile back I used to do work with a major DARPA contractor. If you're familiar with security clearance for these roles, you know that at the higher levels of clearance you eventually need to take a polygraph exam. I was never interested in going the clearance route, but got into a conversation with a grizzled industry vet that seemed like a character torn from a hard-boiled detective novel. At the time I had recently learned that polygraph exams were "fake" and when the topic of the exam came up I was quick to point this out. His comment surprised me, and, in a sense, demonstrated to me that saying a polygraph is "fake" is akin to saying WWE wrestling is "fake". Of course it is, but that is a misunderstanding that what you're watching is a real performance. He said the polygraph itself is just a tool for the interviewer. The real value was in someone who knew how to use the machine to convince the subject that they knew the truth. He continue that in his time he knew some mighty good interviewers who could easily extract anything they needed from you. My father did go the clearance route, and when I asked him about the polygraph he told me he confessed things to the interviewers he would never have told my mother. "Fake" or "real" the polygraph does work in this sense.
- keiferski 2y agoYeah, polygraphs remind me of those TV shows where the investigator pretends to use magic, voodoo, astral signs, etc. to solve the crime, but is really just using them to manipulate the psychology of the subject and see their reaction. Put simply, the polygraph is a powerful tool if the subject believes it is a powerful tool.
- Terr_ 2y agoThat's incomplete. As the article points out: > Even the United States government isn’t dumb enough to believe the polygraph works. The machine’s real purpose is symbolic, as an icon of the power of the state. Law enforcement agencies don’t use the machine to detect lies. They use it to coerce confessions. [...] It’s a fact, part of a story power tells itself to justify its power. Maybe you can beat the machine— they don’t detect lies, so it’s not that hard—but you can’t beat an entire country that believes in it. Even if you know its nonsense, there's still something coercive of any system where it can be used as a pretext to punish you, or where you are punished for not pretending to believe in it.
- torginus 2y agoIt's (unfortunately) not an American problem. I have firsthand experience that courts are highly prestige-driven and the best way to make your case is have a ton of expensive-looking and official-sounding documents written by 'experts' that support your argument. Judges are like every high-level decisionmaker ever - the thing they fear the most is publicly being proven wrong so they always go for the safe option where they can share the responsibility of their decisions with 'experts'.
- rdtsc 2y agoWith the polygraph used as a universal filtering device for hundreds of thousands of employees in powerful agencies, we end up with a mix of either super honest ones who reveal everything to the polygrapher (i.e. interrogator), or psychopaths who lie through their teeth without showing any physiological signs and passing with flying color. Next time when you deal with these agencies, as a fun mental exercise, try to figure out which one of the two types you've got in front of you. When it comes to climbing to the top through the ranks, which ones will get there more effectively?
- analog31 2y agoI wonder if it's simpler than that: The examiner is just choosing whether they like you or not.
- rdtsc 2y agoOfficially they have to follow their training, so to speak, and I am sure that's all about how polygraphs are 100% reliable and it's scientific and all that. I wonder if any instructors at some point close the door and tell them "listen, students, yeah, it's all bunk, but we just have to pretend, ok?".
- analog31 2y agoThey're apparently allowed to manipulate the subject ad lib.
- xboxnolifes 2y ago> I wonder if any instructors at some point close the door and tell them "listen, students, yeah, it's all bunk, but we just have to pretend, ok?". If online stories are to trusted, this has occurred in a lot of government clearance related situations.
- odo1242 2y agoAlmost certainly.
- 2y ago
- rightbyte 2y agoWatching Dexter this 'blood splatter anaysis' seemed beyond ridculous to me. I thought there were no way it would be a thing in the US in the way portrayed. But then I learn truth detectors are? What more movie tropes are not tropes?
- Hikikomori 2y agoPlenty of techniques are based on junk science, much more in the past than now. Police/FBI don't actively try to find out if techniques are based on real science or not as they are useful in securing convictions. So called experts in these fields testify in trials and are paid quite a bit, it is in their interest to continue being paid so the fraud perpetuates. Unless you have money you have no way to put up a defense that can discredit expert witness testimony. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/apr/28/forensics-bite-mark-junk-science-charles-mccrory-chris-fabricant https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/apr/28/forensics-bi...
- duped 2y agoMan it's shocking how bad forensic "science" is. If you watch Law & Order you may be convinced that police can detect gun shot residue on a suspects hands/clothing or match shell casings to a specific gun. It turns out just throwing handcuffs on someone is enough to get a false positive GSR test. And matching a shell casing to a specific gun is essentially impossible. The false positive rates on forensic "tests" are hard to study because no one has an incentive to, and if you go digging you'll find how bad they can be. Like for example K9 units have about a 50% false detection rate (dog indicated but no drugs/weapons/bombs found). If a cop told you they flipped a coin to decide whether to search a car then the search would be tossed out of evidence immediately!
- mrguyorama 2y agoThe vast majority of "Forensic Techniques" used by cops are literally things an ex-cop made up / """observed""" and are now charging insane prices to go across the US, giving presentations to other cops or giving testimony in trials. It's a factless and truthless system.
- 2y ago
- MikePlacid 2y agoWhen we presented our pediatrician with our third child who could urinate in a sink on verbal command at just six months old, she remarked, "We should write an article for a medical journal!" We explained that such an article would never get published because it's not new information; most of Europe begins potty-training at around six months. Delaying this valuable skill until the age of 3-4 years is an enormous waste of resources - but still the whole country was insisting on doing it, don’t know about now.
- n4r9 2y ago> most of Europe begins potty-training at around six months Where did you hear that? Admittedly here in the UK we've been doing our level best to extricate ourselves from the continent, but I've only ever heard of one mum even thinking about it before 18 months. Ours is just over a year and we haven't thought about it at all yet, same with our ante-natal group and friends with slightly older babies. I googled around a bit and this reddit thread has a lot of Europeans with similar experience to me: https://www.reddit.com/r/Mommit/comments/tdb1f2/what_are_non_american_cultures_ideas_on_potty/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Mommit/comments/tdb1f2/what_are_non...
- knallfrosch 2y agoThe German term is "Abhalten" (from "halten = to carry") or ("windelfrei = diaper free") and you'll find quite a lot: https://www.google.com/search?q=baby+abhalten+*.de https://www.google.com/search?q=baby+abhalten+*.de Our baby was born potty-trained (which actually means the term is misleading in our case) and a relative started at their childrens' birth.
- n4r9 2y agoThis sounds different to potty-training, which is where the child knows that they need to wee or poo and tells you or goes straight to the potty to do it. "Abhalten" sounds like the parent training to know rather than the child.
- tetromino_ 2y ago
- Okx 2y agoNo wonder he heard from his brother that the Border Patrol were always hiring; they seemingly make it impossible to get hired.
- DoItToMe81 2y agoSadly, not All-American anymore. The US police force doesn't exist in a vacuum. There is a whole industry of pseudoscientific interrogation techniques that has set itself up in other nations and regressed their policing by decades. Several states in Australia, and I believe parts of the UK, removed the polygraph as a discredited technique and now accept it as evidence once more.
- n4r9 2y agoUK here, just looked it up and although it's not admissible as evidence in court, since 2021 it can be used as a requirement for release from prison for domestic abusers. Bloody hell, that is scary.
- xnorswap 2y agoThat is scary! Well, we've recently got a new prisons minister, this might actually motivate me to write to them about this.
- n4r9 2y agoI looked them up: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Timpson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Timpson Woah. It's actually the MD of Timpson, whom Starmer has parachuted into the role along with a peerage. So an unelected Minister, but apparently he's very into prison reform, so there's that.
- xnorswap 2y agoIndeed, Timpson's are a leading employer of people who have served their sentence: > The company is well known for its policy of employing ex-convicts, who make up over 10% of its workforce
- Quarrel 2y agoWhere in Australia? I've been out of Aus for a few years, but in NSW I understand they're still largely banned (Lie Detectors Act) for employment, courts / evidence, insurance etc (and if they weren't by legislation, they would be for evidence by precedent, which is how the Act came about). As I understood it, this and the Canadian precedent that NSW relied upon, have basically made them a non-starter for courts in Australia ever since. It's a bit horrifying if they're making a comeback, but then our politicians have always been a bit prone to right wing shock jock rhethoric around election time.
- bell-cot 2y agoI'd describe American (govt. agency) polygraphy as a psychological hazing ritual, run by a pretty machismo crowd. Who don't like their beliefs and rituals questioned.
- Unbefleckt 2y ago[flagged]
- nelox 2y agoYou can add dissociative identity disorder, a.k.a. multiple personality disorder, to the list of All-American delusions.
- graemep 2y agoIt reminds me of the GK Chesterton short story "The Mistake of the Machine" which suggests it was a very American idea even back then. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wisdom_of_Father_Brown/The_Mistake_of_the_Machine https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wisdom_of_Father_Brown/Th... The evidence it "works" reminds me of alternative medicine.
- motohagiography 2y agomy experience with the polygraph was it detects your ability to submit. it's less a delusion than a ritual. as a filter, it produces a completely polarized bimodal distribution of banal followers vs. the basest human malevolence and contempt, while disqualifying relfection or doubt. if the purpose of a system is what it does the polygraph is perfect. it finds expendable souls.
- davemp 2y agoThat’s about as well founded of a statement as the idea that polygraphs are lie detectors.
- mbg721 2y agoThis is in line with the joke, "How do get the NYPD to catch a rabbit?" You ask them, and a week later they bring in a badly beaten bear, who shouts "Okay, I'm a rabbit! I'm a rabbit!!"
- bloomingeek 2y agoMany years ago, at the age of nineteen, I was forced to take a polygraph if I wanted to keep my job. Someone was stealing products from the store, we heard out the back door, and they required everyone to be tested. Naturally, my co-workers and I discussed this among ourselves and we all agreed to test, we knew we were innocent. One of the men said all they're trying to do is see if anyone cracks under the pressure of the test. Being kind of a nervous type of person, I was concerned they might misread my domineer. I talked to my sister and she told me to try my best to control my breathing during the test. For me the problem wasn't that I was guilty, it was they would think I was guilty. We all passed the test and went back to work, later it was revealed the thief was someone on another shift. Or were they just nervous?
- dfxm12 2y agoThis might have been illegal, depending on how many years ago this was: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employee_Polygraph_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employee_Polygraph_Protection_... In either case it was complete BS and just shows the sorry state of labor in the past few decades.
- MathMonkeyMan 2y agoConfess! Confess!
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoA LOT of businesses break labor laws on a regular basis, especially smaller businesses without a legal department telling managers "You can't do that". You'd be alarmed to know how many restaurant owners tell the staff to clock out when the store closes and then finish closing duties off the clock, among other types of wage theft.
- GrantMoyer 2y agodomineer → demeanor I only post the correction because it took me a couple of minutes to figure out. Domineer is an uncommon word, so initially I thought I had a gap in my vocabulary, but couldn't find any definitions that made sense in this context.
- withinrafael 2y agoHey quackery or not, the Polygraph saved my heart. (Disclosure: A bit of an exaggeration.) After hours of uncomfortable prodding, an interviewer came into the room and suggested I see a doctor for what looked like heart arrhythmia. I did shortly after and they were right! (It was deemed nothing too serious though.)
- bityard 2y agoYeah, the instruments work fine, but the interpretation of the readings is just modern day tea leaves.
- jmyeet 2y agoAlternative take: lack of accessible, affordable and comprehensive healthcare almost cost me my life. I'm actually curious. Do you get an annual physical? Does your PCP give you an EKG? That would be the appropriate way to catch this.
- kwhitefoot 2y agoAre annual physicals provably worth doing? Or are they the medical profession's version of the polygraph?
- withinrafael 2y agoI was young back then and was not getting annual physicals. That has changed, along with regular exercise!
- selimthegrim 2y agoLast night the polygraph saved my life…
- ttyprintk 2y agoFrom the article: Even the telltale spike in the polygraph chart, itself largely a myth created by TV and movies, can indicate anything from a heart problem to sexual attraction. (Indeed, the machine’s inventors used it to detect both of those things. Larson married one of his first test subjects, and Keeler discovered a heart defect while testing the machine on himself.)
- JohnMakin 2y agoThis article touches on it but to me the most offensive part of a polygraph is the presumption of guilt if you refuse to take one. This is very much on purpose, of course, given as the author accurately states, its purpose isn't to detect lies, it's a tool used for coercion. There was a big robbery at a place I worked, luckily I was not a suspect but the FBI came and administered polygraphs to anyone who could have done it. I asked what happens if someone refuses, and the answer was basically "they won't." Of course it ended up being someone that didn't even work there. The test was clearly for intimidation purposes, at least from the view I had.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mmmlinux 2y agoAren't polygraphs not acceptable evidence in the US courts?
- bityard 2y agoPolygraph tests are not usually acceptable as evidence in court. HOWEVER. Law enforcement can still use them as another tool in their questioning process to produce a confession when there is other evidence pointing to the guilt of the suspect. But of course is only effective against defendants who represent themselves, don't seek their lawyer's advice, or ignore their lawyer's advice.
- RIMR 2y agoPolygraphs can be used as evidence, but you would have to be a moron to submit to one, and refusing one cannot be used as evidence of guilt.
- singleshot_ 2y agoI’m very curious about your last sentence. Are you basing this on the fifth amendment, or something else.
- OsrsNeedsf2P 2y agoThe author is uncooperative throughout the whole test, fails it, then claims the polygraph is quackery.
- thornewolf 2y agothe only lack of cooperation communicated in this article is the account on drug use. that said, the claims on quackery are unrelated to the author's specific set of behaviors during the test. i reckon that i, knowing the complete lack of scientific backing, would also be uncooperative to some degree.
- jrgaston 2y agoA wonderfully written piece. It’s not a lie if you believe it. - George Costanza
- diogenes_atx 2y agoThe writer is obviously an intelligent person with good critical perspective, so it is surprising that he missed some important material about known countermeasures that can be effectively used to defeat the polygraph. A quick HN search with keywords "lie detector" offers a number of excellent articles on the subject, including discussion of the book "Lie Behind the Lie Detector" (available for free online) which provides detailed information on polygraphs and techniques to subvert the tests.
- jmyeet 2y agoThere is a long history of junk science in forensics [1]. Often this junk science is used to reinforce established biases and give bloodthirsty juries a hook to hang a conviction hat on. Now polygraphs now generally aren't admissible in court. This wasn't always the case [2]. Still, law enforcement does use them to eliminate or confirm suspects outside of a court environment. This can just confirming existing biases. And that's the deeper issue here: the American criminal justice system is mainly retributive or punitive. Long setnences for minor crimes. High conviction rates. Abuse of the power imbalance between prosecutors and defendants. Judges that essentially work for the prosecution (eg [3]). Juries that just want to convict. Of anything. Yet there's ample evidence none of this is effective whereas something as simple as giving inmates cats to look after is extremely effective at reducing recidivism [4]. My point is that technology can be (and has been) used as a crutch to confirm biases and that criminals are still people and we should treat them as people. [1]: https://www.propublica.org/article/understanding-junk-science-forensics-criminal-justice https://www.propublica.org/article/understanding-junk-scienc... [2]: https://axeligence.com/polygraph-admissibility-in-united-states-courts/ https://axeligence.com/polygraph-admissibility-in-united-sta... [3]: https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/young-thug-rico-trial-judge-glanville-recused-1235060731/ https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/young-thug-ric... [4]: https://www.indystar.com/story/news/local/indianapolis/2020/10/19/cats-inmates-rehabilitate-each-other-through-animal-care-program/5798291002/ https://www.indystar.com/story/news/local/indianapolis/2020/...
- lesuorac 2y ago> Why should I be banned from a job for being a small-time delinquent twenty years ago? Fair question. I'm not sure that's 1) been shown to be true 2) the fault of a polygraph; it's a policy decision not a mechanical one. > As he pumped up the cuff, Kevin asked if I was comfortable. He didn’t seem to be joking. Yeah, he probably was serious. Kevin has a job to do and it's to ask you questions and record your responses; not to torture you. Sometimes people really forget that not every examiner thinks you're the next Aldrich Ames. But I mean also if you're in a very uncomfortable situation and somebody asks you how you are, maybe being honest will help resolve that situation? Like clearly you can't resolve it on your own otherwise you wouldn't be in such a panic. > Except for the last two, all of them seemed open to interpretation. For instance, I absolutely had misrepresented my past drug use, but only the number of times, not the drugs or the fact of doing them. If only there was somebody that could've helped you determine what the answer should be. Maybe Kevin? --- I mean yeah, if you go into a polygraph expecting a fight I don't think it's fairly surprising you don't get the job. Who wants to hire somebody combative to your employees? Sure, it's unfair but you're taking it out on Kevin who didn't come up with it.
- ewy1 2y agoMaybe you misinterpreted the intent of the article - isn't the purpose of it to point out absurdities and fundamental flaws in the uniquely American polygraph obsession?
- newzisforsukas 2y agoWho wants to work for or with someone who pretends they can read your mind?
- TomMasz 2y agoI watch a lot of true crime programs and the polygraph is mostly used as justification to harass innocent people. The police consider the refusal to take it as a tacit admittance of guilt, despite the fact it can't be used in court. It's all shit.
- javier_e06 2y agoNo Polygraph discussion is complete without Moe being subjected to the Polygraph... Eddie: Checks out. OK, sir, you're free to go. Moe: Good, 'cause I got a hot date tonight. [buzz] _A_ date. [buzz] Dinner with friends. [buzz] Dinner alone. [buzz] Watching TV alone. [buzz] All right! I'm going to sit at home and ogle the ladies in the Victoria's Secret catalog. [buzz] [weakly] Sears catalog. [ding] [angry] Now would you unhook this already, please? I don't deserve this kind of shabby treatment! [buzz]
- macrael 2y agoSo good, and I love this SMBC take on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJS76Bf-ZYo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJS76Bf-ZYo
- blast 2y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdIDwYW_JZg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdIDwYW_JZg
- monktastic1 2y agoOne of the two best polygraph jokes in the Simpsons! The other, of course, being https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Or2iZ-mOvf8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Or2iZ-mOvf8
- dang 2y agoRelated: UK police increasingly using polygraph tests - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39161771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39161771 - Jan 2024 (5 comments) Spanish police plans to extend use of its lie-detector while efficacy is unclear - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24905780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24905780 - Oct 2020 (38 comments) Accused spy Alexander Yuk Ching Ma evidently beat the polygraph - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24197310 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24197310 - Aug 2020 (186 comments) We tested Europe’s new lie detector for travelers and triggered a false positive - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21358288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21358288 - Oct 2019 (114 comments) Why Lie Detector Tests Can’t Be Trusted - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20556201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20556201 - July 2019 (190 comments) Attempts to Censor AntiPolygraph.org - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20311040 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20311040 - June 2019 (45 comments) The Lie Behind the Lie Detector - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18431683 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18431683 - Nov 2018 (96 comments) An AI Lie Detector Is Going to Start Questioning Travelers in the EU - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18351733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18351733 - Nov 2018 (202 comments) Personal Statement of a CIA Analyst - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18155548 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18155548 - Oct 2018 (104 comments) The Lie Generator: Inside the Black Mirror World of Polygraph Job Screenings - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18120270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18120270 - Oct 2018 (95 comments) NCCA Polygraph Countermeasure Course Files Leaked - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17277049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17277049 - June 2018 (4 comments) Do Polygraphs Actually Work? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12951926 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12951926 - Nov 2016 (4 comments) An Ex-Cop's War on Lie Detectors - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10002889 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10002889 - Aug 2015 (64 comments) How to Beat a Polygraph Test - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9481385 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9481385 - May 2015 (92 comments) Man accused of teaching people to beat lie detector tests faces prison - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6308878 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6308878 - Sept 2013 (152 comments) The Lie Behind the Lie Detector [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6307479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6307479 - Aug 2013 (22 comments) Seeing threats, feds target instructors of polygraph-beating methods - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6229185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6229185 - Aug 2013 (4 comments) All lies? Scientists threatened with legal action over lie detector article - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=457996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=457996 - Jan 2009 (1 comment) My NSA polygraph experiences - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=428489 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=428489 - Jan 2009 (46 comments) also https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=giles_corey https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=giles_corey
- michaelteter 2y agoWriting mostly for the sake of writing. That’s not to say it wasn’t interesting; but it could have been 1/3 the length and provided the same information value. It’s as if the author wanted us to experience our own suffering, wondering when “the rest of the story” would finally be delivered.
- Covzire 2y agoOne of my college professors was adamantly against Polygraphs, he made the case that over time it causes sociopaths to collect at whatever work address requires them because they can pass effortlessly and normal people on average get stung by false positives.
- ttyprintk 2y agoI used to think this, but learned it filters for three modes: 1. The average person who hesitantly wishes that the examiner will supportively pursue establishing the true state of his/her personality and the World at large. 2. Someone entirely lacking empathy, unable to value the examiner as someone seeking truth. 3. Those who effortlessly pass, every time. I think the reason three-letter-agencies maintain such expensive theater is to discover and protect #3.
- JackFr 2y agoI took a polygraph about 30 years ago a Ft. Meade during a background check for NSA. Honestly it took like 45 minutes, guy was totally pleasant and he treated it seriously, but it seemed mechanical, strictly scripted, and more like a box checking exercise. However, I also had an interview with a psychologist which was very intense and manipulative, but effective, in eliciting true information about how much I was drinking at the time (too much, quite frankly). It was only years later that I realized that was the information they really wanted and all the other embarrassing sex questions were just to set me up.
- ttyprintk 2y agoThe sex questions are often the setup. You fill out a ton of background material with one or two sex questions, then the poly has hours of it. People use the word “ambush” and I think it’s useful when they’re trying to build a baseline profile.
- farceSpherule 2y agoPolygraphs are b.s. pseudoscience, unreliable, and subjective. Polygraph "examiners" are like drug dogs who always fail to find drugs because, since they do not find the drugs, they receive no praise and they do not receive their "toy."
- shove 2y agoNot a single comment in here connecting the fake bullshit detection technology of the previous generation to the present bullshit generation technology (“AI”)? I’m disappointed, y’all.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- darkNeo 2y agoKeep your propaganda to yourself... the polygraph is a scientific tool... it's been proven the body goes through physiological changes when humans lie
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoHow so?