15 ms·
Indian startup 3D prints rocket engine in 72 hours
- instagraham 2y agoAmong world-firsts that happen in contemporary India, this is probably one of the coolest.
- passion__desire 2y agoThere is a veritasium video on rocket 3d printing.
- edm0nd 2y agoFor the curious: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz165f1g8-E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz165f1g8-E
- mlindner 2y agoIt's not a world first. It's an industry standard in tact.
- greekanalyst 2y agoThat's super cool. India has enormous potential and it is amazing to witness the rise of its tech scene.
- otteromkram 2y ago[flagged]
- aprilthird2021 2y agoImagine reading an article about the achievements of an Indian startup, based in India, with Indians at the helm, and thinking "Ugh, they only achieve things because US companies grace them with jobs!"
- iamthirsty 2y ago> Celesta Capital, Rocketship.vc, Artha Select Fund and Artha Venture Fund, and existing investors Mayfield India, Pi Ventures and Speciale Invest.[0] Not making an argument about off-shore work, but to be fair a lot of the funding came from out-of-country. — [0]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/catherinewang/2023/10/17/indian-space-startup-raises-267-million-series-b-to-launch-satellites-using-3d-printed-rocket-engines/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/catherinewang/2023/10/17/indian...
- aprilthird2021 2y agoA lot of the funding for various American startups comes from SoftBank and the Saudis, but we don't hear the same criticism of them when they achieve things...
- geodel 2y agoAnd funded by Indian money?
- s5300 2y ago[dead]
- mlindner 2y agoI wouldn't jump to praise so quickly. Additive manufacturing (aka 3D printing) is standard in the industry and the time is dependent on the size (and to some extent the mass) of the engine. They then further claim you don't need to do any post-manufacturing qualifications, which is absolute nonsense. So it's either misreporting or it's an indication of Indian incompetence/lying.
- ab8 2y agoI wonder where Indian incompetence/lying falls on the Elon scale.
- mlindner 2y agoI don't remember Elon ever stating something does something it's not actually doing. His future timelines are off but it's never his competence that's been a problem with anything relating to SpaceX. And calling SpaceX (the entire industry leader) anywhere near "incompetent" beggars belief. WDon't believe everything you read in headlines written by people with no understanding of the space industry. If you want to read about the industry, read about it on industry specific sites (like spacenews.com) or from industry specific reporters (Eric Berger or Stephen Clark at ArsTechnica). Davenport at Washington Post is good too.
- alephnerd 2y ago> feature eight engines in total and able to carry a 300-kilogram payload to an altitude of around 700 km. The launch vehicle used in May’s test was only 6 meters tall Significant military implications as well [0]. There is a significant spy-sat race going on in the region right now [1] with China, India, UAE, Saudi Arabia, US, Japan, South Korea, North Korea, Russia, Iran, Israel, etc all investing in capabilities in the region. Also has an impact in enhancing India's Ballistic Missile strategy used to combat a two-front war [2], because Missiles are to Indian military strategy what Drones are for Chinese military strategy. Also highlights how the India-US relationship is built by the Indian-American diaspora. The VC who funded Angikul is Anand Rajaraman - the Stanford professor who started "Big Data" with Ullman, was one of the earliest investors in Facebook, and lead Amazon Marketplace after getting acquired by Amazon early in it's history (Marketplace was originally an Indian e-commerce startup called Junglee). As India gets richer, and America's immigration system gets more and more rickety, a reverse brain and capital drain has started to form, much like with Chinese Americans in the late 2000s. [0] - https://www.deccanherald.com/opinion/agnikul-showcased-more-than-rocket-science-3056157 https://www.deccanherald.com/opinion/agnikul-showcased-more-... [1] - https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/Defense/China-and-India-lead-Asia-race-to-expand-spy-satellite-networks https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/Defense/China-and-India-lea... [2] - https://www.usiofindia.org/publication-journal/Evolution-of-India-Ballistic-Missile-Defence-Program-Prospects-and-Challenges.html https://www.usiofindia.org/publication-journal/Evolution-of-...
- fallingknife 2y ago> America's immigration system gets more and more rickety It's completely insane that we allow mass migration of people with no money and no skills and make it incredibly difficult for the most valuable immigrants to get in.
- nordsieck 2y ago> It's completely insane It makes perfect sense when you understand the principal-agent problem and the current political landscape. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_proble...
- pm90 2y agoThis is amazing. Strap several of those engines with a control system of some sort and you can basically launch a wide variety of payloads.
- euroderf 2y ago[flagged]
- philipwhiuk 2y ago> control system of some sort Control of multiple engines is non-trivial. You get fun stuff like plume interactions between the engines.
- aamoyg 2y ago[flagged]
- alephnerd 2y agoHere's a better article - https://techcrunch.com/2024/05/29/india-agnikul-3d-printed-rocket-launch/ https://techcrunch.com/2024/05/29/india-agnikul-3d-printed-r... > There are only a few players in private space which print rocket engines, and our very own SpaceX was one of the first to pioneer this The US isn't the only country with a large private space sector. China and India have both been heavily investing in it since the mid-2010s, because a dynamic space sector also means having an indigenous capability to deploy spy-satellites and ballistic missiles. There's a reason why Maxar, SpaceX, etc all get outsized DoD funding. India's space sector is also getting a massive cash infusion from the UAE [0] and KSA [1], as they both begin their process of building domestic space capabilities due to worries of Iran. [0] - https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/spotlight/indian-space-mavericks-in-dubais-celestial-potential-enhancing-india-uae-space-cooperation/articleshow/104370206.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/spotlight/indian-space-m... [1] - https://www.zawya.com/en/business/technology-and-telecom/saudi-arabia-and-india-will-launch-special-space-program-al-falih-mveu8zdh https://www.zawya.com/en/business/technology-and-telecom/sau...
- aamoyg 2y ago"The 6.2-meter-tall vehicle is made of carbon composite, which gives it a liftoff mass of 1,268 lb; at its heart is the 3D-printed semi-cryogenic engine that Agnikul manufactured in-house, each of which provides 6.2 kN of thrust." This is like they clubbed together processes which Russia seems to use for manufacturing of some of its Novator cruise missiles. That technology must have transferred over somehow and they are just adapting it for space. It's great they adapted a military technology for something else (though I expect it will stay military), but it's nothing novel.
- alephnerd 2y ago> That technology must have transferred over somehow Nope. Russia and Israel attempted that for India in the 1990s but were threatened by US sanctions for breaking MCTR. Idk why you're so surprised that these kinds of domestic capabilities exist in India now. India is fairly poor, but R&D capabilities have been strong, and there is an actual reverse brain drain going on from the US now that GC backlogs are multi-decade in length. > it's nothing novel It's a significant incremental development, as it drastically reduces the upfront cost for ballistic missiles or sub-orbital launches (eg. satellites), because you can manufacture much more faster. Plus, it is actually indigenous, which is a significant change.
- Etheryte 2y ago> The machine also automatically outputs a report that details any deviations during printing, removing the need for postfabrication qualification. Anyone who's previously worked with 3D printing knows that this simply does not pass any kind of a sniff test. Both preventing and detecting internal defects is one of the, if not the hardest problem in 3D printing. There are many large companies trying to find ways to reliably solve just this problem alone. Saying that this method doesn't require any checks after production is simply false.
- guax 2y agoTitan submersible sound detection system vibes.
- nathan_compton 2y agoExactly what I thought.
- cjbgkagh 2y agoI'm not sure how many people know about their 'sound detection system'. Carbon fiber is a fickle beast and is prone to such failures so that alone worried me, but it was incredible for me to learn that they expected some sort of early warning from cracking.
- ladams 2y agoDo you have a link? Google just gives results about the US Navy detection of the implosion…
- azornathogron 2y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/oceangate-2020-boasted-incredible-accuracy-detecting-titanic-sub-hull-flaws-2023-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/oceangate-2020-boasted-incre...
- lucianbr 2y ago
- deskamess 2y agoBuild your own web form: https://agnikul.in/#/ https://agnikul.in/#/ Select your launch location, orbital inclination, payload mass and then 'Build'. And another more detailed form at: https://agnikul.in/#/book https://agnikul.in/#/book
- eagerpace 2y agoThis is really neat, but would like to know more about the engine. The image seems to show a very simple design, without turbo pumps that are a mainstay in any other "rocket" engine.
- russdill 2y agoIt looks like it's electric pump fed, and it doesn't look like those pumps are part of the engine. Is it just a combustion chamber then?
- shrubble 2y agoI wish them well, but the rocket went less than 9km to apogee and 8km over the ground. It has to continue improving...
- 1024core 2y agoWright Brothers first airplane flew only 100m or so.
- nvy 2y agoThe "Wright Brothers" moment for rocketry happened 60 years ago.
- gridspy 2y agoThe first useful rockets were during the second world war, used for artillery into London. So over 80 years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-2_rocket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-2_rocket
- hermitcrab 2y agoDepends what you mean by 'useful'. They were a technological marvel, but an incredibly inefficient way to deliver approx a ton of high explosive. But I guess we should be thankful that Hitler wasted so much of Germany's increasingly scarce resources on 'Wunderwaffe' like rockets. The Allies developed technology that was less showy, but much more useful (computers, cavity magnetron, proximity fuze, atom bomb etc).
- nvy 2y agoYeah I was referring to Sputnik, as the V2 wasn't orbital.
- BHSPitMonkey 2y agoEvery new team has to start somewhere; even SpaceX had to learn to crawl before they could walk, and that was with the benefit of decades of prior art to draw upon. It would be a shame if SpaceX became the last company to ever succeed at designing a rocket because no one after them would try.
- surfingdino 2y agoNice pre-flight photo of the engine. Could we also have a look at the engine post-flight?
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoRelativity Space are also 3-D printing not just rocket engines, but entire rockets, and have had a successful first flight. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz165f1g8-E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz165f1g8-E
- CarVac 2y agoThey backed away from printing entire rockets because, well, it's a foolish way to fabricate large tanks.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoThanks - I wasn't aware of that, but it does make sense. They are sticking with 3-D printing of the engines though, and have been testing their next-gen Aeon R engine. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjKJMcOQYBQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjKJMcOQYBQ
- Spod_Gaju 2y ago[flagged]
- itshossein 2y agoOr perhaps probes to the Mars?
- Spod_Gaju 2y ago[flagged]
- eks391 2y agoThe primary purpose of rockets these days is to put satellites into space, not to bomb people. This includes the rockets built by the world's militaries.
- aamoyg 2y agoGuided missiles fall under the umbrella of rockets. There are far more guided and unguided missiles in the world than rockets for peaceful purposes. The primary purpose of rockets is to annihilate an enemy military with a secondary benefit being to put things and sometimes people into space. That's how it was pitched, and that's how it will always be.
- anonymousd3vil 2y agoKudo's to the team! This is a great success.
- surfingdino 2y agoI hope they all get to ride on it like true engineers would.
- constantcrying 2y ago>Constructing a rocket engine using conventional approaches can take months, followed by extensive qualification testing to ensure it meets the required specifications. Using a metal 3D printer from German company EOS, Agnikul produced its engine in roughly three days. Agnikul printed the engine out of inconel, a high-performance alloy of nickel and chromium that can withstand high temperatures and mechanical loads. The machine also automatically outputs a report that details any deviations during printing, removing the need for postfabrication qualification. What amateurs are at work here? This plainly is not true and if you believe this can work you can not be trusted to be anywhere near an engineering project. Besides, the question I have is why 3D printing? There are innumerable ways to manufacture a rocket, why did they choose 3D printing? If it is because they think you don't need qualification and testing for the produced hardware they should not be allowed to launch anything they make.
- wiseowise 2y ago[flagged]
- filcuk 2y agoThis is a very ignorant comment, as is the one you're replying to. Making engine nozzles used to be extremely manual and involved process, which could take up to a year to make a single nozzle. These need very particular channels within the walls for cooling, and that's impossible to manufacture with simple reductive methods. They used to form wax modls and deposit nanometre layers of metal.
- sa1 2y agoWhat part is not true? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz165f1g8-E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kz165f1g8-E I'm sure that there are lots of problems with this approach, but it is not as obvious as your comment makes it out to be.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AustinDev 2y agoCan't wait to 3D Print a bootleg PATRIOT system.
- instagraham 2y agoI take it you've seen the DIY 3D printed SAM some random Hong Kong dude made? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvcDwSmmxWs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvcDwSmmxWs
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoI really would love to have the time and energy to replicate that. That guys work is pretty nuts
- instagraham 2y agobased on his other videos, either he's actually a Chinese missile scientist or you can pretty much make an entire rocket fleet in your farm in modern China
- mlindner 2y agoPatriots use solid fuel. Additionally nothing on a Patriot missile used 3D printing. There is no benefit for 3D printing.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoI hope this doesn't lead to an exponential increase in space debris.
- 1024core 2y ago[dead]
- 29athrowaway 2y agoIf SpaceX could produce a rocket every 72 hours it would be a concern too. Also, best of luck in your quest of fighting imaginary villians. By conflating unrelated things and jumping to conclusions such as that you are not acting as a good ambassador for your country.
- nordsieck 2y ago> If SpaceX could produce a rocket every 72 hours it would be a concern too. Just FYI, SpaceX is trying to launch a Falcon 9 about every 48 hours this year. So far they seem pretty responsible about things, though.
- MobiusHorizons 2y agoI don’t hear anyone disparaging the ability of Indian companies to build great rockets. ISRO has done some really great work, and deserves lots of credit. But this startup seems to be bragging about making some pretty basic mistakes, like claiming not to need QA without having actually done anything to solve that problem (they didn’t build the 3d printer). So they seem to be doing the same kind of non-serious stuff we see from other vc backed startups all over the world which deserves skepticism.
- agent13 2y agoWow. Talk about getting triggered.
- 1024core 2y ago
- nedpat 2y agoTest
- panick21_ 2y ago3D printing is the conventional way of designing rocket engines today. Literally every new rocket startup does it a lot. Its more unconventional how much isn't 3D printed on the SpaceX Raptor.
- imtringued 2y agoNow do it again, but this time build a fully automated rocket factory on the moon.
- paulsutter 2y agoIf you take a look at a real rocket engine you will see hundreds of parts that cannot be printed Raptor 1, 2, and 3: https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2023/07/spacex-further-improves-the-raptor-3-engine.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2023/07/spacex-further-improve...
- mlindner 2y agoFor very simple pressure fed engines (which this appears to be) it's actually cheapest to additively manufacture (3D print) engines as you can integrate the cooling channels. On engines like Raptor you have pumps, which notably need to move so while you still use 3D printing (Raptor uses a ton) you can't print it in a single piece. 3D printing is already an industry standard and nothing this company did with relation to its engine manufacturing is anything special. They also appear to have lied that no post-manufacturing qualification is required.
- Narhem 2y agoNot surprised hellers have been doing it for centuries for pennies
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mlindner 2y agoThis company has been pushing a lot of press about this but it's really not anything special. The industry has been printing engines for many years and the time to print is dependent on the size (and to some extent the mass) of the engine and the speed of the printer. Take this with a grain of salt.
- pierpaolot 2y ago[dead]
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoIt sounds like they're not doing QC/QA, which would be unwise and maybe isn't necessarily true. While 3D printing allows printing shapes that cannot be forged or cast, testing is always needed as part of the manufacturing process feedback loop. X-ray and dye penetration nondestructive testing check for abnormalities on accessible services, but destructive testing is needed sawing samples into slices to also check them for hidden defects.
- newswasboring 2y agoI've seen less skepticism on cryptocoin threads on HN. The absolute racism in this thread is disgusting.
- 93po 2y agoi wish there was more than a single photo, and maybe some cross sections or something. didn't see any with a quick google
- downrightmike 2y agoI approve this for all billionaire flights in the future
- booleandilemma 2y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
- rldjbpin 2y agoregardless of the veracity, i wonder about the space debris implications of making rocketry accessible going forward. we got regulations, but can they be enforced well enough?
- Netherlord 2y ago[dead]
- yakshaving_jgt 2y agoI had no idea so many Hacker News commenters were rocket scientists.
- joenot443 2y agoWe have nuclear physicists, CRISPR researchers, philosophy PhDs and specialized physicians posting here all the time. Is there something about the topic of rocketry that you expected would keep it away from HN?
- weavermarquez 2y agoTotal random comment, but for posterity's sake -- apparently, Agnikul is organized using a free and open source ERP called ERPNext. There's not been much discussion on it, but I'm doing my best to get my foot in the door using ERPNext and Frappe Framework (what it's built on) in North America.
- shash 2y agoThese guys are friends... We share investors, I've visited them at their test site, and they're neighbours at IIT Madras Research Park (where their rocket factory is). Their engines are a pleasure to hold and see in real life... Couple of points that are missed in the article: 1. 3D printing is a way of bringing down assembly costs - the geometry they print is quite intricate, and it allows much better performance. The disadvantage is that it wouldn't survive multiple launches, but these are meant to be single-use rockets anyway so it doesn't matter. This is a way to build a semi-cryo engine relatively cheap. 2. They are doing it _really_ conservative; three attempted launches of which two were cancelled in the last two minutes (the fourth succeeded). But they always err on the side of caution. It's impressive enough that they're able to cancel so close to launch without losing the vehicle. 3. Here's the launch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGWruZR4rSg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGWruZR4rSg