19 ms·
Signal: Will leave the EU market rather than undermine our privacy guarantees
- sed3 2y ago> Either you agree to have your chats scanned or you can no longer share&receive pictures/videos and links!
- mmmmmbop 2y agoOh no! - How will I be able to buy crypto in my messenger if Signal leaves the EU?
- jksflkjl3jk3 2y agoTelegram is far more heavily used in crypto circles in my experience.
- mmmmmbop 2y agoSignal introduced its MobileCoin integration in 2021. It was completely pre-mined, with the majority of coins distributed to its founders and investors. Moxie sold out his reputation with that disingenuous cash grab. Now, three years later, Telegram is following in Signal's footsteps with another shitty crypto integration. I don't know the details of that one, but I wouldn't be surprised to learn that its another cash grab.
- geekpowa 2y agoMobilecoin doesn’t use mining Their stated design goal was to create an actual usable payments system; not a speculative asset . Edit : Urrgh got that wrong . Fixed distribution of coins and yes the founders control most of them
- fauigerzigerk 2y agoThe problem is that it's still a taxable asset and therefore gives the authorities a legitimate reason to look into people's Signal data. Any privacy protections for speech are unlikely to apply to financial transactions anywhere in the world. This is a disastrous mistake.
- EGreg 2y ago[flagged]
- ldehaan 2y ago[dead]
- _Microft 2y agoAnd we still can’t backup our chats on iOS [0]. Does that mean that we might lose the history of all our messages? Signal developers really seem to have some misconceptions about the priorities of their users… [0] It‘s not a limitation of iOS itself but that Signal doesn‘t want to allow to store data and keys in a way that would ‚leak’ them to Apple - not even if I, the user, wouldn’t mind that.
- MattGaiser 2y agoSignal is primarily used by people sensitive to privacy concerns, so I’m not sure they are misconceptions. Signal without the privacy obsession has no reason to exist. If you don’t value privacy, it is just a niche, hard to use messenger.
- cess11 2y agoWhat do you mean, "hard to use"?
- Hackbraten 2y agoI daily drive a Linux phone. I use Signal because there is no iMessage or WhatsApp client for Linux that works for me.
- p4bl0 2y agoHow is it "hard to use"? It's really as simple as WhatsApp or Telegram.
- MattGaiser 2y agoNo web interface and constant need to link to other devices.
- p4bl0 2y agoThere is a desktop application that works really well you only need to link it once. Exactly like the WhatsApp web app.
- elchief 2y agoIs this Europe's plan? Pseudo tarrifs via regulation to boost local industry?
- dimensi0nal 2y agoNah, the people who force you to put your home address on your blog just care about individual privacy and consumer rights.
- KingOfCoders 2y agoIs there an alternative? (I currently only use Signal). Also something where features work? Since this week my Signal "Something went wrong with you username, it no longer is connected to you. You can try to get a new one"
- kisamoto 2y agoThreema? https://threema.ch/en https://threema.ch/en
- egberts1 2y agoDespite Swiss "neutrality", it is also a member or E.U. and must comply with GDPR (and thusly the new EU rules) EDIT: Switzerland is not a member of E.U.
- trustno2 2y agowhat switzerland is NOT in EU
- egberts1 2y agoWell, I goofed. Nonetheless, Threema is claiming GDPR-complaince: Excerpt from their main web page: Threema is 100% Swiss Made, hosts its own servers in Switzerland*, and, unlike US services (which are subject to the CLOUD Act, for example), it is fully GDPR-compliant.
- anonzzzies 2y agoYes, everyone wanting to serve clients in the eu (even if they are on vacation in non eu) must comply with the gdpr; this article however is not related to the gdpr though.
- jurip 2y agoGDPR is about not storing information about people without their consent and has nothing to do with the encryption legislation.
- augunrik 2y agoJust let Signal operate via Satellites and you are fine: https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weltraumtheorie https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weltraumtheorie
- EGreg 2y agoNo, you’re not fine. They can ban that as well. The only way anything can continue working in practice is if it’s decentralized, and served by different websites secured bu https rather than one app in one app store. Hard to take them all down. Perhaps Moxie Marlinspike now better appreciates decentralization behind messengers. I have written here years ago as a response to him exactly this scenario: https://community.intercoin.app/t/web3-moxie-signal-telegram-and-why-decentralization-matters/2230 https://community.intercoin.app/t/web3-moxie-signal-telegram... The thing with https of course is that the governments can insist that browsers include their backdoored certificates. But the browsers are large enough that it’s difficult to get them to do it. China’s Great Firewall probably can. But in order for that to happen they have to prevent packets encrypted with the non-backdoored certificate chain from being routed. That requires serious control over all the networks. This is partly why I started Qbix. So people can host whatever they want on computers of their choice. Without this decentralization, the governments are two steps away from mandating ALL your voice conversations are scanned, transcribed and analyzed by AI at the edge. Microsoft Recall + message and voice scanning = 1 step away from total panopticon of everyone everywhere. And with superintelligent AIs doing precrime based on everyone’s conversations!
- hellojesus 2y agoIf CAs start to get backdoored, people can operate a la web of trust or other asymmetric protocol where the public key is posted on a public board and the server can verify its ownership of the private key without a third party other than the public notice. More work but should be doable.
- EGreg 2y agoThey won’t be able to operate that over public networks in China, because the routers will drop their packets. You’d need to roll your own mesh network — definitely doable in local areas but the question is how to connect them over wider distances without going through the Great Firewall. Satellites?
- ggm 2y agoGood. Stick to your position. No irony or sarcasm, there is only one reason to use signal and these rules undermine it's integrity and purpose.
- newaccount74 2y agoI don't agree with this. Encryption is a feature of Signal, but it's not the only reason to use it. The bigger reason to use it is that it is independent from Meta, so you can use it without having Facebook track you. I don't rely on Signals encryption, since there is no way to verify that it works in the way that it does, and even if, there is no way to know that the recipients are as careful as you are. If there is something I don't want others to find out, I just don't write it down. No encryption is fool proof.
- adastra22 2y agoIf you just want to be independent of Meta, send an SMS. They’re free and built into every phone. Signal is about privacy.
- DrSiemer 2y agoSMS is far less convenient and lacks many important features, like groups, emojis, speed and presentation. Independence from known data harvesters is the only reason I got pretty much all of my contacts to switch.
- somenameforme 2y agoThat Tweet links to this [1] description which, in glancing at the text, seems to indeed be accurate: ---- According to the latest draft regulation dated 28 May (Council document 9093/24), which is presented as “upload moderation”, users of apps and services with chat functions are to be asked whether they accept the indiscriminate and error-prone scanning and possibly reporting of their privately shared images, photos and videos. Previously unknown images and videos are also to be scrutinised using “artificial intelligence” technology. If a user refuses the scanning, they would be blocked from sending or receiving images, photos, videos and links (Article 10). End-to-end encrypted services such as Whatsapp or Signal would have to implement the automated searches “prior to transmission” of a message (so-called client-side scanning, Article 10a). The initially proposed scanning of text messages for indications of grooming, which is hardly being used to date, is to be scrapped, as is the scanning of voice communication, which has never been done before. Probably as a concession to France, the chats of employees of security authorities and the military are also to be exempted from chat control. ---- Strange times we live in. Entertaining, but strange. [1] - https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/majority-for-chat-control-possible-users-who-refuse-scanning-to-be-prevented-from-sharing-photos-and-links/ https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/majority-for-chat-control-p...
- heroprotagonist 2y agoSeriously, who are they expecting to pay for that? AI vision detection run against _every image every person sends to anyone_, among other things, will get ridiculously expensive. Half of the reason Microsoft is pushing "AI PCs" with special hardware is so they can push their spying to on-device and reduce all the extra costs the data processing they're imagining for things like automatic-screenshot-analysis-every-x-seconds will need. And they're pretty much experts on spying on users. They've been collecting so much data for so long that apparently they've found a way to utilize what they collect in a way that makes the costs balance out in the end. Whether thats with government access, preferential antitrust treatment, or some actual financial method that directly affects the bottom line, I don't know. Somehow it's worthwhile for them. BUT -- when even Microsoft is looking for more efficient ways to spy on people, and forcing new hardware to support that effort, you know the data collection and analysis technique is definitely not ready to be made a legal mandate. It doesn't make sense at all for some EU decision makers to decide it's acceptable for their citizens to bear the cost of so much data processing. ....wait, how much do large players in AI contribute to these politicians campaigns? Or if not them, who is really pushing this? It seems like someone should really try following the money on this one.
- isodev 2y agoThe EU elections are just around the corner. It's a good moment to make an informed decision and stop electing alt-rights who'd do anything under the slogan of "protecting the children".
- t0bia_s 2y agoWe should seriously ask, if being part of EU is beneficial or not. Electing left or right is just a game to keep system working. But it serves to scrap responsibility from us and lead to slavery with every new regulation.
- weikju 2y agoLeaving the EU hasn’t really been helping the UK either
- t0bia_s 2y agoSure, voting system remains same.
- personomas 2y agoIt hasn't really been hurting them either. By the way, UK had GDP growth by .6% in first quarter of this year, which is a lot more than a lot of other EU countries.
- mike_hearn 2y agoPresumably Signal will remain available in the UK. At least, it could.
- spockz 2y agoYes, at this point I see no way forward except with the EU. Unless each individual country wants to go at it alone and eventually end up working as a Vasal state to either USA, Russia, or China. The cost of products and manufacturing is so low that a significant part of the final price is made up of overhead costs such as tax, tariffs, and transport. All of these will go up by stepping out of the EU due to increased friction. If anything, we should go a lot further into embracing the EU. In the current political landscape we are committed.
- EGreg 2y agoFirst they came for crypto, and you guys laughed and cheered them on because “crypto and web3 sucks” I told you then, that end-to-end encryption is far more worrying for politicians, than mere cryptographic signatures. And that they’ll be coming for it next. Because it can hide billion-dollar transfers, or CSAM, or gasp seditious material against the king. Well, it’s not just Europe, it’s all over the world: https://community.qbix.com/t/the-global-war-on-end-to-end-encryption/214 https://community.qbix.com/t/the-global-war-on-end-to-end-en... The above chronicles many cases even in your own country! Today regular people are just as clueless about end-to-end encryption as many on HN are about web3 and decentralized network innovations. Think of the children! And then they will come for the regular person, and by then there will be no one left making tools that could have helped them. As for me and my views, I have come to believe that end-to-end encryption vs state actors is a band-aid, that if you are reduced to sneaking around then your government and agencies need fixing. Whereas digital signatures and smart contracts and decentralized networks are useful as they allow everyone to be in control of their own identity, voting, balances etc. without relying on a third party. It’s done in the open. But the difference is that it can be limited to “benign” things and enforces the rules, while everyone gets to make their own decisions and one party can’t corrupt the system. To me, the transparency and resilience to corruption is the main thing. The sneaking around, I can see how governments can declare war on that.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> First they came for crypto, and you guys laughed Crypto has probably done more to undermine privacy than Hoover’s FBI. Its proponents are ambitiously unlikeable, relishing their distastefulness to burnish outsider credentials. Its damage is easy to quantify in a way troublesome speech is not. And because a broad set of the population either doesn’t like it or, much more prominently, doesn’t care, it serves as a stalking horse for advancing general anti-privacy laws. Signal is a great example. They should be a unifier for the notoriously-apathetic privacy crowd. But it isn’t. In part due to its crypto crossover. I genuinely can’t seriously take Signal as a canary of anything, because it’s unclear what motivates its leadership.
- EGreg 2y ago
- j-pb 2y agoHeck. I'd leave the EU too if this passes. No clue where to go though.
- philippta 2y agoSwitzerland
- stakhanov 2y agoBecause Switzerland is so immigration-friendly?
- popcalc 2y agoIf you have the means, yes.
- _zoltan_ 2y agoyou don't have to have any means, just a job, albeit your employer must prove that they couldn't fulfill the job within Switzerland (and within the EU, if you're from outside the EU)
- popcalc 2y agoMagyar?
- johnisgood 2y agoBased on username, probably.
- _zoltan_ 2y agoyes, I'm Hungarian.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoIf you are an EU citizen you have free movement rights to move to Switzerland.
- g15jv2dp 2y agoI am very skeptical about this statement.
- t0bia_s 2y agoCentralised service is weaker against surveillance than decentralised solutions. Signal should adopt selfhosting and federation.
- slt2021 2y agojabber/xmpp is open standard and supports e2e encryption and can be self-hosted, has mobile clients
- rocqua 2y agoHow does it support e2e?
- rakel_rakel 2y agoBy clients having support and/or plugins for things like OMEMO and OTR.
- Hoodedcrow 2y agoI use XMPP with OMEMO for my main encrypted messaging, and I don't get why Matrix got popular instead of XMPP (aside from a big marketing budget). Even a lighter server implementation takes up several times more resources than an XMPP server, plus the concerns about the enormous central instance. XMPP FTW.
- zx8080 2y agoLast time I checked (2018) the support for media&file sharing was in a quite bad shape in all available Android clients. Even without e2e encryption enabled. Is it good now?
- Hoodedcrow 2y agoFor Android - Conversations is in a very good shape now.
- 2y ago
- croemer 2y agoOriginal reporting: https://www.euractiv.com/section/law-enforcement/news/audio-communications-excluded-in-latest-draft-of-child-sexual-abuse-material-law/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/law-enforcement/news/audio-...
- egberts1 2y agoSo cannot wait for GNUtella (and its floating peer-to-peer cloud concept) to come back but retrofitted with Signal protocol.
- omeid2 2y agoThe problem with GNU and Gnome is, to put it in the words of Steve jobs about Microsoft, "lack taste". They are too distant from the mainstream to cater to them. postnote: this comment was Authored on Firefox under Wayland running on Linux 6.
- doublepg23 2y agoI don’t think Gnutella is related to the GNU Project or GNOME in any way. It was initially going to be GPLd but I don’t think that came to pass. As far as the mainstream I believe Gnutella, the protocol, had massive success with the LimeWire client.
- egberts1 2y agoGtk-GNUtella is a GPL license. https://gtk-gnutella.sourceforge.io/#:~:text=gtk%2Dgnutella%20is%20free%20open,it%20run%20unattended%20for%20days https://gtk-gnutella.sourceforge.io/#:~:text=gtk%2Dgnutella%....
- neop1x 2y ago>> words of Steve jobs about Microsoft, "lack taste". They are too distant from the mainstream to cater to them. Yeah, that's why Windows has been by far the most used OS by the mainstream
- omeid2 2y ago2015 called and want their stats back. https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share#monthly-200901-202401 https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share#monthly-200901-20...
- arlcode 2y ago
- egberts1 2y agoAll you have to do to circumvent this new pending EU rule is to apply muLaw encoding of your data stream into the audio file, or something. Terrible Shannon's Limit although.
- anonzzzies 2y agoSeems they will reconsider this after the elections. So there is time, depressing as it is. As has been said here before : every country will eat away at privacy every few years with similar proposals that failed a few years before. Until they succeed.
- hcfman 2y agoLooks like we are going to have to move to two phone solutions. The second phone will be very basic with open source hardware and self installed open source software, simple enough that you could build it yourself if you wanted. Its sole purpose will be secure communications and it would just use your phone as the communications medium.
- ornornor 2y agoIt’s already a difficult to convince people to use signal instead of WhatsApp, FB messenger, iMessage, etc… if it requires a new phone with sideloaded software etc, I won’t have many people to text anymore.
- Hoodedcrow 2y agoI just gave up on smartphones altogether. It is much easier to make a laptop/desktop private instead and limit your private messaging and activities to it.
- jenadine 2y agoBut that doesn't fit in a pocket.
- effie 2y agoKeeping stuff in pockets is overrated. There are ridiculously small portable laptops though. https://www.gpd.hk/gpdmicropc https://www.gpd.hk/gpdmicropc
- karma_pharmer 2y agoThis Is The Way. Bonus: you get a real keyboard.
- lakomen 2y agoHowever 2FA. They're making it hard to not have a phone
- 2y ago
- wojciechpolak 2y agoIf such a law is introduced, will it still be possible to download the application from the website and use iOS sideloading as an alternative scenario? (I'm not talking about the convenience or ease of such a solution)
- SheinhardtWigCo 2y agoNo because Apple still has to “notarize” the app before it can be sideloaded
- wojciechpolak 2y agoSo there is no way to overcome this by installing an unapproved app (unverified, unsigned, etc.)?
- popcalc 2y agoYou could just change your App Store region to any country outside the EU. For example all you need to change to US is an American phone number and credit card.
- grishka 2y agoYou don't even need a credit card if you don't plan to pay for things. I changed my Apple ID country to US with just a fake address.
- immibis 2y agoExcept you can only sideload in the EU.
- fingerlocks 2y agoFor free. Side loading costs 8 bucks a month in the US but you can self-sign the binaries.
- grishka 2y ago
- Thorentis 2y agoThis is why Signal needs to decentralise. There is no such thing as "leaving the EU market" if it can obtained from anywhere on the internet. The EU has shot itself in the foot with demanding alternate app store exist, and then Signal has shot itself in the foot by not being open enough to be distributed on any app store by anybody. The answer to these encryption laws, is to use their other laws against them. You want the iPhone to be an open platform? Great, here's a bunch of open platform chat apps that cannot be banned because they are decentralised. Perhaps Matrix will be the future after all?
- goodpoint 2y ago> This is why Signal needs to decentralise They have been building a walled garden for a decade. They talk about "market": they want to make Signal profitable.
- lambdaxyzw 2y agoRight now they live off donations (including mine) and I won't donate if they commercialize. Also, there's no easy way to monetize on users without ads, and I'm pretty sure signal users are one of the last demographics to fall for "privacy preserving ads".
- poisonborz 2y agoMoxie's stance is that "people won't self-host": https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html Which I find very naive and destructive, but that's how it is.
- hcfman 2y ago[flagged]
- elefanten 2y ago[flagged]
- protomolecule 2y ago[flagged]
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 2y agoYeah, only pootin is allowed to wage war, all the rest should put their efforts into peace by surrendering to him.
- protomolecule 2y ago[flagged]
- effie 2y agoThose are incomparable. One is a political influence via civilized methods, money and propaganda. The other is a brutal military aggression. The proper acceptable course of action for Putin & Co. was to compete economically and propagandistically, not invade with soldiers. They tried before with Yanukovich, but in 2014 these russian collaborators lost grip on power, and Putin & Co., instead of folding up graciously, or trying with another helper later again, went insane and tried to force their interests with military methods. That is an escalation that has no moral justification.
- protomolecule 2y agoOverthrowing a democratically elected government in a foreign country is hardly a civilized method. And yes, Putin was competing economically and propagandistically, but when he won and Yanukovich declined to sign a bad [0] agreement, the US, instead of "folding up graciously" like the EU did, said "Fuck the EU" [1] and went ahead with the escalation and supporting the 'revolution'. "has no moral justification" Of course, only Western escalations are always morally justified. [0] http://europe.newsweek.com/german-official-says-it-was-wrong-make-ukraine-pick-between-eu-and-russia-251038?rm=eu http://europe.newsweek.com/german-official-says-it-was-wrong... [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-26079957 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-26079957
- k1t 2y agoIs this the same Signal that threatened to "absolutely, 100% walk" away from UK if the Online Safety Act "undermined" their privacy? So I guess it didn't, and they'll find a reason why this won't either. All meaningless talk.
- MadnessASAP 2y agoMy understanding is that the UK removed clauses that would undermine Signals security. Regardless of which, Signals didn't, and was never going to make concessions to the UK that would compromise it's users privacy. Their strategy then as it seems to be now, is to do nothing but say they disagree and wait for the regulators to forcibly remove them from the market. That is if they did themselves non-compliant with a countries laws, they'll do nothing and wait to be evicted rather then comply or voluntarily leave.
- cuu508 2y agoYep, that's the strategy now too https://mastodon.world/@Mer__edith/112535637912550792 https://mastodon.world/@Mer__edith/112535637912550792
- fauigerzigerk 2y ago>My understanding is that the UK removed clauses that would undermine Signals security. My understanding is that the law empowers the regulator (Ofcom) to require the use of accredited scanning technology if they consider it necessary and proportionate. No further changes to the law are necessary for that to happen. But as of now, no such accredited technology exists. It seems likely that any client-side scanning technology that the EU mandates would also get accreditation in the UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/end-to-end-encryption-and-child-safety/end-to-end-encryption-and-child-safety https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/end-to-end-encryp...
- dfawcus 2y agoNothing changed in the UK Online Safety Bill before it became an Act, the troublesome clauses are still there. All that happened is the government accepted that it was not currently practical to implement what they desired. So 'promised' not to require any providers to do so yet. If they deem it practical one can expect them to instruct providers. Hence Apple and Signal both ignored their prior statements, and continue to provide their respective encrypted message and speech services.
- freddealmeida 2y agoSomehow however the NSA was reading Signal chats...
- effie 2y agoSource?
- gbnvc 2y ago[flagged]
- xandrius 2y agoGive evidence instead of just random opinions masked as facts.
- mikhael28 2y agoHow do they even make money? No ads, no subscriptions - what ‘market’?
- froddd 2y ago> users of apps and services with chat functions are to be asked whether they accept the indiscriminate and error-prone scanning and possibly reporting of their privately shared images, photos and videos I take it this should apply to any web comments and messaging platform, and therefore require that all websites and web services comply if they can be accessed within the EU? I’m not sure how that’s even remotely doable.
- beefnugs 2y agoWhat do you mean? There are thousands more pixels in the timeline that can filled with POPUPS telling you how to think and how to CONSENT and how to OBEY
- _ink_ 2y agoGood. Meta should do the same.
- Klaus23 2y agoSo far, the law doesn't have a majority. Even if they manage to push it through the Commission and Parliament, it's very unlikely to survive contact with the European Court of Justice.
- RedShift1 2y agoWe shouldn't count on that though.
- vaylian 2y agoand the court of justice typically takes a looooong time to come to a conclusion
- knallfrosch 2y agoPlus the court can simply be ignored when it comes to data protection. See: - Safe Harbour - Privacy Shield - Data Privacy Framework
- MyFedora 2y agoIn case you didn't know, the court retroactively voided these agreements. EU-US data transfers have been illegal for around 25 years or so thanks to that. People can sue you and win, even though the data protection authorities don't do much.
- effie 2y agoWait, so the data transfers still happen, disrespecting the court decision?
- h4ckerle 2y agoYes. The court voided privacy shield in a ruling known as Schrems-II. The commission then created the Data Privacy Framework which is esentially the same as privacy shield against the will of the parliament, re-enabling transatlantic data transfer.
- lencastre 2y agoSMS 2FA should end like backup recovery email. One is not safe, the other is a loop hole. If breaking encryption is too expensive, then either use the hammer approach, or compromise one of the terminals (or both). Computation will get so cheap and so good, that unless cryptography evolves pari pasu real freedom will be affected.
- yard2010 2y agoYes please. Then leave the rest of the world. Too bad Merkel is not in charge anymore. She would make herring from such bullies
- ahodgkinson 2y agoSee the following. It seems more EU procurement lobbying and corruption, using child pornography as the dog whistle to garner public support. https://www.europeanpressprize.com/article/the-eu-fight-against-child-pornography-stokes-fears-ofwidespread-online-surveillance-2/ https://www.europeanpressprize.com/article/the-eu-fight-agai...
- bambax 2y agoI absolutely support Signal's position and abhorre the whole security circus with cries of "think of the children". But, I'm in Europe (France) and I wonder who actually uses Signal? There was a move a couple of years ago to quit WhatsApp and go to Signal. Some groups did make the move, and then everyone went back. Today I have dozens of WhatsApp groups, and just one Signal group (and it's dying). If no one uses Signal in Europe then obviously this threat is moot.
- rsolva 2y agoThe network effect js real, but I have managed to move some groups to Signal. But you need to spend some social capital convincing people to make the move.
- swores 2y agoSame here, have got a bunch of family groups and a few friends on Signal now, but lots still on more popular apps like WhatsApp.
- Ylpertnodi 2y agoNo signal = no comms for me. I refuse to use whatsapp and i have probably missed out on a lot, but oh well. I had neither 20 years ago and i survived ok - people called me, or i called them. I do see the contradiction, as i know calls are recorded but er...I've nothing to hide.
- rsolva 2y agoSignal has some advantages over WhatsApp, namely that you can install the app on more devices (including computers) at the same time, which has been a convincing argument for some of my friends. They hate how WhatsApp is locked to your phone without an app for your computer. Signal has become the default video conferencing app for several of my larger groups, and it works surprisingly well! This is a trick WhatsApp currently can't do.
- croes 2y agoThey try to prevent people from sharing links? Oh no, I wish there was a way to obfuscate links //news .ycombinator .com/item?id=40551260
- vaylian 2y ago> They try to prevent people from sharing links? They try to surveil people. You can post all the links you want, but you can't be sure that they will only be seen by your intended recipient.
- croes 2y agoHave you read the article in the tweet in the tweet? >If a user refuses the scanning, they would be blocked from sending or receiving images, photos, videos and links
- vaylian 2y agoThanks. I missed the "links" in that list while I was wondering why "images" and "photos" are included together in that list.
- darkwater 2y agoNext week we have the European Parliament elections. Any tip on any "mainstream" party which is strongly against this? I know for sure the Pirate Party but they would never get a seat, at least in my country
- qludes 2y agoEPP is pushing for this, ALDE is probably mixed depending on the country. So if Greens/EFA and parties like Volt or pirates stand no chance you could still not vote EPP.
- mcjiggerlog 2y agoI can't find specific policy positions for Volt on encryption, but they're very positive about open source [1], so you'd imagine they'd have a pretty reasonable approach to encryption too. [1] https://volteuropa.org/policies/european-democracy-act/open-source-software https://volteuropa.org/policies/european-democracy-act/open-...
- vasco 2y agoVolt has way more political stances, so it's a less neutral choice. If you care most about internet freedom the ones to go for are the Pirates.
- tremon 2y agoIt's indirect, but in their policy programme (https://volteuropa.org/storage/pdf/eu-elections-2024/volt-eur-electoral-moonshot-program_v5-final-(1).pdf https://volteuropa.org/storage/pdf/eu-elections-2024/volt-eu..., page 45) they mention: Transform the Declaration on European Digital Rights and Principles for the Digital Decade into a binding legal instrument, so that the Declaration is upheld at every step of policy making. The Declaration that they mention is not from Volt, it's from the EU itself and can be found here: https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/library/european-declaration-digital-rights-and-principles https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/library/european-de... Privacy and individual control over data 17. Everyone has the right to privacy and to the protection of their personal data. The latter right includes the control by individuals on how their personal data are used and with whom they are shared. 18. Everyone has the right to the confidentiality of their communications and the information on their electronic devices, and not to be subjected to unlawful online surveillance, unlawful pervasive tracking or interception measures. Of course, given that this Declaration is signed by the same parties that are currently pushing the ChatControl measures being discussed doesn't fill me with much confidence.
- almazzz 2y ago[flagged]
- rdm_blackhole 2y agoWell, there is only one thing left to do. I am going to self host my own XMPP server and try to move my friends and family to it. Signal has been great but they won't be able to stop it. Or we could encrypt the messages before pasting them in the messaging app so the CSS will be neutered. Either way, I won't have the EU stasi look over my shoulder each time I send a message to a loved one.
- kara4151 2y ago[flagged]
- raspyberr 2y agoDon't implement the scanning for images, photos, videos, links. Just send the image as a base64 encoded text string. Decode when received.
- siilats 2y agoIt’s the easiest thing for intelligence agencies to scan all your messages. They just need to submit a few million fake “content id” hashes and automatically your phone will share the images that match. Nobody can tell if content id has is of a photo of a document or a photo of a person it’s just a 256byte hash. This is so easily abused. I bet the way it’s implemented it doesn’t have enough resolution to read text so one evil content id hash will match any photo of any document or screenshot you have taken. So essentially your WhatsApp client will send every screenshot of a text document to nsa.
- stavros 2y agoA few million fake "content id" hashes still gives them a 1/100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 chance that any one of those hashes will match. 256 bits are a lot, besides, what are they going to do? Sift through random vacation photos that happened to match this "ten jackpots in a row" chance?
- gorbypark 2y agoI think OP is saying that the algorithm is designed in such a way it can match “visually similar” photos/content. The idea is you can’t just rescale, crop or otherwise slightly change a photo as you could if this was just a regular SHA hash of the file. Now they are saying that it might be possible to create an “evil hash” of a document that could match a large percentage of documents, because the hash algorithm obviously doesn’t have enough bits to actually represent the content. So if you have a hash of “white document with some black text” (for example, if looking for image scans of documents) and add this to the db of “watched” hashes, you could in theory hoover up documents. A quick search didn’t lead me to any proof of concepts about this idea but on the surface (I don’t have any knowledge of the hashing algorithm used in these content filters) it seems like a plausible idea, depending on a lot of factors.
- stavros 2y agoI'm not sure that this would work, mainly because it would mean that all the documents would have the same hash, rendering the content ID system useless. I don't know how many bits a content I'd contains, though, but I imagine it's enough to avoid having too many collisions (as that would reduce the usefulness of the system).
- echoangle 2y agoHow is that going to be enforced in practice? Isn’t someone going to write a messenger PWA without client side scanning which everyone will be able to use? Are they going to block the domain?
- lakomen 2y agoThe EU is progressively turning into a Faschist dystopia. And this is coming from the not elected council, not the elected parliament. The EU in its very design is an autocracy, that wears the mask of democracy. And right now it's acting as the puppet of the USA, supporting its world domination plans.
- Ylpertnodi 2y agoWhich eu countries do you feel are the most detrimentally affected?
- lakomen 2y agoOh and just today I've banned yet another pedophilia fediverse instance with no easy way od reporting it the any authority. I'd have to give my name and address and potentially put me with 1 foot in jail because I have viewed the images and have them in my browser's cache. If they really wanted to protect children from sexual abuse, they would've created easy to report online services. But it's not and never was about pedophilia.
- amai 2y agoOk, then we all need to switch to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EncroChat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EncroChat Ohh, wait…
- rvz 2y agoBut we love the EU though? /s
- gangstalkvic 2y ago[flagged]
- gangstalkvic 2y ago[dead]
- gangstalkvic 2y ago[dead]
- akho 2y ago"We will run a secure messaging platform wherever governments protect security of messaging platforms." Very understandable, but not particularly interesting.
- bdlowery 2y agoThe EU is a joke. Regulating themselves into obscurity.
- figassis 2y agoWhat upsets me the most about this and similar trends (ie. Climate change, AI, etc) is that when crap hits the fan, the current proponents will: - tell you they couldn’t have know it would end this way - they really were right, except for this one unpredictable thing that broke their master plan - hide/pretend they were never pushing for this - ask for help - tell the rest to take a hike (the ones that managed to still benefit) And there is no way for people in the present, who see this coming to prevent it or to ensure proponents are help accountable on the future. You will end up with lawsuits that take 20 years, watered down verdicts, weasel politics, etc.
- michaelcampbell 2y ago> - ask for help cite? I somewhat kid, of course, but this generally seems the last, if ever, step forward considered.
- figassis 2y agoI don't mean asking for help fixing, I mean asking for help in getting away from consequences. Like a scientist unleashing a zombie apocalypse asking for a ride.
- michaelcampbell 2y agoOh, yes, that I totally have experienced!