10 ms·
I think the main reason people get nervous about "the public" roaming their land is the liability and the personal injury lawsuit industry in the USA. If I let
by SoftTalker 2y ago
I think the main reason people get nervous about "the public" roaming their land is the liability and the personal injury lawsuit industry in the USA. If I let someone cross my land and he trips on a tree root and breaks his leg, now I'm possibly facing a lawsuit.
Also, what are they allowed to do? Simply crossing the land is one thing. Around here many private landowners are dealing with homeless encampments that are not only a liability but a sanitary issue, as they tend to be full of litter, needles, food waste, and human waste and end up attracting vermin.
- oooyay 2y ago> I think the main reason people get nervous about "the public" roaming their land is the liability and the personal injury lawsuit industry in the USA This is somewhat a solved problem in the US, what you're describing is actually nefarious behavior by cities and counties. I'll give an anecdote and I'm sure someone will come tell me if I'm wrong :) In Texas we called these "public easements". Back then in order for the city or county to establish a public easement they had to establish that there was a reason, they had to indemnify the area and some buffer around it, and they were obligated to maintain the land that they created the easement on. Sounds simple, right? Not so much. Cities and counties would often short change the indemnification, leaving the land owner on the hook for things they shouldn't be on the hook for. Sometimes the city would also have vaguely phrased policies like, "all public easements must have sidewalks" and those sidewalks would often incur some amount of damage to the landscape. Think about, for instance, a sidewalk going from a road, through someones property, to what is a dirt trail through the woods. Doesn't really make sense - but the city has a policy it's obligated to abide by! I think in general cities and counties could benefit from some non-court oversight to these processes with the public that don't need to involve expensive things like lawyers and are frameworked to understand the perspective of both the public and people giving access. There should also be a zero tolerance policy for underindemnifying the easement. Since you mentioned homlessness - I now live in Portland. Here's the way I deal with it: If you camp on public land around my neighborhood I expect you to be a good neighbor. Clean up your trash, no feces or urination in public, no leering/jeering/being creepy etc... I've generally provided water, heating devices, medical aid, etc to people that need it - the same way a good neighbor would. Some amount of people don't care about those boundaries though and will violate every single basic human expectation you can have. City code enforcement is generally not setup to handle disputes like this and neither are the police so it puts the public in really weird spots. I don't know how to solve that, but those folks aren't using easement rights. They're using public camping rights, which are entirely different and have more to do with camping on BLM and forestry land.
- ledauphin 2y agoI'm interested to read more about the "personal property liability" thing in the US. I have never heard anyone explain why your example would expose you to liability. There are other things I can imagine, like unfenced swimming pools or open sinkholes that you knew about, but tree roots and general features of the land? Maybe there's a long history of case law about this.
- dboreham 2y agoFUD
- devmor 2y agoI am not a legal scholar, but anecdotally a common theme in US law is that if you don't make obvious attempts to stop someone from doing something with your property (be it land, objects or intellectual property) then you are tacitly approving it. The most well known example is probably Trademark Erosion. Given this theme, it's not hard to see how a judge could rule that if you allow a lot of people to traverse your land, you are inherently maintaining a passageway and are thus responsible for ensuring its safety.
- b112 2y agoIn Toronto Canada, the Eaton's center, which people walk through to get to other streets, closes once per year for this very reason.
- crazygringo 2y agoBasically just think of it as a continuum from things you're obviously responsible for (a child drowns in your pool because you didn't put up a fence), to things you're obviously not (somebody fell and broke a bone because they tripped over a tree root in your acres of backyard forest). That there's a big gray area in the middle, and that somebody can sue you if they're injured in that gray area, and even if they lose it's still expense and stress and a time suck for you.
- lambdaxyzw 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bpodgursky 2y agoIn the west it's more often that the public "roaming" their land is hunting for big game and trying to edge onto private land to find it. Hikers are inconvenienced but they aren't the norm.
- NeoTar 2y ago> Also, what are they allowed to do? If the law in England were to be similar to the one in Scotland (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_Outdoor_Access_Code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_Outdoor_Access_Code), then "access rights can be exercised for recreational purposes, some educational activities and certain commercial purposes, and for crossing over land and water." "Access rights do not extend to motorised activities... Access rights do not include the right to hunt, shoot or fish... Gathering items such as mushrooms or berries for commercial gain is not covered by access rights; but the customary picking of wild fungi and berries for personal consumption is not prohibited under the code." "Wild camping, defined as lightweight camping by small numbers of people staying no more than two or three nights in any one place, is permitted under the code. ... The code requires that campers leave no trace, and must take away all litter, remove all traces of the tent pitch and of any open fire, and not cause any pollution" So, homeless encampments are not permitted since these would not fall under this code.
- arethuza 2y agoSome areas in Scotland also have bye-laws stopping camping during the summer months to reduce potential environment impact: e.g. https://www.lochlomond-trossachs.org/things-to-do/camping/campingbyelaws/ https://www.lochlomond-trossachs.org/things-to-do/camping/ca... These are relatively small areas though.
- dahfizz 2y agoI mean, are homeless encampments ever permitted? Yet they show up and are very hard to get rid of. Its not a can of worms I would want opened if I owned property on the west coast, that is for sure.
- Pet_Ant 2y ago> "Access rights do not extend to motorised activities... This seems problematic as there are remote properties that are only accessible through long trails. Stuff like ice fishing spots where you might need to snowmobile a few kilometers. Same with ATVs for deep woods camping. Personally, I have a registered trail through land I own and have no problem with it. I hope people get it to enjoy since I don't get enough chances to. I can't even get to it myself without passing through a dozen different lots.
- balderdash 2y agoI’d also add litter, trampling of grass/shrubbery, illegal structures (e.g. deer stands/blinds), theft (picking flowers, berries, apples, vegetables), and idiots trying to pet or take pictures with livestock that weigh 20x what they do. These are all things my family deals with despite our farm being posted no trespassing the entire perimeter. I literally can not imagine how bad it would be if people felt legally entitled to be there + how hard it would be to get law enforcement involved (“I’m not poaching, I was just taking the scenic route…”)
- maxerickson 2y agoIn Michigan, agricultural land is treated as if it is posted, so you are trespassing if you go on it, no notice required. I would think that is not uncommon.
- Loughla 2y agoIn Illinois, Iowa, and Missouri, it has to be explicitly signed via actual signs, or purple paint (relatively recent laws allow this in rural areas). Alaska requires signs. Indiana requires signs. Those are the states I am familiar with. I believe the states that do not require notice are in the minority, but I'm not sure how to prove that.
- lambdaxyzw 2y ago>litter, trampling of grass/shrubbery Obviously illegal, in public places too, do no relation to the topic discussed. >theft Come on. Theft is obviously illegal everywhere. >idiots trying to pet or take pictures with livestock that weigh 20x what they do Good thing is that it anyone is hurt in this scenario it's the idiot. Why worry about it? >I literally can not imagine how bad it would be if people felt legally entitled to be there + how hard it would be to get law enforcement involved I used to do a lot of hiking (in Spain, France, and some other European mountain ranges). Many remote routes go nearby or through someone's fields or even properties (like through someone's backyard). There are many farm animals on the trails or just next to them. Fortunately nobody here cares and we are all more happy because of it
- duped 2y agoSeveral states have spiritually similar laws, like how all beaches in California are public and it's illegal for private land owners to cut off access to them. I don't think anyone has won a personal injury lawsuit against a land owner for tripping over a root, but land owners have been sued for breaking that law and trying to create effectively private beaches.
- SkyBelow 2y agoWould this be because the beach is deemed public, not private with a right to access it? To allow someone to sue a landowner on the beach would be confirming it is privately owned by the landowner, no?
- estebank 2y agoThey are sued for blocking pre-existing access. Everyone, including those doing the blocking, acknowledge that the beach is public, but by blocking access they are trying to avoid people actually using it so they can enjoy it as if it were private.
- SkyBelow 2y agoI was speaking to the idea as to why these people haven't receives lawsuits about the injuries occurring to people on the beach. It is because the beaches are public, which means that it isn't an equivalent comparison to land that is private but which people might be given some sort of right to roam on.
- duped 2y agoI'm not sure the specific details of ownership, but the gist is that in California, everyone has a right to access the beach. Private land owners aren't entitled to blocking access to the beaches, even across their property. This court case has been going on for years over this (1) and the only reason it hasn't been tossed out is the billionaire who owns the land keeps paying lawyers to appeal. (1) https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/martins-beach-lawsuit-can-proceed-judge-rules-19457579.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/martins-beach-la...
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> I think the main reason people get nervous about "the public" roaming their land is the liability and the personal injury lawsuit industry in the USA. I would be surprised if that were really the case. I'm sure people would say that is the reason but I rather doubt that is the real reason. People want their own kingdoms. (And private land ownership likely self-selects those people.)
- Loughla 2y agoI live in the US, and I have a "large" amount of property that is clearly marked for no-trespassing. The reason for this is the prior landowner was forced to sell when a trespasser drowned in the pond on the property and the landowner was sued, successfully, by their family. If there were clear laws regarding trespassers and liability, I would gladly take the no trespassing signs down. I don't care if someone wants to go swim or fish on the very nice pond we have, but I absolutely will not lose my house for someone I don't know.
- cratermoon 2y agoIn the US, at least for most states I'm aware of, the attractive nuisance doctrine applies. And almost anything can be considered an attractive nuisance. It just sucks for everyone because it means the public and property owners lose out.
- arethuza 2y agoFrom my reading, the attractive nuisance doctrine applies to children - who I would have thought would be the people least likely to pay attention to "No Trespassing" signs? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attractive_nuisance_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attractive_nuisance_doctrine
- s1artibartfast 2y agoThat doesn't negate the parent point, and it's not just about attractive nuisance, although childproofing 100 acres is a ridiculous task. There's also been successful suits from people who get injured after breaking and entering locked buildings
- aiisjustanif 2y agoThe article is about England not the US, where there are already different laws for this and land has not been seized because that would be crazy. Also you would already see many areas that people can roam that are private properties especially in the midlands.
- eurleif 2y agoIn Vermont, where activities like hunting and hiking are allowed on any land not explicitly posted to prohibit it, there is also a liability shield for property owners in the statutes: https://legislature.vermont.gov/statutes/section/12/203/05793 https://legislature.vermont.gov/statutes/section/12/203/0579...
- groby_b 2y ago> If I let someone cross my land and he trips on a tree root and breaks his leg, now I'm possibly facing a lawsuit. Don't worry, you're impacted by laws anyways. (My fave example is outdoor pools in LA, which by now require a fence. Never mind if there are never any children on the property, there might be at some point) > Simply crossing the land is one thing Yup. And it isn't just homeless encampments (which we could address, if we wanted to ever provide housing), it's also that a good chunk of people are, well, asocial assholes. See e.g. folks defacing public parks, destroying natural monuments for kicks, destroying vegetation to get their insta pic just right, etc. I don't have a good answer. People should be free to access public lands. There should be more public lands. But the consequences of that right often are destructive, and we don't seem inclined to fix that part.
- amarant 2y agoHere in Sweden you're allowed to cross any land that is not directly connected to a house(read someone's lawn) you may pick wild mushrooms and berries growing there, and you may raise a tent and spend 1 night. The rule for camping as I understand it is that after you've stayed your 1 night in one place, you have to move "out of sight" from that location before you strike camp again. You may not damage trees, cross fields where food is grown(as this would damage the crops) and you may not pick any planted fruits or berries. Landowners are not liable for any injuries you may incur while on their land. Unless(I think?) you're on their lawn, which you're only allowed to enter if you have permission from the home owner. There are probably a bunch of cornercases I'm unaware of, but that's the gist of it at least
- DoreenMichele 2y ago1. Right to roam (in the US) might might actually reduce homeless encampments. In my firsthand experience, people are generally more sympathetic and supportive if you are just passing through as a homeless person. They may give you a ride and/or a small amount of cash without you asking, but the US is actively hostile to pedestrians in most places and you have zero right to pitch a tent overnight anywhere. 2. If homelessness is something you dislike, the primary root cause of homelessness is lack of affordable housing. This is a nationwide problem, not peculiar to the West Coast. So if you don't like homeless encampments, try to find ways to foster the existence of more affordable housing generally. It's a win/win solution that helps the homeless without rewarding or encouraging bad behavior and gets "the homeless" out of "your" face (not intended as a personal attack). And has zero relationship whatsoever to this issue. None.
- gspencley 2y agoI approach this from a matter of principle. I don't recognize anyone's "right" to enjoy someone else's privately owned property or, stated more honestly, to infringe upon the property rights of others. My wife and I currently live in a medium sized city but we are not the type to enjoy city life at all and thus dream of buying a sizeable chunk of land for the both of us to enjoy and retire to. The biggest factor motivating us to want to make that "investment" is our ability to enjoy peace, quiet and solitude on our own property, knowing that there is not another human being within several acres of us. Our lives and property do not exist for the enjoyment of others. We are not your tools. Find somewhere else to loiter, wander, roam or whatever. Our property is private for a reason. We have no desire to encounter anyone else on it regardless of what they are up to.
- fifilura 2y agoAs a matter of principle, what gives you the right to own a part of the Earth? Who did you buy it from and who did they buy it from?
- prepend 2y agoSociety is just a set of mutually agreed to rules. There’s no natural law for language, currency, culture, etc. So saying property rights are bogus, but body autonomy rights are ok seems like an arbitrary line to draw that makes society worse. We need some civil method of organizing and managing scarce resources, I think.
- sakjur 2y agoProperty rights doesn’t have to be bogus for the right to roam to exist. Can you develop random land under the right to roam? No, that remain the exclusive right of the owner. Same goes for logging, farming, and depending on legislature a whole heap of other benefits to owning land. That doesn’t mean your country has to acknowledge a right to roam, it’s ultimately up to all legislatures to decide where to draw its lines. None of those lines are self-evident, though it doesn’t matter which rights the land owner cares to acknowledge, as that is the prerogative of the legislator.
- ben_w 2y ago> I think the main reason people get nervous about "the public" roaming their land is the liability and the personal injury lawsuit industry in the USA. If I let someone cross my land and he trips on a tree root and breaks his leg, now I'm possibly facing a lawsuit. I rather got the impression that it was rich people wanting privacy. As for lawsuits… I'm not sure how effective they are, but here in Berlin half the woods say "Privatgelände / Benutzung auf eigene Gefahr!" which means what you might guess without a translation.
- danaris 2y agoIt's entirely possible that the reason this type of lawsuit is still a real thing is because of rich people recognizing that it also gets them extra privacy. (At least in part.)
- codexb 2y agoI think the problem is that there doesn't appear to be any plan to manage the land usage. In the US, there is tons of public land, but there are giant federal and state departments that manage it, and there are entire books of rules for how that land can be used. The public land is a collectively owned asset that is managed for public benefit. Areas can be closed off, or require permits, or limited to a specific usage. The "right to roam" seems almost completely unregulated with no power to manager or limit this public asset. It's a right without any responsibility.
- aramova 2y ago> It's a right without any responsibility. How can you say something so controversial yet so brave?
- mauvehaus 2y agoThere's certainly a responsibility to follow other applicable laws. You aren't allowed to litter or murder your hiking buddy on private property even if you're allowed to be on it.
- codexb 2y agoI'm talking more about permitted usage. In the US, public land is public, but you can't just use it however you'd like. Things like, can you camp overnight? Can you camp anywhere or just in specific locations? Can you use a horse or a bike or an ATV? Are you allowed to have a firearm? Can you fish? Can you hunt? Can you do professional photography? Do you need to stay on trails. Can you access the area by boat? Can you use radio-controlled model aircraft or cars? Drones? In the US, the answers to all these questions are different depending on which piece of public land it is. Each is managed separately based on what is most important about the land and the people and wildlife around it. It's just not clear that nearly as much thought is being put into the management handling these competing priorities in this case. There's almost an expectation that each landowner will be able to manage it themselves, without having any authority to really enforce any of their management decisions.
- mauvehaus 2y agoI know if at least several states that have a recreational use law, the gist of which is generally along the lines of "if you aren't being charged money to access the property, you can't sue the landowner for anything that happens to you while you're lawfully recreating." Kentucky has a law of this type on the books, and it helps a lot with access to climbing at the Red River Gorge.
- kyleblarson 2y agoI live on a large property in a very rural mountain area in the US. My property abuts state land on 2 sides but we've never really had any issues with trespassers, likely because of the first sentence of SoftTalker's comment. Our area is one of the most popular mule deer hunting spots in the Northwest which seems like it could be problematic, but in my experience the hunters are extremely respectful of private property. It's also nice to be able to hunt mulies on my own property and not worry about errant bullets. It is a but unsettling in the last 2 weeks of October (regular rifle deer season) when the local grocery store literally fills the aisles with pallets of Busch Light and Fireball.
- INTPenis 2y agoYou're right, I don't think the US overall system is ready for a right to roam. I come to this conclusion sometimes, one simple example is that most US suburbs are not ready for public transport because of the distances between each home.
- chasd00 2y agoI have some land in SE Oklahoma the going rule that I’ve been told is if you cross an open gate leave it open and if you cross a closed gate close it behind you. However, I still make it a point to meet and shake hands with the owners of the land I cross. I live in Texas and, especially near the border with Mexico, you’re putting your life in danger trespassing on land, no matter how remote, without permission.
- techjamie 2y agoNot a lawyer, but an important part of why those lawsuits can happen is under the idea that you invited someone onto your property, therefore, you have a duty to ensure they're safe when they accept that invitation. Places open to anyone, like a restaurant or grocery store, have an implied invitation because they want everyone to come inside and spend money. So if someone jumps your fence and breaks their leg walking through your property, you didn't invite them there, you aren't intending your land to be open to the public, so the onus would theoretically be on the traveler to cover their own bills. They could sue anyway, sure. But they can do that right now without any legal changes anyway, it would just be under well established law and they likely wouldn't win.
- nick7376182 2y agoThe law could easily include a liability disclaimer. People just don't like other people, want their privacy, and want their "I got mine" land locked public lands.
- chaostheory 2y ago> Also, what are they allowed to do? In Vermont, where they have something similar to free roam laws, a lot of people are having issues with hunters roaming their property.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoPersonally I like to let my children roam on my land unattended. I would not be willing to do this if random strangers were allowed onto my land.
- nullc 2y agoLiability is a major reason but it's also a security concern. Is someone up to no good? Casing a location to plan a robbery/kidnapping/theft/vandalism/squatting/arson (or any of these in progress but not yet committed or committed but not provably by the tresspasser)? It's difficult to impossible to know because you can't just determine intent. But if their mere pretense in a location is prohibited that is easy to determine and prosecute. It's very important for security sake to be able to create bright lines that bad actors need to cross and which good parties are unlikely to cross accidentally so that response can have a high accuracy. People passing through may also litter, set fires, scare off wild life or travel to a space where they are allowed to hunt (and then kill wildlife that crosses properties lines, or inadvertently shoot bullets or arrows into space you're using). The need to immediately paint one party or the other as in the wrong in a dispute can make it hard to see that in many cases all parties have worthwhile concerns and that there aren't easy answers.