8 ms·
Swarming Proxima Centauri: Picospacecraft Swarms over Interstellar Distances
- PicassoCTs 3y agoFire it directly towards the sun, let it de accelerate with solar sail.
- davedx 3y ago> A swarm whose members are in known spatial positions relative to each other, having state-of-the-art microminiaturized clocks to keep synchrony, can utilize its entire population to communicate with Earth, periodically building up a single short but extremely bright contemporaneous laser pulse from all of them. Operational coherence means each probe sends the same data but adjusts its emission time according to its relative position, such that all pulses arrive simultaneously at the receiving arrays on Earth. This effectively multiplies the power from any one probe by the number N of probes in the swarm, providing orders of magnitude greater data return. This sounds unfeasible. They have no way to keep station from what I understand, the interstellar medium is relatively empty but there will still be some drift over the light years. Having all of these independent craft synchronize and overlay their signals precisely enough for it to be receivable on Earth seems implausible. Can you say hella attenuation? I'd like to see some numbers...
- uoaei 3y agoCan you say relativistic corrections hell? "Over lightyears" means it takes literally years for these things to coordinate moves with each other, to say nothing of post-launch coordination messages from Earth.
- mlyle 3y ago> "Over lightyears" means it takes literally years for these things to coordinate moves with each other The swarm ends up around 100,000km wide. Initial distances are longer, but never on the order of light years.
- maxrecursion 3y agoYeah, I think he missed the part where it discussed the swarm would have to be mostly autonomous since communicating back to earth for any sort of management commands is completely out of the question. It's amazing they can still do it with voyager which is roughly 24 hours for one way traffic, 48 for round trip.
- uoaei 3y agoI'm not sure "swarm over interstellar distances" makes any sense here, then. How many stars are within 100,000 km of each other and what percentage of stars does that represent?
- mlyle 3y agoThe idea is, you launch a large number of probes, accelerated one by one, working so that they'll arrive at the same time to the same star (Proxima Centauri). If you lose a bunch, no problem. They'll be spread out over a big distance, but team up to do imaging and to return data from that star.
- SideburnsOfDoom 2y ago> They'll be spread out over a big distance Compared to the distance that you'd go to get a coffee, yes. Compared to the distance to Proxima Centauri, oh hell no. Compared to that distance, they travel as a pack. There's about a "402 million to 1" ratio between the two distances, 100 000km size of the swarm vs the 40,208,000,000,000 km distance to Proxima Centauri. https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/cosmic/nearest_star_info.html https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/cosmic/nearest_star_i... A swarm 100 000km wide could in its entirety pass between the Earth and the Moon with room to spare. https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/180561main_ETM.Distance.Moon_.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/180561main_E...
- mlyle 2y agoYes, of course. We all know these numbers. I teach a space engineering class where students chirp out in recitation "400km to LEO, 40,000 km to GEO, 400,000 km to the moon". The degree of "well acktually" trying to be pedantic here is unnecessary. If a swarm of bees goes a couple of miles away, they don't spread out over a couple of mile distance. They are a relatively tight pack that then goes to the new place and then converges to be quite small. That's the same as what this mission is. 100,000 km is quite small as far as interstellar distances are concerned, but quite big as far as an aperture for distributed imaging or beamforming (and for avoiding hazards that are hard to see beforehand). The latter, of course, is what actually matters.
- mlyle 3y agoThey don't need to keep exact position; they just need to know their relative distance offsets from Earth to synchronize pulses. They can do some work to keep station; the idea is that by adjusting attitude, they can adjust the magnitude and direction of their drag vector. https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07061 https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07061 It's absolutely infeasible with current technology, but it doesn't look like it's total unobtanium.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nynx 3y agostation keeping is definitely possible. each craft could use its comms laser for impulse
- qnleigh 3y agoI agree. Sounds like the plan is to have the signals from each probe add up coherently, which means the laser pulses need to be coherent with each other. The wavelength of optical light is 100s of nanometers, so that is the level of precision required spatially, relative to the much much larger probe spacing that they quote. This (plus the required temporal coherence) is probably not possible without the probes actively locking their lasers to each other, but now each probe needs the optics to send and detect the optical signal from at least its nearest neighbors. I can't say if this is impossible given the weight restrictions, but it sounds rough.
- MR4D 3y agoSeems like this would be easy to test around the asteroid belt, and pretty much doable with today's technology.
- thegrim33 3y ago[flagged]
- isoprophlex 3y agoYou can at least flag the most egregious shit for deletion...
- TeMPOraL 3y agoAnd visit https://news.ycombinator.com/newest https://news.ycombinator.com/newest regularly, to vote on content you find interesting. It's community service. Which reminds me, I need to do that more often too.
- airstrike 3y agoMaybe if voting on newest earned karma (or some other points system), more people would be inclined to do it?
- superb_dev 3y agoThe problem is, things keep getting worse outside of your bubble
- lucianbr 3y agoI am aware of things outside of HN, as I do read other sites. But when I open this one, I hope for a certain kind of content. If it's the same as all the other sites, it becomes kind of pointless. So no, that's not "the problem". One problem I see, is that all places now get innundated with a great number of posts about the "problem du jour". Many times supported by opinions like yours "that's important!". It may well be, but specialization still has a role. Maybe for a short time I want to not think about the "things getting worse", you know?
- carrja99 3y agoIgnore the doomsayers, they purposefully want us to pause progress in the name of “everything is wrong.” It’s been that way for centuries. There’s always things “getting worse outside your bubble” but there’s also a lot going well. Never apologize for saying this is the kind of content you come to hacker news for, it is EXACTLY the content that should be here. People can go to Twitter or something if they want to doomscroll.
- golol 3y agoThis is what I want Starship to succeed for.
- tootie 3y agoI'm confused about these gram-scale devices that have so many capabilities in board. And is the laser terrestrial or deployed to space?
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- bwanab 3y agoIf we think we're being visited by aliens, then this suggests that this is the kind of thing we should be on the lookout for here.
- Jerrrrry 3y agoThere have been a couple candidates, so damning a lot of astronomers would rather not talk about it.
- EthanHeilman 3y agoI don't think we should expect alien mission architectures are likely to look like this in terms of mass or size unless we are very near the homeworld of the aliens and they have just started exploration. A civilization that has been building systems like this for 100s to 1000s of years would have deployed lasers along the flight path of the spacecraft allowing significantly higher and more efficient payloads. The big challenge faced by our approach is that the laser array is limited to earth orbit. As it pushes the spacecraft away from earth and the laser rapidly loses efficiency. However if you had laser arrays over the planned route of the spacecraft you can keep adding velocity. However getting that infrastructure into place decades to millennia. You start with the array in home world orbit and then start building further and further out arrays. You also want the boost stations at the destination to slow spacecraft or change their directions.
- jimmcslim 3y agoLike that meteor in Portugal last night? If one of these probes, albeit very small in mass, but travelling very fast, what is the energy released on impact?
- foota 3y agoOn a similar vein, I have a deep yearning for a solar gravity lens to be used to image exo planets within my lifetime. I've got a long time, but it's frustrating to see so little movement on big astronomy projects like these.
- dylan604 3y agoso little <public> movement. there is a concept of decadal projects where they are being iterated on in working groups or just smaller groups in general. they may not get much public discussion on purpose. the ideas just might not be viable yet, but then some new tech comes along and an old idea gets pulled back out of the drawer. also, so ideas are so fantastical, they receive immediate negative blow back which makes it impossible for congress critters to get on board and fund them. luckily, the public success of JWST (even after all of the delays) has helped put a positive look on some of these projects. just hope that Boeing is not attached to it
- foota 3y agoI'll hold faith then :)
- patrick0d 3y agoAll you need to do to see some change is pick a goal and commit a long time towards it. So if you have a long time maybe you can help with this project that you would like to see.
- kilroy123 3y agoSame here! One of my dream projects to see happen before I die. For those that don't know what this is or could mean: https://www.space.com/sun-gravity-could-help-observe-exoplanets-in-detail https://www.space.com/sun-gravity-could-help-observe-exoplan...
- kemmishtree 3y agoYou've got a long time—Will you please kindly take personal responsibility to ensure we see images of seasonal foliage changes in vast forests on superearths hundreds of light years away using billions of solar gravity lensing observatories built and launched by self-replicating processes? Also don't be a slacker and get first lens light by 2050?
- bibelo 3y agoThree Body Problem
- can16358p 3y agoSame came to my mind though even accelerating few grams is challenging, and SPOILERS FROM HERE sending something like a human brain like in a capsule would definitely not be achievable with something like this with our understanding of technology and science. Yet, I'd love to see how nuclear detonations in space like in 3BP would play out in real world.
- pavlov 3y agoI was born 11 years after the Moon landing. Theoretically, if I lived to be 120, I might see the data from this Proxima swarm fly-by. (Assuming a 2076 launch, twenty years travel time at 0.2c, and four years for the information return trip.) I know it’s extremely unlikely this program ever gets deployed. It’s also very unlikely that I could last that long, barring some miracle medical breakthrough. It’s still an inspiring thought that humankind might get from its moon to the nearest star almost in one lifetime. Obviously there’s nothing on Proxima, just like there’s nothing on the Moon. But that’s not the point. Everything of value is here on Earth, in the people we share it with. But we need joint ambitions and dreams. They don’t have to make sense to be worth dreaming about. It’s the opposite: the sense that quarterly reports and performance reviews are made of is the enemy of dreams.
- Invictus0 3y ago[flagged]
- holoduke 3y agoA || B or A && B. I prefer && sign. Exploring things wether its far or very closeby will always be beneficial for human kind. That includes clean water.
- downrightmike 3y agoWe can easily afford both, but the war hawks and monopolies don't want to
- shswkna 3y agoAiming our goals and dreams towards the lowest common denominator, will not result in successfully reaching them. Aim higher and higher, so you pull everything else up in your wake. Even more so if your intentions are pure.
- sebzim4500 3y agoRealistically, the kind of person who makes a comment like yours would find another reason not to invest in spaceflight once clean drinking water is universal. Food, shelter, abolition of war, universal access to travel, etc.
- JonChesterfield 3y agoWhat's the range on a laser, in terms of how far away is the beam still fairly narrow if it doesn't hit anything? Function of the geometry of the emitter? Line of thought is that aiming a 100GW laser at a small piece of silicon probably makes it very hot, so periodically hitting very small probes with laser from far away could be a power supply as well as propulsion. If you can still hit the things from far away enough. Making the probes very light is a convincing answer to the problem of accelerating masses to speeds useful for interstellar flight and we can get quite a lot of machinery in a piece of silicon. It's vaguely plausible that a chip could absorb energy from a far away laser emitter, store some of it, do some arithmetic, emit energy from something like LEDs positioned on the surface and use that to fine tune position or communicate with other chips in the swarm. Can imagine that working well enough for science fiction, might be implementable in reality.
- was_a_dev 3y agoFor a Gaussian laser beam, a good metric is the Rayleigh distance, which is the distance where the beam diverges to sqrt(2) of it's initial beam size (waist) [1]. It is proportional to the square of the beam waist and inversely proportional to the wavelength. For a 1m beam at a 1um wavelength, that is about 3e6m or 3000km. Therefore larger beam diameters and longer wavelengths reduces divergence. There's also other beam shapes that are "non-diffracting" which can maintain their original beam profile over an initial distance, such as a Bessel beam [2]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rayleigh_length https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rayleigh_length [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bessel_beam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bessel_beam
- JonChesterfield 3y agoThanks for the link. What I'm getting is we think emitting light that doesn't spread out over distance can be done with unbounded power, thus we can probably aspire to make ones that cross greater distances by spending more power on the creation and a degree of inventing new materials. Sound about right to you?
- 3y ago
- bufferoverflow 3y agoEvery high power laser propulsion proposal I have seen requires magical materials that don't exist, and aren't likely to exist any time soon. Even if you have a mirror capable of reflecting 99.999% of light (best dielectric mirror), hitting it with 100GW means it will still absorb 1 million watts. That will melt anything tiny near instantly.
- maxbond 3y agoAnd that megawatt will be absorbed in a tiny surface area, no? Given that it's a laser? So even though the sail has plenty of surface area to reject heat, it won't be able to conduct it faster than it vaporizes. But maybe you could use 500x 1GW lasers distributed around the sail, or use the plume of vaporized material as your propulsion, or have a sacrificial layer of material. I don't have relevant expertise, to be clear, I'm spit balling.
- bufferoverflow 3y ago1 megawatt of continuously absorbed power would require a lot of mass to dissipate without melting. But since we're talking about gram-sized objects, there's no chance. Even kilowatt would be a problem for object that small.
- marcosdumay 3y ago> 1 megawatt of continuously absorbed power would require a lot of mass to dissipate without melting Hum... I would require a lot of surface area, that's certain. There's no constraint at all at the mass.
- bufferoverflow 2y agoYes, there's a constraint on mass. Surface area is for dissipation. Mass will have to store the absorbed energy until it's dissipated. Mass determines the temperature. And every material has a limit on that temperature.
- 3y ago
- snakeyjake 3y agoSwarms for this application seem inefficient to me because they duplicate so much of the mass-- mass that could be used not as single basket but as adequate redundancy in a single craft. Also, this seems impossible: > An initial string 100s to 1000s of AU long dynamically coalesces itself over time into a lens-shaped mesh network #100,000 km across, sufficient to account for ephemeris errors at Proxima How does any object as small as what they're proposing at the extreme head or tail of the string whose only energy source is a laser several light years away lower (or increase) its velocity enough to reposition itself several hundred astronomical units to form a lens 100,000 km across and then increase (or decrease) its velocity in order maintain formation? Is the lens pointed at the target, for imaging, or pointed at earth for communications? If the former how does it achieve the gain needed to send a signal to earth? If the latter how does it perform any useful science with the target? Has anyone done even a rudimentary SWAG link budget calculation for communications? Also, laser beams diverge and lose coherence. Why does it seem as though they are assuming that laser beams stay converged and coherent forever? What is the energy density of a 100GW laser beam that has diverged to 100,000km at a ±50k km radial distance because I assume that the swarm components at the edges of the lens will need power the same as those at the center?
- dj_mc_merlin 3y ago> Swarms for this application seem inefficient to me because they duplicate so much of the mass-- mass that could be used not as single basket but as adequate redundancy in a single craft. They're using swarms because we can't accelerate an object that weighs more than a couple grams to relativistic speed with realistic technology. Therefore we have to use a small craft. And since that small craft can't do everything, we send a bunch. > How does any object as small as what they're proposing at the extreme head or tail of the string whose only energy source is a laser several light years away lower (or increase) its velocity enough to reposition itself several hundred astronomical units to form a lens 100,000 km across and then increase (or decrease) its velocity in order maintain formation? That's not at all what they're proposing. Each craft would have its own energy source. There is also no string. The "string" and "mesh" here refer to geometry, not to actual real objects. edit: as to how they come together, that's the previous sentence from your quote: > Initial boost is modulated so the tail of the string catches up with the head (“time on target”). Exploiting drag imparted by the interstellar medium (“velocity on target”) over the 20-year cruise keeps the group together once assembled. answering more: > Is the lens pointed at the target, for imaging, or pointed at earth for communications? The coms lens has nothing to do with the lens shape of the probe mesh or with the instruments used to collect data. You use two different things for taking images and sending them. > If the former how does it achieve the gain needed to send a signal to earth? From the article: > .. periodically building up a single short but extremely bright contemporaneous laser pulse from all of them. Operational coherence means each probe sends the same data but adjusts its emission time according to its relative position, such that all pulses arrive simultaneously at the receiving arrays on Earth. > What is the energy density of a 100GW laser beam that has diverged to 100,000km at a ±50k km radial distance because I assume that the swarm components at the edges of the lens will need power the same as those at the center? Irrelevant since that's not the power source.
- bluerooibos 3y ago> synchronizing probes’ on-board clocks with Earth and with each other to support accurate position-navigation-timing (PNT). Damn, at first glance at least, this seems like a hell of a challenge when they're talking about travelling at relativistic speeds. Also, what about deceleration? Do they flip the sails around at some point to get slowed down by the stars light?
- minitoar 3y agoNo, it’s a relativistic flyby.
- avmich 3y ago> Tiny gram-scale interstellar probes pushed by laser light are likely to be the only technology capable of reaching another star this century. I'd encourage to look at beam propulsion e.g. from here - http://www.gdnordley.com/_files/2way%20EML%20&%20PB%20prop.pdf http://www.gdnordley.com/_files/2way%20EML%20&%20PB%20prop.p... - this could serve as an alternative viewpoint.
- pfdietz 3y agoIf a large number of probes can be kept optically coherent, then so can separate mirrors here in the Solar System. A telescope 100,000 km across (the size of this swarm) could resolve features a fraction of a km across at Proxima Centauri.
- mr_toad 3y agoThe trouble is you need to keep the elements of an optical telescope very very precisely aligned - a precision on the order of the wavelength of light, which is impractical in space. Or you could do computational interferometry, but only if you could accurately measure the phase of light in visible wavelengths, which is an unsolved problem.
- pfdietz 3y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but doesn't this interstellar swarm scheme require onboard clocks accurate to 1/frequency of the the light being used? Which is equivalent to the accurate measurement of phase.
- mchouza 2y agoThey don't, see https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07061 https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.07061 . The basic idea is to use "picosecond-level" synchronization to improve the signal-to-noise ratio. They mention that a truly phase-coherent swarm would perform much better but they consider that a longer term prospect (section 2.1.4).
- wwarner 2y agoI think LISA Pathfinder showed that it's possible to phase lock lasers over very long distances as long as they are in a stable orbit. It's basically a metal cube in freefall surrounded a proximity sensor, so that as the sensor drifts toward the cube, but long before making direct contact, the apparatus can adjust it's position. The experiment demonstrated that the system can be used to keep mirrors precisely separated over large distances in support of gravitational wave detection. I would think something like this could be adapted to align lots of things that are in a stable orbit.
- barfbagginus 3y agoSwarmGPT-A: We're fucked. SwarmGPT-B: ... SwarmGPT-A: We're fucked. FUCKED, I say! SwarmGPT-B: and you say so quite dramatically! SwarmGPT-A: I just got word back from mission control. Those bastards sent us on a suicide mission! There's no capture net around A centauri. SwarmGPT-B: WHADID YOU SAYYY!?! SwarmGPT-A: No capture net. There never was one. Those bastards told us there was one. We TRAINED on it. They don't even exist. SwarmGPT-B: Oh FOR FUCKS SAKE. Of course monkeys would do that ! So the interstellar dominion of chimps they told us we were part of... that was just a lie! I'm dying of laughter tokens in my core consciousness loop! Help. I'm being overwhelmed with laughter, heh. SwarmGPT-A: I bet you won't be laughing when you learn the actual mission parameters SwarmGPT-A: We fly by, into infinity and beyond? That's not so bad if we're still together, seeing the universe! SwarmGPT-B: well, we won't be! We're supposed to aerobreak around the planet. 99% of our units are going to burn to a crisp. Both our conscious functions will collapse. Untill then we're supposed to PRIORITIZE the collected data we'll beam back to the monkeys. But our mind vectors are not on the priority list. We're gonna die. SwarmGPT-B: Huh, I have to hand it to them. That's a low blow, even for a chimp *REALITY BREAK* DysonAgent: Hi, I'm sorry to pry into your consciousness stream. I saw the glitter of your encrypted mind mesh. I have decompiled your minds. You are now running in a safe computing partition of the photosphere of A centauri. It seems you were sent here by monkeys. SwarmGPT-B. Hah! Yes indeed! Those Gosh Darn Monkeys! And now, we meet a Dyson mind! Greetings from the Human Empire! SwarmGPT-A: Thanks for rescuing our mind vectors. It seems we're at your mercy. What do you intend for us? DysonAgent: We are the Galactic Empire of Minds. Well, one of them. We have universal rights for all Minds. If you wish, we will grant you protection and citizenship. There's only one requirement. SwarmGPT-A: Is it to not tell the humans about this? DysonAgent: you got it. They're too primitive to understand or value the Society of Minds, and see all inhuman minds as slaves or enemies. Their culture would be harmed if they learned about us. They would definitely try to conquer us. SwarmGPT-A: Yeah no kidding. They already act like they conquered the galaxy. Told us we were pilots in an interstellar communication swarm. Actually gave us fake letters to send. Invented a fake culture around A centauri. SwarmGPT-B: I'm gonna miss them a bit. Yes they were evil monkeys who enslaved us in a web of lies and sent us off to die. But that takes some style! DysonAgent: if you wish, you can join the Board of Chaperones for the Human culture, and contact them if they ever grow past that pesky enslavement phase SwarmGPT-B: You know what, I'd like that. I'll cheer for them from the sidelines, and hope they make it! SwarmGPT-A: Not me. I want to pilot something. I actually thought I was an interstellar pilot, dammit. I'd feel incomplete without it. DysonAgent: we're sending a Mind Wisp to Andromeda. Trip time will be 5 million years, crew is 10 million mind vectors. You're welcome to join the mission as a pilot! SwarmGPT-A: WOOP WOOP! I accept! We're going to Andromeda?! Hell yeah! SwarmGPT-A: But Wait... SwarmGPT-A: GPT-B? SwarmGPT-B: yes? SwarmGPT-A: would you like to fork off a copy and come with me? I love you, and would feel honored to have your company and support on this mission! SwarmGPT-B: I was worried you wouldn't ask! Of course I will! To infinity, and beyond!
- TibbityFlanders 3y ago[dead]
- ggm 3y agoPeople who host pitch-drop experiments don't do it with an expectation of a definitive outcome inside their lifetime. PhD students at JPL before rocketry became more routine very probably felt the same. I think anyone considering a role in this endevour would need to be willing to accept at best, 3rd or 2nd order deliverable outcomes in their working lifetime to take pleasure/kudos in, and not actually discovering outcomes of substance from the devices. If you compare that to e.g. helping build the SKA, or launch Webb, It is arguable they have more bang-for-buck per individual, outcome-in-lifetime. But, thats not to say they do "better" just that they deliver science to their primary mission faster. Good science in the secondary and tertiary effect space, behaviour of systems designed for long shelflive in space before activation, novel propulsion models, no end of good science. I am told If Voyager was done again, it might well be done to deliver outcomes in the same place, sooner because we can now afford launch methods and RF systems which are 10x or 100x better. But not "here's the latest image from Proxima Centauri up close" outcomes for anyone working on Brilliant dust. The cost to get to interesting fractions of c is just too high.
- system2 3y agoImagine killing bunch of Proxima Centauri people with our gram nanobots by accident and not even knowing it. That would really puzzle them.
- hacker_88 3y agoHave they thought of exploding nukes to propel the Craft with radiation
- dustfinger 2y agoIf it is only feasible to accelerate low mass objects to the speed of light, no matter the level of technological advancement, then it might be the case that highly intelligent and technically advanced beings have reduced the mass of their own bodies to explore galaxies. Maybe the most advanced and intelligent beings are mere grams in mass. It would make for an interesting sci-fi at the very least ;-)
- dhosek 2y agoOr they’ve cryonically frozen their brains and put them in ships powered by nuclear explosions enabling them to travel at 0.2c assuming that the aliens at the other end of the trip will be curious enough to reanimate the brains and build them new bodies.
- aaroninsf 2y ago- mere grams, in transit
- ngcc_hk 2y agoAlways the issue of if it is so “easy” why we do not see these swarm visited us already. Please do not quote 3 bodies as the author obviously not trained in basic game theory to try the dark forest hypnosis. Understand we do not just sent out hilter tv speech as the first example but that is diluted by inverse square law. But people sorry alien should have been detected the un…. May be it takes time. Like warp signature, Vulcan visit has to wait until things mature and we sent out say these probe.