11 ms·
Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liable in 737 MAX crashes
- chii 3y agocriminally liable, but not enough for jail time? Then it's not a criminal liability, but a cost of doing business.
- dragonwriter 3y agoCompanies cannot go to jail for crimes, its not an available sanction.
- consp 3y agoCompanies are expressed through and by people, and yes I ignore the "limited liability" bs since it should not shield you from criminal behaviour.
- semanticist 3y agoSo the owner of Boeing should be held personally liable? Okay, cool, except Boeing is a publicly traded company which means that the 'owner' is countless individual shareholders around the world, many of which are in turn other companies, whose owners are in turn things like pension funds. So if you have a pension, should we be locking you up 'cause it was partially invested in Boeing? Alternatively, you can have a specifically named role which is to be held liable? But then as far as the 'company' is concerned it's still just cost of doing business. There's only three viable ultimate sanctions for a corporate entity: financial, being split up, and the death penalty.
- hiatus 3y agoWho said anything about owners? _Management_ should be held accountable.
- dragonwriter 3y agoAn explicitly cited reason DoJ approved the deferred prosecution agreement was that, on the basis of the facts available, management was not collectively, even, much less individually aware of the facts imputed to Boeing based on the knowledge of lower-level employees which were necessay to be guilty of the crime.
- ericd 3y agoThe thing is, this sets up a moral hazard where it’s advantageous not to know, not to keep close tabs, and tight control over your supply chain. If there were potentially harsh penalties for allowing this to happen, regardless of knowledge, I think you’d see much better controls put in place, and the incentive would be to keep safety critical operations kept in-house, where they can be better monitored, rather than spun out to make the return on capital look better to public markets.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> The thing is, this sets up a moral hazard where it’s advantageous not to know No, they would be better off if they had known what the pilots were doing and stopped the fraud rather than allowing it. > If there were potentially harsh penalties for allowing this to happen, regardless of knowledge, I think you’d see much better controls put in place, and the incentive would be to keep safety critical operations kept in-house, where they can be better monitored, rather than spun out to make the return on capital look better to public markets. If you made inaccurate reports to governments a strict liability crime with a harsh pubishment not requiring intent, recklessness,or negligence, I think that would actually be a bad thing and lead people to actively avoid any activity or field of business that might require reporting to the government. But, in any case, the fraud offenses at issue ARE NOT strict liability crimes now, so people without the requisite knowledge and intent cannot be guilty of them.
- ericd 3y agoThanks for the thoughtful response. I was admittedly thinking more about their quality problems due to their spinning out big chunks of their manufacturing, and the general failures of management, rather than specifically the MAX problems and the fraud in question, so my comment was somewhat off-topic. But in general, it seems that they’re encouraged to not look too closely at parts of their business that are acting in risky ways, and if that’s the case, perhaps we should change the incentives to try to fix that. I don’t know what that would look like, there are obviously limits to how much someone can know about what’s going on 6 layers below in the org chart. But making them liable would certainly be an incentive. I think people would still take the job, given how much is typically on offer.
- fbdrgvv 3y ago[dead]
- sp332 3y agoIf the stockholders didn't make the decision to defraud the FAA, then why would they be on the hook for this?
- chii 3y agoNot that i disagree, but the corporation also has a way of diffusing responsibility to thousands of individuals, each making a small piece of the total decisions that led to an outcome. It's impossible, in theory, to pin a particular individual with absolute certainty, that they'r totally and 100% responsible for said outcome. Of course, i am in the camp of changing the regulation such that outcomes that would be considered gross neglegence leading to loss of life is layed on the management, regardless of whether the decision is diffused or not. Aka, they hold the statutory responsibility, and is criminally liable - that's the price of being in management. They would get the tools as management to put in place preventative measures, which can be used to cover their ass.
- heavenlyblue 3y agoManagement gets paid money to make money make more money, but that does not include implying they need to break law/walk on the other's people's bodies to do so.
- OJFord 3y agoAnd it doesn't, but the criminal behaviour then needs to be a personal one, not just like (and not saying this is the case) systemic issues at the company, regulatory oversight clearly insufficient or not preventative, no one person really specifically at fault through malicious action or reckless negligence so ehhh blame the CEO.
- Karellen 3y ago> I ignore the "limited liability" bs since it should not shield you from criminal behaviour. It doesn't. That's not what "limited liability" is for. > Limited liability is a legal status in which a person's financial liability is limited to a fixed sum, most commonly the value of a person's investment in a corporation, company or joint venture. If a company that provides limited liability to its investors is sued, then the claimants are generally entitled to collect only against the assets of the company, not the assets of its shareholders or other investors. A shareholder in a corporation or limited liability company is not personally liable for any of the debts of the company, other than for the amount already invested in the company and for any unpaid amount on the shares in the company, if any, except under special and rare circumstances permitting "piercing the corporate veil." The same is true for the members of a limited liability partnership and the limited partners in a limited partnership. By contrast, sole proprietors and partners in general partnerships are each liable for all the debts of the business (unlimited liability). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_liability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_liability (emphasis mine)
- dragonwriter 3y agoLimited liability has nothing to do with this. Individuals can go to jail for crimes, to the extent they individually have committed them, but because corporations are aggregates and not individuals, it is possible for them to be guilty of crime when no individual would. On the facts alleged in the 737 Max charges, if any individuals would be guilty at all, they wouldn’t be the executives or shareholders you seem to be lusting for, but two test pilots (and its not clear they would be, only that they personally had the knowledge whose imputation to Boeing combined with corporate representations to the federal government made Boeing guilty.)
- baq 3y agoboard members and executives can and should. shareholder equity should be zero'd (or at least devalued if the shareholder had a significant impact on votes, whatever that means.) so should any vp, second line and even front line managers if they collaborated. whistleblowers should get government protection. not sure which government, though.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> board members and executives can and should. If they individually committed crimes and that can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, sure. Of course, by DoJ’s own description of why they approved the deferred prosecution agreeement, that's absolutely not the case with the 737 Max charges.
- feoren 3y agoHow can the company commit crimes without its decision-makers committing crimes? This double-standard we have is ridiculous. Every 1% increase in stock price is always attributed entirely to the wunderkind CEO and he therefore deserves tens of millions in bonuses every year, but a criminally negligent company kills people and suddenly the CEO has nothing to do with it? They are acting as the chief executive of the criminal corporation. Those fuckers should be thrown in jail. "Oh but then our favorite Harvard MBA Graduate with a transcript full of Gentleman's Cs who's the grandson of the previous billionaire CEO wouldn't want to be CEO!! Who would want the job!?" -- fucking GOOD. They get paid 300 times more than line workers, and we're worried about how the job might not be cushy enough to attract our favorite nepo-babies? Maybe the most lucrative jobs in the entire world should only be attractive to people who are actually competent at making sure the company is operating well and not literally murdering innocent people!?
- dragonwriter 3y ago> How can the company commit crimes without its decision-makers committing crimes? Very easily. Companies as aggregates of people beyond just the decision makers can both do actions and have knowledge that the decisionmakers do not, and knowledge and action tend to be important in the definition of crimes.
- sethammons 3y agowhich is one of the many reasons why corporations should not be counted as people and allowed a political voice.
- dragonwriter 3y agoIf corporations weren't counted as people, they couldn't be held criminally liable when, viewed as a single entity, they had the requisite combination of knowledge ans action to be guilty of a crime, but where none of the constituent individuals considered alone did.
- sethammons 3y agoa corporation being held criminally liable holds about as much as a wet paper bag. It is an accounting issue; the cost of doing business. Absolute worst case scenario for the business: it folds. "Oh well, killed people; guess we need to make a new company." There is a lack of _personal_ accountability. Hold executives criminally liable. Fine companies, sure, but if people die from gross negligence or due to processes endorsed by leadership, that should end with prison time as a warning to others. Don't let them say they didn't know and that the decisions were spread out over people and time. The buck stops with leadership -- that is, ostensibly, why they make the big bucks. If they couldn't know due to spread out decision making then they set up and perpetuated the wrong system.
- schmidt_fifty 3y ago[dead]
- will1am 3y agoСorporations can face serious consequences for illegal activities. And these consequences can completely destroy them
- anonymousab 2y ago> Companies cannot go to jail for crimes Seems like they really should. No business activities, commerce or services for the period of incarceration; the company effectively freezes or ceases to exist. It would naturally be as life-destroying to the company and its relationships with business partners, customers, employees and those who rely on it as it is to the average joe.
- 1-6 3y agoWhat was the crime? Negligent manufacturing?
- alistairSH 3y agoFraud. Lying to federal regulators during 737Max approval. See link for a better description… https://apnews.com/article/boeing-justice-department-737-max-82145b25ed988cd8cae0bce3de79ce9d https://apnews.com/article/boeing-justice-department-737-max...
- mlindner 3y agoThat sounds a lot harder to prove than if they were going for negligence.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> That sounds a lot harder to prove than if they were going for negligence. Well, it was solid enough that Boeing was willing to pay $2.5 billion plus accept a bunch of behavioral controls not to settle the charges, but simply to get a deferred prosecution agreement in which, if they were really good, they wouldn’t have to face charges for it.
- hgyjdetjj 3y agoLying is quite easy to prove with a few incriminating emails.
- wsc981 3y agoOne reason why the Dutch PM uses an old Nokia phone with very limited capacity, so he needs to delete SMS messages often: https://archive.ph/q6a3l https://archive.ph/q6a3l And I don't think he emails much :)
- ThunderSizzle 3y agoDeleting official communications can be a violation of law in the US. Hilary should've gone to jail for it, but she didn't because she's a Clinton.
- madcadmium 3y ago[flagged]
- purple-leafy 3y agoNarrator: A new car built by my company leaves somewhere traveling at 60 mph. The rear differential locks up. The car crashes and burns with everyone trapped inside. Now, should we initiate a recall? Take the number of vehicles in the field, A, multiply by the probable rate of failure, B, multiply by the average out-of-court settlement, C. A times B times C equals X. If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one. Business woman on plane: Are there a lot of these kinds of accidents? Narrator: You wouldn't believe. Business woman on plane: Which car company do you work for? Narrator: A major one.
- ebri 3y ago[flagged]
- whoknowsidont 3y agoThere's a button for that.
- lukan 3y ago(The reference is "Fight Club" for the uninitiated btw.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Liquix 3y agothe third rule of fight club is that it's okay to explain references to fight club on pseudonymous discussion boards, provided the explanation is furnished in parentheses
- dralley 3y agoDon't turn this into Reddit
- mcepl 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Pinto#Fuel_system_fires,_recalls,_and_litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Pinto#Fuel_system_fires,_...
- mlindner 3y agoI think it'll be difficult to prove in court. To actually be found guilty they'll need to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the executives knew there was problems it wasn't just ignorance or ineptness. That'll be difficult to show the jury unless they have some really good smoking gun evidence.
- sigmoid10 3y ago>unless they have some really good smoking gun evidence They need witnesses. Like the ones who suddenly die a lot.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> I think it’ll be difficult to prove in court. To actually be found guilty they’ll need to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the executives knew there was problems No, they won’t. For one thing, the charges aren’t personal charges against the executives, so they don’t have to prove that executives, specifically, knew anything. The basis of the 737 Max charges that were put on hold because of the deferred prosecution agreement that DoJ has now determined that Boeing violated are addressed by DoJ here: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/boeing-charged-737-max-fraud-conspiracy-and-agrees-pay-over-25-billion https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/boeing-charged-737-max-fraud-...
- sp332 3y agoSo, two Flight Technical Pilots and that's it?
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoIt’s exactly for ignorance and ineptness that they should be going to prison.
- langsoul-com 3y agoI highly doubt they'd be criminal indictments. Boeing is USA's baby, can't have them losing against European Airbus, or God forbid, Chinese Comac. Reminds me of when FAA didn't ground the Boeing, despite the fatal crashes because of that association. Instead, it was Chinese aviation authority that did, which forced every other airline to follow suit. Most likely a fine, round up a few line workers to take the heat, a manager or two, then call it a day.
- ars 3y agoI agree with your premise but your first sentence contradicts your last one. I think there will be criminal indictments, but the punishment will be monetary and will not damage the company long term. It would be really hard to put anyone in jail anyway, there's too much diluted responsibility.
- amelius 3y agoBecause the EU never started a (criminal) lawsuit against a US company?
- ai_what 3y agoIn this hypothetical situation, would the US would be extraditing American Boeing executives to Europe? I think you're overestimating Europe here.
- niemandhier 3y agoWe have a mutual extradition treaty, and since the us frequently desires the extradition of high profile cases it’s not impossible that his could happen. The biggest problem would be the absence of an European criminal law pertaining to companies. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/summary/agreement-with-the-united-states-on-extradition.html https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/summary/agreement...
- BlackFly 3y agoIf they need a head on a pike to get the rest of the world to trust them enough again to keep competing with Airbus then maybe they will find that rule of law still makes sense.
- cowsaymoo 3y agoSomehow another disastrous news cycle for Boeing. Any feature suggestions for my new extension that highlights MAX routes on Google Flights? https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/iabbdbcbohcifefhimdmflnhafjmbkoj?hl=en&authuser=0 https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/iabbdbcbohcifefhimd...
- qxfys 3y agoI have been intentionally avoiding Max since the Lion and Ethiopian (at least when I buy the ticket). However, there were occasions when the airline rescheduled my flights (for many different reasons), which resulted in me being on a max flight. While I can change one of them, changes to most of them were not practical (time-wise, effort-wise, etc). So, at some point, I have to live with the fact that flying max is unavoidable. Any idea how we can practically circumvent this?
- jfim 3y agoYou can fly carriers that don't have any Boeing planes. JetBlue, Spirit, and Frontier don't operate any Boeing planes, as far as I know.
- qxfys 3y agoAvoiding all boeing planes altogether seems to be an overkill solution to me. An older version of 737 and 777 seems to be working pretty well. At least historically.
- stevesimmons 3y agoFly airlines whose fleets are 100% Airbus?
- qxfys 3y agoI don't mind flying an older version of 737, though. :-)
- cowsaymoo 3y ago
- ForFreedom 3y agoAnd the insurance of boeing pays up the fine/money..
- gonzo41 3y agoUntil a few C-Level people go to Prison for a terribly long time, nothing will improve.
- thuridas 3y agoFiring them with their bonuses and golden parachutes won't help at all
- cj 3y agoAlternate approach that doesn’t involve sending people to jail just to make an example of them: Make up a new position with equal authority as the CEO, but their only charter is safety and compliance. Lift the corporate veil specifically for that role (and only that role) so that they are personally liable for the performance in their role and the safety of the company’s products. Require that companies halt sales and production if this role is unfilled. In a free market, no sane human would accept that job unless there was a (legitimately) extremely small risk that they would ever be personally liable. CEOs need incentive structures like this in order to change their priorities/behaviors. Sending CEOs to jail is the brute force approach.
- triceratops 3y agoThere are always people willing to risk jail time for a high-enough payoff. They're called career criminals and the role would attract them in droves. The only way honest people would take it is if they outranked the CEO on safety matters.
- EasyMark 3y agowe need laws like Europe where they can charge significant percentages of global revenue (not sure how much at least 10%, possibly 50%?) before they'll listen. It's so rare for people to be criminally charged, the only really plausible, realistic change in policy is as I stated.
- hgyjdetjj 3y agoStill nobody will go to prison. TooBigToJail as they say.
- amelius 3y agoThe least we can do is give them a criminal record.
- zaptheimpaler 3y agoI wonder if they are criminally liable for murdering 2 whistleblowers as well..
- logicchains 3y agoI'd guess not as nobody wants to be the judge (or jury member) they find themselves also criminally liable for murdering.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lupusreal 3y agoWith only some circumstantial evidence? Almost certainly not.
- thejohnconway 3y agoVirtually all evidence presented in courts is circumstantial (including DNA, fingerprints, etc.), eyewitness testimony of the actual crime is pretty much the only thing that isn’t.
- lupusreal 3y agoIf they have anything like that then there might be the case, but so far all that is publicly known is that Boeing plausibly had a motive for wanting them dead. No sane prosecutor will try their luck with only that to go on.
- thejohnconway 3y agoSo the argument is that’s it’s weak evidence, not circumstantial. Circumstantial evidence is often the strongest kind.
- okdood64 3y ago
- ceving 3y agoSome details: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PlaMQBEg-9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PlaMQBEg-9M
- rob74 3y ago> Boeing has violated a 2021 agreement that shielded it from criminal prosecution after two 737 Max disasters left 346 people dead overseas Somehow I think this phrase would have been better without the word "overseas". After all (to quote the old Depeche Mode song), people are people, no matter if they're from the US, Ethiopia or Indonesia, so the fact that it happened overseas shouldn't make a plane crash less relevant. Although, if the first crash had happened in the US, maybe the increased scrutiny would have led to the second one being avoided...
- bell-cot 3y agoTrue from most PoV's. OTOH, the U.S. Department of Justice's turf generally ends at the U.S. border, so "overseas" is an important distinction here.
- sofixa 3y ago> OTOH, the U.S. Department of Justice's turf generally ends at the U.S. border, so "overseas" is an important distinction here Nah, the US is extremely aggressive all over the world, to the extent I'm not sure anyone in that country understands the word jurisdiction outside of state/federal in their own context. Be it extradition of people committing crimes elsewhere/online, enforcing their own sanctions on companies in other countries, and tons of other things. Otherwise you wouldn't have Ukrainians getting extradited to the US for running torrent websites in Ukraine, Australians being extradited for running leak websites, French banks being fined for working with Iranian businesses, Colombians and Mexicans being assassinated or extradited for running drug empires in their own countries exporting to the US, kidnapping random civilians to be tortured based on their name/watch model, a law being on the books allowing the army to invade any place that held American war criminals (like the Hague and the courts there) and on and on and on.
- robertlagrant 3y agoIt's still an important distinction. Your list of things doesn't seem relevant to that at all.
- projektfu 3y agoIt is amazing to me how much grief could have been avoided if Boeing had committed to the 757 instead of the 737. Almost every operator who is using large 737s is using ramps and lift buses to access the aircraft, obviating the need to fill a large aircraft from a short staircase. Training pilots once to use 757s would have been a small expense compared to the risk that the entire Boeing brand is destroyed. And, the 757 could probably have stayed competitive with Airbus. Was all this craziness due to some business magazine article about Southwest Airlines doing so well because they only had one major type of aircraft?
- sofixa 3y agoSouthwest and Ryanair, two of the biggest airlines in the world, are exclusively 737. It allows them to keep maintenance and flight crew costs low, and they were the primary forces insisting on Boeing improving a design which is beyond its limits. They'll kick the can down the road for as long as they can.
- projektfu 3y agoDid Southwest sell off all the 717s when they bought AirTran? I haven't flown SWA in a long time.
- sofixa 3y agoAccording to Wikipedia: > Southwest integrated AirTran's fleet of Boeing 737-700 series aircraft into Southwest Airlines brand and livery, and the Boeing 717 fleet was then leased out to Delta Air Lines starting in mid-2013 Same as Alaska Airlines getting rid of the A320s they got by acquiring Virgin America. (Although they're in the same predicament again by acquiring Hawaiian).
- gosub100 3y agoI'm sure they considered it. Can a '57 fit in every airport (runway length, gate size, or base altitude) that a '37 can? What about engines? Would any engine maker have been able to deliver revamped '57 engines when they have been mostly focusing on other models?
- thedudeabides5 3y agogood
- laylower 3y agoI wonder if the value of life for those whistleblowers no longer around is the same...
- Kalanos 3y agocorporations are not people. people are liable.
- paxys 3y agoA company being criminally liable just means slightly larger fines. They aren't charging individuals. No one is going to jail over this.
- EasyMark 3y agoThis is one of those things that "sounds good" in a headline but I will never believe it until I see it. You have to do Enron level of white collar crime to ever get prosecuted in the USA for abusing the "corporate veil" above the middle management or specific individuals who take the fall for the higher ups.
- Ancalagon 3y agoMonopoly busting when, Mr. Government?