6 ms·
So... A single company has just spent about 0.1% of the US GDP in a pet project, and it's not even the leading one on the market? That's just incredible, and n
by marcosdumay 3y ago
So... A single company has just spent about 0.1% of the US GDP in a pet project, and it's not even the leading one on the market?
That's just incredible, and not a good thing.
- brevitea 3y agoDo we know if the Meta AI effort is subsidized by the US Government?
- mlsu 3y agoI would challenge that a little bit -- I think it is a good thing, given that they have open-sourced the results of the project. It seems to me to be far better than a company which simply gives 0.1% of US GDP back to shareholders in the form of dividends or stock buybacks, which is a very common occurrence given the size of companies nowadays. Or worse, a company which spends 0.1% of US GDP manufacturing things that are wholly useless or even actively damaging to consumers, the environment, etc.
- klyrs 3y ago> or even actively damaging to consumers, the environment, etc. Jury's still out on this one
- WalterBright 3y agoThe shareholders normally just reinvest the dividends. That isn't bad for the economy. > manufacturing things that are wholly useless Companies manufacture things that people want to buy. Presumably those people find the things useful. Companies that manufacture things people don't want go out of business.
- gdsimoes 3y ago> Companies that manufacture things people don't want go out of business. Do they, though? When was the last a time a really big company went bankrupt?
- toomuchtodo 3y ago2008. Lehman Brothers and Washington Mutual. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_in_the_United_State...
- dchftcs 3y agoThey manufactured things people wanted, but shouldn't have wanted...
- bobthepanda 3y agoGM and Chrysler also went bankrupt the year after. Silicon Valley Bank was actually the third largest bankruptcy in US history, which is news to me. And apparently Signature Bank was fourth. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1096794/largest-bankruptcies-usa-by-assets/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1096794/largest-bankrupt...
- toomuchtodo 3y agoMF Global in 2011 as well, but not terribly big comparatively speaking.
- qeternity 3y agoThe point is not that lots of companies run around making things people don't want and go bankrupt. The point is that's what would happen, and because of that, companies focus on making things people actually do want. Look at what happened the Facebook stock over the last few years as they rebranded to Meta and started spending wildly. The market whipped them into shape, and rewarded them handsomely.
- eru 3y agoThough Facebook/Meta is actually a bit of a weak example, because it is very much controlled by its founder, who can outvote any public shareholder. So any compliance with the 'wishes of market' was somewhat voluntary.
- eru 3y ago> It seems to me to be far better than a company which simply gives 0.1% of US GDP back to shareholders in the form of dividends or stock buybacks, which is a very common occurrence given the size of companies nowadays. The whole point of investing in companies is for those companies to eventually give the shareholders more resources back than they put in. [0] Those shareholders can then consume those resources, or invest them in something else; like eg startups that pursue new technologies. Returning capital to shareholders is exactly how investing works and how it has to work. Otherwise it would be charity, which is also fine, but it's something different. Are you also against companies paying back debt, instead of endlessly rolling over one loan into another loan and paying interest only with money from new loans? (If not, how is that different?) [0] On average, and in expectation. Investing in risky endeavours means that sometimes they fail, and you get less or no money back.
- mlsu 3y agoNo, I don't have a problem in general with returning capital to shareholders. I'm not making an anti-capitalist argument here. I'm saying. For humanity, net good. Facebook could do a stock buyback with all of that H100 money. It's a significant amount of money. As a human, complete non facebook shareholder except in ETFs, I would rather they buy H100's and train huge neural nets and then release them for free. Maybe I've bought the kool-aid but I think I believe that Zuckerberg genuinely wants to move humanity forward with this one (of course, it's also a business move). A lesser chairman of the board would have not spent huge capex on GPUs, and instead simply issued a fat dividend or what have you to shareholders who eventually would buy a newer nicer house in Marin or whatever. And indeed, it's only Zuck's unique position with preferential shares that allows him to do this; at a different company, he'd have been shot down and dividends it would be. On the whole, which is better? What moves the needle in terms of bringing humanity forward? And this is kind of true of companies in general. "Returning money to shareholders" is not created equal, even though it's all money in the end. Sports betting companies are also returning basis points of GDP to shareholders. Is that a worthwhile thing to do? Net good? (Please, dear reader, do not make the argument that sports betting is actually a good thing because hey we all make free market choices.)
- deleted 3y ago
- jazzyjackson 3y agothey've open sourced a babble-bot that allows any individual to sockpuppet infinite identities, I have a hard time seeing how the impact will be positive
- ornornor 3y ago> things that are wholly useless or even actively damaging to consumers, the environment, etc. Oh you mean like Facebook, Instagram, and friends?
- VelesDude 3y agoWhen I see things like this I am always amazed at how we manage to squander our potential. When I see the best in people and then see the silly loops and squiggles we get ourselves into it is like playing Chopsticks on Mozart's piano. We know it could do so much more. I mean, we are free to play chopsticks and that is fine, but ultimately in focusing on the short term despite being aware of the long term, it eventually gets taken out of our control and the base ecosystem has its way with us. It is better to show restraint now rather than have it forced.
- chii 3y agoWhy not? If someone is willing to make large bets like that, all the more power to them. Society has (and should) continue to become wealthier. The laws that govern us has improved from the medieval days where money is everything, so just because a private entity is able to spend a lot doesn't imply there's anything untoward.
- eru 3y agoYes, taking risks with your own money can be a good thing. But taking risks also means that project don't always pan out. I don't know enough about Facebook to say whether the expected value of that bet was positive. But that's not my judgement to make in the first place. > The laws that govern us has improved from the medieval days where money is everything, so just because a private entity is able to spend a lot doesn't imply there's anything untoward. Yes, I agree that it's a good thing that people and companies can spend their money how they see fit.
- mcmcmc 3y agoThe problem is that it’s not society becoming wealthier, it’s the top strata getting wealthier off the increased productivity of society as a whole.
- bogwog 3y agoFacebook (and all the other big tech companies) are entrenched monopolists that engage in illegal business practices to maintain their position. This is a net negative for society overall, and a huge detriment to innovation. They're able to spend that much on GPUs (and have to because Nvidia doesn't have real competition either) because of the stranglehold they have over their markets, not because they earned that in the free market through the means by which the free market is meant to work (competition, best product/service wins, etc). That money they spent is being used incredibly inefficiently because of this. With more competition, a lot more would be done with a lot less. Facebook tossing us a pseudo-open source kinda-free LLM will make some of the nerds on this site happy though (like how decades of evil from Microsoft were erased with the release of a free text editor lol). I guess that's all that really matters at the end of the day.
- loeg 3y agoMeh? It's the sixth largest company in the US; it's not surprising that it can direct 0.1% of US GDP.
- eru 3y ago> That's just incredible, and not a good thing. Why? It shows that they were willing to spend lots of resources on something risky. That's how you get progress. Risky things don't always pan out (almost by definition).
- int_19h 3y agoThe fact that entities large enough to control so many resources by themselves exist, is not a good thing.
- eru 3y agoFacebook is still orders of magnitude smaller than the government. So you could start your complaints at that particular entity. (And I have sympathies for that! We should have more smaller countries, like Singapore or Switzerland.)
- int_19h 3y agoIt's orders of magnitude smaller than the US government (which, yes, I also think is too big for anyone's good). But, as I recall, large American tech companies actually have budgets exceeding those of quite a few smaller states at this point.
- Invictus0 3y agoATT has $400B in assets on their balance sheet
- segmondy 3y agoYou think Llama is a pet project?
- refulgentis 3y agoAll kinds of funny math, gotta pretend it was all spent in 1 year, ignore that it's a fraction of what they spend in general so it sounds more shocking, and it's tracking to be gpt4 ish
- whateveracct 3y agowaste is still rampant in the industry despite all the correcting factors out there
- choppaface 3y agoIt’s easy to see as a pet project given the metaverse failure but their aim is more towards beating Google Search, which looks more plausible after OpenAI’s traction.
- spacebanana7 3y agoThat sort of investment level is why the US dominates the software industry.
- marcyb5st 3y agoFor better or worse also the fact that in the US it's possible to fire people without any issue (IMHO). Being able to prune underperforming people should mean that those money are better used. Here in EU I saw many people that basically just clock in/out everyday and then mind their own business because they are un-fireable due to labor laws/unions. A colleague was calling these people "institutionally pre-retired", which I believe it's a great description of the phenomenon. To some extent that happens in the US also in the Public Sector, but I believe it's rarer.