7 ms·
Akiya houses: why Japan has nine million empty homes
- ekusiadadus 3y agoAging population and declining birth rates causes it…
- toomuchtodo 3y agoRelated? https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2024/04/26/japan/society/homeless-people-record-low/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2024/04/26/japan/society/h... "The number of homeless people in Japan fell 8.0% as of January from a year earlier to 2,820, the lowest level since data began in 2003, the health ministry said in a survey report Friday."
- justsomehnguy 3y ago[flagged]
- Invictus0 3y agoThe San Franciscan mind simply can't comprehend this
- lagichikool 3y agoIt may be an under count but probably not by any huge amount. Although there are a much larger number of people that are desperately poor. Japan has a relatively low cost of living (especially in rural areas), reasonably good social safety net, low drug use, high levels of familial support, and other factors that make it remarkable. It's pretty hard to become homeless. But even in the US, where all factors are far worse, there is a surprisingly small percentage of the population that is homeless. The absolute numbers are much smaller than most people would guess (even accounting for under counting). We tend to focus and exaggerate homelessness because it is so visible. Poverty in general is a much bigger and worse problem everywhere.
- 39896880 3y agoThey also have massive societal pressure to conform and a ton of 24 hour businesses like internet cafes. It is likely that the definition of homeless being reported here doesn’t capture people who don’t have a stable address but would never come forward to be counted.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 3y agoAlso even Tokyo has some extremely cheap housing options. They are not great, but at least roof does not leak too much. They might not have full niceties like big kitchens or showers or even bathrooms. But they are very cheap. The bottom end is much lower than in west in general.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoDoesn’t the birth death ratio in Japan make this easier to solve? Housing is constantly being freed up by deaths, but apparently not conserved by the government or non profit to house those without housing.
- ceejayoz 3y agoUpon what do you base that doubt? Wikipedia cites homeless advocates in Japan contesting the number, claming it's as high as... 5,000. Which is still pretty neat.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoOn the common sense. And definitions of the term and the methods for obtaining the stats. Especially if you know anything about Japanese.
- turrican 3y agoWe just spent a week in Japan and did not stay only in tourist areas, my Apple Watch logged our walks as around 10-15 miles per day. Over the entire week, I saw one obviously homeless person, one “maybe” and no encampments. It really was striking coming from the United States. ~3,000 homeless may be low, but they have drastically fewer than us.
- TheBlight 3y agoDoes Japan make a much more substantial investment in institutional mental health care?
- 39896880 3y agoNo. Mental health in Japan is not broadly talked about. Anyone experiencing a mental health crisis is probably being cared for privately.
- Larrikin 3y agoThe homeless tend to congregate in encampments. You'll sometimes see the rare one in a park or a station but usually you only see them if you happen to wander into an area where they've all set up. Homeless in Japan don't panhandle or really bother regular people.
- nox101 3y agoGo in late January, Shinjuku station, above Marunouchi line, 20-40 homeless sleeping in the main tunnel under Yasukuni-dori to get out of the cold. Go into the park behind city hall. Look in tbe bushes. See tents made from tarps. Same is true in many other parks. Also that park behind city hall hands out food to homeless people. I'm not saying Japan has lots of homeless people, only that they are there. My impression from XX years in Japan is there is a strong ethic of "don't bother other people with your problems" so the homeless generally try to keep to themselves.
- resolutebat 3y agoWhen were you last in Japan? The tent encampments were cleared out before the 2020 Olympics and have not come back.
- Anon1096 3y agoThere have been lots of empty homes for a while now, so no, any 1 year drop in homelessness rate is unrelated. But the absolute number being low could be.
- ZoomerCretin 3y ago> Vacant land attracts higher taxes in Japan than land with buildings A hell of an incentive to build or sell your land to someone who will build. We've struggled with land speculation in the US for longer than we've been a country despite an obvious solution being available to fix this. We really could benefit from taxing land value alone, regardless of the value of any structures on top of it.
- skybrian 3y agoThere are lots of kinds of land. A vacant lot in a subdivision is one thing, but what about agricultural land? How about a wilderness land trust? Incentives are a blunt instrument. They necessarily push in the wrong direction sometimes, because they’re dumb rules. Beware one-size-fits-all solutions.
- idontpost 3y ago[dead]
- zdragnar 3y agoNeither agricultural nor wilderness trust land are counted as vacant. There's specific zoning and tax rules in most municipalities for them. Land that is zoned for some form of residential, commercial or industrial use but doesn't have building is considered to be vacant. The US doesn't have a shortage of land. However, vacant properties (residential or commercial buildings with no tenants) are indeed a problem in densely populated regions. For some areas, it's because the city population shrunk and nobody wants to live there (Detroit comes to mind as a semi-recent example) but for others it is speculative investors who don't want to be a landlord and are just betting the price will go up.
- skybrian 3y agoIn urban areas, sometimes they put in a parking lot, which I suppose doesn't count as vacant?
- 3y ago
- stephc_int13 3y agoThis is likely something that will happen globally, simply because of demographic trends. Large cities will also be impacted, with a delay, as this is where most young and educated people choose to live, for obvious reasons. In my opinion the housing market is the real demographic dampener, more than anything else, and it means that the long term trend for both demography and housing should be a slow oscillation around equilibrium.
- mynameisnoone 3y agoEverywhere except the SF Bay Area, Santa Cruz, Malibu, Boca Raton, and Maui. I think it's simply a communication and logistics problem to match people from other areas to empty homes. If anything, Japan and such should explicitly incentivize and encourage migration to declining areas to ensure their own tax base.
- ghaff 3y agoMany young and educated people in a relatively small number of cities until they decide to start a family and then historically they moved out. One also wonders what affect more remote/hybrid work will have. My cohort in the late 80s basically didn’t live in the city unless that’s where their job was which it wasn’t in the case of the computer industry. There’s nothing inevitable about young professionals wanting to live in cities and certainly not staying there.
- kube-system 3y agoRemote work is also giving professional workers more leisure time, and many are putting more thought into where they live as not just a place where they sleep, but also where they work and socialize. Also, for the people who prefer living in cities, there may be shifts in which cities are desired. Many mid-sized cities in the US existed because of the physical proximity required for the jobs there. e.g. In 2001 a worker may have moved to Cincinnati or St Louis because they got a job there. In 2024 a remote worker might move to NYC or Austin because they want to live in those places.
- 3y ago
- incomingpain 3y agoJapan's population decline does seem to suggest that they are going to have ridiculously affordable housing for the foreseeable future. But most likely a general thermodynamics of disrepair over the buildings to come as well. Don't own property in Japan.
- downrightmike 3y agoIt's the same as everywhere else. People will move to cities for work because that's where the jobs will be. So buy there.
- autoexec 3y ago> Don't own property in Japan. Maybe don't buy property as an investment, but if someone actually wants to live in Japan, finds a nice bit of land, and can affordably build a nice place for themself in a small town or countryside I doubt the declining population is going to make them think twice.
- spacebanana7 3y agoIf the decline becomes severe, areas can become difficult to live in. Having schools, transport and shops closing for lack of population sucks.
- incomingpain 3y ago>Maybe don't buy property as an investment, but if someone actually wants to live in Japan, finds a nice bit of land, and can affordably build a nice place for themself in a small town or countryside I doubt the declining population is going to make them think twice. Im going that extra bit here. You dont want to own even in non-investment purposes. You propose some solitude life, but that will be a rather bad decision as people will tend to move into the cities because of affordable housing.
- masklinn 3y agoSmall / detached residential buildings have never really been valuable in japan, with exceptions: because of natural disasters either you could not expect the building to last that long, or by the time you went around to buy it it was not up to code anymore and you had to tear it down to build a new one. Also while Japan's population declines overall, it also concentrates in a few metropolises, so rural land becomes cheaper, but also ever less attractive. Same with smaller cities. Japan is not going to have "ridiculously affordable housing for the foreseeable future", because the cheap housing is not where people are looking for housing. It's like saying that the US has affordable housing because NM has cheap land.
- spike021 3y agoIt doesn't seem like it went into much detail but while many of these end up advertised to foreigners as cheap homes to buy, they're not really easy to just live in unless you already live and work in Japan. Simply buying an Akiya home and moving to Japan won't be sufficient to live there. Someone with more knowledge than me could probably explain this better though.
- timr 3y agoA lot of the most ridiculous deals you see online require that you update the building. The whole reason they're selling the thing for pocket lint or the price of a cheap bento or whatever is because they don't want it sitting there rotting. Local municipalities are going to be very skeptical of anyone without residence buying such a home.
- aredox 3y agoExactly. That's also the deal behind those "1 € houses" - castles, even ! - that one can buy in Italy or Switzerland.
- Faaak 3y agoItaly yes, but not Switzerland for sure! Maybe France or Spain?
- aredox 3y agoThere was the same deal in Switzerland! https://www.thelocal.ch/20220104/gambarogno-the-latest-swiss-village-to-sell-houses-for-one-franc https://www.thelocal.ch/20220104/gambarogno-the-latest-swiss... It floundered, because it wasn't just practical to do anything in such a remote place.
- tstrimple 3y agoDon't count the Swiss out. Everyone likes building castles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_castles_and_fortresses_in_Switzerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_castles_and_fortresses...
- neaden 3y agoI've always heard that in Japan people don't generally buy a house to live in, preferring to knock it down and build a new construction. That seems like it would be an important contributor since this is more like how many empty lots there are. Edit: Here's an article about it that was posted last year https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36952874 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36952874
- coffeebeqn 3y agoThey at least used to build houses that they expect to get destroyed by natural disasters
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RockRobotRock 3y agoJust because the construction is cheap doesn't mean they're prone to falling down. They probably have the strictest earthquake codes in the world.
- underlipton 3y agoHistorically, not earthquakes; fire (or tsunami, if you're by the coast).
- kalleboo 3y ago> They probably have the strictest earthquake codes in the world. They do now, but a lot of these old houses that nobody wants predate them. The big earthquake-resistant building codes came in 1981 and 2000. Nobody would think anything of buying a house from 1980 in the west, but in Japan I would never do it (a large factor in the death toll of the Noto quake earlier this year was the high level of pre-1981 housing stock in the area). As newer, safer, houses start filling up the used housing stock I can totally see attitudes slowly changing.
- timr 3y ago
- Animats 3y agoThe US has about 15 million vacant homes. Look in Zillow for towns more than 20 miles from an Interstate. Also, there's Cleveland.
- neaden 3y agoUS has about 2.7 times more people, so equivalent to 24 million houses with US population.
- duffyjp 3y agoI lived in rural Japan for two years, and there were a number of akiya in my town and this was 20 years ago. I wasn't aware property taxes are higher on vacant lots but that explains things. The akiya I saw were 100% beyond repair, they looked like something out of a dystopian movie. I don't know the motive behind that tax law, but if they reversed it I bet a lot of those eyesores would be torn down and replaced with a little much needed green space. In my wife's neighborhood in suburban Tokyo there were several lots used as mini farms or fruit tree orchards. An infinitely better use of the space IMO.
- Klonoar 3y ago> I wasn't aware property taxes are higher on vacant lots but that explains things. If you look around Tokyo and see the dumbest set up parking lot possible, it's often a land owner who's just gotta put something there.
- underlipton 3y ago>I don't know the motive behind that tax law My guess: tearing all those buildings down and dealing with the trash and demolished materials takes a lot of labor and possibly a "supply chain" (since you're presumably centralizing it for dumping/incineration). But the circumstances that got you into the situation are 1) shrinking population (small labor force) and 2) too much space in the countryside that people already consider low-value. Essentially, you don't want to incentivize a demolition industry expansion to clear land no one wants anyway; there are more important things to be doing.
- freetime2 3y agoJapan is pretty good at demolishing homes. Two homes in my neighborhood were demolished in the past month - and it took a small team of maybe 4-5 workers a couple days for each home. It also looks like a lot of materials were separated out to be salvaged/recycled, too, although presumably a lot of it gets incinerated or becomes landfill. The cost varies, but according to this article [1] it is about about ¥1.2M-¥1.5M ($7.7K to $9.6K USD) on average to demolish a wooden house, although I suspect in rural areas it could be done for quite a bit less due to lower labor costs and not needing to worry as much about neighboring properties, directing traffic, etc. This reddit post from 5 years ago [2] says they were able to demolish an abandoned home and dispose of all the crap inside for ¥800,000 ($5.1K USD). So not exactly cheap, but not prohibitively expensive either I think if the government could provide the right incentives (e.g. combination of eliminating the tax reduction for abandoned home, and also maybe offer some subsidy). It definitely makes sense to prioritize homes where there is some demand for the land, though. There's a home in my neighborhood that has been vacant for 5+ years. And if they were to demolish the home and put the lot up for sale I feel they could sell it fairly quickly (less than 1 year) and easily recouperate the demolition costs and get ¥4M+ for the land. [1] https://www.arrowsrealty.com/column/how-much-is-the-cost-of-dismantling-a-detached-house https://www.arrowsrealty.com/column/how-much-is-the-cost-of-... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/japanlife/comments/9inwp1/demolition_costs/ https://www.reddit.com/r/japanlife/comments/9inwp1/demolitio...
- chaostheory 3y agoHas Japanese culture changed its mind over immigration yet? World demographics will likely get even worse if war spreads globally, including in Asia.
- resolutebat 3y agoThe tide has shifted over bringing in "temporary" workers for service industries. Convenience stores, hotels, restaurants etc are increasingly staffed by Nepalese, Vietnamese, Taiwanese etc. However, Japan remains very resistant to accepting permanent immigration.
- shiroiushi 3y agoIf you're a highly skilled worker, Japan is one of the easiest countries to immigrate to. Far, far easier (and cheaper) than immigrating to America. For unskilled workers, not so much, but it is easier for them to come work here than 10 years ago.
- swozey 3y agoI follow an American car drifter on youtube who moved to Japan in '22 and I've been shocked at how affordable his life is. He has kids and a wife and they'll go out to dinner and I think his usual bill is in the 20-30s for everyone. He said it's super hard to rent a house as a foreigner there, he lucked out and found a landlord that knew him from youtube and leased an absolutely beautiful townhouse for $1800 that would be well into the $5ks in my city. Glass garage doors, just decked out. Fruit though, he loves to show how expensive the fruit is and it's shockingly expensive. Not exact here but we're talking like $10-20 for a single melon. I'm not sure what city he's in, he seems to be IN a city and is in Tokyo a lot but I can't remember if he's IN tokyo. So maybe it's not Tokyo expensive but I'd always assumed Japan was incredibly expensive to live in, in general. If anyones interested he has a bunch of videos where he talks about the move, house tour, etc. He's one of my favorite youtubers and I'm not even that into the drift stuff. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDQkOPQXPLM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDQkOPQXPLM
- resolutebat 3y agoThose $20 melons (and it's not hard to find $100 melons) are for gifting purposes. Suburban neighborhoods will have little fruit and veg shops (yaoya) that sell all the fruit that's not perfect in every way at a steep discount.
- lmm 3y agoOrdinary supermarket fruit is still very expensive. Perhaps not $20, but apples are like JPY150 each (I'm sure there are discount shops, but I'm used to getting fruit with my normal groceries).
- shiroiushi 3y agoThat's about the same price as high-quality apples in America these days.
- hkmaxpro 3y agoFor comparison, China’s vacant home problem is at least 5 times Japan’s. China probably has so many vacant homes that even 1.4 billion people can’t fill, according to an estimate of a former deputy head of its National Bureau of Statistics last September [1]. If each vacant home is occupied by a household of 2.76 [2], there are about 510 million vacant homes in China. That’s 55 times Japan’s. But China’s population is only about 11 times Japan’s. And vacant homes only multiply over time [3]. [1] https://www.reuters.com/world/china/even-chinas-14-bln-population-cant-fill-all-its-vacant-homes-former-official-2023-09-23/ https://www.reuters.com/world/china/even-chinas-14-bln-popul... > How many vacant homes are there now? Each expert gives a very different number, with the most extreme believing the current number of vacant homes are enough for 3 billion people > That estimate might be a bit much, but 1.4 billion people probably can't fill them [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1087871/china-average-household-size-by-region-province/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1087871/china-average-ho... > The national average was 2.76 people per household in 2022. [3] https://www.tbsnews.net/international/empty-houses-hit-record-high-japan https://www.tbsnews.net/international/empty-houses-hit-recor... See the chart.
- lozenge 3y agoChina's vacant homes are new builds. "Since the 1980s, China has built enough new housing to re-house the entire population but the construction boom has become a self-sustaining, perpetual engine of construction for the sake of construction – supply with no demand. And there are not just miles of empty apartment blocks but entire “ghost cities” complete with office towers, hospitals, schools, futuristic airports, museums, universities, libraries, theaters, sports fields, and miles and miles of apartment towers and subdivisions of McMansions – but almost no people. (20) Twenty-one percent of China’s urban residents, the wealthy and middle classes, own two urban apartments, some own three or four – all bought for speculation, not to live in, not vacation homes. More than 22.4 percent of urban apartments and houses remained vacant in 2014. (21) By one estimate, more than 64 million surplus apartments had been built in China, enough to house almost half the population of the United States, yet millions more are under construction."
- hkmaxpro 3y ago
- gwbas1c 3y ago> Nevertheless, interest among foreign tourists in experiencing a stay in traditional Japanese accommodation is high, with demand currently outstripping supply, notes Sakata. A few years ago I noticed that Universal Studios in Japan, and nearby hotels, are cheaper than in LA. (I want to go to Super Mario World.) Unfortunately, flying my family to Japan is super-expensive. Anyway, this article makes me want to stay in a converted house in Japan.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shiroiushi 3y agoJust about everything in Japan is cheaper than in the US (esp. LA), sometimes dramatically so. It's not really that Japan is that cheap; the problem is that the US is just horrifically expensive these days, and Americans haven't quite figured that out yet.
- gwbas1c 3y ago> the US is just horrifically expensive these days, and Americans haven't quite figured that out yet It's called inflation, and the vast majority of Americans are painfully aware of it.
- shiroiushi 3y agoThe problem isn't inflation. The US was horrifically expensive well before the pandemic and the inflation it spawned. Americans think it's all normal: they think it's normal that medical care and medications cost a fortune, that an ambulance ride costs thousands, that you're supposed to "tip" 20-30% for service when you eat in a restaurant instead of just paying the advertised price, that there's huge but hidden taxes in many places, such as with hotel rooms, etc etc.
- kmeisthax 3y agoOk, I'm curious, so I'll ask the dumb question. If I were to buy one of these homes, how much of a bureaucratic nightmare would it be? For the record I don't live in Japan and have no viable immigration basis. Nor do I have a clue if they have a "no foreign property ownership" law like the one Canada just got. I do speak rudimentary Japanese and could probably bumble my way through the paperwork.
- rgmerk 3y agoI’ve seen stories in the Australian media about foreigners (Australians and Americans) buying these and restoring them. The story was set up by a couple of Americans who’ve set up a business assisting people to do it. Even taking into account the fact that they were trying to promote their business, it was clear that it’s not easy, but with patience it’s possible to end up with a pretty amazing house incredibly cheap - at least by, say, Californian standards. The thing I found strangest is that some of the houses featured were in beach towns not that far from Tokyo. If I were a middle-class Japanese family, I’d be buying one of these as a weekender.
- lmm 3y ago> The thing I found strangest is that some of the houses featured were in beach towns not that far from Tokyo. If I were a middle-class Japanese family, I’d be buying one of these as a weekender. You can buy it, but what would you do with it? There are plenty of cheap hotels in those towns. It's like buying a boat - it seems like such a fun idea, but ultimately it becomes just another thing tying you down while you pay to maintain it.
- rgmerk 3y agoYes, there are costs involved, but for some people, at some stages in one's life, owning a weekender is great if you can afford it. Taking a toddler to a hotel is a major PITA; taking a toddler to a holiday home, while I wouldn't call it "easy", is considerably less stressful.
- lovemenot 3y ago
- Tiktaalik 3y agoIt would be cheaper for me to buy a rural Japanese property and fly there every summer for the next thirty years than it would be to buy a recreational property in nearby cottage country. Really goes to show how remarkably expensive things have become in Canada. (As bad for the environment as this would be CO2 emission-wise, I have actually thought about doing this)
- freetime2 3y agoFor anyone who is curious to see what kind of abandoned homes are available, this websites aggregates abandoned home databases from municipalities across the country. It's in Japanese, but works pretty well with Chrome auto-translation. I personally would not recommend buying an abandoned home unless you are really looking for a lot of new worries in your life, but still fun to look at. https://www.homes.co.jp/akiyabank/ https://www.homes.co.jp/akiyabank/