7 ms·
Tesla failing to deliver Semi-trucks on time to PepsiCo, Sysco, UPS, and Walmart
- alephnerd 3y ago> Svein Sollie, the transportation director at ASKO Norway, the logistical arm of Norway's largest food retailer NorgesGruppen, used his personal credit card to put down an initial deposit on 10 of the Tesla Semis in 2017 but has not received any. "We are not happy with the situation at Tesla," Sollie said. "(It's) almost seven years now, it's a long time to wait.” ... Meanwhile, UPS, Walmart Canada, Sysco and Schneider National (SNDR.N), a transportation company that works for PepsiCo's Frito-Lay, said they are turning to Daimler Truck, maker of the Freightliner eCascadia. All four companies said they had begun to put dozens of eCascadia electric big rigs on the road.
- quijoteuniv 3y agoJust for reference ASKO delivers ALL the food around norway. And there is a general discontent in Norway with Tesla, plus solidarity with the union issue the workers had in Norway.
- EA-3167 3y agoWell Musk himself said that Tesla isn't a car company, it's a "Robotics and AI" company... maybe he just meant that they can't deliver on their orders. Then again they've failed to deliver on their automation promises too.
- rchaud 3y agoThey're likely pivoting to software as legacy automakers and newer Chinese entrants take the lead in mass production. Looking at how frequently Tesla is slashing prices, they may not be in the hardware business for too much longer.
- EA-3167 3y agoWhen it comes to software do they have any sort of edge/moat? I feel like Waymo and the rest could eat their lunch.
- rchaud 3y agoI would think a lot of patents related to battery tech and the charging infrastructure.
- surgical_fire 3y agoDo they own battery tech? Last I checked they relied on companies such as Panasonic for that.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoI do not think the time is right for electric semis. We need a few battery breakthroughs before it becomes reasonable. Right now they have to carry around far too much weight and bulk in batteries, and take far too long to charge, and the batteries don't have a long enough lifespan. Right now this whole effort feels performative. Its greenwashing. Some day it will likely become very practical, but that day is not today.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Right now they have to carry around far too much weight and bulk in batteries, and take far too long to charge, and the batteries don't have a long enough lifespan That's why electric Semis are heavily subsidized by the IRA - in order to incentivize the economies of scale needed to spur innovation in the space. It's a similar move to the PEV industry and Obama's, California's, and Texas' subsidies for it in the 2008-12 period establishing that market in North America.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoTo me this feels a bit backwards. The issue is not the semi part. It's nothing unique to semis. It's just that the scale of semis makes the flaws of current battery technology significantly more of an issue. Really, the funding should go more directly to general battery RnD - not eSemis specifically.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe time is right if you properly price the cost of diesel truck emissions. Certainly, you can always kick the can into the future if you're not willing to pay true costs and dump the externalities on everyone else. Current cost of CO2 is ~$185/ton emitted. > The social cost of carbon dioxide (SC-CO2) measures the monetized value of the damages to society caused by an incremental metric tonne of CO2 emissions and is a key metric informing climate policy. Used by governments and other decision-makers in benefit–cost analysis for over a decade, SC-CO2 estimates draw on climate science, economics, demography and other disciplines. However, a 2017 report by the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine1 (NASEM) highlighted that current SC-CO2 estimates no longer reflect the latest research. The report provided a series of recommendations for improving the scientific basis, transparency and uncertainty characterization of SC-CO2 estimates. Here we show that improved probabilistic socioeconomic projections, climate models, damage functions, and discounting methods that collectively reflect theoretically consistent valuation of risk, substantially increase estimates of the SC-CO2. Our preferred mean SC-CO2 estimate is $185 per tonne of CO2 ($44–$413 per tCO2: 5%–95% range, 2020 US dollars) at a near-term risk-free discount rate of 2%, a value 3.6 times higher than the US government’s current value of $51 per tCO2. Our estimates incorporate updated scientific understanding throughout all components of SC-CO2 estimation in the new open-source Greenhouse Gas Impact Value Estimator (GIVE) model, in a manner fully responsive to the near-term NASEM recommendations. Our higher SC-CO2 values, compared with estimates currently used in policy evaluation, substantially increase the estimated benefits of greenhouse gas mitigation and thereby increase the expected net benefits of more stringent climate policies. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05224-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05224-9
- flerchin 3y agoThe article lays the blame at battery production, and servicing rollout. Both of which seem solveable. Sure would be nice to have a datapoint around how many batteries they need vs how many they are producing.
- willsmith72 3y agoi for one am shocked that an elon company would fail to meet a publicly-declared deadline on the plus side, having competition, especially from the mercedes subsidiary in daimler, is a great thing
- tombert 3y agoI think Elon operates on a different temporal plane than regular humans. When he says "next year", that means "I have no fucking idea" or "like ten years from now maybe?" At some point though, it's hard to even blame him; investors keep enabling him. It's extremely easy to find all the cases of outright dishonesty that he's said (e.g. "We'll have full self driving next year", every year since like 2018), investors should really know about this, and they still give him money. I don't really get it, outside of S&P500 ETFs that I don't really control the strategy of, I won't give Tesla any money, since it seems like everything Musk does is kind of corner-cut. The Cybertruck release epitomizes this, where they're charging an extra $20,000 for the potential of a Full Self Driving feature eventually just seems cartoonish, and maybe getting to fraudulent territory? (IANAL)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xenadu02 3y agoEven if we assume you are correct this is a great example of being correct and losing a lot of money - and boy howdy are there lots of ways to be 100% right about something and losing out. I invested in Tesla's IPO with some chump change (mostly because I was a lot poorer then). $4000 turned into $200k+, at which point I sold half. So perhaps you are right but I'm $100k cash / $100k paper richer for being "wrong". Being right won't pay your rent or keep you warm, but it can sometimes help you miss out on a lot of gains. See my other comment for my bearish negative thoughts on Tesla and Elon. On the positive side they have crossed into volume production territory. The place where suppliers not only return your phone calls they send people to ask you for meetings and offer discounts not available to the plebs. They have great brand awareness. They have a best-selling vehicle that continues to sell every single one that rolls off their 100% full production lines (at least in the US, not sure about elsewhere). That's demand and inventory positions other car makers would kill for. Tesla foresaw battery production as being limiting and their joint venture with Panasonic in Arizona has given them battery supply and battery economics that other automakers simply can't match right now no matter how much they try. There is a reason investors are bullish on Telsa. Twitter has been a massive distraction for Elon. He seems to have surrounded himself with yes-men and enablers who just want to cash in on him. None of this is good but in a way the Twitter distraction has kept him more hands-off from Tesla than in the past so it may end up being a blessing in disguise.
- JanSolo 3y agoThe critical part of this article is this: "But in June 2023, Musk said at an energy conference that "there just weren't enough batteries" for Tesla to reach "volume production" of the truck." It looks like battery production is the major constraint on Teslas endeavours. Someone at Tesla clearly did the math on ROI-per-cell and decided that Semis just don't pay as well as Cybertrucks or Powerwalls. That's why they're starving the Semi operation until they can spin up more battery production.
- Workaccount2 3y agoThe craziest thing about Tesla is that people still believe what musk says. I agree it makes sense that battery production is the limiting factor, but my ability to trust what Musk says is close to zero.
- harborsong 3y agoThe craziest thing is, regardless how people feel about politics, Musk has achieved a lot for technology yet people in technology forums disparage him. I guess politics trumps technology.
- uuddlrlrbaba 3y agoThe parroted introduction has me reading this comment in bad faith, but I'll bite anyway. What are some of his personal tech achievements? Emphasis on personal.
- PaywallBuster 3y agoNonetheless I have to agree with both you and parent reply it's possible if it wasn't or trade wars it would've been easy to source batteries from china but who can control geo politics :)
- rchaud 3y agoBut Musk himself has said that American EV makers can't compete against Chinese EVs without trade barriers. Barriers that western governments have been more than happy to establish. > "If there are no trade barriers established, they will pretty much demolish most other car companies in the world," he said. "They're extremely good." https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/tesla-ceo-musk-chinese-ev-firms-will-demolish-rivals-without-trade-barriers-2024-01-25/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/tesla-...
- e44858 3y agoOne positive effect of these delays is that competitors are appearing with elctric trucks that respect your right to repair: https://www.edisonmotors.ca/edison-history https://www.edisonmotors.ca/edison-history
- nomilk 3y agoTelsa's behind schedule, but the scale of the ambition is frankly wild: > In October 2022, Musk told investors that his goal was to make 50,000 Semis in 2024. If they achieve a tenth of it 5 years' late, that's still incredibly good for humanity.
- peutetre 3y agoOr just buy from another company that can deliver EV trucks right now (Volvo, Scania, MAN, Mercedes, etc.).
- jojobas 3y agoThat's a big if, just like anything else Musk said was production ready years ago.
- rchaud 3y agoMeanwhile customers take their business to a competitor, as is happening here. What is ambitiousness worth if the product/delivery is delayed by years and has to be discounted heavily to chase market share?
- rsynnott 3y agoSo, 5,000 electric semi trucks in 2029? I mean, I would think that would be a drop in the bucket. Volvo alone appears to have delivered 2,000 of them last year.
- unregistereddev 3y agoIn this case that's not enough. When an incredibly good consumer product arrives 5 years late, consumers can buy something else in the meantime. They have freedom of choice in an open market. When a B2B product shows up 5 years late (and TFA indicates it's over 7 years late), it causes actual damage to the purchaser - and arguably to humanity. These contracts typically include exclusivity clauses. They lock PepsiCo in, preventing them from purchasing electric semis from other companies that ramp up production sooner. PepsiCo has to lawyer up and nullify the contract with Tesla in order to purchase electric semis from companies other than Tesla. Meanwhile, So Tesla is locking companies into contracts, failing to deliver, and leaving them in the lurch in the meantime. Cleaner transportation and fewer emissions is good for humanity - so let's celebrate the companies that are actually bringing us electric semis. The Freightliner eCascadia, Volvo VNR, Kenworth EV, and BYD 8TT are all in production. The eCascadia and the VNR are each being produced in higher volumes than the Tesla Semi.
- nimbius 3y agodiesel engine mechanic here. ive been following the tesla "truck" thing for about a year now and it seems pretty miserable. i dont have the sources, but from several blogs and trade rags (trucking news, professional driver, etc..) ive read the situation seems like it wasnt very well thought out. - first callout was OTR longhauls. Musk clearly didnt want his trucks stuck as lot-tenders where they would work brilliantly, he wanted publicity on the road. - longhauls cancelled because obvious infrastructure limitations. batteries and motors failing more frequently due to the load and the range. reports of using tesla consumer vehicle components in the drivetrain. switch to regional routes - regional routes failing between AZ/CA due to thermal and performance issues. range issues. - professional drivers hate these trucks. worse than international (truck brand). center-seating makes visibility, toll booths and logbook checks a chore. side mirrors are static and too high. Musk needs to come back to earth. OTR (over the road, long hauls of 1800 miles) is a non-starter and will never work with current technology. professional drivers can not lose 30 minutes every 400 miles on these routes to charge, they will miss all their drop times. make the tesla semi truck a lot tender. massive power to realign and arrange heavy trailers all day long in a parking lot or warehouse lot. bonus points: make the tesla semi truck a driverless lot tender since lot-tenders dont need a CDL. EDIT: If you want to see something I think the actual trucking industry is getting excited about, check out Edison motors. They're running a hybrid diesel/electric design that would work wonderfully for things like clean-air city driving where the batteries are getting topped up at every stop and speeds are under 50mph, and a small diesel generator when the batteries need a charge. this is similar to how Great Western Rail in the UK runs their trains (just with batteries) and still supports a traditional truck drivetrain. Its designed to be punished from what i can see...the primary application is as a logging rig. https://www.edisonmotors.ca/ https://www.edisonmotors.ca/
- Tokkemon 3y agoBuild more freight rail instead.
- jojobas 3y agoRail was made obsolete overnight by the Hyperloop, remember?
- pat2man 3y agoAmerican actually has the largest freight rail network in the world. In theory electric trucks would pair great with our freight rail network though. Still need to get from rail to stores and homes
- shepherdjerred 3y agoIsn't a lot of long-haul transport still done via truck? Like you noted, last-mile won't go away, but maybe there is still room for improvement with rail. I don't care how much I'm taxed if it means the US will use it for decent transportation that isn't car-based.
- Tokkemon 3y agoYes we do, but it's not nearly enough to cover every major town and county. Stupid flaws in the system like the Selkirk hurdle should be systemically removed.
- 3y ago
- nashashmi 3y agoAs a Bridge Engineer, I am not looking forward to massively heavy battery carrying truck damaging the roadways.
- bloopernova 3y agoAlong with all the far heavier electric SUVs and "light" trucks. Is there any solution to this kind of increase in weight apart from "build stronger roads/bridges"?
- nashashmi 3y agoThere is the possibility of reducing the number of lanes.
- sidcool 3y agoFrom the article, it seems the problem is not with the technology of the Semi. It's the battery production. So solvable I feel.
- xyst 3y agoTesla needs a change of ownership/leadership. It was fun when I pumped my portfolio with a quick $10K (0dte TSLA put options) when the ceo would say some controversial shit on Twitter (before the leveraged buyout) or smoke weed during after hours with some random podcaster. But the entertainment is over and the constant news coverage is just spam and reiteration over what we know about this company and its products: very shiny things, but like the CEO’s ego, they are very fragile and have a tendency to be unreliable; or just not live up to the hype.
- stronglikedan 3y agoThat's just a strawman. These are complex issues with complex problems. He's doing fine with the resources he has. Unfortunately, resources are naturally constrained.
- cush 3y ago> He's doing fine … Unfortunately, resources are naturally constrained His entire job is understanding those constraints and ensuring they don’t get in the way of creating an actual shipping product. When they do, he is not fine, he’s failing.
- cactusplant7374 3y ago> He's doing fine with the resources he has. He isn't devoting enough time to Tesla. He is distracted by Twitter and his other companies.
- tim333 3y agoI was going to say. Back when he was sleeping on the factory floor to get production issues sorted he was doing good stuff for Tesla. Not so much since Twitter/X.
- mattmaroon 3y agoThis had to have been expected since everything they have ever made has been delivered years late. Elon is nothing if not overly optimistic about timelines.
- cush 3y agoOr never delivered at all. Expectations can change. As other EV manufacturers have surpassed Tesla on every front, consumer patience has worn thin.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hedora 3y agoThe article says eCascadia's are shipping. Here's the product page: https://www.freightliner.com/trucks/ecascadia/ https://www.freightliner.com/trucks/ecascadia/ They're also offering charging logistics services, etc. The main innovations on the truck cab are creature comforts for the driver, and safety features like blind spot detection. That looks like a winning strategy to me. They're also building lower range trucks, which makes sense. They can build more trucks with the same battery supply, and local deliveries are a much better fit for current EV trucks than long range routes. The charge time is 90 minutes for about 200 miles of range, so it's pretty clear this is for short routes. edit: I wonder how much wattage it takes to charge one of these things in 90 minutes. Whatever it is, it's about 1/3 as much as a 30 minute charger would be. Since they're helping out with logistics, it wouldn't surprise me if building faster chargers is currently infeasible.
- Symbiote 3y ago"Up to 180 kW with single port charging / up to 270 kW, with dual port charging." There are 400 kW chargers in use, so it must be some other reason.