17 ms·
The walls of Apple's garden are tumbling down
- ukuina 3y agoIt was very surprising that Apple did not strong-arm the EU by threatening to pull out of the area. The short-term loss of revenue from leaving the EU is nothing compared to the long-term decline this is going to cause in Apple's services/subscriptions revenue if the iPhone is commoditized.
- cjk2 3y agoThere is no way Apple would consider even suggesting pulling out of the EU. The shareholders would hang the entire CXO class in a nanosecond if they even mentioned it.
- da768 3y agoIf Android becomes the only platform with a worldwide reach, no one's going to bother writing apps for iOS anymore.
- rootusrootus 3y agoThat's a reach. If you want to make money in mobile apps, you target the US first. We could cut out the entirety of the rest of the world and the US market would still be plenty big enough to drive a lot of developers.
- beardyw 3y agoYes and no. iPhone only has about 25% of the world market, but developers are keen to develop for them because users are more willing to pay for apps. Reach isn't the same as value.
- wetpaws 3y ago[dead]
- 4ad 3y agoThere are plenty iOS-only apps already. Reach is worthless if you can't monetize it. iOS users simply bring in more money.
- robocat 3y ago> no one's going to bother writing apps for iOS anymore Bullshit. By that logic there would be no Mac specific software. There was Mac software when Macs were 1% or less of computers. 2022: 74% of computers worldwide run on Windows, according to StatCounter. This dwarfs macOS, which accounts for 15%
- pavlov 3y agoA quarter of Apple’s revenue is from Europe. (This number includes the UK and a few other smaller non-EU markets, but it’s close enough for comparison purposes.) I don’t see what would be “short-term” about pulling out of this market entirely. If they lost 25% of their revenue, they’d have to increase revenue in other markets by 33% to make up for it. Where is that going to come from?
- cydonian_monk 3y agoThis depends on how high the operating costs are in Europe. If their profits are approaching zero in the market, pulling out of it entirely would have less of an impact. Obviously that isn't the case, but operating costs for the market also aren't zero.
- layer8 3y agoApple gets 25% of their revenue from Europe, but only 7% of their app store revenue. This means that most of their Europe revenue is from hardware and AppleCare/services. Even if they opened up the app store completely, they would lose much less than when pulling out entirely. The fact that they work so hard at complicated solutions in order to open up the app store as little as possible shows that they think it’s worth it.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoA lot of the value proposition of owning an Apple device is that it doesn’t get bogged down by rogue software like other phones. So that 25% of revenue that doesn’t involve App Store revenue can still go down if they mess up the App Store too much. But I think as long as rogue apps is something you have to opt into with full knowledge of the consequences, it should be fine.
- aetherson 3y agoFrom Europe, yes, but less is from the EU. They don't break this out in public statements so we can only guess at the numbers, but less than 25%.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jillesvangurp 3y agoThey tried and lost. They can threaten all they want. The EU would let them and good riddance as far as we're concerned. But there is this pesky notion that it's a huge market and Apple earns a lot of money there. So, they really can't walk away from that. For the same reason they play by Chinese rules in China. Because it's a big market and they need to be in on that as well. And if you think the EU is picky, the Chinese are much worse. And of course there's a whole world outside the EU and China that is paying attention as well. Apple's negotiation position simply is not that strong. It has no real leverage. And Apple as a US only company would not be anywhere near it's current size and importance. Share holders would revolt. R&D investment would implode. It has to be an international company for it to justify its share price. So, it has to adjust and can't afford to exit markets. It has no choice.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> The EU would let them and good riddance as far as we're concerned. But there is this pesky notion that it's a huge market and Apple earns a lot of money there. So, they really can't walk away from that. Does that not seem contradictory to you? If it's a huge market they make a lot of money in, then there's by definition a lot of people who don't think "good riddance" if they leave. Apple has more leverage than you give them credit for.
- alangibson 3y agoAmerican living in Europe here. in the EU, you can't just apply economic logic to everything like you can in the US. Policymakers will absolutely piss off a huge number of people over some basic principle. Look for instance at Germany's willingness to burn it's industrial base to the ground over Ukraine.
- geoka9 3y agoI would argue it's not (just) over Ukraine that Germany has finally decided to wean itself off the unrealistically cheap natural gas from Russia. In fact, the writing has been on the wall for decades; Russian leadership never made a big secret out of the fact that they considered their gas industry a geopolitical weapon. It took a big scare and popular demand to stop the wholesale selling out of the German political class to Russia.
- tebbers 3y agoI honestly doubt opening up the App Store will cause much of a hit. Maybe 5% of users will download another App Store.
- jncfhnb 3y agoAnd those users will be the whales who are benefiting from lower prices the most.
- kranke155 3y agoYes they would leave something like 1/3 to 1/5 of the global revenue, sure that sounds brilliant.
- cjk2 3y agoI’ve got to be honest while I appreciate the direction they are forced in, I have yet to find anyone outside the tech industry who actually knows or gives a crap. Also the only reason Epic and Spotify are after them is not some altruistic reason but they want to be the guys charging the 30% margin. It’s a bit of a grey victory but I’ll take it.
- stale2002 3y agoThat sounds horrible. Maybe Apple should open up their ecosystem, that way multiple other app stores can compete and drive that percentage price down to zero.
- joecot 3y ago> I have yet to find anyone outside the tech industry who actually knows or gives a crap. Lots of school kids who get mocked for being "Green Texters" with crummy images and videos in their group texts. They really want their parents to shell out for an iPhone so it stops. Just because non-tech people don't know the cause, doesn't mean it doesn't affect them.
- abaymado 3y agoThis is an outrageous take. Is iMessage the only group messaging app? If Apple was gate keeping all group messaging, I could see your point.
- jpalawaga 3y agono, it's not, but is the default that works well for a large chunk of people, with an (intentionally) poorly degrading experience if one person in the group is not with the "in-crowd." Yes, life would be better if everyone mutually agreed to use things crossplatform all of the time. but they don't/haven't, so there is this friction.
- jwagenet 3y agoBlame the carriers for not implementing rcs and getting stuck in horrible mms. Then blame Apple if they don’t implement it.
- s1k3s 3y ago> Apple executive Eddy Cue pushed for an Android iMessage app in 2016, but Craig Federighi responded in an internal email that “iMessage on Android would simply serve to remove an obstacle to iPhone families giving their kids Android phones.” This conversation happened 8 years ago and it was about a product released 12 years ago. If anything, this shows how slow regulators are before they take any action and how they are effectively contributing to building the garden walls, through inaction.
- aurareturn 3y agoThe truth is, all businesses do what Craig suggested. AirBnB isn't opening up their platform to Expedia. Meta isn't allowing your Instagram data to be accessed by another platform. Your own company isn't voluntarily making it easier for its customers to leave.
- s1k3s 3y agoExactly. It should be expected from any company to do this, which is why I'm blaming the regulatory agencies for being too slow to act.
- talldayo 3y agoWell, yes. It's a great reason to not let businesses decide on these things, because their petty interpretation will always override a communal solution. Once you reach Apple's scale, you shouldn't expect to start replacing stuff like SMS with a proprietary alternative and get away with it.
- hyperbovine 3y agoMaybe Apple’s “scale” is because its users do not enjoy being shackled to crappy SMS?
- talldayo 3y agoMaybe so; it doesn't really matter when you're looking at damages. It's Apple's job to solve interoperability with their own platform, and not only have they failed to provide SMS-levels of interop, they actively work against it to promote ulterior products. It's exactly the sort of anticompetitive bundling that harms the market without improving competition. Maybe Ma Bell's success was in-part due to their free long-distance calls. It's kinda moot speculation when you look at their top-down business strategy though.
- swingingFlyFish 3y agoI think when companies become a 'necessity' like this, they have to be regulated or broken up. I'm not a big fan of Apple taking a commission if you port an app to their phone and I loathe the idea of having to use iCloud if I want to use Apple Pay, in fact, can't stand the idea of a phone company being my credit card company/bank either. And don't get me started on non standard USB...what was that? I applaud the EU stepping in and quite frankly i'm looking forward to Apple being broken up. It's that time.
- pmarreck 3y agoI disagree. _I_ think that when companies become a "necessity" like this, they end up resting on their laurels because they won the economic game. And what happens next will happen regardless of regulation or not: They will begin their long but steady decline into irrelevance. I state this as a huge Apple fan since 1984 when my family bought the first Mac: The best things to ever happen to Apple were almost dying in 1997, and (essentially, despite the M chips being fantastic technologically) losing the PC war (which I will argue was not due to price, but to 2 things: 1) failure to embrace the AAA gaming market and thus the mindshare of the next generation, and 2) re-closing the Mac platform after it was open, which it only did because the news kept reporting only on the impact to Apple sales and not the overall Mac market, which was actually growing at the time!) > And don't get me started on non standard USB Do you mean Lightning? That was a massive improvement (both physically in terms of design, by being reversible and supporting higher voltages as well as being durable) on both mini and micro USB and came out long before USB-C existed. And to this day, Apple devices are STILL some of the few devices that fully support the USB-C spec, as opposed to all the Chinese crapware that uses a USB-C plug but will fail to charge when plugged into anything but a USB-A charger because someone picked the cheap way out.
- pertymcpert 3y agolmao some strong feelings there. Lightning is a brilliant port.
- ambichook 3y agolightning was brilliant when it was introduced, but now its just USB-C but nonstandard
- bugbuddy 3y ago[flagged]
- EgoIncarnate 3y agoCan you explain? My intution and rough calculations say you are wrong. ChatGPT agrees "To determine the long-term annual sales of phones for a company with a constant customer base of 1 billion, where each customer upgrades at different intervals, you first need to know the average replacement interval, T years. The annual sales can then be calculated as 1,000,000,000 divided by T. For example, if customers upgrade every 2 years on average, the company would sell approximately 500 million phones per year. This approach assumes the replacement intervals are consistent or average to T years across all customers."
- bugbuddy 3y agoI was wrong. It was a joke. Please don’t tell the phone manufacturers this. I want my phone to last at least a few years.
- Bjorkbat 3y agoSomething I keep thinking about is how we’re seeing the end of what I call the “tech zeitgeist”. Started upon realizing that we‘ve likely seen the end of the social network era. No new social networking startups have popped-off in a while, and the recent ones are arguably more about connecting you to entertainers than friends. Besides that, a lot of the tech ideas from 2012-2020 have kind of fizzled out. 3D printing will likely never enter the mainstream. VR/AR has failed to launch. In broad strokes, everything has either reached maturity or faded away. AI is the one exception it seems, and when you realize that you start to realize that all the hype and money being poured into AI may be more out of desperation than anything else. It’s AI or nothing it seems. And then, you have Apple at what is arguably its most vulnerable, while many other tech giants go through some kind of enshittification phase. Can’t wait for the end personally.
- xyzzy123 3y agoI notice you didn't mention drones...
- pjmlp 3y agoThey are turning into a military success in Eastern Europe.
- delfinom 3y agoThe online tech space is reaching maturity. It went from nothing in the 90s to the global scale industry we have today. The winners have been chosen and the reality is infinite growth does not exist, infinite ideas do not exist. But for 2 decades it seemed like tech was the be it all path for infinite growth. VCs pumped in hundreds of billions of dollars into the industry. Marketing painted everything as the next big thing as the money flowed and you had 3000 clone startups for every potential SaaS. The money tap has run out (interest rates being one factor, but cracks were showing even before this), the bills are coming due. The industry is consolidating. AI however is the last big hurrah for the industry. Investors and companies see it potentially as a big new exlosive growth space. Yes, the entire stock market right now in the US is being held up by all the AI sentiment. Though it's starting to deflate.
- fidotron 3y agoThe thing people love forgetting is a huge part of the iPhone success is based on the North American cellular comms industry being a trustless disaster area. The deal Apple did with AT&T opened the floodgates. Android was initially designed so that operators could customise it. The idea was apps were developed (and sold) only by operators, and everything else would be via the browser. If you had used a Nokia device in the EU in 2005 and then the exact same model in the customised form released on a US carrier you'd understand why this was such a terrible idea. The exclusion of carriers from being able to make modifications to the phone was, and remains, an active feature for end users. People keep having to learn that developers cannot be trusted either, someone somewhere will always trend towards the very worst thing they can do, and you need look no further than this forum for the levels of avarice which have overrun the tech industry. The EU regulators live in a parallel universe where they're all dependent on WhatsApp as they've never truly internalised that there is no such thing as a free lunch and that people see them as easy marks.
- api 3y agoI summarize the second point as “the Internet is a dark forest.” If it’s bad and it can be done it will be done, and at scale.
- hn_version_0023 3y agoYou have neatly summarized why I feel strongly that the Internet has become a liability to humanity. I have no illusions that we can shut it down or walk away… but on a personal level I am trying harder than ever to remove it from my own life. If I can stay off Reddit, well, I can eventually remove it all I think!
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- api 3y agoUse it for the things it’s useful for and avoid the addictionware, rage bait, gambling, and other trash.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoOne thing that I haven’t seen mentioned in discussions of communications tech monopoly (or “monopoly” in many cases) is the risk of future political censorship by a hypothetical future evil Apple. Centralized market power here isn’t just about unfair profits or bad products, it’s also about control of information (and therefore control of minds).
- sircastor 3y agoI think this is because we haven’t really seen it. Though there is a subset of the right wing that’s been saying exactly this is happening, to them in the context of Facebook and Twitter. I don’t recall seeing any convincing evidence though.
- fsflover 3y agoAFAIK we did see how Apple banned political apps in China and Russia.
- sircastor 3y agoYes, but this is not “Evil Apple”, but the respective governments of those countries forcing Apple to take the action on penalty of being ejected from and country. This is abusive government, not abusive corporation (though it’s arguable that an appeasing company might as well be evil.)
- fsflover 3y agoYes, but it perfectly demonstrates what could happen, and people affected don't care about the reason. The actual problem is the monopoly. Also try to force GNU/Linux to remove some packages.
- smokel 3y agoThere is a lot of discussion going on about this. Most of it is not very constructive, but "power structure" research is a scientific thing that might interest you.
- ChilledTonic 3y agoI’ve been a recent convert to the iPhone. It gives me a unique perspective since I’ve spent almost my entire life in the Android ecosystem. I first bought an iPhone 5c on a whim, which is well out of support by apple, 5 versions behind the modern iOS. If you turn it on, all the default Apple apps work, in 2024. You can stream Apple Music and download podcasts with no App Store whatsoever. It’s a powerful little device, more then ten years later. Compare this to the Android system, where google has wholesale deprecated their podcasts app. You’ll have to find a 3rd party one if you want to access that functionality. The point I’m trying to make is that for Joe Consumer, everything on an iPhone just works. Modification isn’t even something they consider doing. In the end, Epic and Spotify get a fat 30% boost in revenue and nobody notices anything different.
- s1k3s 3y agoThis has nothing to do with the classic Apple vs Android debate. It's about Apple's practices of pushing people to purchase the iPhone even if they might not want to.
- ChilledTonic 3y agoRight, and I’m trying to state that those practices are ancillary at best reasons when the end user just sees a functional phone. Joe Consumer doesn’t even notice the garden has walls.
- layer8 3y agoJust wait a bit, you will encounter lots of stuff that doesn’t work, or that has you jump through hoops or buy a subscription, soon enough.
- nozzlegear 3y agoCan you name some examples, instead of being vague?
- 3y ago
- bozhark 3y agoApple grew from Big Brother into it’s own Big Sister
- stephc_int13 3y agoBeing developer-hostile has always been part of Apple's identity, one unfortunate side of Steve Jobs's hubris enabled this stance, but it has worsened considerably under Tim Cook. The eccentric and slightly authoritarian leader knew how to offer just enough to sweeten the deal. Under Cook, on the other hand, Apple has turned tone-deaf and has continuously played hardball, making numerous faux pas along the way. I believe that developers good to be considerably worse now, and even if the numbers don't speak loudly yet, I have no doubt they will.
- VelesDude 3y agoI always sucks when you have to quote Steve Ballmers but "Developers! Developers! Developers! Developers! Developers!". At least in principal Microsoft used to get it. I think they knew that without developers, Windows would be nowhere. Apple sort of gets it with the App store but not as deeply.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ripvanwinkle 3y agoAs a newish user of Apple (Macbook and the IPad mini) it was not as big a leap from Android and Windows as I had feared. I still live in Google services including Gboard on the IPad mini and apart from klutzing around with system settings occasionally the mini feels "not terribly different" from the android devices I use. The Macbook is a bigger challenge though. I only picked the mini because I couldn't get the same performance with that form factor in Android. I only entertained the mini because I was forced to use a Macbook for work and realized that apart from annoyances with keyboard shortcuts and system settings I could continue to live in a Firefox + Chrome + Edge + Google services ecosystem. I will now definitely consider Apple hardware if I don't find a good fit in the Android + Windows world
- phmqk76 3y agoAnd yet, in Apple’s preferred world, they suck up 30% of all of the revenue made by developers who develop for their devices. The Mac model may not exist in 10 years if Apple can get rid of it and replace it with a locked down App Store from which they charge rents.
- baerrie 3y agoI think the iphone becoming a commodity means the apps themselves are more of the focus. I am surprised Apple never put work into making killer social media app, a search engine, etc. these things live beyond the lifecycle of phones
- nox101 3y agoIMO most people here seem to be missing the point. The point is not directly about consumers or the choice between Android and iPhone. The point is about Apple (and Google's) market power. Imagine a self driving car that became popular. Imagine that car manufacture asking stores to sign up for a account to register their store so the car will know where to drive users. Imagine the experience using the car is amazing and it's widely successful. Imagine car company then demanding 30% of all sales any store the store drives someone, refuse to pay the 30% and the car will stop showing the store as a destination. Their market is so large, if you refuse to pay you immediately lose 40-60% of your customers. This is the power that Apple and Google have. It has nothing to do with choice in phones. It has to do with no app can escape this 30% tax on their business because the 2 gatekeepers control the entire market. There are many similar issues but they all boil down to market power over hundreds of thousands of companies, not phone choice.
- lamontcg 3y agoIn principle I like Apple being legally forced to crack open all their walled gardens, and I hate how far they've come from the open and hackable original Apple computers. In practice, I worry that they're going to imminently pivot to a more Google like model of selling their customers out to any third party with cash. Right now they have the means to do that, but they're selling privacy as one of their features and they've been largely benevolent with your data. The end result of opening up the walled garden could be the rapid Enshittification of Apple.
- idle_zealot 3y ago> I worry that they're going to imminently pivot to a more Google like model of selling their customers out to any third party with cash No need to worry about that happening in the future; it's already happening! iOS collects user data and builds an advertising profile for each user. This is used to sell ad space in the App Store.
- VelesDude 3y agoIt is only a matter of time until Apple ends up selling this data to 3rd parties. The quarterly market performance demands endless growth.
- VelesDude 3y agoJobs always hated that the original Apple 2 had expansion slots. Woz wanted them because it would allow folks other than Apple to make things. You know, Woz being Woz. Those expansion slots allowed Apple 2 to become what it was and practically made the foundation of Apple. Jobs ended up tolerating expansion slots but tried to minimize their availability where ever possible.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI think this article is overstating the effect that Apple's walls have on lock-in effect. I'm an Android user, and a little less than a year ago I actually bought an iPhone, specifically due to Apple's iMessage lock-in (nearly all of my friends have iPhones, and the especially broken group messaging between iMessage and Android was the primary driver of my desire to get an iPhone). Except the problem was that, after over a decade on Android, I had zero desire to switch over all of my data and apps over to iPhone. For better or worse the "Google ecosystem" is where all my stuff lives and I just didn't have a desire to spend a bunch of effort just to switch. I ended up giving the iPhone as a gift to an iOS-loving family member. That's the thing about both iOS and Android platforms - I think you'll find anyone who has been in those platforms for more than a couple years will be extremely reluctant to switch just due to the effort. Our cell phones are often the center of our digital lives now: apps, headphones, watches, etc. The lock-in I think is more from that "ecosystem effect" than any amount of particular lock down.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoYou're right that lock-in isn't just about one application. Like a wall, it's made up of multiple bricks. But different bricks matter more to different customers: for some people (usually teenagers who have relatively little data invested in other apps) the blue-bubbles iMessage is the most important brick, for older users it's usually the piles of data in cloud services, password manager, photo library or purchased media. Typically companies use some features to bring people into their ecosystem, then gradually them in with all the others. Unfortunately our anti-trust laws were written in the 19th century, so they deal with very specific types of anti-competitive behavior. Modern tech firms basically grew up in an environment where the goal was to maintain the absolute minimal level of competition and user choice that stays within the law.
- mirsadm 3y agoAll of Google's services are also on iOS, often the apps work better than on Android. There is no barrier to switching.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago
- tammer 3y agoI’ve come full circle on this but I now think native applications on smartphones was a mistake. There is no technological reason why applications can’t be distributed as PWA packages similar to the days prior to the App Store. This would serve two important functions: 1. Remove most if not all distribution monopoly concerns 2. Create application standards that function nearly identically across the myriad of screen sizes and input types that are now available. The current status quo of some service that makes my life easier or better only being available in a browser or only available on one or two of my devices (or, most often, available in a few ways but only bug-free or full-featured in only one method of access) isn’t the future I want.
- asddubs 3y agomy half-hearted counterpoints: 1. what about something like a usb flir heat camera? yes i know webusb exists, but having to go to a website to use a peripheral (and give it permissions to that peripheral) is not ideal 2. apps can change on you at any point, potentially maliciously. I'm not naive enough to think the app store will catch this kind of thing every time, but at least you have control over updating apps, and some guarantees that everyone gets the same binary 3. you can kiss any sort of ui-cohesion goodbye
- Gigachad 3y agoOS cohesion/themes are already kind of a dead idea. These days the priority is cohesion within the app and platform. When I open Discord, it looks basically the same on Android, iOS, Mac, Linux, Windows, and web. If I know where something is on one platform, I can find it on all the others. I don't care that Discord on Mac doesn't look like Spotify on Mac. The others are also kind of mute points, No one is auditing app updates, and I'm not sure how an app can be more trusted with access to a usb/bluetooth device than a website. they are both 3rd party programs doing the same thing.
- skydhash 3y agoOne of the plus of platform cohesion is that you don’t have to learn the same thing twice while you’re on the same platform. I know that as soon as I press CMD+<Comma>, I get in the settings of the app. Option+CMD+T, will toggle the toolbar if they have any, and you can customize it to your liking. But today, applications wants you to live in their space, so they make things harder to switch from it. No one cares that Discord on Windows looks the same as on macOS, as most people only use one platform, if you have to hunt for everything as it doesn’t want to use the menubar. And for app updates, people do. I can hold on on updates until I’m sure it’s good to use. You spend a month not using a web app, and it’s become something alien.
- jen729w 3y agoMeanwhile Paul Thurrott loves the MacBook Air and sings the praises of Apple’s integrated ecosystem. https://www.thurrott.com/mobile/mac-and-macos/301371/apple-macbook-air-15-inch-m3-review https://www.thurrott.com/mobile/mac-and-macos/301371/apple-m... So the truth, as usual, probably lies in the middle.
- FrostKiwi 3y agoDeep into a Mixed Reality project with WebXR right now. So sick of everything working on Meta Quests and even cheap Android phones, yet Apple Vision Pro requiring the user to confirm warning messages and iPhones requiring so many insane workarounds due to no support at all. Can't wait for other browsers than safari being green lot on iOS.
- dangus 3y agoThis article acts like Apple is going to get anything more than a slap on the wrist anywhere outside of the EU. Even in the EU, Apple is complying with alternate App Store requirements as minimally as possible. I’ll believe that Apple’s walled garden is tumbling down when I see it. The iPhone is still a money printing machine, and their users aren’t going to go through the hassle of doing a huge cloud data migration to leave. Yes, replacement cycles are getting longer, but we are talking about averaging replacements every 2.5 years to every three years. https://www.statista.com/statistics/619788/average-smartphone-life/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/619788/average-smartphon... On top of that, Apple’s marketshare is increasing in many of its important markets. The only one that is in some peril IIRC is China. Finally, Apple’s service revenue is their fastest growing segment, and they don’t need a walled garden to earn that revenue.
- samirillian 3y agoI recently bought an iPhone due to peer pressure after using pixel for years. I think the ux is better on android, every common function takes more gestures on iPhone. Typing this comment reminds me of how annoying it is to edit text with an iPhone. I think there was maybe a time when iPhone ux was better but maybe not. Still I feel better from the perspective of pure vanity when I pull the iPhone out, or those blue texts show up. It sucks.
- acidburnNSA 3y agoWhat kind of peer pressure did you experience to get an iphone? This doesn't seem to exist in my circles.
- samirillian 3y agoFor example when you're on a group chat and somebody sends a video and the quality gets degraded and so somebody makes funny of the guy who shared the video but the guy is like "somebody on the group chat has android". and then my pixel was literally being held together by tape and one of the guys is like, dude, why are you such a contrarian, just get an iphone, and true detective was good! but true detective is not good, it's good bad.
- thr0waway001 3y agoI don't think they'll ever hit that low of the mid '90s ever again, unless maybe Tim Apple leaves, and they get a really incompetent leader. It happened once, but you'd think at least they'd learn from the past. I'm betting on them having learned from the past. But, on the other hand, I think their peak is past them and they can kinda either do the Microsoft thing and just, stop trying to innovate, but, buy up and coming companies instead, OR they can just kind of settle in their niche where they are a big company, selling nice looking tech to their die-hard patrons, but no longer leading the way, and no longer being the top dog. Which only lasts for so long.
- karlgkk 3y agoI don’t think they’ve ever cared about being top dog, just the best. And the best might not be for everyone
- thr0waway001 3y agoWhether they cared or not at some point they were the most valuable company and, therefore, the top dog.
- karlgkk 3y agoI didn’t say they weren’t.
- mrangle 3y agoI like the Walled Garden. I want the Walled Garden. Almost everyone wants the Walled Garden. Even Android users should want the Walled Garden, as a true second option. The Walled garden is fantastic. When everything just works, it's fantastic. Apple's product quality is without consumer equal. The quality a bright-light in a world otherwise brimming with hardware junk and a software wild west market. The antitrust issues are obviously without basis. This is an institutional effort to degrade the product line, and the lawsuits and regulations smell of hidden agenda. As a longtime Windows user, Windows is a privacy and security clown show. Linux is a server OS that is unusable for most casual desktop OS consumers. We're decades into the information age, and embarassingly there are only two usable desktop operating system ecosystems for the common person (Why is that, exactly?) aside from ChromeOS. And only one of the ecosystems, the one being targeted, is marginally acceptable from a consumer perspective. Given privacy, security, usability, and quality factors. A better so called "anti-monopoly" solution would be to build competitive products. Antitrust law was conceived to open up markets in the circumstance where the market was actually actively walled off by the monopolist. It wasn't conceived, for example, to stop car manufacturers from engineering the cars to accept parts that are only made for their cars. The last time that I checked, Apple was not preventing competitive product development. Android has a massive user base. This State effort to abuse the law so that things are worse quality has to stop.
- dlubarov 3y ago> As a longtime Windows user, Windows is a privacy and security clown show. I'd argue this is because it lacks proper sandboxing, not because it lacks curation. > A better so called "anti-monopoly" solution would be to build competitive products. Even if healthy competition could exist in this space, Apple (formerly?) barring developers from saying things like "our prices are 30% higher on iOS due to Apple's tax" gets in the way of consumers making informed decisions about competing products.
- takeda 3y agoJust because you love walled garden, doesn't mean others think the same. In fact you are the minority. This is especially visible on Android, where Google introduced side loading since the beginning and is struggling how to disable it. For example by blocking it in new android based products like Android TV. Or EU ruling that Apple needs to provide side loading, so Apple still only enables it on EU SIMs, making it hard to still build products with it. You mentioning Windows that it's "a privacy and security a clown show". Yet you are dismissing that Linux is for servers. That still doesn't change the fact that Linux is even desktop is much more secure though. Also mobile problems was not solved by mobile phones, in fact it was much worse, and more recent windows versions "backported" those ideas. > It wasn't conceived, for example, to stop car manufacturers from engineering the cars to accept parts that are only made for their cars. That's not what antitrust law supposed to protect. It's clear that different products will have different parts, what antitrust laws would do (if they weren't rendered toothless) would punish any blocking of competitors springing up.
- kyletns 3y agoFor anyone who wants much more detailed coverage of these cases, and are willing to pay for it, I can't recommend Matt Stoller's Substack enough. Here's an older article, but he regularly covers developments in all the anti trust cases: https://open.substack.com/pub/mattstoller/p/monopoly-round-up-apple-becomes-the?r=3hrku&utm_medium=ios https://open.substack.com/pub/mattstoller/p/monopoly-round-u...
- nojvek 3y agoiMessage gets the attention. In another perspective, I was reading Meta quarterly earnings and they have 3.5 billion active users on their family of apps with WhatsApp still growing. That’s almost every internet connected person. And Meta stock still tanked with that kind of growth. Meta has far more reach than Apple. Only Google comes close with their Search and Ads reach. I am wondering whether Apple is going to grow much. Vision Pro was a meh launch. Apple Car isn’t going anywhere. There is so much they can juice the App ecosystem. Is Tim Cook going the same route is Steve Ballmer?
- iamnotsure 3y agoNonfree software market bubble.